Topic 21 Asia between the Two World Wars Objectives Knowledge 1. 2. To know the causes of the rise of Japanese militarism in the 1930s To understand how militarism led to the war of invasion of China and the Pacific War Skills 1. 2. 3. 4. To read historical sources To understand role interaction To judge, contrast, cite and evaluate sources To compare, elaborate and explain sources Attitude 1. 2. 3. To have spirit of enquiry and willingness to think To reflect on the impact of wars on human society To cultivate sense of belonging to the history of one’s nation Teaching Flow Items Format Teaching Objectives Content 1 Question to ponder Questioning To arouse learning motives by providing an outline Why did militarism emerge in Japan? 2 To know more (1) Basic Information To enable students to understand the important concepts of this topic What is a cabinet? What is a parliament? Data-based questions To let students explore relationship between Meiji Constitution and Japanese militarism How did the Meiji Constitution contribute to the development of Japanese militarism? Data-based questions and character interactive concept map To let student explore how the genros and the military affected Japanese politics. Political struggle between Japanese cabinet and the military. 3 4 5 Task 1 Task 2 Task 3 Data-based questions To let students explore the causes for Japan to carry out imperial expansion To illustrate the relationship between the Kanto Army and Japan’s imperial expansion 1 Rise of Japanese militarism and Japan’s foreign expansion 6 To know more (2) Supplementary materials 7 Task 4 Concept map of drawing lines To let students explore the approach of Japanese imperialism. Approach of “Slow advancing” or “Radical advancing”? Data-based questions To let students understand the responses of the Nanjing Government towards Japan’s invading actions. Change of Nanjing Government’s attitude towards Japan Supplementary materials To enhance students’ understanding of the topic. Causes of Japan’s sudden attack on Pearl Harbour Concluding activity To let students consider different causes and their relative importance. Various causes leading to Japanese militarism Summary chart To summarise the characteristics of Japanese militarism. Assisting students to master key points of this topic Analysis and design To enhance students’ critical thinking skills and to cultivate in students empathy and creative ability Analyzing the relative importance of various causes of Japanese militarism and designing a newspaper headline on Japanese invasion of China 8 9 10 Task 5 To know more (3) Task 6 11 Conclusion 12 Extended activities (1-2) The Kanto Army hastened its pace of invading China Question to ponder Why did militarism emerge in Japan? To know more (1) Cabinet and Parliament A cabinet is the administration organisation in which senior officials of the government discuss policies on behalf of various government departments. The legislature of a nation is called Parliament. It is the legislative body of a sovereign region, and its members consist of representatives of that region, who are either elected through direct or indirect elections or appointed. Task 1: How did the Meiji Constitution contribute to the development of Japanese militarism? 2 Study Sources A and B, and then answer the questions below. Source A The table below compares the spirit of the Meiji Constitution (1889) and that of the American Constitution. Japan The United States Divine power of the emperor who was infallible Popularly elected President Citizens were the emperor’s subjects Men are born free and enjoy liberty Legislative and executive powers vested in the emperor Separation of executive, legislative and judicial powers Military power belonged to the emperor The President is the commander-in-chief directly of the armed forces Topic 21 Asia between the Two World Wars Source B The following text is an analysis of the Meiji Constitution. Firstly, a very special feature of Japanese politics was the role of senior statesmen (the most trusted courtiers in the early Meiji period and former prime ministers).They had the power to nominate cabinet ministers to the emperor. These elder statesmen, and even the prime minister or cabinet ministers, were not necessarily members of political parties. So, although the parties took part in election, the results of the election did not determine who had power. Secondly, the Meiji Constitution stipulated that the emperor was sacred and the source of all authority. The emperor was the highest commander of the army and navy and could command the armed forces directly. His constitutional power could, therefore, be used by military leaders to shield themselves from the control of the cabinet or the prime minister. As long as they were not restrained by the emperor, they could decide and act arbitrarily. Thirdly, the Constitution stipulated that the posts of Army Minister and Navy 1. Identify differences between Japan’s thus Meijivirtually Constitution American Minister three must be held by current servicemen, grantingand the the military Constitution. Explain the yourright answer with reference to Source A. of vetoing cabinet decisions. Suggested answer: Differences between Japan’s Meiji Constitution and the American Constitution: (1) The Meiji Constitution believed that the sovereign rights of the Emperor was bestowed by the Heaven and therefore cannot be overthrown. On the other hand, the American President comes to power by election. (2) The Meiji Constitution believed that the Japanese people were the subjects of the Emperor. On the other hand, the American Constitution incorporates the principle that everyone is born equal and should enjoy freedom. (3) The Meiji Constitution stipulated that the Emperor has the executive and legislative power. On the other hand, the American Constitution adopts the political principle of division of power of the executive, legislative and judicial powers. 2. According to Source B, what is “genros”? How did the “genros” affect Japan’s democracy? Suggested answer: The “genros” are the important ministers and retired prime ministers of the early years of the Meiji period. They possessed the power of nominating the cabinet prime minister to the Emperor, and therefore they played an important part in Japanese politics. Besides, the genros, the prime minister as well as members of the cabinet were not necessarily members of political parties. Therefore, while the political parties might take part in parliamentary elections, results of elections did not determine who would have real political power. 3 3. According to Source B, what privileges did the military enjoy as stipulated in the Meiji Constitution? How did such privileges contribute to the emergence of militarism? Suggested answer: The Meiji Constitution stipulated that the Emperor was the highest commander of the army and the navy and could command the military troops directly. Military generals could make use of this power of the Emperor to shield themselves from the control of the cabinet prime minister, and could act arbitrarily as long as the Emperor did not stop them. Furthermore, the Constitution stipulated that Army Ministers and Navy Ministers must be servicing military personnel. It also granted the military the power to veto any cabinet decision. Teaching Tips: With regards to how the genros influenced Japanese politics, further analysis will be made in the “character interactive” concept map. Task 2:How did the genros and the military affect Japanese politics? 4 Source C The following text is a description of how the Japanese cabinet and the military struggled with each other for political power. For example, in 1912 when the newly formed cabinet refused to increase military expenditure in an attempt to deal with the economic crisis caused by rapid inflation, it aroused the discontent of the military. The Army Minister resigned and refused to nominate his successor. As the prime minister was unable to form a cabinet, he was forced to resign. However, in the 1910s, public opinion thought that the army had encroached upon the constitutional government. It thought that the military had failed to respect the voting power of the elected Diet over the budget, and, as a result, supported the government’s efforts to reduce the budget. The political parties also initiated a movement to safeguard constitutionalism. Riots broke out in Tokyo and other cities. As a result, although the senior statesmen never gave up their right of appointment, elected members of the Diet came to be included in the cabinet. In fact, members of minority parties, by being included in the cabinet, could gain influence by proposing to dissolve the Parliament and have another election. In most cases they won in the election and became the majority party. Topic 21 Asia between the Two World Wars Based on the content of Source C, complete the “character interactive” concept map below. Suggested answer: “Character interactive” Concept Map (“Movement to safeguard constitutionalism”) Character A: Cabinet Objective: To solve economic problems first, and initiated the “Movement to safeguard constitutionalism” Character B: the military Objective: Increase military expenses, and advocated expansionist foreign policies Effects Acute inflation Economic crisis Effects Cabinet refused to increase Action military expenses Led to resentment of the military. Minister of the Army resigned, and refused to nominate successor. Response Prime Minister unable to form a cabinet and was forced to resign. 5 Character C: the people Objectives: Believed that the military had infringed upon the “constitutional government”, and had not respected the voting right of the elected parliament. Therefore they supported the Parliament in cutting the budget. Effects The political parties initiated the “Movement to protect constitutionalism”, accepted elected parliamentary members and let political parties to join the bureaucratic system. Action The genros nominated leader of the minority party to form cabinet. By controlling various important government posts, they proposed dissolving the Parliament and conducting another election. Response Efects The minority party won in the election and became the majority party. Results: Election politics was influenced by the genros and the military. Parliamentary democracy was harmed and unable to restrain the power of the military, resulting in the rise of militarism; Character D: genro Objective: Possessed the power to nominate cabinet prime minister to the Emperor, so played an important part in Japanese politics. Task 3: Why did Japan carry out imperial expansion? Study Source D to F, and then answer the following questions. Source D The following text is about the causes of the rise of Japanese militarism. As the world economic crisis set in by the end of the 1920s, Japan’s economy was hit hard. Between 1930 and 1932, Japan’s industrial unemployment rate reached as high as 15 per cent of the labour force. The unemployment rate in the cities was even higher. Many army officers became increasingly discontented with Japan’s domestic and foreign policies. They saw the conciliatory diplomacy as cowardly. They considered the reduction in the military budget as a way of degrading the armed forces, impoverishing the soldiers and undermining their morale. They were of the view that this was the result of collaboration between big business (known in Japan as the zaibatsu) and political parties under the capitalist system. The success of the Northern Expedition led by the Kuomintang in China also prompted action from the Japanese military. After the fall of the Qing dynasty, China was dominated by separatist warlord regimes. The completion of the Northern Expedition and the establishment of a unified Nationalist (Kuomintang) government in Nanjing in 1928, could eventually lead to a stronger China. An imperialist viewing China from Japan would have argued in the early 1930s that if war was inevitable, it should be waged sooner rather than later. 6 Source E The following text is about the expansion of Japanese influence to China. Japanese politicians, including the senior statesmen, political parties and the military, endeavoured to obtain equal status for Japan with Western powers and agreed that Japan should establish itself as an imperialist power in Asia. After the First World War, when Japan faced economic crisis caused by serious inflation and renewed economic competitions among Western powers, imperial expansion seemed imminent. However, through the 1920s, successive Japanese governments took a conciliatry attitude towards China. China, fragmented by internal wars, was at it weakest point in the twentieth century. In 1928, the Japanese army stationed in the northeastern provinces of China (known then as Manchuria), took matters into its own hand. Members of the army decided, without approval from the Japanese government, to assassinate the warlord of Manchuria, Zhang Zuolin. The Japanese government knew of the event, but failed to hold the assassins to account. Instead, the Prime Minister resigned. By September 1931, the Japanese army stationed on the Manchuria-Korea border attacked Manchuria, and drove out Zhang Zuolin’s son, Zhang Xueliang. It took over Manchuria and turned it in the Manchukuo Kingdom. The Chinese government protested to the League of Nations, but the League was totally ineffective in restraining Japan, even though it condemned Japan’s aggression. Topic 21 Asia between the Two World Wars Source F The cartoon, with its title “The tiger devouring a small man”, was published in 1932. 7 Source: Issue 70, Ling Long Women’s Magazine, 1932; Image from Columbia University Library 1. With reference to Source D, identify two causes of Japanese imperial expansion. Suggested answer: Source D points out that Japan’s economy suffered severely in the late 1920s, and many military officers became increasing resentful of Japan’s internal and external situation. They resented the cooperative diplomacy adopted by the political parties, believing that it was a show of cowardice. They believed that this was the result of collaboration between the zaibatsus (i.e. large enterprises) and the party politicians under the capitalist system. Source D also points out that China would become wealthy and strong along with the success of the Northern Expedition led by the Kuomintang and the setting up of the unified Nanjing Government in 1928. By the early 1930s, Japanese imperialists believed that war against China would be inevitable, and the sooner it occurred, the better. 2. What changes were there in Japan’s policy towards China in the 1920s? answer with reference to Source E. Explain your Suggested answer: Throughout the entire 1920s, the Japanese government still advocated treating China with its conventional pacifying attitude. However, by 1928, the Japanese army stationing in China’s northeastern provinces (i.e. Manchuria) ignored the cabinet government and took things into their own hands by assassinating China’s warlord in Manchuria, Zhang Zuolin. By September 1931, Japanese troops stationing on the border of Korea and Manchuria invaded Manchuria, indicating the beginning of change of Japan’s policy towards China. 3. Identify the historical incident referred to in the cartoon in Source F. What do the tiger and the small figures in the cartoon refer to? Suggested answer: The historical event referred to by the cartoon is the setting up of the Manchukuo in northeast China by Japan. The tiger refers to Japan, and the small figure being devoured is Manchukuo. 4. How did the Chinese government and the powers respond to this incident? Explain your answer with reference to Sources E and F. Suggested answer: As described in Source E, in September 1931 Japanese troops occupied the northeastern provinces and set up the Manchukuo there. The Chinese government lodged a protest to the League of Nations. Although the League of Nations denounced Japan’s invasion, it was unable to sanction Japan. In source F, the Chinese government and the powers merely stood aside, denouncing Japan’s action but unable to stop it. They could just “finish watching this show in silence”. To know more (2) The Kanto Army hastened its pace of invading China 8 The Japanese Kanto Army stationed in northeastern China was set up in 1906 to protect Japanese interests in Japan’s leased territories in China and its railway rights in South Manchuria. It had attempted to make the Japanese government adopt a more proactive Manchurian policy by assassinating the warlord, Zhang Zuolin . Although Prime Minister Giichi Tanaka realized that the main conspirators of the assassination of Zhang Zuolin were the Kanto Army, the Japanese government failed to impose any effective sanction on them for acting without authority. Instead, Prime Minister Tanaka was forced to resign because the emperor was dissatisfied with his handling of the event. This event set a bad precedence for the military. It also encouraged radicalism among young army officers and right-wing nationalists. Leaders of political parties and business later became their targets of assassination. At this time, leaders of the Kanto Army advocated that as war between Japan and Western powers was inevitable, Japan must control northeastern China because the region was rich in mineral resources, and its fertile lowland could be reclaimed for agriculture. By promoting migration to Manchuria, Japan could also ease population pressure in the countryside. 課題 19: 歐洲的民族主義 Topic 21 Asia between the Two World Wars Task 4: Drawing line concept map – Was the approach of Japanese imperialism one of “slow advancement” or “radical advancement”? What changes were there in Japan’s China policy in the 1920s and 1930s? With reference to Source G and using your own knowledge, identify from the diagram below the line that represents the degree of support the “slow advancing” foreign policy, and present the reasons briefly. Teaching Tips: This activity aims at letting students think about the importance of different approaches to Japan’s diplomacy in Japan’s historical development. Students need only to know the general degree of support of the different approaches. Source G The text below is an article on Japan’s China policy in the 1920s and 1930s. During the economic downturn in the late 1920s, the Japanese government adopted stringent measures to reduce the government’s expenditure. One result was the reduction of the military budget. The majority of military commanders accepted this policy. At this time, the government adopted a cooperative policy with Western powers towards China. For example, Prime Minister Takashi Hara agreed to return Shandong to China even though Japan retained its long-term interests over major railways. In 1924-1927, Foreign Minister Kijuro Shidehara refused military intervention in the anti-Japanese movement in China. In the 1910s and 1920s, there was no controversy over whether Japan should expand, the only contention being whether expansion should proceed gradually or radically. The gradualist faction advocated cooperation with Western powers, especially Britain and the United States. The radical faction, on the other hand, advocated acting alone, taking into account only Japanese interests, and disregarding the China policy adopted by Britain and the United States. Public opinion largely agreed with the gradualists, whereas the military advocated “radical development”. By the end of the 1920s, a more apparent dissent appeared. Political parties advocated cooperation and consultation with powers like Britain and the United States for the resolution of disputes over China, but the military, especially the officer of middle or lower ranks, were impatient with such conciliatory diplomacy as they became increasingly critical of the political parties. The army viewed China, in particular the problems in northern and northeastern China, as the biggest threat to Japan’s position as Asia’s leader. The navy, on the other hand, was concerned with the challenges posed by Western powers in the Pacific Ocean. At this time, leaders of the Kanto Army advocated that war between Japan and Western powers was inevitable. This line of thought led to the Manchurian Incident, when on 18 September 1931, the Kanto Army launched a full-scale attack on Manchuria on the pretext that the Chinese army had been responsible for an explosion on the South Manchurian Railway. Although Prime Minister Inukai Tsuyoshi did not agree to the annexation of northeastern China by the Japanese army, he nevertheless allowed the establishment of a puppet government – Manchukuo (Manzhouguo) – by the Kanto Army. The fact that the Kanto Army could take matters into its own hands by occupying northeastern China without the approval from the government reinforced the growth of militarism. 9 Approach of Japanese Imperialism — “Slow advancement” or “Radical advancement”? Degree of Support 100 Extremely high 1924-1927 Kijuro Shidehara became Foreign Minister 1937 the July 7th Incident The Manchurian Incident in 1931 75 high A May 15 Incident of 1932 Prime Minister Takashi Hara reached an agreement with China Prime Minister Inukai Tsuyoshi disagreed to annexation of China by the military B 50 average 25 low 10 Year 0 1920 1925 1930 1935 Suggested answer: A represents the degree of support of the “Slow advancement” approach of diplomacy. Because Japan’s imperialistic line in late 1920s and early 1930s skewed towards foreign expansion, the collaborative policy of “slow advancement” was not popular. Task 5: What was the change of the Nanjing Government’s attitude towards Japan? Study Sources H and I, and then answer the following questions. Source H The text below describes the change of Japan’s foreign policy towards China in the 1930s. The text below describes the change of Japan’s foreign policy towards China in the 1930s. Between 1931 and 1936, the Chinese government in Nanjing conciliated to Japanese demands in the north of China. By 1936, in concession to public opinion, the Nanjing government pledged a hard stand in the event of further aggression. When by the Marco Polo Bridge Incident on 7 July 1937, the Japanese army captured Beijing, full-scale war broke out. In the initial few months of the war, China lost heavily and even the capital of the Nationalist government in Nanjing fell. With the fall of Nanjing to Japanese forces, the Nationalist government moved its seat to Chongqing . Topic 21 Asia between the Two World Wars Source I On 1 January 1938, the President of the Chinese Nationalist government Lin Sen (林森) said in a speech: We demand final victory, and we will fight a protracted war of resistance. In this protracted war, any temporary military retreat is only the loss of a battle. It will not affect the overall outcome of the war. During the First World War, in less than one month, the French government had to give up Paris and half of France fell into enemy hands. Nevertheless, from losses France emerged in victory. Although the French situation was slightly different from our present situation, the weaknesses of Japan are too many. Its soldiers are mostly grassroots workers. Once their young men have been conscripted, students abandon school, farmers cease to farm, merchants cease to trade and workers cease to produce. As time goes by, Japan cannot hold out. The more land it occupies and the longer the frontlines of war, the sooner will come its defeat. We must drag the war on and wear down our enemy’s military and financial strengths so that its economic structure and military advantages will collapse simultaneously. The removal of the capital to Chongqing shows our determination to engage in a protracted war … to accomplish the aim of final victory. Source: Zhu Huisen ed. A Concise Account of Historical Events in the Republic of China, 1938, Part1, Taipei: Academia Historica 1989, P.2-3 1. According to Source H, what changes were there in the attitude of China’s Nanjing Government towards Japan? Suggested answer: During 1931-36, China’s Nanjing Government adopted a policy of retreat in response to Japan’s invasion in northeast China. In 1936, the Nanjing Government changed to take up a firm position against Japanese invasion as a result of pressure from public opinion in China. 2. Why did China have to move its capital to Chongqing? Why did the Nationalist Government believe that China would eventually defeat Japan? Explain your answer with reference to Source I and using your own knowledge. Suggested answer: Source I shows that moving China’s capital to Chongqing was intended to carry out a long-term war with Japan. The Nationalist Government wanted to extend Japan’s war time so as to consume its military and financial resources, in which case its economic institutions and military situation will collapse at the same time. Thus China would win the war of resistance. In my knowledge, Japan’s invasion of China went almost unstoppable at the beginning of the war of resistance, and its troops occupied Nanjing in 1937. Therefore, the Nationalist Government had to move its capital to Chongqing. 11 To know more (3) Why did Japan launch a sudden attack on Pearl Harbour? The Japanese government deployed 600,000 men to invade China. They could hold the cities and transport lines in the areas they occupied, but were unable to control the countryside. In March 1940, Japan set up a puppet government in Nanjing under the leadership of Wang Jingwei. By September, Japan tried to break the stalemate by allying with the two Axis Powers, Germany and Italy. That was preparation for its attack on Southeast Asia, as Vietnam was a French colony. When Japan occupied northern Vietnam, the United States expanded its oil embargo against Japan and provided cheap military supplies to China. When in June 1941, Hitler declared war on the Soviet Union, Japan turned to Southeast Asia knowing that when the Soviet Union was occupied in war in Europe, it could not wage a separate war in northeastern China. Japan attacked the British and American colonies in Southeast Asia and seized the oilfields in the region. Conclusion 12 Japan was a constitutional monarchy in which the emperor’s power was divine and absolute. Although there was an elected House of Representatives in the Imperial Diet, and voting right had been expanded and the cabinet was formed by political parties, the Diet was not able to control the military. Military power was placed directly in the hands of the emperor. When the Japanese government dealt with a financial crisis by adopting stringent economic measures and reducing military expenditure, the discontent of the military was aroused. The army opposed conciliation with countries like Britain and the United States. It acted alone in northeastern China, launched a military campaign and promoted a policy of advancing into southern China, hence moving Japan along the road to militarism. China’s Nationalist Government adopted the policy of “Pacifying the internal first and then repelling the external” in order to eliminate the communists. Therefore, it made concessions to the invasion of the Japanese troops, which further encouraged the Japanese troops. When Japan launched its full scale invasion on China, its strategy was to win quickly. In only several months, it occupied the Nationalist capital Nanjing, forcing the Nationalist Government to move its capital to Chongqing. By now, there is no way to retreat for the Kuomintang except fighting to the end, or else its rule will collapse. The Sino-Japanese War became a persistent war and a consuming war. After occupying Nanjing, Japan suggested to China about signing a peace treaty, but was refused by the Nationalist government. At this time, regardless of whether it had intended to occupy the entire China at the beginning when it launched its invasion of China, now what it could do was to continue on with the war. Topic 21 Asia between the Two World Wars Summary Chart The chart below shows the content structure of Japanese militarism. Characters: genro, military, cabinet Scene: Japan 1889 Promulgation of the Meiji Constitution 1894 Sino-Japanese War 1902 Anglo-Japanese Alliance 1904-05 Time: 1930s & 1940s Russo-Japanese War 1919 End of First World War; Paris Peace Conference 1931 Manchurian Incident; Japan invaded Manchuria 1937 July 7th Incident; 8-year War of Resistance began 1941 Sudden Attack on Pearl Harbour 1945 USA bombed Japan with atomic bombs; WWII ended Advocated “radical advancement” foreign policy Japanese militarism Influences Causes Intensified struggle between political parties and military Military had right to veto cabinet decisions Sought equal status with western power Invaded China, starting China’s 15-year long War of Resistance Japan was facing serious economic crisis Characteristics Led to the Pacific War Success of Northern China Political power centred around the Emperor Advocated expansionist foreign policy From “slow advancement” to “radical” advancement Serious disagreement between military & Parliament League of Nations was unable to sanction Japan 13 Extended activity (1) Analyse the relative importance of various causes of Japanese militarism. Analyse the relative importance of various causes leading to Japanese militarism, and put a in the appropriate box. Fill in causes. Analyse the relative importance of various causes leading to Japanese militarism. unimportant 14 fairly important very important important Causes of Japanese militarism The Chinese Kuomintang succeeded in its Northern Expedition in 1928. The Japanese imperialists believed that the sooner it staged an invasion of China, the better. So they increased their militarists’ pace. e.g. Success of Kuomintang’s Northern Expedition Topic 21 Asia between the Two World Wars Extended Activity (2) : Designing Newspaper Headline Synthesizing what has been learnt above, design a piece of headline news on the newspaper The World Daily for the day 8th July 1937 with pictures and texts (200 – 400 words), using Japan’s full-scale invasion of China as its topic. The World Daily Published in Hong Kong Thursday 8th July 1937 Picture 15 Text