1
Thesis | Apr 14, 14
Murphy Hall
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Copyright by Hasenstab Architects
Introduction
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
| Murphy Hall
| John Carroll University
| 1 John Carroll Boulevard, University Heights, OH 44118
| Faye Poon
| Lighting / Electrical
| Advisor: Shawn Good
2
Thesis | Apr 14, 14
Murphy Hall
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
PROJECT
OVERVIEW
THE STATISTICS
Address
Occupancy
Size
Introduction
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
Total levels
Sustainability
Construction
Cost
Project Delivery
1 John Carroll Boulevard,
University Heights, OH 44118
Dormitory, worship, business
89,809 SF
3 stores above grade, 4 stories total
First LEED certified building on campus
May 2013- August 2014
design fee: 1.4 million;
construction fee: 22.1 million
Design-Bid-Build
3
Thesis | Apr 14, 14
Murphy Hall
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
OUTLINE
4
Thesis | Apr 14, 14
Murphy Hall
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
DESIGN
CONCEPT
RETREAT
WEST LOBBY & HALLWAY
THE LOUNGE
Introduction
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
SUITE LIVING
Structural
Electrical
Summary
THE FACADE
5
Thesis | Apr 14, 14
Murphy Hall
DESIGN
CONCEPT
RETREAT
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
WEST LOBBY & HALLWAY
THE LOUNGE
Introduction
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
SUITE LIVING
Structural
Electrical
Summary
STIMULATING
HOMECOMING
BONDING
RELAXING
THE FACADE
6
Thesis | Apr 14, 14
Murphy Hall
DESIGN
CONCEPT
RETREAT
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
STIMULATING
RELAXING
Introduction
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
BONDING
Structural
Electrical
Summary
STIMULATING
HOMECOMING
BONDING
RELAXING
HOMECOMING
7
Thesis | Apr 14, 14
Murphy Hall
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
DESIGN
CONCEPT
RETREAT
STIMULATING
RELAXING
8
Thesis | Apr 14, 14
Murphy Hall
LIGHTING
DEPTH
LOUNGE
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
STIMULATING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
RELAXING
WEST LOBBY
9
WEST
LOBBY
Murphy Hall
SPACE DESCRIPTION
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Area
Occupancy Type
Design Criteria
Introduction
STIMULATING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
2567 SF
(1940SF ground floor, 627 SF 1st floor)
Dormitory Multipurpose.
Stimulating
Spacious
Energy Efficiency
IES Recommendation
Eh
Ev
Avg:Min
IES pg. #
Dormitory – Multipurpose (lux)
150
50
3:1
24.10
Lighting Power Density | IECC Table 505.5.2
Dormitory
1.00 W/SF
10
WEST
LOBBY
Murphy Hall
LIGHTING DESIGN
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
STIMULATING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
11
WEST
LOBBY
Murphy Hall
LIGHTING DESIGN
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
STIMULATING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
12
WEST
LOBBY
Murphy Hall
LIGHTING DESIGN
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
STIMULATING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
13
WEST
LOBBY
Murphy Hall
LIGHTING DESIGN
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
STIMULATING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
14
WEST
LOBBY
Murphy Hall
LIGHTING DESIGN
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
STIMULATING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
15
WEST
LOBBY
Murphy Hall
LIGHTING DESIGN
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
STIMULATING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
16
WEST
LOBBY
Murphy Hall
LIGHTING DESIGN
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
STIMULATING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
17
WEST
LOBBY
Murphy Hall
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
STIMULATING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
| Circulation Space
West Lobby
Area
693
SF
Watts Usage
473
W
Average:
LPD
0.68
W/SF
Floor: 22 Fc
Table: 28 Fc
18
CORRIDORS
Murphy Hall
LIGHTING DESIGN
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Area
Occupancy Type
Design Criteria
Introduction
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
STIMULATING
1432 SF
Dormitory Circulation
Stimulating
Spacious
Energy Efficiency
IES Recommendation
Eh
Ev
Avg:Min
IES pg. #
Transition – Independent
Passage Ways (lux)
25
15
2:1
24.18
Lighting Power Density | IECC Table 505.5.2
Dormitory
1.00 W/SF
19
CORRIDORS
Murphy Hall
LIGHTING DESIGN
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
STIMULATING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
20
CORRIDORS
Murphy Hall
LIGHTING DESIGN
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
STIMULATING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
21
CORRIDORS
Murphy Hall
LIGHTING DESIGN
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
STIMULATING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
22
CORRIDORS
Murphy Hall
LIGHTING DESIGN
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
STIMULATING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
23
CORRIDORS
Murphy Hall
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
STIMULATING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
| Circulation Space
Corridor
Area
1432
SF
Watts Usage
604
W
LPD
0.42
W/SF
Average:
Floor: 5 Fc
24
Thesis | Apr 14, 14
Murphy Hall
LOUNGE
SPACE DESCRIPTION
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Area
Occupancy Type
Design Criteria
Introduction
RELAXING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
1432 SF
(1940SF ground floor, 627 SF 1st floor)
Dormitory Multipurpose.
Uniformity
Illuminance
Accent Lighting
Place holder for Lounge thumbnail
IES Recommendation
Eh
Ev
Avg:Min
IES pg. #
Dormitory – Multipurpose (lux)
150
50
3:1
24.10
Lighting Power Density | IECC Table 505.5.2
Dormitory
1.00 W/SF
25
GROUND FLOOR
LOUNGE
Murphy Hall
LIGHTING DESIGN
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
RELAXING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
1ST FLOOR
26
GROUND FLOOR
LOUNGE
Murphy Hall
LIGHTING DESIGN
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
RELAXING
Lighting Design - Lounge
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Structural
Electrical
Summary
1ST FLOOR
27
GROUND FLOOR
LOUNGE
Murphy Hall
LIGHTING DESIGN
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
RELAXING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
1ST FLOOR
28
GROUND FLOOR
LOUNGE
Murphy Hall
LIGHTING DESIGN
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
RELAXING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
1ST FLOOR
29
GROUND FLOOR
LOUNGE
Murphy Hall
LIGHTING DESIGN
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
RELAXING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
1ST FLOOR
30
GROUND FLOOR
LOUNGE
Murphy Hall
LIGHTING DESIGN
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
RELAXING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
1ST FLOOR
31
LOUNGE
Murphy Hall
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
RELAXING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
Double Story Lounge
| Large Work Space
Average:
Lobby: 25 Fc
W/SF
Stair: 20
Fc
Area
2567
SF
Watts Usage
2072
W
LPD
0.81
32
LOUNGE
Murphy Hall
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
RELAXING
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
LPD:
Average:
0.81 W/SF
Open Plan: 14 Fc
33
LOUNGE
Murphy Hall
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
STRUCTURAL BREADTH
34
Thesis | Apr 14, 14
Murphy Hall
LOUNGE
STRUCTURAL BREADTH
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
Type
Factors
Load
Attic
Live Load
Dead Load
Live load
Dead load
Dead load
40 PSF
75 PSF
40 PSF
80 PSF
107 PSF
Live load
Dead load
Snow load
30 PSF
80 PSF
29 PSF
Floor
Exterior
Wall
Flat Roof
Distribute
length
8.5 ft
# Floor
8.5 ft
2
8.45 ft
tall
7.84 ft
2.5
1
1
Load
LF
340 lb/LF
638 lb/LF
680 lb/LF
1360 lb/LF
2261 lb/LF
235 lb/LF
627 lb/LF
228 lb/LF
35
LOUNGE
Murphy Hall
22”
STRUCTURAL BREADTH
Introduction
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
Factors
Load
Attic
Live Load
Dead Load
Live load
Dead load
Dead load
40 PSF
75 PSF
40 PSF
80 PSF
107 PSF
Live load
Dead load
Snow load
30 PSF
80 PSF
29 PSF
Floor
Exterior
Wall
Flat Roof
Distribute
length
8.5 ft
# Floor
8.5 ft
2
8.45 ft
tall
7.84 ft
2.5
1
1
Load
LF
340 lb/LF
638 lb/LF
680 lb/LF
1360 lb/LF
2261 lb/LF
235 lb/LF
627 lb/LF
228 lb/LF
33”
Type
36”
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
#3 @ 8” o.c.
(8) #9 @ 2.7” o.c.
36
ELECTRICAL
DEPTH
Murphy Hall
PHOTOVOLTAIC SYSTEM
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
Metric
Cost of System
Annual Energy
System performance factor (%)
Total Land Area
Payback (years)
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
Base
$457,108.18
71,717 kW/h
84 %
0.31 Acres
1.32 Years
37
ELECTRICAL
DEPTH
Murphy Hall
PHOTOVOLTAIC SYSTEM
Annual Energy
Delivered
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Monthly Energy Delivered (kWh)
10000
8710,04
9000
8802,9
8974,54
8194,42
8000
7296,62
7000
6000
Introduction
85,390.5
kWh
82060.7
78417.0
72441.3
71716.9
71716.9
4021,49
3132,03
2740,71
3000
kWh
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
4964,85
5000
4000
6462,77
5977,69
2274,22
2000
1000
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
0
1
2
3
4
5
6 Month 7
8
9
10
11
12
38
SUMMARY
Murphy Hall
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Dormitory
Lighting Concept of Retreat
Stimulating theme for West lobby and Corridor
Introduction
Relaxing theme for lounge
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Transfer girder as alternative to columns in lounge
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
PV system produce 71.7MWh annual energy
39
SUMMARY
Murphy Hall
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Dormitory
Lighting Concept of Retreat
Stimulating theme for West lobby and Corridor
Introduction
Relaxing theme for lounge
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Transfer girder as alternative to columns in lounge
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
PV system produce 71.7MWh annual energy
40
SUMMARY
Murphy Hall
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Dormitory
Lighting Concept of Retreat
Stimulating theme for West lobby and Corridor
Introduction
Relaxing theme for lounge
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Transfer girder as alternative to columns in lounge
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
PV system produce 71.7MWh annual energy
41
SUMMARY
Murphy Hall
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Monthly Energy Delivered (mWh)
Dormitory
10
8,71004
9
Lighting Concept of Retreat
8
6
Relaxing theme for lounge
4
8,19442
6,46277
5,97769
4,96485
5
Introduction
8,97454
7,29662
7
Stimulating theme for West lobby and Corridor
8,8029
4,02149
3,13203
2,74071
3
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
Transfer girder as alternative to columns in lounge
PV system produce 71.7MWh annual energy
MWh
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
2,27422
2
1
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Month
8
9
10
11
12
42
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Murphy Hall
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Introduction
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
Lighting Design - Lounge
Structural
Electrical
Summary
Carol P. Dietz
Christian Todd
Kelly Hersh
Dr. Mistrick
Dr. Houser
Shawn Good
Leslie Beahm
Associate VP of Facilities, John Carroll University
Principal, McHenry and Associates
Engineer, McHenry and Associates
AE faculty
AE faculty
Lighting Department Head, Brinjac Engineering
Electrical Advisor, Reese Engineering
Family and friends for their support
43
SUMMARY
Murphy Hall
QUESTIONS?
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Monthly Energy Delivered (mWh)
10
8,71004
9
8
6,46277
4,96485
5
4,02149
3,13203
2,74071
3
Lighting Design West Lobby and Corridor
1
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Month
Structural
Electrical
Summary
2,27422
2
MWh
Lighting Design - Lounge
8,19442
5,97769
6
4
8,97454
7,29662
7
Introduction
8,8029
8
9
10
11
12
44
Thesis | Apr 14, 14
Murphy Hall
APPENDIX
PHOTOVOLTAIC SYSTEM
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Dormitory, worship, business
89,809 SF
3 stores above grade, 4 stories total
First LEED certified building on campus
May 2013- August 2014
design fee: 1.4 million;
construction fee: 22.1 million
Design-Bid-Build
45
Thesis | Apr 14, 14
Murphy Hall
LOUNGE
HVAC BREADTH
John Carroll University
Advisor: Shawn Good
Outline