Proceedings of European Business Research Conference Sheraton Roma, Rome, Italy, 5 - 6 September 2013, ISBN: 978-1-922069-29-0 Some Facts and Figures on Corruption: A Perception of Economic Financial Crimes Commission’s Performance in Maiduguri Metropolitant Council of Borno State Baba Gana Kolo “Some facts and figures on corruption: A perception of the performance of EFCC in curbing corruption” talked about theoretical and empirical issues on corruption and its control. It was established that Nigeria has been corrupt. With slightest political will Ribadu the pioneer chairman of EFCC showed possibility of enforcing anticorruption laws at all levels and situations. From Balogun the former Inspector General of Police, the sum of #17billion was discovered as stolen money by EFCC. It was also revealed that 75% of respondents maintained that EFCC’s performance was poor. Only 0.4% believed that it has performed excellently. While 50% said only a governor was arrested by the commission, to the best of their knowledge. 50% said only a commissioner was arrested, 38% (and majority) said between 2-10 local government chairmen were arrested by the commission. And 50% said only a traditional ruler or none was arrested, to the best of their knowledge by the commission. Basically a recommendation to legislate capital punishment for corruption was made, to enable realise the zero tolerance objective of the commission. That all agencies must annually forward reports of their activities particularly in relations to possessions of assets and financial transactions in Nigeria and beyond, for necessary legal actions against defaulters by the commission. Introduction Transparency International, a world renowned Non-Governmental Organization (NGO) ranked Nigeria as one of the most corrupt nations. It was observed that an independent commission against corruption be established. Awards of contract and public procurement be made transparent (Shenokan, 1997:27-29). President Olusegun Obasanjo created the Independent Corrupt Practices and other related Offences Commission by Act 2000. The function of which is investigation and prosecution, preventive and support against corruption. Subsequently enacted Economic and Financial Crimes Commission by EFCC Act 2004 (Otite, 1986; Akanbi, 2004:2-4). Some Facts on Corruption Former Ogun state governor in the defunct dispensation, Chief BisiOnobanjo, was locked away for 21 years for enriching the proscribed UPN to the tune of #2.8 million. Solomon Lar of Plateau state sentenced 21 years for misusing security votes. Professor Ambrose Alli of Bendel state jailed for using half a million naira to bury his father (New Times, 11-11-1985:23). The #20 “toll” has become an accepted norm for men of the Nigerian police, Ehindero the inspector general warned policemen not to “make returns” anymore, suggesting, perhaps, that had been the ___________________________________________________ Assoc.Prof. Bambang Riyanto, Faculty of Economics and Business, Universitas Gadjah Mada, Indonesia. Email: bambang_rls@yahoo.com Proceedings of European Business Research Conference Sheraton Roma, Rome, Italy, 5 - 6 September 2013, ISBN: 978-1-922069-29-0 practice. Commissioners of police posted to state perceived to be lucrative are given targets of as high as #10 million monthly revenue that should go to some superior officers. Such CPs could in turn hand use DPOs to also make returns depending on the economic viability of their stations (Tell 6th June, 2005:22). Gani Fawehinmi on Monday 23rd May, 2005 joined and defended, the EFCC, ICPC and Code of Conduct Bureau (CCB), wants answers to 8 questions. Whether or not it is right for a serving president to receive gifts from local and foreign contractors concerning the donation of #250million #211.6 million and #200 million by Mike Adenuga, Chairman of Globacom Communication Company; AlikoDangote, an industrialists and Sonny Odogwu, a businessman respectively, etc.The foreign contractor in question is Richard Brandson, who just bought Nigerian airways. Whether or not these 2 agencies ICPC and EFCC should investigate the presidential library project and its donors (Tell 6th June 2005:4). Economic and Financial Crimes Commission handed over to United States government a list containing about 200 Nigerians, including governors who might flee the country after the expiration of their term in government. Also in the list are two former head of states and their associates, businessmen and others. Ibrahim Babangida, AtikuAbubakar, AbdulsalamAbubakar, BoniHaruna, Oji KaluUzor, SaminuTuraki, Bukar Abba Ibrahim, Lucky Igbinedion, James Ibori, Chris Ngige, ChimorokeNnamani, Joshua Dariye, Victor Attah, Mike Adeniyi, OtumbaFasawe, Chief Adigu, Solomon Lar, AuguAgbe, George Akume, AdophusWabara, Anyim Pius Anyim, senator Chinwumeriye, Ken Nnamani, AttahiruBafarawa, HamisuMarigo, SaniYerima, Bola Ahmed Tinubu, Senator TokunboAgikulforis, Chief YomiEdu, Ayo Fayose, Adebayo Mao Akala, AchikeUdenwa, Ade Alake, Ibrahim Shekarau (Mail News 2-08-2006:31). AlhajiBalarabe Musa blasts at traditional rulers in the northern states over their reaction to the trial of some former governors from the sub-region on corruption. The northern Emirs were not courageous enough to out rightly denounce the former governors, who are already in the EFCC net (Joshua Dariye – Plateau, Reverend Jolly Nyame – Taraba and AlhajiSaminuTuraki (National Daily 19-8-2007:3). Attorney-General of the federation Michael Aondoakoa defended some governors that Ribadu investigated for corruption,designed to frustrate Ribadu‟s work. (Dailytrust, 9-1-2008:17).Chief of Navy Admiral Samuel Afolayan gingered the police that a missing ship was handed over to police before stolen. The alleged #2 billion worth of crude oil suspected to have been allegedly stolen and was being diverged outside the country was actually in the NNPC which received presidential directive on 29 January, 2004 to evacuate it. DIG Onovo in February 9 gone to take over the ship but the request was allegedly turned down by the flag officer commanding (FOC). (Daily trust, 10-9-2004:12). Governor Mala Kachalla inherits #776 million liabilities from the past administration in the state (Borno). #198 million owed to local contractors and #207 million was outstanding workers‟ salaries for the month of May, and #358.9 million was due as arrears of the minimum wage owed civil servants in the state for the month of January to March, while the sum of #11.4 million was for unpaid outstanding gratuities. And what he found on the coffers was #77.8 million and not #97.5 million as contained in the handover notes of the state administrator Group Proceedings of European Business Research Conference Sheraton Roma, Rome, Italy, 5 - 6 September 2013, ISBN: 978-1-922069-29-0 Captain LawalHaruna. Cheques in transit worth #50 million were also stopped since his assumption of office on May 29 (The Post Express 14-6-1999:3). Ex-Inspector General of Police including Sunday Adewusi, Mohammed GamboJimeta and Ibrahim Attah, gang up against NuhuRibadu. They are daily sensitizing their own in the police to be wary to Ribadu and his boys, during and after their tenure and to mark them as 5th columnists who must be avoided at all cost or taken out of the system entirely if possible. If he could be so hard on Tofa, an IG to the extent of parading him in handcuffs, they reasoned that they have to mind their association with him (Exclusive 01/06/2005:3). Gross misconduct allegedly committed by Governor Malah Kachalla was the misappropriation of #7 million from local government allocation. The assembly built 35 housing units in Abuja. The house said #342.9 million was approved but the governor spent #612 million for the houses. Lodge for #70 million as against #18 million approved by the house for the purpose. Spent #129 million against #80 million approved by the house to rehabilitate Borno state hotel in Maiduguri. #70 million was spent against approved #40 million for rehabilitation of hospital at December. #267.03 million was approved for Urban and regional planning in the 2000 budget but the total sum spent so far was #464.5 million, an excess of #197.14 for water project, the excess was put as #90.6 million while #320.3 million was over spent on general administration. The total excess was put at #608,387.712 million (Newswatch, 06/11/2000:38). Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) arrested over 500 suspects as a results of which some top government officers lost their jobs, like the former Inspector General of police, the former minister of housing and development, Mrs.MobolayiOsomo, the former minister of education professor FabianOsuji and senate president Chief AdolphusWabara, all fired for corruption by the president (Weekly Trust, 7/10/2005:13). The Joint Task Force (JTF) has accused the traditional ruler of Koniju in Okirika King captainNemiOputibeya, Okirika Local government area of Rivers state of aiding and abetting oil bunkering and other criminal activities within his domain (Daily Trust, 14/12/2007:6). Among the charges slammed on AlamieSiegha he refused to disclose his account number 005482562491 with an American bank with a balance of $160,000 in the declaration of his assets; Account number 201006285006 with Bond Bank Plc. With a balance of #105 million alleged against him. He was sentenced to 12 years jail term by the court in Lagos over six charges, to spend only two years in prison as the sentences were to run concurrently (Leadership 14/12/2007:1). Police Equipment Fund national coordinator, Kenny Martins, his deputy, Ibrahim Dimiye, were arraigned before the court on a three count charge of criminal breach of public trust and mismanagement of about #7.74 billion belonging to Association of Local Government of Nigeria (ALGON). Of the #7.74 billion, they were accused of dishonestly converting about #59 million to private use and unlawful retention of another #774 million for personnel use, in violation of an agreement with ALGON and the federal government, punishable under section 312 of the penal code CAP 532 laws of the federation of Nigeria (This day 21/11/2008:7). Proceedings of European Business Research Conference Sheraton Roma, Rome, Italy, 5 - 6 September 2013, ISBN: 978-1-922069-29-0 Perception of Efcc’s Performance in Curbing Corruption Table 1: Distribution of Respondents by the Overall Assessment of Efccin Terms of Performance in Curbing Corruption Responses MMC Poor Below average Above average Good Excellent Total Source: PH.D survey Categories of Respondents EFCC officials 180 20 2 200 Frequency 180 22 Percentage (%) 75 9 3 3 1.2 3 3 1.2 1 1 0.4 40(-31) 240(-31) 100%(-13%) NB. 31(13%) No response The table shows that 75% of the total of 240 respondents maintained EFCC could be rated as poor in terms of its performance, 9% maintained performance of EFCC is below average, 1.2% said it is good, while excellent was given by 0.4% of the respondents. Thus, majority observed that EFCC poorly performed so far, or performed below public expectation. that that rate has By virtue of the special powers in section 7 of the EFCC (establishment) Act 2004, the commission‟s performance would have been excellent success as observed by 4% of the respondents. .Corrupt authorities fearlessly erecting mansions around, which are apparently beyond their legitimate income, and also riding vehicles that appeared to be beyond their legitimate income? More so, maintaining family sizes, living ostentatiously without any fear of being ridiculed by the law. Smugglers are everybody‟s neighbour at all border towns of the country. In fact, they have associations that stand in defence of their members. This revealed/demonstrated high degree of poor performance of EFCC and complete disregard to zero tolerance to corruption, designed in the federal government‟s 7 point agenda. For Economic and Financial Crimes Commission‟s (EFCC) performance to be upward reviewed, all suspicious elements must be massively called to book as prescribed by section 7 of the Act 2004. Each constituency representative (councillor, member‟s house of assembly/representative) must be held responsible for all economic/financial crimes of his constituency. Each must as a duty give monthly report, cover every developmental project; estimate the cost both in service and materials of each department/ministry or parastatal. Such reports be submitted to appropriate committees at all levels of the legislation and observations be given to government for necessary actions. Copies of budget at all levels be submitted to EFCC together with the monthly legislative constituency assessment of performance of government reports. Each representative should be made responsible to directly write to EFCC any infrastructural development by anybody under his constituency, including new cars owned by anybody together with the estimated amount of its price. With these measures taken, no criminal can hide in Nigeria. And if the legislators fail to give appropriate report as suggested on jointly bases to EFCC such councillor, member, house of assembly/representative or senator will be subjected to the application of section 7 of the EFCC (establishment) Act, 2004. And such legislator shall equally be subjected to section 16 (1) – (3) of the EFCC (establishment) Act, 2004. Proceedings of European Business Research Conference Sheraton Roma, Rome, Italy, 5 - 6 September 2013, ISBN: 978-1-922069-29-0 Section 16 1. Stated that any person who, in the discharge of his duty under this Act, gives information which is false in any material particular to a public officer or any person who is to take decision or do any other act in relation thereto commits an offence under this Act, and the onus shall be on him to prove that he exercise due diligence to prevent the commission of the offence having regards to the nature of his function and circumstances; 2. The penalty for the offence under section (1) of this section shall be imprisonment for a term not less than 2 years and not more than 3 years. Provided that where the offender is a public officer the penalty shall be imprisonment for a term not less than 3 years and not more than 5 years. 3. Without prejudice to the provisions of any other enactment, any regulatory agency or body in the financial sector shall in the exercise of its function liaise with the commission to 4. investigate and monitor the commission of economic and financial crimes. If this recommendation is put to use by the commission and other stake holders, Nigeria will very soon see a non-existing land of corruption, and further prove how serious Nigeria is on zero tolerance to corruption. Table2: Distribution of Respondents by Knowledge of Number of Former Governors Arrested Resp. Don’t know Only one Categories of Respondents MMC 80 Freq. EFCC officials Percentage (%) 80 - 33 120 2-10 - 120 40 40 - 50 17 11-20 Above 20 Total 200 40 240 100% Source: PH.D survey From the table above, it is clear that 33% of the total of 240 respondents revealed that to the best of their knowledge they do not know any former governor arrested by EFCC so far. 50% of the respondents said only one former governor has been arrested by EFCC so far. 17% said between 2 – 10 former governors have been arrested by EFCC. Proceedings of European Business Research Conference Sheraton Roma, Rome, Italy, 5 - 6 September 2013, ISBN: 978-1-922069-29-0 It is obvious to note that Nigeria‟s anti-corruption laws and judicial procedures of litigating corrupt authorities are frustrating. For instance, many former governors accused of breaching the oath have been let off the hook, after a plea bargain (claimed to be guaranteed by the law). Code of Conduct Bureau chairman, Sam Saba said, some governors had made some refunds, hence their exclusion from trial (e.g. somebody like SaminuTuraki made refunds to the federal government) (Ogundele, 2001). Such laws are in favour of corruption and corrupt authorities. Corrupt authorities could carelessly commits said crime with clear mission of taking advantage of the short falls of the law, by simply offering part of their stolen wealth to go squat free. This results in mockery of the majority of the general public members who are victims of corrupt practices of same authorities arrogantly moving amidst them. This table further more confirm to the fact that majority of members of public don‟t know the impact of EFCC since its existence. This is too embarrassing particularly considering the fact that more than 85% of the total of 1240 respondents has at least secondary school education as qualification. It is highly abnormal for such category of individuals to be predominantly unconscious of serious happening of the affairs of the dear country. More so, about 97% of the total of 1240 respondents are between the age bracket of 18 – 49 years; the most productive category of population. This category of population are supposed to be the active participants in all development issues and particularly issues like corruption that has given Nigeria the dirtiest picture as sometimes most corrupt nation in the world. Table 3: Distribution of Respondents by Knowledge of Number of Commissioners Arrested by EFCC So Far Resp. Categories of Respondents MC 80 Don’t know Only one 2-10 120 11-20 - Above 20 Total - Freq. Percentage (%) - 80 33 - 120 50 40 40 17 100.1 = 100% 40 240 EFCC officials - 200 Source: PH.D survey The table above revealed that 50% of the total of 240 respondents said to the best of their knowledge only one commissioner has been arrested by EFCC so far. There are no singled out records of commissioners arrested by EFCC from the GombeZonal headquarters made available in the course of this finding despite the fact that the officer in charge readily cooperated. However, ICPC record revealed that between 2001 and 2007 there was generally nobody prosecuted in Adamawa state,only one prosecuted in 2006 in Bauchi state, total of 3 prosecuted in Borno state (2 in 2006 and 1 in 2007), 1 in 2007 in Gombe, 1 in 2006 and 1 in 2007 in Taraba state (totalled 2) and only 1 in Yobe state in 2007. A total of 8 were prosecuted in the region between 2001 and 2007. The reality of the skeletal service given to researchers when it comes to records by EFCC is a clue of insincerity harboured by the commission which in itself is corruption. Proceedings of European Business Research Conference Sheraton Roma, Rome, Italy, 5 - 6 September 2013, ISBN: 978-1-922069-29-0 Section 192: (1) Of the 1999 constitution said there shall be such offices of commissioners of the government of a state as may be established by the governor of the state. (2) Any appointment to the office of commissioners of the government of a state shall, if the nomination of any person to such office is confirmed by the house of assembly of the state, be made by the governor of that state and in making any such appointment, the governor shall confirm with the provisions of section 14 (4) of the constitution; (3) No person shall be appointed as a commissioner of the government of a state unless he is qualified for election as a member of the house of assembly of the state. Section 14 (4) of the constitution stated that the composition of the government of a state, a local government council, or any of the agencies of such government or council, and the conduct of the affairs of the government or council or such agencies shall be carried out in such manner as to recognise the diversity of the people within its area of authority and the need to promote a sense of belonging and loyalty among all the peoples of the federation. By application of section 14 (4) to the affairs of state, it is likely to have at least a commissioner from each local government area under a state. Thus, Nigeria could have at least a total of 774 commissioners at a time for the federation which is equivalent to the total number of local government areas. If each commissioner served for a minimum of one year for the past 48 years we shall have a total of 34,152 commissioners to have served as maximum in Nigeria. And for north eastern state, Bauchi, Borno, Adamawa, Taraba, Yobe and Gombe state with a total of 113 local government areas, there should be 113 x 48 = 5424 likely to have served in the region. And for the sampled states are 64 x 48 = 3072. If EFCC meant a real business in fighting corruption in Nigeria a significant number if not all the 34,152likely to have served commissioners should have been suspected, most likely arrested. Section 7 (1) – (2) of the EFCC (establishment) Act 2004 should have been put to effective use accordingly. The insignificant numbers of commissioners known to have been arrested by the respondents is a testimony that EFCC lived below expectations. Proceedings of European Business Research Conference Sheraton Roma, Rome, Italy, 5 - 6 September 2013, ISBN: 978-1-922069-29-0 Table 4: Distribution of Respondents by Knowledge on Number of L. G. Chairmen Arrested by EFCC So Far. Resp. Don’t know Only one 2-10 Categories of Respondents MC 60 Freq. Percentage (%) - 60 25 - 50 21 - 90 38 40 40 17 40 240 100% EFCC officials 50 90 11-20 - Above 20 Total - - 200 Source: PH.D survey The table above revealed that 38% of the total of 240 respondents mentioned that to the best of their knowledge 2-10 local government chairman have been arrested by EFCC so far. In total of 80% of the respondents maintained that less than 10 local government chairmen were arrested by EFCC to their knowledge. Nigeria has 774 local government chairmen nationwide. From 1960 to date, we may have less than 30,000 local government chairmen that have served offices nationwide. EFCC have not lived up to expectation since it cannot boast of arresting or prosecuting 1000 of them from this 30,000 or less. Level of corruption at the local government level is known to everybody, including the commission. And for northeast zone there are 113 chairmen from which 64 are of the sample state. And a total of 64 x 48 = 3072 at maximum level could have served as chairmen. Mrs. Farida Waziri, executive Chairman, EFCC at 2nd EFCC/ALGON National Workshop held on 26th August, 2008 at the Training and Research Institute (TRI), Karu, Abuja, stated that local government administration had become elitist and excluded the people which it was meant to serve their interest, that some chief executives of local government councils no longer reside in the domain they were elected to administer; some only drive in from state capitals when monies are to be shared and then disappear till the next allocations comes from the federation account. That three trillion, three hundred and thirteen billion, five hundred and thirty four million, eight hundred and fifty six thousand, five hundred and forty one naira, seventy nine kobo (#3, 313, 534, 856, 541, 79k) was allocated to the local government councils from 1999 to June 2007, stressing that failure at the third tier of government could not then be blamed on lack of funds but corruption (Zero Tolerance, 1/2/2009:14). Governor Jonah Jang of Plateau stated that local government administration had over the years become drain pipes while some so called development centres were avenues of siphoning government funds. Some state governors share in the blame for the poor state of affairs in these councils as they fail to completely release funds accruable to them, called for a thorough screening of persons aspiring to leadership positions in the councils, as well as regular auditing of local government accounts (Zero Tolerance, 1/2/2009:14). Proceedings of European Business Research Conference Sheraton Roma, Rome, Italy, 5 - 6 September 2013, ISBN: 978-1-922069-29-0 The executive chairman and governor Jang‟s statements are both categorically suspicious of the activities of the chairmen and even some state governors. These two positions are enough to put to action section 7 (1) (a) and (b), and (2) (a) – (f). By this provision, EFCC has special power to cause to investigate into the properties of any person and notwithstanding the less than 30,000 local government council chairmen believed to have served in that capacity since 1960, since they are clearly suspicious to the commission and to almost all Nigerians. The lifestyles and the extent of the properties claimed to have owned by such individuals are never in any way justifiable to their source of income. Table 5: Distribution of Respondents by Knowledge of Number of Traditional Rulers Arrested by EFCC So Far Resp. Don’t know Only one 2-10 Categories of Respondents MC 80 Freq. EFCC officials 80 - 40 33 40 80 17 80 11-20 Above 20 Total Percentage (%) 33 40 40 40 240 200 17 100.4 = 100% Source: PH.D survey The table above revealed that 33% of the total 240 respondents maintained that no single traditional ruler has been arrested by EFCC, 17% said one traditional ruler has been arrested by EFCC. 17% maintained that more than 20 traditional rulers have been arrested by EFCC. The EFCC officials maintained that more than 20 traditional rulers were arrested. The commission has no special treatment to suspects based on hierarchies or social orders. All suspects are suspects, and categorization is based on offences not calibre of suspects or dependent/accused. Even if we go by this declaration as accurate, it is absolutely inadequate andproves to the high degree of performance of EFCC is fighting corruption to expected standard. Dailies reported Yobe state government sacked number of officials of the traditional institution for alleged corrupt practices, yet such individuals have not been on the accessible records of EFCC. Even if all of the Yobe traditional rulers sacked were arrested by EFCC the number is still insignificant compared to proportion of those in atrocities. Another example is that of deposed sultan of Sokoto, Ibrahim Macido for fraud and public deception to enrich himself and few other traditional rulers mostly deposed during military regimes. Nevertheless, most of them are not put to conviction judiciously. Proceedings of European Business Research Conference Sheraton Roma, Rome, Italy, 5 - 6 September 2013, ISBN: 978-1-922069-29-0 Conclusion and Recommendation From above it was established that Nigeria has been corrupt. There were also indications of efforts to fight against corruption with the creation of EFCC. With slightest political will the pioneer chairman of EFCC showed possibility of enforcing laws against corruption upon any Nigerian who hitherto were believed to be untouchables. But powers to exercise the appropriate political will particularly on issues of curbing corruption have always been blocked and hijacked by corrupt elements, so the will are almost always used against anti-corruption gangs. No wonder effort of Ribadu was frustrated to the extent that many critical minds could conclude without any fear of contradiction that Nigeria is very unfortunately a hopeless state. Paradoxically we still have elements of anti-corruption gangs who have prepared to risk their lives to face the challenges. Corrupt elements are clear from above that they are cult members who could fearlessly group and gang against anti-corrupt bodies. From Balogun alone EFCC discovered #17billion stolen money. From the perception of performance in tables above, the agency is a complete failure in terms of number of cases handled at least to the best of the knowledge of respondents. Majority perceived that corrupt elements like the governors, commissioners, local government chairmen, traditional rulers etc. have not been significantly arrested by EFCC after years claims of anticorruption exercises. Also the public perceived that from all indications the EFCC has not realized its set objectives. It is clear corruption in Nigeria is an effect of capitalist operation, specifically dependent capitalism where the state was made the only source of generating wealth by bribery and embezzlement. Based on above it is an obligation to make following recommendations. That anti -corruption elements no matter the circumstance should not give up. There must be no excuse for corruption. Assets must be declared publically by all and particularly accounting officers in public. Code Conduct Bureau must be transparent and publish all assets declared and actions taken authoritatively. There must be triangular and transparent relationship between various tiers of government and all agencies with over all common goal of curbing corruption. Money embezzled and bribes collected are not spirits, and so they cannot hide to government. EFCC must have access to information on every Nigerian and particularly on accounting officers directly by distributing questionnaires annually. The questionnaire must contain general survey on income and assets in all forms. Cash in banks, family sizes, cost of general living etc. Banks must forward the statements of accounts of everybody to the EFCC annually. The land departments must keep record of every development on land and forward such reports to EFCC annually. Vehicles and related registration agencies like Federal Road Safety Corps, Police, Board of revenues etc. should annually forward detailed reports of their activities to EFCC for necessary legal actions. Only clean, honest, determined and courageous citizens must be recruited in EFCC and where by errors wrong persons are found in the agency they should be expelled and prosecuted. Let there be more sociologists in the agency. There must be death penalty for corruption, to realize EFCC‟s zero-tolerance objective. And all above are bound to be frustrated under the current dispensation of dirty but well concrete dependent capitalist socio-economic order. For above to be successful and to see Nigeria preoccupied by corrupt free transactions, all hands Proceedings of European Business Research Conference Sheraton Roma, Rome, Italy, 5 - 6 September 2013, ISBN: 978-1-922069-29-0 must be on desk to bring an end to capitalism, so that nobody worships money but respect human dignity. References Akanbi, M. M.A(2004) „Current policy initiatives and framework for combating corruption‟. In The Nigerian Social Scientist. Vol.7 No1(SSAN, Abuja) pp 2-6 Code of Conduct for Public Officers (2009), (The Presidency, CCB). CODESRIA, Bulletin 1990, No. 3 P. 2, Crp January-March 1998, P. 4, 28. Daily Trust, 10 September, 2004, P. 12 Daily Trust, 14 December, 2007, P. 6 Daily Trust, 26 June, 2008, P. 3 Daily Trust, 9 January, 2008, P. 16 EFCC (2004).Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (Establishment) Act, 2004 (Abuja). Exclusive, 1 June, 2005, P. 3 Federal Republic of Nigeria (1999) Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 (Federal Government Press) Apapa. Lagos Hotline, 17 February, 2000, P. 21 Leadership, 14 December, 2007, P. 1 Mails News of August 2006, P. 31 National Daily, 19 August, 2007, P. 3 New Times, 11 November, 1985, P. 28 News Watch, 1 January, 2001, P. 23 News Watch, 6 November, 2000, P. 18 Odekunle, F. (1986). (ed) Nigerian: Corruption in Development, Definition, Methodological and Theoretical Issues; in Odekunle F. (ed). Nigeria Corruption in Development.(Ibadan University Press).(University Press Ibadan). Post Express, 14 June, 1999, P. 3 Sa‟ad, A. M. (1988). In Search of Justice for Nigeria: A critical Analysis of Formal and Informal Justice in Gongola State (Ph. D. Thesis University of Sussex). Saba, S. (2006).“Assets Declaration and Monitoring, Implimentation for Obligation of Public Officials”. Paper Presented at the Retreat for Management Staff and Coordinators of Code of Conduct Bureau State Officers, 22-23 September, 2006. Hamdala Hotel, Kaduna. Sunday Trust, 16 December, 2007, P. 58 Tell, 6 June, 2005, P. 11 This Day, 21 November, 2008, P. 1 Weekly Trust, 7 October, 2005, P. 13 Zerotolerance, Vol. 1 March, 2008, P. 33 Zerotolerance, Vol. 2, No. 2007, P. 15 Zerotolerance, Vol. 3, No. 1, 2008, P. 21