m e i . o r g . u k Curriculum Update Development of new Mathematics and Further Mathematics AS and A levels for first teaching in 2017 continues. The report from the A level mathematics working group has just been published, focusing on areas of mathematical problem solving, modelling and the use of large data sets in statistics. It contains expert advice from group members on how these key aspects of the new content could be assessed and provides examples of questions. Ofqual’s open consultation on subject-specific rules and guidance has also just been launched, seeking views on: the revised version of the assessment objectives the proposed approach to regulating new AS and A level qualifications in mathematics and further mathematics; the subject-specific Conditions requirements and guidance Ofqual propose to introduce to implement that approach. I s s u e N o v / D e c 2 0 1 5 There have been many recent collaborations between artists and mathematicians, and for several “Mathematics, rightly viewed, reasons. Sophia Chen’s article: Get lost possesses not only truth, but supreme in the internet’s mind-bending mathbeauty.” (Bertrand Russell, Mysticism inspired art (June 2015, Wired) and Logic, 1919) considers whether it’s the order in mathematics that appeals to artists, or In this issue we explore the maths in art “simply because math describes nature, and the art in maths. and nature is beautiful”. Chen looks at Joseph Malkevitch of York College (City five mathematically-inspired artists and organisations that use both new University of New York) wrote for the technologies such as 3-D printing and American Mathematical Society in traditional media such as textiles. April 2015, entitled ‘Mathematics and Art’. Melkevitch writes: “There are, in The mathematical artwork of Robert fact, many arts (music, dance, painting, Bosch is interesting, in particular TSP architecture, sculpture, etc.) and there Art and Simple Closed Curves, is a surprisingly rich association illustrating Jordan's Jordan Curve between mathematics and each of the Theorem. “ Bosch can draw the Mona arts.” Lisa with a single line. First he lays down some dots on a grayscale version It appears that rather than being two separate disciplines, art and maths are of the image, and then he uses an algorithm to connect the dots in a way very much bound up together. As this looks like the original.” New York Times article Putting Art in The mathematics in art...or the art in mathematics? Steam explains, “being able to quickly sketch to communicate an idea is an enormously Included as an appendix to useful tool,” says the consultation document James Michael is the DfE’s proposed Leake, director appendices to the subject content which contains of a of engineering list of notation for A level The first ever printed graphics at the Mathematics and Further version of the Mathematics and a list of icosidodecahedron, University of Illinois. formulae which must not by Leonardo da Vinci “To do engineering be given in examinations. as appeared in the you’ve got to be able ''Divina Proportione'' Responses should be to visualize.” th submitted by 11 January 5 0 by Luca Pacioli 1509 Click here for the MEI Maths Item of the Month In this issue Curriculum Update This half term’s focus: Mathematics and Art Hugh’s Views: Guest writer Hugh looks at Arches and Architecture Site-seeing with... Tom Button Teaching Resource: Maths and Art M4 is edited by Sue Owen, MEI’s Marketing Manager. We’d love your feedback & suggestions! Disclaimer: This magazine provides links to other Internet sites for the convenience of users. MEI is not responsible for the availability or content of these external sites, nor does MEI endorse or guarantee the products, services, or information described or offered at these other Internet sites. Maths and art The Golden Ratio The February 2013 edition of Monthly Maths looked at the Golden Ratio in Nature, Art and Architecture, and activities include finding Phi by experimentation and calculation. The Virtual Maths Museum presents artists who use mathematical ideas as subject matter and/or inspiration: “In recent years, the advent of computers has made possible the development of various forms of digital art that allow artists and mathematicians to cooperate in a highly synergistic fashion.” For examples of innovative and creative work by mathematics To access the ‘Beauty practitioners and artists is in the Eye of the Beholder’ PowerPoint who are crossing teaching resource mathematics-arts that accompanied this boundaries, there is an issue, visit the M4 Magazine web array to be seen on the Mathematical Art Galleries website, the online page, scroll down to home of the mathematical art exhibits Archived Monthly Maths at the bottom from the annual Bridges Conference of the page and look and Joint Mathematics Meetings. The for February 2013 in exhibition comprises 2D and 3D the menu. mathematical art, ranging from computer graphics to quilts to geometrical sculptures. The Mathematical Art Exhibits page links to photos of artwork from upcoming and past conferences. See also this 4 minute BBC video presented by Carol Vorderman (originally on the One Show), hosted on TES Resources: The beauty of the golden ratio. MoSAIC is a collaborative effort sponsored and funded by MSRI (Mathematical Sciences Research Institute) and administered by the Bridges organisation. Together, they are creating a series of interdisciplinary mini conferences and festivals on mathematical connections in science, art, industry, and culture, to be held in colleges and universities around the United States and abroad. Maths-Art Seminars at London Knowledge Lab was a monthly series of maths-art seminars held in central London. The idea for these seminars grew out of the London Knowledge Lab’s work in hosting the annual international Bridges Conference in London in August 2006. Regretfully, the seminars are no longer organised, but the site remains online as an archive. The University of Oxford’s Art and Oxford Mathematics web page outlines the connection between mathematics and art at its Mathematical Institute. Included is a podcast of Marcus du Sautoy's talk on the connection between mathematics and art. The Mathematical Institute has a large collection of historical mathematical models, designed and built over a hundred years ago. “The aesthetic beauty of the models should be enjoyable for anyone with an interest in mathematics, art or history, regardless of your level of mathematical training.” Dr Ron Knott, Visiting Fellow in the Department of Mathematics at the University of Surrey, has created a web page Fibonacci Numbers and The Golden Section in Art, Architecture and Music, which has a wealth of information, examples and links about the Golden Section, including Miscellaneous, Amusing and Odd places to find Phi and the Fibonacci Numbers. Beauty in Mathematics Mathematical art The Virtual Math Museum has a gallery of samples mathematical art, including that by Robert Bosch (see page 1): “Mathematics and the graphic arts have had important relationships and interactions from the earliest of times, for example through a common interest in concepts such as symmetry and perspective that play an important role in both areas. In recent years, the advent of computers has made possible the development of various forms of digital art that allow artists and mathematicians to cooperate in a highly synergistic fashion. Our goal in this gallery is to show how beautiful mathematical objects can be, and also to present artists who use mathematical ideas as subject matter, inspiration, or both. The experience of mathematical beauty and its neural correlates is a 2014 original research article by Semir Zeki, John Paul Romaya, Dionigi M. T. Benincasa and Michael F. Atiyah, who suggest that: “Art and mathematics are, to most, at polar opposites; the former has a more “sensible” source and is accessible to many while the latter has a high cognitive, intellectual, source and is accessible to few. Yet both can provoke the aesthetic emotion and arouse an experience of beauty, although neither all great art nor all great mathematical formulations do so.” Fifteen mathematicians were asked to view a series of 60 mathematical equations and rate each one on a scale of −5 (ugliest) to +5 (most beautiful). Then they scanned the subjects' brains with functional MRI as they looked at the equations again. The pre-scan beauty ratings were used to assemble the equations into three groups, one containing 20 low-rated, another 20 medium-rated, and a third 20 high-rated equations, individually for each subject. These three allocations were used to organise the sequence of equations viewed during each of the four scanning sessions so that each session contained 5 low-rated, 5 medium-rated, and 5 high-rated equations. Each subject then re-rated the equations during the scan as Ugly, Neutral, or Beautiful. The frequency distribution of pre-scan beauty ratings for all 15 subjects was positively skewed, indicating that more equations were rated beautiful than ugly. After scanning, subjects rated each equation according to their comprehension of the equation, from 0 (no comprehension whatsoever) to 3 (profound understanding). The distribution of postscan ratings showed that there was a highly significant positive correlation between understanding and scan-time beauty ratings. The mathematical subjects were asked four questions about emotional responses to equations. All answered affirmatively to the question: “Do you derive pleasure, happiness or satisfaction from a beautiful equation?” By contrast, out of 12 non-mathematical subjects (with experience of mathematics up to GCSE level), the majority (9) gave a negative response to the same question. The researchers supposed that non-mathematical subjects who had rated any equations as ‘Beautiful’ “did so on the basis of the formal qualities of the equations—the forms displayed, their symmetrical distribution, etc”. The formula most consistently rated as beautiful (avg. rating of 0.8667), both before and during the scans, was Leonhard Euler's identity: 1+eiπ=0 Most consistently rated as ugly (avg. rating of −0.7333) was Srinivasa Ramanujan's infinite series for 1/π: Study author Semir Zeki writes, “Relegating beauty to the study of art and leaving it out of science is no longer tenable.” Classroom resources Maths In Art is a new online resource providing a programme of activities that suggest ways that you can explore areas of mathematics through an arts-themed project. The scheme may be adapted for Key Stage 3 students. It’s free to use the resources, by signing up on the Maths In Art website. You can view a video about the scheme on YouTube. In 2016 the Science Museum will open a new permanent mathematics gallery suitable for students aged 12-16: You can view a YouTube video design animation created by Zaha Hadid Architects of designs for the gallery. This 2010 nrich resource looks at connections between maths and Plus Magazine’s Maths and art: the whistlestop tour provides a brief look at “some of the types of art with a strong mathematical component, or conversely where a mathematical visualisation has an astonishing beauty”. National curriculum links: the activities based on geometric Islamic patterns in this booklet support learning about shapes, space and measures. Students at Key Stage 3 can study transformational and symmetrical patterns to produce tessellations. The Maths and Art package includes: The maths2art website promotes the teaching of mathematics in ways that are visually stimulating, for pupils of a wide range of abilities in Key Stages 3, 4 and 5. “Using a project to teach maths can be more meaningful for pupils than teaching the curriculum areas of shape and space, number and algebra in distinct units of work. It can allow them to explore their own ideas at a pace which suits them whilst making meaningful connections between different areas of maths.” Projects include: Maths and the visual arts Circles Maths and design Islamic Art Maths and music Tessellation Maths and film Fibonacci Maths and theatre Pythagoras Maths and writing Celtic Knot Try it yourself with NRICH 3-D Models Random Art Fractals Plus’s Teacher package: Maths and art is one of a series of teacher packages designed to give teachers (and students) easy access to Plus content on a particular subject area and “provide an ideal resource for students working on projects and teachers wanting to offer their students a deeper insight into the world of maths”. Maths and Islamic art & design This teachers’ resource provides a variety of information and activities that teachers may like to use with their students to explore the Islamic Middle East collections at the V&A. It can be used to support learning in Maths and Art. Included on the site are links to some excellent resources from TROL (Teaching Resources On Line)at Exeter University; these can be printed for use in the classroom. Maths in the City provides a look at maths in context, with a maths trail around London. Hugh’s Views Arches and architecture Dr Hugh Hunt is a Senior Lecturer in the Department of Engineering at Cambridge University and a Fellow of Trinity College. There’s something very pleasing about the shape of an arch. Classically an arch ought to be a semicircle, but over the centuries arches have evolved, especially in churches and cathedrals, into an amazing array of shapes. Take St Paul’s Cathedral in In his previous London. Designed column Hugh talked by the unbeatable about the different engineering team types of arch: of Robert Hooke parabola, catenary and semicircle. In this and Christopher column he goes on to Wren. From the inside and the look at how arches outside you see have been used in architecture and how hemispherical domes and if you they have evolved. didn’t know it then you’d never guess the cleverness of the construction within. Click to view the Sept/Oct 2015 M4 Magazine View Hugh’s videos on his YouTube channel: spinfun Follow Hugh on Twitter: @hughhunt Hooke had worked out that a hanging chain and a perfect arch have the same shape: “as hangs the flexible line, so but inverted will stand the rigid arch”. It was this key understanding that powered the design of Wren’s amazing buildings. The M4 Editor found plenty of arches on a recent trip to the USA. See the MEI Facebook page. Hooke thought that the shape of the perfect dome was the cubicoparabolical conoid, i.e. the cubic y = ax3 rotated about the y axis. He was very close! By Lwphillips. Shape of hanging chain versus arch. [CC BY-SA 3.0], via Wikimedia The Wren Library in Trinity College Cambridge has arches, but where are they? By Samuel Wale and John Gwynn. Engraving of a cross section of the dome of St. Paul's Cathedral in London via Wikimedia Commons. By Andrew Dunn. The Wren Library, Cambridge. [CC BY 2.0 ], via Wikimedia Commons. By Bernard Gagnon. Dome of Saint Paul's Cathedral seen from Tate Modern, London. [CC BY 2.0 ], via Wikimedia Commons. By Dp76764. Dome of St Paul’s, via Wikimedia Commons. Amazingly, Wren hid them away in the foundations – but upside down! He recognized that the muddy reclaimed land by the river Cam was too weak to take the weight of his proposed building so McGraw-Hill Dictionary of he created a Architecture and Construction. raft made up S.v. "inverted arch." Retrieved October 1 2015 of inverted from http:// arches. encyclopedia2.thefreedictionary. com/inverted+arch Hugh’s Views Buildings and bridges By Jacques Heyman. Hooke's CubicoParabolical Conoid. Notes and Records of the Royal Society of London. Vol. 52, No. 1 (Jan., 1998), pp. 39-50 Published by: The Royal Society. Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/ stable/532075 The bookcases inside the building bear down directly on the pillars of the arches as you can see in the diagram opposite. It’s funny that all this engineering beauty is hidden away. I suppose nothing has changed. The amazing engineering under the bonnets of our cars or in our mobile phones is totally hidden from view. Just imagine how much more interesting airports would be if there were windows into the baggage handling area, or if there were working models of turbofan engines! Perhaps the highest evolved form of the arch is in the fan vaulting at King’s College Chapel, again in Cambridge (sorry for all these Cambridge references – but I ride my bike past these amazing buildings twice a day and never cease to marvel at them). Am I allowed another Cambridge arch? It is the so-called Mathematical Bridge in Queens’ College. So many stories are told about the bridge – they’re all wrong! Via Wikimedia Commons. What is true is that the main lower arch is made up of seven straight lines. Yet it looks like a smooth curve. I think that’s what Newton had in mind when he invented the calculus (or was it Leibnitz?!) that if you break a curve down into little bits of straight lines then it becomes very simple. This bridge is what mathematicians call an ‘envelope’ – straight lines making a curve. So simple, so beautiful. My jaw just dropped when I first saw the Millennium Bridge across From the outside the King’s Chapel the Thames. I imagine looks kind-of square and maybe a Wren and Hooke are By Alexandre Buisse. looking down from their St Pauls Cathedral and bit dull. But those big exterior Millennium Bridge. [CC pillars are part of the engine room lofty dome. They see BY-SA 3.0], via the cables of the bridge. of the fan vaulting inside. The thin Wikimedia Commons. spidery stone filaments inside (see “I told you so” Hooke photograph, left) are like lines on a mutters. “Ut pendet continuum flexile, sic stabit contiguum rigidum inversum, as hangs graph, illustrating the lines of the flexible line, so but inverted will stand the thrust. The forces are channelled rigid arch”. into the pillars in an orderly By Dmitry Tonkonog. King's College Chapel. [CC BY-SA 3.0], via Wikimedia Commons. By Lofty. Ceiling of King's college, Cambridge. [CC BY-SA 3.0], via Wikimedia Commons. mathematical progression. And if you wondered what the pointy pinnacles outside on the top of the roof are for – no, not just for decoration – they are the weights necessary to hold the uppermost stones in place against the huge sideways forces generated by the vaulting. It’s like putting your foot against a ladder to stop it from sliding. They’re decorated to make them look pretty. Site seeing with… Tom Button Tom Button is the FMSP Student Support Leader and MEI’s Learning Technology Specialist. Prior to this he taught mathematics in a number of different sixth form colleges. The MEI Maths Item of the Month is a monthly problem aimed at teachers and students of GCSE/A level Mathematics. Each month a He has a strong mathematical problem is added to the interest in the use of technology in maths, home page of the MEI website. The especially at A level, MEI staff are all mathematics and has delivered enthusiasts and putting an interesting many professional problem on the front of the site is a development courses technological way of wearing our on this. He is the mathematical hearts on our sleeves. chair of MEI’s GeoGebra Institute and runs the MEI/ The first Maths Item of the Month Casio Teacher appeared in September 2006 and there Network. have been over 100 items since then. Tom has also recently A full archive of the problems is developed MEI’s new available on the site and they can be technology-based A used for enrichment, problem solving or level unit: Further as a way to encourage mathematical Pure with thinking/proof. Technology. A curriculum mapping for the problems has recently been completed and this can be seen at: mei.org.uk/miotm. This is mapping is not intended to be comprehensive – for example many of the algebra or geometry problems can be used with GCSE or A level students. There are also a number of problems that were hard to categorise and form a Follow Tom’s blog: Digital technologies fairly lengthy set of miscellaneous for learning problems at the end! mathematics One of my favourites is one of the You can also earliest ones from December 2006: follow Tom “19 not out” – Some positive numbers on Twitter at add up to 19. What is the maximum @tombutton product? There is also usually a Christmasthemed problem for December. December 2014’s was: “A Christmas Star” – An eight pointed Christmas star is made with a gold layer and a silver layer. What fraction of the gold layer is covered by the silver layer? Another resource that has had a significant impact on me is Improving Learning in Mathematics (often known as the Standards Unit box). The full set of materials in available, for free, in the National STEM Centre elibrary. The materials form a definitive guide for using active learning approaches with A level or GCSE students. There is a range of activities including open questioning, card sorts, group work, learners creating their own questions and many others. All of these are presented in the context of lesson plans so that teachers can see how to use these strategies effectively to improve students’ understanding. There is also a set of professional development materials that can be used by a Mathematics department to develop teachers’ skills across a number of areas: learning from mistakes and misconceptions, looking at learning activities, managing discussion, developing questioning and using formative assessment. Maths, Religion and Art It sometimes surprises people that there exist strong links between Mathematics, Religion and Art. Look at the images on the next few slides and describe the Mathematics you see. Maths and Art Using some of these designs as inspiration, during this activity you will construct some of your own. The ones here are nowhere near as complex or beautiful as the ones shown, but can be used as a basis for something more intricate. Maths and Art You will need a pair of compasses, a ruler and a pencil (or a Dynamic Geometry Package) and will need to be able to: • Draw a circle and divide it equally into six • Bisect a line (perpendicular bisector) • Bisect an angle These skills are outlined on the next slides. Divide a Circle Equally into Six • Draw a circle and keep the compasses at the same radius throughout • Mark a point on the circumference • Place the point of the compass on the mark and make a mark on the circumference • Repeat until you have 6 marks Perpendicular Bisector • Open a pair of compasses to approximately ¾ of the length of the line • Place the point at one end of the line and draw arcs above and below the line • Keep the compasses at the same radius, place the point at the other end of the line and draw arcs above and below the line to cut the previous arcs. • Join the 2 intersection points Bisect an Angle • Open the compasses • Place the point at the vertex of the angle and draw an arc to create points A and B • Put the point of the compasses on A and draw an arc • Keep the same radius, put the point of the compasses on B B and draw an arc • Draw a line from the vertex of A the angle through the intersection of the arcs Challenge 1 Challenge 1 Construction lines Challenge 2 Challenge 2 Construction lines Challenge 3 Challenge 3 Construction lines Challenge 4 Challenge 4 Construction lines Teacher notes: Maths and Art This edition looks at Maths and Art and encourages students to use precise geometric constructions to copy the given designs and/ or create their own. Students can use pencil, straight edge (measuring is traditionally discouraged) and compasses to construct the designs or could use a Dynamic Geometry Software package. With each of the designs, working out how it has been constructed and the geometric properties involved is the first step and may require quite a lot of discussion. Working individually with pencil and paper methods, but seated in small groups will encourage this. If using a DGS package, working with a partner should be encouraged. For KS3 and KS4 students, use of pencil, straight edge and compass will reinforce some of the geometric constructions they should be familiar with, but A level students might enjoy these activities too. Teacher notes: Maths and Art One way of extending the activity to make it more challenging, particularly for A level students, would be to ask them to use a graph plotting package to create some of the designs, which would require a good working knowledge of: equation of a circle, equations of straight lines and trigonometry. Students may find it helpful to firstly create the design using pencil and paper methods or a DGS package. This will ensure they understand how it has been constructed before trying to create it using a graphing package. Teacher notes: symbols An opportunity for students to discuss something in pairs and then feed back to the class. Teacher notes: Maths and Art Slides 2 – 8 When looking at the images, initially simply ask what students see, then probe their thinking by asking them to describe specific shapes, symmetry, and underlying structure. Some designs are based on dividing a circle into 6 (and then 12 and then sometimes 24), whereas others are based on dividing a circle into 4 (and then 8 and then 16). Often there is rotational symmetry. Sometimes there is reflectional symmetry in the structure, but one needs to look carefully at the colouring. Ask students how they think the basic designs have been constructed. What mathematical or geometrical skills did the artist need? Teacher notes: Maths and Art Slides 9-13 These slides ensure that students have the geometric skills needed to construct the designs. Traditionally, a Geometer is only permitted a straight edge, pencil and pair of compasses to construct designs. Teachers may wish to allow students to measure distances or angles, particularly if the students need practice at using a protractor or find using compasses difficult. Students will need to calculate the angle required in each case. Teacher notes: Maths and Art Slides 14-21 These slides show 4 different designs for students to re-create. Show students a design and ask how it has been created. They should then try to construct it for themselves. If they cannot work out how to construct it there is a second slide for each which shows the construction lines. The teacher notes below describe the constructions in more detail. Once students have constructed the design, they might like to make a more intricate version of it. The 4 designs do not have to be completed in order, nor do students need to complete all of them. Slides 14, 16, 18 and 20 could be reproduced full size and groups permitted to choose which one(s) they work on. Teacher notes: Maths and Art Challenge 1: A Rangoli style pattern • Draw a circle and divide into 6 equal sections • Bisect one of the angles • Use this distance around the circumference to divide the circle into 12 • Draw other circles using the centre point, these can be equally spaced, or not • Use intersection points and lines to create a design in one section • Reflect and repeat the design around the circle Teacher notes: Maths and Art Challenge 2: An Islamic style floor pattern • Draw a circle and divide into 16 equal sections. • Draw a diameter and then construct a perpendicular bisector to obtain 4 • Bisect one of the angles to obtain 8 and then bisect again to obtain 16 • Use this distance around the circumference to divide the circle into 16 • Draw other circles using the centre point • Use intersection points and lines to create a design in one section • Reflect and repeat the design around the circle Teacher notes: Maths and Art Challenge 3: A Trefoil • • • • Draw a circle and divide into 6 Select 3 alternate points Join each to the centre Bisect the radius to obtain a required centre point • Draw the red circle to obtain the other centres • Draw the 3 circles Teacher notes: Maths and Art Challenge 4: Seven Circles (one solution) • The challenge with this construction is that a radius needs to be divided into 3 equal sections. • The easiest way to achieve this – without measuring with a ruler – is to draw a line, use compasses to mark off a short length, keep the radius the same, move to the new point , mark again and repeat. • Using the red dots as the centre and radius, draw a circle • Divide the circle into 6 sections • Draw concentric circles at the other marks • Use the intersection points shown as centres for the other circles with the radius the same as the central circle Acknowledgements Rangoli designs: https://www.flickr.com/photos/rejik/9758154621 and http://homemakeover.in/rangoli-designs-for-holi/ Islamic floor design: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_architecture Stained glass window: https://www.durhamworldheritagesite.com/architecture/cathedral/intro/st ained-glass