An Examination of Mother Goose: Making Some Sense out of Nonsense An Honors Thesis (ID 499) by Laura K. Bash Thesis Director Ball State University Muncie, Indiana April, 1990 May 5, 1990 .- 1'190 ,03'1'4 Funny isn't it, how last week, but you're memories that you can't remember what you did able to remain vivid recall despite the clearest and fondest memories from my was six years old. to start food, or eating was like food. to get engaging in everything, but what finally about a One of my childhood is I should baby cooperative child, and trying not spit, years. when I At that time my younger sister was just beginning to eat baby enough numerous childhood small boy say she She was her to combat. worked was was old not a swallow, but My mother tried the famous jingle who terrorizes girls on the playground. This boy was Mother Goose's own Georgie Porgie. We tried many other distracters after this, but my sister refused to eat unless Georgie was sung continuously--it exhausting for those singing, but she loved it. got to be It was her first experience with nursery rhymes, and it was a smashing success. The episode rhymes; tongue. I was I had was hardly already a expertly record rhymes, and I listened to verbatim. Seventeen my first which introduction to the tripping them off the told stories about the it until I could recite them years later I am as captivated by these compact masterpieces as that five year old girl. more I learned controversy they about The the rhymes, their history, and the sometimes spark, the more intrigued I 2 - became to study them further. although I believe I discovered have only fascinating "Mother Goose" have been. controversy as scratched the theories actually was, players might suitable for And so I have learned more, as to as well surface. I who the revered as who some of her Most amazingly, I found a heated to whether the Lady's rhymes are actually young children, or whether they model deviant behavior and encourage violence. So just abound, my who was Mother personal feeling of both her charm Although theories Goose? is that her anonymity is part and success. As varied as her rhymes however, are the explanations as to her identity. well-known theories are often more sound as intense fanciful research, although lacking logical easy to discover, theories can be One of two famous the of Charlemagne two French folklore as sitting and, so the story pleasant was Queen she was known for having an pictured in much to her tales. The other was married to Robert II of France, goes, a child common at a spinning wheel surrounded by children who are listening this theory most The first oddly shaped webbed foot which was and is marriage was which, women both named Bertha, both from France (Baring-Gould, 16). - found in dramatical flair, contain a simple and explanations combines Bertha of although they as the jingles themselves. Upon believability. Bertha, mother The more the with the visualization, and result of their incestuous head of a goose. certainly the Hardly a name "Mother 3 .Goose" as applied to this Bertha than any adult would conceive of. of these two women were is a more literal term Originally the stories separate, but because of their shared name, the two stories became one over the years. Having heard from Europeans, it seems only fitting that Americans make their bid to claim that Mother Goose is indeed, like institution. apple pie Their or baseball, candidate is an American Elizabeth Goose (originally Vertigoose) of Boston who lived from 1665-1756. Having had several grandchildren) , children Elizabeth wonderful stories and imagination. (and in turn supposedly rhymes, both several more told from the memory most and her In 1719, her son-in-law supposedly published a book from his printshop which contained many of these rhymes and jingles (Delmar, 12). Some say he did so to mock her, but it is {Bleirer,34}. much more pleasant to side with those who believe he did it as a tribute. at best. been found, Either way, this is a flimsy theory No matter that a copy of the 1719 book has ever no matter ever been uncovered. that any printing of Indeed no matter that the first usage of "Mother Goose" as connected with was Perrault's the book has stories for 1679 collection of fairy tales. fact that Perrault's pUblication the young Ignore the appeared twenty-two years 4 - before Thomas Fleet's elusive book. Even supposing that the Fleet book did indeed exist, using the Goose was hardly an idea that began with Elizabeth Goose. Proponents cling fiercely to the theory, the pilgrimage in however, and make Ironically, to "Mother Goose's" headstone. this grave holds Isaac buried title of Mother an Goose's unmarked first wife; Elizabeth is grave some distance away (Delmar, 13) • Romantic as this version the rhymes believable theory Autbe~jc it, support for and the Goos~, Mother is, few serious scholars of actually a simple and quite name does exist. ~ In Barchilon and Petit suggest that in France the older women of the village were given the job of tending the strength. geese since Because it it required did require so little, were no doubt faced with a dilemma. and stiffen from boredom or find little skill these women Either they could a way or to pass sit the time. Telling stories and singing songs were amusements the women could share not only with each children as well. Mother Goose glamourous always theory, in with the village These women earned the title "rna mere"-- (Barchilon charm other but and the and yet Petit, 10) • Hardly decidedly so, for there is thought of the common a person contributing to something of lasting importance. - Although I personally sense this last closest to the truth, I must admit that I think we never know. If Mother Goose had been theory is it best if a living, 5 - breathing person whose picture make real we could to them, then I believe show children and she would lose some of her appeal. Now she is a friend whom each child creates in his/her own mind, tailor-made to fill that child's special needs, and what is more real to a child than that which is magic? Magic or fun had beginning, however. little to Basically, do with the rhymes in the the verses served four purposes for those who used them: educational, historical, political, and/or social. The first was educational, as these jingles were sung or chanted for infants and toddlers. Most of these Most of these rhymes have accompanying movements. This group is perhaps the one which is still widely known and used by parents and teachers of young children today. Such toe or finger play rhymes as " This Little Pig" or " Thumbkin" are ,- popular in nursery, child care, {Arbuthnot, 125}. and preschool centers, at least those that I have observed or worked in. Concepts such as parts of the body, letters, 6 - and counting are not mastered after one exposure, and even in Mother Goose's time rhymes were this was teaching the of teaching These the rhymes had children aware of the learning taking place. is probably many of the same lesson with different words but very similar motions. advantage apparent, as the wonderful without their being This group of rhymes one of the smallest, although for someone with young children dozens of them may spring to mind. Another important group was historical written The event. category, of course, is people are that "London familiar with record to most famous of this Although most Bridge." the first and ninth verses which tell of the bridges "falling down" and being may not some rebuilt, they realize that sixteen additional verses exist. For example, here are the first four verses of the rhyme: London Bridge is falling down, my Fair Lady. How shall we build it up again, my Fair Lady? Build it up with wood and clay, my Fair Lady. Wood and clay will wash away, my Fair The entire rhyme actually tells the story of the bridge's lifespan and its destruction by the for although the fire did not great fire - it specific as describes, Bacheler, who bridge through While the rhyme to which reconstructions of the bridge documentation in 1437 her of London, burn the bridge itself, it greatly weakened the arches and supports. is not Lady(Spier, 1-9). does left her will of one Margery gold wedding band to the (Spier, exist 35) • Perhaps this 7 - inspired the verse "Build it up with silver and gold, my Fair Lady." Another lesser known rhyme which records a historical event is this one: Dr. Foster went to Gloucester In a shower of rain; He stepped in a puddle Up to his middle, And never went there again(Delmar, 124). {Lobel, 22}. This rhyme is speculated to be about Edward I, whose horse and coach became so deeply mired in mud that the king vowed on the spot he would never step foot in the town again (Delmar, 124). .- Although almost every rhyme is said to hide some historical or political allusion, this is highly unlikely. Some authors, however, such as Katherine Elwes Thomas, 8 - interpret all rhymes to fit some political scandal. Many of the have which seem explanations believe. One such jingle, "Jack is her terms for priests, two in Poor Cardinal Wolsey. jingles in simply claims of the famous the names are Bishop Cardinal Wolsey during groundwork for this however, he trip, two the priests explanations. documentation but Thomas frequently could draw conclusions. 92). reading when First, seldom uses her intriguing gives conclusive that Secondly, she Two problems from fails instance, myth of while trying to steal a Not only does Miss was said two children bucket to of be which she to offer any additional theories that exist about the rhymes. Scandinavian laid Henry's VIII's split with the Roman Church, themselves for Tarbes and is attached to at This time, therefore undoing themselves (Thomas, Jill," to to France(or " up the hill") and Miss Thomas that present fantastic states that least a dozen rhymes in her book. is travelling too particular, event or Thomas's book interpretation She and Jill." historical "Jack and based on a captured by the moon dew (Eckenstein, 20). Thomas ignore such theories, but she presents her own as if they are clearly documented fact. Some rhymes however, - as that were was written the only expression in the days of kingly their political critics heads, catchy jingles full of as political statements, safe rule. of form of negative To avoid losing the time would write symbolism which the common people 9 - would pick up and circulate through famous in this category Diddle England. be the Diddle," a is the rhyme the land. well about known Queen rhyme Elizabeth "Hey I of Elizabeth was often called the cat and is said to cat of many nursery rhymes. It is also said that she loved to dance to fiddle music, and did so dog in The most the rhyme often. The is speculated to be Elizabeth's on-again off-again lover Robert Dudley, whom she once referred to as {Mother Goose's Nursery Rhymes, 37}. "her little lap dog" (Delmar, "spoon" were involved in arrived free from poison. 131) . making The sure The "dish" and the the story goes Queen's food that when the 10 Queen discovered that her dish and spoon had married, she was so enraged that Tower of London where they spent been secretly she locked the rest them in the of their lives and had two children. While several other famous politically based rhymes exist, such as "Ride they are not as a Cock Horse" abundant as or "Mistress Mary," some would have us believe. Many of the rhymes do, however, show something perhaps more fascinating and important political influences. than Robert either Darnton historical believes rhymes exhibit a social record of their times. as "The Mother Old Woman Hubbard" common people. a single in a Shoe," "Pease demonstrate actual life, these reflect the general harshness women, and Porridge," or "Old rhymes were and struggle they did Children and in violence not hide this from that most men, with they faced daily. hours playing believe in coddling period moment Mother Goose's catchy jingles no doubt for dealing Because the horrors of society time the tale of written to children lived every day(Darnton, 40). their children, poverty Such rhymes living conditions of parents of the 1600s and 1700s did not from them. that the Also, rather than being a specific person's or grew they gave them up with were born. a outlet the hunger, abuse, and hard labor which During this the games time, children spent many that went along with these rhymes and indeed, parents knew them as well as their children. Not everyone has embraced the nursery rhyme though. 11 Almost from their beginning, These their use with children. reasons why opponents the rhymes have criticized opponents give are unsuitable for children: of moral codes and encouragement of violence. were one of the first groups They felt that many sacrilegious, but two basic acts to object described admitting their in lack The Quakers to Mother Goose. the power to tried to doctor the rhymes (Baring-Gould, jingles were catch on they 19). One rhyme that underwent the transformation was "Hey Diddle Diddle"; the lines were not "Hey Diddle slaughtered. sober 'parson' barks; the totally rhymes failed. that the the the attempts of But rhymes exhibited rhyme was . was redone by some dog does meadow. not laugh, but ."(Bodger, 405). the Quakers they are the over the moon but under the not jump moon, that is, below, in but Diddle . as follows: cow does Obviously the changed, not the to tame the Lady's only ones who felt a negative influence. In 1925, Mrs. Winifred Sackville Stoner, ~r., tried her own hand at writing what she considered to be sound educational nursery literature (Baring-Gould, 19) . What she turned out, unfortunately, were poor imitations such as: Every perfect person owns Just two hundred and six bones(Baring-Gould, 19). Probably the most famous tirade against nursery rhymes came - in 1952 when Geoffrey nursery literature Handely-Taylor published reform. a work on This work contains a forty- three line detailed breakdown of the violent and unethical 12 - acts taken from collection." find an what The list example Taylor claims includes some of, for to be an "average acts which instance body I cannot snatching or devouring of human flesh, and lists acts which although not violent, can be considered discrimination and cursing. rhymes to support literature which all I immoral, such Not only did I as racial fail to locate of Handley-Taylor's list, but the studied gave no indication of his having listed these rhymes in his own work. My research opponents side. turned up surprisingly little from the Taylor's publication in major critical work that I discovered. 1952 is the last Literature from the mid-to-late 1960s is much more positive, with the 1970s and 19808 being relatively quiet, but positive as well. As fiercely as those above cry rhymes, proponents of Mother Goose clamor for their using continuance. Mother Goose learning tool. out against the just as strongly The advocates see many benefits of as both a formal and an informal One reason that many educators support the rhymes goes back to Darnton's view of their social origins. Children from the inner of the sixteenth little time to and city share much with the children seventeenth spend worrying playing or learning; their - centuries. about goal was such Both had luxuries as in surviving. These children of the city live in a hard world, and placing them in a middle class learning American child in a situation is Japanese classroom. like placing an When these urban 13 children are presented with material class cannot relate to it. Further, presenting this type of material to such children fails to ideal, help them they simply that is the middle deal with their problems; quite the contrary, it frustrates them and may actually outwardly in a negative manner. however; she exclusively is to not the lines they can work them to react Mother Goose is different, pretentious, well-to-do. off their cause nor does she cater When children read her anger through them without actually having to go out and do something negative. All children (all people for that matter)use some kind of escape mechanism when they need to let off steam. Some people turn to athletics, some to hobbies or work, others to reading. Take the rhyme, "The Old Woman Who Lived In a Shoe," for example; the child can use this rhyme to pretend to be the mother and - can play out the role of being in control of a situation {Lobel, 53}. rather than a helpless child. This eliminates 14 the child's need to go do something destructive to let out this same energy. Bruno Bettelheim feels that deal with anger and violence has (Bettelheim, 188). punished for been neglected Children material which is blatantly even minor teaching children how to by adults are presented with reading devoid of acts of aggression and then violence with no thought given to the violence in the punishment itself (Bettelheim, 189).Children use imitate what they play see violent punishments to at tryout many roles and often home. at home Parents who give out should not be shocked to find their children engaging in violent play. Indeed, by using nursery rhymes, children have the perfect cathartic vehicle which is no more destructive than the imitative play of the home. " . escape values are necessary for coping with the hard realities of life. We might hypothesize that disadvantaged children, of all children, stand most in need of the magic fare" (Seaberg, of the 509). fairy So tale for the in their literary disadvantaged child, Mother Goose is a sort of celebration of life, all that is good, bad, and glorious. But other all children. Mother Goose benefits of the Lady's literature exist for The major is in benefit the children area of can gain from language/reading development. Beginning with the educational rhymes that are done with the infant children to the flow and and toddler, rhythm of these rhymes expose the language. The 15 - actions accompany that the rhymes and the necessary encourage interaction, whether it is a coo a smile and from an infant or a toddler's hesitant voice joining in the power of not proximity Educators have song. the jingles, always been instance, in long known although the implemented 1916 a to of the teaching use of the rhymes has their potential. For series of basal readers published by Ginn used a nursery rhyme as an introduction to the lesson(Delmar, 267). ... The rhyme was first to be memorized by the children and then the lesson was to be read. Unfortunately, the lessons themselves used the Mother Goose characters reading format. the actual (Baring-Gould, 245}. to present The rhyme itself reading lesson, a "Dick had little and the and Jane" relevance to text of the reader continued on for page after page engaging the characters in what Mother Goose herself must have considered appalling conversations. But before children are ,- printed word, skills. One vital auditory through objects. and slight they must ready first skill is visual. in attack develop that of Children differences to can the actual the appropriate discrimination, both learn these skills voice, expression, or In a house that is noisy and cluttered, learning 16 By 404) • impossible(Bodger, if difficult, become can discriminate to not using Mother Goose rhymes, children can learn to discriminate by alliteration, rhythm, rhyme~, and refrain, that learning while having so much fun in doing so ceases to become a chore and is instead a pleasure. Probably the learning to read is approach to Approach. thing a child needs when most important of repertoire a reading teaching This school's oral skills. One is the Language Experience philosophy is that if the child can say it, then it can be written, and if written can then be read. child This approach takes dictate a story better motivator than pumpkin could some experience and has the related to that experience. these be hollowed rhymes. Perhaps a made into a house for magical out and Peter's wife, or several shoes could be compared which would make the children. From best home these What to decide for the old woman and her simple activities, it is truly amazing what detailed and imaginative stories that children will create. And because the stories the children themselves, after teacher a their own. few times, Some true reading, but others which gives feel "cat" LEA along can then this is told by with the read them on memorization and not is a valid technique a child practice with real reading situations. While seeing a group of letters is reading the children would say have been can be and knowing that the word attributed to memorization, seeing that 17 word and comprehending what accept the definition of from print. Reading and rhymes are is, is reading, if we reading as being gaining meaning writing experiences with nursery unlimited because of their utter silliness. If for are a cat no other valuable reason, then, because of their Mother Goose's rhymes creative possibilities. Joan Bodger quotes Walter de la Mare: "These are the rhymes . that the inward problem free the eye" (Bodger, solving literature. Little Bo We fancy, charm tongue and ear, delight are can Peep to 404). easily set Creative fostered children find her thinking and with thinking sheep. Should search party, Put an add in the paper? of We can dig of today know immediately who Humpty Dumpty is, was illustrated, which the answer was example of that ways for she organize a of the nursery riddles for the children to solve. the rhyme nursery up some Children but before it was meant to be a riddle to Humpty was an egg. Another a riddle rhyme is the following: Little Nancy Etticoat With a white petticoat, And a red nose; She has no feet or hands, The longer she stands The shorter she grows(Delmar, 45). -. The answer to this rhyme is a candle. If children are a bit older, they can rhymes into more formal types of writing. incorporate the Letter writing, 18 ,for example, is a very successful use Allan read "The This Ahlberg. postman on his rounds the fictitious A good way to begin such inhabitants of Mother Goose land. an adventure is to of Jolly Postman" by Janet and delightful little book follows the and fairy tale characters. finds him delivering mail to Various types of mail are received- a postcard, a business letter, an advertising flyer, and a formal invitation, patterning a letter which they for to a could allude example. Children would enjoy favorite to the nursery content of well as follow the correct format of the character in the rhymes as letter. Another way to use nursery literature for writing is to have the children turn a rhyme into a news story. They must take care to include all important information who, what, when, where, why, and how. I have seen examples of such "nursery news" compiled into a newsletter format which can carry the experience into determining headlines, arranging the articles on the page, including pictures, CI#I'p Pure;l. jNtitib.r Q#(/ pi60 KISSed 1M rirls tUttI llUJde ~; Wltll 1M girls INri" 1111'47. G-ru P-rU MIllS 4nViIJ'. ' 'nN and naming pUblication. It seems apparent, then, that the rhymes can be used not ... {Baring-Gould, 170}. 19 only as a learning tool, but to build a positive attitude toward learning and school. only Finally, remains. the question of moral corruption If the question is, "Were the rhymes writ- ten with the intention of teaching 'bad' morals?" me, the answer surely must be no. Morals are very much in the subjective domain; what is acceptable to one taboo to another. Handley -Taylor sort of While critics like person is Geoffrey argue that the jingles encourage the wrong behavior, rhymes. According others feel to Barchilon differently about The grossest nonsensicality and mistake often the and Petit, "The rhymes are not to be analyzed in terms of logic common sense value. then for is or moral to believe that their sadistic content can be 'corrupting' (Barchilon and Petit, 35). Adults have a funny children think and to them. The way determine problem in of what doing so standards, so that an adult trying is guess how appropriate for is that decides to they use adult that the rhymes are unsuitable because of what the adult sees in the rhyme, not what children see. children do not One thing adults might consider is that think as they do. A child has a very egocentric view of the world and a fairly life. adults perhaps A are, child often not frightened of things which especially because experiences. is of Children brave outlook on in the often the world child's have need of literature, for concrete difficulty visualizing 20 abstract situations; because nursery rhymes are either read by the child or visualizing the the wayan sung children, interprets them. Also, concepts as death are elusive. hard time grasping the permanence of in terms meaning. accept to young They have a new. Such events seem scary if they are seen as only a temporary Additionally, analyze everything Children the take rhymes for adults and then the world have some strange attach some symbolic at face value; they what they are -- entertaining and fun. For the moment, the debate over the appropriateness of nursery rhymes seems to be dormant. No doubt it will surface again in time, as most issues do, and as with most issues, will likely remain unsolved. It is, I think, important to remember that nursery rhymes have survived from the sixteenth century (and possibly before) to the present. be of Wiley Coyote, who is crushed or flattened time state of being. need to could death; children think and again but always comes back good as do not they rhymes any number of ways, and none may be adult children, such to They survived in {Bleiler, 5}. 21 ,great part because they were picked up by children and handed down from parents to children, or passed to child and cherished by children everywhere. are, right at this moment, some child, sharing a song or verse with Mother Goose. (Bleiler, 98). from child And chances somewhere, is Works Cited Arbuthnot, May Chicago: Introduction. Hill. The Real Mother Goose. t Rand McNally, 1916. Barchilon, Jacques and Pettit, Henry. Goose. Denver: Baring-Gould, Ceil New York: The Authentic Mother Swallow, 1960. and William S. -The Annotated Mother Goose. Potter, 1962. Bettelheim, Bruno. Surviving and Other Essays. New York: Knopf, 1979. Bleir, E. F. Introduction. Mother Goose's Melodies. New York: Dover Publications, 1970. "Mother Goose: Is the Old Girl Still Bodger, Joan. Relevant?" Wilson Library Bulletin (1969): 402-08. Darnton, Robert. The Great Cat Massacre and Other Episodes French cultural History. Delmar, Gloria T. Jefferson: New York: in Basic Books, 1984. Mother Goose From Nursery to Literature. McFarland, 1987. Eckenstein, Lina. Comparative Studies in Nursery Rhymes. London: Singing Tree Press, 1968. -Mother Goose's Nursery Rhymes. New York: Random House Book of Mother Goose. Knopf, 1984. New York: Random House, 1986. Seaburg, D. Child?" -Childhood Spier, Peter. York: "Is There a Literature for the Disadvantaged 1. Education (1969): 508-12. Afterword . .1ondon Bridge is Falling Down. New Doubleday, 1967. Thomas, Katherine Elwes. The Real Personages of Mother Goose. 2oston: Lothrop, Lee, and Shepard, 1930.