Center for Banking and Finance Beischer Challenge Complete! 2011-12 Newsletter New Programs The Political Economy of Bank Regulation. On February 7-8, 2013, at The George Washington University Law School, the Center will co-host an academic conference, “The Political Economy of Financial Regulation,” with The George Washington University Law School, The University of Connecticut School of Law, and the Institute for Law and Economic Policy. This conference brings together legal scholars, regulators, judges, practitioners, economists, political theorists, and other social scientists to discuss the role of the political process in financial services regulation and Scott Cammarn addresses the inaugural class the role of money in both. The ABCs of Banking Law. The Center held its first Confirmed keynote speakers are Simon Johnson, “ABCs of Banking Law” program on Wednesday, MIT Sloan Management and Michael Barr, Michigan. March 28 in Charlotte at the offices of Moore & Van The distinguished panelists include the New York Times Allen. This program focuses on the basics of banking columnist Robert Frank from Cornell University; law and is intended for new lawyers, seasoned lawyers Harvey Goldschmid, Columbia Law School; Robert wishing to brush up, and for those who work with Jenkins, Bank of England; Tim Noah, The New Rebank clients and would like to learn more about bank public; Michael Taylor, Financial Stability Board; and regulation. The faculty was composed of Karol Michael Waldman, New York University School of Sparks, Barack Ferrazzano; Lissa Broome, UNC Law. School of Law; John Douglas, Davis Polk & WardA complete schedule and registration information may well LLP; Gene Katz, Wells Fargo; Scott Cammarn, be found at the Center’s website. There is no fee to Cadwalader, Wickersham & Taft; and Lawrence Bax- register, but space is limited. Program sponsors are ter, Duke Law School. Twenty-eight students attend- guaranteed admission and are invited to the speaker’s ed. dinner at which the Hon. Stanley Sporkin will deliver The 2013 version of The ABCs will take place March after-dinner remarks. Please contact Lissa Broome for 20, 2013, at Alston + Bird in Charlotte. The program more information about becoming a sponsor. The will precede the Banking Institute, which will be held Banking Journal will publish a special issue with papers March 21-22, 2013. from this conference in fall 2013. To order a copy, email ncbank@unc.edu . The New York Lecture Series—Sponsored by The Clearing House 2012 Lecture - Domestic Bank Regulation in a Global Environment The third event in the New York Lecture Series will be held November 14, 2012, “Domestic Bank Regulation in a Global Environment-A Comparative Dialogue.” The discussion will focus on how domestic financial institutions are impacted by the work of international standard setters like the Basel Committee of the Bank for International Settlements and the Financial 2011 Lecture - The Costs and Benefits of Big Stability Board. The struggles of cross-border finanBanks cial institutions with the issues raised by operations Generous gifts from The Clearing House enable the in multiple countries while being primarily regulated Center for Banking and Finance to host a lecture se- by their home state regulator will be explored. The ries in New York City. The second lecture in the panelists will consider the appropriate balance beseries was held November 8, 2011, “A Spirited Con- tween domestic regulation and global financial reguversation Assessing the Costs and Benefits of Big lation, whether there should be different frameworks Banks.” The panelists were John C. Dugan, Covfor wholly domestic institutions and those that operington & Burling (former Comptroller of the Curren- ate globally, and how the post-crisis approaches to cy); Ingo Walter, NYU Stern School of Business; home country regulation taken by the Vickers ComArthur E. Wilmarth, George Washington University mission and the Dodd-Frank Act affect the activities School of Law; and Phillip Swagel, University of of financial institutions in host countries. Maryland School of Public Policy. Paul Saltzman, The panelists will be Chris Brummer, Georgetown the President of The Clearing House Association, University Law Center; Robert Hockett, Cornell and Lissa Broome served as moderators. Law School; Cyrus Amir-Mokri, U.S. Department The debate took place at the New York Palace in of the Treasury; and Nick O’Neil, Clifford Chance New York City. The event brought together law LLP. Lissa Broome and Michael Helfer, Vice school alumni and faculty, The Clearing House board Chairman, Citi, will moderate. of advisors and senior leadership, national banking regulators, and prominent banking lawyers. The edited transcript of the debate was published in Volume 16 of the North Carolina Banking Institute journal. Banking Institute The 2012 Banking Institute was held on March 29-30, 2012, at The Ritz-Carlton, Charlotte, NC, and featured panel discussions on the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau; Dodd-Frank Act regulatory implementation; Basel III and capital under Dodd-Frank; the new role of community banks and thrifts; and restructuring commercial loans. Robert J. Johnson, Jr., General Counsel, Corporate Secretary, and Chief Governance Counsel, BB&T gave the General Counsel’s address following Thursday’s lunch. Beischer Address Jeffrey M. Lacker, the President of the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond delivered the inaugural Beischer Address on March 29, 2012, following dinner at the Banking Institute. Dr. Lacker joined the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond in 1989 as an economist and became its president in 2004. In his remarks, “A Program for Financial Stability,” Dr. Lacker outlined a broad agenda for achieving a sustainable 2012 Dinner and Beischer Address and effective relationship between the government and the financial sector. The full text and Clifford Distinguished Lecture a videotape of the address are available at www.richmondfed.org. Margot Saunders, of counsel to the The Beischer Address is named in honor of George National Consumer and Susan Beischer who matched $1 million in gifts Law Center, delivto the Center in 2011, several months before ered the 2012 George’s death in September 2011. The address Clifford Lecture, recognizes the Beischers’ leadership in this fund“Threats to Federal raising campaign and honors the memory of Safety Net Benefits in Bank Accounts,” Margot Saunders at the 2012 Banking Institute. This annual lecture honors Professor Donald F. Clifford Jr., who served as a faculty member at Carolina law from 1964 to 2004, specializing in commercial and consumer law. The Clifford Distinguished Lecture on Consumer law is a fitting tribute to Clifford’s many contributions to the profession and his vision for a more just society in which consumers are protected from unfair risks. Jeffrey M. Lacker The Dan K. Moore Program in Ethics Peter C. Buck, Robinson, Bradshaw & Hinson 2011 Program - Whistleblowers Bernard A. Burk, UNC School of Law The 2011 program was held on October 14, 2011, at The Center for School Leadership and Development in Chapel Hill. The program addressed a variety of ethical issues of interest to corporate lawyers, both in-house counsel and attorneys in private practice, discussing particular issues that arise in the representation of corporations and how the attorney should proceed when he or she suspects wrongdoing within the corporation. The panel explained the variety of whistleblower statutes, including the relevant provisions of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010. Special attention was focused on the impact of whistleblowing provisions on corporate compliance programs. The program also included a networking lunch for panelists and participants. Jana J. Litsey, Bank of America James P. McLoughlin, Jr., Moore & Van Allen Karen A. Popp, Sidley Austin Sandra D. van der Vaart, LabCorp Professors Hazen, Broome, and Burk serve as co-directors of this program. Consumer Law and Consumer Credit Symposium at the Festival of Legal Learning Bernard A. Burk, UNC School of Law David B. Fountain, Progress Energy Matthew T. Martens, SEC Valecia McDowell, Moore & Van Allen The 2012 symposium included 12 separate sessions on a variety of consumer law and credit issues, including: Edward P. O'Keefe, Bank of America Reid L Phillips, Brooks Pierce McLendon, Humphrey & Leonard Dr. Elliot M Silverstein, UNC Dr. Martha Simpson, HRC Behavioral Health & Psy- chology Kurt E. Wolfe, McGuireWoods Professors Hazen and Broome served as co-directors and co-moderators of this program. 2012 Program - The “New Normal” The 2012 program, “Adjusting to the ‘New Normal’: Ethical Challenges for In-house and Outside Counsel,” will be held October 26, 2012, at the Friday Center in Chapel Hill. You may register at www.law.unc.edu/cle/dankmoore/ default.aspx. The program will review privileges and conflicts, issues common for businesses, and will discuss the expectations of general counsel for outside counsel with respect to budgeting, billing, staffing, communication, and coordination. Ethical and practical issues raised by outside counsel guidelines will be considered, as well as issues associated with disaggregating legal services and outsourcing. Panelists include: The Consumer Law and Consumer Credit Symposium was offered at the annual Festival of Legal Learning on February 10-11, 2012, and will be offered again on February 8-9, 2013. RoboCalls and Do Not Call Enforcement Lawyers on Nonprofit Boards Access to Justice in North Carolina The Practical (But Mostly Impractical) Impact on Bankruptcy Practice Mandatory Binding Arbitration Agreements in Consumer Contracts Nonprofit Governing Board Members’ Fiduciary Duties and Liability Remedies Under Consumer Protection Laws: North Carolina Hot Topics in Arbitration Identity Theft, Scams and Your Community Mental Health Issues and Bankruptcy Cases Auto Sales and Finance in a Changing Regulatory Environment Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: What We Have Learned Career Trek On October 20, 2011, over the University’s fall break North Carolina Banking Institute journal students had the opportunity to meet with attorneys and learn more about legal career options. The students were hosted by Wells Fargo and toured the Duke Energy Center (DEC) building with Rich Belthoff, Senior Counsel, Enterprise Services Division, Wells Fargo. McGuire Woods graciously provided lunch for the students attending and Wells Fargo’s Carla Archie, Rebecca Henderson, Marc Iverson, and Gene Katz. At lunch, the students also met with Carter Arey, Jim Hedrick, Matthew Morrison, Meredith Sorrentio, and Scott Vaughn of McGuire Woods, who described their varied areas of practice. The Center is especially grateful to Gene Katz of Wells Fargo, and Jim Hedrick and Raj Natarajan of McGuire Woods for facilitating these visits. “I’m honored to participate and really enjoyed meeting such a great group of students.” “Thanks for the opportunity to speak at this event. I thought it was extremely well done and a great opportunity for the students.” From a journal student: “I really enjoyed getting some insight into career possibilities in this area of law, and getting some encouragement from the speakers about the current job market. It was certainly worthwhile for the students.” DEC and Wells Fargo Center, Charlotte, NC Practitioners in Residence The Practitioners in Residence Program brought attorneys and industry professionals to the law school to participate in classes. Scott Cammarn, Special Counsel, Cadwalader Wickersham & Taft (formerly with Ally Financial/ GMAC Financial Services, Lending Tree, and Bank of America), October 12, 2011, Volcker Rule, Affiliate Transaction Rules. Gene Katz, Senior Company Counsel (Regulatory and Compliance) for Wells Fargo & Company, November 8, 2011, Supervision and Enforcement Activities by Bank Regulators. Externships The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) hosted Alex Abramovich as a full-time extern for 12 hours of academic credit for the 2011 fall semester. Adam Batenhorst and Eunice Park were full-time externs at the SEC during the 2011 fall semester, and Danyeale Hensley was at the SEC for the 2012 spring semester. The Law School continues to offer a one-course credit externship with the North Carolina Office of the Commissioner of Banks. Other one-course externships from the Spring 2012 semester included Asanka Pathiraja at BB&T, David Herring at the Finance Division of the NC Legislature Bill Drafting Section, Zach Marquand with the Foreclosure Unit of Legal Aid of North Carolina, and Eric Roeling at the Self-Help Credit Union. Mortgage Settlement Oversight and Prometheus Group. Director Diversity Initiative Laurie Wilder - Executive Vice President and Managing Director of Parker Executive Search in Atlanta. Porsha Williams - Principal with Parker Executive Search in Atlanta. Corporate sponsors for the next program on May 29, 2013, are entitled to two complimentary admissions and recognition in the program materials. On May 30, 2012, the seventh annual one-day program, “Broadening Corporate Board Diversity: Earning a Board Seat,” was held at the Rizzo Center in Chapel Hill. Twenty-one diverse potential board members registered for the program. The panelists discussed topics such as skills needed and how to develop them, realistic approaches to advancing your candidacy, diverse directors in non-diverse settings, and evaluating companies and opportunities. Panelists included: Diversity Resources The DDI maintains a collection of resources for potential directors, diversity data on NC companies, and media reports on director diversity at: ddi.law.unc.edu/default.aspx Board Diversity Research Professors Lissa Broome, Kim Krawiec, and John Conley have been engaged in a study based on interviews of corporate board members about whether and how diversity affects board processes and corporate performance. Professor Conley presented their most recent paper at the University of Illinois College of Law in March 2012, “The Danger of Difference: Tensions in Directors’ Views of Corporate Board Diversity.” Maryann Bruce - On the board of Allianz Global Investors Fund. Walter Davenport - On the boards of Blue Cross Blue Shield of North Carolina, the N.C. Center for Nonprofits, IntraHealth International, Inc., NationLissa Broome and Professor Thomas Hazen published al Association of State Boards of Accountancy, and “Board Diversity and Proxy Disclosure,” 37 University the United Way of the Greater Triangle. of Dayton Law Review 39 (2011). Professor Broome Genevia Gee Fulbright - On the board of the spoke about board diversity throughout the year in Research Triangle Chapter of the National Associa- North Carolina and Washington DC. tion of Corporate Directors (NACD), previously Database of Potential Diverse Directors served on the boards of M&F Bancorp and its subPotential diverse directors should register on the DDI’s sidiary Mechanic & Farmers Bank, the YMCA database so that registrants’ names may be provided to (Lakewood), and the Small Business Technology nominating committees of corporate boards, governDevelopment Center (SBTDC). ment commissions, and non-profits when requested. D. Keith Pigues - On the board of the Office of ddi.law.unc.edu/database/ Spotlight on Saule Omarova Assistant Professor Saule Omarova teaches Banking Law, Global Financial Markets, International Banking, and Corporate Financial Institutions. She is visiting this fall at Georgetown University Law Center. Her recent publications include: Bankers, Bureaucrats, and Guardians: Toward Tripartism in Financial Services Regulation, 37 J. Corp. L. 621 (2012). From Gramm-Leach-Bliley to DoddFrank: The Unfulfilled Promise of Section 23A of the Federal Reserve Act, 89 N.C.L. Rev. 1683 (2011). License to Deal: Mandatory Approval of Complex Financial Products, 90 Washington University Law Review (forthcoming 2012). That Which We Call a Bank: Revisiting the History of Bank Holding Company Regulation in the United States (with M. Tahyar), 31 Rev. Banking & Fin. L. 113 (2011). The Dodd-Frank Act: A New Deal for A New Age?, 15 N.C. Banking Inst. 83 (2011). The United States: ‘With Freedom and Liberty for All’ (with Lissa Lamkin Broome, John Conley, and Cynthia Williams), in Banking Systems in the Crisis: The Faces of Liberal Capitalism, ed. by Suzanne J. Konzelmann & Marc Fovargue-Davies (Routledge, 2013), pp. 57-79. Wall Street as Community of Fate: Toward Financial Industry Self-Regulation, 159 U. Pa. L. Rev. 411 (2011). 2012 Banking Institute Sponsors Alston & Bird, LLP Bank of America BB&T Corporation Bradley Arant Boult Cummings LLP Brooks, Pierce, McLendon, Humphrey & Leonard, LLP Bryan Cave LLP Cadwalader Wickersham & Taft LLP Davis Polk & Wardwell LLP Dykema Gossett PLLC FHLBank Atlanta Fifth Third Bancorp Gaeta & Eveson, PA Holland & Knight LLP Hunton & Williams LLP Jones, Walker, Waechter, Poitevent, Carrère & Denègre LLP Kane Russell Coleman & Logan PC Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP McGuireWoods Mayer, Brown LLP Moore & Van Allen, PLLC Morrison & Foerster LLP Nelson, Mullins, Riley & Scarborough LLP North Carolina Bankers Association Paul Hastings LLP Poyner Spruill LLP Raymond James & Associates RBC Bank (Georgia), N.A. Robinson, Bradshaw & Hinson, PA Smith, Anderson, Blount, Dorsett, Mitchell & Jernigan, LLP The Clearing House Troutman Sanders LLP Vorys, Sater, Seymour and Pease, LLP Ward and Smith, PA Wells Fargo & Company Williams Mullen Winston & Strawn LLP Board of Advisors Please see our website for a complete listing of our distinguished Board of Advisors. law.unc.edu/centers/banking/staff/advisors/ North Carolina Banking Institute Journal Volume 16 of the North Carolina Banking Institute journal was published in March 2012 and distributed at the Banking Institute. Twenty-four students served as editors or staff members. The journal published the transcript of the debate on the risks and benefits of big banks, which occurred at the Center’s New York Lecture Series in November 2011; an article by Margot F. Saunders and Johnson M. Tyler on the threats to federal safety net benefits in bank accounts; and Reggie O’Shields’ article on what comes after Fannie Mae Bank Directors’ College and Freddie Mac. In addition, there were eleven stuThis program is sponsored by the Center in conjunc- dent-written comments and notes, and a book review tion with the North Carolina Office of the Commis- contributed by Louis Massard, a 2011 UNC Law sioner of Banks and the FDIC. The college consists graduate. of two, two-day sessions and has been described as The entire journal may be accessed at: the most comprehensive educational effort of its www.law.unc.edu/journals/ncbank/volumes/ kind in the United States. The 2012 Directors’ Colvolume16/citation-16-nc-banking-inst-2012/ lege was just completed. The next college will take place in the summer of 2014. Banking Journal Scholarship This scholarship is awarded annually to an NCBI editor based on scholastic and writing ability, as indicated by membership on the NCBI board of editors, and financial need. For 2011-12, the scholarship was awarded to Charles KabugoMusoke, Editor–in-Chief, and Christopher T. Fowler, Publication Editor. For 2012 -13, Benjamin Weadon, Executive Editor, will receive the scholarship. Center for Banking and Finance Save the Date North Carolina Banking Institute journal Mark Your Calendars Fundraising Dan K. Moore Program in Ethics Chapel Hill, NC October 26, 2012 Learn more The Center welcomes your gift to support the operations of the Center. Please contact Assistant Dean for Advancement Brandon Wright for more information about current use or endowment gifts for the Center, wright@email.unc.edu, 919.962.6718. You may contact Lissa Broome about sponsorship opportunities for The New York City Lecture Series New York, NY November 14, 2012 (by invitation) The Political Economy of Financial Regulation Washington, DC February 7-8, 2013 Festival of Legal Learning Consumer Law and Consumer Credit Symposium Chapel Hill, NC February 8-9, 2013 The Political Economy of Financial Regulation February 6-7, Washington, DC ($2,500) The Banking Institute March 21-22, Charlotte, NC ($1,500) Broadening Corporate Board Diversity May 29, Chapel Hill, NC ($1,000) About the Director Lissa Lamkin Broome is the director of the school's Center for Banking and Finance. She serves as faculty advisor to the North Carolina Banking Institute Journal, and heads the school's Director Diversity Initiative which works to increase gender, racial, and ethnic diversity on the boards of directors of publicly traded corporations in North Carolina and throughout the United States. ABCs of Banking Law Charlotte, NC March 20, 2013 Banking Institute Charlotte, NC March 21-22, 2013 Broadening Corporate Diversity Chapel Hill, NC May 29, 2013 NC Bank Directors’ College Chapel Hill, NC June & July 2014 Contact Information UNC School of Law Center for Banking and Finance CB #3380 Chapel Hill, NC 27599-3380 http://www.law.unc.edu/centers/ banking cbortz@email.unc.edu Lissa Lamkin Broome Wells Fargo Professor of Banking Law The center's mission is to play a leadership role in the continual evolution of the financial services industry by: Studying the legal and policy issues related to banking and finance; Advancing the teaching of banking and finance; and Sponsoring conferences for industry professionals.