T~ IA-L --rt<EPARAll 00,
,Qll-\Q1Q
('+1
LiAVES).
, .....
TRI, L PREPARATION
~lATERIAT.S
REV. M1YJOSES. ETAl..
CI\'IL ,\ Tllo:\'
"o.
CA->-7t>-}~
Art. 7. 16.
ntECllYtlfLrBMl(K.ETAL.
c .... _
1'.~_ ..'ot'''I'F''_'''''''''''_·.''
_
n<
"
n·.~
l[~l>t:ST
Of i'Ulsnrrs ...." 0 rUISTlrr·I1Hl:IYDOI
Nil Jl:DICIAL :roTla or roll.'U:l TI:XA.S L\II ......D
c\1SSTln.,.IO~,U. PlO\'ISI~ CIlSI:ER.. . ISG SEGR.t:CATlml
,.. .
-_.
_::"'2:=:2
- ..
~. "~
'. t.o."..__ ... _
......
,--
-~-
T~,,~~ ~Ialul'"
of bL.ck
ff~N
and a Te,,""
cltll~n. . . nd
~"nnlt"tton.. 1
provision dellltns vlth Illllr","tlon
vhtt .. cltl ..... In th.. Stat .. of T"""I. 11_
rep~lIl..d
_ _-
~
~.§;:~;f€:1~~I~;
or
......,._." 1._
_,-..,
... .E~{~'~;,~~';~:~:~T~~2
, "
" ..
..
~~~:~=-::; .........-,, , -" .._,, ,, ...
".." ,. ,_, ,,_ , ·_.AI '....
,
~.
i.~:~.~:=:.;;;;::~~;;:
.
§f~.:~:~ j: i~'.:;:': 0~2;:~
In th. Stilt. of T"iUl lind th .. City of Luhbock. T.... lI. fr_ the t i _
...
~'':''. :"'";';~:';: " '","";;'
17. .,.,... n..
500<'. j, SeI..rateKhoo!I.lur.1t boo ,,""·ill..,,1 t•.,. the ..'hil.e&Jld
rolon'd rhildrm, and ;m\>arti.J provl';un .h.U be m•• ~ tor buth.
DlTl:arl.£TIVE COMMESTAav
~~~~:~i~~~§!I~~i:;;·:~:::~~:~:~:;:'~::~::~i~
ALIlERT PEREZ
u:n:
"""''''''
IWIUTP.DAVIDOW
IUD: HALL
Ilu~~::~,~::'~~~;~::~;;~~.~;:~',~',~,'.';-'~ ',:I:~: ~~~':::,:
AIlTllUIl
S......CV rIlEaAUCM AltnlUIt
~~g5f~~f1f.::~;~1;~:;}Dtf~~~f~
DA:UUK.IDSOS
Iy:'
_
5:s:~:.~~~S~M;'~:',~~·,~I.,,:,I:::~::;,~
The dn'ftVnooa of opinIOn anJ rlu~u.,,,,( "'lI,~"'•• ,~ .....1
''':''1'ly rrll«,f<! ill k,:,o1'''''r .-.u..11t.
"
I ..', -., I"~" Tho,
C<"h'ituli()"OrlSt(;I.".. i<lnJr~~'I.
.) " ". ''''"1''''-
T.... eon.fltut I"". Artl~l.. 7. S"Cfton 1
(Re"..,..
/lVI'.
ff,
/U1)
-2-
••I n ' ' ' I....... u,~r
"'.''''14
Art. 46.
1,1, I .;,~"r".h,~lwo\l.~,""I;",f"I""II,.1<ll.e~.J ."I"fll
f.,lI.~r .10 .• 11 ".1 I.e ''''' ...... ''n·. "",I Ihe ...." .'", ... r 11.~ R.,I"r.,1 "•.11. r
"·~"J·,II,,,,,, "f h,·. "Kf'•• 10.,11 "n ..
.:::......_
~:::::=
. .."
:'~;:.::::.:'.=-~:::...
-
'_
_ _a'_
_ . .-_' · ·.
.......tDo.I.I•••
o- •
- •
............
~
..............
.. ,,_ ..__.
•. . . .·•.• co
~·;I.··
&· .... - -
_
_
III.
.. -
lel I" Iloe ..""""r " .. hil,II'1..' •. ll., ,t.· 1'. n·m" ill "dil.l.l" _r,:
"~"·'H·.'· .. r i ....lilllti.." li,... n"",ll •., 'I,,. :-'I.,,~ I ~·l."rt,,' ..nl. r 1·"I.Ii•. \\.].
r"rel",.Ia«d,ildrMl rorl"~.I"~"'.it.blll..:,,,rr;.,'nlr"rllell,uK
""n·"''''I.. "''''''''RllIl
ilml: 'h"t .,..-10 ,...,r,(')·.r ""t.u.Il.." ldl> ..
• ....11 d,ihl f"r:u.loot'lio",
1 "" r""'hrr"", ,''' !>h:>'I!H'
I"f
.....h l"·,,lJt 1"""""'1•
'""1"",..
If' 101 I'K' <':uo:' or ",n)' ,'-n._1 I" 11,.. " ..t"r.,ll"rTnts.,I~ .... ,an.
'lu' ....llnlhorlldot"i<>nntami....-.rr"iJ.I. .-.,,:.,...11_ ..r ..-I>dI~rnrnuc
....idrhf.. I
lo>ntin la.ful ..·.,I~..-l;•••orho:-,.... nl .....llloe ... tf......nl
if Ii'.... In rilil\% arl.... lit<' Lorlh of qi<l t'hi"l .ad <lui)' ...,l"".. ~
.. ~ ••i..;
IM ..'UIW.d"I.. ;t II~""""rloirthor ... idrh,I,I.:lJIOI
.haU.J,,'Hlo ,..."""'......
'.\.·r '''''r''.e.ru~''''I}·.'''"II>:>..ml,,1
.ulhonl)" of .".1 ",~r ""i.1 .. I,,~I. MO.' e"hlIftll to iu IUk>l't
"l-.n
J"drnK'nt of .n)'"
of
" ...telll Jur...liction •..,Ihoul th~ n '.'..(1
of __ ltl".,hneilllhen"
rl .... '''' .... nllll,)''"lolotl"n.
I1)·.",·
..,,,It
I , -... ~,~ ...." " ..... ,,, l ..... ft. .
s....~. ~othinlf in 1101. '\r\ .• Io"lll'n·, nt ~ C"""I nr Conl!'M,'II: Ju.
ti.dirt ... nf""", '"kin•••·'U· rrom.,..." "",t".l.relll Ihet"U'I<>J,'or
1headut'I<'lirhll<llO'.t"....I,n.. II ·w'll"I,,'U ...lllr.lfUlt..,'I.o••.r..;.
l ....r nf I"",, or I..."y<>lhn ,
u,...... r.......,r "r 11.., 1 1 .onl
rhllfM'ter of autfl """'.n·~ 1
,. ur "1_ l.~....r of :t1A>~. , iot'"I ....
illl,....ln..... luf.uci'
ld.,TI ... 11._'~~'I"l\·r ,....... :.
___ ....
,...'1 ....
.....
~
-I,,·......
...........
s..c,.I!. :"" ..hitechildr.n
..... llli<oj>l.fod
....rurhll.l . . lIdo>t,ted '''''' .. 1"1~ ,"'non.
a
--
Il<"VOIH'ISOn
norr4l1"
g,.,'.!I. W"~n" m;n<'lrrhild i. "·~'lt...1 '''.
,I.",'~" .11: ,I"'l."",.
• ion. of 11t(••\,·Iide. "" k-ii:"I,.·i:lIl,,,,·I"I' .,,01 ",: ,.,:10'. ;.,,,1 ,Iut!"
1...h"'·"'"chd,il.J"n.lil"""tomdr'''''',,1
,11,-,·.... ""I.i,I.""".
"nd lOut·to rhild .h.U 'h.. ,'~~f'.. r I.· .",,-,~.. I .,,,! ' .. ,.1 I" I r.. , .........
1>1''1 __ lit<' ,hi'd of 'Ill I",.·"t .>r I ,,,' I., ~'.r.'
r"II, ..
IhCllllllh ""'urall}·,.....nl"IIHm ,"L, I"
:-.,<1 •. I .11...
...tlillolio
" ..r n1K.lion ""•. '1. n.. '.1
, ·t: '.... '" '~Ie
f"""llal.lloa.renl"rl'a......tal" ..,H·1 ."",I.~1
.-t·, I...........
"'>adofl.... aftalJbe~litlf.dlo'... w" ...... J'I
·''''L~
foatdadot'lnI.-l .. ~I.:a1l
f
.Iff
, .. ·u .. t . . ~
Jl:Ilur:llrhlld. t·MI"'. . . . .finl....,I.....
r,h. . . . ,r
"
.....t.-....,. ..
W~
T........1... Civil Statut••• Article 46., Section 8
(repe.lled)6J",..~ 117-1-).
SEj'ARATE COACH LAW
Art. 1659. 11.\:3]
[1010]
Srpu.le-'oM
E\'~(y Dil,,''')' ('Om'~~Il.v•• I"""t car C'<'n'I'''II)'
1 rlltrn"l~n
niI.~·ftMIll.n)·, .... any
norlhe~lltor""}·I,,- ,n.l1rn'.or
""1"""'tioa ... h.. 01 ..•
iIltf'l'llrl_.f"m".......".l h",I".. "~,,..Je
I.
\II f&lT}'llljr llllJUnllen ror hire lIn... "",n .1\,1' eil,". to.." .... "r \'il~~
llt this Slilte. 1,...",·. IlUln"ll't'T", or tft..i...., r the r d,,'nll' Il\l~in'''''' in
Ihis S ••I..... """"moft earne.. ot J'UHIlJIen r hll\' shU ,...... ,·id•
~
ilttion of .·hile
.-pant• .,...,hn or tunpaM",wb ror the
aadl>f'CTOl........nl"'on.
2.
rrery
State.
.. ~erro .. drl1n..d.
rer-
of A(IYa"
The term ""I""' •• 11"",1 hnein Ind,IdH
... c1e[......J b,. Ih.. Stat\llN of tllia
~t
I.,
"S<'paDleCo;ach"dl'l;n...t. E:... hron'l,,"m~"l ur. r.il.
road ~h dh·i<I...t by Il"lOd .lloi .u!»lantW "'<I(ld"ll I~~r.jli.."" "ith •
4oorIhnori.. Wallbe~ .. ~te~h ..-ilh;nlhenl<!aninl:o'
II". ~"'••nd..,..,h I<!f"'nl.. ro:lCh .hall mrln _
............. ~~u
,,~'rol'r;lIle ,,-onl. in l,lAln "'Iten jno.lklllin.. th no«! t"r .. hieh it i.
3.
~~;~ ;.:*~.::-;~ \~~~~.:,~ ..e.~',~:
.>b<-.
=-:;;:- ;"" _.,'- ....._.r ~:~~~: :, ::... ,';;,
"''1'''''"'
t\.o) Srpame f'Ol1\part/lM't\ta tor .trwt far. i!ttnurl"'n f
....
~l'('iaImotllrw"i<·
.. <I<'fined. E.c-h.trft1 ....... inl...... rl.. n~ ..
or ('Onln,,,I'(';'] molllr "hid.. h'I\'inl" a t.Ntnl or mArker I~"".,.l in ..
t<W\Ipic,uouar]xe\.oe:lrinll~""I)rial
....-ord.i"l'l_,;nk·Il.,... i..dlo-alinll
tile rxt to.. ..'hith .1...... II let 'l..rI .•luJlloe aulr...... nt a" .. "'I""",t.
COll.panment w;lh'IlI'" meanl,,&" ot Ihia law.
•
Le-......_ _ . _••_
D_........
•.••• __ .....
......
".
"
,
~::~~g:~~ r::f.:t:;f;::f:~f~j
L Violallnl"aefUn.I.('Oa<h ]",w. tta"YllU""nllrrul"",.lraln
... ItrHt mr. Illtltl'W'tJaD ftJ" CIf' eortllIIft'ria1 _or ..... ide 1...."iJft(
rill MPU'l'U
CIf' ~~rtlMnU . . alIKe pnw;o,.d dWl .....
i.aayfOOlCh"rron'l...nn_llOOldealrnAtedtorhi.........fl..rh.'·illl:
beellforbidd<-'Illodoao\.o)'Il!eco,i<luoctorlnduulIeo(lI,.. lrn;n.h
«*""
IlulIILetlDedDOtIuatAu.t"l,·.Dollan(S;;J_~I"lUlT"·en'y,
.... Dollant.~J.
r;. l>lIty llf Oo.-I,... t"r. Condud.on of ru~""Fr lrain~.•11'f'et
nn.lnl~rt.nll_or~llIl(ltor'·"'Io-IeI)f'\»·ide<l
.. l.hMTI..,.U a.:he. dlalt lin. 1"- IIl1thonly tD ....r_ ...)' pa-....r ....
•"lIa>1C'1 to J.llJ' f<Illol'lI or comllU1-.1 iII .. hith the)' aN _ c.lillnl
10 ride Il.... no III. pn;n·Wo... ot Ihi. law, and the _"IlK'tor in ~h"rn
01. Ih. tn.ill .... 11rft1 fAr. inlenl~~ ........ "",,",lIlrfd,,1 nlOl".. \·..tok~
IUD Iuo... lolIU-;t,.. and II ..... be hla dilly. to nen-... '",,", a .._II
....Inet far. or iltt_rt.1I carOf'roIlUIM'lTlal-... .. '""~ an,. ~
....pr lICIt entitled 10 rifle Ihenln under tlte pl'""illlo"" or tlli, law.
... uponhl.....Jvaa110do .. k""...lqI1 M JIt,.JlbetlMdnotl8.Jthan
" ... Dollan(J:»_ ......... than-r-.... ly·ft\·.DoIIanit·.).
MI.•••' ••, ....
...........
....... __._
.. ,.....
.~-';:;'::'::,~:::"".'- '"
0 . - .......
_.
~..::r-,
..
..·_· ··_·',..·n
"J
,...
•
....
"'t•
t
••
An. 1661.1
l.'.......... ,._0 10 _ ..._ .
... _0
..
,,~_.
,
~
_ ,
L
,.. .,
,. oM •• ..,.
~
0
T
'l
'"
.'
T....
___
nll::£ "ASl'I:C'S, TtlA:SSI'OkTATIOX. I:TC.
Ta. It
_.
TMAS"I'OKTAT'O~."-rc. Art. 1661.1
..._.o...
..
~
_
L
nlt:t; 1',\:lSt;,i,
~
I".'
_
...
._
,,,. _ _
,".~.
. .. - -
~'~"
.
~
..,
r .. _
__
, ...
o
.
~-
"RO
.
,
"".
'
"""r
Art. 1661.
l.........,..llU...
II)" tht "·o.d .. l.... ~ nn all u.....l i.. thia .rtk~· b ""·,,..t " ..,...1'·1lr.:l!C.·. 1<n'·'It<c". r,jttll. "1'I_tulli!}·. rn....~k·nc~. d'.....·••. r",·ur. I·.ionly.orp'.. tl.Jolis«
'·bP....... J<Ml.htor,.,.,.o>rdt..bP ....
r<l.d
Il" ... nl.,I.',wn.•1~ ,~1, I",n•• in ... l o.nlr"""" 1...")·1.....-.
1.1
thllOll',:IS Ml(al1 ••1 ""rolh.·, (H'.,..n. 1.......'...rth",l('lO II.........
n~pt. ~.rnalr'·. t ........"'.ruliun. ""'''
N. I't.,..;"•••I"nnl(. 1"....110".,
C.... I\I rur .... oklow!')' or .n)'" f",i,d.t
mod.ty OC' I... h~k. Or ...,.
'Mit,,,••1 ~'" "r bj' ""l' C"""""" ~ •• ri,·r in thi. Stato·. '" ""."
or
.mplo)·'; I""......'. A..,. I......... "'no ...... ,Il ..k...>loc'l. "'~tl"tl.1. 0' .....
R"W.d".-c1b·'"", hn..,lb·.f""".n'·"'·....... ~\o·, oI '"'i .
• 'l}" lO"'''''r, n·..·
l.
hi" ... f,l. "r oth.r thi.. jt of '-"1
lhoe
proml""of ..;tMr
'.id~.. ti
fllr 1"")<\I,in
tf.'TII"lf, 0'
...ithtlwllll.... torllwp"
»kil\Jl'
IC'tlll
ndU.lf. eh....i...
or ..."...,,·,n,: U,....~ ...... or Il'Io- prom
th~
,f. tluit eh I~'"'''''' un
or,o'Il.~ko.. unMn.k"tullroC'UreOt".·ft' t.n~·I'..·f" ,l<"<"i"I"e
""""'I>l. ~.'n.:I~"', ,,"',lJ'J"'rtllt....ll•• Iuri"lf
u'...,.... "I. I,L 'nl(. handli
ell""'" r.........I.-I....!')· of .11)' 'n~l(ht. (Oll\n~.l'l)·
11I"1'..1... or
anj' ~ill'l.Mlt (11.' b,· ""r""mmun ~" ....;"rin Illil 51:>le
")' ",",nl ".
rmplo)·~th.·n'<l(.wllbt'nll<,l ,"" ;'-uth""""'- hllnd ", ,,,.r ""'"'
IhaIl_thnul.llndd<>lbnandl...i"'I.. iao......ti .. j.'I oI ..•... IMn
!.hln)' ,1",. "o.. " ....... lhlln
""'lilt... A~III~':'.I" ::1.
.I/.·"t
f",·",.
.,J<
~
Arl. 1661.1. .........
_. _
... -.
::::
tionl'<llfll...,............ maM~ .....
bl>_ ill IlIia SI"le
.
carrln o( I~uaot......n fot' hire all..l prov
and require th.I"1 Whill
....-.....n t-nlin. tMir - . - ror I
porat;"" Ot"
ah.ll
take _u I.tn. (....,.ardor (.-1 end of tM bua. fllti. 1M Lus r""",
th.. fronl~.lndlhlt ..lN
I............... boardilllflhoti.hl._for
t .....p>rtalio. or . - . alI w .. _u I, Ih.. 1.:11 or.-.. fflII of
I.ll& bu.o, 611iq
r__ tIM '-II ......... Nd..
S«tloa t.
F..·"'Ylra""
.......,.,
.~,
.... "'., ,:' ~'
~n... nd OWl1ft' t~. ~tl .... motor
'_If"!
iQ_
-
S«.:' Thetoenn-Scro
of Afritu. """,,I ..
~
R
b:r I
--- .
_
-
hft"oti. iIlcI\adota .... otr')' ~
Slaltltel oflhot Stall or Tn-.
and.1I p«'IOlII not i..dUlllod 1ft the driblitioalnf MS"'lf"'M ahaI1 lit
te..-d MWhile penouM wilhin 11M _llII' o! Ihll A~t.
M
T.....
"e.."leoda,
Anita, 1661.1 (Tlpoealed>(Aw:.
.z~ ,,~7).
••.•
t,
, ••
,. . .
Art. 2899b
Arl. 1689
(,'OUSTY l.lIlR"IlH:S
Til,!:.
Art. 1686.
","p"rt "r IIhnoriu
nl(' hllr"ri"n "r ~"rh r,n",'" Iil.r,"~· ,h"l1 ,." "r '"'f"ro' 'he Ii""
,1:'1)" "r (1,1,,1 .. r ill ""d, ~"'\r....·I."·l ,,, ,I"., ,~,,,,,,.,,,,,,,,·r~ ,'''I(,'l .. ",II"
Ih~ ~,,,:,. 1.,1>tO'r",,, lh,' "I"'ral',," "I Ill,· ,·.nlll.' lih"M'Y ,I"..nll tl,'"
)~"r "'hh"ll A",,:u~1 :l1.t l.r,,,',,I;l1(o:". :;;,,,10 '-'1·"" .h,,11 1>0' m,"l,' "u
!!b"k.' r"ro"sl",1 by ,I". Sink 1.,1,.-:,,.,,,,,. ,,,,,I sh.,11 ,·""In;" " ~'"I~~
,n",,1 "I ,h,' "l1l.lu,.", lOr 11\l' hhr.• r~·. ;1'
,htm'"ll", l,·nr. m,.1
M.,'h 11""",·",. ~",I I......... sln"Slir" ns ,,,,. k"l" '" \\.11 '''''1,,1''1,,1 hI,r.or,,·' 1.1
",.""1'"''
, ',
",
~""
•. ~., ,., •. ··~'..• -l'·'.
Art. 1687.
JO'''I"· ... i,J''n of lill"V)'
Th.> ('\}unly lo[,r:lry~hnl1l.·,,,·,I.r'h,·,,,,,,·ml "'I",·"i.• i"" "'th'
,.,,,,,n"'~'"tl,''' n,"'·t. ~l"'h hhm" ." ~h.,n "1·,, I..· "".1. r II". .<"1' r·
,''''''''' • f lho :'1",.> l.,hr,,,i,,,,. "II...1",11. II ..,,, I"" .. t.. ,,,,,•.. ,·"h~,·
1........",,1Iy "r h~ "",' "r hi<
""'<. ,;, II II,· ,."""", I,·,,· 101,.-:"" ,
m,,1 ""l"ir,· "1"lh,·,r,,,,,,llI,••,,.,,.h";"1l ""I, th•. h",."n""~,,,,,l.,,,,d
'\Il,l ,..".1<1'\"": .'''.1, :<~,,,I,,'"~''' "Il ,,,.•11.'1.' '" II' "'.0\" I.· .,Lle
"',I<,
"",1'1
'''1'"".1,1
L ...."
" ' ••" , , ,
Art. 1688.
•.•. ~"'".<;-,,
u...
,.,.••".
~'
. •· t < .
of lib",-I')'
An)' ... h,l~ l,awlI "r ~ud, ,,,ullir mJI)' """ Ih~ ce'""I)' ft"1'C lib r)'
un,I,'r Ih., '''~.,. ~",t "'1ClIlnt;""~ 1''''$Cril",1 10.. Ih,' """"ll""i",,,, L rt
al,,1 "",). h~ .mtitl~d In nil th,' r,ri,·,~~ Ih~"..,f. !'-~i<l r·"""t
11 nl~k"
I,rul~'r l'n>"jIlQn r..,.. tit,·
"r f.lIid roullir I" l~· ,"'<\'",llh"""'lI"h
a "'l,~'''lr hnnrh "r br""rh•..,. "r Ih~ ",.",.)' r".· Ill.r.,rr. witH, ~h"l1
.... ,",hnin,~'cn ..l by CUII",lian "f 1110< 1"111'0 r;o<:,' ""'~'r ,h., ~"[!,'''''I,,,n
crtlt......,u"'yl'!!.... r;",,.Io1.
'"'If'''''''
".-
..'".
...,,,, ,. ,--.,
_..,,,,,,.....,.- ,·<-·,·
"""
. . ." . ' •• 1,
Art. 1689.
•
•
hid. for
library
,
All r"1ld,, of Ih........ ntr ft<l<: 1iImtry.hnl1 I., in 11"''''1.,1,.1)' of the
c,ountytreaa"~r.orotherrou"tyoln<lal."!',,m,,)·,I''''-h
...,.lt''tltedll.
tiH_1ydoelepkodUltlwl_nl,Ucaaul"Cr.Th••)·shallro".I,.
tutt.""pa,ratefundUlbellnow"ulhecounl)·rrl!'elibraryfun,I•• n,1
.h.t1notbollltledf..r.nyothl... pu.....-aU...·ptlht*"r.COI1nty'''"
. ,.
,
...
,,~,
, • • ,4 ,..,
I
~ ~rl·~
~,
~
..
.., .•
,.''"'
~,
Te ..... "vl.ed CiVil Statutu. Article 2900
Tn. . Reviled Civil Statui"'. Article 1688 (upuled>
(S"In;
J., /16'1).
(rep"'led)~",~~
I''"d
." ,".."-, "."._,.",,_. '7,.';',;:~~', 1l.,~.1
<"J'
Art. 3221
'''" I_'!eoo. ,.,_....... ,.........
...."' ....'_
, ........,
.....t' .... '~'n.~
$«. ~ TheSI.I.. I~ d"f(·.'"lml ;.lw""I')·"uth........llo.U.
«pI..nd ..,... f,
"'1~.>rI and mainu;n .•• rrI""n '.":'" ,I ild
n
.. ;~....... f.........
,,~
...... , " . , ...
Wro,'
:0..''''
I;"IM·~~.I. ,\~t. 19.\.t,
J 1. t:ff.. \UII. ~Il. Ill.\.'
Art. 3220-1.
-0
,
,
"j
Arl. 3221.
1.:\ ,,, !"l·lI,-,OI.
nil: TIn:
:!Il' '·""""~lId,lut"",...
II~""'
...
1..-.:.. Po :1. ~1l, Iii,
'-~
" .. "' "
~
........... f ....
1)~:At-"
n,..... "'(""'rol
,,,,,,,,.,~-
"ii.
".h",__,.." I" ·"i,',~ .• 1"",.
::;~;:~:~. ," :;~':'; ~~ :~, :';.' :-~-:;.. -;:.:-;.:;:.~,,::"",,:,:,:::'
4"~'"
, _ , .... __ "'
...... ,...
',:::',:::':::::
NioI "",.111
1 :1I A....tin. T.·~. ~~I 1:..,,,1 01 11 I, "
.,.
tIlor"1 to>
'·e ""J" " ... 1 all .... Iok.~n ...,.ru ~"[~l.~n f
lhoe h" l·
... ("...., 1 Orph"n.~IC" ......1,"'1 Il..n .. iln..... T~\.L•• (0. A...I,n. "n,1
p~t......,ln ....iol"oll.. nl."n,r ..,
r"•.• "I~.'H'"~I"'a"'t,,,,,tl"'. ...
in ...ill ilUltilulion "·h.. n..w,thl')· , '" il,,,hi ..~',I.. I",~''',; "",I1Int,1
IlI<h lin ....:\;,11:."..1.10"111..·"",10..,,,,,,,110 "~·Ih.· 1",,1 "".1 ",I".
I'....'I.·~· ~I roil....... T.. ~,
""'W
·UI'j..1 ~,~I .,~ll,.' ",i I 1',cl .. ~,
~ O'ldl3n.~IC'· (". ~ h "
f
",,,I ~k.1I I."., "II j"""
,.n,1
.", ril,.IMo... 'nn>nr,.
II"
,lnd tl ... I'.. '••·HJ .. r ,•• ' ..'l,jn"'•••..
.1
I"""'. " , ..... il r,." ~
1....1•...." ""I,t .... ',
.1 ....
~"""Il
..-...f
n".r,'r ...i.I".'ldL."·,.,.",,".II .. ~r.
Dumb an,1 llli ...1 A')'I"m r (",,~, ....I '"''''I~ .",,1' ·.010·... 141, f"'~n. al
Anlin, Tn.....
K' ....".
'I ...... ~'."...
f.~
...-.. _1
5«.:\. The Ollon .. r S<'""",)·.r"'e lln.. ,I",1 "~.:"".'." 1•. II.,ro
1I"".....')·.l'I''''I'.iJ,I<'d ....' ..rt!w':-:I,,'.. T ........u.... ,,,,<0)·'1,.. ,.,.,,....
", ..rilllt ror.nd 1
'•• rli"1< ""ill...,.", (io,~h'"""" ,.".".1,.1 r". ,n
!kiaNt.a""lur.>.nr
nl'''nl:oi.. " ... I f·f· .. t '''I ..... ,,~·, ... I ,~I "
........n rr'O\i<Wd 1 1.... r.....,,1 ,....,
Ii ..1( .'lIl"" "1. l:r.:.,. tl...
_to1A .... [~tolh.. I~n1u(I·, lnoI'''r.'''hl'.IrI·_...
A
M~
.....
"r TIII.I,. 1'1",,, .",,1 .~·~I' •• ".'I 1,,1.
'). _1'1...","nl<,1 "111 "f the !'12I" T.·.·""'".· rn. II~· ... ,.....
I'port _,~, 1... n,;I.,rt..~1i"n"" .."lori",," ...,.r.• ,.10,1·
4m f . ''''
f'lIdi1ltt A~I :\1. IXiI
1"1,,.. 11... "'" ,.f Th,n.·
,....,ndlPl).OOO.lIO' DoIbt... t,... lhe"ea
'"'''' " ..,,"·1::1. IXI.
tM __ to 1M' ..·.ib. . to ..... IkJol.nl u( l",nl,,4 r,.,. ....." I.'. . '......
Ser.,1. TI,. (u,1I..., '"'"
\1,.. La hI..;nlo1l
"0';1'
......,......OiI_....... I...·L_·--...'...._ ,...
_t. IlIHrin d_ribM In Ih" d."",
"'''''''''''''1( ~"j.1
1""1' ".' t.. \\ H.
rn-e;... TrtaItee. ill 1....1 rur u Rial" "r Tr."". f .., tl,,·, t:tl41.1,.
_ _ o( .... ~ . .,.""" '''''
l''Nlril.l.ln·n. ~.,r L'~I, ,........1.
iWoI. • .....,.lrnately ....... hundrod
II··!,dl ••1
tllalM
_theT..... o(Gi!tnoTilll"I.,j,. . ("
I oro'
""hall
..~btht.-.oaicti..._·""""'t....,..."h.. l(,i.ll "ilnJlle
trt_Iy·IIIMbooildillP. ill ;roKft'I>o:"''' ....1 ..".1',
"'h.- ....
','.T..,.,
T..... a."I ....d Cldl Statute•• Aulel. 1221
·~I· ........
Sec. 6. ""00""1;',,, b)' Ihenid,.."" (·..I""·,f".!,'",, ".·1 · .
""'"'t~lolheS,..teof1'..no"'thelnnd._"'II'.....·,i.. ·."'.. liml' ' ....
An. 3221
II)' ,11.-..:,,,,1 1" ~~«u," "".1 ,\coli"cr ,~ 1'"'1_ de<o<l ~nw)';nll" .... id
L,,,J ,,"'I I
;,..,. ~nh. 11~· "11,1.· or Tu"," r..r the '''''''- Mn-in
~1 ....,r••~1 r
r,,_ all.~ 101--. I"·n~.,,. ........ ml,"'""'" Dr "tlJ' d .... radC'r
..·h .•'" ...., ,·,: 1'... '''''I"'n.. ll........ ,~il.. uidl'ro.... rt,..h.1l1 .. d"'..·n
1.,' Ih.. ,\ll ......·.'· (;"wr,,1 ,,,,.I.,th·rit,u,",,uli"n••h,,lll .. rlrli.· ."",11"
\I ,. ~l"l.· Ito",.,1 At '·""h.,1 ,.f ",~ ~ll,'e of Tex..... '" 1Je hy It rile<1 and
,.'''''·1 1 'nlh~"ff.......ttl ... C,,'.n'lrl:"'rl<otl:I>d'urf' "I)·.T""":
I
1 I.... I.....h..'I.I1 .J~. r"nolA! I.. Ih.. AUnt'....,. C
..,.I .. r I....
~1"t~.rT•• »anal..I,...... lorl'IL,.IO ... idprol'"1,.d
-,Itll'u.ld I>""'"
•·'ll-'"'..:(r.... t ....ll .. l1.ld·I,.1i...... ll'.~nthr"n<... ot"")·eha....,,.....
"bll~rd,ynm,I .. lh"'lulr"(th"Allu'n(')·C... 'lel'ltlto
n"",,, ,,,,,t"n''''''·o/'ll,·I;llct,,..,',lp'''''1... rt,..
n....Io.....liwll,rth ;.' 1.;"I< C""'"'IOrpl~.."""II\t'<JO'T'<In'.
on
~: leotT
"f;;Il,,,,
£! ~_-lIol'd br It .....d-.l
Inf~n"e<:t'''n .... ilh"rl, ''I....l,.' ..,ldll...>haNlP.•".I ....... li.II"'OC_·..r •• 1 f"rl... ,,1< of brick: "1'1>f\'~ln'''Ic1)' """thou..,"" """kI"tfemenl:
"h,,' '·.... ,,".1
...h ..r ,,"" ......til:l.< ...~i<ll:"",nllll")· d"'''ITIl;ne to, I.. f•. r I.... 1""'1 In.
I....." .. r Ih"~I ..l... ",.. 111'" 10
1 ...."1 ""1-'.1.' sl,,,"I.· ..,.."·e'·.. 1
IOlb
h:olf.b)·.k....I.I..I)·u ulnll.,.lh"m..·"'I"'.. "rlh"l;.:"ml
~t (' "r
1 III<, Ulk III tI... 1"'
a1 1'<"'1. rty h,,11 IJC •.......t In
tbe "".... I~
10)' hill .,( l'aio. duly e"
led by
~, ..."I...."". Tho!
~. rrom the ..~Ie .. r ..'~II""I.... rty .. "~,, ... ~I«I.~I "haU 1< u ".[
I.r lh...'.IIt.,;'nl ..{('''nln,lf... lh.. I........ h:>...,<>f'''.I,\JOII'''lla'''1,
u.. ..r«linn <O( ,,<ldil~," ...1 bu,.linlC>'. or the ."!'I-,n 11".1 n,.. i"I~"" ......
!~ lite ~ I_r. n ..mh " ...1 mind ,t')'lum rlOr ... 010<..... 1 \".""h.. " 1
OMcorffl Ort>I,al\l.' Awli ... T..,.,... "" uid 11t... n1 "",y determl".. to be
f~""'bellinlnnt ..!u.idi,,"liluliool.
Ad. Illl'1. 1'. 1:>1); Ad_ 19~~1. ·tlit 1..'1:.• :1r" l'~>O: •• I'. ~.~ ••,. :1: ,\d.
193(1. llal I....... :'il" C~". P. lllO.~". 411.11.
""t.... ..
.1''
1'''''t..lyn1....t....nmulo-f.r''''''oo
h:l!1\ty.ri.."headnrr.irly
r
Iltr.oOt~· ."UIfo.........t1.. 11'
foar ri.:a." r....· d,lrk~
n:lIM...,... f:o""'1IC 'm,olnnNlllo. "-hold and Icitdwoft fu .... lhl~.
c:ookinll'ul.n.il~ •• n;I{""'I."PI~_. i. herd.,. ....... pled."" the Iklard
"fConlroloflhiIStalei.h..r<'byaulhori.....-t.nddirwt.... lo_pt
:uuI n'ffi.·.. Mid 1....--"ll'''',....t1)·. IInd"' ......1td di.!"'M of t.M
.......... in this Ad r""-'''''''-
r,. :':<>thi,,~ in Ihi. ,\<1 .I.~II J.I(' ",noln"'" ",,:u In I";~
...t:oleh."",;n loh" d"...l"d t., Ihe SI.le of TUM ""r" Ih.
l:"nI ut C"",roI.""IlI,,,,,,, I..... ulhonl)· In _Ihe moIM'Y hemn ......
J'f"opri:olftl{"rlho/' .." ... of ..~ i<t:.:~"... olu."".b..ttothe_lra..,.,
lhi',\(1..h"ll 1..........
I,..."" 10 Ilth", I"" 'k>;u>lorConl.....IIIhori.
lyt.. "'·...I'tlhel'''1M'.,)·I''·''·'nn...nIM......I"I.1l)·I'''''''IIl.<\;'' .. n).
m:"""·r""k.nl: ... lh··r'~"""'hin<llheSI.'leofTu
.. ,"ra'anyi"·
~1Af'd
nld 1''''1
MId tI,l. A'I
a1... j!i,.., Ih"I:..:.nI
n{f >!
" .. I),..'," ,
". r, mall",.,,, ........ l~."t .."I :s....... "".
'''''''' '''II........ ".,.'1.."t1
''''.. '''....rlhinpl............ looJl.. ,he ..·e1.
~.;~: .. r :".I'·rr·h,,,- .h a.. 11,.. 1'.."'1"(('....1".. """ .•1......., .. I,i~_
~
Ihe~a1
'nt.. .
.,,,,n
'1'·'
T .......... " ,t4",i..ial."lh·. "_"'hilityand I·... II~.
afN._
TA .. ........,v... r.f ••<1 "".. ,.i~I""';r.. rT~,..,,,,;I,;li', lor
Ill" Tr.rou mig. tH.I .<NI Or'......~rAooI
f"" ... I••r.-.l
/ ...... fir Tu.. I'...IA C......;/I. fAr
r.... nI /
T.~ •• Sf"fe
n"''''flll....d ,';1"";'1 SrA....t. /or Ad~ InJ. J"A I .. , ...., _... ~.
... III. II >1>101 lro.. 'II.. /:"..r" /
T • .r.. ~ ...
1f'''J•. '~I"
.IHISp«inISrA...w.I./A..."'Mrr. rJ"f':."n,f,... ,., I".
"tI.
"C.n,A UtI.. ,.. I':. fA. "~.II.
111,..,.,.., lira/ SrA-' />r .1..,. In:;.
"I If .. T./"<'•
I.. 'I _,.. I'i, ,~. :~.
T~, Mff"'r
~f/A
11t •• .r .........,./fffI/.. IA.Ta... SrA
(nf!A./I,.,f,,,,,1rf.
"67.1OI.1-rt1..... Il!Ji.• A,~Jl.ll. .'·",,,rI,rl. ·••.. k.
_._....... _---_
.... ... -- ...
-.. _...
__
---_
-_.... _ . ..
~
,
---~.--.-­
;-...... ...
,_...- .... ....
,
,-~_
~;.==--..:.~:.::
,,_
,
I
"
....o. ... , .'
,
~
I.
,
0'"
,
!,«, ':'
,h ........ "IIII.......",..,riIild.........""
od(AIf\I
id
Diork· .. I'"I"",! 'lrI,Io"""OC" I.)' Ihe l~e...1 "f (·""Il'<ll
,,",,"""I (....
,n Ih;~ ..td.Il,,· ",,,,I I:..",··. ·1,,11 I.. "mh"ri.",1."n,1II ,.1.......I.,."'''de
,u <I.. ty. to ""II Ihe .. 11;,.1.
Col<>tc'<! O'I>halUllo!' "rollen)' for Ihe
bertl~lh.alnnl..... ob
ltl... ~{or-; ..."' ... t..I.. Looeilllerfo.
i"
""
Te.... ae... l ...dChrll SUt", .... Article ]221 (contln .... d'
Art. 5920
TiI.t4
Art. 5918.
................ -...... ,.......".. ,' . . .
,--~
'
,
ia Ih .. Stal.. I.. i,,·rnltl "")'
rk ~,,,nI;lJ "".~.• I"
"l.. ~ I.. " _ ,,,,,,,,
ia all1 n,,, k",Il'
lh~ .. 1M( .~."
,.,,,, I~."r
I" ,.".1 or I" ,.
II\lllnt..r lan'·
"nimalin
lm;!I<'.•• rlu.I'.u·url....,.a")·
ftolfl ,
·h _imab in .... ill m".... t:a.l. "........., t"""'~~"". (Gr1",",,1;""
j•.••, ahu ,I.:tll ,n all' """" r ,~~ '., :t'I\' l" ..' .. ~'"
of Itlia .rti.'I.·
~II f..,. .."..h <>If.,,,,,,· , ..m", I, ••, r..". it aI.1 I"'" ,..
WSUI··"I" alt, "'
""lh"", ·II .. ,.lr•• t'''.rn~'''·tl...·,' .
IIgntl",,\,",llano. a""I
1••ln<'l nr ,
,1> """11'"
r~... :'
Igil ,n III.. name", II,.. S(.,I.. f ... r II, .. , "' ..... uf ........' ."rtlll!'II •
;::~··-::c t:~;.'~ .-,: t~_,-;~:·~,:~_.-;':,i; .,:_·.~ ,:,_·~ :,~·,~.;~'.-:",~.;__,
.•. ..
:':_:,t'~~~:;~·~~M:;'~''';:
_~ ~
....""
'... "'_'..,. ,_.... ,
,
'~
•• '" " ,.. n '
,~,_
• •·.1'
,.. ~ '" ",
:-::;~'7.~":';:;':I:.",::',~'-::.0
-: :::,;;::;-~,:;'"~;-; ..''',;::-,;;'';'".',':''",,'h~_o/'-"""""'··""'·""··
......
" ........... ... , ,....,..
,
.::::"'~:"':':.M .~':"7":'':"'='::
Art. 4607.
~_
,.,
oo-t
~,-'_..
_
,
"
CntaiJI
, _ ........
,
.... _.~
F.uf'III....
Art. 5920.
......11oIt....
1Iatil 'arillI....
nw"""""'lur
"'.>caM
,~
..
.'11«.
,-~,
ItohaU_bo-la..·fulro'an)· ...""""ofCa......,iallhlolodorlhri'
~ u to .nl.nna,ry w'th
or th.. ~·••",'n;bnu ..r
"rnea..... Ir an)".""-- mall ,,,,!Ill. allY pn.u• ....., "r Ih,~ art ......
••ft rNtr...... ~haU1lo"n;oll"n<I ........ PD•• IroO; P.e-.:)I"
•..--1., .•__
...
1'1Ml pr,.."..,lin. ar1itl,· ~h ..ll n..1 "t'l'ly .. h,,, Ih.. ~t."I,'. in "h"'h
....rtanirn.I..... k..ltla.... ··I.. it·,··I ..·ilhri... I', •• ,(.I•• '... al'·,"'h
optninr••dlh <t"orh"",,,,, 0' ro"c,,·(o'.•In"•. "r I,,..,k. Ini,1 in mor_
IIr.an<t ...·hitll'Ioo,i.k..,.I .. lo!<t'ol,I".in.-"·""k",I(I".",•. ,..,,'\,,h..r"
aoln_.. th"'''h'·'·''I)'.''",rh.."r.'.''I'I'I) ..r I/r",.... ""''''. h",'".' ,,1I"'r
lib! Inn.n,nlAlJIio r,,,..I. U"-'I" "'..n. n"'n ,h"I". 1":<,, ~Il,l ~h ..l... t
.u. i.laken '~I"'n in an)' mine in .") "n.' II",. RIl,1 "I~'''''''' ouch
rHd. U<'t'\,1 .vrn. ...,.." ~Iool'" 1>.." "ml ..It. I~.I ,,~IO. '" lal..·" d".. "
lalM "';,~... ",it an .... I"'" " ..."lar ,I",' .hifl;. I'll\ ,,(Ih., n11l,.,.",,,1
"0 Ill"'" lirtn ia la~.n in," al') 1I"... ·,y"~IlIoJ al"lo"· In "")
mlllt'.ld.
M ..
',~::.;:-.'"';'~:~"::':'';;
[-*'11) (~l ('mIl)
~
Art. 5919.
, -,..--
_
:~:~~~: ..:.;:..:.::: :,7:7" ',':"'::
,__ I
,,,.\U"'.
..
~
........ •__...._. __ ....... ca'
.• .·.....
~
......._" ...•_'
...,
..
~f~Q1.tXi~~~~~~~
,.,": _N_·..·.
,-". '·.....
·- . . ·."".
__........... _'
_..u_.,.",.'...
:::;:. ~.~.:7.':.~;: ..~. ;,~ :"7..;.
."_.._0/...-._...........,..••
.:;·:~::.·:.:~7.':'__ :~.:::.::,::.:'=
:~L~·::.::::~.:·:·:;'::..'=
..·.f.
A .. I....... V. mill..
1\ ~":ln I", ""b.-'"l rur nn)' I.-"."n. """'~ "I;'", ar I........",'
torP"''Illk.., o. " ..... j,.•.,
,""•• "I.,.~lil1l( .,r """''';:''''1': ",,)' "'",..
nr.illI;lI.lh"':-I"l
...biI'Jo.. nr
..' ·..I·'ri,'.,
tM .... of I
.r .-aahlllif ' ...,.. 1 a"'l .·fta""" ~ \' . ,
fW 1ctI"ma' th,- mu..·• :-:".-1, ""'~i"l:
I.
Jehtall.1 ho",I
ilh ".III'l.I) ,.,-1.· "
•
..1"".and ... ,lhl 1.....1)"... ·I~'"t
0/ .1kiI •
T1te
~
_.~
III
~a...t
kor..rth.·;, ...,~.,,.,..''''l,l
bilrft
,bko'""aUI'r<II"·r1)·b)l1","lol'
......".I·'·.n ...,:.
..."'..,,.1'\':1.
T..... lIevlaed Chili Snl"I". Artlde 4601 (repealedl(.,}.".
·".....~
I'lo..,lIllf'N1"r .... ·'"
'·.-i(;,'IIllo ..... l.n""I." ,'11
'·"' ",·" In an,l .,.....
I
J, J171).
"",4 ,•.
T..... leda.d Civil Sutula•• "nlele ~920 Il'r",·l_!.'n"" .... pa... \. balh
raclUtl. . ror "ne&«H!I" d.I.led. SeJlI. I. 1969).
Art. 5920
Art. 6070e
.".I\.._I.."'r,...... «"•• ~II.· ... I"'~t.·r'·
but """ ",. ,,, th.· ...,.... 1""1.,,,,-. ~ .. '-'l.r.. I,
,""
r~
.. h't .
r. J"....." ....
"..i.:~";:::":t .;::.~'I,:,n:;,~ :~:~i~:1 :;:~~ ~;:;r~~::~~7:;
IY I. ~
n,.. I·,'m'nc.
~ ·n.,l .. ·n "r "")' 1'<"I~·rt\· Ion "t lOr ,n ",~.I "'-'.
r ..r I"~h.>t' SI3I...U......r ,ho·
r T~ •..., ~h"l1
'nr.,~I"'·I''''''''"''''''orlltl
"
"',,$.· ..
.• ''r1'c'''.
,1,.... ,,, '........ \......... , ..... 1·...:. ....
"",rl.. ""
II
'''',..
''n..... I~ '" "
)...r II .. I.. ,.. ",..I ,
'..-I.r..~I .....l
I.· '''"''
an' " ........ lJI t.... t"_ra"-.t
ho,,.. i<-
ltb
""", u:"kl".. lo\.· I.'''tl'~Il,''"rT.·1''''1,,·I ..I1,
'l.·
laall 1.·
,,,,,,,,.,,II»·.n) " '''Ih.-''''.......rtl... ~t.;olo· .. rT,'''',r.... th.. l J... 1
A'~I!l;\I.I::"II
:tr.IC.s..I·.llf).rh.~.tl.
Acl~l:.I:.,I>·lt..,.
""~
Art. 6070e.
s,.,....I. 'arilIl"'" ,... "hit" .1011 ....1:'" ell;'.",
SO..·li".. I. ~·I""·"I.· r....·iliti.... "lwlll.· r.ll'ttI.I",1 '" th~ .)"1.''''
I""'b r".lh" .·hit~.nd '''-'1'''' ,
".1 ""1'."1,.1 1'.V'.. i.i "
.1"dloon""lo.·r"rllutll .........
s.~.::. 11"'!lI~I~I'~,1iJi Ilu;or,1 ill ,,"11<....t"l:
("I To ....k.. n'......".1 r,,,.. \.~Ii",,~ r.,r ll" ..,.. "r Ih "Ial,'
"atka a"d 11M- ("'ihllo-t Ih"mn"" Ih.· .. 1"l'·lu~1 "'"lI:'" ran" I·,· "".
• i,lill,J: "'loara" I~,rt<a <0.....1 \0· ''''·,1.1 .... ".110". t". . ."" 1~~rJ.·
""a«h blu-i•• , .. ,II , .. n.ioJ, "'I l ......,....", ..·""I"I.I 1.."I...... nd.t
I~ _I,mr 1'''.«1.nd .....,.......~
"""'OJ·. I.·...' ,-lr."-.lo.·,,lth.
a"'I ....r.... yu('...·Slal......lt ................lI.t,.
tbl T" ."-IlI,' roark or r.dlot)·nr r... ,hl
or
tit th.
Stat~ I",rt<a ..IoI",rat .. "l",,1 (...,lo" rut'
h,1t awl ...."'...
.-..,..."""
ru...·.hnI.....IIll"'
I
I
~ ... h r,.nl.h
"rSI.I~
.r.. . .
......,·.,b..:
tr) To"'
""....U'·lot.... h~ ...... II~.I."
nrpnr.. ~.'" II'
r""illlr I""'''''''.'' hoonJ.. " ..,I
· "n '.• a.h' l./. r.
prot""lion."'I"I' p .. flll.. prop"~·. S....h
lu.lll>rl''' oo,h
..h·r.lu..t"'....,
'mr.,.,.r"u...- 1o..,,,.,b.l••.,".,J.h ".· 1"1.
1"11"'("0,,,,1)' I" "·hkllth"j.,,k i& "I"I. Irllt~,·,U"') h--."
h
'''''''.P''j''''.•urh .,l....rti""n..'nl mI)' h" rll" ill" •• ""Iar "''''I'~l''
In all)' ",ljoi"illlt ",.. nl)·. 11,,, l:o.~ 1 i. ""111".",,.1 '"mnJ.r .,I,ltl" ""I
....10.'0- for .",,11 1,'uinJ(. Th.· 1'"
1. ,\..-.·"".1 rn··" ,,,.,, I·., ..' ".
I ...... Ih....."r
h
b,.II1'1' .....I.ri:<..,llolh,.!'t"".I·.r
I:.,".II.. l.· ..... I{. '1
1." ,".. "I .. r I..·• ~l"lo' 1'''10.••
".11" I.... \ .. r ,1,··.
..1..-n'.i"lItl..• ...1oo (Or Ira>o<'. A<1.' I!','l'. "'at I~~·. I _II ~" .• I' 7·
,.1""'
07.
n..
,""
•. - .... ,'-._
. " ....... ,.. ......
. - -.. _ -.. -...
.._
_
~_
....
T~
_,_
Tuull.v(.edClvt! StatUI", Artlde 5920 (p'Dvl"lon rn, Itpnat.b.lh
fuilltl . . ro,"n•••oel"d",leud. Sltpt. I. 1969).
_- -
.. _ ·..
_
.-
of
',e
(Tollell:!
A".t1nl:.n.&
An.6U7,n.(
Char·S)
s. E.<~rtion •.-",;.... id~ M.n nOl "1·;,1,. to a",. nell..'''''' lrai..
or"'r<'ln.o<inl"""bl"U'UIU<h for Ihe \>(ncfi,ofc'llIe. ,xc.nC><
to.lKbfrcitbll••i... uca",.""...."t'<'.. ,ncl~•• no.. beIOCO."..IIC'
",0p''''~''II",I,oadCOIItI.."iu f.o", II.uH",= .I."pi,,:: ur.. dini"c<w
ClI,~u.lorclui.carlallxbrd'.'hctrtr";n.to""
........ e:l<th,,"cl,.l;y
cilh~.....·c. l<1oalud,. loll' lIOI ;";"11,.. Dr to prc"~1lI n"'><:1 11o,," I· ••·cl·
Inc;. an,. «...,.-b or <....."""... cnt ';Ih Ih... , ~"'l'k..,..<. ot ~ml k.~<'. upon
th~ lI.i. or carl in Ih~ ditch•• 1:" of tIKi. <1..1,..
6. 1->.... 10 "" 1_'.<Inl_I(~••,. la:I"...·1 ...... 1..."1 <I<'~: - 1"" c"e:tt.
i"lh,. :-1"U .....nikcpthilla.l""fo!rd ," a (<>ft'r~c"",,:,,.lCC in u,h
1'. .........,•• lqlOC and ",<h J'IIue.." < (<>.><!' 11... ~1e<I in u,~ .......
1.
01 wad Of.-e-d... k
oil'" r,,~ t'"I~'. ''' 1 .Hi.
or;llIn .. d",,, bnc. l" .-itk<l ",Ih "'1'
c ......hna U b,· :., .. .:·
1.....'1110 .dll..- ,my , ' ..·n\:<1' a<l".. It~'.. c ,,, .nr
h ... Ie, .\.
_n\;" .. hi<h Ihc,. ...cnr>l r",i,led •• ".Ie ..".1" ,"r 1'".,..-..01.1.
la.... and l"c<""'I~'orin<h"<C~oll""...,n'...l'..I
ori"'(njrba ..
... oII.11hn~.lIlhori.,.. • "d,lah"nhcl".olllr.IO"· '~c''''ma(,>kb
or al .....1 ca •. or ;"'ern.h"" ca'••ny ""..... '1:•• not <I.h·. ,j .n ",Ie li.~rt
ill ",,00 '~"llr",i,ion~ oIlh" ta.... 1,\<1, 1~')I.I'. ~", I\<b l....li. I'. ~~
Ou.,.
a.I.. ' ....
IO'r~1
. . . . ,.•. -.• C'h
...
,~"'
"
",
.,
Art. 6417. [67461067531 Scp...tceo;>c!lu
I. f... ~~ r.ilwa,. C"n'l'an~.•,,,..,, Ut <n"'p.,n:!,. An,l inlrrn,h... nil·
;~; S'::'I:l~;~'c~~::"~:;,:~7:;,;.::;~::: l::c~:: ;~~~~",:;;~r:p~~
ra.c.~huor<on'I"'It"'C"".uh
..cinaflc.prm.i,lrd.f<>Tlhc.cC01T>rno-
ola'i<>nor ..·hi.cand .....:
pann,enl' 011.11 b.. .... u~l i
1.
ru ..."l:c..... hichoc1...utrcNlchr.o'cOft!·
UI"';n,.",' ,.,n,(or' and convenience.
-l'r;:ro- drli"""._Thr 'rnn ~""I:"n- U uoed "e,rin. lntl-..dn
..._., Ah'm ,....,.. """""''''''''''''.'''''S''''')
J. ~!" l... ulr ..... h- I.fi.. ~I_l:xh ">r
·IT,...". "I. t.i!mad «>a.!!
oli•. ;I\cdIo,.J:<'"IanJ •.,.. ,."tj,I ....... I<.n. 1""'."_""i,~, •. ~tlhC";"
.hall be ,I.... "'" ! a",,'''' IC <n:o." "''''·,n ., C ,,.,.-._ •..~ <>,
b ....... ·1
n.!l "'i""~u" .,,1. .·.·1 ...... in ..".><: <
" .....' 1·!.r .·~,'''I.. '..'e
......4. i.. pbi .. I........ ,n,:,.uinC'hc r:><"C , ,,·hir!. iii.....'.1...11; .n4
urI: .,"",pr.m.n' 01 ••:."1 car or Inl<''''''~'' far d"iJc.II,l' • ~"I
1a' •• bc.·.,:.;I.."l"' .. ..-ord.i"
Qtnu'k"l'lacrd,... c.....
pb;"lrll... indic""r<:,"cta<cfor .. b,.hil' cl "I",n••h.n"'e ... ffi.
as"",!, ,~IC. ~nl"'r1 n, ...ilh,n l!lc .... ,r.:.. t: .. I.I.i. b .
-t. P,.,..,ll,..-An,. ra.il ,. """'J'II",.•• Utt' U' c.-pa",.
i,ucr'
.ailr...w _pan,.. Ie
"",,,,,,,on or Ie<;n'tft" .hnwf,
kh .......11
failloprM'tdci,.u•• l;u.;.C pulnl:ft... i,ll ~,""IC ~hc:I or coat·
pa,rmomtl,u .bou pro>'iokd Ioo-• .aall be I;~~ f.... ~acl. f.,lure 10. petl.
aI11ofllOClns.ha
rhlllldr........ morclhan"""'tboouafttldolla...
lObe =_cralh, il;n IM .. _of.M SIaIC; .nd eadllt;pu.. willi
II>dl ,r-aill Dr .I<ttl ca.... i"fCno,ba.. car ';I!wu' ...u. "!'Mae. -.II
_compallmnt.haU be 4.".....: .1qQ•• 'e ... 1t~1lK.
.to·.
·,'Ol'_"r
.ic",
.,haD
,.
Till" .... lied CI .. II Stlltut... Auldll '417 (repe....
d>(rm. ~ ",,).
'_
_ ,•• '~
_"
_ _ of . , , _ . : " . - .
_lot'"
ao..."........
.......
,....-.,..
.. , .
L"_
.. " ' , _.
L
L
I.
~.
11
,._,
_
"'.. ''''''
1•••_ ••••_
".,
_
....
.. , . .
,.
_...,"'"..."" ,•••• ' ,.1_'..
_,",'v ,._..
,..
.""",
..
. _ - ..".. " _' ,.,a.....
1......' ••• . -_ _
-==
-- - - .
,
.......• .. ,
,.",
cO' .........
~
....
,
1 Il_
""__
.. _ .. __
.
..
,_
.. 1_ _ ..'
..,.. ...
... ' - ' o f _ _ . , _ .
~,
to •••
..
C ...... "
.. .... "~..... _ _ ...
.....
.
~L
:~':,,~:::.:-=:.. ,-;~;=
...:: ...::...-:.."',=,::-= :::- ,;':;" c,.::-.:a:-.:: :::;;
.. ....... ,
- ...
~
._---.
... _.....
.
?f~:.==,: ;s~:&.: ::::'~~~E,: ::~ :~?~~~.~
_"
,
.,....._ ......
.......
-_ . ---
I~~ ,.~:~:~:;~.:
T.... Inhed Cldl Statutu. Arllcle 6417 (,,,,,.I"lU'd)('l! pealed)(r"1'.'i"t1).
-20~
(T,ddl!
Art.&I118.... ,
nlml.i...uchd.polbuildin,."'" llu.u.. of ...hil .. pu.. n~""lJ1d keep
aood mainl"'n IdrqllJ'" and .uiub~ ' ....i&:h, d",.,,~ a<>d bui/J,nr:_ loe
A"- 649). [66911 Othon"ptNI,y
A 'M,I",..,1 h""I""}' "I,...h ..11..11 i1l1..lIy, Ity lllC"'U "~C'II:""'~.""
by ,lie J;n~' ;;h~~t1c~ 0:4 '10 ~;: U humc cUrJ:~ ~"" m..... '~m'''n
...t dl~ .. '~llc 1 1"",iohi"l: un. lail 01" nl"K I" h"lIish 01" uc:h.nl:'
UrlI I' I.•"-i,, l,,.,..;'l,d I..... or 10 ...", .. tf'Ol1 .". d.li,'.r Ih. nm. ,,·i,hi..
Ih.tunol'ro..:"l ...,ll,y II" C"nnniuion. . . tof•• il:h,u"ird h.t .......
po)inll"'h"l1,· ...i,"i.. Ihi.S'.I •. ". iln<>llol"'K.ibcd, 11>r..... i,hi.. a
.u ,.',I.w"r••h"'1Iinl<l.li"".. 'n'I>r"'h('tI ...Lili,io;• ...,rri.. r"""idI'd I
,~rfr I
lhe !it>!• ...t T<1<.O" I•••ach 01 luch ..i<>blion....ot
1... tl
,..... ,
ll'IOfttiQ .. _b1lndrt'l!dnlll
I."..acb ......... ;and
.,xhd.>.,.r4.",·, 1.,11I1••. r ....I:..... : .. I" •••b
lIid' it.1,y ItKhwilll .. l"j.,"fuiln.;.:h;;rtI<•••hlUfa,IOI"rd"MlOf" i,horud... nl:.shall
'..,a""j",ral.uf:."K
.... _ , ...." ... ,
~·I.""
A".~96.
MSUpper-
"
, . , _ . ,~.
I~"LI
"
~=,:::"ioe m.y drrm oraso,,"Ll... lAo .. l!.l.O.l",1 C. ~ .• 1'. -Kl1,]
::T::~:~··::~·.?J:::'i':-:~
~~:E.7~.7;~;:~··,:~t~~:::
_", ....k". _ .... ....... •.......
_, _ .. ,.. _ ....... ,....
~
~..
~":'S~~2~; ~::~::.::=.;:.~:~:.::=.
[ld.1
,
~
" "'" •..
•,
~i::~::~I~,:~:~~t:~::::~~:~~:;l~~~;
".. ,
,,,. '''''. " •.
~
,
,
,,"
n ,~.~
_ _ &<
..,•• "'"
,
~
._.,.,
,' I
-
_ ...
To••
'
_".~
1"""_.
l·,..~ 1<,
~.I"I·I"'~" h,,..,.. u· '. it .....:'n
,Ii.... «
.or; .•••• "I t.I . .·;.....I,tf.,..sh'l
"I.a"'la.y
.i:_ crlOOOl •
'4;.,« .1 ~,,~ 1,,11 • I b hOlI:.• of •." ..... I~ , n. ti...., "'~lioto havinC
tl ... i~h. ,.1 .,,,.,,,;:....... o
,ilo:n"". lid I
An. 6417. [66')11 "R on.hl.. lim.~
1\ ,10.11 1", ,1.. lnN I'.i",. !>,i•• t< ..... ,~hlr ,i",~ ;Ihi" ... hit:h 10
Of~ .. r .... tllal an1 _1.'1'1'" .h~n ti,·~ 'H'Il~n ..... io;~ I ' .... 10 I~ .u·
liGn al:'''' ~llbc l-lac. of .I"p"'.,l\.... in hi_ ab
10'iol:
r.H
l1al.....I:..., <>fII>r""I..-l·.....:.."1'0 ..loith.ucll.I'P'ir.'
'
dor.
,hkO: .by_ bel
h o)"pmrn, 01 Ii,'. u .. or k ... and i
day. few
k
d.u
Ih
6,
."d"Chtd,", I", I
..
or..... ,,_c .~'! ,I
,..",
"~11 f.. rni ... Ibri....1.....",,"11 .. ilb
".inted blon"
hieh .hirl"''' "'.~ .. 'l>pliu'iooI for IMi.
Suth"'I:'nll"•• n,I'hl"·.,,..... ro"nl(.nitl.... h.llbl:.Ontlnr..dl"
U."'pl '''1 ,.11..."" N\ItIl"'''ylr'''", tt" ohli!::>!;"" 10 I"m;o!t .u. for
.h'l""ut ..·;I""-'\ ....h ....n ... _''''''. bUli, tJuJl ooly be .ubjOd 10
,1KJ'""Iltir. "'Ihi.b.. for!>i/l......o I.miolt ..... ,
hi""".........
_io:-<
".haUh.I" .... ,... nt-"I:.Of ill .."" 0:4 shil'
1 of fnit\1•
...hc>l111 ' ..-«IOI>rn"b'.,lh.. ~u'... I..... ;.,~lICl!wi,"I"".....1
<>.nd.q;.blr......1
C.......'"....... lid.)
(I".
"I"'"
,b.
\
:,::;:~:;~::'~~~ ;~i~~n~~',al:,,~h~I~,:~~,~,,~::1 :~;~~:~~ ::;~
{
..
...,.'-, ...... I,r'h. . .c<>m"wwbl ......ll'
"trr.. ·"dktq:> ..iddq>ot
b...Id,,,,,.-.:III,,, .• I.,I ..,d ...nMCIl.,,.tll
IOO-landarr-omlB04aliool
olI,l..,n...d.n':l,ulob•. TIory ... ~k .....PI
'n••• oq....I.. arort.
T.lIA'" Il<er.HoI Ch11 SUI"t... Artld...., .
for
"vhtu~
,..._.... ddnd.
s.pt. I, 196').
-21-
('· .....hlon fo, npe ....t. f••111tl••
T
for"whit
I . .d Cldl
SUtu~•••
Article 1>49
p. . . .nC·.. d• 1eI.d.S.pt.l.I969).
-22-
Ip'o .... I ..... fo.- ••p.,et. fae-lIltl••
11- ~ rtpt ~ft4-:
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
Northern Oilerict of Texa.
Lubbock Division
REV. ROY
JO~ES.
/
et d.
vs.
CIVlI. ACTION NO. 0.-5·16-)4
THE CITY OF LUBBOCK. et al.
STIPULATIONS
TO THE HONORABLE JUDGE OF SAID COURT:
COMES NOW thl" Plaintiffs. Rev. Roy Jone •• Con~.lo Car~a .nd Juan
Antonio Reye•• and Plaintiff-Intervenor Roae Wilson, being all of the
parties plaintiff herein. individu.lly .nd •• repre.entativ•• of their
re.pective cla ..e. heretofore rec08nh~d in thi.a c.u.e; .nd COflle. the
City of Lubbock. a Home Rule Municipal Corporation of Lubbock County.
Texas. and. in their official capacitie •• Dirk We.t •• Kayar. and
Alan Henry. Carolyn Jordan. M. J. "Bud" Aderton and lUll Hc:Ali.ter. a.
raembeu of the City Council of the City of Lubbock. Te..... being all
of the p.rties defendant herein; and each .bove acting •• part i •• to
the above c.ptio:'led cause and each acting herein by and through their
re.pective .ttorney. of record. do each. jointly and .everally. atree
and .tipulate tOKether that the fol1<I'".·ing 1r.atter•• conclu.ion., fact.
and .tatement. are not in contest between or alllOng the1ll and .hall ac·
cordintly be construed by the Court in ail deliberation. herein a.
bein~ true and entitled to the .al:'lt! consideration aa if eech had been
elicited by actual teatilllOny properly introduced for con.ideration of
the Court for all purpo.es and not directly challenged by any contra·
verting testilllOny. Each party retains the right to ch.llenge the legal
applicability of the theories of recovery or defense to which the other
may seek to .pply said stipul.ted evidenthry f.cts. and the.e stipul.tions .h.ll never be construed .1 a ...· .iver by .ny party a. to any
ultimate que.tion of fact or conclusion of law to which the atipulated
evidentiary r.ct. may uItir.lately be 10'.Ight to be applied by any oth.r
p.rty. 'nIe credibility in applic.tion .nd the weight of e.ch of said
.tipulated facta iI left wholly to the d.ter'1llin.tion of the Court. To
such end. accordingly. the p.rties do hereby agree and .tipulate a.
foilows:
1. 'nIe partiea .tipulate that the Plaintiff, The Rev.
Roy Jone. i • • black citizen, taxpayer and elector of the
thited States, the State of Tex••••nd the City of Lubbock.
and .s a qualified voter in the City of Lubbock. Tex.,. i.a
enUtled to VOte for _mbera of the City Council of the City
of Lubbock. Tex... Plaintiff Rev. RQy Jones bring. thla
action on behalf of himself .nd on behalf of aU other peuons
simn.rly situated as qualified .lecton of the City of
Lubbock. Texas. punuant to Rute 2) of the F.deral Rules of
/YIVil Proc.dure.
I
I
2. The partie• • Upulate th.t the Plaintiff. Con~alo
Car~. i • • Mexic.n-American citi~en. t."payer and elector of
the United St.tea, th~ St.te of Tex••••nd the City of Ll>bbock.
and a. a qualified voter in the City of Lubbock. Te..... 11
entitled to vota for _lIIber. of the City Counc11 of the City
of Lubbock. Texa.. Plaintiff Con~.lo Can. brings this action
on behalf of hi. . . If and on beh.lf of all other penon. 11111ilarly situatad a. q~Ufhd electon of the City of Lubbock,
Tex.s. pur.~nt to Rule 2) of the Federal Rul.a of Civil
Proc.dur•.
). The p.rtie• • tipulate th.t the Plaintiff. Ju.n
Antonio "yea is a Mexican .....ric.n ctti~en. taxpayer and
el.ctor of the thited Statea, the St.te of Texa•••nd the City
of Lubbock, and aa a q~Ufied voter in the City of Lubbock.
T..... , i. entitlad to vote for lHlllber. of the City Council of
tha City of Lubbock. T...... Plaintiff Ju.n Antonio Reye.
brine· thb action on beh.lf of himlelf .nd on behalf of .11
ocher par.oos li.i1arly .ttuated •• qu.lified elector. of
tba City of Lubbock. Te..... purau,"nc to Rule 23 of the Feder.l
Jule. of Civil Procedure.
4. 'nIe parti.s .tipul.ce tha~ the Plaintfff.lntervenor
'lo•• WiI.on is • bl.ck dthen. taxpayer and elector of the'
UIl.ltad Statel. tha St.te of Te.... , and the City of Lubbock.
and a. a qualified voter in the Cfty of Lubbock. Texas. is
.nUtled to vote for _mbera of the City Council ;3f the City
of Lubbock. Taxas. Plaintiff RI:lse Wihon brings this action
on behalf of hera.lf and on behalf of ,11 other penon• • i.ilarl,. situ.ted •• quaUfied electors of the City of Lubbock.
T...... pur'uant to Rule 2) of the Feder. I Rulel of Civll
Proc.dura.
-2-
~
5. The partie• •tipuhte that the Defendant, City of
Lubbock, 11 a Home Rule Munidpal Co!poratlon of Lubbock
J
/
election.
7.
The partie. slipulate that it i. tha agree_nt and
.tipulation of all coun.el herein, with the agreeMnt and
con.ent of their respective clients and the individual.
involved, that the current Kayor and -.bel" of the City
Council of the City of Lubbock, be sub.tituted in their
official capacitieS in lieu and in substitution for the
loverning body representalives previoualy na. .d herein.
/
8. The partie. stipul.te that .t the date of entry of
thb stipulation instr..-ent the Kayor of the City of Lubbock,
11 Dirk w•• t and _mbers of the City CouncU are Alan Kenry,
currently .erving officialS_y be named in their offidel
capecitie. a. paTtie. Defendant in this cau.e a. n.ce.sary,
in the .o.t expeditious _nner pe~ittad by the Court with01'
.ervice.
,;
10. ne partie. stipulate that appeaTance is h.reby
ent.ud by Coun•• l fOT such of .aid named Def.nd.ntl in
th.ir official capadties a. h.d not heretofore . .d.
appearance in this ca.e.
j
11.
12,
~ /
/;""
The partle. stipulate that an I/.·iOT stipulations
of the partie. a. to the indentifiable nature of the lllack.
.nd Kaxican-"-rican. a • •eparate distinct claa.es are hereby
14. Thet . .ny of the _p', plata or chart. herein.fteT to
be the .ubject of the.e .tipulation., are too large or cumber.ome to be attached to the.e .tipulation.. In .uch case, lhere
shall be sttached hereto only a nlaller copy, reproduction,
photolraph or written di.cription of the infonaation contained
upon the face of the orilinal in.t~nt. In all inslances
whare such a .ub.tltuted instn-nt is .ttached hereto, the
original of .aid inlt~nt shall be . .intained by lhe Defendant, City of Lubbock, and availeble for view by any party
hereto durinl regular bu.in••• houra fro. date hereof until
date of triel. S.id originals shall be delivered by lhe City
of Lubbock, to the F.deral DLltrict Court on the ...rning of
tri.l or .t .uch earUer date or t~ a . . .y be requested by
J
16. That for the purpose of trial the, phrase "Hinorlty
Influenced Area." .h.ll include Census Trai:'ts l.OJ, 2.02,
3. 6.02, 7,8, 9, 10, 11, 12.01, 12.02. 13, 24 and 2S, as
'.hown on STIPUU,TION EXHIBIT "A", l.. JP_ • ...<. A .. ~ .... ~,....
r- ~ ../
",.,
nd.nt. in thiscau.e.
7
"r
111. p.rtiea stipulate th.t accordingly the City of
Lubbock, Tella'~A':' the member. of its current governing
body in their otUclal cap.dties, constitute all of the
17.
,--
Ttwt for the purpose of trial the phraae "Hinority
Ar. . . . . . hall includ. Cansu. Tr.cts 2,01, 2,02, 3, g, 9, 10,
i.t_.l;.Ol, 12.02 and 25,
81
shown on STJPl1U.nON EXHIBlT ""''',
( r ~/r¢'1~\
effl~d.
-)-
o<'pu'o<"" ..
U. That th.re 11 attachad her. to as STIPl/U.TION EXHIIlIT
"A", a . . . 11 copy or reproduction of a . .p entitled "Minority
er KinoritJ Influencad Area."; that a large color-coded orililIal of this _p h. . been prepared by the City of Lubbock,
c~il.d frca 1970, U.S, Can.u. data; th.t an parties stipulate
and aSre. that aaid ori,1nal _p and all ~bols and dati reflected ther.on . . . accurate and co~cf:~n{f1'hXt'h;"t.rge
erilinal of eaid _p . .,. be introduced into evidence upon trial
of this cause by anJ party without any further proof as to the
accuracy ther.of. That .a1d .ap during trial shaH be idenlified a. STIPUU,TlON lXHlBIT "A",
Th. perti•• stipulate that it is .tipulatad that .uch
out the need fOT fo~l alll'tndl!lent
.ho, ,11 p""
'Z·,·
Carolyn Jordan, M.J. "lIud" Merton and lIill Hc#oU.ter.
9.
p,.".. o<'pu'",
chue. are hereby .ffitWId as to the Plaintiff. and PlaintiffIn/venor above n.-d.
6. The parties .tipulate that .ince the coaaencement of this cau.e the governing body of the governing
body of the City of Lubbock ha. changed in c~oaition by
/
Th.
to the sufficiency of the Plaintiffs and Plalntiff-lntervenor
to .erve as representatives of .aid two .eparate distinct
County" Texa•.
-4-
~.
~
That for the purpose of trial the
l~hr~;~o'~B:~:k12.02.
sh.J.Il include Cens....s TT.c:t~~. If. J~'1::..
as shown on ST1Puu.TtON EXHUIT A. ~7!--
~9
--
~ ~.
,
That for thl! purpo.e of trial th_ phr••• "Mexic:an-
AlIIln'!c::n Are
8. 9 and. 25
shall include cenau. TTacti 2:,O~. Pl:..A~.
,hO'ft'i on STlPUUTlOft EXHlIlIT A.,..,.
/
,han
tAO. That. as noud above. Tract 9 and 11
be
counted as both .. "81t1cl< Area" and .. "Kelllc:an- American
Area".
/.;2{
That the City of Lubbock, h . . cauud to be prepared a _p of the City of Lubbock, based upon 1910 U.S.
Cenaus Trlcts, and reflecting thOle Irea. of the City which
are '1Ullority Influenced Area." a. hereinabove defined.
That .aid _p 1& oriented
.0
tbat North 1& at the top of the
map. That a .ymbol 1& prepared upon the face of .dd IDap
identifying thou area. in which the Haxic.n-AmeriCln population exceedl the city-wide average percentage for .uch
rIce, by dbgooa,l line. running frca tha Northwe.t to the
Southea.t, and tho•• ar.a. in which the Black population
exceed. the city-wide average percentage for .uch race, by
diagonal line. running frOID the Northea.t to the Southwe.t.
actual' area' to be {neluded vith 1n
Influence Area'''. "K1noorlty Are.....
That upon the border of . . id ~p :,~~~ i/~ n~~~d,Re,"J..~.~1
population of the City and by race) A Th.t within each Cenlu.
Tract the identical infOl'1Ution Co:" elch .uch Cen"u. Tract
i. allO r.flected. 'nIlt copies of .Iid _p in .ufficient
"Hexic:an.Alller1can Areas". there hal been prapu:ed .. chart h
consisting of four 'IIlapl of the City of Lubbock. That .at
of •• id _P' denote. by colo:::. the actual a"ographic. at••'
vithin tht Clty of Lubbock, 1,1nl withln the •• parIU
phrases of definition used.
the side of each .Iid - p
ia • box reflecting by nUlilber percentage and rICe, che
nUlllber have been provided to Plaintiffs and PlaintiffInterv.nor, for u.e in trial. Th.t any party may introduce
.uch _p, or a. _ny copiel thereof,al required during trial
without any further proof of the _p or in original l,.bob
and inforaation . . lbove ducribed. Any additional infonution
added to .uch _p prior to introduction lIIU.t be proven a. to
/21
~t
to cladfy further and visually reflect tbe
~he phr••ea ::Mi::rit y
Black Area. ..
.0
population in .uch defined
:~:a:h:o::~:a:.~::e:~ f;;:l~h:sid
~~:~:po:;~:i~i:::::.:~:d ht>reto
V23.
That all areas and population figures on this .:d\ibit are
ba. .d upon 1970 tansus TTacU and population totah.
r
adllai. . ibUity and accuracy prior to introduction.
.aid
a' STIPULATION UNtalT "B".
p h
A copy of
atUched hereto aa STIPULATION E»IIBIT "C".
That a _p identical a. to siu and .,.-bola and
type of inforaatlon reflected by . . ld STIPlJLATIO\'C EDlIlT
"C", abo_ de.cribed, haa been prepared reflecting .uch
information baled upon the tract I and population data
contained in the 1960 U.S. Cen.uI.
b
Sdd map .1 to 1960,
arChed her.to I' STIPULATION £X}IU1T "D".
J
24 . Tbat the population of the City of Lubbock, by
race within each Cenlul Trl'ct baled upon data reported
by the 1910 U.S. CenlUI, 11 a. reflected by inltrument
entitled" Table I 1970 CensuI, Bureau of the e."nlul",
attached hereto al STIPULATION E»I18lT "E".
-,-
-6-
.J..
·<').
Tho< ...d T.b.lo<1,• •h. . " " ' ' ' ' ' . , l y . . fl. .,
that of all S9 c.ndid.tea for all Municip.l elective
podtion. frOlll .nd including the April 1970 Gener.l Election
to thLa d.te, Sl or 86.441 have been white, 5 or 8.4n h.ve
been identifiable Bl;;;-.nd 3 or 5.081 h.ve beenl;"ntLfi.ble
Ke.ic.n-Americ.na.
That the population of the City of Lubbock, by
yael! within voting precincts baud upon data reported by
the 1970 U.S. Cen.us, 11 . . reflected by lnttrUlllll!nt entitled
"Table t l 1970" atUched hereto a. STIPULATION UtilltT
~.
"r'.
That there h .. been prepared. map reflecting
visually the precinct voting breakdown fro. the 1l1l1D'tdlauly prlor Exhibit ••howing precinct nuabera and boun.u.rl••.
S.ld _p is attached . . STIPULATION EXHIIIT "C:' - fbe
''Heavier'' or "bolder" torab reflected on •• 1d _p i_el1.tely
adjacent to the "ch:eh:d" precinct nUlllber. 11 the populations
by total and race for that precinct. Said rotall are ahown
in the same orde~ as the breakdown of total city population
and by races appearing on the upper left hand corner of •• id
bhlbY·
~7.
That the results of .11 lener_l and
T'\,R\
off etectLon.
held vithin the City of Lubbock, Tex•• , vith note• •hown by
precinct •• well •• by tot. 1 by candid.te by po.ition,
.t.tting with the ye.r 1970, down to date of thi. tri.l, .re
e' reflected by in.tr\Jlllent. attached her.to .a STIPULATION
EXHIaIT "H".
/
VU.
tha
Th.t bued u~,..t~,~~t i.nfo~t\g!!...vaU.bIe to
_ Idantifi.ble alack or
~there hadA~' . . a._
MIIlxican-A!De'rLca:t canHd.te for the oft'ice of Mayor or podtion
on tha City Council (or City COIIlIIIi. . ion •• pravioudy
dedcn ated ) prior to the General Election of April 21, 1910.
h.
Lnfo~tion
That baaad up«! the but
available to
Xe ~heY have caused to be written upon the tabulation
aheeu aum.Ltted . . STIPUlAnON EXHIBIT "H", a h.ndwritten
not.tion •• to the r.c. of ••ch identifi.ble .inority
c.ndid.te. E.ch Bl.ck candid.te htlll been indic.tad by the
.)'IIIbol "8" and each Ma.ic.n-.....ric.n c.ndid.te by the .,-.01
"'H-A".
~l.
Th.t of the laat two electiona held for Municip.l
elective poaition•• of r.he 19 toul candidar.e. 2 or 10.$31
have been identifi.ble Black. and 2 or 10.531 have ~
i/tifiable Ku.ican-..... rLc.n•.
vJ:I!-
32. Th.t _pI .howing precinct linu followed in all
election. covered by tabulation .heet. 'ublllitted, ••
STIPULATION EXHIBIT "H", above, .re att.ached hereto ••
STIPULAnON EXHIBIT "I". The General or Ru., Off Election.
1'1{held during the effective life of e.ch .uch precinct \Up
i. written upon the face of e.ch auch pr.cinct _p .
.I;;: rr
r
r/
,
33. That a a . t of an citizenll who have held office
.a M.yor of the City of Lubbock, Teltal, frolll Aprll 1909,
through d.te of trial of thi. cau.e La .ttached hereto ••
STIPULATION EXHIIIT "J".
~.
That none of the citizen• •erving •• Mayor on the
Exhibit . . .di.tely above de,cdbed, La identifiable a' •
llleIlbar of aithar .inority group involved in thLa cauae.
/35.
That, liat of ,11 citizen. holding oifice . . a
. ..bar of the City Co~cl1 (or City eo-i .. ion AI previou,ly
deaian-ted), froa 1910 through the tera.ll e ..piring in 1980,
ia .tt.ched ....r.to a' SnpUlATIOtl EXHIBIT "1(".
1
36 . That none of the cithene serving on the City
Council (or City COIIni.. ion) on the Exhibit i_diately
abow deacribed La identifiable all a melllber of ei~her
alnority group involved in thLa cause.
.,.
-7-
~. The City of Lubbock, Te..as. is currently a "hOlllerule" IIlUniclpal corporation org.nbed punwmt to the provlaion.
of Te... Rev. Civ. Stat. Ann. art •. 1165-1182. It va.
originally organhed ...nder the general 1a..a of the State of
Te.... in the year 1909.
\..a(
The origin31 Charter of the City of Lubbock v ••
.dopted by the City of Lubbock Decelllber 27, 1917. A copy of
the original Charter •• adopted on .uch date is att.ched
hereto a. STlPUUTIO!t EXHII17 "L".
V
9 . TrOll'l the original Charter and AIIlendlllenu introduced,
it is apparent that the Charter of the City of Lubbock
origind1y provided for. "eo...i .. lon·Han.ger" fora of
govern_nt con.luing of • _YQr .lind four c_laaioners.
All \lere elected "at large".
...6.
The Charter of the City of Lubbock va' _nded in
the year 1961, to provide a terg. of office of tWO year. for
:~~~~r :n:o;yt:~t~~ ~e~tf~'J~~:,!{\~:rr~::~lof
a.ld election la att.ched hereto •• STIPUUTIOM EXHIBIT
"H"
~
/
44. The Kayor .nd City Council decide pollcy _tten (or
the City of Lubbock, by .. majority vote. All, inel...ding the
Kayor is entitled to ca.t ':JI\e vou each on .II que.tion•.
Any three () me_era con.tit...
a quorUlll, and a _jority
vote by the quorum is required for any _ ..ure to p.", except where by atatutory or charter provision a greater vote
.t.ndard is required.
te.
~.
o~:~ than
The Hayor of the City of Lubbock hu offield duties
voting on poUcy IUtter. involving cere_nlal
function, and
duties of 'ubUance conferred by other
statute,;
~6.
.a.e
:5rt'(IF'\Jt<!.J; (G~
All elected City Offiei.ts of the City of Lubbock
h.ve been e~d in ".t-hrge" election. from the br.ginning
of the City-~ the pre.ent ti......
/
47. The deslgn~on of Council~n lIS "Phce No.
"etc.,
r.bu.!
'~atoricd conside~it,~~rr,1j • nov
nothing _rIO than a _thod of keeping the po,ition, .ep.rate
by na. and haa no geographical or priority significance,
other than that the _mbera of tbe Council .erving in "Place
110. I" a.rve. a. Kayor "Pro Te.pore" during telllporary
.bk0ancaof the Kayor.
The Charter of the City of Lubbock v .. _nded in
the year 1964, to provide for run-off election. in the event
th.t no candidJl.te for .n office received. _Jority of the
vote. A copy of ordinance c.nva.. ing the re ....lt. of eald
ch~rt7 election la attached hereto a. STtPUUTION EXHIBIT "Moo.
~2.
The Charter of the City of Lubbock va. _nded in
the year 1967 to change lIl\l1\icipal election. to the Wlnth of
April in even nUlllbered yean. A copy of the ordinance
canva.sing the re ....lu of .aid charter _n.-ent la aU.ched hereto a' STIPUUTIOM EXHIBIT "0".
43. Unde the "Council-Hanager" form provi~ by the
relit O\a er, the Kayor and the Cig Counc1'tA provide pollcy
gui nee, nd execution of policY~AProVided on. dJly-today b
by t.he City Hanager. "'0 City Han.ger is allo
given a
e~loJ'lSl'nt re.pon.ibilitle. vith the exception of
c..' .in de rt_nt he.d. to be selected by the Co..-acil a • •
~p.
-.-
a. A copy of the current ch«rter of the City of Lubbock
T. aa, i , attached Mreto a. STIPUUTIOM EXHIBIT "P". Sa.1d '
Exhibit con.hting of a bound pattplet vith hhtorical c~nt.
vith aU _nd_ntt through November 7. 1961. vith all ....nd_nt. aince .uch tt_ attached ina.1de the front cover thereof.
1Je'/''1+~EE~~~~~h:
the pr arat
.
tM C:J:o
the drt.te'of the original
A copy of .aid ori~ina1 draft and t tt cover letter
of tran.mittal is attached hereto .. STIPUUTION E),;!IBIT "Q".
•.'[;?f
,,-----
(bj
(oj
eacz
~.
p..f'*e . . of
to
~.
_
No challenge 11 rabed by any puty to n.1l require-.ntl lilted lllDedlately above. They are not genune [0 any
i.lue in ehb ca.e .inCIi they cast no special burden upon
61
? Ue
•
II avail
y 0
oS • candidate 11 publicize
on
-t"M _di•.
C't)~...
pp
t
CliMe",
.ny repAid
::)~~ d
ballot and the
y t II City prior
u
msrtr"ierf
t
the minorities hereinvolved.
;::ff-~ ha.
I
~
~ ni~,.,.cI,.ri1a~. )P"t1jke~
Mtropol1fan citin,
or8~rz.[tons·vl~ de:chive lc.n-al'iJi'te
no ...ochtlon. or
,eheftoR pl'Oce... contrgl..;
V
51+. ~ are ...oeiat.10ns o~o
anh;ationa whOle endone_nc'.n' finan..s:J1r\ . . . btane in viduaL cand16atea
.uba uently aeek:" !hire also edU In[O~bM. or
I up' of eithen., usually with II
•• interest.
frequent}y~nLtjng b0ind a candidate.
ThCle include 1Il1nority
c~u.lne
group .Mehtionl.
l/
copy of aever.1 for.a of reque.t to phce na_
on City office election ballot u.ed in recent year. ~re
attached hereto . . STIPULATION EXHlBIT "R".
~6_
Positions on the ballot itself are deter-1ned by •
"pun' chance" drawing held after the end of the period to
request a phce on the baUot. held in the presence of aU
candidates or their deaisnsted repnesentatives and open to
the p,reols and the public.
1
V~
,,'.-Me
t"'''("i'~
~
I'.
,..1.....
v'e
d."~l",d 'h'~
V<:,
Th" be" •• ,ouid b.
by
~ to thb caulll and thelr attorna,s. 1968",11 the
fir.t year in which ;m identifbble Black or Heltican·Alllerican
candidate ran for a place on tM Board of Trustee. for the
LubboJk Independent School Obtrict .
5'''''''' "I
./..
~
i
r.~
v<-<----r-J
~~'"
-~.t:n~
j
70.
That the
~.'Ult.
That map att-ached hereto II STIPULATION EXHIBIT "V".
renecu by .olid color dot, the approllimate place of
reaidence of every Mayor or IIIII!mber of the City Council aince
April 1970. Where an elected official held different
po.Ltion. or .erved more than one terll, he or .he 11 .till
repre.ented by only one .olid dot for an .uch service.
Where an elected official .,ved ra.idence. during their
tara or tenu of office. they are indicated by two dou
colored only on one-half t.he dot .urface.
of all regular and run off alactloaa
held by tbe Lubbock Independent Sehool Dhtrit:t. vith VOU.
shown by precinct (or voting box) . . _11 . . by total by
candidate by position, surting vith the year 1968 down to
date of trial. ar. a. raflected by instrument attached
hn.t~. STlPUU,TIOif lXHUIT
~. ~. based upon
be, "$.
74. That a. renecud by .aid Tabulation .heet.~ one
identifiable KeltLcan-Alllerican and one ident-inable Black were
elected
'
&1
~he Board of
T'ru.Ue. of the Lubbock Independent School ')htrtcL
~"-
'>y".
info~tion
the beat
avanable to
thc ..-.... A,ttey have cau.ad to be written upon ths tabulation
sheet. lubll1.tud on STIPlJU,TION EXHIBIT "r' •• handwritten
notation a. to the rac' of ••ch identifiable ainority candidau. Each Black candidate hal been indicaud by the a)'1'bol
"B" and each Hellican-~rican candidate by the a~ol ''H-A''.
~2.
That _p' .howina precinct or votina bolt line.
followed in all electionacovered by tabulation .heeU .ubaUtted a. STIPUUTION EXHIBIT "T". above, are attached hereto
a' STIPULATION EXHIBIT "U". The regular or run off election.
held durin! t.he affectLve life of each .uch precinct _p b
writ.ten upon the face of each .uch pred.nct _po
-14-
the
P:~~(:~;: ::u::u:~d~h::~e::~:::e~:,t~;6~n:~~r:~eof
flnt year in whieh an identifi.llble B1.llek or Kexican·AIIleriean
eandidate ran for a place on the Board of TTultees for the
Lubboek Independent Sehool Diltrict.
74. Th.t a. reflected by .aid Tabulation sheetl both one
identifiable Kellican-AIIleriean and one identifiable Blae'" _re
elected and lerved (or iI Itll1 serving) on the Board of
Trustees of the Lubbock Independent Sehool DlItriet.
7S. That a c:1ear plastie overlay, refleeting by aoUd
color dot, the aPrrollh.ate place of resldenee of every Kayor or
IIlRlber of the City Councl1 stnee Aprll 1970, hal been prepared
and ia adopted herein as STIP1JlJ,TION EXHIBIT "V". Where an
elected offiei.l held different podtiona or sarved more than ona
tem, he or she ia 1It111 represented by only one blaek solid dot
for all such service. "'here an eleeted offieid 1IOved reaideneal
during their tem or teml of offiee, thay ara indicated by two
yellow dots. One member of the City Council having four reaidenees
during her period of Scrvi<:e 11 indieated by four blue data.
Thil overlay also reflecta the boundarie. of tl-e City of i.ubboek,
and 11 ahed to fit over -.ap desisoated STIP1JlJ,TIC:t1 ElOtIBIT"C".
For con~nience there 11 attaehed to theae Stipulationa a _p
repralentinR in smaller scale the .aDe reaidence loeation contain·
ed on the overlay. Thil IILBp .lao lista the ellaet .ddreaaea and
names of thl! officiala involved and also reflact' flppro:d_te
loeation by slightly different symbola than used on the overlay.
Both thil up and the overlay together or separately ahflll be
STlPUU.TIO~ EXHIBIT "V".
./
76. The partiea through these Stipulations have adopted
and aceepted generally for the purpose of thia trial that the
1970 Cenaus r",flecta the MexiCfln·A::Ieriean population and percentage in the City of Lubbock, at 23,010 (lS.43t,). In eandor.
the Court ill infonaed that this La an "eat i_ted" figure only
ainee tha Censul reports do not "count" Hexiean-AIIlericans as
such. The 23,010 (lS.43t,) figure hu been llelected since even
though an estb.ate, it had been lub:::titted to and aceepted b)'
the United Statea Departaletlt of Justiee in . . ttera relating to
the "Voting Righta Aet". In faet, Me:dean·Amerle.ns are counted
a. "white" under tha u.S. Cenau.. It is onl)' by resort to nonconeluslve designfltions .ueh as "Perlons of Spanish language",
"other peraon. of Spanilh .urname", or "per.ons of SpanLah
.cth4!r tongue" that even elti_us m.y be lIUlde. The "Spflniah",
deaignation. noted, of course, would indude virtually all
Mexican-American. but would aa well indude those whose parentage
tracea back to any of the ....ny other Spanilh .peaking areas of the
world other than Mexico. The lS.437; figure h accepted by all
partie. for the purpo.e of trial as a reaaonflble e.tilllate of the
.ize of the He:dcan-Amcriean d . n in 1970.
~.
That the U.S. Cenaus t.bulationa for the City of Lubboek
for the years 1920, 1930, 1940, 19;0. 1960 and 1970, are .ttaehed
hereto . . STIPlJU..TlOH ElOtI!lIT ''W''.
~.
Stipu1a~10ns
Th.t a. noted on
to this point the 1970
Cen.ua r.flected frOlS a City of Lubbock population, a. lito 190
White (76.Sn), .!Q...lli Blaek (7.327;), .!l......Q.!Q Hexfcan-ADeriefll\
(lS.It)}' and other llIinorities 989 (0.667;).
lIS9. That the partiea s t i : . : e and agree thflt while there
1. no definiti~ evidence as to eurrent populstton of the City
of Lubboek or Lubboc:.k County, that updated population (:Stilllnea
by the Bu...elllU of Cenaus IIInd the Texas EmploYlll£!nt Com.1Iiaaion Labor
Fo...ce aur~ya are reasonably perauaalvc aa to popu!o1tion growth
and eh.nge .1nce 1910 for Lubbock County And should therol':fo be
.u~tted for eon.ide.... t ion by the Court
p
0 0 . That the Lubbock County estimates os to population in
total .nd by race, thl': Isbor force and thol': number thereof oI':lIIfloyed
or une.ployed are aa refleeted by ,exas Elrployment Commission
ccxaputer read-out .ttached hereto as STtPUu.TIO~ EXHIBIT "X".
-1)-
~.
flo
of STIPULATION EXHIBIT "X" in chart form is attached hereto u
STIPULATION EXHIBIT "y".
.,
1'.1 ,S
That a ...ork force presentation reflect1n, the contents
, l-
,,<- ~~f
~,JrIf'"
...112. That a Survey of Workforce of ill employees of the City
of Lubbock, Texas . •a of specified date. f'fOlll June 11, 1971,
through June 30. 1978, ill attached hereto sa STIPULATION EXHIBIT "Z",
~ ~I
,
~6.
"n~'"
STIPZTIO:::H:::T'::::'bU"~0' 'u1I."_ ~ploy... of ,h.
.
92.
~~
f17
That I.rvice .ward. pre.ented b} the City of Lubbock
for COllpleted yea'n of service. for period. of yean divisible by
the year 1977, h
.... reflected by STIPuu.TION EXHIBIT "JJ".
9]. That the IDOst current available indication of experienced
individuah aeeking employment in Lubbock County by occupational
caugod,e•• but which includea both employed .eeking beLter joba
;
a. _11 a. un....,loyed. and not including entry workers with li.ited
Job .kill., h a. reflected Texas ElIl?loyment Corrnisaion ACTIVE
FILE dated Harch 1978. and attlched hereto as STIPUUnON EXHIBIT
"n",
·h,,'/f%
94. That the .ole recently pnparedAsurvey of City of
Lubbock ...micip.I l!1Dployees by race and salary nnge. is reflected by inltrUlllent attached hereto as STJP~TION EXHIBIT "LL".
City of Lubbock. Tell:a'. by race. sex. and job category within
the uunic1pal organization fro. June 1. 1973 through June ]0,
1978'/1 reflected by STIPUUTION EXHIBIT "EE".
Vae.
..'' ,
.'
."
.
That the
~It
recently COlll.puted breakdOloll'lof the City of
employees by depart_nt and rae•• h
Lubbock.
TeJ:sA~;'110rce of
attac"J<'
tIS
STIP~TION
.
nUlllber of employeel and lmOunt. in dollarl, are attached hereto
tIS S2lJLATION EXHIBIT "II".
~5.
That a .urvey of permanent full-ti_
hirel" by
the City of Lubbock. Texal, by job category. race. and lex. fr(lll;
June ]0,1974, through June 30, 1978, is attached hereto al
employeea on such date lola. 6. S yearl. 1.110 attached al a p.. :-t
of l.IIid STIPULATION EXHIBIT "HH". ia an average for yurs of
'--Iervlce per all employees by department al of July 28 1978
1,
'.,,84. That the changes in Workforce of !!! elllployee. of the
City of Lubbock, frOlll June 1971 [0 June 1978, is u reflected by
attached STIPuu.TION EXHIBIT "B8".
That a comp8rison of the percentase by race "r new
employees hired by the City of Lubbock in the yean 1974. 1975,
1976. 1977 and 1978 ",ith the April 1978 uti_tu of population
and workforce contained in STIP~TION EXHIBIT "X". i. attacMd
hereto III STlPUUTION EXHIBIT "CC".
90. That the average length of lervice by race an, u ..
of all minority e 10 eea of the City of Lubbock. Texu. in
poaitions tIS of July 28, 1978, is as reflected by STIPULATION
EXHIBIT "HH
T e aver
ongevity in emptoyclent for all
91. That ItabUity pay (for City of Lubbock employees
after completIon of Five Yearl of conti.nuous service with the
City) diatrubutionl in 1977 by r.ce .nd sex and .howing both
L1J. That a Survey of Workforce of pet'1W,nent full-ti_
employee. of the City of Lubbock, Tex•• , a. of specified daus frOia
June 1971, through June 1978, inclusive, is attached hereto ••
STIPULATION EXHIBIT "M",
J~f 1 .
.~V!
EXHIBIT "Ff"".
~9.
That loIS of Ill\lnidpal employees (turnover) by sex and
race for the City of Lubbock, Tell:lI~, for the perlod January 1. 197B •
through June ]0. 197B, is . . reflected by STIPuu.TION EXHlIIT "CG" .
-17-
--L '?..IJ
,J.1- r";
. ,It "'/:,.7
to r j.,- fN
',4.-v-.
I . '"
~
That chart Ihowing &TOWth by perrent of the Anglo,
Held.can, Negro and other Ichool population prepared by the
Lubbock Independent School District for the school year 1943-44
through 1977-18. is attached hereto . . STIPlJu.TION EXHlIIT "!'If',
/
1i6. lhat the Lubbock Independent School District "as for
the .chool year 1970 through 1971. inlohr al d_entary Ichooh
only. on a "neighborhood" b.,b, in which the eleaaentar:y age student
attended the facility
~7.
in
the voters a. reflected by Reaolution Canvaasins the returns of
aueh election attached hereto (including tabulation sheet by precineu) as STIPuu.TION EXHIBIT "TT" -
the district in which he relided.
That for .uch reason the incrClole or decre••• in ..inority
elementary school enrollment within an elementary Ich001 boundary,
while not conclusive, ia lome evidence as to the increase OJ:: decline of minority population within the area c:overed by the specific: elementary school boundary.
104. On January IS, 1975, e charter a_ndnlent election vas
submitted to the voters of the City of Lubbock. Under such proposed 8llIendlllent (1) the Council would have been increased by 2
members to a Hayor and six councilmen, with 3 council_n residins
in geoSHlphic wards (an elected at large); (2) place a two-ten
lillit on the Kayar and ISf!IIlbers of the Council; and (3) increase
Kayor and Council salaries. All such _ndllen~were rejected by
I
. ,.. . 7'",
1
'0'
Th. '''olu<1o", "nv... 'n• •
d.d"'n. <h. mu1<o
of all bond election. (general obu;;:n and revenue) held since
January I, 1970, in the City of LtboCk, including tabulation
sheet. reflecting votea by precl,Pcu for each election, are attach-
~-".
LJ9.
",.
That a study prepared by the Lubbock Independent School
DistTic:t entitled "Student Enrolllllent by Ethnic Cl"Oup-By ea.pus
1954-55
1977-78" and dated Oct. 1977, is attached hereto as
~
r
STIPtJU.TIOH EXHIBIT "00".
lJ'60.
1bat a chaTt entitled Enlaated Population DispeTsal
~'1. :~:-::eB::::l::tl~:~:::sE~::n~~~~:~:.'.;~~;n~~"b::d
"00" as compared with is attached hereto as STIPtJU.TIOft EJ.:HIBIT "PP".
J.
t·
~l.
Elementary School bo=dariea for the yun 1970 through
1977, are attached hereto as STIPtJu.TIOH EXHIBIT "QQ". The school
years durinA which .ach auch boundary lIIap vas in effect is written
upon the face of each such boundary ma!\
~
list4r~tltf:;;;;:flnd/or
102. That a
active appointive
boards, cOIlrIinions or cOlmli~tees of the City of Lubbock. Texas,
re£1ecting the nUtllber of lllItlSben of each such group, and the racial
composition of each such group singularly and in total by maber
,IT,d percentage, is att.ched hereto .s STIPtJU.TION EXHIBIT "U".
-19-
14....-
1
(
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE NORTHERN
DISTRICT OF TEXAS
LUBBOCK DIVISION
A. GENE GAINES. et al .•
)
)
)
)
)
Plaintiffs
vs.
) CIVIL ACTION NO. CA-S-76-34
)
)
)
)
THE CITY OF LUBBOCK. et al .•
Defendants
ORDER
In response to the motion of the Plaintiffs filed May 6. 1977.
and the stipulations of the parties filed subsequently. the Court
has determined that the above case is to be maintained as a class
action under the provisions of Rule 23(b)(2). Federal Rules of
Civil Procedure.
The primary classes consist of the black population of the
City of Lubbock. Texas. and the Mexican American or Spanish Surnamed
population of the City of Lubbock. Texas.
Together. these groups
constitute a larger. secondary class as to which specific orders
are not deemed necessary by the Court at this time. but fthich may
be entered later if necessary under the provisions of Rule 23(d).
Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.
It is the opinion of the Court that no notice to any members of
the classes involved is necessary at this tiffie. since this is an
action for injunctive and declaratory relief only under the
provisions of Rule 23(b)(2). Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.
and thus the notice requirements of Rule 23(c)(2) do not apply.
and since the existence of this case is generally and '-"idely known
throughout the City of Lubbock. Texas. due to media coverage of
the case. and any additional notice would be superfluous.
The Clerk will furnish a copy hereof to each attorney.
ENTERED this
,,~J: day
of June. 1977.
!iif!!!.£;A~
United States District Judge
IS nt: \r.(ITf'J) STAm DISTIllCT lXlllltT
n"R TIlE SCRlll'.R.'t
UJIIIJCIl:
Phlntirr,
Cl\'tL .len(\!{ !'lO. c'\_S-7~.)4
{'If
LlJIlOOCl,
(:T
I're<:\u.le-lllCoth.. r ...plO)'ll.... t by thesttllnl",...... toacc.. ptlnc..
ofllnd ..lll"ko... tllhc.a....
OI\'IST(I~
RI\'. ROY J(l'\'l:S,
TIltCln
S.
DtSTlUCT Of TDAS
LL
WMtMf th .. Ce.. h
11_ lialtat.lllrl.l_pe.ed by tht ell .... t or e1l"O*StUlce••
9.
"-ount invol"'edlrldr",ulUobtslnt:<l.
10.
lspert .... e... rep.atation.1d ability or the attorney••
11.
The "wtdesi ....bllity.. of th .. c.u.
12.
the ... at"r" Md ICflCth of th.. proC....Iana.l r .. VtlonshJp V'ith
th ..
1ll.. 18nl ... In th ..
",t.>o... e-entithd Md n_b<P.red ea..e .t1pu .... te WId ",ree
a.rollovs«Jl\(.. mln,t!wa.:ltUfoC"'ttom,,~ f .....
fixed 01"
ellftt.ln~etlt.
7.
8.
di~t.
the abov .. fu:tof$ ....... f"rt..hl'1" Ht fonh aJld dhC::UUN in nsinttrh .Id
bc-ift'.oucht bf nto","1'
"'pr..."'t1nll:Pu.intlfhM;lPlalntlrr-Iftt .......'"orln ....ld(t.. St:.Jlnrridc4~
C1hd v1th t.he ColIn
It
th .. cllrlclllslllrl of the tnal, but Oef.... d.anu do not.
" .....1" tMt ~11 p>ol'tlt:l ~,.. ......" th.. ri«!lt to p.....selIt funM.1" " ...iden.... <;WI tM.
aatul"lfn .. «.ury .. nd .pe-e1fically O.. rendanu do not .dldt t .... t.uonl"y.
f ..... lhouldh.,"'''1IrdMiin thhcsu, .. ,ftOfdoO..fendsnuadldt or.,re:toany
partiOllar_toJsttom..y.C..... shouldanyb<P.
.......... t Plaintiff• •nd/or Plslntlff-Inu..........or pre
TIl .. tl ... u.pendedandupen'''' ""..ount .. rNby.nonl",.forJ'lalntlffs
sttaeh..dhul'toand lneorporatedhere1n. do.... toth .. d .. u
PN"("f\t.
RespotetfulIy""baIttN •
11 in said c.U":
.ndPhlntifC_lnt ..rvmorI ....sid ...u .... r .. as ..... n"etN InEAhiblt ....•
naintlfr. .. nd Plalntl((_Int .......etlol"v1l1
li.ted.baTe.
rdl"dbftheCourtinthe
oItM • •tlpuhtl<;WIl
supple-cnul evldmee of
fllrth .. rtl ... Cllpe-ndl'd and u::p.. nH' incurred as llfthe final date llf tnd at
!tlAX c. tau.
'.O.Ilex2187
I.lIbboek, Tau 79«18
~,".EL
I2:IDBro;td"""y
L<mboc:k. Texa. 79401
Lubbocl<, Texa. 79«>9
IlOIll':RT P. IlU'lOOV
110&, "....
Sehoo!llfLav
T..
T.. ehUniv..r.ity
H. ~SO!'l
p. O. 8u«lXl
u.
lOOEilJthSt ..... et.
Lubbock, Texa. 79401
.\LIlIRT PDlJ'.%
1001 Main Stre..t, Suite 6.w
Lubback,T"u."9401
Ttle&uldeHnu and el..-enU OIln .. ld .. red by th.. Cllurt. II apJlnlpri..uto
deurwl."stlonoftheilMllunt oCattllmey.reutob.,a"",rd..d,ICInY, lnlny
part..1C1Olarta .... lnclucltth.. rollllVi.n&:
1.
11.,.. and label" required.
J.
""dty and dlfflOilty of the qu ....tllln' and lilue' pre.enteO.
•.
Skill. re"u.hluto Jl<'.rloratlle l ..pl.erriecs pI"llpotl'ly.
lASOf.ARnut
.... 'tCt' nRT.MLCH ARTIIlR
H.. tnl T_.. r, Suite 1.506
TRAVIS D. Stc.TO!f
IIIXlHS V. HdltU.
U011JtbSt ....."t
Lubbodt, TCltI. 19«11
.w«sP.1lflJ:WSTnt
JOJIl' C. as, JR •
•• O. eo. :IIOOlI
Lub1lodl;, Tu.... 794S7
',.'
------
l.lAl~ck. Tn.~s
79«>9
~
Conference with at.torneys for Plaintiff
"I'd Jim Brewster and Dcnni .. McGill re:
stipulations and exhibita
8-30-78
12/l0hr
Review Ilubmitt.ed stipulations by City
Reviewed stipulationa with Plainti!f'lIiI
IIttorney.. llnd Jim Brew.. ter and Dennis
McGill
9-12-78
~~l£.£
pret-ri"l =nferencc ....ith
at-tClrne,... re: .. tip"latiom'
1 5/10 hr
Conference with Tol' Garza.
toano Arthur. Albert perez.
reo trial rlanning and dutiell
Met- with Rev. Roy .lone..
conference with attorneylO re:
lOtiPllla.tion8
Conference with Benson.
15/10hr
9-23-78
)-28·78
Conference with attorneys ret
depo.ition.
4-26-78
Conference with attorneYIi
lI.t.tendod NAACP 1&8etin(j ... nd met
wlth prospectiVO witnclillell
C(.-nfarence with attorneys re'
Dltll~Il' ca.e • •"b.titution of
"laintiU. \fiee 't. Lip.on, and
c~n,.ol1dation w\th city IIchool
c;,u,,, and preparation of a"b.ti\'-<.Hon of plaint-ioft· .. IllOtion
Prepllred with Lane Arthur specific questions
for expert witnells
2 1/10 hr
9-30-78
Conference with Lane Arthur on testimony
questions of Dr. Orr
10-H-78
Interview with Dr. Orr with Lane Arthur
Conference on trial brief with Dan
Senllon and Lane Arthur
11-16-78
Reviewed slide preparation lind trial
strategy ....ith Torn Gllna, AlbeIt Perc;: llnd
Lane Arthur
11-17.78
Conference with Lane Arthur lind AlbertPere;: re: witnesses and are"'" of testimony
1
11-18-78
Viewed ea.t Lubbock photo arcas with lAne
Arthur. TOIIl Car;:a and photoqrapher Jim
Watkin. and prepared testimony of Jim
Watkin.
2 5/10 hr
15/10hr
Conference with lAne Arthur and Tom Garza
on areas of witne•• testilllOny. prepared
a~cifie que.tion. for witnesses, conference
~ith plaintiff'. defenae attorneys lind
Judqa Woodward for final pretrial and meetin9
reqarding trial atrateg-y with Plaintiff's
attorney,
1 5/10 hr
C("';I~~enca wjt~ attorney •• Harold
"M.:P;~I<.."I" R39. J....-..a•• and Tom
"'''f<f.o.!:>'.e- ,. ".
" . . n"old Chap....n
:ellli,-.o,.,
C')n::.:s.·,;e ~itli ':"'ne I\rthur "I'd
'1'0", Gaua roo
W~'i:ne!ili ,tate_nt.
1 5110 hr
Con(erence with Lane Arthur and Dan Benson
on order of witneslles at trilll
oepo.ltiorl of (ormer Hayor ROy
BIIo". and di.cu•• ion of stipulatio:u
with .11'" Brew.ter
2
73
Conference and work lIession with Plaintiff's
attorneys and expert witne" .. for Plaintiff
6 5/10 hr
Conference with Lane Arthur and Plaintiff'lI
ROlle Wilson, 0"... ,,<, Jonl<s. George
Conference re: budgct~ depolli.tions
and preparatiOn of sllde prepara15/10hr
tion with attorneys
>-,'
1/2
~~~e.ses,
2·25-78
~~28-78
It P..,...:
18/10hr
conference re: ROy Ba.lIs depo"ition
and 6tudy of budget and cOlMlunity
:~~e~~:~~\:~:~s with Lane Atthur 2 )/10 hr
~_5_711
H~U
Conference wi th Lline Arthur Oil wi tnes ..
list and lettera to wit.nesse..
15/10hr
Conference .... ith attorneYli re:
ROy Ba.. l1 deposition lind. voter
stud" compll<!'d by Dr. John..on
and revi.ew of expert's report
2-14-78
lnveatigated ... rricisli written by Dr.
T..ebel. defense expert witness with Lane
Arthur at Tech Library and reviewed former
te6tilllOny in Am1l.rUlo trilll of Dr.
T...ebel
15110hr
11-22-78
1 5/10 hr
Conference with Lane Arthur on witnesli
queations
Conference with witnesaes Ch.. pman. Wil"on
Rev. Jones, and worked on trial lltrateqy
with attorneya
11-10-78
Conference with Plaintiff'" attorn"ys and
expert witne.s on trial tellt-irnony
.'
I!!!!..1!!l!! Date
Senne.:!
12-10-7S
!l.... VI~N
12-11-a
Td ... l
12-12-78
~~c~:~~lo~~;~~~ ~~~~t~i~~:"~~~s~~~<ll
file for t.rial pr"('paration
6 7/10 hr
In U.S. DllILru::t court
with ."tto.nc~·OJ on trhl Ktrlllc9Y, ,l.nc\
lnten'le...· with T • .1. PllttcnlOn on te»ti1llOny
12-13-78
~!'lTr.L".IIfX50lf
Cdn... .,. ClIy of whbac:k. !to. CA_5-7f>-)<I In United Sut... Ilhtrlct
c"urt. forth.,lf.ll. oCTu.... LubbockD1villon
12
kn.,rltH_toVl.UhT"'ylor•• ny. Cor
PlaintifC ufO" joini~ <:au u ~n)'. Cor
i'laintHCl
6 SILO hr
Tnal in U.S. Distriet court
85/10hr
12-14-78
Trial in u.s. Dilotriel Court
12-1S-78
Trial in U.S. Oilltrict court
12-16-78
Conference .... ith PlIIlntiff'. attorney. on
o;rial "trate9Y al\d .. itnolls es
12-18-78
Tnal conference with attorney. and court
i-a-HI
Conference ... it.t! PlIIind!C'. attorney. re:
Prepued"l'laintHf' ....lthdnv:ll •• COUnul";
"EtItrrofl.pp.,.nnccnCounael"fol'.dC.
Ta)'lol'. t'cru&C.ra.al "Hollon frol' Contlnulnc.,"
65/l0hr
& "H_t1Indu. of La.. in Support";
ConC..l'frlUvithPlaintHf.l.C.,..... Clin........jt&rdln,( hI. vithd..._l •• e-... I. CUed -II oC
.bav.. lhtedi ... tno-..vithChtrletCl.. rlc:
and conference with Plaintiff'lI attorMY·
,.nd
P....
f1..&intlff'. "Flr.t A.nd.,d C-plltnt"
.nd "Hod .. for Cla.. Aaion D.oreno..iftltlon".
and "rhC In Support or Hotl~n for cta .. letio..
Det ....ll\&thn.· ..dlepl ........ n::h""'111of_1
witne•• telltlw:.ny
1-9-79
Conference vith ... ttorney. re:
1-10-19
Conference with Dlin &cnllon anc:!. L.1.ne
...itne••
ilecched.ftdconh ....edvithco-coun
1cncror5-9-17re:Stipuht!on
Deter.inuion;
tClltllllOny
Arthur with ,.itncll. Geor9c scott on
... itnellll testimony
1-11-79
Prepar"'tion of outline of .... itnCSli
1-15-19
Trial in U.S. DilJtrict Court
15/10hr
telitimony of Ccorqc Scott
6 SIlO hr
1on <;ourt.·.
Ch. . .ctiOft
!>-1l-17
''-''(&l'edDn.Ct ofP",po.edStiy,thtion. en CIa..
Aethn PeUnUnat!ol\l fort ....der to Chy;
S-Jl-77
Confcr""ce with Cit)' I.ttO"'~1. rc: Ch .. I.<;uon
Stipulation.; f11ed .... vith Dl.trict Clerlc,
alOrl& vith Pl"Opo.ed ord ..r on Ch,,"etlcn Dete.....
.:in.tlo"'l
.ftpar.d"Hod .... foI'C.... ti ...... nc:c".nddiaOl..ed
_ v i t h oppoat", c_.et Cor City of wbboe:lIl;
....pared ... rtcfill SuPport"l
'Ued"'Moiti .... for Contl_cc".ftd"Br1r.fIn
s..PJ'Crt"oC_vlthDhtrletCl.. rt;; MI"Cf.Irlll:
vith _ . . , 1 & owad ..., coo.o...cl en tlU",
...poattlOI'll of Cit)' PfI'llO""cI on 'riday. 7_n-77;
Cenferenc.. vlthc....n.el """JII:l,l
pnil", contillU",..,e; calC re_
Oft lI'o_bu 7. 19771
ood_rdre_
for tri.l
Conference vllh Lane'"h.ur .... utuia.l in H1e;
Trl.ll're... rad ..... mdmce, f·v!t..,nea;
ConC"renc", w1.th Wlllh Ta)'lor, L.a" .. Arth.ur ... d
..1 '~re •• co-coun.el. en wi t
r ..... J .... l.d<01ce
In CIK_ and upert. ..hn
;
Conl'lltN vllh Llo... Arthur r .. urJln .. ,Ipul._
tiona to be
.!;ht Cr_ Chy ..1 L.,~ba.:lIl.
vit"e...... eTl
ce;
1atcIl_conter.nnvl.lhLa.... "rtllur .... cY!dll\« ..dvltn""'''' to \>e wi"'" I. .. Udrt: of 1"tld..tellchy.dpulaUon.;
,.,... J
~_ll'."In.K.BD\'Sl'!ll'
(':a.l.nuv City "r Lu!'ollrck, Nil. ('A_~76-J.fl.nUnltfldSt.UI Dhtrtc:t
COUI't ror til.. If.D. or Tua., Lubbock Dhi.lon
TMU 1flS.
&
I'Npa~
and dethuN to City
l/lo MR.:
Tl)f;UIIl$.
t>'1/10HR.:
1-1.)_11
I'roJlOll~
L.. thr to Court N: .""Itln~ ....... lr.,(
S. Ct. Ii.S. Dt:ehton In "alluC.u heCore
~rial oC tllh uU;
5/10
"-t"llaroldct.t-etl .....tatu."f ca."
1/10 tu-..
=::\l~",,~:~::~t~':e;l~~~~
h....
tHf', alol.notlce. etc:.
Ree..IYf<lJl..Ba....url.l ........ .,Cl~lJ..77
N!pNln( 1411as ca..e at U.S. Sl.lp..-.. Court;
t11,cIJuedwirh co-coun... l;
1-1~1I
D..... Cudt ..xtC'fleturloh.. _ttoCaurt
....pnlinID.. U .. IC• ..,:
"itll Juclle V...dvard Ind e-toWI.rl
and.,ppo.l,-c.,l.InlrlOl\cOl\tinlJllKetoil.tt
D.Uudechio";
8-1~1I
Conhrltn«vl.thVl.llhTlylo... boIltlti.wlt~
d ... OI1I1,1I counHl.lldhrillftillt:HlII'llKaUOI\
as e""".et fo.. rat ... ifh: draCted let-tel' (or
T.,.lor', st"",u'Nto'lsint1ffCa1"u .'bout
01\ his withd ...... l . . PhilltIfCt• • tty..... dCd .....' acre• ~t to.s- and ....... Mall coallltli I.n . . 'lai....
8-18-11
1"~0
l_U-18
t
21t5/10
tHf' •• uy.
.vlo
I'reJillNG d...ft.,f lIttter to Caul"t f"rta....
""h",rt.,icn1t\lre re'.rdi ... the ,tatUl of 0.11.1.
c.a..,.~.ItU.S.S
.. p.COU"..
.M
hr.
:~~~:n' and ,....... rch
on
1" 2/).0 " ....
projlOle<! pre-tri.l
~tr{alorder;
~18-18
Work
........ rch .... l ....ppUc.lll.. toCl ... _hu.-.Mn • •f
proo(OIII'tl.toryoldhcthdMtl.en• • t . ..s.rdol
proof. Md OCInt....t1en. of parttn;
'''5/10 lin.
=:e~:':;:-"'-:;':":"i~te~:=;
~:
ape" wit"U'1
fo~rl'ltlyorofLutl"-dt.
lrtt.rto
c.... CD\MIe! en eritical ....edt"l"utelftd prep....
vl.tne''''sf"rtrial;
114-11
'''silo
lin.
1l~1_"
I'repa... tt"" "CJln.-trhl orderd...Ct;
Letttert"all-.c.ounnl ... _edf.r_inct.
rr.ll.. u ....
andour ..ecedC.,rvl.t......... f"rtri.l;
d.i.o;u .. IRlp.Ct. U.S."<Hchton tn
Meet.lAavttll _ _ ~ .... u .... pl_tnc .. d
fIan.... rtri ..l
ttOft;
pre,....
wttr-rto R..... RoyJlW'lfl.IUoACP. vttllc"ptnto
ACW ..d Lea«ue of \I_Voter•• l'i'prdllll!l critl.cal
fteed forvl.t
attridl e.....latl.... ofwtt.....
_terid to _t
otlter e.. I"""""'1
1 ~'/10 hn.
11--..,.
\Iort .. Ph-Triol Order;
11-1.."
h....
2lt5/10
b .....
f'h..trlalllrleCwrtU"':lnd ""surd!
Conf.~Ct: "hh Wlle "rthll .. and ~rIc ItaU ...
.rhf.anol ....... rchoutdwrtttn.t .........;
:':"::
....
14-5/10 lin.
Pr-Tri.l Ord.rl
Dr&lttdtrlollrirfandc...C"......ctewitIlLa....
.lrd.r ....._ :
Confe
wit
1 ~ 1,/10 1Ir••
011
~~~.~~~:f; rr.rio- ...d Lurr
1/10 hr.
1 .. 5/10 lin.
hn.
1lt5/10
~i::u~t~c~la'::o:ol~:po..:~ft~:::l.
2. & SIlo
't-tncprl.orto ....,..1tJo.. :
2 b 5/10
ColferltnC<l! vtthwneAl"tlaar. "ute 1la11 ......
Albr.rt Peru to Co o1'er'ropo.ed rre-Trhl
Ordrr.erlderlcr.t.. c.... andtrialplannl...:;
,rtelMratt .... oCd... ft"f'r"""lCd'~T.... alOnler;
cOl\ferltncevitl."-te"rtllur ... _.e'ltd ....ce ..
witne.....:
Ilepoa1ti_o(a.:.,.
witll_.el-
II....
eonfef'tllCt:w:l.thta....Al"thur.r.dTo-C.rn
:iol....Pl....,-;nt1ll (or trial ....aibbtr wit.."'.....
Crmfereac:.vl.tllt.n.....rtkur. to-CU"u.Al
I'ern. rith o.....tnl co...... l f"rCity .t
ChyHall. re: Stipulations ...dJ:xhlbttl;
s/10 hr.
~~11
.,r
lin.
eonrfrltnCl "Hh VlUls T.,.lor
'n.
Ko:etM,Il:vl.t"_ .......I.R..... I\ooyJ .......
HarolclClut-etl ... p~•• ~: 5t.u•
ca.. lcallt"Jud.'eVooolvardto
.....tuCOUrt
ol _ _ ;
"f_ ..
Co~hl'1"ltc:..
lJ_B...11
1/10 h....
"it" w..•• T."Albert en
st.tu• .,f caM. frialpla•.Mn.c1
Cood'U'rftI;..
>/1o
lrthllr
trTrial 'rid with La.... lrt ......
c.. withLanelrtkur.lldNarlcllaJ.l""·
~PC\f'II.. lilt. tri.l pl
i"";
•
1 &
Vlo lin.
(, &
1,/10 "".
,It silo
h
.
4 & 5/10
II
.
,& 5/10
lira.
.....
.....
'n.
Pa,;e4
.... RoyJone •• etu 'I. TheCityofLubbodc,etal.
~b":;~~~c:.~ u. S. Dhtriet e-n: for tlle lforthem Dirtrlet ot fUll.
~_rA~1EL".8[lCS(11
C"h,rAo:rtC~O;:~~~~r ~~I~~~D~~I~~~SU1:U Dhtrlrt
SZltnCZ OR!:lf'E'G!:
Intem.... v~~rt Davidow "" b.dI,....... d
anellt.t..lofca.e
11-21-78
11-210-18
1:z..1_18
I're-Trld <:onfere~e vl.th Jud~e Wood_rei
IlJ'ld <:o-<:OWII.,l and appodnll: <:ounle11 f\ll"t.lIer
<:onfe..-ncevl.thco-<:OW\ae1 on 1'N!!pe.,...tton'
fortrllll;
lleedns. MarkliLll'. ofn<:." dl pldntiff'l
c_f;CWlld, far trhl pbM1n~i
H«til\l;, Mark Kall'l affiee, .llu_ooWl.e1.
f .. r trho..! pbminAi further pt"epandOll••1:
offiu for trial of case: p"pe.radClift .f
In.t1,,ctiCllftIh<<ufor P hintHf t .vl.tnUM.l
11o-U-18
2"1/10
hn.
I"S/10 hn.
Woriled on vl.tnenlht .nc! u.hibltl Hit;
2"1/10
"n.
I:z..U..18
110-14-18
1:10-15-78
l:1o-1~78
1:10-18-16
'repan-tion of Trl.1H_ara",ch. on Hn4ln,.
ofF.ettn"l_:u.1'Ie!:lectton'Ylt~eaM':
.. & 1/10
r..rthervortl on
,,,,/10
2(,3/10
lftfo/lO
of 6'
further p"""'~
tl .... oftrlalafe....
and~counUl"rthur"Kall,.,.,f
.. rt""'rtrla1
1 & s/10 Ion.
tMel"'fellor",
Se-.s
wcoplu of
./10
'-oded ee.p1.a1nt
lIde copt... .r Leacue af " - " 'l'oter. n 1...
l • .u...... _.
2"1/10 Irl.
e-t.IWl.CR w/t.,lor......_
1"4/10 lan.
MMe_t.......rr..,.ofAntet.t-aen.... EaIl
Looblaodtando..aa...l ..pt~ •• vA.1bertPeru:
hum_ v/J" 1tatkln., ,rofeutond pholoIn""r,'" color .Ud•• of",",,,. 1dephCllfte
confermc:e v~ Lny Ira W. .hi"'t....
1&1/10 hn.
Teleph_ oont.rea!lU v/Mchard n.,,.h tn "'Ultin
lan.
:~~.u..~r:'":"~1:t:~..:~~I:""71:~;J,n
2&S/l.0
..11aM
~=~..:.:.~~,:~~:dtyt. flrlandal
12.10
1.10
" Pet"e..
2: b
silo
hra.
'.J<
rwlxpal"t.W1tn....
Drdtec!reqaaut for Jucllddllotleeafpriar
poll tue and o..-...tl<: Whtte Prl... ry SUt..t ....
anc!re<r...... tror'Judtebo!(otieeof~and
l..l...L!o.<:&M:.lnt.h"""l't:
l'teeti!IC vith J _.... rahall JloI _
hr••
Latte" to T'ra',h Aelton. MI. Musahrrl..
Canlyn l&ader " .....
Lawoclleoneonferea!l~vlthvltne
.. Geor'leS~t
,reparatlOlll
"U_
Z/lo
./).0
Ltttert.Ma. Mutaluri re ,le.eli",. tiled
COlIle,..,.,eelnJudc.,.~erIOlleOllti
...atlon
ofcaMl.nrOlfJ'-1'T1S.1919 1
hr ••
Inte"....o..'. Modon for
_foratty.,
Conti_tlcoooftrialafeue
fl.Jlr.la.,..rtrlal:
$19.20
'/10
Lea,.. to '-'4 Int'l'\'eftor'. "ndad ec.,l&1nt
& "-nn~ of Lev In S ..pport of _ : Inti .....
YOn.r t .Sec:ond .....dedCOll9Wntv/eopluof
Contil\WltiOll 01 trial of cue:
CoodI,..,.,<:evl.thC_. e1Ol1 preparatlOfloC
trial of calC. vitn....... rOo;:en~. . . d )epl
.uthority:
1_1:10-19
""r
ple.4ln ll:.for_-.,tpw-po• • :"".... rchOfl
It~ofblalpodtl
... :
.rid . . .tt ..... .".·.f• • :
1-11-79
Luooinatl... of Dt!politiOll' olClfySeereta.,.,
Tt"enPb11lipaandTran.it n ........rfarClty
.rLubbodl• •,...d.a ......
lAtt.. r to D.:ridov,.. trial brief: t"e.........
~~:I"t~t~-;:-~=~~~:.-~rt~-}tof
1_9-19
hr••
rw
CClifttinuatlonarlrl.lo/.calel
0lI
hra.
Ifr3/l0
Copyl", DanclovKaurl.h
and ,,,,,pant!_ of Inte",,",ort.
NodOfl
Leue to '-01 Int"'l"'O'..or'•
Aamd.ed e-p.1.&1ftt v,A:lrder: "-oran"- of
Lt." In Support of Interneor'. Motton for
Laa.e to ""-rId tnte.~orl• ......."e4 ee.,Wnt.
lle,tNlin,eftria1afca ... :
e-teren« vl.tla ea-e-Hl
./).0
ConfeNnee ../Dan DenlOn
ae...a.rcll
COI'llI ..... ationoftrla1ofClM:
1:z..1~18
Jfts/lo hr..
Conferrn<:e II!Judlte Woodwlt.rd re COfttlmaance
re-.et rorllol'. 7. 1977.
eau
•• S/lJ>
....
4.17
old Io-J - . . . e r fU... re 1923 o""""",ee:
. .H&rda .....le. Ua. cue: e-ae1 v/IIM
. .,_reca. . . .tipalatt"'.f... C1tyiCcantaclCett.ftl1. . . . .rtvltM-.. :I't.Sov.ier ....
,.Ut1cU . . . - " 1ft Lubbodl. Froy Sdilln ....
-,
46S/l0
.....
$!m'XCI: Olll1l'tSS£
UI-4-77
$ZIMlZ OR f:In'ISE
~r'~~:"~~:~~/Il~t~~~r~: ~r;I~C~. znl
Dtrec:tor.w/l4vUlittrn.eDCoonll.lI.tor;
Td..phonc Q.1J.toCou",U. polltble upenoritllcsa:I:.:\_IIMCD_teri.hft
fc<1.. ral-.ncy lpent in Kc:tiona of ell,.,
c:on(ermc:e ../ilos.WUson", witne.....
Illumew w,Alarold Cl\at-. ft A.Hrd Cavtel
rc H.dr;orint..... ; Met vl5u.te Ikpreletltlth •• rroy~.;v/Dan8eftaonre.tipuhtlon.: I1diy.... d a.-r to Ji. 8~ur;
ulel'hone to Dr. CMndlerD.rld..n. polilbl.
"pen witn... : v~1 Peru re Cbl_ 111&11
ot QU; w/C D CoonUnator. Darid litten,
prepa.re4c:cph.ofe-pl.alntftA.na-ra.
e-nJ.ty Ile.... l~t 8udceu 6' bpeoIdlu.re••
e-.nlty Ileyelo~t Keton far
.tt,.•.
10-7_77
2-15-78
2 (,1/10
i~1:;"",4 ~rrl~.,:...~~~~a:.i~"H;:::~
1~18..71
~~~r:; ~~~b~J~·~~=s;;;treUl:n~·~}
hr ••
7 ft 4/10 hN.
•M
Tehph......./I4rldlcnefHou.t..... ;
10-17-77
hN.
".n
_lItiooin~:1o:ttertoJud&ere.UUl.
1~~71
a/lo
of 1laUu.
Obt.a1.. ed.~ldhtrie:tele"t1mreeonl.
forc:c.pariaon ../c1l,..hetion., ",nffrrel1
v/Or. Jol'ft.... reatlaly.h.
1 fr 5/1.0
"',.
"'.
"'..
Tele"- to Dr. lami& re caM
Pretri.l 1;ClI\t'II'~Tlc:e
1..17..78
1_1"'18
1_~11!1
v/.n,.•.
re rtlpala.t1on.
Conht'ftlt'lC vlt_ C&r5I. Nan: Hall, Albert
'eres re trial pluuU", .. dud ... ruearch;
......archLubbodlA..... reatat_taotCity
o(flc:i.la;breald..tpl"Ol..... tn.dlool.;
draft ot stip.ilatlo... ;
A.tt,.. Conferenu re 1lrUla.. caM. (:OlIrid.ered
....
sIlo
Ift5/J.O
l_U-18
LctterloJudp IIoodward w/ooph. tar
.ny•• recaM.
1 .. 1/10
1-14-18
1-1"'18
2113/10
hN.
s/1o
hrl.
1&5/).0 hrl.
$ 12.00
lee:tedpbotollldu;.tt".",nferelc:e;prepared , " ' . rele.H, .nulled fir. J.Kln'.
.....h.tton ot J.abboo:k dec:tton ••
6 & 1/10
$11.90
bterrlew wjbr. Orr
2621\0
hN.
Ifr9/).0
hN.
)6's/1o
"'..
1 & 5/10
'N.
""pari,,, Dr. Orr'. Vit"... St.at-"
*de .".,in~t vltb Cbannd 28 to Tiew
tUa.rCltyflultbdireetor; Tie,," fit.
w~; ......,....
c:.lfer-tt: ..I
.U".,
Ien_.
:-;::r:~";;'u~a.:~rW.~"~t~:::d
Ma1dn&
eopt., of Voter St1ldy tel' Leape
....JlP'iIlIlIlt.•••tat-.t•• OOIIt'errlq
tdtll Jtuootd Clw.uan roe u.~y:
"'1..18
Interrl....../r_Bunh.Vt<:ePre.ldentof
MACP roe ee.pla!1lt. to City; ..de ClOPl... ot'
dtM. . .tat-..t"
IJ.-S-1I
'...,.n.llIdt. . . . .t.teeeftt.../copi •• (er
.tty,.
Ifrl/10
wJ\la.U ftCaru re vllne. . .llte_
IlIM:t"re ..eerlo(.ll
Idler n.at_u 1.n 2 ......
1 (, 5/).0 hN •
"'t-18
•M
hN •
1ft
~~::~~~:.e-~.:~ ~b:e~~~
1-2&-11
'.a>
1&8/10
"'..
T.bpboneeonfet'altt: ../Or.Orl'.Clt,....caunty
Garsa, Peres &
....
"'..
h,.
~~t.:;:~t~c::~:.J::~~c::~on
l.a>
) 6' 3/l0 bN.
1"
:=::t~~~~oo;~:t:~~~
"ttend.d!&4ct ....tl lllrevlt1\.....
6-28-18
- r _ c e v/loc:al paper. TV" ltadio
n.ad..... "n.atll.of ca...
Conf.rred ..latty•• "' .dp.ilatlona
Letlu to Dr. JolrI_ reyot.en studt·
6-17-78
hN.
"'.
Depo_ torwer HaJOl'. 8.... Uld dhar.Md
.tlpul.tion. w/brewster
1..1t-18
Metv/lleY.lloyJ_1
~1~71!1
e-t.rmu wI.tt,.l, doole Illd.. to ~ llIed
htriaJ, eont.rtcdJtey.RoyJ ..... renw"'
bi.J'WnUtf-ln_ch1.e(; Brewlterre.c:hedulin(
d.epoa:lUcn. ~d .U,..atlcnl.
1 .. 8/10 hN.
1-24-11!1
Conferred ../.tty•• re Ball Deposition &
yOter.t\Idyoo-piledt17 Or. John_for
Dpf!rt U.u-,.f copies of upert t'Cport.
4-216-18
1ft 5/10
Coph.of.teriaJ.
1..JI_78
DhC:Ulledd.po.itiOft•• pboto.1t.. tor
trial V~I.rU IlIIdPe"'"
~pre-trialordet'pnJ*J'tion.
~ U.S. S"pre. Court dec:iricn.
~~;:'~c;t=.~~~~t~~t~ri
....al
no. <:aM out
4-5-78
7..1)..18
.. &
IftS/J.O
w/.tty•• ft depo.lU_
4-U..78
14.10
photo&rapherfol'c:olorpholo.for.Udepre-
of <:aM: c:opiesof.t.rial.;
Co.!f'eZWIU re Iludcch. c1epolitlonl&
prepa.raUon of ,Ude)ll"umtauon wIatt,.••
e-te~e
•
2.50
• ....
"rl.
e.t.rn:d
-UofClw.~ ..
....
;....16-78
....
mtYIa:(\n~
::~~~~ ~ ~i ..:~~~r::;:B~~e~t~il
na Brevster lfC1tyAttol'ftll!'J' "' nlpu1&-
tlonl:_lwJt;U'"'UlU'ldlknllOflonpbns
Corprepandon of trial and p......n .. report: .,/beatmlU,.by, Corwer dtyCCM\cllun, .. plltential vitn.lI.
P'rej:*re4lpedrlcquutionl (org..
pert wit"...;
10-17-18
'/10
.....
.....
silo
h~.
Jfts/lo
~.
HetvithlAic1anohrel,llRCdhoeC1:or:
Ifln1l.cd ...~ Hall on tutt-,. 'Iuud . .
otDr.Orr;
sIlo
¥ortted on .dpulatlon.lUt.l.tted to WI
CitJ',lthru7S;TelephorwtoUl"'rt
vitnell,o;:qpl.rdvitnu.lt.teaetlt.
....
• ....
bJ
•
10-1l-18
Inurriewd Dr. OfT nth Ht.tk Hall
11. .18
IIorlled on trial brid with Ilran
11-3-78
IllhrrillW4 Major 'bee Hicucd, Sod&!
.lrtl .. Or!lce:rlt ...... , _l1r;ed an. trial
briefw.AJen_ftKallI
City "'--"" hIatt on. e-d,.s1on
¥OrtEN on .tipolldon.16 thra 105; Mo:t
w/hn_, C....... ftHallllld ..jDet••tty....
'",""ter&McCill anJru<.Md teftt.Un
I,Jre-..t on nlpul.tion. ft ~bltl 1 thN
105.
lfts/lO
Sfts/lo
Inutipted.rttclnvri.tteftbt Dr • T1II'bel,
n.et.Ui'II'rtw1.tne....,.,....rtEKall.tTedl~n
Ub,....,.: telephone o:all. uArllrctontr
Iryan. Teu.l
....
!l<tad 'lahtUf' .. ape" vltnu.' tuti...,. I"
upert
.l.aarillotrlal. nllnt1tf to ....._
...
Fl.orther ..tudy of
.....rillotrlal.
-1S-18
H.de topin of Or. T.ebel'. tntt-lJ'; aaaiMd
propo.ed p~t'l1.al order ..I.tty.,
flall,
6' 'eru; _ t ner proposed ord.r brietly ..I
lrewt.r: V!'Ote opert vitM•• re our upc:a.i,.;
".UII&._t tophi ot n.et. espe:rt vltnell In
....rill.ca•• ;
uplrt
• ....
....
vltlltu u.ti-my In
ht_.
lftS/lO
-19-18
'repal"edl.tuntopo..lblevit..... N.
_~78
,,",..red hthrat.po..Sklevlt"IN.; PI"O,.........TrlalOrdtr
VortEld vlth other 'lal"tUt .tto""",. and our
upert witne. . .t Tecbla...dlool.
h~.
.....
Vol"ked,,""l11 Mall on vltroeull.t and c__ 1n
leturatovltnn.n;
J 6'
1/10
Vol1led_cue;
Vol1led w/h.._ ft Dnid_ on trial brief;
Net wtth JudeII' ~
4ftS/lO
U-l~18
Vol1led _ trial briet ../Ie.on .. Kall;
wner to a:rev.ter "' mUdt.1 talked to
Lud._o'wes .. 'ht_Mende.1
9 ft.vl.o
h~.
11-1S-1'
Met...,.ilal.l ..... _ _ order01 witne..u
.t trial, ... bpoma U.t; wort:ed _ trial
brld',.u.oopluottriaIbrtef;
8ft2/l0
h~.
$ 19.00
11-16-18
Veot OYer allde prueot.tJ.on ft trial
.tl'lteo w.m..u. Carn .. 'eru. rUed
trial brief wAurt. de1hered Qloples to
Def.eo-l,lrewaterftHcCl11;
.....
S
11_11_18
Conferred ..Ikall" 'ern re witn.... (,
U'ft. of teltt-"l prepe.red lettera to
wttnesM •
6 6' lAo
h~.
'/10
~.
.....
'.23
S 10.25
]]-18-18
tu.lMd pilot. area. with Hall, C.ru ."d
pt!9to".,her,Jl.a llatkiu l
2.IIS/l0
11-»'18
, "..red vltll... letter.
1111/10
11_2.1_78
Voned w"lall .. 0..... on .re.. of vit"e..
h~.
•
1.80
:'-::~i:'~t::~t::~~f~~":tr:r
$U.J8
• ....
1"
11-9-78
./10
~.
_1~18
.....
aen-
11_U_18
S.62
ContiNle4vol'l< on .til"'l.d .... IKl•• l-1S;
Jnurri~Ladatlo'eres.d1l"tlctc:rf:l
h~.
'/10
lo-~78
1 It
.....
1 ft1/10
~~:~::~":t~~~in~:-~~H'
lo-l~7'
Statu.confereleevflt,.rk!l&ll. copies
of repo"";
-1~18
!J-26-18
Kall ..,ltltyltty•• Jl.arevtt..rallollllennls
Kd:1U ..... upal.tlonl. _",• •p.,_nority
~'" popu.lat:lan.. ,.oter p~d,"et•• CllIa"1
OC!llcemed;
l..11_18
"""'"
done wft(.11r; Kall vitti
"'tauHI, 1101. V1bon, o.cuo Jonn
and Oeo,.e Scott.
eo.terred
ConferN1d .../lIm.on, Caru.. fr Peres at City
t ....rt •• etc. ~paredlett"'"toCltyre
Plaintiffs & Plaintiff btenmor be Idf,ntlfled In ItJpulaUOlU, ..alled«lfllu to aU
....31_18
S!RYIC23 011 I:ll'E'eI
lJ-25-7'
eo_tyShat'-", MadhOlllowder; telephone
"/OlIpIIrt tdt"eN; Het with other
'*".l"ftIOil
=tt:r~r:r '=:~1:. c:::~wc:~
TrlI.1 ttl'lt..,. v,htiJ.ntUf .tty••
ll-D-18
pre.......
$14.65
1l-%7-T8
6trS/10
Vcwtc.iwitklall.wittl".qlHl'uOOI.;
·-'-"1
h~.
eo,t.........; ...l1ledon"'bpoena.and
IOOlItacud witlte'N., Utord Caudell. Harold
6" silo br••
c._,
kott;
An. Joaell, J _ Bhtn. . .d Ceorce
~.
$ 10.Xl
....
17... 4-18
Worited on .ubpo~"as &nd fl"dine' of het
and crnd.ullion.o( 11..
hr••
VorilMOft:fU\)poftIuan<ifl"di",.;>(het
&ndconclu,lon, ..( h..;
hr••
I'rej)l.red and ftl..d fl"allflt""., llstand
esh1btt Hltl Hadeco.,in "f Wltneu Lht.
~rt', Report. ExhlblU" OnU"M1CC';
.5" S/).O hrs.
H.>.J.. e('lptnof'h.i"tiff',b.hl.biti4
$
I'f'lPpl.rrdVlt ....., <:Uution•• 1f!u.. r to Ju..tge
Woodv.lrd. Plaintiffs' and i'ldnti(( InUrTmor',
SuppH~tal List of IIltnuae'l lOade Q)pie. rJf
-,
......
l"t .. rvi"vedChat...' ".R.Wil.on.!tey.Jon....
and CfO...." Seott; trial Itnt~".
br••
Studifd upert vater ~ltation report;
dpl<;kedupexpertwitne.... Dr. J0h8_.
at al~rt; _rbd ../attt,. Ir Uilert on trial.
4
TriiIJ. in U. S. Dhtnet e-rt
6"7/).0 •••
_t ...
I'ntrial .eetiJl« "Mtneuu; trUl ia U.S.
Dhtrl.etCc!ul"tlni,ht_ritseut.ontrial
• tnt ..",,;
10" silo lln•
6"
silo
......
~~"~~,Ui.~: :~~~ ~ ':~l-Unc
8" S/).O
,".
U-U-18
Trial iI.U.S.Dhtnc:tCola't.
6" .5/).0
1~1i-78
CoGferenc:e
,,)lIm_. Rall. Pens ~d C.ru
and
ero..
...m...tlonofdefetlsevibltl...UI
~r••
......
.....
CIIltrialstnt"",.~
.. rltlltl ....
• ".and fir trial ..,r..f'ftIc:e h
4.-40
!In.
Trial 1ft U. S. DiUrlet Court;
1~1""1!1
$ 88.00
J~ell
mal ...ti-e4 _til l-lS-79;
-rena« wit" .ttomcyw follovl", _ _..e_tofeGllU_cel
Conhrmeevf8.,n.on. HalllrGaru
hr.
~~~~t~_wl~'"~:c:,.1:":::t~
~::Ct_
-rrJf'rvySalilll•• Shteraq;b••• frMlrt.
IWrcado;
"_rd
Prepared MnoonlIdI. of t.v on
of
"tty. It...; ae.... rdtoMeo..tydKdon nouno. v/stty. Albert I'e""l
J" 2/10
7 .. 5/10
......
....partnc li.U of CoImtr eo-l ..tonera
Ileetlon.
vI MillOrtty
c...dtdatet;
1fr2/10
1-1~79
Iaurt1.noedJ_.MlMlhlllvftla"left_
1&'/10
1-1~79
t"un1~Mlrt'""l"CIdoof" ..htll.(ton.Il.C ••
and Silter lleai"" 'opte. vir.......... v/.ttys.
's"- .ft" G'"-Il
4 fr '/).0
......
...
1-14-1'
~:"rir:rt~r:..::~:: ':.r:: :"~;:arJfon"~U:'~:;tll
1-1~7'
TrtallnU.S. Diuricc Court;
hn.
66'7/).Ohrl.
Sl.20
...
"Th'lI
l/1f>/79
~ .._ C!t
N
"h
Iv lIubrn l'_
FIIetll.. llnvestlt·tlon
Jllll.'. 1971
~t"L •.",,"nt of hour. Slwnt on th" ""M" <If
of Lub_bodt
"~vldow
,~
FfluualJnv... tl,.tlon
>D. 1977
J ..... ll. 1977
ll<!~ulptlon
of Work
Jllnln. 1911
C"nr"r..nccwlthother.ttorney.
J ...... J6. 1977
AprH
,.
Apttl
n.
1917
rh...... conveuUIOllwhh oth.t .uorn.c:,.
April
".
1911
Phune conv.,r.ulon....lth "Uent.
1917
l'rC"parattonorcorreapondlnc.
A;>run. 1917
'r..paratlol'lof corr•• ponHI'IC.
Jun. 21, 1977
April
1'71
".
2 hoUfi
Jlln.20. 1917
21/2ho1lTi
Junln. 1917
L~
r ..et\lal Inv•• tIIUlol'1
Jun128. 1917
Juo.29. 1977
:t.y4. 1917
Pr.. pu.t1Ol'1o( ple.,HOf,.
Jun.)O. 1977
:tayt.. 1911
Pr.. p. . .tIOftof pl.adlnp' corr... pon6l!r
Jill)' 1. 1977
April
".
1977
FleluallnvutllUlon
Jun. 11. 1977
Convenatlonyjth "lI.nu
Aprtl 2S. 1911
ractll.llnveullulon
houn
heillallny... tllltlon
Confer"n".. .,ilh OtMr allorneylJ
I.~
houn
F."tlll1 Inyent,.rlon
I.Shou...
F.elu.llnvenl,ulon
h"tll.! Invutl,.tton
rlctu.l1n"... tl,.t!on
May
".
1977
.-a"tlll1 In..... U'.tlon
July 2. 1977
r.<:tu.ltnve.tl,ulon
~y
11. l'J17
h"ul.l tnvutl,ltlon
JulyS. 1911
C"nference ..lthother.ttorney.
1917
"" ".
20. 1977
r ... tlll1lnv... tl,atIOft
JlIlyll. 1977
!'. .,.
Factu.l In..... tl'.tlon
Julyl4. 1'77
Kay 2'. 1977
rartllallnvuU,IUon
July 15. 1977
Fartual tnvutl,.tlon
Jotey2S. 1911
r3uu.1 Invutl,ltlon
July 20. 1'77
FaftllaltnvelJtllatloo
"" ". 1'77
". 1977
'"JoIayll.
1977
.·.nu.) Invutla- tlon
July 21. 1977
r ..etulllnv..stll"tion
f-.,etual tnv•• ti,ltlon
Jllly2t.. 1977
2_S houn
r.ulll1 hveltl,.Uon
July 29. 1977
.5 hour
Jvne2. 1977
Factual Inv.IU,atIOft
",",.. tIO. 1977
2.5 houra
Jun.]. 1977
r"uII.1
J _ 5 . 1'17
ract .... 1 l"veltl,ltl_
......uu 12. 1977
] houra
h"t,,11 I"...UI,.U_
.......t U. 1977
].S .........
.....pantlonof preU_lnery<lraft of
trlal!>r!.!
"'''IlISt 17. 1977
1 hour
Pr<'l'.ratlonof trll) brief
J ...... 1'77
,-
J.1977
Ju... a. U77
1.5 houra
lo~ltl,.\tlon
"'",ultll. 1977
r."tu.lln .... ul'.tlon
hu".1 1ft..,..ltl,ulOfl
r.ctUlll tnvllttptlon
OetolHtr It. 1'77
Co"ferenulnJud'.. ·.ch.... r.
F• .,tuallnv...tl,.tlon
l .. l · l r.....r<:h
.K<>vlO'abcr6,1918
L<:I;olrr."arc:h
lOov...bu I!, 1978
Ilov....~n 13, 1976
rU'l'natton ot nhl bder
r'''raratlon of nlalbrld
Conference wI
h. l"erClI:
w. ""ylor,
C<. r,a;nea,
I ' 1/2
~-20-77
I ,
1/2
Conference wI Isidro Cut;er..el. via
telephone
Conference w/J. WQOdw.... cl rc,
continuance
10-20-17
1/2
Conference w/J. Woodw.. rd re,
eontinu,lnce
Conference wi attys. re, stinulations
l ' 1/2
Conference wi .ttYl\.
duties, ..esearch
trhl plannin'J.
1 , 1;10
Conference wIatt..... rc:
stipulllt10ns
I ' 1/12
Confe..ence w/atty•. rc: 1l11,.e depo,ition,
voter study by D... Johnson. copies of
expert's report
1 ,
8/10
Confe..ence w/.tt.ys. l"C: BUdqcU. depoait.ions. prl!pllration of slidl! prl!scntation I ,
1/2
Conference w/atlys. re:
OCpo.iuans
OiscullsOd dl!pos., photo ,ileS far trial
w/Pe ..ez. Arthur
Conference wIatt 'Is. , chose slides for
tri.l w/Rev. Jones. Brewster vla telephone
6-21-18
Attended NAACP lIIoI!l!tlnq re, ?a.sible
witnl!Ss w/H.li
1 , 1/2
Conterence w/.tt.y,. re, Dallas cas..
Plaintiff a\1bstituallona, possible
consolidation w/achaol aUll, wilnea.
Ust, Mhs v. Lipaeod:> •.
1 ,
1/2
View f11. at Channel 21 of t:'ltr He.lth
Director, prep.r~ sliJ,
•
trUI wI
Arthur. Pere:.. Benso"
J ,
1/2
COnfsrancs wiatt 'I •. • news eonfert"nce
w/Media. conference w.'lI. Chat!".an, Rev.
Jones, , To," Burtis
I ,
1/2
SERVICE
12-13-78
TU'l: SPENT
Trlal i.n District Court
Conference w/P"ther Hoffman. Sister
Reqlna
,
·
5/10
hrs.
hrl.
12-14-78
Trilll
Dilt.rict Court
Conference w/Joe Valdez. troy Salinal
hrl.
hrl.
12-15-78
Trhl
hrl.
12-16-78
Conference W/lt.tyl. D3n B<-nson'l office
~~e~p<:O-.1n'i witnellel. trial Itr{lteqy
12-18-78
COnference w/J. Woodwa rd on cont inu{lnce
of C{lle
Conference "'/SI-on C{lrrl.zal .... vb telephone re: pollible witness
'"
'"
Diltrlct Court
1-8-79
Conterenee w/atty••
house
1-9-79
Conference w/atty•. GarZ{I office
hrl.
h ••
h,.
'/2
Lane Arthur'.
hes.
hr ••
·
,·
·
1-13-79
COn terence w/M.lri{l ~rcado:Sister
Regin{l
Perez office
,
1/2
hrs.
1-14-79
Conference w/Meria Mercado
office
1
1{2
hrl.
1{2
hr•.
1-15-79
Art.hur
Trial; Conference w/Froy S"linlls
TO~J.~ r....~1l7,.
Attorney "ne Plalntiff
''''''''
SEiMa: OR ElGU&
elCPll5ES
IS nil: lJ"'ITl:D STATES DISTRICT COURT
1-31-18
<blfillned w/attys. 1", 8MB
Il!poaitie-l 'wter st-oldy COIp11C'd
oyOr.~foreopen.t:at.inaIy
I ' !oIIOhn.
2-14-71
Di.s<:uuedBasadep:leiticn'su.ty
of Ill&19l't, Q:r:wuUty Dl!ve1oplarlt
f\ndII v/)lA11 lin:! ArVur
2 ' 1Il0hn.
.-oR 'I1i1: NORTHERN DISTRICT OF TEXo\s
LlJBIIOCIt DI\'ISION
1lI:\'.
ROY JOSts, £"!' AL.
CIVIL ACTION NO. C"'-S-76-)4
>-,.."
3-2~7I
ATTORNEYS LOG OF TIME AND EXPENSES
5-1l-17
Conference w/WilliR Taylor i
"tt.ornej-'s
l.S hr-.
6-27-17
Cor,ference w/Will1~ T;lylor
re' Deposition t.o be tatsn
of City OHichls
2.3hu.
Depose<! w/Willi. Tay~or:
City Secretary ana City
Tr;lnsit. Planner
7-29-77
Conference w/.lud'Je woodWard
re' ecmt.inuance, Case re-set
for No... , 7, 1977
9-20-77
conference v/Ta}'lor, Benson
i Art.hur
9-21-17
'prepa.rationofslldep~t.1ol
I i SIlO hn.
Ctlnterenoe w/attys
OlSCUSlleddeflc-it.1ons,ph:ltosltee
£Or trial v ~ and ArVur
<DIfel'Ql'Q v/attv-, dlcee .lides to
be used in triaL
S-1-78
Cbta.1redYroyS&1iNllleloct.1.cnresulu-CtluntyCOJrth:lu8c
6-17-78
Attendlld N1IJ\O' rreeting re, vJtne..es
6-2~78
"'tty.Q:In(eAlnOere,D!llWcasc,
CDllIideredpWntittslbltitut.101'l,
pou1blc CltIfWOU""'Uon v/lIChool suit;
"'1~1I
Paid puti&l fee of Dr.
"'1~1I
0lnt1l':ftflCe
"'U-71
Mat vith .. ttys., Karold Q\a.~, Rev.
~,''rt.!lUrt.isre,~t.ilacnyat
$114.80
2 ' SilO hn.
~,
!'4rtv/Sta.te~re-'lta.ti
. .. ,Ftot
Ca8l!
TV i Radio
1-17-78
Qlnfenll'lC8 wj'l't:lllGanll, l'tu1t flaIl
r..ne kthw" reI trial pl..-.dn9
~
rw, .t..n".
t i S/IOhn.
i Art)ow: at
Clty l:Ia.l1 w!CLty tttty., .lis! ar-lll':r am
~Jl-78
Ctlnt-.:. v/l'llluiCllrl G.I. I'tm...,
2.8hn.
Q:ln[enedv~, Gana.
Dsm.i.sM::GUl"".tipulat.icl'Ls.~
~,lI1:oortty~,popula.tiCIn,lo\.Iter
~,c.....trllel.l,ete.
liS/IOhra.
==~e-~ot
OollAo.
Pret.rlal CO'Iflllrence wIattv-,
nt' stip.Uatiaw
aer.on re,
~n-71
Q:rlfe.reflOeW/3vI!Jqe.\otlodoIud i auys:
1-12-78
Arthur ,
trialltttUftied~cxntcrwocev/local
pIpar,
ans1e of
$lSS.OO
O'Iarlee,)at'~
..-cmrerenc::e
of_
ChIc.>O
1'5110hra.
Pa.1d~iticnor~8.Iu
:ra.p,er, re, coloE"sUdMo!
Art)ow: ""
li5l10hra.
~~~'=~
S/JOhr,
ft,Ide routine survey of ...met.tBenson, East Lubl:lock and
Guadalupe area. v/ Lane Art/'aU";
~u-.; ~
dl!poe:tUor.
4-26-78
ln~w/.lU.WiItJtilw,prof_icroal
lo-s-n
nl'
4-S-7I
EXPENSE
SERVICE OR EXPENSE
7-1S-17
QlnfeI8lCere'blD}e~,depae;it.1orw
w/attys.
nll: CITY OF LUBBOC'It, E1' AL.
M1b'lb~rw,wi~
t-1~1I
liS/lOhn.
iduti",~ch
1 i 8jIOhn.
OJr>!ll':ned w/att)'. ",I sUp.detJ.orw
1,5/101\nI.
~ ptqlC&lld ~tri&l
. ,.."
pOaibl.evi~
t-23-1I
lIxted with
-.on,
lIa11, i Arthur.
ordllr w/llttys
1'S/lOhrs.
Pn!IpUwl5 'SSltout l~te... to
ou.r
Plaintiff att.tJonoys
=::rm(lertwi~at~1..
6 ' S/IOhn.
r . . Three
l>\TE
SERVICE OR f:XI'DS£
12-10-78
o::af.vithattys<1rXlexpe:rt
Dr".Jctv.:lnQlluW,trateqy
Trial in d1at.
10->-71
10-6-78
Ctln!~w/'F"rOtS&liMSre,
~i.t.iQr"'f!Iect.ic:wlresulU
Qlnferenoe w,lLuci.roo Perez
re,pl"Oten\NU'd'l
1.51\n.
12-12-78
Im."eniqllt«l. lXllightcd .~
foc~bil'Jiml'''tJUns
Trial
Ctnftm!rlOli!
l.ShnI.
12-13-71
10-7-18
murt
Ctlnf. v/Lucl",., Jlcre;l., F'n:Jy
sat.inas.SilIIterf\lljln;).
Tri.,
w~.
llerTf!l"a
<l:lnt. wtrather llofflrwl
SilIIt.erlOJinll
2hrs.
12-14-18
Trill1
Qln!. w/Joe Valdez,
11-16-78
Wellt O\"er lIide Pl'e$('Ilt..tion
, trial strlltee.JY w/H.-lll. Garza
11-11-78
Ql:lfcrred w/l\ll.ll ,';llL"ur ret
vit.neU' a._... of testi;:aly':
,Arthur.
»-16-78
,t.rateqy.et.c:.
Draft 1cttect.OJi.... Srew:at.« re:
~ib1e _tine; with city QulCil
re: BCttlem:'!Clt of issues
11-21-78
6.7~.
• hr.
1 hr.
6.5h['8.
2.0hrs.
.....,........
, ....
4 ' 5/10 hnI.
Ph:lneCD\f.wj\oiu-MllriaHen:a;io
t~ Wash.
arrarqe for pl_ fll<#ll
D.C.
Phcne csll
Pi-. !am
0.5 hr.
52.90
5286.00
~lld' outline OOpoositia>s on F'ra:f
sa1inll11.~llC:to>e1l1nSUtele­
2hrs.
di'trletinqcase
11-22-78
.....
~ for tri&1 CO'lfenn:e in Judri!e',
dl.1dlen.t.rtalCXJnt.in.JodU'ltiII-lS-79
<D\!erence with attys foUCIoi'inq ~
t:r:'J\t. of o::IIltiAIllnce:
1 hr.
~t \11th other Plaintiff' D1!!_
attom&',.. with.J\ldge~!or
fin~ pn-uial oonfererlCll!. Trial ,tr"...
te<1I..:/PlllintiH att.)'!>.
11-20-78
Ctlnf. v/.. ttys. DlII'l8erwQn"
otnoeQll~vi~, trial
~ letten to witneDM
l!-'21-i8
F'n7t Sa1inu
12-15-78
, ....
o:vt'
.-tne "History of (hlC\WlO&
in~Q:ulty-.t7yOr'·AJ'dreI;
Ti.jeri.'la
1l-~71
~r1IcdQl ~wjL:lnc ~
t.-~71
OffiOll ecn!ennoe w/(lllnUlo Cllna.
11-»-78
N:>a.d Ql ~
I-IF"
3hr1l.
$14.20
CDlt. v,Mula Men::-:b , Slater RegIna
4.5 hrs.
Qlnf. v/KUia MtI'CBlk>
plaintiff
St!.ldi.ede:q:ert_tuel'll1Ui1lt.ial
~rt:lllI!t.ll:"(!pi,*ed~expert.
JUpcctfully
vittW!SS.Or • .JDt¥ea'l.-.airport.:
worl<cd v/~tomeyB , ~rt. on tTbl
MJ"(I, ,-:.)C~,\
Qlof. vjM. Aquilar. :ol.. CU'cia
C. CSVaX*
12-~78
<l:lnf. wiG. ~. L. Ga1incD
Friltlk 0::lrIZa1ez
QlIl.f.
~t. MnOI
p.... 71
rtrerez
lItt.Ome'{ for
3.5 tin.
w/Fathr.r Clts'IZalflZ ,rau-r
IbfflNnl. Joe Rlftil'ltll. atdal AquarO
Q:r\f. "'/htMir~• . - \lal.da
~t.erIlsq1n11
N:m.1tt~.
5.5 hnI.
o4.5hn.
.....os
Ptaint.1~f
Goru:a.lo Garza
p~ ..
1
~_.Ilt\J'U:LM.IlPISOll
C.dn.., v. Clrv ... r L.lllb
C<lu.rt for th.. S.Il
~k, ~('I. C.\_~76-J..i
r r..""••
Lub""~k
In lInlttd Stilt... blnrl.ct
Dlvl.lon
(:~inu"
Cln rr LubNck. NO. D._~76-..w 1ft l!nitt<l St.Utt Dlnrlct
CounCortbcJf.D... rT~•• LubbockDhl.l.. n
T1JltlSHRS.
ltl/10Hll.:
ktt ..rlt)k..,tolllllI.sTII)'l.. r.llu)'. r .. r
I'lalntlffuponj..lnl""""se ... nty. r ..r
1'1:Ilntlff;
r~p....f'<I ·t')lIiMi((· . . .\tM ....... l II e-.• ..t.;
-,;"try ..(A..,......anl;l' . . eoun.d·for.ill.
't.'rl"r, }'t~t~r.~r'$II; ~t1"" hrCOlltl.......ee·
II ~ .... randull "r WlIln Suppon·;
vlth rlaintirr. 10. eno.. COliM'. re-:a.nIl",l:;hl.svlthd _laseounsrl. nleQIIU,,(
above lin..d inu _
...ith Dhuit1 Clrril;
TlW.tslflS.
It 1/10 Ill.:
1&1/10 hn.
s.
t'~IlD~d."ddtlhtrtJt
.. ChY'ro,...t<l
kttcrtoCow-t reI a... ttt"l ....... h or
Ct. u.s. n..c.hJonln "allateascbtfcl"t
crial ..r thia u.c;
5/10 bn.
1&s/10 hn.
IleCthtdJI.'l'tIIStcrt.ltttcr .. fl~l3-T7
....prdhl; I4lI11 ""IC at U.S. Sup.-- Court.;
di.CIl ....dvl.th .......ec..... tl;
2/10 t:r••
I~l6-77
Conrr,,",~"
1 & s/10
4 & s/1o
......
Kreched and ....n(trr'edvhh e coun.el on "ourt'.
ltttcr ..r5-g....77 I"t:Sd ....hti
""Cla.. aetlon
DrU,..j".ti",,;
5/10
h....
P~ja ....dl)ra(t ..r rn,,.,... dStll'o'hti""'. "",Cl...!
t.ctl<"l'lDeUnalnati..... rortfttliut.. Ctry;
5/10 II....
eonft'ra."" vl.th City lou .."''''' I"tl CL~ .. t.ction
St1pa1I1H"".; tl1td .... vl.thDhtrictCltril.
al.... wl.thpnl,...ed ..N .. r . n... t.etl.... Dete~
Illnnionl;
'Ued~i ...
torCo!ltl_Ct·and"8rio:fln
Meetlnc
tM1 ",
y.7-U-11;
1"2/10 lin.
1"S/10 Il....
,/10
et.
e-ftl"ttlCt witll t.ne Anl",r ... _ttrial In nlc;
T.hl pl"ti"OratIOft. rrldftlce. (, "'tnc ..
1*"2/10
.vIo
PJ"c,.rtddro.ttoflettcrt.. Ccurt.C..rt.nt
t.nhur·.,tl"aul"t I"t"ardlne the .tatUi of Dalla.
ClI....
Ullfcpb. u U.S. Sup. Court.
5/J.0
~l"edf'n:ll•• I"t,.,rt.CDr.C.Johnl"";
5/10
Vl""
2.IrS/J.O
_bunlftll ..r
ptr'DOf_ldu• ..,.01 dhcrh.lnatl , n ...cIard .. r
proc(...... COfItftltlon• •rpsrtl .. ;
J.5/10
Depodtl_ .r Roy Ian. r.,..r ""'y.r ..r Lubb...: k,
vlth _ _.tl-."dph.."lncprlo.. todc"".ttio .. ;
J&S/J.O
II....
......rdI ... 1a.. applltablct.ea
bn.
h-t,....
tl ..... o(Pre-trt.l c....lud'dl; l .... terl.
t ....- . t l o n erith.d ....edtlllocat.. an:l pr01>&'"
CclftCet'ftlCt"'thVU1h Ta)'lor. wn~"'n.hur""d
....l '..r n . e _ ...l.on04t
c.atWf'Y1delcc
lDe........ l:lIJIertvltnc
;
2"1/10
eon....h..J "'111. WM t.nhllr rf:f.llrdin:: .t1""I....
tl_tobcaoulht.Cr.Clly ..CL"bbodc.
vl.tfte........rl ..... ce;
1&s/10 II....
lMoo;ll_coaft~..cc
:" ..."ct.nhur ... crl.....ce ..d ... t
bcuUedi.. Up.t.rll_
tlcipateddty.tl",,1atlo... ;
-,
d~.....l •• naintifrt.nt'J' •• ""dGaI"..' q ........
"",....tlon .r d...ft of Pl'OfIIClU Pr-Trld Onlu;
_rereott.wl.th1.arl.ArthurOft ........ridftlccfr
wit.n....... ;
s..pport..or~wl.thllhtrietCl
.. ril;
Cororertl"::c with coun.ct -.N Jud«cVood.. rd re,ar<Un&t...til'llllnce; ca... rt-.et (.rtrid
• Jf. . . .bcr 7. 1977;
Conf ...... Ctvl.th UU.fayl .. ra~t.hbvlthdraV1to,(uCOUft 1.ndbrl. ..lnl; ... r1c ..... UOft
at c.......1 ror Platlltlff&; draCted letttr for
fay10r·.dpoltu~toPhtfttifrCal
.....bovt
_ttO_llfIdNarll .....llcoall\li" .. PlDt_
tifrt,uty.
1"5/10 Iln.
witll _ _...l&oppoa!na cou... tt
ok,.,titl.... rJClty ......nne:1_'ri
h....
toat.I"tlICt IIIl.th'a'l.llh Tayl..... hb vl.th-
PI"tp'l"td"HoU. r ..rContlnuance"llftd.dllal"ed
_
with "pp"lin.r. e _...l for Chy ..t LoobbKk;
1'n"'~"ritt1JllSup",rt.";
Z/l0
Ccft(tra.t.. vl.tIlJudl.cVOOdwo.rdandc-c...... tt
aJId.JlPODi""COIIl'I.tlOft t ...tl ..ua ....ct ••""lt
Dlllas dedd""l
t'~Jlo'rf'<1t'1d"tlrf"''''lralA''ndedC_plahlt''
anJ "Hotlon r ...r Cla.. A.. ti.." Det~na.lnatl ....••
;Utd "rhr I" Support .,rH..,I.." forCh .. Actl.."
D,ru.-i""t1on ........ hp.l ruean:h .... all .. r _ ,
Drd'ttclt~crletttrtDb,·."'ttDCCUn
rtpl"ltinIlDal1&,,,,"c;
vltfte.M.fortrld;
h....
J.ettert••Uco-ccuoo.el ... "el'd.rll.......tin.c:' •
.u.OOI .....p.CI:.U.S.·.d.. rl.I ... I"tbllncasc.
......ourll.edf.... ""'t ......... fcrlrl.&l;
1&7/10 ......
2/),0
Meetlaavlth _ _ .et ... ca.... phnnl ...c:""d
~htrtrlalprc..rati",,:
1"5/10
Let:tcrt.o"". RoyJ ...... ,llAACI',vitht.. pl ... t ..
ACUI
Lota,:ue of W..-en \''''''1'1. r,,~rdln.c: crttical
n..... r
""'t......... &ttrld; e¥aluaI;"" .r"';l .. n.
_tc.ria1t.. c&atc aftd ocher evllll"ftt.. ;
1&1/10 II....
n~S}fl:T_U\'fln.H.1lE'lSOl"
~-M!l'n:LN• •ENSlIl
Gdnu y Cin rot LubNoclc. liO. o.-s.-7r.-~ In Untt~ SUln Oi.tl"h:t
C<>un for thrlloU. orTu:... lubho<::k nhla10n
C,tnny Chyof l.,bbgs... 100. CA-So-76-J4 i .. U.. ltrd Statu Illnrl<::t
CoIlrt for tile M.D. of Tuu. Lo.ahbod Illylaton
TD£ IJIIIIS.
(,1/10
".1
TIn:TJI'Hl'IS.
b 1/10 1lR.:
~to~ro1dClat~on.tat\l.ofCl'"
lIlo lira.
'laJ_.c
1/10 Ian.
11-21-71
H,.,..toIb.I"01dCha~IIO"""r.,qlaiah
•
• tu... or .,u;" Md .,..t .. of Chin«
t1!fI.lid"notiu, etc.
7_1~7e
Gonf .. ralcr oritla "-nl. TOIlI & Ukrt
11-22--18
on
Pre-Trial eonl~renc. vith Judo!,:" Woo,h",rd
....dco-<:ouns..l .. doppoal .. '_~:I .. rtller
..onfel"ftl... vitll c - . . - t l _ p~paratton •
for trial:
2&1/10
Worked on vitn.... Un and rxhlblt.lht;
1 b 5/10
.ut... ofc..c.trll1p1AlWIi~1
Meeti",. KarkKUl'. ofUc.,.n pla.1ntl(fl.
7_19_78
Hutl ....:;vitht_vn.d.""".JloyJ...,••
Harold Ch.~t.." ICd p",lI. ""I Stat... or
ClSt; call 10 Judlr 'OIoochllr<l to adYbe Court
ot..., ..dc:ontent:;
Confrrm« vith La_ "'nh.r and T... c.....
"I
'!DnnincforCrlal. U'aUabl"ori1ne..U .
rndmee,
Uraftll\l.ndreSC"af'daonpl"O~e<:lpre-tria1
c_counsel. fortrhlplaNLinC:
2&
2"1/10
h....
• b 1/10
h....
• & 5/10
b....
H~ctillJi, Karllllall·. otll"", •• U co-c:o..,... I.
for trial plannin,; further p,..,pH:Hlon~ at
s/l.o bore.
orfice for tri.l 01 0 .... preparation of
lnltnlttionaheetlfor'laintHfl.ltit""uu;
1" 2/10 hra.
I~U-7I
on:l..r,
2ft 5/1.0
tin.
Conhrcnu vlt:. Lane ... rth..... T. . C.n.....l
Pe ..n.vithoppo.inlc:oun.dlorCity.at
City Hall. reI Stipulation. and Exhi~t'l
1 (, 5/1.0
hra.
8e&im.l.nloftrialofc.... :
Continuatlonoftri.l.fulI<:;
ContiNlatim oltri.ld CI''';
Jolec1;llllv1tlae~..land.p.oal"",CGlud.
City Ilall. on arlpulatlon. Md ubibiu ...110
pI"O!'-tridordrr;
2& 5/10
ee.d'e""u rith Lane"'rthur. Kar1lll.all Md
Alben 'ern to C. onr Propoted '.--Trial
OrOIr. eft"'ul.c"... and trial plannil\ll
1 ft 5/10 h
Vork on tre-Trlal OnUr,
1
_ N l and Dr. John_ to
rnl..teJ... _'.nportaotoStertl_y ..
UPS" vl.Ule"l
• .1/10 h....
11-6-78
_d.
Draft'" Trial Britf araI
o;mr"rmc"
vitia Lane
~on._:
&
2/10 Ia .
Conl.reate viti: La"" .l.rthurand. Jobrk !l.n on
.rlel.....d.ueardoandvriUnc""'_1
.J.5/1.0 hr••
Cont~renc~ ill J1004.'.
la-l8-,.
c..r_
1~7t
.et forJ
vitia .._
.....
c.ha"er.
ecntln... Uon
ry U. 1979;
Oft
rl on f .. rtll.r IlNpara-
tionof trlal01 c.aM;
1" s/10 hr••
eonc.rome. vitll Co-CCUl.el on r .. nher trial
of QM. A.rthar·. " - ; prera... tlo .. or draft or
.rt.d ....nom""·.rr. . :
2'" 1/10
Cont.I"ft"",vitb"o-<oWlld onprcpo. ... tt"" of
trlalofcan.wl.tn........ evlc....c.. , ••ndlcv. l
.uthority;
1 (, 4/1.0
Iare.
u..dl<l..
_hl"ftcevithvilnt.. C.....-,;cSCott
an4~rlA.rt""r&IlI.U,t'nr
.. nh"rtrial
1(,1/10
&ratted "'qIIUt fot Judiel,,} ~atlct C.r prior
paUtUllftdo.:-<:ntt.. Whlt .. l'rt ...",.SUtuIU.
ancI1"eq"..... ltforJudlc1lOl1otittOr~.nd
L"", "'rthur
c..r.,..,..,.vltIlLaRlArth.r ..... MartElIallnl
vlu.....ea............ Un. trid pl... nlllCl
c...ti_tionoftrialofCln
1:'18-,.
P"P'",UO':'I:
on rn-Trl.1 Uri.f.
ll_U_71
l )..1s.-7I!I
.Jft 5/1.0 hra.
4.5/1.0 ......
\oIoril.rdon .......Tr\ll.ri.cwl.thLa""Arthur
.... Men-Hall;
~i...tiondtrialofClSC";
.
he-trial8ridvritJ ... and,..,.... rdo
e-t.""". vith'" DaYl.... ....s
11_14-78
of Trtll1 Hc.ora",h_ on rlndill,.
01 'att lll.lt-la". Electio...yate. u,SC"',
1~14-18
.feaM;
IoIorkon're-TrialOrd"".
Keet~
'~p..... tio..
J&.l.da!..CI.... inlhhc..... rt;
.....
..rt
2foS/J.O
Ia....
M.rtillCvlthJ_.Mar.haU ...d e<J-COWlsti Lane
n: Telti.....y.baut elty's Bnandal
tr
rtioo •• LlJar·.ofn"":
2& 5/10
ahtllllay of trial;
T6TAL
b".
.....
I~S liltS
IN Till.: UNIT!"!) STATtS DISTRICT COURT
I'I)R TlIt ::OPTlltRN DISTRICT 0"
TI'XI\5
SERVICE
1.1IBDOCK DIVISION
Confurence wlllall, Arthur re: witnells
:~:~~:~~~' need for 311 otl.er ....itness
I\TI'Ollst'l"S TII1E LOG roR 1O~AS GARZA
JONES CASE
TIME LOG
8-10-78
COnferene.:: w/Jesse Reyes
8-21-78
Conference ....I.tty. for - bre...· ster.
McGill, re' ,tipul.tion•• Iilllptl. census
tractl. etc..
TIKE SPENT
[),o\TE
5-11-77
Conference .....
,\. rere:.
5-20--;
Co:'!ference ..... If. Taylor. D.lviddow.
Renlrm
5-27-7-
Conference ....1 Isidro Gutierre:. via
toelephonc
\o{.
'!'ayl<Jr. f;. (".aines,
conference v/J. Woodw'ard re,
continuanee
9-23-78
lOtipUlations
Conference ....1 attys.
duties. rese<lrch
trial plannin'},
Confercnce ../attys. re'
hn.
1/2
...
1" 1/2
Conference w/llall. ,Il,rthur, Perez. Ber.son.
Dr. Johnlon re: expert witness testilllOny
TT Law School
6 ,
112
COnference w/Judqe Woodwar
11-16-78
Conference w/atty!:. re: str3tcqf. slide
pres.nU.tion
11-17-78
Conference w/Perez. Arthur re: subpoenas 3
11-18-78
CO:'!fere"ce v/attys. re:
Base deposition.
voter stooy by Dr. Johnson. copies of
ellp<'rt's report
1 " 1/10
2-25-78
Conference w/attys. re: BudqeU, depositions. prep.nation of slide presentation 1 " 1/2
3_28_78
Conference w/attys. re,
r.x_Ir.ed photo areal w/Hall. Arthur.
Perez, W!ltkir.s
Conference "'/Hall. Arthur. f"C: witr.esl
Itat_ntll conference ..../J. Woodward:
trial ,trateqy conference w/P. attys.
l ' 1/12
1-31-78
Depositions
11-29-78
Working on subpoen.s ..../Arthur. Perez
12-4-78
Helped Arthur prepare final witness
lilt. list of Exhibitl. Expert's
Report. d.livered copies to atty's.
12-5-18
Conference w/M. "9uilar. M. Go"\rcia
C. CIvazos
12-8~78
Confere:'!co w/rather rlC'Covl'rn. Joc
Valdez, Joe Ramirez, Rid"l Aoucro •
Ernelt Barton. -'liter Re9lnll. Jessie
Rang.l
Discussed depos .• photo sites for trial
w/Perez, Arthur
4-26-7.
1/2
11-13-78
1 " 1/10
stipulationl
I ,
Jnvest.i9ated b1i9hted areal for photos
by Jill. "3tkins
Conference v.'J. IlocxN;ud re,
eontinu."\nce
Conference ....1 /lttys.
1 , 1/2
Conferenc. w/8er-son .....rthur. Hall 3:1d
auy. - 8rewlt.r and McGill
I , 1/2
1.1/2
TIME SPENT
COnference ",/rather Gen:.alez ilnd Hoff-
Conference v/attys .• chose slides for
trial wIReI.'. Jones. Brewster via telephone
6-10-78
.... ttended NNlCP I'leetinq re' possible
witness v/Hall
l ' 1/2
hrs.
6-28-78
conference w/attys. rl': Dallas cafte,
Plaintiff .ubltituations, poslible
consolidotion ",/school suit, witnel.
lilt, 'fhe v. LipsCOfrb.
1 '1/2
hra.
Vi ..... f11_ at Channel 28 of City Health
Director. prepare<:! slides for trial vI
,Il,rthur, Perez. Benson
3 ,,112
hra.
conf.rene. v/attys •• news conference
w/Media. conference w/H. Chat_no Rev.
Jon.'. , Ta. Burti'
1 "1/2
hr,.
Conference "'/G. MOreno. I.. (;,llndo,
Y. Gen:.alez
12-10-18
Conference ",/attyA. lind eXDC'rt On
tr1ll1
Trial in District Court: eO' f, rC'r'ce
w/Lucuno Perez. Froy S3li,·.Js. ~i,s~er
Regina
12-12-18
Trial in Di'trict Court
Conference wIG. Herrerll
TIME SPENT
12-1J-78
Trl",l 1n District Court
Conference w/Father Iloff.an, Sister
Rc9 ina
12-14-78
Trial in District Court
Conference w/Joc Valde:t. f'roy SaUnall
12-15-71
TrL:.1 in District court
12-16-78
Conference w/~tty•• D~n Ben!lon's office
on uP<'Olainq vitnesses. trial !ltrate'ilY
etC".
12-18-78
Conference w/J. Woodward on COntinu~nce
1-8-79
Conference v/attY5. - Lane Arthur's
house
~~n~:~:nce v/Si.,n
Carrizales via telephone rel possible witness
1-9-19
COnference v/attys. Garza office
1-13-79
conference v/Karia Mercado:Sister
r.eqin.. - Perl!'I oUice
1-15-79
,-. S/10
tin.
REV. MY JONES. £'I' AL.
hrs.
THE CITY OF LUBBOCK. ET AL.
A'M'ORNEYS LOG Of' TIME AND EXPEt:SES
SERVICE OR tl:XP£NSE
Conte renee w/'Willi. Teylor ,
attorneys
112
..
6-21-17
Conterence w./Willis Teylor
re l Deposition to be taken
of City aUichls
1-15-17
Deposed w./Willis Taylor:
City Secretary and City
TrA1lsit Planner
7-2'-71
Con terence w/Jwqe Woc/dofar4
reI continuA1le., ease re-sel
for Nov. 7, 1977
5/10 hr.
9-20·71
Conterene. v/Taylor. Benson
• Arthur
2 , 5/10 tin .
112
Con!erence ../Rari ... Merc.:odo - Arthur
nHice
1 • 1/2
Trial: Conference v/Froy Salinas
1.1/2
2.3hrs.
$184.80
Made routine survey of AmettIlenson. EaSt Lubbock end
C;Ua4alupe ere.s w/1Mle Arthur:
Interview w/Jb w.tk1ns. profeuio'oal
~ ~ ' ftl Olllor" .Udu
ot
Ileprnent..t1'"ll, !"roy
SSl1nM I W/LWIe Arthur re, OU(>1l"lO
Mtt
v/S~
anqaotc.we
10-20-77
Qlnterencew/.:J\Pge~.atty&:
Trial~~~~
o=urt ac:dcn on Wi..
Dal1M.
0Il0M
out of
-
I'VIOhrs.
1-17-71
Qlnfe~ w/l'an Garu, Mart. Hall
1.- Arthur reI Uial plamJ."':l
i&lties.rMlilSTdl
I ' 8/10 tin.
liS/10hf'S.
~
AttOrney For Pl.lntiff
Page Four
(wm
SERVIa:: OR EXPr.NSE
T1ME
12-10-78
(bnL with att}'s and expert
Dr. Johnson on trial strategy
3 hrs.
EXPENSES
Trial in <list. oourt
Cbnf. w/lJ..lciaro Perez, Fray
salinas, Sister Regina
6.7 hrs.
12-12-78
Trial
Ccnference wiG. lIerrera
6 hr.
1 hr.
12-13-78
Trial
Q)nf. w/Father Hoffman
Sister Jegina
6.5 hrs.
2.0 hrs.
12-14-78
Trial
Cbnf. w/Joe Valdez, Fray salinas
6 hrs
2 hrs.
12-15-78
Trial
6 hrs.
12-16-78
CCnf. w/attys. Dan Ben:>on's
office on upcx:cning witnesses, trial
strategy, etc.
2 hrs.
12-11-78
12-18-78
4 hrs.
Appeared for trial coofererce in Judge's
chanbers, trial cootinued lD'ltil 1-15-79
cooference with attys follQoling anrolU1cement of continuance;
1 hr.
1-9-79
Ftx>ne conf. wjwitness Maria fo1ercacb
arrange for plane flight fran wash.
~.C.
Ftx>ne call
Plane fare
1-10-79
Ihr
$2.90
$286.00
ct>tained Lubbock Cbunty Election
Iecords for <XfTPill"iSOl1 w/city Lane
Arthur
2 hrs.
1-13-79
Cbnf. w/Maria Mercacb & Sister Iegina
4.5 hrs.
1-14-79
CCnf. w/Maria fo1ercacb
1.5 hrs.
'lUI1\L
J~
1'0 DATE:
157.90
'lUI'AL EXPENiES 1'0 Oo\TE:
$942.90
Respectfully sul:Jnitted,
!PiJ
'
LA.~Pere;:;'::~z"';:':"""':"':':::";"'<.lI.s'--
Attorney for Plaintiff
Gonzalo Garza
n
Tie lM1ED SUn:s DISTIIJCT COlaT
FOR nE !tORrnEll'f
.....-nof.ttorney.t.... t"
IIISmCT or Tm.S
_
.rc .pedal draaut ....ul Il&kt
WSllOa DIVISICS
..td.2U ..S.C.11MJca.. aanl... thcrc
just;
,uda an
h .. llI.7be ..... rde4~1111..Th
and. (c)
.. U.rneyl
pecuotthenev.tatut.wt.llbe
cl.1 .. culledlnthtlorduj... tat.-en.
(al ""
1l£\'.IIlll"tJCf!l,"Y.S.nal.
.setu" .DDU" totM, CI"
'Mae Roan "port p1..hl.:r at.ted the Conare.. .dona1 1fttent that the new
Plaillttfh
.tatut.would 10.-em .. U ca.... th.t Iftre pcudi.Ja,on the dati ofenlct-ent:
I".ccordanuvlth"ppUcable dedl1ml oftheSuprc-e
tllEClTtor LUBIIOCX. et .1.
Dt-,... lbnu
C... rt.thebI.l11.aI.ntendedtof'PPlyto ..llc. .",pendlqon
thiJdat .. of_C't-.t ••••••• H.I.It.port!fo .. ' ...lSS8.94d1
Coclc.
P1.htith .nd Plalnttff_Intcr"O'tIlor
M~by
tender dab
~
4won .....rdo( .. ttome!"'eealnthe .. bo\'ecaptlonedandl\.-be~dcau
2dSn
n .. 6 (Sept. 1.5.1916).
0.. the noor ot tta. Kea.e 01 It.cpreMfttat.h'n. It
of
wa,
twt.« Npha.hcd th.t
theat.tuU ... uld .. pP1y retrOOlcthelytopetldil\&cuea.l.nc_mt,b)'
.
eona"""_n A... de,..... (112 C..... Ilec. 121.5.5. Dd1,. ed. Oct. 1. 1916) .... 4 Cora-
for the eul.dance of theCow't.
II'CI_ Drlnaa (112
1.
leport aho
et..... roe-
Cowa.d for the nai..tl.fh ancI. t1&I. .. tift-IrIt.rTmor. . . . da.
p~lente4 by the nal.ntUh and PW..t!lf-Inten""or, 18 tlaI.l ca..
ret.,..
(l974), In wIoJ.da the
Ire _ t t l _
Con,. Itotc. 1n60. Dally eel. Oct. 1. 1976).
to
'ndIa"
IUd.....d S%l Iksnl
Th. MOUle
416 U.S. 696
e-rt "pplled the .chool de..,reptlon coun.el fee
to .Uo....q, hu lnlder the "«Ilt ~ t to.2 U.S.C. 11988. IlaWc low
- ....
~.55'.'.thCon,~II.Oct.1'.1"".90Stat.2641.wtddl~delinpertt-
'
t_
prindplehwtlut.b1hhed;
In
&fQ'
.ctie-a or Proceed:l."l t. Mtf.rc. ..
~,t....f
HCtlOlll
1911.1918.19"19. 1980and1981oltheltnhedStatutea.tl.tleU
of dedal_.
IfglllilMA.Mtltpdn
Thi.
OOurt' . .lt.pp1ythela.. ln eff.ct.tth.
laGa" Itt st-md
SeJ
hoi J!!.2I:I.:
.!l!2.o!LL..
JtJOoS. 26e(1969)...nd.utlaor1H.,.c1tedtherdn.
n.c It,t.!!
uw!n, 'n .... td pC "tome!' 'fro.
0' Public Low 92-J18. or in...,. d:ri1.ctl.e-a or praee.dha,. by or
(b)
mbehalfoftheUnitedStatelof".rlca. t.enfore.. . . charal.lII
Th.Itancla.rd.l....aedbyCoo,cre... l.nthenewat.tut.hlhc . . . . . . the
• nohtl ... of... proyll1e-a of the United Statu I .. t.mt.lltnftl. .
-'andard ""d.r the lJ64 ChU IUcht. Act.
Code.ortl.tleYIoftheChl.tltlpU"rtoflt64.theCOUl't.t.
• . .HI orcl.1aar1ly ree-r all .. ttona"",'. fee ...lul ,pedll c1ra.atlllcn
It,dhcreUCIft. _,.aU_tJa.prenl.llnc
UnltedState•••
p-.rr:r.
~lClnableattom.,.·.h
. ...
A. c0PJ'.f the tut of th.lt.tllte h
otl'aerthaol tlaoc
p.rt.ftbaco.t••
attacheel hereto and Incorporltecllterei.ft
n,. a.prehetad:" leChlath.. hhto..,. of tid. rt.tvt. utablllhe4 dl.u
the ,tatul:. appU •• to
tJMdat.ofen..et-.t;
-W a.der ..da ...............,.,,. ••
::tIllS
S
by
....pl'"'41..-. ....••
b)
ordert.c. .,.....t.ooulelfor.errioe.rend.re4prlorto ....etllftlt.
(tI)
1:1. . 1
Hb the prelCftt _
the ,t.atwt. h
u
whlda
_re ...."UII& _
... tnt.l'1'f"'tted to J'f"O'+"I.defor
J_29.1976;
" .. 5-6. Sept. 1.5. 1976).
lfn-n
t
,.
I . t... l.aat
(Sen.t. lteport .0. 94-1011. '.Ih
leport.o.'
Cone••
1.5511.'.tIlConc•• 2d
Thl.a ta the Itand.rd thn ....1 eaubllahed
' h d , hrk Iol£rprhea
l!'9I"Sbgpe'!
In brief. the p....nlllgc !!nt
Ins • J90 U.S. 400, «)2 (1968). ",01
gt E+Qtlm .12 U.S. U7. 421!1 (l91J) •
tCl... th .. re.renO·.pPClalclr~tancn·t,.t_1d
and circlalltam:U in "ndene. in dd. a •• point to an .".rd oC CH"
(ao;t.
Sine. the
tt..l.r
1'1"" .u.tuU
nled diro:o;t.l,.
_,. bt!
nw ....
hdin.l.ons.
h~hbth" hbtol"J'
e~.r• •2 U.S.C. I 1983
a_..
tN .ttom~ hu
.~&iut sut••nd local official. and -.lend. . .d
no D""th Noenaart probl••
h
of tM n.... sutute h
coaelu.h".
n.
",ah,.
tM
of counsd
ern
apiut tIM [iUti/
sut~t
Sen.U bport 1(0. 94-1011. J!!R!:l,.t p. S.
h
1.. the
d
•
M,'rrtj} la_.... d tllat feil ...rd. a ....
..,1 ..te'ralpartofthe ........ <H ... n"«..ar'1toobtaln • • •
~.nca••
1'b<I
Senat" Como.!.ttee therefor. luted t'-t f .. a..rdl.ra proricled "in locordane.
vith
CconCrcu' PO""" ...nder,
S." lJ.
In fltt,!!!Hlek"
1n1..tr.l11J,.,
the 'ourt• ...,th"-.d.ent. S.<:tion
Bltur. _U.S.-, 96 S. C1:. 2666 (1916). dted
""ttl 'ppl"OYal by the House e-ltt
".-........t 11 nO bar to f"......rd
th.
s..~ Court
held t"t tlla I:l.....""t"
cIe P'"....,t to Con&......i _ l .uthorlsAdoa
....der thi. fl\&bllna p,..",,\.slon of tM 'ourt.enth"-ocl-.ent.
the nat\lt. . . a ertac;tM
"intire _t tMt
~t to S.ctiOft S. Cool&re~n 1Irl...... n a t " _
the noor thl.t -..ay qIK.don .ria", 1III<ier do. nC'fenth "-eNl_t h
b
Cnor of awardiq f"" ,,&ian ItaU do!f""du'u.·
(122
r. .o1",",
Con,. "c. 12160.
t)e
eona...... Uftt...,.tatU d ..t
. . .rob WId"r tha nev ,tatute -,.
be "CoUect" dtber directly f . - til. official. In M, offldal capa.dty.
f . - fIaftd. of hi.
,1f'I".-....
&&_..,. or " . r hi. coontrol. or f __ the n.ta or 1~
(wbttherornott!l."aKJ'or'crn~t\.s
(S"n'u ."port 1(0. M-I011,
~ .t p. S). tn other
lill.-
(Seruou
eap.a.tsu that "Suc:k .... rd.
1'8
an i.-portut _cter
of lltiptlon. even . . he wntwtd,. doe. not pn:Tall on.U
<l!I..).
til tbe
,....._t
caM. b
the event th" Plalntiffs and
nab._
In thh g.e. ther will haTe pmaned on the kind of UJIOl'tartt _ncr eont_
pl.tedhJthe ..evsu.t ... te •
ThaHOI1sell.eporthexplldt in lJutl",thlt"Th"vord'p,..,...I.U",'h
notl.ntendedtorequirethef:ntryof.11DIl.o nlerhtfo..... fces ..,.ht:recoo..erf:d ...
(HGlIuReportlfo.94-1.558• .I.!l.2[l.p.8, ...phasl.sinth.,oriCi...1).
quotuvith.ppronltbaS...pn:-eCourtt.hoUl ..clnBradlny
TtleReport
81&159 od
~,.16U.S.69fi.l1J(l914).that"'dhtri<:tc:ourt . .stha"edi.-
c....dOftt......rdf..... ano:t_t.inc1dent to ttle final di.po.ttiOlt oflnt....u,
_tte,...·
Tha "'port.deb tNt "Such ......... .i!:tI:l!knl.tJ.ill.re parciaolarl)'
i.arfort:lllt i.e prot....cted llti&ation. wtlera it is difficult to prediet vlth-r
certaint), t _ . U upool WIlda. n ...l or"do.r vt.ll be entered.·
"'port
<It.)
Tlte
eat. . . . Ittanllbrd the pJdelllte ot.l!r!!!ls:I that &oI'J' order "that
batantialrlp.ofthe,.rtie......,. ...pportana_rdofre....
(U.).
t .. the pra_t ........... eqW.t.ble ",lief onl,.,. _ld nrcahl,. aupport
......... ",f. . . .tthhn.'eoftll.ca.e.
....... partJ)·
WI;lrd•• the CollI't _1.
Tha.-eoltllefe
ts.ofeour........tterwithl .. theCourt •• dl.-
<tinct that .tto""'1' f"eslnthp""ftOt COOlIe ba paid either hJ n.aClty of
cretl_. but .tanet&rd.for
Lubbock. or by the r ..~<:th. Clt,. of I.oIhbock Dd'endanU In tMlr ofndal
tha le.dh, e. . . of Jpbn.SI!l !
upllc1tl ....
n..lteport.
theyl.aiatthq.ft ....dtl. . todooat... b. .hofthefflden«ofncoonl
....u , . .
ktl,. .... O<:t. 1. 1916).
t...Htd.
Jl!2a. at p. S).
tIft_tnten-mor prnail on tke _cter el tbe t:qIdtable relief so"&'>t, as
• f1.ndl.... that "'the "frectl of ~eh fee ...nI, .r. andllal"J' .noS lnc:idaftt to
...curi .., COl'lpll....c" vith th"... idYll
_I"sa
in......•
.pelled CllIt ClIllT 1a
Th"ro:.th.,S"...teee.-tt tea •
feu under ~""e n_ n.tutil.,. be ...,... ~
Ife. 94-1OU.
.re uped.U)' 'Pllropriat. we,.. • part)' .... pm&iled
Rooa.. e-.itte.
,~,,~t.· (M ••• "'port 110. M-.IUl.
'"'" "sh for thh
TheSenueReport.pecUIcaU,.n.t... thlt"tn.Pfropri.udr_tanco....
ReJlOrt
upll.dtly suted that -rM tl.....enth ..... ~t h ftOt a bar to tbe . . .rdia,
.Il!RD.> p. 1. n. 14).
_.et
The Mou,.Report JlOintaout that "Tha&rc.ter
to 'O.,.,,.,..,..U prvrid. an UlPh ba.. frOll whtdl fe... can be
Cl\Irc.......I lable
rded to the
(Sth Clr. 191.).
rdJn' re..on.bte """nvl fces.r...et forth in
btbl:wm .......
&$1'«" ltichvnf:w"tu
Inc, 488r.14114
Title vtt "",ployotcnt dlacri.h'Hlon 'l.oIt, but
t ... U..,danl..... ot«mual.ppllcatlon.ndhav.. be"" rreqIJent1:f.ppll.edto
pra,..llI", pl.a1"tUf In .odu ",lIl.t '1f'I.~t&l ofttc.t.b or entltl ...•
.JU.8.C.'lMJellle.,e.,•• 5ttn'rclD,"""
("""'.....JlOrC ..o.94-US8.J!!.RI&..t'.1).
Cal.ltl."
Miller
y
C!rh9l!
401
r.s... pp.
Z"Nn
64f.It.D.680(I".D.
US. 817-859 (M.D.
rho
197.5).
"'ccordhl,l)', the ~ &U1ddhlu should ~ "pplito! in tM. cue, and. vlU
~tbertharlf,..apn.Yat"la"P"'etlce. httheCcNrtbmtitledtotalce
now~di'l;\>ssed.
iIlto considentl .. tbat la"",cr, IlOIlplO)"ed "" orpni....tl'llls othu than prl"'te
(a)
The tie: ;tod labor rrgu1a d •
la.... n,.. arlt not pn:dv4ed fl'. rscoverlnc fit"••
lllh n:fe .... to the nud>er or houn and the _ n t of effort ppeftded ""
COUftlSl.
In this au, the boll.... an: e.tablish" by the tutl_r of Mr.
a.
CowIn
Hadhon
aent If LtuSfu.
laid"! htUDS!!
Selt, e.c., ~
496 P.2d 681. 689 (Stlo Clr. 1974);
49J".2d 598, 6Ofo-607 (Sth Cir. 1914); ~
Vun:n Coss and the eshibiu uttl"" rorth the hOll .... expended. ,.le1l be u-
"""is"
_ined. and ..hid! ""n: a~tted Into evldocn"e in tIlta <:ate.
~4.J7r.2d959(StIoClr.1"'U,.rnN1IlCJ40,..SuPP.rog(E.O.
T1Ie mdtlle.
uubU.hed that an sueh hours 1ft thh eate _re lIe«....1"7 to proper pre-
Lo.. 1970);
parulon and trlal oC the ease.
(Sth Cir. 1970).
(b)
(n.b.lfos.
stf tbt guutipn••
'nIe "ayflU Md dtfUSuln
This CilU hil. pre.ented a _~r oC unusual i ...... and
VIo'.
or course,
to invutl&"te /lnd c«:lple..x h
It hili pn:H'ftted ract .ltll&tiOl'L' diCC1wlt
nature, iftvolYi", the conduct oC Municipal
.-.en.
It con..-d
Clad!
Mldn.!
'[JndmbuaU'!
TheR'"
It & It
..... d""
'I'
426 P.1.4 534. 5~5J9
...
'I'
TM...nd. 52..S
wcr...... t I
.510 ".200 1090
4941,1.4 885.889 (ithCir. 1974);
Csn, ",111 Cgrp •• US P.2d. 86, '~90 (4th Clr. 1911).
Moat .uc:h e...es "'vs .1n'l'o1"ed the MMCI t.e&al Dd!flse Fund, but .. the
liftllClro.dtha,uplalnedltt
Elections, and the lack or rupon.l"llnen or a Municipal OO'fe~t 1ft In
operiltion. t_rd thouaand. oC class
J (5tlo Cir. 1971);
Other dradU In 101 accord, ••C•• !'loo!,,!
(7thClr.1975);
k' J
ft.
Hillsl'! Allam.,t !nhrprh" InE
r.2d q~. 486 (1tlo C.1r. 191.5l!
.... ext..nshe cbu action sutt ....der Rule ~3, Fedenl Rule. oC Civil rl"Ooe"'e.
It tnvo!Yed I'I.Iltiple JIo'rttu.
444 ".1.4 143, 147,
C,O
~h Court hu llldiea.te4 on aeurd 0<: .... 11"". thet Pllootabl"
110"
feu and upensc• •)' not be re-duced ~",u.e appellants' .HOI1lIl)"
w..
da)'.lntrialalone.a.""n .....riouapre-crial ..... rl"".,.ClOftie~uvltll
_plO)'ed
01"
f\ondecl "" a choU rl&bt. orpniution Ut4/or
t&ll;
the Coun.
Thr
(e)
sldU, tr9Y"iu
Thi' raetol' h
tp
pufo" the IUd 8M$' pmpsrlJ.
Whether the attonwy cba!1:u a fee or be .... all~t thet the
larau)' a .ttel' Cor tho e--t to «terwl......ed .poot
Drpfth..ti_ t ....t -ploys hU wlll rc«.he any 'varded atto""cys'
.£JIperthe ,alaed C,... put aperlnlcc a. a la>l)'er" aM "obMrnt1_ ft'Oa the
belch of la>l)'er' at vor1<.-
481 1.1lli at
ns. no..
fn' .... lIot be,.a _
e-rt ,houlel OIll'Iaielel' tloe
(hlrln"
vtdc:h t. derl7 or It.:!.t auol'll",,'. hn or cQeflsc••
bU,I'Ill!! • .E!iBo 49J ".2d at 606-607.)
IttonM')'a' ~ product. theIr ~,.ntl«l. anel tlodr pnerol abiUt,. bdon
AccanI1llC1i1'. tllh e-rt _
tM Cou"-.
otfOlt't. of aU att_""" l'ePftaentl"l the na.1ntifts .. d Pla.1m:Uf-Inte ....mor
(d)
l.(.
T1!.prscllOs1mortther,.p1!!'!H!tbyshtattornfT4ustplSssP'toS,
..... t"" bwtcIred.
and .IlGlld talle IJlto mn.idcntiCft tM ....... utd
of -.ben of the cl'lSes vhiell thy ~prumt In the pre-
s1..lIlUW.
nUt
_ t of ti_ .pent "" nalntlCh' cowoael ren" C.cu. utd NaU,
• nd PhintlCC-Inten",or"
cluded their doine other
(0)
c_ael .. rthllr, on this ease has nccu... rll:r pre-
heal bualnus. Then .... ~ft\ no recIIlcthn
in t"
DCA'",n'".
8eeauM of the UfOUIlI.l and co-p)vt n/ltvre of tlU. ease, it h ycry
cIlfftalltto.poc.u'ya"O::UStOlMryCee. 1t
a-..nt or inc_ camed "" Ph.1nttch' counsel ~I<Pft, or n.I .. UC-Inter-
b7 (1)
vO\or'. c;oUO'IMl Darl4ow, .lnce the)' ..."e ~ero capltl)'ed "" the Sc:hoo1 of ~,
cuft_ryf«.1nthiaal'Cll.'
Te;U' T"chllnhenlt,., 4un."lldl,• ..-it Iftd.have4cn.t.... thclrtl_ .. a'l'aU~
able r,..the rsqui..-nt, of tbdrteac:hi"ll Min at th<lSchoel ofLo.".
(1)
jail
Ho~y"r, 'OII,,~idanc# I. provided
reported clKt,iOft. 1ft other ea.u, and (1)
h
MUlar J
rd.,. ea...
earl
tltltCcNrt
the Court'.
9>fft
knovled&e of
«11 F.Supp. SJ5. 857-860 (H.D. rla. 1975), a
ntH $60.00 perl'lolO.r for 0DU1"t tillt'to a llJ'ur
old hwyn who had bc-~ in prattlce for 'l!'J~ yurt.
The Court .""Ned $40.00
forhhout-of-couftti_, slnce.uc:btl-e. unlike the prumt c. .,
inc:lltded
Qlc:h n...... I.,Cd .... ric tr~t .... unnecc.urU,. ~rlor.ecl b,o th. la..,.er hh'Hlr.
In Parksr"
Haubsv,
.11 f .Supp. 1059. 10&6 (D.D.C. 1916), • Tith VII c..e,
~r
Jud,e Klchey .... rded $60.00
hour to a la..,.er .d.l.tted to tbe I.r in 1968.
.nd $JO.OO and SlS.OO per hour to her cmpletdy lnf!!5J!!dmord ."edUf'.
In SUnfprd DaUy"
rursbS[
64,.II.D.680.~68S(M.D.Cal.197.),an
lOS9. 1068 (D.D.C. 1976);
toclsbesd Minority !M1dadsy Calltl90 Y kdshm
«)6'.SUI'II. 828, 834 (".11. Cal. 1976);
680. W1S-686 (ll'.II. Cal. 1974);
usa
(H.II. Ill. 191-4).
Ta
St.nfgrd n.nTY
Ar!!!IO!! Y Ilsu.n! of T,..d,
lJJir£.
the Court detendned the !..-ber or
01 the ClOfttIn.enc:y.
In ~ the Court found that 750 "oura had
$37 500.00 but then _ t on to ..... n! $47.500.00
for the lXlnt1!!IJ:en.". r.rter.
the up<eftln or ,uc:h
.""r,1, han raneed f ...... a
~
la~ ....
In ",«tit antltn.,t ca.u.
or $128.00 po::r hour fer the leart t:XJlerimced
j .... lo.. associates to $500.00 per hour ror u:pefta In the fhld.
J.rm!!<'n"
Bo:!rd s( Trade
J72 Ls..pp. U49 (lI.II. Ill. 1974)
$140.00 to $500.(0). and aee the .... rd. cited therein;
See. e ••••
n.nc'
r ....
~,n2
'-ra
been upended .... d that $50.00 per hour -.Id be a re..on.ble rau. tetaUine
dla<:ountlncthehwy.,r.thic/leru_lb1.111ncrat.. becau.. thelltic.t1on .....
.no. or
64'.1'.11.
312 '.S"Pp. 1,)(9.
&tld ....e.l«I.blenteperhCll.lr• • ncIthentA!1r!l2.SlC .......in<;entlYe.. beClull
.n-lon in,,01¥iru; pollce od.,conduct. the r.oun: a",Ned a11,. $50.00 per hour,
out ef the
{uahu
6
I" the
l1Inl2csl
b:r
the .ddl.Uon or $10,000.00
call the Court relied on Canon 2
of the .... Code of ProtelSlonal lteapondblUt,., Dt.adplln• ..,. Rule ~106(')_
(11)(1969), Wddl«lnte-platesan1ac""."d fce becau.eotc:ontincendea.
In
~theQlntl"'en.".fartor.... 12O:JC.rll~theC9Urtqu.dl'up1ed
tlte :U~r.' no. .l blW"" rat",.
(37:'.s...pp•• t USS).
In the preaent caaetbelndhldu.1Phlntlfh"renot pa)'inc counlll • ..,.
r.supp. "78 (S.D.lf.T. 1970) (.v..rq:e of $128.00 fw.ll :U..,..era. junior and
fe'" wtlaUoeYfl".
senior).
SJO.oo per hour..,. the LoJqc or " ' - '·ote...., of which Pl.I:rtl1f-hu"'ftlor
(2) Of courl•• the Court _,.
b
UII
ita
~
kn_led&' er curt..,.,. fee.
11 • --'>ar.
naintlfr..r"teM'8tOr'. attorney Lane Arthur It bd.. paid
Since ...,. re_ery of Ices b,. Plalntltfa' ~tlSd dependl In
tM.ca"'''poatbe«lntlna en c:yefboth.fnw.blerull.... b7thh Courtand.
thearu. for rederal Utl.pti ...
eOUn1WU"de<lfea 6 thefeetor'1alntlffa'OOWllelllhouldbe.djulteduplMn!
'OIOrtl rau bd_ the $Xl.OO per hour pra.c:rlbed
b:r
the Crl..-t.",l
Jllat:i~
Act
(4811 ,.:ad.t nil).
fIoooeyuo. fN' at lUc:h • rata III th<e pre_t c:a .. -IoI"'e
erolll,. In.deq<l.te.
Under that Act. the Couft-.ppotnted la..,..el' 11 allW"ed of
p.,:r-m:
of fHI pu.....1lt to the Ano'. adtedlole.
In the p...eaent
(11. . . .
b:r
obYlou• .,entnrt.the.... "'lnO.I.. nnceoflnyf_.lndeed.I• •<rtfortlt
to ... nectthe.. fatto .....
(d
nee 1I.lt.ti .... I.p","" by
ths
slims or tht dr9lafU!!CtI.
T1lt • •ctl .. he. t!!Yobed Mch pdont,. work
Illte......er'I.n.ome,...
(488 '.2d.t 718).
b:r
Plaintiffs' and nalnttrf_
£rt~el,.
I.poftant COfIatitu-
tl_lan4politlc:alrt,trt.hayebem.t haueintMlcale.andn........t
hlHltill.
tlt1. COfItl"&"",."..
I" addition. the I ..un pruented III _at Crild,.1 _tic.
Act .ppolnt..,tl.re _ .... routine than In t'" call.t bar. 1""01'01."" for tlle
. . .t
part cn.1y • f_ n'"'- IslU'" ef cri-tnal la....
'nte fn. of t'" Crildaal
(It)
The Ape! t"J'il!r:c!
MId th, ··'Uulu eM.fnM
The belr of • •pedll.: pecunbry _ n t inYebed in the eln h
...,. ....... a Uldtatlon on the aeotmt of c..... nl r ..u.
_rtle<l, 11 fH..... tied to the _ n t ~eo"ered.nd me _ n t h
(r)
It h
'""'shse
dlc hr h
tiud til" cpm lnems.
..... U srttledthat. vtIcre t ....ttOt'fteoy takes the dak of no
..,t It .11 11 the call It 1000t, . . h
not In
AI me Court hal rerdathc1,.
_11. thh _ld lpore the "prof"slon.l .klll Ind the e"'Plwt,. ."f the "llrtl
p.,,..
th" JI"_t lltlptl_. he Is ""tltletl
Inyol...... and c:o.lol rc..lt In an in... fHehnt
._reI
for "meel l"C>Idered.-
~ Jl2r.Sup•• 478, 4&11 (S.D.'.\'. 1970). Indt!ecl, thlt the _et...,.
_ l n c..troYe,...,. .... llttletodO\Oltlothe-.ntorth...ttornl!J"lfeea
c:aa he' -
f . - H"I'e,..l prt'enera' Mehtl eall'" In whlch.ll.i _ r t• ..,. ",Uef
va. ,rantEd and yet the .no1'1l~' fec. wre substantial.
SH. c.,••
!.o....£a.r.!!S40lF.Supp.8J5.8S9-8GO(H.D.'la.I91S)($45.192.00);
.tSl1ltt
2.!!.u...L.
!!2lL!..
£2!..lllL, '»1 F.Supp. 1)68. InJ (If.D. Hh •• 1911) ($.41.1.50.00);
eta..c.herctn.r.notcountllO&on.nynrepca.tbu.l.n.... viththcaccllcnts.
Tbat b.vhU.tnSO... lCIsc. lt lti&htbcpropcrtoreduUthefcuUCOUI'l ...1
l:!!!ll2,161,.Supp.19•• 211(E.D.Ario;.1911)($9.000.00);ct.~
tould rcasonably expect. COlItinui",.nd pcrhaJllll tI"tl ... re1&tlonshiplOith_
~ J!!.22.> 64 '.ll.D. at 681-688 (Ult'pl sc.rchond schurc cu••
theillcnt. thhf.e:torhwtloll,..b.cntlntheprc...ntlitlption.
(1)
~1.SOO.00 tcc).
Thc
"r~ ...lu
obt.a1ncd lt hi the prucnt aM 1od.U be thc injwlcthc relief
,ra.nted by thc Court, Hit h&rantEd.
n.e
lt
relUltlobtuned"villhthc
proper Cllftstltutional opcratlon of the Ch,.ot t..bbock I+.niclpd El.e:tlon
51st ..., In •
(I)
1M
ImJ\n~r
~nlQllsr .t,"U
IsditfiQllttotindIllCDe:tl,. ..dodla .... "'
....e•. ...,..
I)'routi9!!'M ability o( the ,upOIm.
~rtlc:ular ~Ict~lity .nd
of thcse City of Lubboek otficlal. who .... Ddc.." i•
abo•• vill prorlde _
that h tdr to .U cithm ••
p;pui~sr
A.VJrh in t1_plU'euu
Beca.... of the Issuc. unique to thh
l\lldcUncs 0" tlla I
lnthls. en •••
rd 01
f~ca
thc
.,u.
it
11Ic "'.n dte<!
In rou&hl,. dlailar
cr.
Thi.h. ot course, .....UerCOrtheCourtl.detcndn.tlonba.edupool
J.
h.eduponthe1allll2.ll.",•• factOrll, .nd. OOnddel'ltionofthc other
.uthOritycttcd .. d~cd ..pon.boY",th.P1alntltf.lfIlblltthat..,hou ..ly
CCI\U\selintM. asc.
(j) Tbt "urdu,,..,biHt"" of the 'iAl"
",t. ot at le.... $80.00 IOOUld be ftltircl,. re._ble In thc P....ent Utfll-
It i. ,11tncult toiJup.ne. __ e "undcslrable
lt
ca . . . . . that tcNha.
Repre_.tI_
bcftl ....dlnconnee:tionwith._sldel'ltionot.ttomtptec••
ot Chtl Ri&hts Plalntltt. In the South hal n.....er bcftl 'OUCht .tter by tbe
~r
u
.vo. of li.....Uhood.
....
A. thi.
~
laton troll expcrillftce. tIM,.. .,..
tl .... for the out-ot_ _n vortr, and $700.00 per .ttol'Yley ft'r cia,. tor c:lch day
«trial.
,",.Coun hretcrrcdto'lalntlfh' txhl.bl.t."'os.
forth.vor1lpcrfO~by_chotthen.atntllY
••
tewattom.,..wtlolOOuldYolunteertorep...........tth.PU,1ntU'horn..J.ntitfhtc~lIftor
&ad the cla..... in this litl,.tt...
11Icrc are """en f _ r 1&ll7'.n
wtIo - t d acre. to repreHnt the." Plalntlffa Mol
nalntitt-tnte~IIftOl'
d •• cla..... lIrl'ol....... witbout ...,. • .tnnce ....rance of Iny fee.
..01
And thcra ....
rca_.
Por tbe
~
'hud, and
tICf-1nt _ _ &owl d .. ell
lItten...or fa tM. llUpU
tall. the rcpre .....t.tl. . o( ndal .,01 ctt.dc IIlnoritle. fa • • •si
..... .....
,o"c~tll
set tin,.
m. ch.l1en&inath• .ethod ofelce:tII'C
.,01 _
d do.
U12Texa
.etIOll. of re'pOIlSlblc -tdpel public offlcl.ls In • local
1l>c u;t.-- dUflc:ulty In tlndl.", couuel to rep.... K!lt radal .inOI'-
hie. In ca.... like tM. one _st be con.ldcred by the Court •• nlhanclnc tlte
_ntottccacobe .....rded.
(k)
'"" ",nrc .... 4 hon:. pf
tll,
prgtuti".w rrhtip",Np
09
the
011
d.c bUh of the .utl>ority .et fonh .bo••
the Court should lvarcllttono.,.. (HI to _ . d tor the Pl"nHlY••nd P1al.n_'
• till t _ r ta"'1crs. npecially in the Lubbock. Texa ••• rc. wtIo _101 ...,d.l'-
plu: c&le 11k. the prncnt
ancll'laintlrr_tnte"'enorl.
attorn.,..lnthhlitiptionuPtoth.tt.eo(trial.
reprUftlte<! by the Plllintlth and 'Wntltr_
Jlm!l..m1.lllis•
Respecttully ..bedttrd.
_
Lubboek. Teu. 79401
,.... ......
10Clithin_thStrect
Lubbock.7exu79401
IAMC.1tW.
U02Tu.. A...._
LubbodI. Texa. 79401
1A..<;I:A.JlTlUl
SASa AltTJA;R
HrtI'O T_er, Su.it~ lSOEi
wbb<.:-k. Texa.'').t01
IIOBDtT'.llI.\-rl"OV
Schoo1ott...
7cxaITcdll'ftlYc"ity
Lubboclt. tUII79109
1lU'IU.II:. ~
The ..... 1'" of the
lllb1Ioa
caM h
-..bat .,d.u OIl tM. point. bolt
P.O. "40JO
Labboct.
rexa.,t401
inlftyncntcoWl.elfortltenaJntUh ....d'lalntirr-lntc"''"or ...dth.
"'.,---------
""'--------
1
Thh is to ur'tlfy thcat on the_ _oby of J~ .... ary, 197', umee of •
tnle ;a.ndcor.....c:t
MClIlCI","<:tu.
C:0PJ
of La"
011
of the for",oh'C Pbintiff. t ;a.ndPlsintif'f-lnte"lIIIor
t
•
9OSTAT.2Wl
ru8UClA.~.19.197'
Public ..... 94-SS9
94th Conl'941
A""r<t of Anome)'s Feu _s ..de upon Dd""danu by
haIl.t--dellveri". the saae to the.lr attorneys of recotdu fo11__ t
Kr. Jo.... Ron. Cit)' A.ttOtftq
Hr. J __• P. 8reorster, Cit)' Trial Attomq
t..abbodc Cit)' Hall
916 To.-. &',.11II"
Lubbock, Ta. . 794Q1.
Kr. fn,ri. 'D. Shd,ton
Hr. DeIlnh V. Mc:C1l1
Tn-Ti. 'D. Shelton "Auoc:hte.
1507 Thil"tec:nt)l Street
Lubbock. Texa. 79401
1ly""",.,."COm"'.'=-r..:«=-I'h='....
:; ""',,,..----
1ly""
••c::••:=....
=r..:•:•:-I'h='.;;;...
IU"-_XOI.....;;;";;;m;;;«;--
APP(NDIX(A)
-ll~
2ii)~
.--
::;: &r~ 7;1~--
~$q ~ ~~-~?---
_~
I
~.rIA~·
.~
__
----------
----
------
-1:------I
Active in civic or9an1zationli.
All white orqanizationli.
Por example:
~
III
,.,
Ibl
lei
("
(2)
(.1
'bl
'el
'"
~~~~::fu~~:~~~~ti~~11bi~~k~t~~:r;~hOOl Bui ldin9
I\!l"t henefit ill at large >lYlltem to city of I.ubbock.
,",ould not jU>lt hold. on to your offiC<! to st{l.nd in
w{l.y of best interellt of thh <:ocIllIlunity.
r"'miliar with {l.ny data or direct info on thill particul"rly
Texas eitielS.
Familiar with any corruption becaulle of divilllion
of 7SA , 7Sa - in 1976 election or any of our
c:onstitution",l dililtrictll or c:ounty ~iasioners.
Not _aber of Black of I'lellican An. orqanizations
121
~n~~~;t:~n~~~: have trOUble eonmunicating with city
You ask recently to meet with repraaentativea of
£"st L.ubbock.
"''ho att.ended - knOW' all before.
That was to hllllillarize you with needs.
Th"t'", a necessity because you're not personally
a"'are of peculiar need'" of r:allt. Lubbock.
Have not called IIpecial meeting of whiteII' to
(a:'liliarite yourself with their special needs.
They don't vote (or you when choice.
(li
tla~'e trOuble distinguillhinq between Graenf{l.ir Manor
Apts , Coronado Apts.
,<)
Carolyn Jordan -
x
Ran aqainllt Adolpus Cleveland.
He wa. black.
Talked to whitell and citizen:. of SOut~st Lubbock
~~dJ~~~:~ion on why they voted. for you inlllead
That wall b(!caulle you were belit quali~ied.
Your opponent - Robert Kizer, pulled m.inority boxes
lIow ole! la KI::ar
III
You've heard minoritiell telltify.
Adr.lit, hOWever, blaCks thought. he w.:as qualified.
,<)
~~tcr~~ :r~~~~~tpe~~~;v:e:~:~o~twould
Larry Cunninghalll:
11)
You carried Dlnority boxes in 1972.
(2)
You lost votes In minority
in !"rimary.
Lalilt all in ru.,-off.
boXDII
X-exam by Lane Art.hur
'11
:~~;~n:~~~~~~ Perez
'"
~n;~u:ou hevt'! channel Ii of authority be(ora can qo
in next elaction
Cempaiqned hard in 1972 that 9Qing to reprelilent
minoritiell
(li
be political
by Albert Perez
~:
h: c:ould not qo to dClIlOnnration
III
{aJ
OutOlpent aU in your race.
Is this .&1110 with.Luclano Perez _ head o( IlUlllan
Relation. Cor..isston.
,,,
(bl
Ad'II reach more white people.
By Whose order.
,"
Know don't violete open _etinqs ect but i. not .:1st
of your perOlonal c:ontacta with whites, end white
busineslllllel'!.
Would you nana the blacks you have had lIOCia1
contact. with.
I . this sal\llC for Planni.ng ,
(3)
Zoninq CO!'Wission.
Lenier Park
.I3oftn Alford - Park.
To. Garza or Perez ell_ine about Atyalan p .. rk
Tho.e contact with and liatene<! to since on council.
,<)
81ack. on your C&lllpaiqn committee
Mex-AI!lerican.
~
AfUrMative action progru.l.
Since when have you had.
/
Doe. not fed. law require you to have a~!lrll'atlve aetiol'!
proqr4J'l.
\.Isa
~-Tl::l-.Garza
'"
'"
Public Worh
~~:r:~~e;e~~ ~~~~a\'ing
:~uc~~r :OIT~~::e~e~~~;~ you
:.trect In I..''lerry Point,
Wllh .1
('<,~plaint.
don't
~m
Foster - Fire Depart. - Dan Benson
~rville Alderson
Your program ever referred to as "nigger removal"?
G.~ -~)(.~oN"''''/ j),. • 171 t'Ji'cL :
(}"...~f $U.v'~"o/ IN;r.rAI~
•
J ' , '7
I/"'''~ l'.roruIJ
MINd"/r! 1Q1,r"Yl.h-'r¥/I,V
P/V CJrJ' rt:ICtJJClLJ" /AI ff1L 5':rcr-«. Se.J44
t . j,,£
<
q<mcl!.<7
,,)0"'<- 1,'1?~
I
tt1,~
;(. )fOiV
? (v"'. >1).
c-,r,1f ~q Sfv.ltd
TH,jIrJ 24-J)
~
/;4i
(c5J>
;I'f,(,,?
-II.
y'''''
7;""1\'
~T'f(.4
>T.. . . .Ii<~ sr_~.~~
3. [)'J '/'. /",,,",,,r /!.~
,Mm."",,....- 1/#<$ (..5'~1? (~
.f.- Wh/ A.¥r? (il/'"/'<''''' "'tI~ ~
...,
""1;- ""
S'¥I~Jt 1/1 IIVcr
!IJft;PlCr6Ir" II'Ir/Mr
•
~
£"A.;
1M1ooV
s: P'I5..- tf-J ""'~Nb
r-
ytN'-
fo<'
ilSK
/
.f. 1..,11I641<.
HAl'
Ii
A-t".....,t)'
lVtMr
/iJtI
.:7.
c<>u~(u-..
1f.1"""""
Th~ filII,,,/(
01-)
I r fll'our?
C4.~" .. "'~/~
VHp·"
f"'NCL.oIJ(¥~ ".& ,.,..,~t4..1./PI
feur
1-;
'J,jfIC&
ydv
;4tIMI''''')
eJ",.4uc.l
(YF5),
/1-. .,.., 'TJf£ <'I'
ctu&lJ.k
C""""<"
~T -'~'& .;,r;~ 7}I~, ~v ~
fHt< 1H1!~f1"Sr /A/.F4'fI'7 5CM~/ ~I$' /7 ~r?
I/v,/I(. ,Iv
::r, Vii'"
t
,f. />/
.
ydll<.
TIlt:
>C~£"M£f~7
'/#&4"''1
C_LVj""'~V
1'1I#'
"'.<n,,~
PI $rR~
"'.1
51J('&>
Al.&
li/IU-
f1.'V"'r
QS-UIIAIIJJOIICLY
Ii'UCX J
~(JV~~(Af6lJ
AR"A? / (f./si)
,.,..,. h 7~.' .,. .IN)' /,Ie/I/e
/I
/...." .
I<A'"
1$
C'lWC'ffY("NIt~trJ,
IrLHIUI
IA./ff!'
"'''''''l''
I
il
po)
:fl~U-"'I>!f'(/l
Cd_Til> NIVF/1J'Ift&
't
~"
)40
t~
,I
!
--II
__CLiSJ' .5JIplI l1etf!J1JJ':
~
YI(/ frlttur;
_
f()f!uIflf!~}l
~5~~C1~/:::c...-:::5':......C.:....../..:f!)/--....:.(,I~~=~~'Nflf.=..:....:.1:/l~C.~Y)_
"c'7
. 2, f).1
t1 N f
7H&
4uli5T
~.;J
C~
rx/JCfldAJ /tk£.kMtiJ
MIVI!l(1 A,/:P41!SJM'AfLd1J/" IJlfv# yld ).Ilr?
£vtFtftP/
t1,vp
liJ
dCl)/ € (7 ?t9
Al?rJ c.t;;
'.t,
f~
ff/8Cfrtf1P PflJPf../' """ r.A~"l:
fdr)rr (~1J 1'/111'1" 7~U PJJ(£ t1',IJ /'II!!
dfltc/L
.J~~r;
I." r (J'.i)
-- - - - - - -
-------~_._------------------
-------------------
?-)o
. . . . . . . ._ _
eM .. _
-, __,
_._,
-_._
-_
_ 0 . .." • ..~
,.
................. Q'a
_
-_
,.., ••_
,;
_
'
~
. . . .~
-~
_
OS ""'ILL TA.~ ....."11 YOIl'lER STATUTI: 0:; Dl:.'IlCRATIC lo'lIlTE PRli'Co'lRY
j
2
"-..4~
"'~4'
~
,~
"
4
,
_ _,
~_.
'2.
"._41
"'~
~.,
,.~
'
~
"
--
~~~·~2~;~
;;~~;:~~ ~.
.
, ..-,. ,,_
-.
,
..
~'
,~~' . . of ..
•• ·
...... - -.'_" -,
---.. _ _-,-_
- .......".. . ,..
~
-.,,~
........... - .
.......... _..._"'u._,-.
.....
.,,,,, ""
.,.., ...
....
.,
--..
.....
~
•
fi.~~r*~~~
....-- ......_-"
.. ..-.tt
__,,-_
--,
..
Ucr':I:ST ur PLUSTlfTS A,.~D l'l.Atll1'l .. r-l~lnv~. FOI JtiDlCIAL
s,)nCE ..n' fORl'IU TEXAS CUSSTlnrTlO:tAL ,\.'in STATUT"RY PJlo\'ISIOSS
<$.. c\40hd IUIC'-'ftUltt:.'i"nal
~
Art. 6,
tll'Al.ll'lCA'flOXS ot' \"OTI:Wl
_ _-" '_ ...._,-1·..·"·
....... ,_--; ,
.......
.. , . -,_
,-,... - _.._"
_ _.#"..
........
,
,
...............
,...
..._....,-"-., >-.,.._,,'" ,.... .,........_., ".._".. · , _ · .........
,
.. _
,.,,..... _ ,,-. '.'- ,........ --....-"
..
,.. - ...
_._ _
...............
,
,.,
..............
.. -., ,,_., .. , ...
'
'--'
,
_
,
,..
~
',
_
~.
',
,
..",.
"~'"
'
h
•
,"lr'·.·..'i"l::
r.-~q .. ;)ll""-lt.n~; polll".~; .....
""""I...,. '" A ..nn1I·,..,....
5«.~. I:'~f)' \>0-.....>:> ...1oj,..,1 h•• ~",,-. "f lIlt' f. _-.'):,', I!'; ."
bltON ,,'100 .I,,,lll.n'~ "11..,,...,1 tl,.· :...~ "r IW"t.l .... '
I~I' ";".
and who .1",UIlC' It dtiz..... of th" lI'Uh~1 :-:'I""~ ", ' ,,), ' . 111m',
n-s:&d in this ~I •• I~ one (I) ' ..... r ,...·u I"'" •
I" :'" ,I.• \ ...." .0:. Ill.
Ia&til"'(G)n"'ltt..... I'hm~d.llrio:t
"'I)·.lI .. ,.'.'_ ",1'1.··.11
""',nto.·"tt'•• hllll....,"'.~I>eolllqunh(,· I,h-lor-; .",11" ' .• 1.,1 (,'rIM•.
.n)· .·,':"r .. I:" i.I."uj~..... \.. flo '· " I~·lll. \ 11I1,1" t
of thcll:i\lt~ or T"!l:lI Jhanl:",'" I"~ki ."mll". 1><-(..,,, ".!".,.~ '.-"\'
.t allJ' ,1,...-11,,10 ,n 111.. Stnt" ,"ltll.. ~l .. '.....1.1 •.. ',. , • I) 1,-" I
roU ta", "':u JI"Ild 10.-(.,,.. II", I ",1 ''-'y "f F,~., "" •. ,I J' •• ~ ,l",~
~":dIOll. 0. If ..... ;.1 "01••• h.~U l",,~ ~.,
Ill' I
.1,-,' 1,\
nuipt, ... or .1.... AlII,,·.:u<' "",y I.....!>"II \0.•• P' 1'.·.1 ,.. ",I" "J~'"
""L.;"C.rrlfb'·ltbrfore.oyoffi<'e• •utho rl·.d1 0
·r ....'I.
WI .IIC" tas """til" h:u ~ 1..01. ~ll"h all.b. " '1,.,:1 J_ ,,,a I. In
..rill"C .nd Ietl with the j'kll/t' f't tho ,,~ -tl....
n.· t.".I,~,,,1 m~'
pal tlw poll las o(hil ..·;C. . .1d n...,i~rtl • r'.... "· ·I,,·,'l'.r. I" l,l.
maaan'. lhoe ... i(o nQJ'" ~)' 'M I"'U ,,.. of hrr h -'."
..; , .......
t!llI~ptthr",ror. TholI...,;.. I"w..· ... "'·,l·nlo..".'·M
.·1·
in•• Aact tlti. pnrt'iI;OIl of 11M! ('IInllIlull"n oh"lIl• • ' . ' •. ,,'1 ..
.·ilhoutl.... _il'ofr"rlh.... Io'f'i.I"t· ..n AI
nol.,,!,
ArIllC"d . ' _ of IIIC' U..IIl'J Stltl....... c''''''ro-"t I"
II .... r.
In lltllUlon. "r a .....d.. d. bu, which VOIr" in 1,,11
.,1.,
In 11,11,"(lon, or • •nd"d; .... d. 10 aid the Co\lTl
I"".
wt
lndnlnl_", aCDP1of •• ch
.n
.·r
.'r.".....
ALJEIlTPEUZ
T~CAlZA
I'.UXK.\U
!.A.1f[Ullll:11
ll ...." lCTfIIEaAllCKAIlTllU.
ROiLlTI'. llI.VltlOW
DA.'ilna.I[l4$OS
1
1:'
_
h . . . COII.ttt"tioo. ATtlcl. b. S."tlon!
".b. 1. 1968).
""II I~'" p." .. I.I"" d.1Pltd.
A".~fLl
«"irM:l.n 01 U~n1I'lio".1.c ~n.id.d '0
...d«l\ln'yol'll..,.. [ld.;o«. •. J
ARTICl.E VIII
<,
vo,. 10. S,U" <!ilt,icl, municirll
T.\ ,ATlON AND l:EVF.NUt;
I·'I~. '·.'::~.:~t~,:r:~:;.:tE,::~:::u:r;:;;,;,;~:~,~~~r.:S~
. 'n ~
•• ~
I
~-..,
' '.
~,; Il.
'·~d
n,,,,;.t'OfL
,,~:.~ ,:::~ ~::~~:,';-;,. ulr..rmi";
.umpli
,
.
Art. %9a. [Z942) Liab".op<>ll ..
A jM>Il IU .bU I.e ...1'. ,.-.I , :,. nr1)' 1........... I~·l
11M- I~' •
.....nlr_.oMl.,.. ".~.... I ' ••• kk.l"'d,,, ..,.'
'I,
.~ •.·,I.I.".. '.' ",~~ 1M" I,.!•• I
... d..n.b••ndl""- ..11.. h>" ~'I I
!.'VI. o' vc'nunc"lly d",
Ihk.I. ""'r'"" It .h>11 I~ I' .J ~l '1 .;, ,..., ....... IM- ,;nl •• ~ .. 01
CkI<Jbc.....llh.6b.o.Lo.· ..!I·.·'Wl'1 ',l..... 'r~' ~nlll<.l""._.~""
I"'}' " •• holl l.oc.nt"I<-.1 ... I·,. ,....1 t."""'I'I••••" ,,1. ....,1.., U~ •• a,·
IInpawl. 11;1.: Arh~lhC:> l'I.lll'_ III
",,<1.>.'"
J.......,'I p.... n1i,l:,u ....}.ln.' ......."
""M'
. - _,..
_-,
--.,_ _-_
_
..
_
.._...
- -....
...._,_ -_.._
-_.,_. _ -,.-...,.-_.
'.v_
.................
...... , , _, "
__
.
. ..
,..
.,.
I
_t>o~~
§ 1.
Tall•• Conatll"tIOfl. A.tlda
a.
~
~' =~'7.'
..'::.",:
.
.;.':"
:-:::..
:.=':..:..:..~
..._
_
••'...
...__. ,,._ro
AU 1'n>l"Crt1
......_
.~
,.. ,
_"..
,
.,...'
"""
,_.,,
,
~~::::
_. _
..-
_
..-..
...• ... ,...
.
..
"
,C"• .... I
~: '.,;~
M'_"
..• ' .'.
_
..~:~= ....:.,"':":;=.
..:',M',:_;;"-: ':~
. "." . ;',":::'"
'.'• •' 1 "
.
~
P
,
,_ ,,.,.-
::£',i,;:-::~~:::: :::.~~::
~:~~~~:~!~:!?:,:;F:'~~~;~~:;~;'£~~~~~~~:@
topollt. .).
n
,,'
L...11_ ••• •
.. ,.,• • • - _ '
_~~.-
:.=:"..: : :'.
).....,I"...i' ......
1 I~"ll"" .h~\l "" '''11~,1 ,"", "Illr"rm.
..
-
~·
~
=::'•.:::.:...~~.::.',;.~":'.~':
.':::I:'~M:'~~'~:::~;:;:':; ~::;;:~;:...:--:~
~" •.• ~I I
,
_
".~
__
M.· - -
.-.~,
.
, ..
",.~'':
.
"",,,,,,,.,..
, . . , . . . , . . . . " ••
,~,
,_'n
..'
, , , . , . _ , . ., .
i~i~~J~:~~:\." ;::i:(.:L;~;;~~
h ••• ~vl"d Civil SUI"IU. "Ttl I.. ~j\q \r"pl"c"d b'l [l"e1ton
SaCtlOfl 1 (app.renll., not upa.led .••
Cod.,
An. S.09 In 1"1).
~titS.08
_oil, _ _ ........ _
,
•_
. _ .. _ _._ ..._.. _.
.. "
_ _ ' ."" 11_0...,
........ ....
ra."
-"""--"'-"
.
.,.,
~
•
III
~~i~_.:_~_,J~~ E-~~-~~-~~~~
Art. 5.02
Art. 5.09 U.bllll, .. ~, p<>IllU
Th. . . .Ioall w
l.d alld co>ll«loed from .'cry 1"l'>On 1;OO:.. ..,n
tIHIq-"""ft .....Lt H ..... ai.tyyunonlhellr<td::ydJ··"."·l
of e.:lCh }·Ut.nd .-.iMnt"ilhl.. lhil.l.al.on I!' t 11..1
hl
.al.poll\.uofwo.doIlar.ndfiflttc:nu.olledoll.r"f"'''lfhah"U
bef()rtlloUtneritoflh.f
athno:;l'.ndfiflyttnl.f,'r"'''er.I ... '· •
... u.pU·...,..,.;llru'·ided.ht. '·.r.tllatlhef'fl)·..:en:I"'rtlOfloflh.
lax for.enenl1 ....·... u.pur""""".halll\(l( .... ~'·,e-t, >dtol!fflfo.l
1"""_hll;\lll'orlllil>C!.I'-ewhoha'",ioolahand,,,f.'.
1"- l>ftllllo ... ntl)' diMlMd•• nd d_llIerI "elerans of f",e'!:" ....,.
..-lltorcllKhdianbllllyil forty per ttrli or more. or from ",a"llftSl}(
th, .ct;~e ",Ilitl. of tllilitale "h" •• eud"l,t IhO'C'fr"fI1 un<le.lh.
provillOl\ll of Artklea r.IllO lIlld 6i1l of Ih. Re,.-l Ci~11 S"'lut..s
ofTuu.1925.OIIpolltalrnteipU ......-ttopt.--.au....ptf......
the fifly..:...1 port_ of the La.. lhe ta. c.oolltn<M" -hall make lhe Malion. "l'uliaJ uemloliorl.
" flA\J"r th4' rl"lllln1 the....
fo••• nd Ilith penon IIo.ll nol lie iuu~ 0' I .. l"'lU,red v' ,,"',,~i.. All)'
othtr .... ldell« of the ne"'I'Uo". Th#tllXlhAlJlo('l'I'id.t:.n)·t"'~
bttWfftl the finldayotOc:t.>toer.hd Ihell,i'I)··fi"lcb)'orJ... u~ry
follo--in•. bot.I\ dales ;... h....... and oiu.lJ bf' I>"lld ;11 I~~ _":1)' In
,'Ioltlt. lhe lufl'lTer rnidtlal lhe Ii..... Ilf ••).......1; .nd tIM I
•
....henlo.. l'*Jlil, ....J1I.ef'nt;tll'll\.o"I.Il(lII ••'.~I'
r"'fl".
other \.uH An! unlllold. Atta 19~1. G~nd 1..,..-. I'. 10!i7, ell. 49~. a".
oil; 1!l:'!l.!lGIItLo-..• p.I~I.dl.r..II; Acta 1!lG:1,::.8tll Lo-r.. P 1017.
ch.421.fZO.
..
......
H..,.....I
't~
rloi•••".rlr ,'• •r"",W h, Ad. I!'"
p. I.
~""(
_.
t". t. f ,.
••r'.
rll.t",..Ft~.
$.0:.
A... 'NI.•"" ....... "N.......
.
~
Teu. tt.ctl .... Cod"
Art.
~.'la (.....d.d
to d.let. poll tn,
relo.
I, 1967).
,. -,,,
I.
""~
..... , . . . " " " .... 11.
IJD.. Itt CS
l.lfJH. S,·,I..tloricalllOlr.
.
• • ". l'
~
....... -.- .........
Art. 3104
IILE("TIOxl
(Titlt 50
COllin itl<'c o( tht port)', \\ ilh tht as iotallce alld appro al of at Itast a
majO! ity tli th,' 11I1'1111'1'1 "f Ihe e<lullt)' I'xl'cUli,'e cOlllmittec'. Such pre'
sid ill\; jllti 'I' <h,11I sdl'ct an " sodate ju,ll:e an,1 two clerks to assist ill
I' mlllctill!; the dectilln; two sUI en isors may be chosen by any Olle·
founh oi the pany callJidates, who, with tht jlllt/:'cs and clcrks, hall
takc the oath rClI"in'd oi sllch oOil'ers ill hell",al elcction. Two addi·
tional clerks may VI' all'"illtc,I, hut Illy when, ill the opinion of the prt·
sidin.: ju,lhe, th II' will he m re thall 0111' hundred \'otcs polled at the
primary e1cdi,," ill the precillct. [Id.]
HI.toriul
l"ft,m \""rnoll'. ("Iv. f:;l. 1!1t (ltll\. ('1'1.
SC4 lUI) Drt '0 '. \llIIllllns tt"'h,rN", the
re-'llIlrrm,.nc Chill JUII"., clerk or lupenltKIr
,h,,11 hn\'t!! f\l\1tJ pOll l.U~
Art, 3105. [~090] Judg.. of primary
.1",1'1'5 ,,( prilllory ch'cti II h3\t the 311 h,',ily, alld it ,hall bt Iheir
U\1t~. to :ulmll1i:-h'r l':lth . tu pr <l1ocr . "pJ~'r at 1he lceliou. to appoint
spc.·ci:al ulli""crs h. \~ttfllrrc the ob 't"n alln' oi tJr,f~r and to make 3rr~st...
3~ jutl~"$ uf l:fllC'ral rlt.'chuns aflt authtlrill'.1 an" H', \lir J to do. Such
jud 'es allli "".. "r< shall cttlnp I the J, cn'. II"\' ,,( II,,· law that prohibits
1 Itt-flU).: or l'k,·thH\t.'l'ring with none hllndH',l f,"\.,t nf thl' ef1tr3nc~ or tht
JIm ~ J,I:ll"l', :llIll :-.h:\11 :1rrr t, vr C:\U"'c to h~ 3rrt.'stcu, .l11)" 01 C cl1g'agecJ
in till" "'Irk l,f ~tlll\l'yillg' \"Oh'r tv the poll ... lit C:lrri,1J.;\·~ or other mr c
of eon",~allce, c. ,'cpt as \' rn:incJ lJy thi, till'. [ilL]
Jloh'• • , Uechlollu
1.
AI;ht of election Judge to c"N'J' .,. .
1'ntl r 'lJlI"lt nr1 ft. II U. II, m ln'
Jud¥~.
n ....r\ II ","II of 1ha peltoCf' .nd t ,.
ar1l .. r. Ch'llIl:' tJ.r .Jr("lIhtln,. omcer of el.e.
ttun. tho
,r. vf th.. dtiltrt('t J~ \0
I.r .er\", or,I,., anll teN'P tht peIV'4t. h,.ld
thAI an t:l"'('\lfln Jud (' ,nA I". fuUy carr,
a pitt I. 1I.lOu "'. :U.. to. 11 ";r. It. n. 1"
a. W. 10
Art. 3106. (3091-2) Majority or plurality vote
'fhe CuUnl)' ex""ntive committee shall decide whl'lher the nomilla·
ti"n f OUIll)' O"'er shall be by majority r (,Iuralit)' vote, and, if b~'
a majnrit), v,'lI', the committtt shall call as lIlan)' tlcctions as may be
nl'CC" ;ory to lI1al.e sueh n minati u, and in ca e the c mmittee fails to
s decide, Ihau the n millation o( all u h ollic rs shall be b)' a plurality
o( th votes east at SU"1t election, (Id.)
Art. 3107. White primary
In n nent shall a nel:ro be digiblc to participate in I Democratk
party pri",ary dectiol1 hc1J ill the tate of Ttxas, and should a negro
vote in a Delllocratic primary elecli n, such ballot shall be \'oid and eltc·
ti n ollieials .hall not count the same. [Acts 2nd C. S. 1923, p. 74.]
t. Vallflt,
or .tah·. and flot In .. loIalion .f Fourthnt"
~41"", Ht"
TIl. I)n:n lalon of thl... rtl~" I 1. JlrnhttoltIn. Il\-Ilitoe-a trttm \,Ith,.: ,,' S_ m,«':""II.:
prim ry.l tloll" h 1..1 .IUlln poIla:
......
or .·lttf'1"hlh Amendment.
(Il
T ..... , ttl .... 111.
Art. 3108. (3094) Ellpenacs of primary
At the'ml'~tilll:' of the county ~lCecllli"e cOlllmittee pro\'id~d in Arti·
cI 3117, the 011I11)' committee shall also cart I Illy estimate the cost of
&l
Texas Revised Civil Statutes, Art. 3107 (repealed, 1927).
-7-
f-2/
f-l/
l~ TIl~ l"'\ln:n SfAn:S U1SlKtt, Clll,U
1'l:11IE L'lUTED STATES DISTJllCTCOUIlT
...lRlllrso.. ntf.k....
FOR THE SORTMElH
DIHKICfllF,t:..US
DISTRICT Ot" nus
LUlBOQI;;Dl\'ISIUN
JO~ES.
R!\" . .:..lYJOSJ:s.nAl.
lEV. JOY
nu:
TMtCITYOFLllJtoClt.nAL.
IT At..
CIVIL ACTIOS
CHY <IF t.LIJOCI'. nAt..
Plaintiff. pnd Pliinliff-Int.rv..nor In Ih.. "boy.. entltl ..d and n...."r..d
u".. judl.lal
rUI'"c~,,,lly r.l.H!n I""" C""rl 10
,'U'"
l1t1~at.d In tills CO"rt lnvolvln", r;ad,,1 hn,,"r3tlon of tile publ~.
CA-~-16-')'
ll.EQUtST or PUlllTtrr A.'ll) 1'L\.1:;Ttrr-l\rt:Rvr~ ...OI'
FOR JL'DICIAL :«rTICEOF PlI.IllIl CAStS lS nils COCIT
ll<JI'ES, 0" PU,ISflH A.'l:D PU,I::TlfF-l·;nRvt:.."lI()1l
Fl'RJl'DlrlAt.SOTtCPllt"PlIlflllCAS[SISlllISCOOU
..."u
so,
PI.lnllfft .nd I'hlntlff-lntervenor In
,10.... b.,vl!
.ntl~l.d ~nd nU"'."'d
c.u•• r •• p.ctf"lIy r.quen tho! Court t .. t.k" Judl'I.1 noll,eof 1"0 prior
not Ie.. of two prior
c •••• lItlpt.d In thlt
COUll
InYOlvlnS r.d.l Int.,r.tlon , f th.. public
.cll_I. In t.ubboco., leu •••nd r"d.1 dillerl .. ln"tlon In theL"bb""'k County
.ehoob In Lllobbock. flul • • nd tach! dUcrl_ln.th'n In the Lubbo.-!r. Co",uy
J.ll In Lubboo!r.. f.:u~. rul'.. e:I .... ly. to-wit:
J.lllnLubboc1<.f...... r ••peetl".ly.'....... II:
1. Unlud St.tu of ...... r1e. v. Th. I .... ~ FA"Ca!l .... A,.n
.cal.
¥,
(Lubboe!r. l ..d.p....d..ntSchool Dlttrlet). Civil
AcClonllo.CA-S_806;
CI"II Aetto.. So. CA-~16-n.
AUElTl'[P.£Z
""'"
o.uu
~K.\u.
ALaUTrUU
lA'lt AltTMUJI
SA.'l:CY nUBAllctl AklllU.
1lO1IUT'. DAVIDOW
""" o.uv.
U'I:[Alrnr.
o;....l fCYFl ..·IAl:GIl4ltflll'll
R"arUI'. OA\'IIJOI.,;
Anua.'lnSP'ORru,ISTlfF-
"noUEYS POI rUIIlTIFf'S
\n,'R.'lUS
"'DAJlT£LM.IEIlSOl'
' ><AU.
tloA.'1IELM. JU$OS
l'l'TU"'!IlOIl.
Iy:
ro~
I'.TER~[:-; '"
_
I'UIIlTlrr.
(-21
f-i./
III nit UNITED STATES DISTRICT COUllT
IS llIE nnrEO STATES DISTilICT COL'RT
rlli TIll: ~UlllllEIl."
FOil nlE 1l0llTIlEIl.1
nll/TIlICT Uf TEXAS
DISTkICT or Tt:JlAS
LUIiliOCKDI\'ISIOll
txIlOO:; 1'!\'ISIOS
J:EV.IIIOYJO!'ES.ETAL.
IlLV. JM'J~ES. [TAl.
THE CiTY or LUIlIOCIt. ET Al.
rlD:CI'NOrLCIIOCIt.ETAl.
UQI.'£ST or PLAlllTlFF "''olD PLAtro.'Tlrr-I·'TUVL~
rDl JI.:ntcIAL !tOT!C! 0' PlIlW. CASES 15 THIS COClT
u:Ql.,£ST or rUll1nlrJ' ASD pUlI:''Tlrr-I''TEIVDIOIl
fO. JllllCIAL S011CI: OF PlIllIl CASES III TllISClX.. ..T
Plallltlffa.ndPI.lntlrr·lnt.....enorIn th. . .b<>v<oentltl.dand ........."d
Plalntlfh ..nd Plalntlff·lnt.rve.... r In the abov.. entitled aftd ....... red
e.u,..,r•• peCifull,
r~_at
thee..urll<>t.llr... Judlcl .. t .... tlee .. r ,,,,,prl .. r
caae. Httpt.d In thl. Cown h''''''I"ln& rati.' I"'etratl .... of til. public
aehoob In LubbOC'Ir.. '"
,dwoli
in
Lubboclr.. 1'n.&I. and r ..etal d18crl.lnatIOfl I.. th. \.JJbboclr. County
JalllnL ..bboclr..T.lla...... pectlv..11.to-.... lt'
at,
dl.~dllhatlon
O.."bbuclr. h"lepend#lIl Srhu<>1 018trlct). CIYII
Th"T •••sldwcatlonA&enr,
(Lubboelr. Ind.. pendent Scl"",1 DIHdn). ct.·11
~tl"nlli...
2. \'.&1
In the LubbN" Count1
re.pectlYel'.t&-llI.'
I.Unlt.dStat#. . . f"-erlra ..
at al.
u
nd r.el.1
J.1l1 .. L..bboclr..T.Il
.,
CA-)_806;
al .... LubbOC'Ir. CIlunl! C"..... ~I"''''rll Court
Civil Act Jon So. t,A.).76-n.
Civil ActlonltO. CA·)-lb-H,
(.A... . EAIlTllU'
AlltlTP[J.EZ
TOMo\Sc.u:.ZA
llANCW rlllUAllCll AlT1l111l
IlOJElTP,Oo\VlOOIo'
IA'lEAlI.11IUIl
""'''''-L
1l0IlEIlTP.0A\'100II
ATT'OMETsroirUllltTlrrS
ATTOR.'.f.YS tllR PUlINTlrr-
s".'.CYFlIlEMllCHAllnlUI
twtULIl.UIlSOlt
MAllJl~U
DA.'lt~LM. JEll~
I'lTt'!lV':NOR
ATTOR.'rlnSY'OIlPUllllTlPr·
ATIOIl.'l[UFOIlPUllsnrn
ALUITPUU
""" o.uu
I~TEIlV!llOIl
Ily:
'1'
_
_
I_
PAGE~
I'ACE_ _
~.DAS1[L"
• •[.'jSOS
TI~:>II[[f
D,,-'l;IEtIl.Il'l;~
-
";';'i~es
e,\·\·1,,·I~
... ell .. of L..ht>->.k. "'...
t.:.... n l .. r the S.D. "f T.. u~. Lub"twrlt
I.. r ..
lt~d
lllvl~l_
sutU Distrid
111'1EISKIIS.
~ 1/10 lilt.,
~EIl.\·I\'E
10..".,11,,,,,
n 'Mr. '. : I. --I1· ...... r{~
',t r...,.. ,"""
r. ., -.{ I", ,r•• o -·· ~;
/ " . / .{••, r,
"'""1,/
v
•
frf"'.
11
r.., ... )
.J - _' :'--'"
&N'''~ wrr"
./
'J
.;'~;,n ~I' A .. rl.· \.. ~ ,.., (:........ < ..
(r-~n-- ',A.
I. ~
f-
-)-17
C,,..,u.... r "
AN'
1-??
tI,AJ
/1-J-77
,4(L IF
(
f,f{,.
Wit"" "''Iv<,
f~A.I"~ (',,_f'~,((~
fA) C"'f
C,
rr
tlf""
Qnu~Vt'­
MrhA
/.5
jr.J\.vrllAJ/ -po 111 SI.,p.r rrr... ,,'" "'"
","~"'~
I',..,...,.,C
£ ...
~,,~
_f,
'I/,J....
AA"'~
/. C
NI,1Ndt II'"
""f'N~IJC .,. IT GtU-CI
1"'1 "'''' N' AAJf'IClJti/'fO CffJ fn/'ttU'f .,0.1(.
"", .. 6
OW~
"All
CU.. f"~'I'
()IJ
lUlt'Po
...,,1'*
/'/v;.....rcJ
/"fI-.K"'W
.
hJ
:. .
g ...
e...->fl".- ~rJIi J.
'/111,1)1. "." a.U/ "J
~=;;,.:~~,~ ~ l~ ~l:rQAc"
"$~'lrD
If;tr,,f,C
,)..q,.,.vf" ......"
1.~IIf1J&~Scf.
J."elt<t(j
,4,....,td
~ ~ "-:,,
",..,r
1'.!01(
i.Vfl~4JrTf r; ~V"IAJC£
~'f',,,r
"CM~ J~rm"'I1J~~;:::u ~~
5- 11 - 7 7
/V'""'
{~(.J?f~c~
~llf"""l ,... "'(Jj'
OJAJFf.;AI')I'C
llf~ Alfrft"'<'
1.5"
("....,.JAJuA~C· UJr
1'lI'/oft.- tiN
i" ...;O~"'Cij <r
,:,:.
~~~~:~i~;.:;:.~;,~~~~~~~x:;<>
'~5'4.fD /'I. .,..,~!J .. nftS"
C,.,~Q.. ,fM~ J,,~~
I4.t-w~' /fUAIf.#II'J#'
<
s
TIH£INHRS.
1oI/IGHM.,
.. ,1
'.'':~,:.::':~~:r~~~~.:'~_1~p':::¥: ~~ ...
+-). ,-
DATt:S£lVleE
I'EU"OR.'lED,
~
'!t·:l.ll:
(6: 'f1'#C""J,Jf tlJJ
/1-11-77
w'111 (,_(NfOA/n
S-f-??
r
fttl1*n
~&U","~ ru (../"1 P~JtIJ'P
t&'f'ra,. ~ A~f.lIJJ'tf,rlW IC~"
iF
CUtJ AcF"1'o1
.>. cf)
CIJ~
(1.,1. '$':"(1'''''/ lJo.J
,.,.,..,. ,.",j(. lJ~ rillS
J~u..IJ
af~
,KAi""NlfWiJ
/'tf0.,ru
~fI
."..,..,-.,. ",,!I,d
7'6)J'r,).
1/«: CCAI1
f.,.4.
"'7'
'n
C'N'(A#JC~ ~"."
~
c,."
1,.2..
¢#Ul1:'/.I
J'T'f.l#f'II'IJSj
,ltd
~~: ~-;:;;U"~':;; ,,~MOC:J1f'~.,.J
pnMAwltf"U lJJ •
rt:rt
"".1"N~ -,it a"o.fl'/fI"A~C£"
M
/ _/ -77
,4,4J1J
£1l ..
AIl<.fld
:>t. <:.""I,i<
fIt" ..
7-2 D -77
I"f~
U-tG" .."".... II.t¥.,t.I'f,,,,,,..,f
\
(II
to11~'Kj
~,...
$""'.~"
......."
f'M-
of'
~rnlNl 1tI~
I""~I.'" "II
I/oJr'I'J'
"":,,Ad t"'u...vc...
".0.4.'.0
.5
If'
"'fld
,,~ uu'?
S!f...r ...,...
CI_uI/flM4 r "N$1Nr
1'4""'" '.."Im-'J'" ''9'
fR'JhII"II- 4/11 ~,'~ 7-t2-1'.
16-/~-77
J. 5""
" -11-77
I. S;
1/ -15-77
,~lU I;.~K
U"ON~CC"
It - 11--71
1t,(r'lI d
.::.
.
..,)"" J/~rt-'(""/'I ~,.,rr~ .1~
h-11-77 t<~/'(""'~ }~Uf' ,,,r,,r-l. /.
fIlU,~£ c.'''-j )11' UP ... •"It r~-,~' •.i\
M"f"f!!}
-rE,IT,F
,~.,.,
1'1 t"tvfo" Itlft~>f"<.N- !'ALt
CI.vU'-"'<L:
I-
&1- C,WoISI{
('AK'loIfI""~
ffr
-If
a ..Jr
l'''C
/.0
"Mu ChI/tEL
-'"
r.,.,.0'1111.41#
dJl
'1r
~'I~ Ut.fP'
)&CUlvJ
r"J"'''- """r
.,,"",,'o......,..u- ..,wl
elllwl'II'fJ;lJj:~
11""""'''.1'
I#-~ "'It TttjlU'r fJl"'~~'
/.L
r",1'£_a: ""•
/lIS
MfUC" ,,," •., oU'
4""
CN,vfAk<t.
p.Af'f'II
1) It,.".,';)", IIIIW':f
/
-t6wr-s..r-c
\
~-D"'''U(LII • •[.'U05
T~u.: ~~:::-~~"::l~ltltd Sial.,
Cal ........ City of LubLock
Coun ror the .'(.D. of
IIiO
Dhtrl.,l
TII'lEINIIIlS.
&1(lOIIR.:
llATl. ~t:RVICI
I'(RruKl'ltD:
T1K£1:-1I1l.'>.
&1/101I1l.'
SF.R\'ICtRESDtREI'''
l',\H ~l~\'lC[
'l,(H'K.'l:ED,
7-/f-Jf
I-J-7;
(I,()F/t't;J(!'
j,C.AT"
/UlLUf
d~
NJW'(
{,I..Anl'(i.v~. . 11 It''I~11~F'.J 1'fr'7'1
'f
A~
Cl'h•.4J' ,JI"~II""~ 1'"1 .J.4,M~ d-
tI
,w1"(~
IIlflt..
ft:t9"r~
t i-.-("
}1'1<0':
O..-,vr..,(.. ,U'
toP' "F
Sl(~"(& ~f'rf4{#'~ r,.&
Afro/,/!'
of
/lttAJflm' -""")
,,.-.rF,A TO CII,}'f.r" J&t..
~Atll.f
C'f£"
~
"r /I.r. J~F f"Iff;
t>1J, .... 'A.f{) ~rl/"'. P,hAf""o," }I, C, ,),,,).1......
f~~".,(/,.i14AJ
OF b,(Aff ,,.
~,p)
'1~_1~'.11r o~ql-i ~,~,.(tfPuc. Wlf'tI
t"vf' ..,c.rl;lA. 'N !t.......~. _,,4110',r;-
bfUt ... '<.I,,'fo,IJ}
S-s-H
( -7-7'
,..-*M_' ""4 .,.,
n
tFf17!ll
Ft<t.
cr: II. r. 'r
rf 'VI{
'1-
t"',urnthJ<.C
t<tP6 IILr",yr. rI11'*' d""41'M (f~l 1t.,,....,I""'~ /io{" r·(fA,
/"'/t.I'''C
...
n
~.s
1.2.
A./ll4NJ~"F1/ ~V,D')'x£.
~ftf
j.Autr
ttl p".A1Vj
I>V
r~s.d
A-,()-IoL
Lov,r,. ",l'if,<if
t -If
t+1lJ.1,v,
IS
It>- CrNPSFt-
/WrT'rl
r- o,/tJr lAJl'
~;~;;~ r{,:).~:~ 6~,;r.;:M1>W'"
I. ,j
'.7
~lL
GfftM"
C''- ClClIJJr'
111~4 n.-M n
C.
,Ife-tlff
IS
,...,
$""
r
(I~ c.,.JJ'rc... "ItJ df~
..,.,.~"./'IJIA,ir. .IJ-
1.2-.
/IIf,.,:f"/4U
/VA'Tf$
,IT'"
tfoj
.,jIN&:.] ,uHc'
lIJ""
",CL" r LfCAl.~ / - , _k,J
.f1~ilJllltl"I>JY c~n~ ~~ ~
klrhI'lJf~/ ...,... ""'4(.. j ~"AUlff''''' IT ""PfJ
~O,#(,.'" j~ d-'fIIP 6., IIIQ/el ,
<."CJ ,..
M/)a6 1J mULl
OJ~ ()fJ
"'11lIf
I~
iii.
""",T" r
I. ,
YMWU"
.....
,1'""
t'O-(tIU~(..;­
TI ~""It""d6 JU"J,6/lY
TF~I....y
t. I
AI Fyrp<r
..,.r,.,~u
11-6- 7 r
v",.r.AS.
(ire.
tA'"
wiIGh.",~1 rd
$4"'~ d- {'"1<J1'C~1'.
"'11"'" _trM',I,J
!AEVJI'i? ,.",,,
7-/1-7'
I"7'IIJ6'F
'UA.l""~~
P&tmlN MJ 1Au.t:r c.Jf~
)AD FI" """")J~ tJ'1J Jt.( "''''~~
fL~tJJJ'!J~
j,FfTY
l""tlt/"r,I'
c,,vF61 &Jcf
17.... CMA:
",,,....,J
~rl("'" ~#-~~fII""'f. ~
~cn rtl f..C#~ .,..
p"",
./
C;;1::"Vt;.:;11. :;ff~;rr:~u/
"e.71w~".'A.1JMITJ'
fltr'MttTHU "
(-/(-J(
J""";
:;":~;;.:: !:''::~..':",:':~::~J.
!.1m
1
'
,,41JM'"
L~""
C"J~; r4<£ T' volrr
.., ,v'r'
,.<t/fflG".!
,#'" "...,.. ~
7- 12-
rl
t.Jt1J1
dJJ Sl'tM f f qU; 1""IU/
,It.
AJ:'~i:,,;::,.(~-';::ft~J~:':""S";7cd1J:-;'
.s
3.5
,~~ If{1tfCf''' T 1ZJ
c~,& _ 6'lJtf11!)4~~ l.f llP ,,.. "'II"f!
rJ {',~T,,,,,}'F
C I1IJ FCnNel'
clr~ ~
~;~:~' tf~..LI1Ff"Attt"
W1TN~ft~J
fF.lE"${H tMJ
d~
1-/f-71
.S
j.5
H~tUcl our""'; n,
h'WN/AI?- S1A1lI.f,'"
,....
,,- #WNJr
SfP6 AM.n:~
"'4't# "
"'''l1Jrnlt-S'
,3
./
~#,rv ]"1f/4C ",,,- rf
".11& ....
#II.JAI'4E
_r.,..
C"J'·
.,In
3.S
TI/llSIlf.n.
lM..''H[LH. BES:'"oOll
Ga~":;t "io~l:h" o~.~~:';";;u~: :=':;t:~~"::I~~Il"d
;':l
n""'f.':rD,
/1_
7--75
"I/IOHII..:
(<'/'". ;v!lfl. /?~I "'F
7(
tt.-n.,
MIII!r('
IvL.r.ve
1J - 11-
1"
lVor,~
COAJ'-F/II9"CF
[141'::
tJl/
d .....
Tlffio.lllHRS.
j,1/lOlfR.,
/c:.vF;'Nr l"v 7.b",,r'J <: H/f ",~r.u
(t:... /41. f'u~ (;F l y,,-. Jft".
-7 r
e....
1-
l$od
r,U-r;(,,,,Mlfltl(
ItI1L'-
,...1(
...;
~.,.
_S'. ,. ",.,. , , et_,.
w'",
~,
,..,.". nMI'. ~It. t
6A' "",.,,,.,... ,.,. .,..
~
. . - _ ~N
I-
fAJI'IN61J ,.Iff
ftltlUf'/"'S
:z. I
/.5
L./
Att.
C.,ewwA#t, It--
"."....,~
".f4" -n,C'4 ....."
1&-""'''*;
,,,,,tIM "IHA.ntIM,...-.tl.
".,. ,W•• "",..
MIn-tAlI. ~._
C.-t.lW"L ,...
::';=I':·~:":::-:~.t·
,,.
,.,.r' .....""",,, ., f#"c ., celT
C'tNt#~1N."'1aIw ,,"'/If'A iI" CMr
11II.,.
",,"""'JI'J'.
"t~''''''
TAl. I '
ClI'W
- It:/:::lf
,7-."
11-"-"
"~,,,.
" /2-/~-7'
" 'l.-If-"
t,tAMJtI,"u" " r""'- .,.
t:_t.tr,,,,.,,.,.,,,
"
'I' elr,
,,-
/. S
~
" "...... " , It,,...·
",,,.,,,,... , ,
1-71
2./
. ., ..... /11II
, , ' " ' " ud",
~,.,.
1"It,~
1.1-
I I
/. I
-1/-7.,
;l.S
...
J111ShJ1, IIAAA- #HI.. '$ "",.~
r;
t"~~"w"" CI-t"A ... rA 1"'" =-,1"'''~
f,UJM-fT--... ,~ ru,Jc ~~ c'l r.c
1- 1-71
PO'''" ~rr
'1-7~
.2..
/
1- r-1f
A""""'" ,.
",. C_"
.,. c..
It. -
I~ /'/77.
Jr,q
~l'" lif".
JI'fC ;fe: ""...... "JI~
r/~l.
Jt4~ ___
.,.....
if;',
12-1J'-75
rl1".
,.,~
.7.S
&1 )-fVI"W ~ ,~ M~
(.u~ AIf"'"", r
11- /S -7t
r
.-terl'CX
,,""j~
/WI;"
flF-f'bA
~H,t"/!Il
C,f,...,G
P-""" ;-- ~n'JI.tclf.r­
I.
SHVICt 1l[1IDEIw./I,
l¢,r"I,,¥ ;if-UJ
RF jFA"'C'"
,,_ ?-
St •• .,. lllstrlc<
TI:u.lllllRS.
~F1WIC[
of. I
/-/2-11
I
2.5
~P
/-/>-71
I 1_11- 79
(~~rr/l6V .:~)
""',(1(
4~
1~r'tJ,(.
1..
H~H(, 1J(("",.rf'f;;~c,:, .
OvL fl, ..
b(A"'7IN(
/"-'I"vly"
0-'1
/.U1f"P
.If'
.s ,...."
fi.,
(·.'r,,·~J*
"'FI-'!
..
rV"AOTI/V
!".
IV
A..J,........
dtll-..f!<J./
,'v
flo
Jl·"vJ I~I"',. ) j'!'f,J,\ ~"" r'")
d" ffw./'I N~I-'...(. ·v ~.'.I'"
Fit. {i f.;,1- v·
•./. l,../ib
"'.1
r.O
Uvt
(
"<;)'<.1(, .... "
~j.
,...
fV.'~'\-..J'<J
,.~
~S
f.~
l~
I_
-_0 _
-
1.
IJ
.. rl'Oll!ft'r·SLClCOFnt€
s:ana: 01
n..Clt.,otIM....... etal.
1on.~J_•••cal
o._S-7~"" 1" u. S. Dturteo Court tor d.f! ••"11_ Dlou1rt or T_••
IMhIled<Dt¥tIl ...
....
lO+n
.......
DI'I'JtIt
~.==:..;ft~~I~;:~~r:-i'~'lroo:
i6.ridllU....
Dlnrtor...
CflCoor41J,u...r.
TI1,"'- can. te Cottrell. po......le ....
pertwl_",r.Qlll"edOD_t,rlalo ...
' .....1 - . , . .,... h ...._ • • t CleF'
-tu·...u ..t\cM, Vtl_ ... v:lta......
IDl¥IC&Ollf:IID,U
,_.n
I .. rern ......!"otw-n
..... -,-.t., of c....
i1...lo-
"' btu.vow"l
JIl<,t\D
CMf.~OI ~.~,.. _t~ce
",.
C.........etfor!t...... .,.lm.
......17
.....n
eonfe.t"IIlu ..jtJ... &t.,...."
16l,V),0
btoIII.... tl.. ot h '...Id..... ~ CttJ SecnlU7•
Trna 1h11lt,. Mel '''''Ilt n ..... f.r Ctty
ofLuDhoclI.lra'lcloMo.u''l'r
....
,. "" ....
W1.,tn..".rt otT"hrwotor·. Matitllll for
W1u'lt • .t.-.4I"t'll"'f'mor'.,.....edc..r,.1a1"t.
....n
lhW
Ift,...,tlll of1f.p1 fI.ld .. ,
u,.•.
.....n
.....n
.... 2/10
2/U>
c..r......
2. sAo
~ . r. . ._ . , ......
".-.tt~_,
r.1ft
wtl.d1wodCuadal. _ _ ....... 1hort ......,
1_"""_ w!JtII "'tldu............ .-1 ,Mot.&.ftI'Mr. ,.. IIIlw aU... et an... To1..-.
....._
....... """ ... Waal-ec-.
.....n
.....n
t~
ill"-J
~n
....
....
- " _ -IItl..... a..t. 1.....t:t"
.. ....,.,Wt_
..
~u.~';:t~..:::~ ~.
- . . u ftle. ,..
""_rdo
-,
192J .N1....cel
MoM)".. Al•• eaRl e-1I1 wfttan
___ .. _
.. 1t:1pa1at:l.1 fro. Ct'J' e-.
t~C.ct ....11.-..rt: .. _.III.~ ..
,.,Utlca1 JOI"IMlI!'8" '" 1A*lIo_,
kU_ "'
r,.,
••
~'·n
T.t,pa.- wfttnt.....
1".lT.T?
I~1e,.'i': ::f=."~~:'O;:.ll"I1:::':~
'o.l6-n
~:::: ~~~':~-;':~~~~i
_n
11.10
1
.. & S/J,O
of 1Cal.c. . :
., & 4/1.0
.....
...~ ' .. Oller . . . . . f...
....
all"',....
_t:att.l·~,1It'tert:ll"-lC
. . . K.lEoI
.t .... , .o'ot.urtall;
.." J/J,o
=:=':='~~~I
..~a1
• • _fIlllall...
W>-2O
),.,11'·11
I.U
....
\lbt.a1aM .--1 etbtrtrt u"Ct:1 ....
.......
.........
.......
......
........
.......
.......
.....
I'fttrla1
-r• .-c:1
.t.ttt•. ....
'-"-.. .,.It. C&rM. H&rti:
t"I'OOO"OI •
1& Vlo hn•
'.or
atll"'t.th...
1I1S/J,O
hn.
16rl/lo
......
flall • .\lbe."
~,.. Miu.
.......~
tlftclNal
"""U1; .....-
"u1ardol
..-J ... aut_to atctty
I• • •
-.It fill rtlJll1ath"'1
001..,
,1"3/J.o
.....
"
....
.....
Cott•• et.t:ef'I.ab
... wI_. _'-•
~
wI_c,.o:....
fti,1I1Att_
let. . t:4l " . . . VooMnI wlCDpf.U t .
attp. . . . . . . .
C.r~
.t.tt,... " .... Doe",I1t1.....
r.tMr
Jr. J......... 'O'oura -'"'b'.
. .- . . . ~..,.llr'.J___ t ..
..,.n: tutt-o'l oop:t... 0' UiH'n ...port.
t:4l
1...
.....
rUe..... t. Dr.latal,,. c....t
, _ ... trial
14.70
",. hn.
~=-='::/~::"_'I .at.~
......n
4.lf
.....
lw.n
1.1'
",
COOlf'l.t~'
. . . . . . . . . el1.e"""••f,...,,\·our.fll..
1... J,a..... _ .
........t - .......,..t
.........
. .....
w.tu... t.Trarl.Sbelu".Ka.Kt.....tam.
Cuool,.
r..t.. . . . . . ""~ wi...... at
"-'4'"
hn.
_
ktCIf't..Me. Mu....u'l't n pl...et1..,.,tled
I . ,.........'. Se-.d
.....n
..
~~ =~=: =:~ ~~'lft
.....
,. 1M
bt.m.... ~ a.r-" .. U ..... ea.",el
.....1a'*wl.tIt..... ,Mat~tatl ..'re_t...
tl,",. rrvr Sa1tAaaJ wt\M '-'- ....tip>wl_a, dall..... d _
te J'" ar--,
tlb..... toDr.~rDari..._ . , ..... ble
GI'I1't
VJl1 ' - ' ... cad_ tnde
ot_,wA:D~t.... n.l1.ellltt ... '
......"....ed ee,t•• ot CoItIo1..ht ,. ~_ra.
1l'ltlt.",
.l'.2Ill
'/10
...turtolla...liowntrta1brtd'......"....
Jl-.......
t... _ _ _ t .......... , .._ , . '"
rV'thlr.n ... burY_or'. ItDt:lol1 for
~ U~ht _ _ r'........... ~ l a t
• "'-~ et t.o 1ft s-.r-t of _ I I"u....
_ .... "_01 "-deoI ~tIt: wi...... fIl
_ f. . .
....n
.....n
......
CorYfllilkl1.u..Mat.rlah
&t-..eh ..01 ,r'ltI*R:tOll of fnt.rYOIIor',
"-tl... r... Lea.... toA_dt"" ......'""o..••
"-odedC~W"t ..ftlro..rl '-","&'of
..n
~
.........
:~tF~~""r..:.:t~~
2/U>
1 . sAo
1612/10
H
.,.,.
.....
br••
.1\.
'n.
2. JlJ,o
.....
,...
...,.
~."
.......
.mmcsoa DI'f.'eI
~.:=:.. Rot~~·:':':~~:·~rtJ'.
t.\f"..-ee vlltty•• n
....."
hr.
....
....
OhCllU't'l4otpcuti_•• ...-. alt.. f Of'
~"
6·.1?-fI
....."
.-U-"
hpft ,.-trial order ....,antl ••
e.t.__ ..,I.ny••
..,.J_· ... ...
.
~r':;:J=~~'"
MJ
.. tt~ ......cr _eUIlI ,.. ""'tllnMa
1> " "
.:::t~~:'J:::I~r:~"
~ U.S. S"..- e-rt ded,t...
~~DQt~;~ .•~r~I~~
launt._ v~. On' ,.. doeat~ of _btul aelMt"
....-• .u"'1 • .-d'_ctl
..... ,..... n~1 - . a d Dr. J.......t •
~
~t. ... ot~elMd.....
.......
.......
....."
IIlt.m_w/IIr.
Orr
.....-ua .... 0JTf. WIt.... su.t"'. . . . . . . . . .t .... t~ e:a.-el •
J.~
t>_
t. ""-
~ City Kulth IilI"K,,,rl d....a
.u__ 1 -r..-e- •
0..... . . . . fr ..._ .
:n~~~,;·~a.at~..tali;t~~
_ . . t.....
-"......
...."
.....
_.
tfto "".
,.11\0
6"
wi\.oa1,.,...." ......
1. S/10
vir- -..rtU. "tOi
....d ...t '"
Ncr"~' , . C l t , , ' " ....n . f
. . . . . . .eat_UI
wI....-
f.r
attys.
...." :::::.==:.
c.I""'" .-n .. ~ ... 111.. . . . . . .e.-:m..:L.:" -' .f all
....
.....
.....
-,.rd..
rnJ'I"bC WltM" etU-'"'f
wltJa ....U ca_ .. t..u-JI
~ vit. . . .eat_U
SUo"
'Uo.
.. 11\0
_.
,. "" ....
-"......"
......
....."
......
.."" .....
MIlt......." at ".t.llr ~ f", t.npa
!Rtarft._
~"
1.1,'\0 .....
1IUtl. . . . ~"'_·
, • •T8
1" silo
J. Inwur .. Cit,. AUMMJ ... Iti,u...
tl_'_~""'_.Jltor ....JlAftdcr.'lwftri&lMCl.,..,..•• ,....
IU...,.. I....,. dty _.u_ . apet...tl-.l 011.......
Jlll"Ci
""-"t_
.....
c.del'T'ed ~-.I. c.r.a... , ..... at City
IIa1l ~ty .tty., JlIIlnvKotr"'~'
McClll ....t1}l'11ati.... - . . . .....
-..rtt,.
..
__ed,
.
.....
hty. CMh""ef "' tta)l... Cl*H. COl'l.tdel'f!d
::.~~ ~ ~:::=:;IB~~~
t~l-
hr••
4i_._
""'.,,,
..mcr..~
=.::.~~;.::.~~::~ty-,..
Platlltltt, .. ftalImff 1",,_ _ ..
(I" in m.-atlan" .-11" • • • u
~
_~
~
......"
dlo. . ,UoIu hi "- .....
t.trbllQOf'll:.~eJR£,.•
..... l'1a1ftd.tr~.h ~.r'" iIdledlIUn&
• .,.lltlGftI.oSstJ.pulld_.
=t
WI-"
IltS!\l)
. . . .t t l _
U'bl~Md""".
....l ..Tt.
a ..
• ....
.
~
.......
fte,t1I8
-r..... v~ IlaU,
.,,.,.rt'l
=:.lontll~tr.~~~r.:.:.~~ t~~ 11,I
tIlQM",
-.t"
aU
1"S/1O
~..
wltn. . . .h t _ U
b7
.....
....
S S...
.....
S I.U
c..,U-.d " . . . . . 8tt~rto......... 1~1S1
~~-:=aIe~=.':l'::CIt
.. ~
lttS!UJ
,".
'''5/10
....
5.~:1::..~:=··
...-e_tIttfII1.Pl_ ....
W.ultllrv.
'OS.
..-dw• .tn.o "r Ilr. T.ebel•
..... ~"n.M""""'ltal1atT... ..s.•
U~I '"'~ calb t.lrU.t_ ..
t~
_...,...,
.".
.... rw.IItUft. . . ." ,,_ _, '"".~ 1ft
A-.rlu. utaJ.. P1at.cltf t ..... __ ~ n
hft.... ___ wI.".rt IIl!lt_
Mut,u. trial.
.......... •t
""
t.IK~"
....
....
....
S S...
Ilr. 1'Mbelt. tratt-"'I ......."'4
I'=:
........~~~~
__
... ':l~~'
_ ........
=....."
..".n:,,~
• ....
.......
.......
...."
..-
:'''m
...... . . . .u ..
Utt.... t .....tfta.....
hf. ~'" .... t •••• 111
1" s,ho
wltM.. Uet.4~•
.dIM1.
tu••
....
.....
s
'''1/10
"".
11••61
,~
..........tfI at.... ftalMlfi aUM1M71' .... _
..,..." ..., ...... Tadl _
'".
'lila
) b
......... lett.... te ...dbta .... t . . . . .
...,...,. let-ten t . . .Mlbl. vitll. . . .,
. . . . ~TWUl ........
,".
'lrS/lo
.....
.......
..-,..llaUwidl
iAod',fft4u
",c.l_l
.....
Wll __ • C,car JOlIn
and CIOI'Ie Seoctl
..... ~.......allt.
~n1_.
2(,1/),0
lIe"wlt""'1
lo..U."
~~:~-::~":t~na~~~;'~t~.
"'ern. Ie
11K with Laad.."
WIIrbd.~Roo.1l
d:lfte:t"CWI
./10
.Ao
.....
.....
Ill' $fto
.....
uti.! brief vlth 110I..
tnum~MaJoryt,.c ..
at"'"
Acd. ClIft..r
brld' ..~_"M..l l l
~
.._
lll"",cct.SocI.IIl1
~
_ ntal
ca_,
'oIorlled_
ll.U..fI
WO... ed".......... _ltilol...-ld_ ... trldbrb(t
4" S/J.O
Nd ..... thJu4l.~
~: ~:~~=bl~l~t~to
"""'"I
wct_ ' - .. yt'd~
tift w,,1Ian .. _ _ ... .,... of wlt_ _•
>W....
_~
___ Ill_
~
...t..,.
~.
,.S/lO
•/10
11+"
n U'tal.
.....,
Ibtl . .riled ... tritl
rIltl1.u ......" ,
_Uti.. " trial
"hre.. '11....
oIdt. . . . . . . ._ t.
ro
.....
..
.....
vt~._.
........ ...-.
........... 1lIl
~~
d1I1all.
o-r. ..
tt:lQ;
2 .. '/\0
101/10
l.ert...
lWo-fI
,".
.....
=ff:..~·~~T.:;::c::
t..,. . .i "\Al.ttf
ft...
.ttyllo
v.t.4 wlth IaU CllI ... ~ . . quoelt1 . .,
...... _.,
1_. "-.. . "'....
=~n:':=~~r:o=~~llI
Q a _. . . . .
0-.
Jtcke4~t!ll;'l"rtwltlle
. ..
I'ntrtal_dtlc~tfte_" Trial"U.,.
" ..rice CoIlrt1 nipt woft Hut. . . . tn.&1.
_t.."
....
.
•.
$11••
• ,...
:=t.-:tt::~~::'.:.r=::J:­
=:==..~~~~
Mal
....
s .. sl\o
lin.
~pert,
.,.eft
M1:
TI'UlbU.......e:fttrte-t;
.. Ouu._ ..... .tvl.uu.
,................,
. ./.tl:7,,"eqeI"tiJI'.J._.
... tr1.&1.
-ur ...u_d.,
..h
.t~,_""'
.....
.....
'''11\0 .....
e:..t.""'"~
r _ " ... u.... '"
..... rIl t " " - n Jft~ htt.n tl
.......
........
t.ct
Hld'ooph.ofPlahlttft l ,r.Dd.bltl4
.........
o ......
uta1 liIhl~.
hr. e - - l , R.-.t." ... Mo:CtU:
...........r.J
and:_~_6t~1
....
!nur"l't .....d Dr. 0". yUh HIUt l:all
_
.u
~ . . . .. - . ...d flItCU~ of
hoepued. Uld tUed ftMl wltna.. Ult -.I
Ghlblt 1.hq .'ade
ot Idtna.. LUt,
!qert'. "pert, IddMt. " Of'dlll.... _1
•".00
•
4.40
$
7.TO
.. t . .tt-Jqu..t1 ...
01 Dr. OITI
'oIo~
,.......
I.,. _
l . S/J,O
.....
S10. _
Tltallll U••• Dhtftllt e--t,
.......
........
........
~~.Ul.::
:r.::-~ ~,-U"l
Tltal hU.,. DltltlttrtColln,
e.t_
•
~-.. lIal1.
tfta1 .enUCJ"
ClNa ........11 ...
• t dd'etl
_'"" .. :I Can.a
wltlw._ ...
wi_."""
atal -r_oe lJo Jude'"
a..a-.,
trial -..a.-..I _al 1.-1.5_'"
OIIIt_tIlt• •n-.,.tel.l.lNl. _ _
'".
4
66' 71\0 lin.
l.O ..
6tt
sAo
sAo
'''5/).0
.
.
"n.
6tt 51\0 tin.
.....
...,..,... t.
-.t_~·f
....
JWI.9. 1911
Iho .. r
Fllct ..al In ..eUllatlon
J _ I 0 , 1971
Fact.... 1 In..eullalton
J ..n.. 1J. 1977
tIol .. crll'rlon of Worlt
"prI17.1977
Fact ... , tn..enllatlO<l
JWI.17, 1971
2ho.. r.
JIlM20, 1917
21/2 h.Q .. u
Prep.utlon ofcorrupondeoce
Ja.21. 1911
I.~
'rcparatlono(corrltapond,nca
J-..el1, 1971
2ho:Nr.
1~.
1917
"pr!!
n,
1911
"prll
n.
1917
"prll 28.
191~
fact .... lln...atl.ulon
I'r"patulonof pl. .dt ....
!tay6.1917
.'act ..al In .... uJaulon
Fact... 1 J" ..... tllatlon
ho.. r.
"act.. a1 In"ealllation
Conr.. rcne<o .. lthOlherallorney.
JWle28. 1971
1.5n<otlre
Factua] 1"""UlllHlon
Juae29. 1971
l,)hour.
racrua]
JIIMlO. 1971
l.~
hours
' .. cI"11 1""".tll.. tIO<l
J .. ly2. 1911
r"ct ..ll Inveatll.. tlon
J .. lyS. 1971
l.2lkJurs
!'tayI9.1917
JuJylJ. 1971
1 hour
Fanull In ..,..tl . .ttOQ
lU,20.191'
Jul, U, 1971
lho.. r
, ..ce..... I" ..e.tlgulon
....ct ....lln..... tl latl""
Jut,U. 1971
.SlIoour
f,n ... lln.... nllatlon
July 21. 1911
l'Iay 24, 1917
~yn.
F.ct....lln... ul .... rlon
I,,_atllatlo~
".ct.. al I" ..".tliltlo"
July I. 1'71
)(ayl6.1971
lUy17.1971
faet .... l In"eullatlon
J .. neI6. 1911
"prl1
~"y '. 1971
".ct ..al tn ..... tl.ulon
, .....,
J ..... n. 1971
1911
!tay26.1971
J .. tylO. 1971
i'tay17,I911
'layll,1911
Fact ... llo..... ttptlon
J .. n.2.1917
J ..... J.l911
Jun.
~.
1977
FactL>:llln..... tll.tlon
r."I .... 1 10..,.. t1 I a tI0<l
.';0<'1 ... 1
'
..... A
Inve.tllliion
....ct..al Inltealilulo"
Juty26.1971
2.Shours
July 29.1971
.SI>o.. r
"".... tIO.1971
2.) ho.. rs
r.,etu"!l l" ..euIS"tlon
'-' II,
J.Shour"
f'IIt'lud 1"""UIS.tIon
).Shour"
!'r.'p.or,ulono( prellalnar)' duft of
trl"llrl .. (
1971
AlaIuel12, 1971
"UI"'1 U. 1971
Fau ..alln_.tllulon
rau,..II"..... tt. . lIon
Confer"nc" with otlHor InOrneya
" ..ust II, 1917
October 19. 1911
...... tu.1 In"""lllatlon
CO llfer..llc" III ju..I .. •• ch.-bers
r ..,tu,,1
n'.... II... tlon
I'r. r~r.tlon o( trial brief
I,
~
1\ r ....,.rch
-3-
November 8, 197R
1 hour
Legal research
Novemb r 9, 1978
hour
Legal research
November 12, 1978
3.5 hours
Preparation of trial brief
November 13, 1978
7 hours
Prepa ra t ion of trial brief
January 8, 1979
1 hour
Confurence with other attorn ys
.. tllLt: {(d 3
It) - ~.",,<P ~f' ~~d"IJL~t c."'<J<rE~
8tJJIAI£ff /lcT/V'}YJ
.!fr'E 8'13
-fY8U<-~.(JtU I~ rH~ 01'/
f'l)
tJF U86d~
I
~_I£)
".1
l"'fT'·jl16"TIFIU
7
if TIlE.
ell! .I6dMI
W~ If 7fl~ "."eI.... c.udU/A,J
51'/lT5Mfff /1/ A !J;o_.r~.,.....
IN ~%JS/"IC,.JCE 7lVE>JT)' ),~"!r5~'<'
MI7~E, WF "1I1"t/E,J71C1'! 01' Wlflt;!/
(S DTltllJstJ£P.
RULE 113 (16) -
f!J
M-
(~"'1tJ~~"'AI&f"~?
EENF/l/f{. 1I/~d'7J /if tr
/AI TI'£1f pdCl... F"AJT.r~
P£FI<tF .711~ C_:IIE,(I)'. 1"1 71/1/
J.ltkl5vlr; IfS 1." CV5'T"I'UJ'f"SOwti=
tl/uP5 HI WE a>MMllJi/~ " "AI~
pi'/5T"EJ
..EII'ENrJ IF 6'E~JIII'-.
9/fT"y'.
//J1J" ..rIlVT r~ T1Ie a'''''<I'''Y-
~8i1LE ~13 13+)
.•
ff"EUll.. ~)'U'TI!JAI "'c/)",£"'T.I JIIf£
-
~E
0) dtZfn~
Tf'F~
.~J 5~'Lt!-e& ff JevC/f'c. ~t:4JM;
~
_
(8)
b,c~,,''''''5
-,AIle
11tf#,(£
llt~'''ttl< m'''-~
17T~~~ ""''''~J I'f"'~..-
---
.~ (c) ~r}JI£C/lt.. 'UI-""J"'F'T1fF /PtIl_n~-E"")6~
".
.\-
If".) T'lfe f'/truJ15 dl"'flr/JTTd
rc/Wcl IT 7fI"""'.'''-''~ 1'
~ ~fnp,l.Jc.,
l1uP
-4
~~p-PE_
/)4""_...0
-f..f'T1e6"
lUIS
.A~ .As ,.e$#oJ"" ~
FIll'S:'" 7l>
;9"£
~"J C!-+).
[j)
&1.J(:
If'"
~PC:c,rlcAI.<.Y ",-,,Eel: SSA'l T?J
f,trr 115 r<,(I('JA>c S;fJ""",o),;.
tOtl,r ;fr The
/11'''''''10 ""j
/luel,,,,,,A/Hld,J.
<?/'
(i)
Hlfll..Ll
PI&
(1.)
11"
A:,.tc'"
IF
~~ -br~'lff.
1*."1('(
VAf
"
""va I?'
Ft/-e, bIrr.
Co",
T' s~ ",t.<J
ftf,.r'c'IJlrlO~ IN ~
11fT
Accl:"rt' ",
I'<u:~ rr ,/
c""~7
('(loArj
61
r-,,,F(rwc
II1'C,r/~#l
IAoer
rrl/
(j.",..... r4'~,
iP-pJ ~~~~-J
~~P-L~~"~
~ 4~ ...... ;?ftf1"fE-< - F~rr CA~
(5-71
r.JJ,J:- '(5.7).
Fr~Fe~
,,/, 1'~5r
""-'Ie""
(S7/ .F.))"f- 'Iss).
~",.;
v·
fflllQU..
"7
{-II OJ, jfS
f:J.> 0'.
er7?
35 t.. $P, 2/
:JJI)
(i'7;)
~,- ,#Ii'Ir~ -; fSfu~CJ. !SII
v.
PoS;
f2. L,PoJ;;"" 7f{
0(75)
Z ..."'U
/:~-r:'"t« ~IV _~M ~~ ISrA..Ir.r/~(f !ttJrJ; /ALr}..Jb,k.L1W
<'<, vr£J'7 .7-:/." r <.~r fi-tJ "-lltd. 7t!i);
.
(1'
:S
:~L~lJVIf/,.t
Uf'
p~
7tHI'
I
1::M.W~/-!.
£
.,.. (IF
-
/"fZf..TI_M~JU-tlfTt<-,--U.!..-IAL.J!H_Jt""" /&Af
CAr ~~
lrl:'"rf ,~ 1"ltt:" #1J'L'?-7_,~~tJlfrN# d"',~
;!.,
!JLf:.Cg' ~
!'';;In'''''M!JE~ jT.AIC
AI(~ /4r
f&t
iF
U£!/YllYC ItilX!<Tf
'1-67 F ) i IJrJ/
IIAJCvJfTl1Yf, At-.
6/
If .1Y!I. I'1ff /tifA4(..'t
~~
F!lc"'(J~J~
I,tIH,cH
Y
t:£...SJ:-~ ,~'J -n...
"'''''II.,(AT€
M' /fpc/rlntl.
FI}JJIJJ~.1
_
d:
rl'lKl
fLIcKS
'l!t1'(>(IIT"",
0""
IN
'5"VC£FfYliJe....
~L#C.rI#AJ
Mds'''''
Ar-
wr t!t-'f'U
tJI!NJ l"nyU!
tid
p,,.,,C,tlPC bl~
INV'
IILICleM
e'IC«'
~~~:~%.::;;/~::::
T4
_ _ _ _.z.f"'v'-'rr~.)'1'
_ _ _-J-1:L'_,/J!ll.JrAlurll
--AI
~
~W£- -
8»-#
./>$'
A
fdrM6t
C'wfT't
Mh-
yq!t{,4bJ'f"'
M(lL.T,..-r1Q1lJ!1 Rw~ICr;: SAN
c,l;fIft"! I1tl7t-!'t/tAl.
IN
VIEw
/N(£~AIA/tr
v.4r,JU
~6~ ~'$"",JJfj
8UcK
rtl""l
:Se,.,,,~
414AI>
r
~J(
iF
!Irr
A
IAtrrlt.r
/f..,."'OA-<r,
I
OJ{t~~
C!'I'JIlM"'&,r
hp IJDf
SCOfF_£.
t/f1'~.
mit/)
,"~.u
A"-l<'1;f~
~.u
Cd,u"U-'IJCr D~ J'&v51l;lt-
/flfell1r-
/)11'>1)1J(./rll,o.l
IN
a"",c
,or!'i(/t
Idlf"..."rc/. df )It.Vl 'eN ""
J'rAIf#",/ A#}
V~f'/~ .srtY.""n'lI ~cr r•• r
,MIJ.1IA'9'
Il5"rt/1I,JrAtJ1 pUT ht-W,ry M£t1ltUL--
-l:iI'l£
Tl
. "·£_1"1tf1J A.r
f¥n c ,!'ArliN
""..
PA~C:1"5t;
Pluflot..
AWU$ II rbE
VAlAccUfill(F
l.(!'/l""'f~"",uAf/;,J
tZr.l4r..L.....J---d& Xl
~
/JVr vlo.- ,('.-"E..-"J" E";
cc~ss TtJ ptE
A!1t/(lTUAJ
ll~tAJ_~1t t'~i'~s:r.cr
-iN.
---7
A
""'1AJ'~7 V""/AJ<;:
T},H?- MJJ.M.AITY tfRteJI HIlt AlIT"" "'A' L6C!ff.AI1'I.L..<;"r,
h! . .-'J!l~tfTljwP 10 1l1tJAl£ 8trDJ fUL •
f
,.;fd;
!J(){../cr f'.hMI6S IN
J'lftfISN/ JlfT'. cr. ,"''''tt.. , u.J
t1;-I."~ce IJ.l4cr'fS#JJJ ~ CIJ(~~I"" !NIThlu/ Ar'Nt",t!J..,
rh~r
') 7J!f S~QFtJ
'>-
S;,r ,hA ~£A'hA"'"A.1"'.l'''''''''''
I'VlflA""
A"'&R_~(~L-£.£.uPJMF--fJJ~
,41£"">,-",,J
1-rs r. 2.1 /217
f'f7J) ~
4-t-. ~. '£"rr- CIfIf~()I.L ,PA~/fH fCH(J~L­
~Q") v. MU,f'JUL ~ 1-.1+ (/.$.6/6 (/9?i)
W/'f LLN::....JNV1J)jtllil1.:?-
pLr T.:i1.
I
v,I1,/IE/nlEN.
(CJ'l' CI/?
I!!:: _OF
3
PJfttt;...";.J.,frl<,JJ.,,
(J~
"'10(
B,,j<lfS' /lAP I"'",J
,,,,,,,,,-,,A17E4.)'
P-'If"t:I'~/.J~
/)Jc."Itf"~ FI#.t,,,,,,~ rlftf'1" T~~
DIP Nit" oj NcT' Plt"""'r
T~E
~lrrJ
CA Iftf(J/"'L
,A1A~ fJl AU.)
f:
1-.2 Jj-
~~/J'JI
~c.I'I'()(..
v.
0,.5. 1'.76
S7tJ Cllfcu'" y ~~ '~JJc
~ulltf11
P6l1 IN ~ ZIA1"'£~ v. C1&/(£I'T'HIi~
1-~5 1: 2-1 12 r -fJ lMJVt,/) 1£ A~'/~I4A/£/)/ #vr
C1'/ N6tJ
II'"
TJIdr
t?"
W,rhdtlf' J11/,(lvA'C.
7/1£ ~Nf"n1'tJrlOA/",," VI4wj
~Xf'Uf5PJ ,)' '/P'£ Sf}' C'fk'u.r/ ~I.I~ ~Artl~
711M"" /,..;
Of/Iff'""
!>,/MII#tf' ,f1"'~/IL
/JD(/S'r/)"-S
(j~P~~/*,
If
~6("IF,/
,u(,r rldloJ IN
f),AJ~(r- ~...... !J~'<
bll1'1(fcr
,A/'''- /AP'TII1t..y
R£"""',(""dAJ~b'r flA~,
Ctt,eountllorh.ll.beenel.ct.dKa,orof t .... Cit, of Lubboclr.. T.u•.
Th.Clt'ofLubboek .... lntorpotaUdlnth.'....
•
s.
A.l:co ..dl"ato the t970U.S. can,,,,. thl pop"IaHOIIof th.. Cit, of
U\'. ROYJONES.ETAL,
TlIECIITOFWIIOCJ(, ETAL,
PU.ISTIFfS' ,\,'\lD PU.ISTlFF_lsnaVDOa·S PaOPOStD rutDlltCS
OF FACT "'''DCOllCLCSIONSOFUW
whlt.: _ _ 1;
bl.cll _ _ 1;
IIIldcaa-AMriean or Span ..h-." ......d _ % .
Th• •".ct sluof the pop"latlon. and lu.uct racial orechnlc co-poatllon. I.
tr.. l.th.populatlonof.llraci.lor.thniearo"p.h•• inc ........dtn.tt... ltt'
Jul,).t91a.
_
. . t ....' ... rel .. 1910.
'dor to tIM tiaa wh... the faMnl cou"U btl.... to &lid ...d.l dhcrlaln.tlOill
thro"thOut tb. lI.tlon and I .. tbl.p.rt oftbenation.p..cHlcall,.
andr.eld . . .r . . .tlO11./foU .... lA.t... .sacislOllof tb .. l/IIltadStac•• Sup ..e_eourt
l".rwa .... Io.ardofEdu<;atiOll. l47U.S.4U(l9)4>, ...dthroual'>outIUhlaco..,
II . d t , . th
Th. Court find' th.e th.d.cUon . ' . u . l n .... e In th.Ctt, of Lubbock.
feu•• b, whlch _lIIben of thl Cit, Council and the "')'or (..ho i • • bo • votl...
• r • • l.ct.d •
• "arof tIM Clt,Coundt) /"pr. .crlbadb)' th.o.anarof th.Clt)'of LuIobock.
eapina
d p.rvllive .,.te.ofoHtclal racl.l &ea"'aatlon
and dhcrlal".tlOII l".ff.ct ln th.Ch,of Lubbock. Tu... the eo""n'0f Lubbock,
IlId the St.t.of T...... dl ...cud .... I ... t and.H.ctlnabl.ekp....o", .nd
aad eluot tlla Ch)' CouncH of LuI>boc:tr.. T..... 60&. . .ot h.... t", .utbodt)' to
_ d tlla uld a..rtlr to ,ro... l " fo ... d.Uf...... t .)'.t_ of d.ctl. . . . . .r.
of tIM Clt, Council and tM "':ror.
l.t.... Ut. c.rrl.....ud! .. bill U . . . and ntlroad•• II .... tl •• loc.l carrl.. r.
Thl ........ of the Clt, Councu and the
i'ta'or.r• • I.ct.don."n-lar'.b..... aad.rellOt .."I.ul ...dto ...ald.I".'"
pleeu
p... Hc .... I" ,.oaraphlc nuor dinrlet of th. Cit, of Lubbock. or to npn. .nt
Th. p.tt.m of offield and \IIIoffidat racl.l dl,crl.tnatlon and ,....... tion
an, de.l.,..ud alOa...phle arN 0 .. dbtdet. but l ... t.&4.re .hct.d .t-lara'
.atabU.hed and.inUlA.d til Lubbock. T...... dld"ot dIff ..... lp.. Oc.ntl, fro.
torq
topro
tthlCU'OfLubbock.t-Ia.....
1111 0 t h e ...... OfvtlatIM..
tbe.tre
r
a
a.Ud • •ubltep
d
l_tn.'OII
re.at.d.
the ........1 p.tt.n fo..,d thf'OUaJ'lout tbe,outhafn p.rt of the ·"'ltad SUt ...
d.for ••Utr.rlllt.'ac. . of.l.ctln.t.........raoftheCIt,C-ell
and t""Mayorb'doln.w., ..lthtbeu-l.r•• .,..u......
vot.ra of thl CH, of Lubbock. • ..d ...... f.acad.
no.
~o
black
~non
r.cI.1 dl.crllli .... tl .... and , ......atl .... d.n .. lb.d.bova .... __.pln.,
h....... r bean el.ctad to the CH, Countll or hAl b••n
,.........1_. and CONIlatent throulhout the hhtory of Luhbock. Tnll, down to the
.l.cud Ma,or o' th.CH,of Lubbock. feu •.
d.te of the Ilr....... de"hlon.
Even In the )'.an I_dt.td)' foHOlIlnl~.
oHldal udal dl."rl.lnatlon and "Irelatlon dtr.ctad aldnU black• •nd
lWKlc~-"-rlcan.cOfttlnued
In 1977. and
Juda-nt .... ent.ud by thla Coun pTotltblt!nl
funher r.clal dhcTI.tn.t1on In the Lubbock County Jdl!n .. 14 cau•••
In Lubbock. f ••a •• fOT a period of ..vaT' I yean.
n..CltyofLubboclthaa,r.cUcedrac:llld.la"rlainatlonln"IU
In order tobe elected to th.CHy Council. or tob. dectedKa)'or. of
Lubb<><:k. fe .... a black person or ,...Klcan-"-r1<:an p.non would h.v. to c-.rld
Ther.. Ia con.Iatantly • lOll voter-t .. mout on the
,.rt of bl.ck• •nd
th.vou.of."Jorttyof tlw",vhH.p.raon. Uvtnl In Lubbock. f ..... and
..
votlnlln ...chele"tlon•.
11 •
Th.ra I. r • .,tall'polaTh.d ........ votlnl In el."tlon. for the
Over a period of aany years, the .untdp.l 10vamMnt of the CH)' of
L..bbock, Teu., ha.b.enunre.pon.lv. tothan..d.ofbleckp.non• •nd
City Council of Lubbock.
~
Tu •••• and In - . . . . - . . . ele"tlon. for . .yor
ofth.CHyofL..bbo"k.T.....
l'IaKlcan."-erl.c.norSp.nhh....rn_dpenona tn th.Ctt·)' of Lubboc". T......
18.
Ill.,,,, aDd lIa.a1"an-"-rlcan. he... bft..... able lO ....,ur. po.llion. of
There hal ~I>
• • tantftcant
dl.p.dt,.
II>
the . .rvlee. pro"ld.d whit.
1.M.rahl, In pollU.,al parll. . I .. Lubbock. Teaaa.
dtllen •• on the one h.nd. and bleck .nd Ma:lltcan-AMrlcan or Sp.nl.h-.um_d
cHtun•• onth.oth.r.-ha.,d.ln'.ubbock.fe.... Ov.r.p.rlodofuny)'•• r ••
b)'tla_tclp.l ..".m_tof th. City of Lubbock. T.....
llack. and ...KI.,an-"-rl"an. I.nanlly h.ve b•• n un.ble lo .fford
ca.,alp .apan••• In polUlc,. ca.,alp. for dectlon lO the City
of Lubboc... T.........d 1..
Iy atatuu, hi the Stat. of T...... bla,,'" _ f a ahcrt-blud Ild...t for yaan
the public .et>oola. _n1.aI" Moptl_.
Inn... rou.a ...... of Ufl. lndudlnl'
" •••tlnlonnUroa4
trar:~~f':.~=l;"'::;~'":: ::::~:;.
public lIbnry f.dUtla•• public par.... an4
.... b bathl"l fac11ltl" of coal aI..... all of which .tatut•• the Court hal J_Idlll, - llOtl".d.
Sudl.tatuu.... raap'l1cabl. to. MId In fOTc, In .ff.ct ..Hh T••peet to. tbe
,,~al....
eo.m.,11
fOT .1.ctlon of lh. Kayorof lh. ctty.
White "aadleLal•• r.c.tv. . .r......y In
do black and Ma:al".. -"-d"an .,.ndld.l•• ln
.,~alan.,ontrlbvlIDI'J' than
el~"ttona
for elly Co... d ) and
lIayor 1.. LublKtck. T.....
CltyofLubbock.ta.....
Cit,. CouDcU ...1... ttl.,. r."al .... lh• •"pport of • _Jorhy of ""he vol.r.
Inlh.clty.nor.,anthaybe.I• .,tedaayorwUh",.. tau"haupport.
flat. of .COltOa1ca ..db.. irI.••• opaTattona tn lhe City of Lubbock. T.......
Th.ra 1. a nellUy I• • t-"ad public .chool .,.t•• In Lubbock. T......
..1'11,,1'1 1a .tlll the .ubJ.et of Utll'tl.... b
thU court and In the U!lltacl SutaaGoun
ofApp. . 1aHTth.nftb~CITCult.. ofth1aeLat•.
belal "Ir.ptl" b
tbe Lubbock eo..t,. Jln. locat'" t.n ~k. T. . . .
,"""rIO Is ,1I.crl.lnuol'}' ... d 1o."ldl..... tre;lt.e¥lt of bheu and ,.,...Ie_
Th• •&lr.pt. of the fa"ts and elre_tane. . Nt forth
.bov.
In tbe
..... rie ..... In the Held of h~lth In Lubbock. Te.....
Then .n .ufflclent " .....eu ;I"d p.re.nu&e. of bhck• •nd "'"dc.... - .... rlc.n.
l" Lubbock.
Te,,".
to Ju.ttfy tIM! c •• ulon of I1nele-.IIb.r dlstlrcu for eleelton
_ _ In th) ~~rl~n~ullbo"k, T~., h._ be.n .... connllutlon.lIy dllut.d and ..uken.d.
U.ekIJand 1'Ie"lclln-"-rl~an or Spllnleh-.urn• •d elth.n. In the City of
Lubbock. Te"••• donot.nJoy.qual.ecau to the polltie.1 proe... In tn.
of City Council . " e u .
City of Lubbock,
Ther. hubliln hlstorlully. and th.r.uUIIs. dsnlHe.nt .aclal
_Srelulon "rod Hp;lratlon of whit •• , bheu. and lIed". .• ..... rl". . . In Lubbock.
T."....nd
u.
dfl.--th.lydenl.d.rr.cth.p •• tlelp.tlon
In .uchpoUtled prac....
Plalntlrt., Pla.lntlff-hHe .........or. _d th.......u
of the cI.....
..pr...nt.d by Pblntltf. and Plah.t1ff-lnt....... no •• ;I'....tltled to
1!'q"lubl. . .d6ec1aratolyr.ll.f fro. tbi. Court •
.... • =otter of _
bet. th.r. ha.. t>e.....nd the Court Ma.o find.,
."Hplns and pervallve raeld ~
H •• ee,atIOfl
a,alnu black.....d .S.lnat l'Iede.n-......lc.n. In Lubbock,
and dl.erl.lnulon
In o.der to "orr.et the ....eonultutlon.l dlhnloo ""'Ieh n"".d. . . In
the City of Lubbock,
T.".. , ..lth
re.pe"t to black elthen• •"d Kede...A.erican
f."••.
• plan "hlch "Ul provld. for .Inel.-.".rdl.trl"u fr....hlch eaeh.llbel
of th.LubboekCltyeo..,eU.hallb• • I.ct.d.nd to""lehueh_IIb. . .h.ll
!HI rupondbl., ..d 1,,""lch .ach ..... r.oal.cud
r .......eh
..."hdi.. rl"t
.MUM_hl."rher ..dd..,c•.
n... oef.Dd.HI
ha. .... not pO'dllCtd .ufflclent ."ldellrC. to uubUM th.at
the .ffects of the I_ploe . .d pe.....
. .d !'1""i"_..... rlun. I.Il Lul>boclr.,
I~~~::~~~1dllula1AulOll
f.II&.,
••,d
ha_ be.- ,1Iulpued or
t ilIac'"
...-d.
llAl.IIf.:ttO. WOQ)IIAIJl. OlltrJUDCE
lllUTm STATES DISTlICT mutt POI
nlEHOITlIEIl!fDISTllCTOFTt:XAS
COIl<1USIOllS OFLAW
[... n.n .h•• tl
Th.for••ol... propo••dflndl"•• of·.et."d"onc!u.lon.ofl .... r •
...,."tfuUy .....lttedfor ... trybyth.eourl.
-(-
ALBERT PEREZ
1112 Texas AVenue
~dH~8... Tkxas 79401
LANE ARTHUR
NANCY FIREBAUGH ARTHUR
Metro Tower. Suite t8BM 1506
Lubbock. Texas 79401
TOMAS GARZA
1006 ThirteentbhSlreetej
Lubbock. Texas 79401
ROBERT P. DAVIDOW
School of Law
Texas Tech University
Lubbock. Texas 79409
HARKC.HALL
1402 Texas Avenue
Lubbock. Texas 79401
DANIEL H. BENSON
P. O. Box 403C
Lubbock. Texas RIIBI 79409
ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFFS
BY:
ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF-INTERVENOR
BY:
_
_
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
This is to certify that on the
day of
• 1978. service of
a true and correct copy of the foreg'ing proposed findings of fact and conclusions
of law was made upon Defandants by hand-delivering the
sa~
to their attorneys
of record as follows:
Ma. John Ross. CityAttorney
Hr. James P. Brewster. City Trial Attorney
Lubbock City Hall
916 Texas Avenue
Lubbock. Texas 79401
Hr. Travis D. Shelton
Hr. Dennie W. HcGill
Travis D. Shelton & Associates
1507 - 13th Street
Lubbock. Texas 79401
By:--,A""TTO=""RNE=y:O-=FO""R::--:P:":'LA"'="='lNT=I""FFS""'"------
By :--,A""TT=O""RNEY=~FO'='R::--:P:":'LA"'="='INT=I""FF""--,IN=TE=RVE=N....,O.,...R--
-7-
IJATIJ£ fSF"
/. /lEA)
::<.
(W"'1) - TN'- ?
S... ,ft'
(L/.I-t..
'''''''~lIy)
V/IJC&
,<f....
(1I.r. •. f.
~l"#.qrGJnt:T
;I1/ctlcclIl
,.,"')
~.....,) "~t~,;I
(1.-,) (c "7
'n--
,""II/"""'''''''~I'''.
S'iCUc.
;f--. .....
,,/t r_....y
Ivrr,.,.~ n~
3.
J"'< rIN
.Ir,kl,,.., ~'.N.
A<',...,,,,.I'
/1'Z:>
fltlt& fA ..
;)
4. ",. I"f"-''''' 1M'#' (CVF)-
-
(('~l tt'",rll o,,.et4 )
;e"E.Niv,
/JUtrJl(
S
r-,.. 8"""'5
0rA.~. rr",;...r)
(w-:) -
,vA..., ,...~16<; ~/_..,.
(Jwr
A''''~; f).« "..4l~
C ....".-A<)'.
I
LI/oIfJl'
(11f/Ittf1M
fEU2...
~
j.",6'#Uf" AI"f'U
!'til,..) -
bclt,_r " ...,-_)
r"''' r.
~~_.#.."_".I.
Vof_ ..."
1r-, J..... ~
/
_.-Is,.
~
~ _ ~J&
,It.A&.K
22.
tftJI.IL'K.D
;f~,.,
~;"-
R'I
''''$
6AAZ-A- (.,,, -,..,)
~J£C"'''''IW''''~
-A'.~
~.",.."...
.JI.
~o.A. "'*8ftuu
,blrot-.
31. o' Cllt 1v
72.
?J.
J+.
~+.
c'<&
H. )1(,-
(re•.
I)t"v
44iNi_
tfI#"J'
1M) IJEn fdA!
Dtu...
""c;...~
( .., )
CH., "",.,.,,-.1
~F~Ih»'J
;'''1( IVrrr
.3.7.
~1f1'~
CHAr. ,JIIIAJJlIJ (.....)
'1/;""«
/I·dM.
S£IEIJ~£ '''Ff$HC)
-rJ/A<
PMr".....
( ..............Iot...~
F~,,,,r
T"1'tn.,,,J'
b'Si'Il''',
jlJ
~)
(1)
(.<»
("')
(~
(
(
".:••,... -.11,,";".1 f:" ..
".I'••,ft. nnl'....
110.,' ...
.\1.0_
~~l~t~~r~;}: on
1:........,. C..... 11'"
TO ALL ,\TIORNHS L1s.t:n OS TilE ATIACHf.O I.IST:
:~v~~~; :t;~s~h:"~c~~ '~~e~h~i ~~:e~~~~tf:~ 1 ~h:x~~~h~~ ;~~~~~~r'
~ir.itt'1~:~~NDl~b~_~~~y ~i~G;' .~9[~8BCiK%islON
In r".
C:~nt
~e i~ii~cdn1nR~~/f;itho~;e~~;ngaf~~~:d~~~ ~~es:~~~~:~;:
I.-tTL":
"'t~<I"h .. .:!
ht'Pt>lD ! .. a Pn··i:-ial Notiee and Of'der. togetht'r .",irh.
sc"edute for the cdal of civil Jury and non-jury cales on the Lubbock
t'...
t~hi':h:T:X:~~t i~~ ~{{:~edrffi~ ~~:e"&~~hbl:l~:~nto~~h:er
2
I
,•.,,,ks-of Seplcl:Ibl'f';lS and Sej)tl.':l:ber 25. 1978. All attorney••
<.IlCt>jH those ill case !'\llllber Ont', will be required to be present in
.... pen cOlin on Y.onl.ll'ly, October 2, 1978. at 9:00 A.!'t. for llnn.>uncelllent •.
.
~ ~~~tf::~ i~L;~:{~~u~~d~~lOo$;:~~:;~iM-9i8IUry
~~~m~~~~lc~~e:ilb~~ ~~e:~Yc~:~~t~a~;,I~u~rn~n~~~t}:';It~e~OI:l~~e~~,y
fi'
DUSt
~~~';~:rI02~~r~~~~ ;~: ~~~id~;~~' ~~d.~~·;v~~~:~ ~~,~;~6c::~, c.n
be rr!ec the lint of the wcek of October 2, 1978 .nd the other
c.sel lo,'il1 all be tded during thi, tetT.l of court.
1:1Iilechi attfmtion is invited to the Pre-Trl.at Noth:e and Order attached
hereto and each Jlttorney i. required to c(llllply vtth thi, order.
If you
have .ny questions
to viu~n yO'oJr compliance is due or the manner of
co:tlpli.nce, ph"", let me knOW'.
.1,
S:ledficall
\Ie on or
e
ssues or
or berore
A peraonal conference bet~en th• • ttorney' t, required, .nd I have
found that telephone conference• •re .ast unll:r.ttsf.etory, .nd the
attorneyl> are urr;ed to seheduh a per.on.1 eonferenee betveen th_
in order to sublllit the proposed pre-trl.1 order.
my uoly,
KAUlERT o. ,"OOO\<'ARll
Chief Judge
Northern District oC Tex.s
' '.1,1
are "lJ"iu'd thal the C'ase .....il1 not nece ••aril b. tried in the
1'1
- u y-S....
• v
0'
!nt .. rllWTloed \.'lth (':\ch other l£.uili1-=-ln particular. your auentton
1I c:Jl (' to th~ l"ctth.t I .11I ,eh dult'd ell>e"here cOfIIDendng vtth
.s
~~~:~trst~x:~~t:~s~oo~~;t; ~~~~e~h~o~b~~;~t represented
"rJi:'rl tsteJ a.,d that the JUTV casrl> an
.In
on
.hould
It n::iV be th.u during tht. tCn:ll of court I "'111 be rpquired to tr
{"ourt In Lubbock, Texa..
,to~k.·t
jl1S
the rall 1978 Docket - Lubbock Division
P.gc 1\10
Juty),1978
HOW,rsv
by
v
!
....
.
('
t
......................................
l:' nU.t..,;m.p::>fUDPt'!" . .:TI:lInn
WI. nu: "oUI'TMEI.' INSTD:TOI- Th.\ 'S
u . . .~...,'l'itIDo
NON-JURY CASES:
l'tI.. tIUL~4:'1i1l11aPt:J;
1.
n.
".r.-
,w.".< ",
,~< • ..,.
""'<~
J ........
... .\11
,~
,.. J
""",,1, .,," ,1M
ro"",
.,....... J
f..
1~<_,1 .....11 d _.."
~
I
All.-
,nol".'''''J.·
'''.oA<l'''.'04. E
"
,
, ..
loIl~.,ft •.
I.NU"""lI
'_0"." .....,,....... "...
u.I_j.,.I
~.
A. CENE CAINES
TIlE CITY Qt. LUBBOCK, et _1.
fOR Pu'INTlFF:
'0 ,10< " ....... f.. " .. I
" -••
"""'...,,""'~
C.."
CA-~·76·J4
ATI"ORNt:YS:
ALBERT PEREZ
1001 :-<..,In Street, Suite 6){,
lubbock, Tex..
79401
TOMAS GARZA
1006 Thirteenth Street
Lubbock, Tex.. 79401
DANIEL H. BENSUN'
Post Offic. Box 40]0
Lubbock, rex.. 79409
--
,0111
I
01<'4 .. ,
.,riot . . .
.............
_
w
...
,,,. oiIrono.
_, ,
~RX
g J4-P).
C. HALL
un ., • _
Lubbock, Tex..
p.e,
79100S
f£YII.I
"ll 21'7
Al-'t".",~G
roR ItfTERVEHOR ROSE WILSON:
ROIEU P. DAVIDOW
...-._....
_II
... _rlool .....................IroH •
lAME AaTHl1J.
HAHCY F1REMUGH ARniUR
ARTHUR 6. ARTHUR
.. ..
, ", ,""',_ "" ..........
Hetro Tower, Suite 1506
1220 Broadw_y
Lubbock, Tnaa 79401
"p......".,.... C..".
d<o
"u ..........,
r.
\U,.. " .....
r
1!.,....,nel~.~_-.,
........... _.w..• _ . _
C n,..,...,....oI
School of 1..Iw
T.u. T.ch Univerdty
Lubbock, Tex.. 79409
f.. ",.J .. ,......,.......... ,....
e-n
FOR DEFENDANTS:
,....,.;,.IoOl;j".1M-c...n." ... . - .. r.....................
.
~
e-n.CIm.,
~ ..,
• ...."...,
'!..!"'!....-
FRED O. SENTER. JR. CITY ATTORNEY
JAMES P. BREWSTER, TRIAl. ATTORNEY
lZOlf lEAN, ATTORKEY
DQMAU) C. VAJfDlVER, ATTORr.:EV
City of Lubbock, Teu.
Po.t Offic. Boll 2000
Lubbock. Tna. 794S?
nAVIS D. SHELTON
DENl4IS W. Hc:CIU
nAVIS D. SHELTON 6. ASSOCIATES
1507 Thirteenth Stnet
Lubbock, Texa. 79401
... _. _. -
- - - - - _.
- -. -. - - - - - -. -
- - -.
-.-
l..EA1llERILY INSURMiCE COKPANY
v.
ATTOiUCEYS :
J. A. FINLEY d/b/a Jilll FInley and
A••()Clue.
FOIl. PLAINTIFF:
WIUIS I. TAYLOR
2206 IIroadw.y
Lubbock, I.....
79401
FOl DEFENDANT:
H. J. lu.I'fCHARt)
IIIJJtCKARD 6. HEDRICK
:~~t~~~e=~~ Id~8'in 701
Coloflldo 511 tel
-- - -
- ..
-
C~IJ[£>U'./J
/5rl/Ef IJP LAW:
/. /{/!PTH& tClj)JJICKY /fr-t.~((CF
cy
C"ttlKIL El/,crk!,v 5")'fTF~ I f VA)~~~JTlrllrl(AMc.
dr )I:(lr I,A.!
!YJ:CAVfF
srR£lVtfn!
r
of
~IU'II'7 V~rFt<.
("0'; 1:FSTZL-LJr-lJf[-
Or
/,
rAcr:
1fI!I&rI1£/I
_
DE. C " " 7 t1r - {M-.U
FleC"h~ S-1S',.E,... DU.vl'EJ_ ;Atf1~'7
~
S'f/lE1Jt;Y" II
(j;2 ~f
(!;}-Ai. (';';
-
"..,
fiACKf
_ ~IJ-If "",.~,~
1ft/liS