Summer 2012 BPC Meeting Prioritized Ranking Recommendation to close over $1.1 million budget gap 2013-14 Description DRAFT RANK 8/29/2012 9:09 AM Average Top 3 Ranks SCORE Bottom 3 Ranks BPC Rank Sum of Deltas 8 7 46 2 3 1 2 16 6 0 Reduce Summer term - Create 11 month 17 employee contracts (May require negotiations?) 9 Consolidate Admissions, Financial Aid, Records Reorganize Deans, division chairs, area 17 coordinators, etc. (May require negotiations?) 3 5 32 3 1 2 4 27 3 0 9 5 6 41 3 3 7 6 43 3 4 5 35 6 6 9 Discussion Dollars $ The District would offer no summer term classes or very limited classes, for example only online classes. As a result, many employee contracts would be shortened to 11 months with about an 8.3% salary savings. This is similar to a furlough. Potenital budget savings for all employees by class are estimated below. Note that the $600K BPC savings estimate is more conservative assuming that instructional employees and certain other employees would not be reduced. If we 600,000 move forward, then more detailed savings estimates will need to be developed. Staff: $422,000 Instructional and non-instructional faculty: $649,000 (only the non-instructional portion could be reduced) Managers, confidential, etc: $208,000 Total: $1,278,000 $ 100,000 Efficiencies from combining services and staffing. $ Efficiencies and cost savings might be realized by reorganizing these adminstrative functions. 80,000 However, a portion of these non-instructional administrative costs are included in the collective bargaining agreement. Faculty release time (May require negotiations?) $ 100,000 27 Employees pay a premium for health benefits (May require negotiations?) $ 300,000 2 19 Eliminate an academic program or reduce athletics $ 60,000 3 2 22 Revenue generating initiatives $ 40,000 42 0 1 12 Centralize AOA staff $ 12,500 7 47 0 1 10 Associated Students funding for clerical support $ 10,000 10 8 55 0 2 7 Reduce Campus Public Safety to less than 24/7 coverage $ 9,000 11 9 62 0 4 $ 200,000 11 Layoffs 1 Approximately $700K in non-instructional faculty release time is included in the collective bargaining agreement. Employees would pay a monthly premium for health and welfare benefits. CR pays a flat rate per covered employee, regardless of number of dependents. Health and welfare benefits cost about $1,900/mo or $22,800/yr per covered employee. Estimate is only employees who receive health benefits, NOT all employees: Health benefits scenario - $100 monthly payment: 130 Classified: $150,000 61 Admin/Mgr/Conf: $73,000 83 Instr & Non-instructional Faculty: $100,000 274 Total annual savings: $323,000 Potential savings from suspending an academic program or reducing the athletic budget. For academic program, review cost data to identify high cost programs to suspend due to lack of State funding. Move forward on some of the revenue generating initiatives previously identified by the BPC, such as locating cell phone or communications towers on District property. Additional revenue is already included in the budget, so conservatism requires that the estimate not be increased until some of the new money starts to materialize. By centrally locating AOA support staff for the instructional areas to one location, efficiencies and savings might be realized. Savings is about .25 FTE at about $30K salary. Associated Students could provide some funds to help offset costs related to the clerical support provided by the District. Certain shifts would not be covered, so County Sheriff would be first responder. Night shifts when school is not in session might be an example. Savings estimate is based on 90 days with one shift not covered. Instructional and non-instructional faculty, and certain administrators work under contract & likely could not be laid off until 7-1-2013, so potential layoff savings in 2013-14 for faculty and administrators. Confidential, classified staff & certain administrators could be laid off typically on 45 days advance notice. The layoff estimate is for illustration and could be another amount. 2012-13 Legislative bgt cut - BPC Final Rankings 8-29-2012.xlsx 2013-14 Addl Cuts Rankings Summer 2012 BPC Meeting Prioritized Ranking Recommendation to close over $1.1 million budget gap 2013-14 Description DRAFT RANK 8/29/2012 9:09 AM Average SCORE Top 3 Ranks Bottom 3 Ranks BPC Rank Sum of Deltas Dollars Total Savings Estimate without Negotiations $ Negotiable Items $ 1,180,000 Total Savings Estimate with Negotiations $ 1,511,500 2 Discussion 331,500 2012-13 Legislative bgt cut - BPC Final Rankings 8-29-2012.xlsx 2013-14 Addl Cuts Rankings