IAQ Check List Building: Seth Paine Elementary School Date: May 7, 2014 Check List Building Inspection Performed by: Lyle Erstad Report Compiled by: Lyle Erstad 1. Ground Level Indoor Inspection a. Univents are on and air discharge grills are free of obstructions. If false, send email to building principal and facilities director asking staff to be instructed to keep vents clear at all times. Record locations here: 2. Ground Level Outdoor Inspection (weather permitting) a. Univent air intakes are free of obstructions. If false, record locations here: IAQ Check List True False N/A b. Filters i. Medium efficiency filters are installed in all univents. If false, list locations and create work orders to initiate corrective action. ii. High efficiency filters are installed in the air handling units. If false, list locations and create work orders to initiate correction action. iii. Filters are being changed every six months and the installed date is written on the outer filter casing. If filter is older than 6 months, list locations and create work orders to initiate corrective action. c. Insects, bird nests, or droppings are not evident near outdoor air intakes. If false, indicate locations here: I found a hornet's hive on the outside of the 200 hallway. I removed it. d. Trash dumpsters are located away from doors, windows, and outdoor air intakes. e. Potential sources of air contaminants do not exist near the building. (e.g. chimneys, stacks, industrial plants, exhaust from nearby buildings) f. Trucks and buses are not allowed to keep their engines idling near the building. Page 1 of 9 Revised 3/7/2011 AMJ Created 11/2010 IAQ Check List Building: Seth Paine Elementary School Date: May 7, 2014 Building Inspection Performed by: Lyle Erstad Report Compiled by: Lyle Erstad Check List g. No evidence of drainage problems exist. Water drains away from the building including roof downspouts. IAQ Check List True False N/A h. Sprinklers do not spray directly toward the building or into outdoor air intakes. i. j. Grass clippings from mowers are directed away from the building air intakes. Now that mowing season has begun, we have reminded our landscaper to blow clippings away from the building. I did find grass clippings on some of the air intake grills. Clean walk-off mats are present at exterior entrances. 3. Roof (Inspections conducted weather permitting) a. Roofing consultant has not found any issues requiring immediate repair. Most recent roofing inspection date/company: 5-year roofing plan completed 5/25/2010 with C. E. Crowley & Associates. b. There is no evidence of water ponding on the roof. The majority of the roof is ballasted and sloped and it drains well. I did see water (it had rained the day before) right in front of the scuppers on the roof at the main entrance. No water penetrated the building. c. Intake ventilation units are operating properly and free of debris. d. All exhaust fans are operating properly and free of debris. e. Air intake dampers are set to allow air flow even at minimum setting. f. Insects, birds, animal nests or droppings are not evident near outdoor air intakes. See note on 2.c. g. Plumbing stacks and exhaust vents are located away from air intakes. Page 2 of 9 Revised 3/7/2011 AMJ Created 11/2010 IAQ Check List Building: Seth Paine Elementary School Date: May 7, 2014 Check List Building Inspection Performed by: Lyle Erstad Report Compiled by: Lyle Erstad 4. Attic a. There is no evidence of roof or plumbing leaks. No Attic IAQ Check List True False N/A b. There is no evidence in attic of insects, birds, animals, or nests. No Attic 5. General Considerations a. Classrooms, offices and/or common areas appear recently cleaned. If examples of poor housekeeping are found, record locations below: b. Only vacuums with HEPA filters are being used. c. All supply and exhaust ventilation units are working properly. d. Occupied space temperatures and relative humidity levels are within the standards listed below. i. Temperature range: • Winter temperatures 70-73 degrees. • Summer temperatures 74-80 in air-conditioned spaces and 74-85 in non-air-conditioned spaces. Outdoor air temperature: 62.3; 51.7; 51.4; 64.8 degrees. Highest temperature – Location: 200, 307; 301, 309W; 309W; 200; Reading of 75.7; 74.3; 73.5; 70.7 degrees. Lowest temperature – Location: 112; gym; nurse; ; Reading of 71; 60.2; 69.4 degrees. ii. Relative humidity range is 30% to 60%. • Non-air-conditioned spaces may be higher on rainy or humid summer humid days. • All spaces may be less than 30% when the out-door air temperature is less than 32 degrees. Outdoor relative humidity: 56.6; 47.9; 43.4; 32.1% Highest relative humidity – Location: 112; 101; 102; 200; Reading of 55.7; 53.3; 39.5; 37.4% Page 3 of 9 Revised 3/7/2011 AMJ Created 11/2010 IAQ Check List Building: Seth Paine Elementary School Date: May 7, 2014 Building Inspection Performed by: Lyle Erstad Report Compiled by: Lyle Erstad Check List Lowest relative humidity – Location: 306; 301; 309W;Reading of 44.8; 39.4; 33.8% IAQ Check List True False N/A Readings not within acceptable standards will result in the creation of a work order, requesting maintenance to address. (Readings are noted on the attached test data sheet) e. Occupied space readings of carbon monoxide (CO) levels are less than 9.0 PPM. Outdoor Air CO Reading: 0 All Days Highest CO Location: 0 Reading: All Rooms Lowest CO Location: Reading: If the CO level is greater than 9.0 PPM in any space as measured with a handheld device or “leave-in” monitor, the space must be cleared of all occupants and steps taken to correct the problem. The issue will be immediately addressed by maintenance and the Fire Department. (Readings are noted on the attached test data sheet) f. CO2 levels in any occupied space are below threshold limits. i. Perform CO2 check with Gray Wolf or other portable device. Measure four times yearly or more often if needed. Measure only in fully occupied rooms. Reading should be less than 700 PPM plus outside air CO2 PPM. 700 PPM + 400; 385; 391; 396 PPM = 1100; 1085; 1091; 1096 PPM Assume outside CO2 is 350 if temperature is below 41 degrees and air is not stagnant with no- wind. Record all occupied space CO2 levels on forms provided. Provide the outdoor CO2 level as well as the high and low CO2 extremes below: Outdoor reading: 400; 385; 391; 396 PPM Highest CO2 reading – Location: 200; 308; 200; 200; Reading of 1479; 973; 1669; 930 PPM Lowest CO2 reading – Location: 111; LL2; 201; Reading of 524; 671; 661 PPM Page 4 of 9 Revised 3/7/2011 AMJ Created 11/2010 IAQ Check List Building: Seth Paine Elementary School Date: May 7, 2014 Building Inspection Performed by: Lyle Erstad Report Compiled by: Lyle Erstad Check List ii. If reading is above threshold, check univent and air handling dampers to ensure a value is set to provide at least 15 cfm of fresh air intake per student based on average space occupancies. If reading is consistently elevated, then use data logging to monitor CO2 concentrations over time and look for other sources of problems. IAQ Check List True False N/A iii. CO2 levels were checked three months ago. g. h. i. j. iv. CO2 levels on “leave-in” devices, where present, where checked. No leave-in devices Offensive odors are not apparent. If false, list problem areas: Water damage is not evident. Check for roof leaks, pipe leaks, spills, stained ceiling tiles, etc, visually and with moisture meter. Look for the source of any water leaks and schedule repairs. Discard porous items such as ceiling tiles if wet for more than 24 hours. For carpeting, if less than 9 square feet of wet area, shampoo with germicide and fan dry. For areas greater than 9 square feet, replace carpet with tile in reasonable timeframe. If carpet is over ACM tile, replace during next unoccupied break time (winter break, spring break, summer). If false, record findings and locations here: Mold or mildew growth is not evident. If false, record findings and locations here: All pest management issues are being handled by Integrated Pest Management. k. No other unresolved concerns or complaints by building personnel are known. If false, list any pending issues not previously mentioned in this report here: Cleaning came up in discussion. l. There are no incomplete HVAC preventative maintenance (PM) work requests. If false, list any incomplete HVAC work request here: 6. Bathrooms and General Plumbing Page 5 of 9 Revised 3/7/2011 AMJ Created 11/2010 IAQ Check List Building: Seth Paine Elementary School Date: May 7, 2014 Building Inspection Performed by: Lyle Erstad Report Compiled by: Lyle Erstad Check List a. All locker or restroom exhaust fans are working. Inoperable or malfunctioning fans are listed as follows: Location: Problem: IAQ Check List True False N/A b. All of the following drain-trap maintenance procedures are being conducted according to the frequency indicated. If false, indicate all deviations and locations: i. Water is poured into floor drains once per week (approximately 1 quart of water) or water and a teaspoon of cooking oil poured into the drain once a month. The Custodial staff is reminded of this regularly. ii. Water is poured into sinks at least once per week (about 2 cups of water). iii. Toilets are flushed at least once per week. 7. Lab Chemicals & Maintenance Supplies a. Lab chemicals are used with exhaust fans turned on. b. Lab chemical storage areas have been inspected yearly by ROE and Fire Department. Record last inspection dates below: ROE: 10/2013 LZFD: c. Flammables are not stored with igniters. d. All chemicals that may react or produce toxic or explosive by-products are separated and maintained in approved containers stored in approved storage. (e.g. lockable, with appropriate ventilation). Page 6 of 9 Revised 3/7/2011 AMJ Created 11/2010 IAQ Check List Building: Seth Paine Elementary School Date: May 7, 2014 Building Inspection Performed by: Lyle Erstad Report Compiled by: Lyle Erstad Check List e. Chemical disposal records for all lab chemicals are available for review. IAQ Check List True False N/A f. All cleaning products used in building contain no/low VOC. List any exceptions: g. Increased ventilation is considered when installing new carpets, cleaning upholstered furniture, shampooing carpets, etc. h. Exhaust ventilation systems in chemical and trash storage areas are turned on and functioning properly. i. Portable fuel containers are properly closed. j. Power equipment, like snow blowers and lawn mowers, have been serviced and maintained according to manufacturers’ guidelines. k. Oil based paints are stored in approved storage cabinets. No oil based paint allowed in District. l. Green Cleaning products and processes are used in this building. 8. Combustion Appliances a. Combustion analysis is performed at the start of the heating season on all boilers. Adjustments are made to the burners to correct any abnormalities and improve efficiency. Barr Mechanical conducted combustion analysis on February 24, 2014. b. In rooms that contain combustion appliances, there is no evidence of combustion gas or fuel odors. If false, record locations here: c. No leaks, disconnections, and/or deterioration were found on exhaust hoods. d. Flue components are clean and free of soot. Page 7 of 9 Revised 3/7/2011 AMJ Created 11/2010 IAQ Check List Building: Seth Paine Elementary School Date: May 7, 2014 Building Inspection Performed by: Lyle Erstad Report Compiled by: Lyle Erstad Check List e. All combustion appliances have flues or exhaust hoods and vent NO2. i. If false, inspect cooking hoods, chemical hoods. Assure that cooking stoves and appliances are correctly installed, used, and maintained according to manufacturers’ specifications. IAQ Check List True False N/A ii. If not vented, ensure that “leave-in” CO monitors are placed in room. Record locations here: NONE iii. CO levels in rooms with combustion appliances are measured and recorded with an IAQ monitor. CO readings outside of normal CO range will result in an immediate response by maintenance to reduce CO level or vacating the room/building, if necessary. Record locations here: 9. Other a. Paint No peeling and/or flaking paint found. If planned building renovation will damage paint or if peeling paint is discovered, lead testing may be necessary. If peeling paint is found, send email to the building Principal and the Facilities Director alerting them of the problem. Staff and teachers need to pick up any flakes of paint to prevent children from being exposed. The Facilities Director will advise the Facilities Coordinator (a Certified Lead Paint Renovator) to test the paint for lead. Lead paint was discontinued in 1978. Buildings built after 1978 are exempt from lead paint testing. If lead is present, required repairs should be done immediately using lead-safe methods and, if necessary, a licensed lead contractor. Location(s) of known peeling paint in building: b. The following preventive measures are being taken to reduce lead exposure. i. Play areas and toys are cleaned nightly. ii. Floors are mopped nightly. Page 8 of 9 Revised 3/7/2011 AMJ Created 11/2010 IAQ Check List Building: Seth Paine Elementary School Date: May 7, 2014 Check List Building Inspection Performed by: Lyle Erstad Report Compiled by: Lyle Erstad IAQ Check List True False N/A iii. Dust at least weekly. c. Radon testing is recommended by IEMA every 5 years. Last testing date listed below: Date: 12/16/2011 - 12/19/2011 ; Reading of (Highest) 1.0 pCi/L in Room 104. National concern level: 4.0 pCi/L or above d. The IAQ testing equipment used for this inspection was calibrated and is in good working order. Equipment Used: Gray Wolf Last date of calibration: 1/27/14 Page 9 of 9 Revised 3/7/2011 AMJ Created 11/2010 Seth Paine Spring 2014 IAQ Data Site Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Location Outdoor Air 100 104 105 107 110 111 112 113 200 208 209 210 211 300 302 304 306 307 308 309 100B Cafeteria Faculty lounge Date/Time 4/29/2014 12:10 4/29/2014 12:33 4/29/2014 12:53 4/29/2014 12:47 4/29/2014 12:44 4/29/2014 12:21 4/29/2014 12:24 4/29/2014 12:16 4/29/2014 12:31 4/29/2014 12:57 4/29/2014 13:10 4/29/2014 13:01 4/29/2014 13:07 4/29/2014 13:04 4/29/2014 13:12 4/29/2014 13:15 4/29/2014 13:17 4/29/2014 13:20 4/29/2014 13:32 4/29/2014 13:24 4/29/2014 13:28 4/29/2014 12:35 4/29/2014 12:27 4/29/2014 12:39 °F 62.3 74.7 75.5 75 75.1 72.9 73.5 71 74.6 75.7 74.5 74.1 74.1 73.3 75 75 75.3 73.9 75.7 74.8 75.2 74.4 74.2 75.3 % RH 56.6 48.2 49.5 45.3 46.4 51 47.4 55.7 46.9 45.5 47.8 46.6 47.3 46.5 46.4 46.6 45.4 44.8 47.5 47.6 46.9 47.3 49.4 47 CO ppm CO2 ppm Occupant 0 400 0 734 3 0 1093 26 0 936 19 0 811 10 0 739 21 0 524 17 0 1047 14 0 832 25 0 1479 25 0 1080 25 0 894 18 0 908 27 0 790 10 0 801 1 0 812 1 0 802 2 0 781 14 0 1004 19 0 1148 20 0 837 6 0 705 2 0 575 63 0 818 3 Window AC Note Site Location Date/Time Seth Paine Outdoor Air 5/1/2014 12:51:52 PM Seth Paine 101 5/1/2014 12:57:49 PM °F 51.7 66.7 % RH 47.9 53.3 CO ppm CO2 ppm Occupant 0 385 0 879 19 Window AC Note CO2 Formula: 700 + 400 = 1100 Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine 106 5/1/2014 1:01:16 PM 108 5/1/2014 1:03:17 PM 202 5/1/2014 1:13:50 PM 203 5/1/2014 1:17:09 PM 204 5/1/2014 1:19:08 PM 205 5/1/2014 1:21:13 PM 301 5/1/2014 1:35:41 PM 308 5/1/2014 1:27:28 PM 309W 5/1/2014 1:32:32 PM Gymnasium 5/1/2014 12:53:58 PM LL2 5/1/2014 1:11:56 PM 69.9 70.9 72.6 73.2 73 73.4 74.3 73.6 74.3 60.2 72.3 51.9 51 41.4 41.5 41.4 40.7 39.4 41.1 41.3 52.3 41.1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 921 923 692 830 855 816 832 973 880 677 671 22 11 12 21 21 22 3 14 6 20 11 Date/Time 5/5/2014 11:14 5/5/2014 10:53 5/5/2014 10:51 5/5/2014 11:02 5/5/2014 11:00 5/5/2014 10:58 5/5/2014 11:04 5/5/2014 11:06 5/5/2014 11:08 5/5/2014 10:49 °F 51.4 70.4 69.9 72.2 71.8 71.8 72.5 72.7 73.5 69.4 % RH 43.4 39.5 38.9 36.7 34.2 36.5 35.3 34.2 33.8 38.2 CO ppm CO2 ppm Occupant 0 391 0 1005 20 0 824 14 0 1669 4 0 661 3 0 919 15 0 885 15 0 796 2 0 847 2 0 666 3 Window AC Note Site Location Date/Time Seth Paine Outdoor Air 5/6/2014 12:17:51 PM °F 64.8 % RH 32.1 CO ppm CO2 ppm Occupant 0 396 Window AC Note CO2 Formula: 700 + 385 = 1085 Site Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Seth Paine Location Outdoor Air 102 103 200 201 202 207 309E 309W Nurse CO2 Formula: 700 + 391 = 1091 Seth Paine 200 5/6/2014 12:22:20 PM CO2 Formula: 700 + 396 = 1096 70.7 37.4 0 930 22 2nd unit off