Brianna’s Law
March 2013
EXHIBIT O Senate Committee on Judiciary
Date: 3-14-2013
Page: 1 of 90
States in Blue Have Passed Arrestee DNA Legislation
O2
O3
O4
O5
O6
O7
O8
O9
O 10
City of Chicago
53
Rapes & Murders
prevented
8 convicted felons
O 11
Chester Dewayne
Turner
O 12
Turner was arrested
21 times
Over 15 years
O 13
Chester Turner’s DNA
was found on twelve
12
rape and murder victims
O 14
First victim was murdered
two months
after the first arrest
O 15
Diane Johnson – March 29, 1987
Annette Ernest – October 29, 1987
Anita Fishman – January 20, 1989
Regina Washington – September 23, 1989
Debra Williams – November 16, 1992
Mary Edwards – December 16, 1992
Andrea Triplett – April 2, 1993
Desarae Jones – May 16, 1993
Natalie Price – February 12, 1995
Mildred Beasley – November 6, 1996
Paula Vance – February 3, 1998
Brenda Bries – April 6, 1998
O 16
O 17
Eleven Lives
Spared
O 18
David Jones
served
11 years in prison
wrongfully
convicted
O 19
One DNA sample taken
upon arrest
Eleven women saved
Prevented an innocent man
spending 11 years in prison
O 20
O 21
Matched a double
homicide
O 22
430
crimes matched
to
arrestee DNA
O 23
California
DNA database matching an
average of
10
crimes per day
O 24
California:
more matches with arrestee DNA in
4 years
than last
25 years
with convicted DNA alone
O 25
California:
rate of cases cleared and
investigations aided increased from
35%
to
67.9%
since adding arrestee DNA
O 26
DNA
Does not go into
CODIS
O 27
A DNA Profile
goes into
CODIS
O 28
The DNA strand has
over 3 billion
markers
O 29
The DNA strand has
over 3 billion
markers
Only 13
go into CODIS
O 30
These
13
markers have no potential to
disclose any medical
diagnostic information or
physical characteristics
O 31
33 RPM
Vinyl
Record
Album
O 32
“The Court should recognize
that CODIS profiling is not the
type of genetic testing that
supplies significant information
on disease risk or other physical
or
behavioral genetic traits.”
O 33
CODIS DNA Profile
This is the only information put into the database
LabXYZ
0012152
13,14,29,31.2,11,12,10,16,18,7,9,11,11
12,17,24,14,15,9,11,16,19,9,12,21,26
DHL
LabXYZ = Originating Laboratory Identifier
0012152 = Specimen ID #
(Number automatically generated upon entry into CODIS)
06,09,11,12,10,10,22,24,9,03,10,08,09,
14,14,15,17,17,22,25,12,12,9,10,09,13
(These are the pairs identifying the 13 markers)
O 34
DHL = Analyst Identifier
NO
Names or
Social Security
Numbers
In
CODIS
O 35
CODIS DNA Profile
This is the only information put into the database
LabXYZ
0012152
13,14,29,31.2,11,12,10,16,18,7,9,11,11
12,17,24,14,15,9,11,16,19,9,12,21,26
DHL
LabXYZ = Originating Laboratory Identifier
0012152 = Specimen ID #
(Number automatically generated upon entry into CODIS)
06,09,11,12,10,10,22,24,9,03,10,08,09,
14,14,15,17,17,22,25,12,12,9,10,09,13
(These are the pairs identifying the 13 markers)
O 36
DHL = Analyst Identifier
13,14,29,31.2,11,12,10,16,18,7,9,11,11
12,17,24,14,15,9,11,16,19,9,12,21,26
O 37
Match is Made:
O 38
Match is Made:
Originating State Reanalyzes
to verify accuracy
O 39
Match is Made:
Originating State Reanalyzes
to verify accuracy
Name is Identified
O 40
Match is Made:
Originating State Reanalyzes
to verify accuracy
Name is Identified
Name Released ONLY to
Law Enforcement
O 41
DNA Match only an
investigative lead
O 42
Only for FELONY arrests
O 43
Only for FELONY arrests
DNA Taken during formal
booking process
O 44
Only for FELONY arrests
DNA Taken during formal
booking process
Taken when fingerprints and
mug shots are taken
O 45
When Booked for A Crime
Can Be:
O 46
When Booked for A Crime
Can Be:
Held Against Will
O 47
When Booked for A Crime
Can Be:
Held Against Will
Strip Searched
O 48
When Booked for A Crime
Can Be:
Held Against Will
Strip Searched
Everything on person can be
searched
O 49
CODIS
is a
CLOSED
SECURE
SYSTEM
O 50
Federal
offense to tamper
with
CODIS
O 51
There has
NEVER been a
misuse of breach
of
CODIS
O 52
Arrestee DNA
SAVES
MONEY
O 53
Sentenced 69 years
with no parole
O 54
Over
Three
Years
Sooner
O 55
$200,000
could have been
saved
O 56
Every
$30
cheek swab results in
savings of
$27,000
O 57
For every
$1
invested in DNA
$90
is saved
O 58
Congress has
authorized grants to
pay for the first year of
an
Arrestee DNA
Testing Program
O 59
“The
Katie Sepich
Enhanced DNA
Collection Act”
O 60
100 United States Senators
O 61
100 United States Senators
2/3 United States House of
Representatives
O 62
100 United States Senators
2/3 United States House of
Representatives
Funded Implementation of
arrestee DNA
O 63
The United States
Supreme Court
will rule
by June 2013
O 64
“Collecting DNA from individuals
arrested for violent felonies provides a valuable tool for
investigating unsolved crimes and
thereby helping to remove violent
offenders from the general
population.”“
United States Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts
O 65
The Attorneys General
of
all 50 states
joined by
Puerto Rico and
the District of Columbia
signed a brief in support
O 66
“I think this is perhaps the most important criminal
procedure case that this Court has heard in
decades. So this is what is at stake: Lots of
murders, lots of rapes that can be solved using
this new technology that involves a very minimal
intrusion on personal privacy.
But why isn't this the fingerprinting of the 21st
century? What is the difference? If it was
permissible and it's been assumed to be so for
decades, that it is permissible to fingerprint
anybody who's booked, why is it not permissible
to take a DNA sample from anybody who is
arrested?”
United States Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito
O 67
Minorities
have been
disproportionately
wrongfully convicted
of crime
O 68
Erroneous eyewitness
identification
O 69
Erroneous eyewitness
identification
Racial Bias
O 70
DNA Profile does not identify
race
O 71
DNA Profile does not identify
race
Either the numbers match or
they do not
O 72
DNA
is our
best hope to
eliminate
racial bias
O 73
Office of the Inspector
General of the United
States insures
expungement is
thorough and complete
O 74
0
instances of
DNA
being manipulated or
queried for other purposes
O 75
Cold Cases Solved
O 76
Cold Cases Solved
Crimes Prevented
O 77
Cold Cases Solved
Crimes Prevented
Lives Saved
O 78
Cold Cases Solved
Crimes Prevented
Lives Saved
Innocent Exonerated
O 79
Cold Cases Solved
Crimes Prevented
Lives Saved
Innocent Exonerated
Taxpayers Dollars Saved
O 80
Brianna
Denison
O 81
100 United States Senators
O 82
100 United States Senators
2/3 of the
US House of
Representatives
O 83
100 United States Senators
2/3 of the
US House of
Representatives
Fifty States’ Attorneys General
O 84
100 United States Senators
2/3 of the
US House of
Representatives
Fifty States’ Attorneys General
President Barack Obama
O 85
Diane Johnson
Annette Ernest
Anita Fishman
Regina Washington
Debra Williams
Mary Edwards
Andrea Triplett
Desarae Jones
Natalie Price
Mildred Beasley
Paula Vance
Brenda Bries
O 86
O 87
O 88
www.dnasaves.org
O 89
O 90