fll?ST AfPEJ/L.
/9Tf-lrJI
!J.NJ)II7£D
ANI>
(9J Lt:I/VI£~
COR.f?.Ii~PONDf£NCE
1f(71- Itt! IIINP UNIJIf"[EJ)
(42 ilillv,")
J 1-l"~:-- ~olrid ~rt
.K.'U:'" '-.trid ., e......
c:.utIp...,
tt
11.iJ,. _1.11",
illS
~
.
.
~.L.... 1"Ol
A.rU 29, 1981
WUli. 1.. C"nett
Attorney at Law
... ttl".
~
8.300 Dou,lA', Suite 800
DaUall, Teus 1522S
Mr. Steve Kc.lathe
...· c.t Tu•• LegAl Servic.s. Inc.
1220 IroadwAy, Suite 1601
Lubbock. Tex., 79401
KIrk C. H.U
O·Sh.u , A.llociolt4l'
Kt.
Attorney. at La"
1402 Te.ua AVCln"e
Lubbock, Tex.. 79401
CORR[SP<r.;O£,XCt
KT. Albe:rt Perez
AttOrney at Law
1112 Texa. AveDue
Lubbock. Tex.s 79401
7
Hr. Dantel H. Be.naon
School of Lav
Te••• Tech Unl-veutty
po.t OHice &0.. 4010
Lubbock,
19409
f....
In 1'.:
Hr. TOIILlII.I Guu
"ttorne)' .c Law
1006 Thirteenth Street
Lubbock, Tua. 79401
Kr. Line Arthur
Art.bur " Arthur
Attoruey• • t Law
MetrO Town. Suite 1506
1220Iro-.dvAy
LubbOt:k. Tex... 79'01
Mr. J .... P. Brewster, Trhl Attorne)'
Hr. Leon kant AccorDey
Hr. Dona14 G. V.nether. AttoC"fley
Off leI! of City AttOrney
Chy of Lub~k. TexAI
POle ott Ue Box 2000
Lubboek.. Tax.. 79'S7
Hr. Tnvla O. Shelton
"r. DermU W. HcGJll
Tuvh O. Shelton" ..... oci.tee
Attorne)'. at Lav
lSO' Thirteenth Street
Lubbock. Te:xa. 1940J
CA-5-76-34. Ray Joan, et d. v. Cit)' or LubbOCk. et al.
(No. 19-2144 (Stb CIT.»
C ntle-en:
In view of the Tee-aU of tM uncl.te 1111 the abov. case. I atI caacdlns our
'Pre-trial cont.Tence "bldt I 'h~ nottflall ,ou to attend on Frida)'. Kay 8.
1981. After. Unal "rtd.te .. Tecdved. p1eue c:ont.ct .e .,.In and we
will acbeetule • cooferenea.
y...... vary truly,
j~
1~~,h
o.
tW.Bt'lT
WOOOW'AJ.D
Chief Ju.dae
Northern DUtrll:t ot Texas
,
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
OFFICE OF THE CLERK
NOfnHC"" Otntt,c;1' M
Joseph :-:cE1roy
I
Jt'.
,......
,
f
~l"iltl .......
lhtilrl~
.stilt,..
Cilbert F. C4nuchea.u
HI' ~ WUlia. 1.. Garrett
Attorne)' ,u Law
:1r. Steva KclnUre
Clerk. U.S. CoUrt of Appoals
Fifth Circuit
600 Carl? Street
};C""· Orl(!'ans. Louisio1ni1 70130
llUt Tun Lead Servfcu. Inc:.
1220 Broadway. Suite 1601
Lubbock, Tex.. 79401
79-2744 - Rev. Roy Jones, et a!' v. The City of
Lubbock, et al·
VSDC No.
t.
:rMO.
Aptil *\981
8]00 Douaha. Suite. 800
DII11... Tex.. 1,)225
Re,
.r
~t
~'.lD
~.riIt11IJ Lu. "'. . . .
~ •.
1205 Texas Avrnue
Ro01ll C-221
Lubbock. Texas 79401
Aprll 29. 1981
lion.
p'oIrid ct-..
1f.rlJJ,,,.
CA-5-76-34
Dear Sit'":
Pursuant to your letter d&t~d A1"ril 27. 1981. I am rer.urninp.
hcrc....· ith the U.S. Court of Appeal's opinion and judR~ent
issued as and for the ""ndate on AprH 16, 1981 in the above
styled and numbered caUse.
Please advise if anyth1n~ further is needed.
Very truly yours.
JOSEPH l'eELROY, JI(.. Clerk
By!~91UtdJvJ
Mr. Hark C. Hall
O·She. , A.. ocjat~a
Attorney. It lAw
1402 Te..... Avenue
Lubbock, Tex..... 79'01
Kr, Albert Peru
AttornlllY at La"
1112 Tun Avenue
lA"bbOCk. Teu.
Hr. Lane "rthu"
Arth... r .. Arthur
.,\ttorne)'1 at La"
Metro Tower. Suite 1506
1220 Iro&4",ay
Lubbock. teu, 79401
Kr. J . . . . P. Brewater. r,,1.1 Attorney
11r. Leon Bean. AttOrney
Hr. Don.1d C. V.ndlver, Attone)'
orUce of City Attorney
Cit)' of Lubboek, Te.x...
Pon Of(1(;. Box 2000
LubbOck. T.d' 79457
79401
--7 ttI'. nante.! H. I4!:naon
/ Sc:hoo1 of La"
TtIIUI Tech Unlvenity
Poat Offtu lox 4030
Lubbock. Tda. 19409
In re:
Mr. T~, CaTUAttOrney . t Lay
1006 thirteenth Str~et
Lubbock I Texal 79401
11r. Trav1a D. Sh.1ton
Mr. Dennia W. McCll1
l'ravb D. Shelton .. "'-"oetat..
Attorne)'a at l.av
1501 Thirteenth Stt"... t
L...bboc:k. Teua 79'01
Roy Jone.e. at _I. Y. City of" Lubboc.k. et .1.
CA-li-76-34 (Mo. 79-2744 Uth Clt.»
Gltotle-D:
Enclosures
cc:
Attorneys of R(!'cord
Honorable Halbert O. 'Woodward
I bave ttr. Al'tbur'. 1etuI' of AprU 27. 1981 requtetinl _ conference .liDOn ..
the .ttorney.. I ••ree that I " vouJd be eon d<ldr.bb.
Therefor•• I •• Mttln& a conlerue. 1ft thu case for frid.)'. Kay 8. USI. at
1:30 P.K. t ,,111 .Ilr. that tM attorn.,. be present . t t~t cLee or at le.ut
on_ attorntl:y for ty.I" part,. 1tII the caM.
T~~
~~EKTO.
-.:
Chief Judie.
Monbern Dhtrtet of Tex••
A~THUR
... II ... ,n
1I.o'1 ..... 1I1."'
Q.
~1t,U
........,-
.
l.,.A .... r
April 27,1981
u ...
_
...
&
ARTHUR
VH AT LAW
!'t j'il :?1. I::lUl
lTonorahlt· Halh(' ( O. WOndlA':'tI'd
DhUr-l('( ('o~ L
rJi:1tric'l o( TC",,,,al'l:
Fcde,·." BuiJdinl:
lr."~.
Hr. Jose?h McElroYt Clerk
u.s. District Court
u.s. courthouse, Room C-Z21
1205 Texas Ave.
LubbocK, TX
~nt'th("l'n
Lubbol k. T,..... lJil"l
'01
B«';
H(l~V "Ion~_'" ('( al VS.
('lIy or l.uhhOl"k c... t at
Xu.
No. 79-2744 - REV. ROY JONES, ET AL. v. THE CITY OF
LVDBOCK, E'T' AL.
10. C. OOckot No. CA 5-16-j4)
~3r
7~}
79401
j!).~j;
,5ln
k.l
Th(' "uo."Of'.y.s (01' ,ht..· Plni!UiHs 3nll Plninlirr -lnt<."I"".t>tlOI' h{lv@ nolA' had an
opDor'wnil)' to rn~C"l with th.... I.· dh:I1L!o' ;n thp almvC" ,'I·f,'I"Pfl\'NI nl~lIE'I'.
\\"«" rC'[!'1 H i:!IJ 3pprourlntc nl this; time- 10 rnt..'cl with \'ou rlml th(" AlU(lrncy$'
Sir:
This is ~o lIIdvise that the court, on its own motion, has
directed that the mandate in the "bOv. caUBO be recalled.
;'\ccordlngl)". 'Would you please return to this office- the!
court's opinion and judgment issued as and for the tl\8ndate
on April 16. 1981.
rOI" the coil\". Ir \'Oll sa dC_lII I·C'. In c1iiJl'U~iol wh::n t•., l.\oln:c. (n 11(' I,<"qulr('d fOl' ch@addilimm1 hC'3I'ln'!.'" in .hb; 0';1:,;1.'. 3nd .. 11.... ~;jiblC" limt'tnhh: (01' same.
It you dt's; re In m('pl wtth liS in
nOllry mt' ail 1("t the tim..:.
Thft.nkin~
I·CI:.~H"(Ii'
9"
".~ "
Susan V4U9'hn
Caae Mana9C.c
"f~
lily
tl.r. OenniS!l W. ."'cCill
Travia D. Shel ton
ase
I-\Ilcwney fOl' 1'1:'1 intirr ·Int(,f'\·('no~
cc: Mr. ·fravis Shelton k /\:;:.'!u'K·I*It"1l
I"': 1\,11'• . lln1 BI'I'W",tl'l'
~lI"(.'t:t
,\ :-It. C'I(~·Anorl1{··"
t'it ..· nf I.uhb..·. ..k
1'. n. I ~p'li: UI.I'\ :!OOO
I UhItOL'k. TL'",;fl:ol ;'I';Olt
'Ir . ~~~l~~n7' B~~~~~~
Mr. !l:obcrt p. Davidow
rotr. Albcr t Perez
r~
)'c"l<lH·~.
t.\ltlbof'k. -f~:lCj],s 79-101
Mr. Mark C. Hall
Mr. Lane Arthur
Mr. Ja'mcB P. Br@wster
"'·(,'h.ld you
l..one' AI·thuT'
AuoI"o":-y ~t I_::H\'
Bar MOIJG 1,",00
LA/rh
1507 13th
sv/sh
cc: Nr.
mrllt('~I·.
~~
tru.ly your.. ,
GILBERT F. GlINUCHEAU. Clork
By
to this
you In a{f\'anr,' fOI' ,\,our 11l""Onlpt atlt"ntton to Ihl~ malle-I". [ remain
\',-ry.
v~ry
Mr.
i
AltOI"n("~'s ror
n('fCnd3nlR
•'~'" :\11-. :Io1:.r·k 11:1111
0· ....111"...... \,,_'Ih i:th'04
'"I(l::!
r,-X:1~
1.~ll\i ....
'-0":
k.
!\\\'.
r" :t.o: ;'·\01
:\Jr'• .-\ II~•.•, I't'1'1'7
Ill:! T,"x:l_-f '\"'.
I.uhh."\o k. T\'~:'t:"" ':"·101
,',"
:\11'. T,10lftrl
"0"
:\11',
~.'h
1I:1~'
n"n,..nn
'l III 1...' 1'.\'
T,~'o;:l-
1'.", h I nin'I':oeit"
l,u\l1""" k.. r1'X3- j" \O~l
z..
.
WEST TEXAS LEGAL SERVICES
, . lA"ua, ltiu.DN:S
100G 1:llh SIr<t'I't
I_ulllmdt.
1"''1(:101
7fl-lOl
110 N.uN '!i1Rttt
rOllT "'Oml. TEXAS 1.101
lal1l336·_
,-,-: :\h'. ~H"'·.' :Ioklnlif'('
\\,' __ 1 T,''\;:''l", I..'i!:"ll :-'l"rvl('C",c InC".
1:!:!O lh'n3,lwa'\· -1601
I.uhho"k.
I
(~:\ ..
I
",,: :\1,'.
r",wl" ,",'01
lUll (;:Il'r,'t!
,'/0 \\
.,,01
April 22, 1"t
T~-"":l;ol:
'-"·enl
~('r\l'h.'(,501
Tlw I.n\\''\"(·,',l''l Huihlinc
!i)O :'01•• in ,~ll·,·.-t
10'.....-1 \\ ..,.'UI. r,''{l't:t i610:!
Ilrs. MAr th. Johnson
DlIlputy Cart
IJnited Stat. . Dinrict Court
L u _ Division
~ed':"~~2~~i141ng
;:bodt, rex.s
Re.
79401
CA-S-76-34
Rev, Roy Jone., et a1
va.
TIl. CUy of Lubbod<, . t &1
DlIlu lI&'a Johnsc,,,
Etaeloaed pl.... find the origin.l .nd One eopy of U1.
lIoti... of Chanve of _ . s l>f Lead COun. .1 to be fU""
,,1tll tlla oUl.r doc....nta in tlIis ""u... All oth.r parties
on thia data .r. being _U84 • eopy of . _ .
lILG.....
.....
All parUes of racor.ll
v'
~Ina.ll
\hlil'flil
,lit....
wk.
J-
)Ulb,1'I G.l.
CIwf
PiolNl e....
,:...".
'ldrWt
. . t.~
c:
.w
lD',..~.&tl
ARTHUR 8r ARTHUR
UU ~_... ~
ATTonNf;Y6 .-.T L,AW
C'&U mOl
April 11. 1981
J~
L.o\"-II
.... ,t'...
XI'. l.'ne Anhur
Arthur" Arthur
••
~
......
Honorable "alllert O. Wood\\'8rd
At fornC!y• •n
L:rv
~"'lro To~r.
Suite lS06
CO'S. Ohurirt ("ourt
"orlh~rn
1220 Iro3d....."y
Lubbock, hxu
In re:
.RT"UIII
r~
Oi!'l r"lcl
or Te)(,Q,!I\.
F't"deral nulldan.:
LubboC""k. TeoX31'1 7 Q -I01
79401
Rev. Roy
Ro)' Jone•• et .1. v. Cit)' of Lubbock, et .1.
Ko. 79-2144 (rUth Circuit)
.lort~B
or
ct aJ
\"8.
LuhbOt k ~t 31
H Plh ("Il".)
~o •• '"1·2";
J)ear .'ud,l:!"~ WoodwQ I"d:
De;,u XI'. Auhut:
1 have your letter o( April 10. 1981 And 1 have: no objf!<:tlon to
the Il'l....,.·s "III~dia r(>port you de.. tr~ to hll"'~ INIdc onnoundn& the
m...din& of the IM'1lIbcu of the du. in the above c:.u.
/~~
lW.U1T O. \IQODWAJ,D
Chief Jud,_
Northern Dhtrict of Tn.••
Hr. Trav" D. SMlton
Tr:avia D.ShoP.1ton 'Auoelates
U01 Thirteenth Street
t.ubbed•• fe-lUIS 79401
Mr. J . . Irevsler. AlShtant
CHy Attorney
City of Lubboc:.k
Poat Of f iu Iolt 2000
Lubbork. Tn... 19408
Mr. Kark 11.3.11
O'Shu , Assocbtn
1401 Tez:la Avenu.
Lubbock. Tua. 19'01
'7
lit. Dan ka.oo.
School of Llv
tun 'hc:h t1nlveuity
l.u.bboclr.. Tun 79407
Mr. To:... Cat'J:.
1006 Thirteen.th Street
lubbock. Tu.. 7'.01
In llc.ht of thf' t'l:"\"C!'rf'al end remind ()( the ahove r{"E'rt>nc~d C'I'I!H~
by
the
Finn Cirruit. the 3Uornf'v" ro.' the PIB.lntifr1'l nnd thr PIIHntlrr·Tnlervenor
reC!'1 thal it is Impe"3tl\'(' Ihal we Ol('('l with ntu· rt'JIIp(',·ch.-e c1ienrs 013 soon
as possibh.· to lInd:lt~ them on the St31uS (If 1h<.' ('35~ anct l''ClllaiH ..... h~1 Il"s
ahead in the lililta((o:1.
~Incf' yQIJ rul~d Ihr rase Is a daBS &rllon. "'... rflel Ihat \t.~ n~ed 10 meet
with an ·nn.. or the 1"0 ("13s~eJl who dflsirc!l' informtHinn "("lallve 10 the ("a§e
at thili point in Iimr. In ,hal 1'(OI...rani W~ rl1lln 10 a.,;k th(" ni'W8 mpd,Q to report
that an,)" meml)('r of the Iwo dlUtSCS .'ho dc"(f'(l>$ 10 mN"t ....· !th u8 nll1\: do so
b)" comtnl,! to a meclint: of the PI3.intif(s and P13inti((-lnt('n"coor on Th\lrsd:w.
Aoril 23. 11)81. from noon to t I). m., In Hu:' COI1(c"cncc rOOM on the 11th rtflOr
or the Meu'o Tower. Ai4 'e~.tll t'eI1l~5eIH~tln'~ or th(" (WO dIUUU~.II. we (e@l
th'. I. rhe onl)' pos.'.lble "'''',v In 1'(,U"lI~(,1 as m3rW nU:'mJle,~o( the IWO l.'I:l~;;;ei! OS:
po'Htlht.. [f this 3rranf,l:ement doe~ not mC'et I,\'\.th "nur :lppro\'al, 1llrall ~'on­
taC't me all lIoon a.s poulble ill 1h31 t·cC"3rd.
Youn
../'
Hr. Sten Kclnthe
Weet rex.. lAsel 5«1"'1e.e:•• lnr.
1110 aroadvay. Suite 1601
Lubbock. fez.. 79401
c--'
v~r'J
.//'
,ruly.
/
~ft;~·
I.ant' Arthur
Altorncy :l.t Law
n3r' 013& 1500
Altorn('v for J'lalntiff·fntervcnor
LA/rb
Mt' • .\lbcTt Penz
1112 Tltlli.t$ Aw:>nue
Lubboc.k. l'u....
Cll)'
79401
~e:
Mr. Tuvill Shellon ,.,
1507 13th
t.ubbo~k,
A~I5C)("i.lt'!l
1""(':
t~~t
Te"as jq",ol
Anorneys for Ocrendant!i
t'l.1=' •• JiO\ nrt""~It'r'
A .. oli. C'ilv AuC'rn("\
l'h\'
I uhbo.k
1'.0. 1\ \ 2000
Luhh k. Tl'\::li' 7!llOR
"r
WEST TEXAS LEGAL SERVICES
.. ~~ :\fr. \1011"k If:tll
(l'~h(>:l t.
\.;: ..
I 102 r('~;'h'
10uhl '""'0
'\f
lOt':
°l:-ltl
:;
0
r,·,~01
O
""
0
v" :'\11·, Il:'l"
r~,,~.
'00
;''JO''
#lLU.~ ~1'IU;,[J
rORT "'ORTII, TEXAS "'O~
18171331>-3"3
I'll Intir~
\\ 1·,.1 I, ,:\., 1,\Oe:.l Ser\lh't'~ InC",
U~O I~l' .:'It!\I;3\· '1601
\It°.
I
n.,
H(" .....
SI ht'tOl .'t: ':au
T(''(3 .. 1',0' h I nl'..('r~It .."
Lchh"",
1Hl ......""" lM\ 1l.llD4'-G
j"'OI
:'\11 0• \111(',0' P"I"(,l
II!:! Tt
1.UI ,11
r,o,:"..1 j" 101
\.""
\1"0 ·I"nmnfol "rtr,..,
IOHf; .'hh -.:,,0('1>'
1 ullluwk. 1'\'\;00"; 7 1'-101
s,~\"
111·llIll
k.
r(o~nr=
AprU 20. 1981
7'1'01
,.\.ra. Mart.he Johnson, Deputy Clerk
United State. DistrIct Court
Northern Distr1
Lubbock: Di Vi5i
Federal Bui 1d
Lubbock, Te:x
Re:
CA-S
Rev.
.,..
et e1
The Cl ty of LubbOeJ<. et a1
Dee,r Mrs. Johnson:
Encloaed please find the ori9inal \\nd one copy of the
8ill of C<'lIts in the! a.bove-relercne~d cause of action. All
other part.ies to this proeeedlng are being t'Mi led a copy of
same on this date.
thank you ver-y m\lch.
~
_ ~ .--/7-
uJf:!::r:J
AttornoQY for Plaintiffs
WLG,emp
Enclo.ure
ec: To all parties in this proceeding.
,
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE NORTHEP.N DISTRICT OF
TEXAS
LUBBOCK DIVISION
REV. POY JONES, et al.
Statement
Plaintiffs
CII-S-76-34
vs
THE CITY OF LUBBOCX, et al.
'15"11
7- :<
I!OG£Il W, MlllEll
11M. C.2OQ
1205 T£XAS AVE.
LUSSOCK, 1D<AS Z!!4O..r
Mr. William L. Garrett
West Texas LegAl services
406 W. T. WAggoner Bldg.
810 Houston Street
Fort Worth, Texas 76102
Defendants
BILL OF COSTS
1', f,
C·~
•
I
0{
iI
Date Au ust 2
.r
.'
1979
The Clerk is requested to tax the following costs against
De~cndants
The City of Lubbock,
and
~he
Mayor and City Council
thereof, Dirk West, Alan Henry, Carolyn Jordan,
~.
Adderton, and Bill McAlister, all in their official
J. -Budca~aeities
as members of the City Council of Lubbock under Rule 39(e),
FRI\P:
S4,932.00
Detach and retl.m this portion with remittance
CATE
O1AAGEs AND CIOEOOS
CA 5-76 J4, Jones, et al vs.
Lubbock, et al.
Ci~y
of
Reporter's transc~ipt of:
Taxable Costs
Requested
Cost of Reporter's Transcript
$4932.00
Allowed
Trial on the merits
(Statement attached)
(Original and one copy)
(Original filed with clerk of
2,466 pAges at $2.00 per page
crt)
$4,932.00
"'i,E,,,-
Wil ~am L. Garre~
Attorney at Law 07700000
100 Main St.
Ft. Worth, TX 76101
817/ 336-3943
Attorney for Plaintiffs and Intervenor
O>''T~
ROG"1 1"1. r,lllLEIl
11M. C.200
120; ,TX~'~ AVr.
1I lJl!OCX,.T..fXAS 2!'lOl'
STATE OF TEXAS
COUNTY OF rARRAN1
Your check IS your rece.pt
I, William L. r.arrett do hereby swear under penalty of perjury
that tho se~vice~ for which the fees have been charqed were incurred
in this action and that the services for which fees have been charged
were actually and necessarily performed. The Court Reporter's
itemized statement for the actual cost of the transcript is attached.
A copy h~reof was this day mail~d to ooposing counsel, with postAge
fUlly paid thereon. This 20th da of April, 19 ~
/' £- _---t:>
.....c:---r
am
z... ..
L.. Garrett.
l':\ITt:U ST.\Tt:S
conn
Rev. Roy Jones, ct al:
Rose Wilson, et al
(II'
;\I'I":,\I,S FI)" TIU: FIfTII ('J1/lTIT
1111.1. IW l:USTS
{\J't,
j
79-2744
~u.
The City of Lubbock, et al.
De~endant-Ap~llee
The City of
LU,~~()!'.~. -,:~__al.
IU':<ln:STED
so
IJot·k ... fil1l( F"ei: ",*1"1"".'.'''IIIIo,,"!I,_:_"'hl.....e"'Ollitil"I..6"'f"'""h"'i;"ik~a~1.
Cu~t
AL.L.OWED
00
of Pdntlng A:PJ1t:1lL1l.s: or Rl'1.'UI"tI Excerpt..-
129 90
83 SS
Cu....t of Printing Allpclhl.11rfll Ih!:l,ly Brief
263 45
TOTAL
Shlle of Texas
(01l11t)'
I.
of Tarrant
WillL:lm L. Garrett
do hf:rt.!b.\' "'\\"4;.fir under l'eltalt.\" or pe-rjtlrr that the senit'1$
tor whit.'h f,t':' nn\'.... l~'m t.·hlln:cd wel'e im'urrcd in thi... urtilm lmt! th.. t the ~r\';ce:ll for which ree.~
hoa'"", OC"ll1l (..h;H"p"l~1 Weri' ,'/("IUJllly :uuJ J11L'1.·~<lril~· In:'r(ornu:d. 1'1110: PRIST";R'~ JTElllZED STATE·
)If::n SIlO\\'IS,; Tin; ,\"T1'AI. COSTS I't:1< I'A<.;t: t'0I1 TilE AI'rt;SIlIX ASD BRIEFS IS
AIT.\t'HEI', 41r t'lInnn~t"\'i:ll l)ritHer not u~l Jlrt.1l4,rc ;mtl u - 'h- it~ml~'IUi~~
0' ro riu,I: cOllI",)
A 11.'"01)" l1('n:o' W:\.011 thi~ d<ls nl:lll...·(\ to liPlJo~int:' coun:4.:t. w'
IkMt ge fully t.h~reoll. Thif4_
31
_ dol' 01
Mar-:h
A,O, IV
~
/~
'//
Ci'V~c~_.
I!-i....
AUu<lle)' lur
C(i.';U lire hcl't!b)-' luxed in the .o.mounl. uf
of
:s
Roy Jones. et d , Pltfs-Appellants
lhu.
• 198
GII,lIEHT "'. GMWCHEAV
flerk
N'OTE: The lim of COil\.;! I. due for filinw in thi!!; otf'u:,c re..,l/i,1 H "ni/JI from Or(" date of tit,. ..,,;[,!lll.l,
ill l\c",ord:lnt~1b '\\"ilh Rule 39 .·.R.A..P. If a 1J1l1
cu~l~ i~ poi 'imC'l~' lil(!'(l in thi,. ol1iC'l!. l)1'0C'~"",ill~ can
II(l :1C'comllli:otht."(t 01\1)' br thE' tiling or 8 formal mu(iull (or lean! to tile ~mC' out 01 tlnK'.
or
SEE R£\'F:RSE SJDF: t"OR RULES GO\'EKS1SG TAXATIOS OF COSTS,
..
"
...J
'J
PRINTING
PRINTING
..
",
'.1 . •
I.,
Custome"s
Order No
Name
~~/- ~-V
Address
\.:'.J
a
Date
"'l
Z
-..,(.
.".1'111
cV
L
•• t.
I. : ':. ~t"
I
.,
-"1t::)
19...£.Z
4r:1
~/16ili $AOAUb
'0
''LI\:~';>'''-
Name
c';P,.
I
S
.II . , , ,
~
co.O"
c"'· 0"
I". . ~
v
.:1",
.f..
.1" ~
/1
Y{PS
.5:¥S
/:to¢:
•
;
.~n' ~
L
It. 'If I
.(
A
...... I
..
'0
1
C-.G
..
~",,'
(0-.:-
'
C"
I
·
I
I
I
I
'"0l~J< (
,."
·'I/'Il.'
-.-
I';
,n-'_
'11",
' I '("
~.
~
4,' ", ...' t
I
"0'/ ,
/
\.
,
I
"
,,,< 0>"':'"
'.
I
I
""l.".' ..
i'.• \.·t~
-l
("",·";-H.'
.
Iii
/-1, 1111 ....
,I.
-. '",
\
'.
I
I
t ••
,,'. "I I' , I
TAX
:
1/.;1?: 9
...
II t ' - ' .... ,.....
_.......
R.celYed
Q
6?CO 8r
... .,,.... - . ....... .... .....
·
~t
"
f •r'rI.-:r' ( . '11:.' ,,,',
\ "t \.,'
TOTAL
.
¥;x(
I ...
.....
//\
:
I
J-~
{/
~ ,.. " i
"r·r.-.
h
',10'
/
1 ....
, ••
I ..
I C'X I~'ACC-I '1"1"'0.'1
"I -)~
\ ,,,, 11 \
#
-1 •
19....::.L
oS
",
oct
.., .~
,
\
,
....t"
•
'I
Address
""0 IT
r....1.,:.r-
I v·
Date _ - J -_ _
' --lJ
Customer's
Order No
\
I
·
I
I
I
TAX
TOTAL
...-t-"
"
I
I
,-
IHPORTA T NOTICE
Plea ~ note ~
Loc 1 Rule 16.3 provide that ny ug estlon
Cor reh ~rln
n bane u t b
par t
docum n and Is no
to b incorpor3L d in a p titlon for pan 1 reh
ring.
not
Al
f
r
tha
und r FR,' 35(c) th
h • ring en bane do
jud~ en
( t h s C un or
T
pend ncy of
usn tion
th finality of th
and:lt.
nOt afC ct
""t
•
th
PI"H CIRCUIT
Gilbert f. Ganucheau
Clerk
~el
504/589.2510
.00
OP,.'CK 01' THC C""CItK
NI'W 0
March 25. 1981
CA"~
.TIt.CT
loA. 70110
~••
MEMORANDUM TO COUNSEL OR PARTIES LX 1'10 ULe»':
o. 79·2744 -
REV. ROY JONES. ET AL.: ROSE WILSON. ETC.
va. THE CITY OF LUBBOCK, ET AL.
Dear (o\ln.els
Bnclo••d i. a copy of the Court'. opinion this 4ay rendered in the
above ca.e. A j " nt h•• this chy been ntered in ccordaAce therewith
pur.uant to Rule 36 of the rederal Rule. of Appellate Procedure.
for rehearing and
prov1cte. that -A _tion for a etay of the i.euanee of a
a cUreet eriJIin 1 ppe.l fil
under r.R.A.p. Rule 41 .al1
not be granted eiJltply upon reque.t. Un1e.. the petition e.t. fortb 900d
cau.e for .tay or clearly d
.trat•• that a -ab.tantial que.tion i. to
be pre.ented to the upr
coun, til IIOtion
all be d ied ft4 the
..n4ate thereafter i ••ued for~itb.·
.-:II~:-=~_1_7
court- ppointed coun.eA, your ttefttion 1. called to Local
aul.' 1eh provide.: -Appointe" c:ou.n.el 1Ib.11, 1ft
ev t of
ffira-nee or other deci.ion dv r.e to the party repre
tea, pr~tly
ad"i.e bta in wrltin9 of Ili. riCJbt to .eek further review by tile fUiDCJ
of a petition for writ of certiorari with the lupr... Court,
aball
file .ueh petition. if requ .teet by auch party 1D wrltlDg to do 80.-
GILl
ay
enc.
cc: Mr. illiam L. GarrettJ
Mr. Oani 1 H. 8 n.on ~
Mr. Robert P. Davidow
Mr. Albert Pere2
Mr. Marle C. Hall
Mr. Lan Arthur
r.
GAllUCllUV,
Clerk
&aU lJad4/
Deputy Clerk
Mr. J
• P. Brew.ter
Me•• r •• Denni. • MeGill
Travis D. Sh Iton
u. 'f.
fa
' ",
nt'
;;1 I
,;
,
.t.
ri
.I
I
,
,''',
.
II
•••
t .1..
I .r
,\l'lll: "
I"
.Ia ·tt
1
•
".
I
'l" J. .1.
ra
I
';a.
I,
•
2.
t'
•
•
•
•
•
::.Irk...· th. :0."1"'>"\4' ••..url ~ ... (".. ml,l, tl •
h I h:Ina.:.,,1 th..· mo.l. Itr ~""""'''In): th.
':·....-='111" •• r 1'1t"\f.ral ....·t"'I1',,·~ .111'"1:",.. 1 t ..
.h~·n~in.ilh· :,~~in,.t :.
"-, mu ... t I'\'m:'n<ll ,hl"
t
.·l;L.....~
Itr
n1IlA'n ...
1.. th., .11,.1,,,,..,
''';L.... •
th.· .>\hl.·"",." :d\ll II ..
"h.:l1..'\,·, ht:hl I" ,,:.. II:.h.. 1 I"
ourl hi " .... "(ulnln.·
rtl',.'in..~. In
11.,M"'I. In :'llflila.Jn.• IUt, 1""" .. Itn.1
Iln"..... I,·nt In.. ",I.. lI' Ih:.l ",tH'n t~, I"ult'..
ur ,hot· J'O.,m,· an.' ,,·han.oW'" ,tw I·I"'~I""
nlll'll1 ,_- ~Irrurl~..a ..
full ;Hillt (iur 1I111-,rlu·
nil~
h. 1,la," 'l~' ,hi' th," "-,:Ulb.li"n::.,
ttl,· h".:--.. nb In .hi.. :W'llUfl
mu... t t...• ~.I1H"'l .... If tht.·~ ,.., .1'-10', In
Iln":M'nl futtI'M'r 1'\ Ill,·n,,· un ... ·m.I"" Ito
Ttk·,...cllr\",
,":-u.ItJI".h 1h.'11"
,-I aim!' u."I."
tti,· I:,~
an·
n",urk,.. 1 in II..M,·n
..I
Jtlf'"....... /ft.
:'.•• ft'ri......I·1 ~ f"rn
t~~1 f·:;!.t :!1 4;,th t:lr l~N".
H..__...~ni,in~ th.· Irk'\ Ilah.hh "t =to "I'·
mm... 1. t."lh .'.....'1"'· . . ""'ut~\,;1 ~.1 ••ral z.,.
""'IrTII-"l tholl ,hi'" I';'"..) ..."., ...... I:ulth,rlt'l
.... I.. Ilk· nll..·.."nln~ .,f 1J.,J.I..·n In unk·, t ..
...:0... . 1<1"1 Ih,· 111~1n<'1 ntU''-'' an dll.. un.' ~U1I1'
Ia" (ulun..·
""6.·"..
Th..· "'·:o.I•• n.!'ll- to. dll"
4.......
n .... lk t t1Iu"t. uf Ik .... ~,il).
"'bltll~
1n4t.lt'"'IU:Wh.·.
1""
4'u,.,..,r~
A1" In,,IL''
an.1
WIIlII
:"urmii"ll I In hL" 1'IInt'urrln}.!: ItlllnllO" I III
1l4,J,I.·n. lh",' :ultf\.·nM: ('''un·.... ll't'"ljooIHIl
.. t..~\"'" lh.· ,".u,lJi.
1",,101'" Oio.lrill I1n un.
..h:II"l,,,1 ...·:L...... Ittl r'~I'" t I .. h.. ~ .. I"....·
.......1 lin ",manti" ·fh.· :O;ulon''''~ ,'''uri I ..
nut .. Unltl"'.' I.. t.\. It I,. ,. t.·O\·h ...h"rl1l
I.~ rmk' Irtllh ..lu.. t...
TlIt· ", ..,...1.. lOr mm.. r·
It~ 1:1""'1'1" uf ju,.t..., .... lin: th.· ".""IJ,
mt.='n.
In..· .. h.:"n... t '·\Iif','~.. i.," uf ••
t1r
ht,'tA.,·,,·,.
) ...... ~ I .....I 101 I
J ~"Ifk IJrrUl,ltJ
j'" C
f I·tl~ "1"\M1..
t. l·tt.o vlur.. l.lh "1'1J11iJ4'1 .,. JlI ..ll
,. ..n--'d
M I~ ( ht'" J"..
Jlnd J" ,
..II ,,'K! Jl:rl'~w .......1d trWI "' nnu"olC
t..-.
1..1'11 m""'1
'l'
",ISi';;1
"......~ 1
I ~!~ ..
u.
P.1\l
U\
11IlJ
1h.. dl\Y'"ll.la: 'ifIUUOR" u, J~,
lilt.,... \1",..hlllll .. lkl
It,...",.,."
"I~lrd 1~1
III dl\ol tlnurwtul'\ Imp.,M"1 1'\ ,,"1111
IIr"l'It
PI"'"
lu .. ,t.. I,
•
SI!!:I
mapl"') !If J 1'1 n ...·.. n·1.1.'11..... 1 . hll:h·
... 1.1\\
·.r '''l.n'') Th. ,...(.", •.• 1·
1 .u~h rn';,-t'l ~.l' \\'1 ,'u i.) II", .H.I~I .......
In fl..I,/,·r.. hi
...... (..r th.· ro.I.,II..n ..!
\h4. Y.JI"m~"r 10 ..... 1 \\;a, ;"'lu:atl~ ,tl·..... l... t
th,'t't In Tho. '" \\:1'" n.· m.IJ''''u" '.I'lnl"n
..n tb" ."lrl""
t.·.. l t,. I. 'f11I'!u.,.,l In
·.r ..
Ih.
........ ulftl:
h't11
"U"I:""
l~ I:~lhl~ H!
.In ,1t."\tlr.11 ...., ....
I ...h .., rlll'll,.•• II· h~;I.n.. t .m·
",. h "jlll.1 II' I \1..,..,... ,.1'. I lilfl 1'..1 .. u(·
(IFI"~'h ,·Ialr\ .. 'hnt til .Ibl','rn lh, .'..111·
1.1,,1. I;.. I~ •• f ~l~ "hldl '" .111" .. h ,. (""111
(u'ur.. 1rull.. :In.1 .ll',,,·;,l~ t .. rlu .~ ~ul.1
I.·(t It.\ tt... :'11,,"111••• ·II''\,r''... "lmult"n,"lu ..
n'JI,""1l'lI'n •• f 7.rmtfh
an,t It .. f:.t1I.1ro '"
''''''''lru,'l =1 ..,........... 'r \\'. tll,·r. (••, •. n
h. I.n ... "t (.1'\'"
..... '1
"'hH, ,
~{;r-!.
:t';'
U'·I:'·~h'r.
I. t:;..t
~II
41:.: I':'
:'11 II!.;:U.
ttJl't'l'(.. r•• Ih,''''' \\ .1'" n.. "I"l" hulollDlJ ,,"
ttl,· 1'1I.. ·.1 I I I""\" ,h"",·rlll1llmli".' ult"n' .,)
..r.t-·r ., I ~1:tt.ll",h:, \,1•• h",•• 11 •• th,· .·ufl·
r
:O:ln'l1I:I,I~. th" ...·
"'Itut"tn'
1fll!:I'
"
....
·"tI..
n......1...•
h.·th.·r l.l.Iq •••• I'll .11",·"""n;,·
It.. n ';In til· In( n 1 (rllm th~' ~Ilf: ...ht~ .. f
1"'· '·In·llm..\;I"''''
(r..m lhl' fill'" th;,t
an "·1,,,'11"';.1 I'''''''''
h,,-+' "1.. -r.1"1I1 Itl ..
Inh
.n'I~\o'''''141 \ .....1"l1I'lln ...... ,,,'" ..........
.... t
1 .. 1'0''''' t ... Ir.!"
liMft
'"to! .'V,nll"''' .,1 ......I"
"'oCnoon.. t1Lt>o-kmlin nd
did r¥+'I ..ddr
tho- q-t1Utl .h.'l"Chn
.rnw.•
""M.·
d1"'nnu......h .. \ Ihl..". ttl.u"t I.. '\hlllAn.n 4 III ..
rl"'q\ll~11 I., luwlln~ 4 "+«I~ll!IU1II.. n~ \101Lrh...
....... 1 ...... ""1 ".9 901
,Ito ...
t.... ~IlL... '
..,101"
1",.mm,,'nh.,llIn th.·
t'.lurt Ih;11 "WI' :11\' nlll r,nl,l
..... '
.I'"
mf"lhM",.
"I'
an·
In(...III'
Irl
,I...'.... "n
~iKt
~UI.rt·Ult·
J;"-J".... tl
(,...rn , .... 1''''''1."·',,, ,.:....... lII..,.\in~ ~ lh,·
"':I","~ 1111""'&:-4'. fu, \um"","t\4'" Hllimlln_
T.lIl .... th.' la .. it. r~lI-1" un thl· :1"lliI,)I"'h" OIntl
"Htl ,'''llrt tu ...."'1InL,IOIII.\ 1M14''1If'''1
1
ill'l.I.\ I hi· nHm".I1\I,-, ,.1 I...· ~u5.,.. m..•
I ........
In .In • ((.. t.. 1"'''\1.1.
~ul.t ..nn· I" Ih, t 'hurt I.. I..". ""\'I
h"HI.t
I.· t;, ,·n;..,. .. " h;ll ,,;, .. ,,"r ........ 1 1 t"
Ilk :-' ,.n m. C·••urt In ll.. foIl/l Th•• •••U,1
....·"··na~ u.. t.. ;"". n'I'Ulh:lh .. t It ... ·:1,1... ,1'
";,',,",.
.1":0111'1'
\'-f',
tho.
tI..""
1.·.""I,,·
, ••,n' (In.,I'': t·lt-nrh thl/'
n (,'r,·n... t .. Ilk, ;o:.uJ.",·m.· C,,"rt ~ "(In.,I" ",I~ l1I,a.l. (rUin il ",,·r.~ nl,m," I-'r"1",,'1".· Th.· Am..,,",·...n tk'C'L....lln.. 1 Ilnll(-~
....... I'annul I.., unah'hI •••1 :.... a (jnih'
..tr:Ul:ht II",·. \lllh "' tn:ll ........ innintt. :In
hl"lliI·IIMI' tn..... I1I· :,nal :, ~ul'''''fnl'' ,'nIl
ItMhI.,.. tt..· IIt.)!".. t ... n..1 1... r.."lil:n1 i~ l·in-u·
I•• r. \\llh th.· :-:'ul'",·tnI· {"uu,t'l" (an;,1 "', ....1"
lu,·t.,nth 1.,.t\I II 1.. Ih•• 11 .. ln.- .... I": t ..
1 ml,:.,,, .••1\ tho t.,~ .. ( J"'" I.ltn).: .. h;ll_ I..
th. ;.m", I,.. hoi .tln~"" ..( /l•• /./t n I.~ a'.I'.,'·
Ifl&!
.tl .,.I"II'&;II.on. 'n~nno.·r. ":L" umlntalnt,,1
1"'· I+ll~ :," r',,;,:.....'...JI...' ,.f It> Ih.'Oo("..imln:tl....
r) ,·ff....·....
...:.". X"lt'rr I .":IIJt~. :171 ... ~I
~~I.::U 1;llh t'lr l~i~1 '\\' IHm. J l'ln·
I·umn.:.· It b ' I,·:" that ~ht · tIU""'alln:,,11\1111,1 th.' :-'l,,""·m,· CIIU" Iln.. lut·in..: lho·
1f..
"lolm.tO :,",1 :.mnrJ"h..u ... h"Mint:'
In ILuM,"n.
II I'" ''''lu.. l1~ .....;., th .., ,h"lr
,..~...,Iut... n "-III h.. ~,· III Ill' thl' !'n.IUd uf:1
IHlll: ,..,t."iMIn~ I""""' ,..
10l"~
I ;II 15(1:. 1511
t.j, 11iI,I·all....
('"tlt'l
..
t="1J,,11lI""" frum :.t.'\'l·.
\\'l1h'lUl
th..·
1''U1.1TI.. C"1I'Yui,
l'Utt'ina::
I""..
",~r(t"lfp
,,,i..
,tk·
•• ~, !'.!'.,
,1~"".1.
1..1...... 1f'd
",,,, d1JMo AOI
iii", I..... Sup-rmr C. ourt
m ,Ultrd In d...1 "lIIb
at
1
dlv;nfnln_lIOn 1ft
t""
.,Otl \llll n1l1'h
,,"hrn
11. .. Ihllln'" '\'f'd In f .... 1
I'
"lrtU.U\ no, bI
tltl'ollt"\;". Itln. 1o)14..m
l""'lf'..
nll) Iftllhlull'd 11'1
J....:.l.td ... i
1""lI·~ihfb.,
"" . . 1....1. .... Ifl."l,&h·nt
...htuhun
~I"'"
"IIII,,~·i(i.. ttu.. l.. n,,· It)
1'".•·,.. "-nlU11'·\:1 n...~iun".. \llluM h.. ,,,,·I.',·n
mu,!.t \IIl·I,'lIm.., Hut th.· ,Hfti,·uh".,.. th,·
jU:'li''''1I (:"".. 1 in ..tll'ml'linlit
n-:wh ~
t",m.k'n~u'!l ." tI11,""IL'nt in thl'ir lCi~ $t,·I1.;I·
'II
1~19 nt.A\ b.- I~rd In 19loo1 dlW , .... It.,. toile'(
tl\ .."'· ...... ndl'"l1rtj:' I~ \\J4 ..:ool ml"""'lt\. 'to"l
Onnl .. WI"'" I'IcM ",,""'.tut.. "hoIlU' ,.,·I\I\-tl\'·
I...' .....nl ul I utlbo.l\'" .. S..-,puLaIIUft :'Wt 1,,1d un
Ilk.. Ilk- J't'l"..onnorl In' 41 li0301W In U'"_''''III-:'''''''
II I,LII,... ... Ih~ 1"Un1nJ: pI.n \ tl.. Ia'rrlae",1 Ill, r
hn,..,.~ "''1.:h, .. >1ft """"Yl4J ..,. ..Irom ma\ tu\.·
bl-.-n IlbC'hll1"'d ..r r'!"dt'~~ m... n~ , ..~r .. "J:"
""",rlon-. .-c." II I~
.nd '."IICU
Ii."'''...'...."
hOl'loe 41.':9\,,"" plan --.
.~ I.. Ie.. n\.tlll"I~
' ..Ill
(""'U~
',I"
It .~OUId br 1m
pm\lhlr I"J'I..ond\II,I IhI' J!'l"'Ifn(JOf"fT1
"'\'!I'"
~r
b\.,lll ",;u. In~.utll'd 1ft IlfI09--.iIf .. IImI'
tJ.l,
~I .....;al l"IQC'UN'l'nl't'
luil..rinJ[ I'\.·mt".
\l'i' Hol,lt·n.
..ttk·, l'ununlhr1)! Jtn"·dl·nt,, :lnal th..· ("un.
Iii,.,.. .. m.'f1
",,'("ho~n
Nt 4n 'If .h.. "lIt'~I"f'" "r '-'llUln~
..."'PO" ..... ,". lhto 11\"'ltl,l"'lIn lit It"" plall ttl
n.ttw.. ul n ",,",IOf.tl1 ~ul"" Ih.ouiJ' It.. 11I,1(
IKIfl ... f lhiJ'M' 111 HHltrt"'
lun In tho'
.1!U1 lurm;'''.lII ,--. a atJ\..n
.,'..1 ....twmr
tur ." .. nap'" .... rtrctor.d phJ<~"'" Lubbock.
l$l.
I .... rill' in
u( al"l.....ah I am ~"i:l(..... 1 ,hal Ih.· Irial
110tl inh.·rrm,liah,· ;&1.1,,·lIa"· "'·IUN <... f'1
Itl
W"P'nblhlw"t'\oof.lp'I..lh
h,) ...lptnni!' Ih.. -"vb)'n1I\'1' tnll>ftl" lMo. III Ihl~
RIIl"'"
~lf"'l. ,_ -'\.lIbtf"C1I\" Inl"'"
'\I..an
or
.II'
~.(·t.
Jtl."inll I...· Hr.It/t·n l'~I"'" ~.u"jO. I""-..·t... k·n·
hal .. nll nth,-"", L....·• nil"'" (:aU" untu th,·
I"hnuMI'f")o u( t hi· ,Ii,tri,·t .'"uN anti "uun...
'ft 41 &.If.....
....
.,
If.'
h''''''UJi4' 1 tlu nul 'Iuih' hoi",· m~' ".1·
Il·..a:U1 ..... IIIJI'n ... Ih.. t th,' t.u,.II·n ..( ul).
~' ~ ~ 9';'~(, ~ ~j
, .. ppI"~
"'l"-"'·'OIII,. ,:un·
n'j4Jh tiS ",., (IIrlh Ily Ju,l)!t· (;ultll"'r~ in
hi~ c.... k·urnnt! "l.in .. -n. Jirloil h:a.,..· hi... ,".n·
....·rn :.1....,
llmih.'~l J"",-.·,,,lt>ntittl ,J:uitl·
af'k...• 1'''''lud,,11 h). th.· Sup",·ftk· ('"urt',of;
111""'~lttn 11'1 f·il.'
_'I,..bil."
Uuhlt,'fI" _Uti
mil""'
I td AI 4:'11 419':':
JUtI~.·.
I (,.nlur. ,,-nholUt n..·,..-n.~lffln. In I hI."
n·sult ....-:ld"'.1 ;md th..· k1lill t..
fllf; Ihat
t1.tld
...... "1 ,.._
til .. h.-rm
u( '''tnrU~'Hn.
.\hbu41,::h .. plUfJl.ILI'\. 011. Ihl" l nurt no........ Ih.tol
·..ubl""".
t ....... nmIftAI.. ld.:an•
...... ";''''11I;:1,-''11' H,.\'~
, ~ 2~.
- ' , " t ~>t~l9...... t.lJ~d ~ ...,;, IS
' l·rJ~,...... ,r
",Jf"lt:h'" I ,,",j:"''' I <'lrfflJfI'l:"J'.utl~"'f1,:Ur'
lht-
14O\4t.·'" rillurt~ :1"'.' ~"fllt.·llt...... 1
ell m.o.1 lhor
(If (lr0+1f
IlI'dH
1.
..ubtnh\1l" "'ll"ftt
"I...nd.ud
H","'" ~ A/J,',. 1.4... t ... -IH ., .... l t Ito0; 1.1- I td ,*,iq 1100-.1. IJ... r.. .. 1fl I "d'ioIUI
nnt;:1
J() 'K: \. ('I \"
ralA.'
( lur:-
mi,
10 11, fd 'n
hall" .\\ ... ', al141 I
lim
l(fl(.
r.
C'
Til· Ill" r
h. a" .,r
u~ -We'
ur
U'IUJ(J('~
;1I1t1"
"In"
• It" a
f'uLli ,n
('y
ao.1 ,,, IIh III· h) .•h((. 'ul..·.1 t' l,~ I.
I';C •• 11,
I In}. 'Ulnl p, .. tinn
-
United States Court of Appeals
for the Fifth Circuit
.......
OWCCOI 'ftC Q.PK
AUIU.t 29,
I II \
1M I" .... ,lthl\"
"1\
wonc' TO
\\u.LL.u~
un: COL Il' JL\S In;TtIl.\Ust::u nUT nlE t-ol.l..O\t.'aSG CA ts SlIAI.l. IE OI.A.U.Y Aa..
t.Ol':\SLl. fOil [,\en, Iln" ~lllST ra£S&.''-OaAl.. A.RGU"'£.~T. U'f(U" EXCV £0
.\' TIIf. COl'ltT "0. GOOD
I r. ~1I0"S. nlOSE CASr.nl.,RK£D. IIALL 1£ AltCIl1ID
soT ro l,"(X.~O -:0 \lISlT1:" ,Ek 101., nil: ARC '~~'T n\lE
THOSE CASf.S SOT 50
\1\M.}r;.tU"IU.IU tl"I:D.\·Tltf~tIU: 10ISGJt:DGE\\'mm~n'£lllIlTSOFn'E"IL.
(~n.D,
~
Q ....
.. ,.jp.Nt.r~i..lw"t
fOG "",,_""',"
~
~ I
I
,
'11 ..., \ "
'lOS".,,". OCTOBE.
20."
11)\111 "1'1" \1
t '041 \
.,.. : I:
I"'''.'''',
....
_n.
.It
.tlWI
(ASU LUTtD fiILOW·
"tu
h nov .pp_a'l"l llkd1 th.t. t1:l1. c . . .
b. eell •• ul •• for oral
.r,,,,ant duriDI ttl. "e," of October 20. 1910
00 a
uad.teral ... d
ibu.
1f 101& do OOt nccl'Ye a c.l •••• r vtthtG thll'ty ()O) hy. 01
U••• tant.tlv. eI.te It ••• G. It v • • • ot po ••• bl_ to celaoder etla c •••
thU ,.rtlc'lilll.r v.ak.
•
_1..... f~IMftiMt'(lf _ _
.*chion, 01 thlt COurr. aD4 oth.~ (,O'l'l't •• locl •• iG, the Supr.... Court
UDlt~' St.te., vbtetll tffect the our.co •• at (bt. c •• «.
at tbe
\1
I ~.. '"
~
11__ "" Lor
c.,.llf:.
~
r....-,ifj,-....
k....'.,........ lt"uJ
•
.. IIIC-•• 14 Ak"''''I_
_~
Therefor •• by !..!...u!!. to the Cl~d.• cot.:lll. •• 1 _.y ca •• eDr. \rlefly 00 al:lY
r.Ja •• n&' lnc.Z'", ..
'eeJ.10n. Clbat ha.e 'b••• t,lul.r •• linc.e tb.lr
h i t br:lth war .. filed.
tb. i.ttu· .houLd b. tU •• 1'1:10 rollr typ.wtf.uen
coph •• vlth '.rylc_ OQ OP,OIIDI cOUl1:llel, 'DOt lau.r th.1lII tv.aty (20)
frOG the •• t I of r.hit Gotiea.
,Un.
'.y.
01111". . . . . . _ , , . . , . . _
el1.lt.T P. CA.!CtlCY!:A\:
CltU;
-rlUDA\'.OCT08EA 21 •• 910
It k I ( ,~, \I """ \ I
f
•
:,.~
_.n..
""_~)UI"'''\~'''''''Or
I nil \
\
.... r-...A'''''''.
19-)190.
•. :":)1 ........ 'lon... c..•
"l'~lM .. fA.u.A"""".,
•
:t.':.:.. ~,"''''''''''Ca.'I'', t.IUy~"''''4' 1.4.u.A'''''''''
•
~,.u~: ,
3Uto .. \..no,.
,,~.
•
I~'" .\1. A..,...
:,.,:
1'"_.'.I(,
._W
''''0,.'
I.41.. A,..,..
,
19-2711.
~.ItAL
fell Kif
:,.~::
..
;t.::~:
•
•
:t-tf.::.
I '1 0111 \ \.1
0,,.........
\to-I.ol,. . ..,.., .. , .....n'c....t'IIff. . c
Llf_"'u....... ......
",,",,11 t...."
....inoCa-.-.•••
\_rl[•• , • •It..... t.-.. I._••...- . . . . .".._ _1 ~1 ..... ~.IU.. [IAI.....
'W.0IIIf'1
"L
.:f.-IfiM. . ..IIII"e-,.,
:"'1)
It'" ' \
·.".t'_. . ,.. "" .
""...... it'flft."
t_.
[JAJ.
O'W" • • ,...,,~.~"
........... AWs.c'"".I
11.,~~e-"..\~"-A~. &nr-.,,'lIIOW
'_.. l4,AL
rUt'lIlsu,". OCTOBER :3. 1980
"'\I,."
tOI ~I
•
•
*.. :t."u
• :....a::"6.
•
:,. a ..
\1
lUll \
\1
"~
...._ .... I.v.~
"-1061.
19-1611.
I.'.AlI'lf'lfH.~l..IAI.
If•• , •.....,.•• fl •• t..u."fIolIot"
"-)0" .
19-n9l.
"-ll48.
19-1UO.
19-$021.
""'-2144.
79·2224.
19-27)1.
_.--...r.r,..
" .. "
~J.,..
c.f41,,,_•.
,,
),jo_IA.'~-.'~.n..bu
.....~.fl&ein ... t«.
- Pf"".'I'\1.
:,na J
~ ..............,f'n
a1U6.
"-1099.
"-11'0.
"EIlSE 1l."'.0CT0Ilr.Jt 22.1910
.:W.
h .... Alfr,..,t.~.[tAL
19-1111.
"-2416.
"-2211.
"-)'11.
19-2140.
19-2150.
1..DDOX Itlchutrh •• lac. VI. W1..I.(ConaoUdat.d vlth ~o •
79-1.94 • • Lla VI. LeDnoa lad'.. tri . . . he.).
Mull. ttc . ..,•• 1.U. C.neral Security h.ur.1:IcC'
Co .• Etc.
LU. A. lClh,. ~ •• Opp.llIIbal *'1' .. Co •• lac •• :"1' "'I.
Ent.lUI 0' 1'1\. EQ K:Jux klal:l .cul. of Lo,'J.S.". v ••
Ean •• ton. Iou •• 5c",,001 '.rlah loard.. El .\1.
South"e.t"ft Electric 'ower Co .• tt A1 "'I. aurllnltoD
~orr.h.rn. Ifte .• It AI.
lJl. S. A. VI. lUck D. L. Torre.
IaJdvlll ='tU.ia Co .• tne. va. F. I., ~.r&ba1l. he •• tt Al.
HOlher St •• l (a •• !Ie. "". r • • • y ='t'1".h.ll. Etc •• tt AI.
U. 5. A. ",•• Jf.r•• n \'. Kr •• dorn.
lev. loy Jon . . . It A1 ",. Th. Ctty ot Ll,lbbock. 11' A1.
Ki •• r.l In'uatri •• , Helv1 COD'tructl •• Croup. Etc. v
OccupatioD .. l S.fety , .... leb .evhv Co •• it_to•.
A•• rlc.D '~... nltufe Co •• IDC •• Etc. v •• lateraacloa.-.
Aceo ••od.-tlonl Suppl,. Etc •• Et AI.
Hubert Leboeuf va. Ctal r 011 Cot'p •• £t AI.
Dor •• falk.nh.t •• t' ., •• L.,.,a1 Ald $oehty or a.ton lou, ••
Inc.
1. U. Tl:chnolo" Corp • ., ••••••• rc.h-Cor.ltull. Inc •• tt 1.1.
Jl •• le C. Peltier, tt Ai va. Au""ptloD. 'arl'h Pollce JUr)'.
te... 0 rlt te £lIplo, ••• r.deral Cr.,,, c U"JdD v •• 'urroll,',. Corp.
"."'Cll A. PerlUaO., ..... Patrlcla lob., .. H.arrle. [tc.
J ••
E. T"lu. VA. Peter len.1Dler. tiC .• lit AI.
J •• ua TrJatcl.4. Jr •• !t,AI V•• Alfred N. Koebla. tt AI.
~hlr1.y
c.
QUl.aT ,. GA"'VQtlAU
Orft .. "" U_.. IiuH'~.t"'....
'- ...... r... Ch.a
"_~lJ...\..'
L.\
, ..... e-.r. __ "lwc--'IM.~"".-.-
Ge""'.
,_ I'" .,~~ _ .1 IW
I~",".oe.w'''l rr
IM"._... ...-.
I~".""., .,(t).re...t.
C.__I..- ""
"...1",......... 1IIf' If'IPt""II...
..........t e-t •• '
~
,.r I'"
~
''''1.,.... ~"I Offl{.
I_I~I . . . . . .
*"" .......... ~~
. . , . . _ " . . . , . . , . . . ..rtkW_~••
wa,.,.'-.,...... ••
lwCJfft.·.~...)
... _I •• " " M n .
__ .100.101 c..,.:!ltIft"l
1J.11If" Swln c.
"'
0........
l'Il.'.
fOIM
. . ·Wi
71
n 'UM'U
Or"'-.
............... 1...
"".(JrIr'
,I1),.."..,
,..t
lec.u •• 01 cb~ u....o!4.bl • • 11.7 J. c.l •••• r •• ' of c •• e. occ.'loo.d
-'1 the cowrt'a Itxtr ••• ly lara' c ••• load. i t •• bels.ved th.t alDce
tbe fUlna of tb. brl.h be' •• D. there ••, h.ve •••• lDt'l''Y • ."lal
' 'i8'N.
,,_.I..:I~
I_.. P'nit
.... ~I.'P_. "'M"
•
~.I
.dlll
3o... 1,..1..11•• U·..., ....... ~""ur,(..__.. S«_iIIyl
. ' " ;',:0.,. I""
"l&n ..... ~ ... O'~I., .. f.'
~
tv.",
",
"'lM.hJII"'l.-.iwM<r"~
, ... 1
I _ . l t k . , " .... _ ... 'W'~
A
. :')0"
IIlh"'nlf,.tlKt.r..... 1f.fCA ,TllorlkMt-.4 r..
:"'U''tO
.", :":a\.
,.,~.
itl
'Ii
Da. r Couluel:
,0-.
Ilir. .f'd' ...ldwl. . . . . .
COU~StL
1910
•
~
.... - - - &_41<:.le. c ••• I. v"lcb '0'1
')If"
"
,
."It
FORM FOR _AIlANCE OF ~L
•
"'4'
&It "{,It,, (V"", "NJ"
•... 'i~/If"II. ../ir,,, Jf~ -.lmJ"i-w '-'
04U"'H,"') tI.1mJII,'..
UH
11th I;'"
_Ill IIN4 Ii. C' i~ lu,,, thl.'" f.*,1
'1#ltllI)J/nJ Jun'j"
UNl11iD STATES ('OUMT Ol' ArftALS
FOIl THE fiFTH (.1RL'UIT
~:\t1
,....\1 :CjW.. li.
MU~!:.L~~
£rrr M.'.t~~1i't"EE·!!~
..,ho... •
I '
::.~ ~1. ••1 Sl.l~.:. ('.'-:ut ~C Ap:o,·.. h.
, r t'.(> :"lit!. Clf,·ull.
,,~ ;1.:~ ,'f nl~ rlu'k
l,I:,).1 ~'-04) ~~ r.:>d
::.. •. ':- l..l.~". __ 'l.lhUn. 70no
~
'j:.:
I ••1'
1
l
\
:·~~; ...~··;t.,~·~~:JCQ:l't·'\(';'
:-
ell .. ,q l.U!··'!'r'ir • •'t 1.1.. iw. 1~'
Al:r•.• ht f1.j d. lllul, Clrd~l~
v
']t.:. ,-,
tt.(!
j l ~
l.tllIOCl. 'ff..XAS 79409
~
"'·1781
J.\II 2
l'r ttIAS 19409
to!)
'Ill"
Ih~n ~lt: ..1I"m~y ~~n,~ II "'np.· fQ.I)· or G'l'\)UP or (larltn.. OOU~I "blJuki ~icnal~ a
r:u1'..·.llJr 1""1,,)11\1:11 h)
IOllrK~llon i~ h. he' lIto""l. with 1M unck-Dl:mdlf\J n 1 .( othef \·oun~1
,Jloold ~ inform,,'" hi' '" ill I""}'t.,u" '~r iNM"..N Thr peoon h.lll( nolml,~ in lhls l:
~
SOTf; \l'IM:n mOl"
-_
Sam~.1 ),Jk' Uf prinll _-;~:-::;~::~=::::,';:'L;:,;:'CAT~=·:::Ec:.TT:.AdJ.~
1.1
Cll)' & Sa.;"l~
.t- .• r'
~::.
•• ~
: ': •• __ • ' .
.•,
-r.
(;:.rl ",r ~
I ''''
:. '.~~~.'.~t~~l~:~'$
ISo..
i6:ul
NUl
.
...::'OO::::...Ila~I~._=S~'~r."!.~t
F:;.~r....
' .=W:::.r:;':::h,-,_-,TCO'",'.::'
.
l,p_~'~I0::'
_
_
.1:
,III''''
'ljJ
"I
.,,1
'::'
I!"
~ t'
~.I"
!•
.
: .'
,I
~ I'
.'",
' :1_' \.
I"': .11":'
.. I ••
JI
'I. , I ." II' '.1 ,\"" II:, :' I- 1 1I. ,.
:1, :'l"I..il\ • • ':~ •• :' '" :l'.
h .... "I,!'!
1.,. hi...·
.1; 1 ~ " •• I
:'"
.,
--._.
', ..~/.. -
UNIftD aT"... COUIn' fW """AU
I'QII _
. . . . . . CIRCUIT
\.-.
"
';,1 ; ; '
"
,~
,'.
~l
----.....
0PI'ICa OP " . c:a.aM
.... .,.,..,., ......--a 70• •
_~
....., .
-...
'r','
\
-
.. -.-
. " " ; I \:.',t .• l',·: " " , I ,/r"
.~
-f
.: ':- ...
I h
t.. i,ll
r·:.
l.tl'.4.
l.:'
0;'11 I !
, ,-:-1 ".. ,.~, . ,
:
..
I •. •.
,.',
: r ' ' ,", I •
~.e ••~ •• I
•
,
Dantel •• Ben..,n
lIobe~t P. Davidow
8cbool of La"
t'eaU l'ech I1ntY'8rdty
Lubbock, 'l'X 79409
,
J
lIlAVIS D. SHEtTON .. ASSOCIAtES
ATTOaNaS .fLAW'
1~·I'1HS1'UIT
WIIOCJt. 1'1XAS
*"
S\RIAJl.Y OP lUtG\lIlIlllT
Dec_r 4, U79
It 1. the contention of Appell••• herein that. the trial
court did in fac:t consider all nee••eary laattera 1n detenaining
ita deci.ion following trial on the _ritl in thia c ••e, th,es,t.
Cl@rk, United State. Court.
of Appeals
600 c....p Street
New Or leans, Louisiana 10130
Attf!lntion:
the t.r .1.1 court. not only conaider.e4 .11 of the
Harry Ad. . .
factors,
~.
'age nWllber. referred to in tbJ. a .......ry of UgWD.eht are those
No. '79-~74" - Rev. Roy Jon•• , Et. AI,
va. City of LlAbbock, r:t .u
Ita:
!!!S!.£
but it .180 conlJ.d..red: .11 of the enbanci.ng fACtoI'. frc.
paq8 nwaber. in Appell.... bri.f vherein the .tatement. cont&ined
Dear Clerk ot the Court;
in thi• • ~ry are JIOce fully explained and elaborated upon.
I have enclosed with this letter the a~ry of the Ar~nt,
which i . to be Atta,cbf!d to the above-refe.ranee4 brlef. ay
conversation of JiU. Su.... n 'tc. 4ln IIttorney for the City of
Lubboek, with Mr. Harry Maaa, thi. Su-ary va. to be att.ached
to the in.ide fJ:ont. cover of the brief. we certainly appreciate
1&1'98 .yat.em of govern-ent. pr••ent .1n the City of Lubbock, Texaa;
your ••• i.lunca and cooperation in thl. aatter.
You.r.
v~ry
trUly,
TIIAVIS D. SHEL'I'OlI • ,\SSOCIATES
The PialntUfa bring tMir ca•• alleqin9 t.hat the cat...
1_ unconstitutiooal, and bav. t.b. burden of proof t.o ahow that
th. appllcation of thia .yst•• unconstitutionally deprives theAppellanta of their right..
.y_taII ie nat
Til. Appellees aay tllat the at-large
per •• uneon.t.it.ut.ional, and tbAt the at-lar<]e
.yatea •• it. uiets . .y not. be atricken by judicial deci.Lon
BY'
IlW»Vdrl<
£ncloaura
ee,
Albert Paz_,
DennI. V. Will
abaent. a f1ft41n9 tbat all of the tacta taken in the a99regat4!
ahow dUutlon of a1norlty voting right..
1973~.
Zimmer v. HcJCei.then,
'to-.aa G.arza
U5 P.24 1297 (5th Cir.
S"cl\ a fl.n4in9 can only be
LIM Arthllr
Dantel H. Benson
Jtobert P. o.vidow
Mark C. Hall
which are &cce•• t.o the political proces., responeiveneas of
pr:ecSlcat:ed. upOn .. con.lderatlon of the priaary
~
f.ctors,
elected official., wei9ht of aUt.. policy regarding at-larg8
.1ectlcma, and effect. of paat diacrJaioation.
These four
factor. 'taken in COf\junc:tlon with various enha.ncing factors
are t.he crlt.eria to be used for detenalnation of dilution or not.
All of
t~is
must be considered in light of previous
case holdings wherein it hal been Itated that the constitutional touchstone ia whether the syateA ia open to full
Dove v. Moore (Page 61.
the aggregate. and when considered under the applicable
standards .s let forth in the case law, DOre than aupport the
conclusion that the Plaintiffs have failed to eatablish by a
preponderance of the eVidence that the trial court improperly
found that the minorities have accesa to the political
syat~
in LubbOCk. TexaS (Page 5 - 161. and that the City of Lubbock
is responsive to the needa of the minorities (Pages 16 - 31).
mult1·me~r
districts is
not tenuous (Pages 31 • 36). and that the effecta of past discria1nation have been eradicated .nd do not preclude Ace••• of
minorities to the political syst. . (Pagee 36 - 431.
Consideration of all of the evidence brings about the
conclusion that 1s evident that in the aggregate, the eviden.dictates that the at-large system in Lubbock.
~&as,
did not
dilute the voting etrsnghta of the minorities (Page. 44 - 49),
and that anti-aingle-ahot voting reatriction. vere not applicable
in this case.
Indeed, the at-large ayatem permits the perfect
one-peraon# one-vote 9061, and to replace an at-1arge .y8te.
\lith several single-....-ber diatricts invites variance fraoa
that goal, and would forever
reinforcing
~h..
compar~ht.lia8
ever "xereising influence on the
~he
bounds of their sinqle-.ember
David v. Garrison (pag•• 6.7, 16, 36, 45. and 471.
Th. Di.trict Court wile correct in its concluaion .. as
aet forth in its opinion, and thi. Court should affirm that
The evidence in the trial court below. when taken in
that the State policy underlying
fr~
political .y.t.- beyond
districts.
minority participation and not whether proportional representation is achieved.
of a .inority class
th_ electorate,
block voting syndrome, and preventing ..-bars
decision.
.... ucd St:ltC'$ Court of Appeal!
OctOber 14. J979
lllAVIS D. SHE1.TON" ASSOCIAYES
AnOkNEYS ATU:.
.)OJ •
un« snu:r
Ll.I8IIOCJ(..1'EXA5 :..-'
J •• by .. copy or thh letter. advisin, opposina (.ounseJ thn the
I'eqUlln. hu b••n aacs. and anntcd for tb. eXUnsion. Th&n~ you for
your assistante and c.ooperation.
Yours very truly.
Oretober 24. 1979
John C. Ross, Jr.
C1'\1 Attome,
P. O. loA lOOO
Lubbock, Texas
United Su.us Coun of ApPCill,
F f'th Ci TcuJ (
Office of the Clerk.
{)()() ClIIp Street
,'\"w Orle~"s. Louj~j~ 10130
"tunlion;
J..es P. 8re~ter
Civil Trial AttorneY'
City IIaIl
Luhbo<:.1l.. Texas
XS. MeliM Barnes
Re:
Tnvls D.
Dennh W.
TRAVIS D.
1507 Uth
CaUSf!! So. 79-2744
Jones Et AI vs. City of Lubbock Et. Al
Lubbo<:\.
This .letter is be1n. sent to conlha
OUT
telephone conversation of
Oetobcr 24. 1979, cxtend1n& the due date for tbe brief for the
Appellee 1n the a'bove-refrnnced Ciluse. As e,Ublhhed in our tele-
phone convenatlon. the original due dnCl WGS Novellbcr 1. 1979, and.
the extended out!' date is nov Deullber 1, 1979. Appell~ requested
the oneMiDn for the (oUow1fte nasons:
1.
Q\e of the trial and appellate c.ounsel (or the AppeJJee
"8 deteralned to haye aaliJ"o&ftl likin C.ancer requirin, sUZ,l.ul procedure. which caused delay in the p1"eParadon of the "rief.
2. One of the tdal and appellate counsel fof' th. Appellee
was required to hBVC dental suracry re-qulrlng th.o loss of !ocveral
days in the oftice.
3. One of AppeU~ts trial and appelU.tc counsel t\as been in
prepnation and has to-.cnc.ed • t,hre-e to four-wHt l.wsuit which hasc.oaan4e4 his &t.tentlon away froll th_ p"paradon of the AppeU. .' 5
brief.
4. Onc of Appelleels trial llnd "PpeUate counsel has been
continuou.sly occ.upie.d with prcpuation and trtd of other -.atters ,et
prior to the receipt of the brief (or the Appellant, N'd the COftlcqUltt\t
due elate ror tho brief for the Appe llee.
s. the transcript an.d b,.iefs In tJtJs case are cOIIIpUcated IJld
in"ol,,~. and reqUire a sienificant uou.nt of concentr~t1on or tl_ .and
efrort. "Thi.s concentration and applic.ation has been seriously intenvpted
by the iilbo'tle-rc:ferC'l\Ced iteas which r~qulre the Appellee to "quest IlII
ext~n$ton
of
ti~
to Cilo arief for the AppellH.
BY:
6
~oItk
ce:
Nark C. 11&11
Oaftiol H.........
1b_ Cn"
Albert PenJ,
Lane Arthur
·:mn.'L. ~::'~t
• tenified Mail - Return bceipt ReqlH:sted
Shelton
M<Cill
SIlliLTON , ASSOCIATES
S
..
is .-Jkl. ~
'Ut}{-V/
ill
•
WEST TEXAS LEGAL SERVICES
to6 W.' WACGONlM BI..OG_
wi. ,e,- t..
J.", j'!'
~~~llro~.
:.. - :"kICT COURT
:H:' 'LtHK
NC>fIl",,_H DI .. '.tCf or TP".
Jr.
120} Tex ••
"10 HOU~"'O STJ
Av~nu~
RoolD C-221
Lubbock. Tex.. 79401
FORT WORTH. TEXAS 76102
1'17) 336-".."
3, 1979
AUS;U8t
lion. Edward W.
W.d'~OTth
Clerk. l.!.S. Court of AppealfE
fifth CJrcuil
bOO Coop Street
Loutst.n. 70130
Sr~ Orl~nna.
SeDt 24. 1978
Dan Benson
Texas Tech School of Law
Lubbock. Texas
Re:
Re: Jones v City of Lubbock.
Dear Dan:
Enclosed is a ROUGH draft of the brief in the above caae.
Please scan it and call me with any major au@teStion8 that
you may have.
1 plan to put the final copy in the mail Friday evening.
and 1 apolotize in advance for the lack of time in which
you have to review. hut I would apprecaita any comments that
you may have.
T really feel that we can turn this one around.
Yours
ttu;.>'.?
~~
Rev.
Roy Jones.
et .11 .•
Y.
The CSty of Lubbock. rt 01.
~r.
o
4T
Mr~
usnc
So.
U.S.
Court of Appea15
CA-5-76-)4
~o.
79-2744
Wad»woTth:
Enclo~ed herewith ple.,e find the original R~cord on
Appeal conalating of Volu.es I. 11 and ]11. 1ncludin~
Reporter'. Tr.n.eript. of Pl0c.cdfnlS con.t.ttns of
Volu.e~ I throu&h Xl. tOlether with D certified ~opy
of the docket .heet entrie •.
Also enclosed ple •• e find the 11.t of Plaintiff,' 3nd
Defendarts' Exhibits which were ad.ttted.
We
IIIr
en-
clos1ng the folloving Exhibfrs:
Pl.intifrs' Exhibits
2· 4 ... 1' 11' 1)-14- 16-25 and D~fend.nts' [xhlb~ts 2 ... 4;
19-23, '26_2':
38-;9; 41-44.
The Defend.nt.'
~troTney'
are sendln& t~e following Exhibit' under separate covrr
becausc of the special containers used for matlin~:
Defendant. 1 E.xhibit. 5-18: 2' .. 2S: 28-34: J7.
Please acknovledse receipt of the enclo8ed docuaenf.
thi~ letter and return it to
thi. office at your e'rlie.t convent~nc~_ Thr pnc)o~ d
envelope 1. provided for your eonven1ence 1n 1n r turn1n~
the copy of this letter.
on the attached copy of
Very lru1
yours.
Clerk
"
WLG.lk
E:ncl.
Enclosure.
cc:
Attorney. of Record
{,
......
Jo.~ph
UNITED STATE'$ DISTRICT COUR"
Ofrl"Cl 0 ' T.. t cu;...!;
NO'Ifld:__", 01.,• .et or TClL...
M~[I
... O)'.
Jr.
1205 fex ... Avenue
loo. C-2.11
.1u1y 27, 1979
L.ubbDck, Te •• 1i 79401
July 6, 1979
HZHO TO:
All I'lalntlff,' COUD.••1 1ft
PRoth
nan unlOft
:!2!!!.! ea••
Hon. Ed",a"d ... Wodsworth
Clerk. U.S. Court of Appeah
Balf-lfl~ llltb~
Wing tdhoda1a la the A... 1aacbe-.J.........1
-Nev. paper-
Ff{th Cf r~ul c
600 C.... p Sueet
S ..... orlean_, LOufal.na
Ie:
TIl. Idlotie edlwrlal In the A-J'. _r"lat edUloll ~.~r4ay
.nU~led ·Ug Broth.r on the Bayou • • • • roainda4 _
of -Ulia9
I b.d ~ugltof befora 1ft th. c.... aDd tlwl~ I .-14 _UOIl w
10130
a .. v. 10)' Jone •• et .1. 'II. The City of
L\.Ibbod:, _t .. 1 .• USDC No.
CA-S-76-)4
D.ar Mr. Wad.vorth:
all of you, now.
TIl••• ab.ued A-J a4lwrlAb by .lay llarrla and ".JU>&th May Iud
otJ:ler •••ort" "uta t.hey hay. 40wn there) cou~ltut. -..oel1eAt "l~
tha~ va eu OIl. 1" .bowl"9 the ·unda.irabil1~y· f.o~ with Afar4 ~
the a.&1"4 of attorneya f ••• in the
If'hey 4-.ollatzat.e lOCal
bo.~l1l~y ~ tha c. .a .nd woo • • •uorllllY' for tha .la1,,~1tfa, ud
va ClOUl4ft·~ ••k for baUar t1n~-haD4 ...1 d _ . TIl." ...... _ _ U~.. ~
r.irly g _ ovld..,.,a of raci.1 1>o.~11i~y \OWard ...... cUanta &b4 Ula
c.....
two cl.••••• lnftlYM in the .'Olt.
-.r,.
Ordinar11y. I do,,'~ thlnk of Ula A-J . . balDg _rth
.""b,
b.. ~ In Ullo luunca ~b. \'Ilr7 .~upi4i~y of _ . a4Uon la 901Jl9
~ ba of .1Ib.u"U.1 •••lat.aMa ~ ... in aaltl"9 ...... 0 . . . .
lla . . - w oollec~ the•• a41~dal., ud · _ a · .tArla• .-~
th. c•••• frooo tha A-J. IlIl4 k .... thea III the fUa au tlwl~ ... OIl"
u.a th_ a. uhlbit& ""... the U- _ a 1. . ..-1"9 tha~ va w111 will
Ula . _ 1 , aa I Ul1nk va cerulaly ,,1111. I ha... NUlaa4 _ a l
of _
thu. far in tlwl
and will aaJ<a au. _~ 1 do au 1n
Ula futu., bo~ I a"'l't"~ tlwlt .U of u. _itOI' the A-.1 lor _ . .
ooalu1 1~ of ...Ida,..,•• au tha~ ... dOll'~ . . . . afty.
0....
'r1Ia A-J 1. au fall of "1'...l<po~ 14. . . ud a41 tArlala
a r&f\llal'
buia that i t la
~ "a. & partlcular _
rala~ ~
..
I•• In tha ·li9 lrother· a4Uor"l of Y'N~y, r dloutb~. &~ t1n~.
U ... a , ..at. aUndard A-J n"t &9.1ut the federal .....-~. a~.I.
SO va all _
~ _tob Ulla. and oollect the _
putaln1D9 to ......
".1'
E.n~lo.ed
are c:~rt1fh'cl copSes of the Sot lee of Appeal
and doeket sheet In tb. above .tyled .and l"\'uabtored causc.
Attorneys for ,hint1frs
Carrett
Le.4 Counae 1
810 HoulHon Street
Fort \louh, Tex •• 76102
\,lUH •• L.
A.1ben: '.1'4:Z
1001 H.1n St., Suite 634
lubboc=k. Tex.,. 79401
"ttorne". fo" De(eodant.
John 10...
City Utorney
P. O. 80x 2.000
Lubbock, Tex •• 194H
8y:
J •• ca'. Brevate,. Trt.l Any
KcCUl
IS07 13th Strf'iPt
Tf'x.aa: 79'OJ
Ih,ftn1. \:.
Lubboc~.
Hark C. 0 .. 11
P. O. lolt 2HI1
Lubbock. Tex •• 79408
'to•• fJ Carz.
1006 13th Street
t,.ubboc:k, Tex •• "'01
0.1' f II! 1
Icn..,on
P.O. lox 4030
\.ub'olt:k, T.x., 79409
H.
Attorne)', fOT Int,.~
"'S 1) J • ., L. C:arr(ol I
810 HoustOn Slrt!f'l
fot't ""ou". Texas i6101
ltob6! r t 'II. b3.v 1 dow
School 0 ( Law
TC!)t:ll8 'Tt:ch Un1\'lt'ra1lY
Lubboc ..... Te-.:U '1'&09
Lane Arthur
Metro Tover, Suit. ISOII
1220 BrOAdway
tub,oek. Texu. 79401
c••e, or .... reI.tees ea....
very t .. "ly your.".
(1
£1\cloav" ••
(:4:::
,,\ttorneys of leC:01'4
1'10.
r.
·1011\ .1.
..' · 0 .... 1:
"'::1 ''l:'''S .. ~(
~",".OC ...
June 22.
(l·SIIE.\
,
WEST TEXAS LEGAL SERVICES
L .....
I: .. Q
11:' • • ,
.0' , . ,
... W. f. WAGGONO I.WG.
.oe
.10 HOUSl'ON &To)
Fon WORTH. TVIAS 76101
1979
41111 su,.3M3
J _ 19, 1978
:-:r. O.1nie 1 n. Benson
P.O. Box '030
Lubb('lck, Texas
79409
Mr. Albert Perez
llU Texas AIo'I!nUll
W>bod<, Texas 7940 I
:ir. Daniel II. Benson
P. O. Sox 40))
Dear Dan:
PINUJC find neloBod a memorandum for ~qal service,. which
I hurr edly dict:atcd regarding some of my thoughts on Judge
t\"ooCward+s opinion.
Mr. T""", Gana
1006 13th Slnet
W>bod<, Texaa 79401
"lr. Lme Arthur
1220 8<OOd.Jay. Sulte l506
W>bod<. Texas 79401
Mr. M.uI< C. He 11
4102 Texas AYOnUll
LIJ>bod<. Texas 79401
14<. Robert P. DavldoJ
P. O. Sox 40))
YO~r5
truly
• It:.. I
.v.ark C. Hall
~1CIl:
/
/f /..J [
•
//(
[/
RE,
W>bod<, TelOIS 79409
Jones. et al VS.
City of lJilbock. et al
Cause flo. CA5-76-34
pr
Enclosure
W>bod<. T."... 79409
Gentl......:
1'urotwIt to ~ _ t wl th Dan Benson and the rumxl Plalntlffs in
the _
oult. 1 and Weat T"""" Legal Services have ~ to accept
the "'\lor RsponslblUty for the _1 of this .. tter to the Sth
Clrcult.
I wuJ.d "lJPRclate It if each one of you would within the Ill>Xt few
cloys write me a letter detailing .not points of erTOr you 1oIOU1~ like
to lee argued on _a1. I ......Iize that this wlll be """,,",,"t dlfflCl1l.t
at thil tin. _ e of the la:k of a transcript, hooevcr. our eeblred ~ wlll be...rul at thla early st8l\<!.
1 pIal to fi Ie a _on for U!aIIol to Proceed in Fotmil P.~rls in
the _ a l of this ..ttel', and I wuJ.d awrcclate I t If I could hAv<>
"""""ration in ~ affldav1ts me each of the nmed Plalntiffl.
I mderstn that
one of the PlalntlIfs has """"<l to El Paso.
and 1 wuJ.d ~te it if you could furnUh me ..n.th m OOdress atld
..1.epllone l'Ild>er or contact penon Ior thla indlvldual.
your
pam-
Please feel free to call . . ..,llect at ....y time to discuss my ""tter
ClOl1ClOtl\Itc this case.
y~~
lll.om L. Garrett
lLG,lm
/!!!"""'
: s· ",
~.
~.
lex-,s lech Unillt'f~ly
Jun.' Ill. 1,11
\;,1111.,_ ~"1l'"r.·tl
'",X,'t.'I t,·~.:JJ 5.·,,'1':\."'10
'00 W. 1. l;.".l,;g.JlW..r !\lltdlll]:
dID HoUllc. ...n St rHt
rol'l '.\,.-th. T.~.lUI!i lblij.!
V..·tfl
Dli'lH 8111:
Dear
Mr. Hlllor,
'octo
!'ul'eUIIIttoOlrte~~.I_~
"'" SU""""'t of
In tl>e
_ t l a d -.1 _ _ .
P~ be advUed that tl>e d>Uo;at1on of PU1ntUfII .-dIac
_ . T.,. Lopl Sorv1_ "., !"'Y fac d>Ia S..-.. of Facti!
11 ""Joet to PU1nt1ffs' ftllt\; • _
fat: 1AlMI to ~ In
~u"I'Iu...nL l .... ""\,IT i'liU~~'''lt''n 0)( th.· "t.I~" d.,y. I ~b .... ttln(· ( .. rlh ~lo...
t:a.I\:n\
tq;.•• rJ1ni' .Iud,-,' uudwllrd· .... u.·,",~I"n In tth' l",bbu .. ilo L~.dJ"'n·.
I ~1.oI't'.· .. t lho.it il• • 0,)1 l.)" f'OllllllLnlb "'Ill lJ.. .lllll •• r to t"'-';..' ...~ by
01 ~ ..••• lh...I&Ui.·... "lIt I ho••- th.. t y.·w "'111 "lh'IIto·' t,u· dU4tl.t~ti :to 'Will.h
if b<t lL"r th..... val "l.,n. .\".1 pro·ll.inar..... 'Il. f • •11 • ,.)vr5i' • •"111 ••1 th..
ltc·_ to b.' Jhu.'UI>",,·J • .J1lI ;:It h'.II!H It\I Inl~·rr.~ 'n·• .-m • x.uL.la.th.n ul .... r
trl",t brl,,·I. '-'",1 p""'l-lrl.11 brl,· • rlnJ tt,.· "'\lft·,.. .... {"'ion .,f
J"".'.
If,0Q!'
c:....#.
ItO.
FoaaP~••
L.lI,:AI,
Y-.n tNly,
141lUo L. Cent<
It I .. .-1'·.lr 1I1.J1 tit •
IU·t '- {tn.·, PI .• Iln>~. I "',-'" ."f "1I{
fhJ IVlI .,f
th~ ".h' .. 1.···(11. t.· ... ll"dnl·ll't.l'I 0I11rll,.lbJ. t.
'ti,.; ,""'.
III 1',1:1 i.'; - l l ,
b....1aodl'l' I h'U .... r t1ilHltll,J ..·rS1.l\.',u I, ...' loJ. tur h'h I ,',.1 ~.' ........... t, rn~
.. (,.t
pulley UlIJ"rl~I1'I~ IIIl' ttr..·f.'r.·I1.·.· ("r Il'Illtl-.rj1. t' ,'r .II-I.ll''';'''' .I11rH ..... Iln ."'
~ . :.....· Jlh..., !'. ~gj ~'.~d
LJlJS (5111 I ' .
~tl,.
til ..' •• 1<n.''':1 in
Whldl thla, (.h·lur Illo ""l f.lnll inJII';llcll • !t.'.lrl\. HI I~ 1.1.' ,-r~) I. ' ..v.'r. "'"
only tdwo "tlw UlI:'! •• f .. IInlll- ·ab.·r IHI!lIrl,th\.... 11'" I .. hJooJhJ In.
1::",'.
.,dto.·r'.I·•
lilron", Iit:H" pollC)' dl\'uri'.·.1 frva 1I
,In,.'uoJlI,.- ." f".h:i~l
..It •• tl ...
Thli: I.h·t~ d( Ihb: ....". ",huw Iha, U
r.. ~..,.. (,.IUI. ,..' n t H ' cllt.. r .tn~J.·
• .....,r dh.trl~lli ur :n"'l:ar
dl.itrh:I"; l",R,. t(., 1'.
n..... tat. ,.'l;,':!! , .. \ r-
jl.
'oj
In, .... HI·~IIIb.·1 IIlhnietos.
~cond. "'Ub n'",v.-~t 10 ,h!....n.I.ua-in,;. I .• I"
.. , 1'1. ;.r
""-·. , f ,h"',,·n ...·
of . . .a.n.tl-lilnll" "IKH "'01111': r,,'q~lrC"aL'nt. it I
h·OtI' UloJt I
\lft :thul"d. rI.~ r.. IAll4ln.lIlp b\:-lv.....-n on an\I-.lnjOh-Io,''''l """ltn~ r qulr,,·
;,· ..niJ th"
plae• • y.l.l'., .ul It ,-",~'r~h''''' In 1.,1Ibbol'lr,. HUT .." .. t-I ri ... l bdd I-nJt.'.I("
cleatL)'. p ....C"!II 0 thrul.lt>h a. '11(1' rue pl.JI'" ~1I'.r. I Ih~, J"-'~U •...,.I~ "~"'I\' oIdH
of an nlt-lI'ingl ..-.hot rn,l ..'llIIlvn. Thus. Ih.' ....HI I ...-t.,... dv wt'.,)nl' lft "Iu'I-(' .. tlll"
&tun thl. (;('1."( I.aVIjU.tj. til..' tJ.'f.'udrlnlS in thf.o. I d .....
a,oo.
11<.
f
'"
l~"'''''''
I•• ~ ...... ~....~
I
r",r ~
JUI:~' 'b~
1.o'J 11 taw
,
"H',
..
Pop )
]1. 19N
WillI_ Gitttlll.'\'
JUflt!'
L;'.U, \ I
t hoFc th,U
If ii",')' r.,
fAl·tfAI.
,,'11 k
1 na ",ur,' L:I.1; ~·t:h·r-- ""Ill i'I~I:tt out •• 1: .··'ar...·• ,h,· .·,.urt 'Ii falll1r~' tu
'" n.·n n,·", th.· pr, '"',·n,·.· ,l( lI.l· 1~~) urdtn.;ul",·~·. J·"n".rt in~ tv r\lst: rlC't 8lack.. ttl
th" "... (,1""0111'\ p,·rti.,.; •• f tillo' .:ity. III ~ll.h·n t,· .·tlf'h"!Ji~in& lb •• ,.,inl, ... ",~
IW.V'
mt h' I~'" tho.· .:.,... n. (,1' c.. lt. judh'f<11 n..ch.· "f cr,,' ••.. lsle-n«· fI( Ii 1-1.50
th~",u,h ~-)l 'll tit" I.ubb..·...k ~.l<k vi &)rdlnar,,:\.·~. whi.:il .. r.' .elU Of! tnu b~
3n4 ~hh lS,,·s.:rlb.· t ....• "Snullk·itliu·na Lubtladt Dt.·\·..·loJlull.~nt.
T'h..· ,te prov •• 'o~
",.. t~ oiarthl",·d .1" r"'(''''I~(,l>' ~a'" ..·.·Iuu.::.r~· 10, l1Jl12. T!.· iIlJJJt IloCrtlnonL St..", ,. I 2-29.
"".u"'."
n .., S.· ...tll.,.l,'l LuM",...... Dr.·\·,,·lnp~nL Joaril Ill, .lnrJ ~, .. 11 ('QU\HUl~ ;1h
44v·",or ..· b.·JtrC: 1n Lk dL)" ~OI&I... lo'h vBh ;1ul~rlt)' 1.0 ltold Matin", ta til..• (it)" .and to ""'ft,."Il4Rr aDd __I'll' r ..•..·.lM¥!lHbUona tg the idly
o:-oaalflil,n In vrlunS. '''-OIL t l . to th-" t on 01"1 and 311 auter.
tt.or.ncd Co.) :t by the c••=t.inlon. The oo..... J _~tllb..·rs shall to.....
clJrpor.t h~u for th",' PUTik)~ ""r ."lliA, hl D.·~r:o. ur the Seero fa!:.€,
ROWS OtrlJ Inta ..lft ,,11.hl1 hUCL'pi .It,~ to b ..· \:"o--.t rucl.L·d.
Th~
ocl&n.! (I .• n..:. "f Ulltf urJln..n(..... ,..,1ft uQly b.' uucJo·r"".UUo&J In tb.. COQtl"IC nt
19/3 .·rdln;m....· r.:cnh·tln.· BI;h'k", tu t:1ol:' .... \'I:•• ·.ul1.·rn I".ttlnn ,.f tl'\... .:It)·.
",tk· "~~"'r
:.10,1.&0\1 ".:Jlnl p..-l'hilpa r..-qulr"·,, """,'11";.1:'1.
tIn p;:I¥'· 21 or th.... CU"Itl'"
Of)ln!,·n. t;:,". ) .. "" n.·:'·r,·n.', to> th.- J"I.'(('c-n;.I ...· •• f ,1I1,,'rltl\."8 l~lI.i'llJY"" b)' t~l(,..,it .... ~r.d f:r,' "'i';flt~·:lII~. Sin · thit c,.;:urt I,·ll.:lh! "~"""ptn¥ ':104 pil!rv,1I'l1v.·
4t.c:-1_tr. •• tl.·a. I'" :'·Ii'..i,'U ~lilll
t(J the ,'11.\ t.· " ... n· '''lfVard ",·(ttl ,,",vloJ,·n.:'l·
ti'l,;t,t Ii'l"I(l\• ..:,h ,':
:". il.. Iv..·111-i. I til< l'.JziL liTI' 1'1' 1:11' !llll.IIl..· ·:llIuf··..... 'trf."l
I h.l.l 1' ,', n r. ""''''' .1. ~uld th.· ,'11., r • ,'1 lo,'':-'t. ,I..'n{ill .n, .> ....' ... :.1. dllislpal..·41..
1111 .... '·IU.• tll\· .• , .I\.·~'·I.,..H 1.. 11'~ ••••' '.:.. t!J••• ~f_.Si~y!Jfs.,t.a
~~.~':'
, .. ! • .'.1. [1'1.1 ... '._1"
\'Ih .11. " j 'J. I' h,., rl\. LhL' rl~""r,'1'l
"',tli r"'~lrJ :.' I,," I.I~\I; ,.' fllll"I'I~I,'''' '.1 lla. 111 .... ,,1 i,.·ll,·,· ,kll.:JrL~·nt" .,1"('
p"rlttr:':ll~ t.· tIl. 1.;!O.h· '. ""","'11 1\"'1\'"''''
~ll' hilt,to.1 '\.:,111 ...1... ·11 t!1II.' Ci(,~ .,.
,.ro\l\- t .. . .,.,n .. I\'·II.... I:. :h'", .,:
jl,~'
I~llr,'"
"t • • • •, .. 0.1" S-.or ti.. ,~a ... J\,'\.· •• l~' "1:,..1.'11 .. " ... '11 ~II" ,',t' 1'1 tIIili>'" ~1t.11 ,1 t ll.:.a-'l IV.· lI~LI"". I: .lolI)',
tilk"11 toJ ...·1.,.. :Llill. r:t . • ·U,j""·:MIi·n(,.
rh.' '-11\ l·r.·,!'Io.,,J ,1" l'luC;h ..·vld>.!o."('.
,\lth,,·u..;h 1","'11 tl::o .11 .. 11"1 ~·r,·JUo.'~' ,·vi.k'TI,-,· ... ~.... I.llh.' 1111'l .Jeatt .. ·r. I k~il'"
fru .. ill"J' own l ... ·~ u;l u\.."i( 1,;.•• 1 i,," ,.f tv.... l'IU~"~ "~", Ill:.! th.· 1t.·",1t ~'Il tn
1~1t1 wlth "':t.trJ
~l;dn;.:. 1·1.,'t!.·.. ·!'" 'n rh~' 111-.' ,I",·,.'I,*-'I;t "·.I~ noL Lht· ~t
r.·CII.·nt t,·~t. .•\'.• ~l il.lt· .• 1 tl •.,1 lip, ~".rl·uv,·r. it 1.,·1 lI"t l..... 'h v.'1UtL:ILt.d !)y
th~' Lllbbo('k ftr,' 1"'I':lnm.·lu III hG,.rd h' ,,'111,•• ,•• 1, I... rl .. nt:dlt~..• ur f"."rfDr'Oo'lnr(.·
In ill trOiinh'.: l'r'·ft,r~. ,\h".~ .ttl t!h.' SUjlr,-:lI.· l:,.~art 'I••• ,dnh'lI tn Co\a\ty ('If
l.oa Anut.!:!.._~-=-':t~·,!~. l:Jtt s. Ct. J'ljlj (19701). ill,H.·.II,." •• ,ttlt·" -..rholJlIi o(
itllh~rlnSftiJn.r'~~' "!:I.1")·=-.·M. In lh\· Ilr,· dI·rart ...·nt ..... n· .,v;lll41bllil ..
In~'Cdt
U b )~"...I' t.1·"L Uh' li~ur.... I.}I" ..-gpJo,.·..·Pt In th.· llr.· .I.nd pol1~e ~pilrl'"
.nt. il.'lIl~bll.h··d.1 •• rlal 111'~(' .·r vlol.ILl"t! ,'1 li:ll.· \'11 •• r tll~ (1'0'1. klgh18
,\.:t of 1'Jr6~ ••'to ;Iia:n.Jo.-J: 1:... bur,i..·f) ",a.9 "'I,t.>ft th.· ,·It\' 1.1 .'''''~rc~1lV cbS. prl.a
lad~ '~eot'; .1..·.ld;," I h\.' Chf dlJ :l.. l .
It ..,). !.... u!M.11I1 I.' a'g,UW" til", pr-....ence
of ~ ..·loJ,.·n.... '1 0.1 '. ..... I..tt n I': i.lll .. \111.
_'t,11'01l"~~"lh ~.
tt.,,! ~hot..,~ ~', ....
'q . . .
,."J. ..
""Ii
t.·
U.aQ !ScU'»1 .Uh. th.... th.-r attt>n"")'!i V:¥J (~':Irt • ll':I1 ..·(\
In"'" fu)ly
at.
t.'I",1
Ah' lOr..· I"allt."
lh.ln I aQ "'11h I~' r~ ..· tll;. 1-IIIlU't· t.mt. lh~y viII ~a
;li'p,.lJpl"l.lh· •. I&:::Io.·U-..... f1, I ''''l-~ r(;'I1 bri,·f llr., ..d ....·~ .1 n·.IMm..bJy aOC'd Ol.itlin... "f dl..• ( .... lit ..... ,d 1)r ld.·" .... 1I.lr...·d "oGtr.,otl '10'1111 tilt" f.1«:tl,l.,l thu!l~~ ttl
th..· Dillltrh:1 I',·\orl.
bt· 01 ...,"'....:o-.I""L:m •• • Wt:GJ,"$1o tOJ :..1)'.1
11",,'"'''' L.th·"" ;ul·,lwr Illt }UI: til "L." \VI"vun-
... 111
Kob~1 1 I'. 1i;,11 I JlOl,:
""-Of"'b>h"'"
Ll\l
"'.:Jh
Ib~
lltb lcUL"
JJ"dl~'" .Ilt\' ,II
1~"I:.o