Chapter11

advertisement

Group “Work” for Unobtrusive Research

 Describe an appropriate use for unobtrusive research.

 List some advantages of unobtrusive research.

 Distinguish between latent and manifest content.

Unobtrusive Research

Studying social life without affecting the it in the process

Unobtrusive research methods can be quantitative or qualitative.

These methods allow researchers to study things from afar without influencing the process.

This can eliminate or minimize many of the threats to the validity of research, including reactivity and social desirability bias.

One common way to conduct unobtrusive research is to analyze available records or events, characteristics or behaviors.

Three common methods of using available records are:

 content analysis

 analyzing existing statistics

 historical/comparative analysis

Content Analysis

Studying human social life through the examination of artifacts

Common artifacts for analysis include magazine ads, books, television shows, bathroom graffiti, trash

Same approach as with any research project:

 Definition of interest(s) and problem, conceptualization, operationalizing

 Development of means by which you’ll collect the data Sampling design

 Data collection and analysis.

Manifest Content Coding

Analogous to survey data collection

Establish variables and attributes – record what is present in each artifact – ready for data entry

Clarify units of analysis and observation

Establish a base of counting for comparison

 Generally code a sample of all editorials so you have a base for comparing to your findings about environmental editorials.

Latent Content Coding

Analogous to analysis of qualitative data

Look for the meaning underlying signs, symbols, language

 subjective interpretation

You may begin inductively; looking for themes

Strengths of Content Analysis

Time and money savings

Safety net – can return to source to recheck data

One mechanism for longitudinal analysis

Unobtrusive – research won’t contaminate research setting

Weaknesses of Content Analysis

Limited to recorded communication

Potential for excellent reliability

Check and recheck source

Validity varies based partially on whether you are coding latent or manifest content

Analyzing Existing Statistics

As backdrop to a study

As the main data to a study

Validity;

 Have to make due with the types of data provided; logic and replication help with dealing with validity problems

Reliability;

 Depend on the quality of the data itself

 How was the data collected?

Historical/Comparative Analysis

Much of the classic sociological work involves historical/comparative analysis

 Marx, Weber, Durkheim, Comte, Martineau, Du Bois

Sources of data; usually a qualitative data analysis process, but not always

 Existing historical accounts and analysis

 Raw data such as diaries, newspapers, magazines, public documents

Validity of Data

Question the accuracy of documents; triangulate

(corroborate)

Is the source of your data perhaps biased in some way?

Download