HPSCGA20: ScienceandMedicineacrossMedievalWorlds CourseSyllabus 2015-16session|DrBillMacLehose|w.maclehose@ucl.ac.uk CourseInformation ThisseminarstudiesthetransferofscientificknowledgefromtheancientGreco-Romanworldtoan ArabiccontextfromtheninthcenturyonwardandaWesternChristiancontextfromtheeleventh centurytotheeveoftheRenaissance.Wewillexaminehowandwhycentresoflearning,suchas AlexandriaandBaghdadorsouthernItalyandSpain,broughtbothcontinuityandchangetothe scientifictradition.Bystudyinggeography,astronomy,physiology,contagiousdiseases,and pharmacology,wewillexplorethewaysinwhichMuslim,JewishandChristianviewsofknowledge influencedeachotherintheformationofascientificmethodandspiritofinquiryintothenaturalworld basedonapaganpast.Howdidthedifferentsciences,suchasmedicine,geography,astrology,and mathematics,connectwitheachotherandwithphilosophyandtheology?Wewillalsoconsiderthe WesternspreadofscientificknowledgeoutofthelearnedLatin-speakingworldtoabroaderaudience throughtranslationsintotheEuropeanvernaculars. Theprimaryobjectiveoftheseminaristoprovidestudentswithanextensiveoverviewofscienceinthe medievalArabicandLatinworlds,viewedfromacomparativeanalyticperspective.Weshallapproach thetopicfromaninterdisciplinaryangle,addressingmedievalscience,technologyandmedicinefrom historical,sociologicalandanthropologicalmethodologies.Byanalysingtechnical,literaryandvisual sources,wewillexplorethemedievalunderstandingsofmicrocosmandmacrocosm,thehumanbody andthenaturalworld. Basiccourseinformation MoodleWeb site: https://moodle.ucl.ac.uk/course/view.php?id=22932 Assessment: Researchessay,5000words Timetable: www.ucl.ac.uk/sts/hpsc Prerequisites: Nopre-requisites Requiredtexts: Norequiredtexts Coursetutor: DrBillMacLehose Contact: w.maclehose@ucl.ac.uk|t:02076792929 Web: www.ucl.ac.uk/silva/sts/staff/maclehose Officelocation: 22GordonSquare,Room3.2 Officehours: Monday,11-12;Friday,11-12 HPSC 2013-14sessionemail Schedule UCLWeek Topic 6 Reorientatingthehistoryofscience 7 Date 11Jan 9 Transmissionofscientificknowledge:East 18Jan andWest Thebodyconsidered:Anatomyandtheuse 25Jan ofcorpses Sex,desireandphysiology 1Feb 10 Magicandalchemy 8 Activity Sa’idal-Andalusi; Lindberg1991 Meyerhof;Guyde Chauliac;Burnett Park;Savage-Smith Decoitu;Trotula; JacquartandThomasset 8Feb Linden;Olsan 11 ReadingWeek 15Feb 12 Blurredboundaries:Religionandscience 22Feb Lindberg1995; Condemnations;Perho Saliba;Maimonides; French1994 Woodward;Gaudio; Beeston Gimpel;Saliba;Villard online;al-Jazarionline Horrox;Touati;Dols 13 Astronomyandastrology 29Feb 14 GeographyandtheImageoftheWorld 7Mar 15 Artisans,architectureandartillery:Medieval 14Mar technologies Epidemicsandinfectiousdisease:Medieval 21Mar responses 16 Assessments Summary Description 100% Assignments Researchessay Deadline Wordlimit Outlineand preliminary bibliographydue1 March2016 (formative,require); Finaldraft:5000 Finaldraftdue24 March2016 (summative,required) The research essay will consist of a topic of the student’s choosing (pending the instructor’s approval) which fits within the parameters of the module, i.e. between approximately 500 and 1500 AD, and related to the history of science, technology and medicine of the Islamic and Christianworlds.Itconsistsoftworequiredparts:thefirstisaformative,unmarkedoutlineand HPSC 2013-14sessionemail preliminarybibliography,andthesecondisthefinalversion. EssaysmustbesubmittedviaMoodle. In order to be deemed ‘complete’ on this module students must attempt both the outline/bibliographyandtheresearchessay. Criteriaforassessment The departmental marking guidelines for individual items of assessment can be found in the STS StudentHandbook. Aims&objectives Theassignmentwillallowthestudenttoworkwithbothprimaryandsecondarysourcestostudyatopic ofhisorherownchoosing.EssaysmustbesubmittedviaMoodle. Inordertobedeemed‘complete’onthismodulestudentsmustattempttodeveloparesearchtopic(to beapprovedbythelecturer),abibliographyandwriteananalyticalessayof5000words.Thestudent mustalsomeettheUCLguidelinesforattendance. Readinglist Week1:ReorientatingHistoryofScience Sa‘idAl-Andalusi.ScienceintheMedievalWorld:“BookoftheCategoriesofNations.”Austin:Universityof TexasPress,1991.(selectionsonmoodle)*** Lindberg,David.TheBeginningsofWesternScience.Chicago,UCP,1992.Chapter1.*** Week2:TransmissionofScientificKnowledge:EastandWest Meyerhof,Max.‘SultanSaladin’sPhysicianontheTransmissionofGreekMedicinetotheArabs.’BHM18 (1945)169-178.*** GuydeChauliac,Surgery,selectionfromGrant,SourceBook.*** Burnett,Charles.‘TheCoherenceoftheArabic-LatinTranslationProgrammeinToledointheTwelfth Century.’ScienceinContext14(2001)249-88.*** ‘FromNoahtoGalen’(unpublishedtext,classhandout) Jacquart,Danielle.‘TheInfluenceofArabicMedicineintheMedievalWest.’InEncyclopediaoftheHistory ofArabicScience.Ed.RoshdiRashed.London,Routledge,1996,3vols. Young,M.J.L.,J.D.LathamandR.B.Serjeant.Religion,LearningandScienceinthe‘AbbasidPeriod. Cambridge:CUP,1990. Gutas,Dmitri.GreekThought,ArabicCulture.London,1998. Peters,F.E.AristotleandtheArabs.NewYork:NYUPress,1968. Pormann,PeterandEmilieSavageSmith.MedievalIslamicMedicine.Edinburgh:EdinburghUniversity Press,2007. Plessner,Martin.‘TheNaturalSciencesandMedicine’,inTheLegacyofIslam,ed.JosephSchachtandC.E. Bosworth,Oxford:ClarendonPress,1974. Rosenthal,Franz.TheClassicalHeritageinIslam.TransEmileandJennyMarmorstein.Berkeley:University ofCaliforniaPress,1975. Savage-Smith,Emilie.‘Medicine.’InEncyclopediaoftheHistoryofArabicScience.Ed.RoshdiRashed. London,Routledge,1996,3vols. Southern,R.W.‘FromSchoolstoUniversities.’InTheEarlySchools:TheHistoryoftheUniversityofOxford, ed.JeremyCatto.ClarendonPress,1984.*** HPSC 2013-14sessionemail Chenu,M.-D.Nature,ManandSocietyintheTwelfthCentury.LesterK.Little,trans.ChicagoUniversity Press,1968. Crombie,A.C.RobertGrossetesteandtheOriginsofExperimentalScience,1100-1700.ClarendonPress, 1953 French,RogerandAndrewCunningham.BeforeScience:TheInventionoftheFriars’NaturalPhilosophy. ScholarPress,1996. Joannitius,Isagogue,tr.H.P.Cholmeleyas‘TheGalenicSystem’inE.Grant,ASourceBookinMedieval Science,HarvardU.P.,1974,pp.705-15. Lindberg,DavidC,ed.ScienceintheMiddleAges.Chicago:UniversityofChicagoPress,1978. Shank,Michael,ed.TheScientificEnterpriseinAntiquityandMiddleAges:ReadingsfromIsis.Chicago UniversityPress,2000. Siraisi,Nancy.MedievalandEarlyRenaissanceMedicine.Chicago:ChicagoUP,1990. Week3:TheBodyConsidered:Anatomyandtheuseofcorpses Park,Katharine.‘TheLifeoftheCorpse:DivisionandDissectioninLateMedievalItaly.’Journalofthe HistoryofMedicineandAlliedSciences.50(1995)111-132.*** Savage-Smith,Emilie.‘AttitudestowardDissectioninMedievalIslam.’JournaloftheHistoryofMedicine andAlliedSciences50(1995)67-110.*** Meyerhof,Max.‘IbnAn-Nafis(XIIIthCent.)andHisTheoryoftheLesserCirculation.’Isis23(1935)100-20. *** Park,Katharine.Women’sSecrets:Gender,GenerationandtheOriginsofHumanDissection.NewYork, ZoneBooks,2006.ch.2. Conrad,LawrenceI.‘UsamaibnMunqidhandOtherWitnessestoFrankishandIslamicMedicineintheEra oftheCrusades.’InAmar,etal.eds.Ha-Refu’ahbi-Yerushalayim(MedicineinJerusalem)1999,pp. xxvii-lii. Corner,GeorgeW.AnatomicalTextsoftheEarlierMiddleAges.Washington,D.C.,CarnegieInstitution, 1927. Mitchell,PiersD.MedicineintheCrusades:Warfare,WoundsandtheMedievalSurgeon.Cambridge,CUP, 2004. O’Neill,YnezViole.‘TheFunfbilderserieReconsidered.’BHM43(1969)236-45. Savage-Smith,Emilie.‘ThePracticeofSurgeryinIslamicLands:MythandReality’,inEmilieSavage-Smith andPeregrineHorden(eds)TheYear1000:MedicalPracticeattheEndoftheFirstMillennium. SpecialvolumeofSocialHistoryofMedicine,2000,13.2:307-321. Week4:Sex,desireandphysiology Delaney,Paul.‘ConstantinusAfricanus’‘DeCoitu’:ATranslation.’TheChaucerReview4(1969)55-65.*** Green,MonicaH.TheTrotula:AMedievalCompendiumofWomen’sMedicine.Philadelphia,UPennPress, 2001.(selections)*** Jacquart,DanielleandClaudeThomasset.SexualityandMedicineintheMiddleAges.TransMatthew Adamson.PrincetonUniversityPress,1988[Frenchoriginal,1985].*** Maimonides.OnCohabitation.InMedicalWritingsofMaimonides. Laqueur,Thomas.MakingSex:BodyandGenderfromtheGreekstoFreud.HarvardUniversityPress,1990. Ch.2,DestinyinAnatomy. Cadden,Joan.MeaningsofSexDifferenceintheMiddleAges:Medicine,ScienceandCulture.Cambridge: CUP,1993. Gil’adi,Avner.Infants,ParentsandWetNurses:MedievalIslamicViewsofBreastfeedingandTheirSocial Implications.Leiden:Brill,1999. HPSC 2013-14sessionemail Green,MonicaH.MakingWomen’sMedicineMasculine:TheRiseofMaleAuthorityinPre-Modern Gynaecology.Oxford,OUP,2008. Lemay,HelenRodnite.Women’sSecrets:ATranslationofPseudo-AlbertusMagnus’Desecretismulierum withCommentaries.Albany,NY:StateUniversityofNewYorkPress,1992. Musallam,B.F.‘TheHumanEmbryoinArabicScientificandReligiousThought.’InG.R.Dunstan,ed.The HumanEmbryo:AristotleandtheArabicandEuropeanTraditions.Exeter:UniversityofExeter Press,1990,pp.32-46. Riddle,John.ContraceptionandAbortionfromtheAncientWorldtotheRenaissance.Cambridge,MA: HarvardUniversityPress,1992,pp.108-143. Solomon,Michael.TheMirrorofCoitus:ATranslationandEditionoftheFifteenth-CenturySpeculumal foderi.MedievalSpanishMedicalTextsSeries29.1990. Week5:Magicandalchemy Linden,StantonJ.,ed.TheAlchemyReader:FromHermesTrismegistustoIsaacNewton.CUP,2003. (selections)*** Olsan,Lea.‘CharmsandPrayersinMedievalMedicalTheoryandPractice.’SocialHistoryofMedicine16 (2003)343-66.*** Savage-Smith,Emilie.MagicanddivinationinEarlyIslam.TheFormationoftheClassicalIslamicWorld42. London:Ashgate,2004.*** Bacon,Roger.RogerBacon’sLetterConcerningtheMarvellousPowerofArtandofNatureandConcerning theNullityofMagic.Tr.T.L.Davis.1923. Flint,ValerieJ.‘TheEarlyMedieval‘Medicus’,theSaint–andtheEnchanter.’SocietyfortheSocialHistory ofMedicine2(1989)127-145. Kieckhefer,Richard.MagicintheMiddleAges.Cambridge:CUP,1989. Maxwell-Stuart,PG,ed.TheOccultinMedievalEurope,500-1500:ADocumentaryHistory.Palgrave Macmillan,1999. McVaugh,Michael.‘TheHumidumradicaleinThirteenth-centuryMedicine.’Traditio30(1974)259-83. Newman,William.‘AnOverviewofRogerBacon’sAlchemy.’InHackett,J.,ed.RogerBaconandthe Sciences:CommemorativeEssays.Leiden:Brill,1997,pp.317-36. Pereira,Michela.‘AlchemyandtheUseofVernacularLanguagesintheLateMiddleAges.’Speculum74 (1999)336-356. Schwartz,Dov,BatyaSteinandDavidLouvish.StudiesonAstralMagicinMedievalJewishThought.Leiden: Brill,2007. Zambelli,Paola.AstrologyandMagicfromtheMedievalIslamicWorldtoRenaissanceEurope.Ashgate, 2012. Week6:BlurredBoundaries:Religionandscience Lindberg,David.‘MedievalScienceandItsReligiousContext.’Osiris10(1995)61-79.*** Condemnationsof1277.Onlineresource.*** Perho,I.TheProphet’sMedicine:ACreationoftheMuslimTraditionalistScholars.Studiaorientalia74. Helsinki:FinnishOrientalSociety,1995.*** Arbesmann,R.‘TheConceptofChristusmedicusinSt.Augustine.’Traditio10(1954)1-28. Bartlett,Robert.TheNaturalandtheSupernaturalintheMiddleAges.TheWilesLectures.CUP,2008. Ferngren,GaryB.ScienceandReligion:AHistoricalIntroduction.JohnsHopkinsUniversityPress,2002. Grant,Edward.GodandReasonintheMiddleAges.CUP,2001. Lindberg,DavidandRonaldL.Numbers,eds.GodandNature:HistoricalEssaysontheEncounterbetween ChristianityandScience.UniversityofCaliforniaPress,1986. HPSC 2013-14sessionemail Lindberg,David.'ScienceandHandmaiden:RogerBaconandthePatristicTradition.'Isis(1987)518-36. Yoshikawa,NaoeKukita.‘HolyMedicineandDiseasesoftheSoul:HenryofLancasterandLeLivrede SeyntzMedicines.’MedicalHistory53(2009)397-414. Ziegler,Joseph.MedicineandReligionc.1300:TheCaseofArnaudeVilanova.Oxfordrd,ClarendonPress, 1998. Week7:AstronomyandAstrologyinsociety,science,andmedicine Saliba,G.‘TheRoleoftheAstrologerinMedievalIslamicSociety.’Bulletind’étudesorientales44(1992) 45-67.*** Maimonides.LetteronAstrology.InAMaimonidesReader,IsadoreTwersky,ed. French,Roger.‘AstrologyinMedicalPractice.’InGarcía-Ballester,Luis,RogerFrench,JonArrizabalagaand AndrewCunningham,eds.PracticalMedicinefromSalernototheBlackDeath.Cambridge:CUP, 1994,pp.30-59.*** Tester,Jim.AHistoryofWesternAstrology.Woodbridge,Suffolk:BoydellPress,1987.*** Dallal,A.AnIslamicResponsetoGreekAstronomy.Leiden:E.J.Brill,1995. Duhem,Pierre.MedievalCosmology:TheoriesofInfinity,Place,Time,VoidandthePluralityofWorlds. Ariew,Roger,trans.Chicago:UChicagoPress,1985. Goldstein,Bernard.'TheoryandObservationinMedievalAstronomy.'Isis(1972)39-47. King,David.A.AstronomyintheServiceofIslam.Aldershot:Variorum,1993. Saliba,George.AHistoryofArabicAstronomy:PlanetaryTheoriesduringtheGoldenAgeofIslam.New York:NYUPress,1994. Saliba,George.'GreekAstronomyandtheMedievalArabicTradition.'AmericanScientist90(2002)360-67 Shatzmiller,Joseph.‘InSearchofthe“BookofFigures”:MedicineandAstrologyinMontpellierattheTurn oftheFourteenthCentury.’AJSReview7(1982)383-407. Smoller,LauraAckerman.History,ProphecyandtheStars:TheChristianAstrologyofPierred’Ailly,13501420.PrincetonUP,1994. Zambelli,Paola.TheSpeculumAstronomiaeandItsEnigmas:Astrology,Theology,andScienceinAlbertus MagnusandHisContemporaries.KluwerAcademic,1992. Week8:Geographyandtravelaccounts Woodward,David.‘Reality,Symbolism,TimeandSpaceinMedievalWorldMaps.’Annalsofthe AssociationofAmericanGeographers75(1985)510-21. Gaudio,Michael.‘MatthewParisandtheCartographyoftheMargins.’Gesta39(2000)50-57. Beeston,A.F.L.‘Idrisi'sAccountoftheBritishIsles.’BulletinoftheSchoolofOrientalandAfricanStudies13 (1950)265-280. Al-Idrisi’smapoftheworld:http://memory.loc.gov/cgibin/query/h?ammem/gmd:@field(NUMBER+@band(g3200+ct001903)) Edson,Evelyn.‘WorldMapsandEasterTables:MedievalMapsinContext.’ImagoMundi48(1996)25-42. TheTravelsofIbnBattutah.TimMacIntosh-Smith,trans.Picador,2003.*** MarcoPolo.TheTravels,RonaldLatham,trans.Penguin,2004.*** Russell,JeffreyBurton.InventingtheFlatEarth:ColumbusandModernHistorians.PraegerPaperback, 1997.*** TheTravelsofSirJohnMandeville.C.Moseley,trans.Penguin,2005. UsamahibnMunqidh.TheBookofContemplation:IslamandtheCrusades,PaulCobb,trans.Penguin, 2008 Eagleton,Catherine.Monks,ManuscriptsandSundials:TheNaviculainMedievalEngland.Brill,2010 Harvey,PDA.TheHerefordWorldMap:MedievalWorldMapsandtheirContexts.BritishLibrary,2006. HPSC 2013-14sessionemail Al-Idrisi.Lapremièregéographiedel’occident.Flammarion,1999. Kline,NaomiReed.MapsofMedievalThought:TheHerefordParadigm.BoydellPress,2005. Mittman,Asa.MapsandMonstersinMedievalEngland.Routledge,2006. Wright,JK.TheGeographicalLoreoftheTimeoftheCrusades:AStudyintheHistoryofMedievalScience andTraditioninWesternEurope.Dover,1965. Zadeh,Travis.MappingFrontiersacrossMedievalIslam:Geography,Translationandthe‘AbbasidEmpire. Tauris,2010. Week9:Artisans,ArchitectureandArtillery:MedievalTechnologies Gimpel,Jean.TheMedievalMachine:TheIndustrialRevolutionoftheMiddleAges.PimlicoPress,1992. *** VillarddeHonnecourt.Sketchbooks.***http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Villard_de_Honnecourt TheBookofKnowledgeofIngeniousMechanicalDevicesbyIbnal-Razzazal-Jazari.DonaldHill,trans. Dordrecht:D.Reidel,1974. North,John.God’sClockmaker:RichardofWallingfordandtheInventionofTime.HambledonandLondon, 2007. Bork,Robert,WilliamW.ClarkandAbbyMcGehee.NewApproachestoMedievalArchitecture.Ashgate 2010. Grant,EdwardandJohnMurdoch.MathematicsanditsApplicationtoScienceandNaturalPhilosophyin theMiddleAges.2010 King,DavidA.InSynchronywiththeHeavens:StudiesinAstronomicalTimekeepingandInstrumentationin MedievalIslamicCivilization.Vol1:TheCalloftheMuezzin.Brill,2003 Partington,JamesRiddick.AHistoryofGreekFireandGunpowder.Heffer,1960. Varisco,DanielMartin.MedievalAgricultureandIslamicScience:TheAlmanacofaYemeniSultan.1994. White,Lynn,Jr.MedievalTechnologyandSocialChange.London:OUP,1962. Wu,NancyandWilliamW.Clark.AdQuadratum:ThePracticalApplicationofGeometryinMedieval Architecture.2002 Week10:Epidemicsandinfectiousdiseases:medievalresponses Horrox,Rosemary,trans.TheBlackDeath.Manchester,UofManchesterPress,1994.(selections) Touati,François-Olivier.‘ContagionandLeprosy:Myths,IdeasandEvolutionsinMedievalMindsand Societies.’InLawrenceConradandDominikWujastyk,eds,Contagion:PerspectivesfromPreModernSocieties.Aldershot:Ashgate,2000.*** Dols,Michael.‘TheComparativeCommunalResponsestotheBlackDeathinMuslimandChristian Societies.’Viator5(1974)269-87.*** Arrizabalaga,Jon.‘FacingtheBlackDeath:PerceptionsandReactionsofUniversityMedicalPractitioners.’ InPracticalMedicinefromSalernototheBlackDeath,pp.237-88.*** Carmichael,Ann.‘UniversalandParticular:TheLanguageofPlague,1348-1500.’InPestilential Complexities:UnderstandingMedievalPlague,VivianNutton,ed.MedicalHistorySupplement27. London:WellcomeTrustCentrefortheHistoryofMedicine,2008. Cohn,SamuelK.TheBlackDeathTransformed:DiseaseandCultureinEarlyRenaissanceEurope.London: Arnold,2001. Demaitre,Luke.LeprosyinPremodernMedicine:AMaladyoftheWholeBody.Baltimore,JHUP,2007. McCormick,Michael.‘Rats,Communications,andPlague:TowardanAncientandMedievalEcological History.’JournalofInterdisciplinaryHistory34.1(Summer2003)1-25. Rawcliffe,Carole.LeprosyinMedievalEngland.Woodbridge:BoydellPress,2006. Stearns,Justin.InfectiousIdeas:ContagioninPremodernIslamicandChristianThoughtintheWestern HPSC 2013-14sessionemail Mediterranean.Baltimore,MD:JohnsHopkinsUP,2011. ReferenceliteratureonmedievalscienceintheIslamicandChristianworlds: Thefollowingisabrieflistofintroductoryandreferencematerialsthatmaybehelpfulinpreparingforthe essays: Lindberg,DavidandMichaelShank.TheCambridgeHistoryofScience,vol.2:MedievalScience.Cambridge UniversityPress,2013. Grant,Edward.ASourceBookofMedievalScience.Cambridge,MA,HarvardUP,1974. Freely,John.LightfromtheEast:HowtheScienceofMedievalIslamhelpedtoshapetheWesternWorld. 2010 Goitein,S.D.‘BetweenHellenismandRenaissance–Islam,theintermediateCivilization.’IslamicStudies2 (1963)217-33. Lindberg,DavidC.TheBeginningofWesternScience:TheEuropeanScientificTraditioninPhilosophical, ReligiousandInstitutionalContext,600BCtoAD1450.Chicago,UCP,1992. Kren,Claudia.MedievalScienceandTechnology:ASelected,AnnotatedBibliography.Garland,1985. Long,Pamela.ScienceandTechnologyinMedievalSociety.NewYorkAcademyofSciences,1993. Pines,S.‘WhatwasoriginalinArabicscience?’InScientificChange,ed.A.C.Crombie,pp.181-205.New York:BasicBooks,1963. Saliba,George.IslamicScienceandtheMakingoftheEuropeanRenaissance. Turner,HowardR.ScienceinMedievalIslam.Austin:UniversityofAustinPress,1995. Wallis,Faith.MedievalMedicine:AReader.UniversityofTorontoPress,2010 Whitney,Elspeth.MedievalScienceandTechnology.Greenwood,2004. Courseexpectations Studentsareexpectedtoattendandparticipateintheclassmeetings,aswellattemptthe essayassignment.Seethestudenthandbookformoreinformation. Importantpolicyinformation Detailsofcollegeanddepartmentalpoliciesrelatingtomodulesandassessmentscanbefound intheSTSStudentHandbookwww.ucl.ac.uk/sts/handbook AllstudentstakingmodulesintheSTSdepartmentareexpectedtoreadthesepolicies.