Slide 9-1 9 Intercompany Bond Holdings and Miscellaneous Topics— Consolidated Financial Statements Advanced Accounting, Fourth Edition Slide 9-2 Learning Objectives Slide 9-3 1. Describe the term “constructive retirement of debt.” 2. Describe how the gain or loss on constructive retirement of intercompany bond holdings is allocated between the purchasing and issuing companies. 3. Explain the impact on the consolidated financial statements when a company issues a note to an affiliated company, which then discounts the note with an outside company. 4. Determine the effect on the consolidated financial statements when a subsidiary issues a stock dividend. 5. Understand the difference in how stock dividends and cash dividends issued by a subsidiary company affect the consolidated financial statements. Learning Objectives Slide 9-4 5. Determine the impact on the investment account when a subsidiary issues a stock dividend from preacquisition earnings and from postacquisition earnings. 6. Explain how the purchase price is allocated when the subsidiary has both common and preferred stock outstanding. 7. Determine the controlling interest in income when the parent company owns both common and preferred stock of the subsidiary. Intercompany Bond Holdings An affiliate company may purchase bonds issued by another affiliate. Intercompany bond investments (receivable), bonds payable (liability), intercompany interest expense and, Intercompany interest revenue, must be eliminated. Bonds not held by external parties are viewed as being constructively retired in the consolidated financial statements. This is viewed as early retirement of debt. Slide 9-5 LO 1 Constructive retirement of debt. Accounting for Bonds - A Review Illustration: Three year bonds with a par value of $100,000 are issued on Jan. 2, 2010, for $85,000. The bonds pay 7% interest each December 31. Assume straightline amortization of the discount. Date 7% Discount Interest Amortized 1/1/10 Carrying Amount $ 85,000 12/31/10 $ 7,000 $ 5,000 * 90,000 12/31/11 7,000 5,000 95,000 12/31/12 7,000 5,000 100,000 * $100,000 – 85,000 = 15,000 / 3 years = $5,000 Slide 9-6 LO 1 Constructive retirement of debt. Accounting for Bonds - A Review Illustration - Issuing Company. Journal entries for 2010: Jan. 2 Dec. 31 Slide 9-7 Cash Discount on bonds payable Bonds payable 85,000 15,000 Interest expense Cash 7,000 Interest expense Discount on bonds payable 5,000 100,000 7,000 5,000 LO 1 Constructive retirement of debt. Accounting for Bonds - A Review Illustration - Investor Company. Journal entries for 2010: Jan. 2 Dec. 31 Slide 9-8 Investment in bonds Cash 85,000 Cash Interest revenue 7,000 Investment in bonds Interest revenue 5,000 85,000 7,000 5,000 LO 1 Constructive retirement of debt. Constructive Gain or Loss on Intercompany Bond Holdings The acquisition of affiliate’s outstanding bonds from outsiders is considered a constructive retirement by the consolidated entity. The constructive gain or loss is recognized in the consolidated income statement prior to the recognition of the gain or loss on the books of the individual companies. In the period the bonds are purchased, workpaper entries are made to accelerate the recognition of the gain or loss. After the bonds are purchased, workpaper entries are needed to eliminate the portion of the gain or loss recorded during the period on the books of the individual companies. Slide 9-9 LO 1 Constructive retirement of debt. Constructive Gain or Loss Allocation of Constructive Gain or Loss Four methods for allocating the constructive gain or loss between the parent and subsidiary: 1. Entirely to the issuing company. 2. Entirely to the purchasing company. 3. Entirely to the parent company. 4. Between the purchasing and issuing companies. The authors consider the fourth method to be the soundest conceptually. Slide 9-10 LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Constructive Gain or Loss Computing the Constructive Gain or Loss On the date bonds of an affiliate are purchased, a constructive gain or loss is computed. The portion allocated to the issuing company is the difference between the book value (carrying value) of the bonds issued and their par value; The portion allocated to the purchasing company is the difference between the par value of the bonds and their cost. There is no constructive gain or loss if the bonds are issued or purchased at par value. Slide 9-11 LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Constructive Gain or Loss Computing the Constructive Gain or Loss If the issue price and purchase price were not equal to par value, there are four possible combinations that can result: 1. 2. 3. 4. Slide 9-12 Issuing Co. Book Value $ 110,000 90,000 110,000 90,000 > < > < Par Value $ 100,000 100,000 100,000 100,000 > < < > Purchasing Co. Purchase Price $ 85,000 115,000 115,000 85,000 LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Constructive Gain or Loss Computing the Constructive Gain or Loss Issuing Co. Book Value 3. 110,000 > Par Value 100,000 + $10,000 Constructive gain < Purchasing Co. Purchase Price 115,000 - $15,000 Constructive loss - $5,000 Net constructive loss Slide 9-13 LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Constructive Gain or Loss Computing the Constructive Gain or Loss Issuing Co. Book Value 4. 90,000 > Par Value 100,000 - $10,000 Constructive loss < Purchasing Co. Purchase Price 85,000 + $15,000 Constructive gain + $5,000 Net constructive gain Slide 9-14 LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Accounting for Intercompany Bonds Illustrated Illustration: P Company acquired an 80% interest in S Company for $1,200,000 on January 2, 2009, when the retained earnings and common stock accounts of S Company were $500,000 and $1,000,000, respectively. On December 31, 2012, P Company acquired $300,000 of S Company’s par value bonds (60% of S Company’s bonds) on the open market for $310,000 after the semiannual interest payment had been made. At the time of purchase there were $500,000 par value bonds outstanding with a book value of $480,000. The bonds mature in four years on December 31, 2016, and carry an interest rate of 9%. Interest is paid semiannually on June 30 and December 31. Both companies use the straight-line method to amortize bond discounts and premiums. The fiscal year-end of both companies is December 31. Slide 9-15 LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Book Entry Related to Bond Investment Prepare the entry made by P Company to record the bond investment: Dec. 31 Investment in S Company Bonds Cash 310,000 310,000 Note: Slide 9-16 The usual practice of recording a bond investment does not separate the discount or premium. Since the bonds were purchased on the open market, there is no entry made on the issuing company’s books. LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Book Entry Related to Bond Investment Compute the Constructive Gain or Loss S Company Book Value 288,000 > Par Value 300,000 - $12,000 Constructive loss On the books of the individual companies, the constructive loss is not recorded. Slide 9-17 < P Company Purchase Price 310,000 - $10,000 Constructive loss - $22,000 Net constructive loss The constructive loss is recognized in the determination of consolidated income. LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Consolidated Statements Workpaper—2012 Income Statement Sales Dividend income Total revenue Cost of goods sold Interest expense Other expenses Loss on constructive retirement of bonds Total cost and expense Net income Noncontrolling interest Net income Retained Earnings Statement Retained earnings, 1/1 Net income Dividends declared Retained earnings, 12/31 Balance Sheet Investment in S Co. bonds Investment in S. Co. stock Other assets Total assets 9% bonds payable Discount on bonds payable Other liabilities Capital stock Retained earnings NCI in net assets 1/1 NCI in net assets 12/31 Slide Total liab. & equity 9-18 P Company 3,104,000 16,000 3,120,000 1,700,000 S Company 2,200,000 1,124,000 2,200,000 1,360,000 50,000 665,000 2,824,000 296,000 2,075,000 125,000 296,000 125,000 1,650,000 296,000 (150,000) 1,796,000 700,000 125,000 (20,000) 805,000 Eliminations Debit Credit 16,000 (5) 10,000 (2) 12,000 (3) 38,000 700,000 (6) 38,000 738,000 310,000 1,200,000 5,420,000 6,930,000 NCI 160,000 (1) 2,134,000 3,000,000 1,796,000 2,620,000 2,620,000 500,000 (20,000) 335,000 1,000,000 805,000 1,000,000 (6) 738,000 6,930,000 2,620,000 2,198,000 160,000 (1) 16,000 (5) 176,000 22,600 22,600 22,000 4,921,000 383,000 (22,600) 360,400 22,600 (4,000) 18,600 1,810,000 360,400 (150,000) 2,020,400 10,000 (2) 300,000 (4) 1,360,000 (6) 300,000 (4) 12,000 176,000 18,600 340,000 (6) 340,000 358,600 2,198,000 Consolidated Balances 5,304,000 5,304,000 3,060,000 50,000 1,789,000 8,040,000 8,040,000 200,000 (8,000) 2,469,000 3,000,000 2,020,400 358,600 8,040,000 Consolidated Statements Workpaper—2012 Income Statement Sales Dividend income Total revenue Cost of goods sold Interest expense Other expenses Loss on constructive retirement of bonds Total cost and expense Net income Noncontrolling interest Net income P Company 3,104,000 16,000 3,120,000 1,700,000 1,124,000 2,824,000 296,000 296,000 Retained Earnings Statement Retained earnings, 1/1 1,650,000 Net income 296,000 Dividends declared (150,000) Retained earnings, 12/31 1,796,000 S Company 2,200,000 Eliminations Debit Credit 16,000 (5) 10,000 12,000 (2) NCI 2,200,000 1,360,000 50,000 665,000 (3) 22,600 * 22,600 22,000 4,921,000 383,000 (22,600) 360,400 22,600 (4,000) 18,600 1,810,000 360,400 (150,000) 2,020,400 2,075,000 125,000 125,000 38,000 700,000 125,000 (20,000) 805,000 700,000 38,000 738,000 - (6) 160,000 16,000 176,000 (1) (5) Consolidated Balances 5,304,000 5,304,000 3,060,000 50,000 1,789,000 * ($125,000 $12,000) x 20% = $22,600 Slide 9-19 LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Consolidated Statements Workpaper—2012 P Balance Sheet Company Investment in S Co. bonds 310,000 Investment in S. Co. stock Other assets Total assets 9% bonds payable Discount on bonds payable Other liabilities Capital stock Retained earnings NCI in net assets 1/1 ** NCI in net assets 12/31 Total liab. & equity 1,200,000 5,420,000 6,930,000 2,134,000 3,000,000 1,796,000 6,930,000 S Company 2,620,000 2,620,000 500,000 (20,000) 335,000 1,000,000 805,000 2,620,000 Eliminations Debit Credit 10,000 300,000 160,000 (1) 1,360,000 300,000 2,198,000 (2) (4) (6) (4) 12,000 1,000,000 738,000 NCI (3) (6) 176,000 340,000 2,198,000 Consolidated Balances - (6) 18,600 340,000 358,600 8,040,000 8,040,000 200,000 (8,000) 2,469,000 3,000,000 2,020,400 358,600 8,040,000 ** $300,000 ($700,000 - $500,000) x 20% = $340,000 Slide 9-20 LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Consolidated Statements Workpaper—2012 Worksheet entries for 2012. 1. Investment in S Company Stock Beginning Retained Earnings—P Company 160,000 160,000 To establish reciprocity, or convert to equity Retained earnings balance—January 1, 2012 Retained earnings balance—date of acquisition 500,000 Increase in retained earnings 200,000 Percentage interest held by P Company Amount to establish reciprocity Slide 9-21 $ 700,000 80% $ 160,000 LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Consolidated Statements Workpaper—2012 Worksheet entries for 2012. 2. Loss on Constructive Retirement of Bonds Investment in S Company Bonds 10,000 10,000 To recognize the constructive loss not recorded by P Company and adjust the bond investment to par value. 3. Loss on Constructive Retirement of Bonds Discount on Bonds Payable 12,000 12,000 To recognize the constructive loss not recorded by the subsidiary and adjust the intercompany bonds to par value. Entries (2) and (3) recognize the constructive loss allocated to each company and adjust bond investment and carrying value of the intercompany debt to par value. Slide 9-22 LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Consolidated Statements Workpaper—2012 Worksheet entries for 2012. 4. Bonds Payable Investment in S Company Bonds 300,000 300,000 To eliminate intercompany bond investment and liability. 5. Dividend Income Dividends Declared—S Company 6. Beginning Retained Earnings—S Company Common Stock—S Company Investment in S Company Stock Noncontrolling Interest in Equity Slide 9-23 16,000 16,000 700,000 1,000,000 1,360,000 340,000 LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Consolidated Statements Workpaper—2012 Complete Equity Method If the complete equity method is used, entry (1), the reciprocity entry, is not needed and the following entry replaces entry (5) above. Equity in S Company Income Dividends Declared Investment in S Company Stock 80,400 16,000 64,400 To eliminate the intercompany income and dividends. Slide 9-24 LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Complete Equity Method Consolidated Statements Workpaper —2013 Income Statement Sales Equity income Total revenue Cost of goods sold Interest expense Other expenses Loss on retirement Total cost and expense Net income Noncontrolling interest Net income Retained Earnings Statement Retained earnings, 1/1 Net income Dividends declared Retained earnings, 12/31 P Company 3,104,000 80,400 3,184,400 1,700,000 S Company 2,200,000 Eliminations Debit Credit NCI 80,400 (3) 1,124,000 2,200,000 1,360,000 50,000 665,000 2,824,000 360,400 2,075,000 125,000 22,000 (1) 360,400 125,000 102,400 1,810,000 360,400 (150,000) 2,020,400 700,000 125,000 (20,000) 805,000 700,000 (4) 102,400 Balance Sheet Investment in S Co. bonds 310,000 Investment in S. Co. stock 1,424,400 Other assets Total assets 9% bonds payable Discount on bonds payable Other liabilities Capital stock Retained earnings NCI in net assets 1/1 NCI in net assets 12/31 5,420,000 7,154,400 SlideTotal liab. & equity 9-25 802,400 - 16,000 (3) 16,000 10,000 300,000 64,400 1,360,000 2,134,000 3,000,000 2,020,400 2,620,000 2,620,000 500,000 (20,000) 335,000 1,000,000 805,000 1,000,000 (4) 802,400 7,154,400 2,620,000 2,102,400 22,600 22,600 22,600 (4,000) 18,600 (1) (2) (3) 1,810,000 360,400 (150,000) 2,020,400 - (4) 300,000 (2) 12,000 (1) 16,000 340,000 (4) 2,102,400 Consolidated Balances 5,304,000 5,304,000 3,060,000 50,000 1,789,000 22,000 4,921,000 383,000 (22,600) 360,400 18,600 340,000 358,600 8,040,000 8,040,000 200,000 (8,000) 2,469,000 3,000,000 2,020,400 358,600 8,040,000 Year Subsequent to Acquisition of Bonds, Entries on the Books of Affiliated Companies—2013 P Company’s Books Entries on June 30 and December 31 Cash Interest Revenue 13,500 13,500 To record receipt of interest ($300,000 x 9% x 6/12). Interest Revenue Investment in S Company Bonds 1,250 1,250 To amortize premium on outstanding bonds ($10,000 8 periods). Slide 9-26 LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Year Subsequent to Acquisition of Bonds, Entries on the Books of Affiliated Companies—2013 S Company’s Books Entries on June 30 and December 31 Interest Expense Cash 22,500 22,500 To record payment of interest ($500,000 x 9% x 6/12). Interest Expense Discount on Bonds Payable 2,500 2,500 To amortize discount on outstanding bonds ($20,000 / 8 periods). Slide 9-27 LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Consolidated Statements Workpaper Entries Worksheet entries for December 31, 2013. 1. Investment in S Company Stock 244,000 Beginning Retained Earnings—P Company 244,000 To establish reciprocity, or convert to equity ($805,000 $500,000) x 80% = $244,000 2. Beginning Retained Earnings—P Company Investment in S Company Bonds 10,000 10,000 To adjust beginning retained earnings for constructive loss (recorded in prior year as workpaper entry only; see 2012 entry (2) and to adjust investment to par. Slide 9-28 LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Consolidated Statements Workpaper Entries Worksheet entries for December 31, 2013. 3. Beginning Retained Earnings—P Company * 9,600 Beginning Noncontrolling Interest ** 2,400 Discount on Bonds Payable ($15,000 x 60%) 12,000 To adjust beginning retained earnings balances for unrecorded constructive loss at beginning of the year (recorded in 2012 as workpaper entry only; see 2012 entry (3)) and adjust intercompany bonds to par value. * ($12,000 x 80%) ** ($12,000 x 20%) Slide 9-29 LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Consolidated Statements Workpaper Entries Worksheet entries for December 31, 2013. 4. Investment in S Company Bonds Interest Revenue ($1,250 + $1,250) 2,500 2,500 To reverse the amortization of premium on investment recorded by P Company during the current year (and not needed by consolidated entity since the constructive loss was recorded in its entirety in 2012). Slide 9-30 LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Consolidated Statements Workpaper Entries Worksheet entries for December 31, 2013. 5. Discount on Bonds Payable ($5,000 x 60%) 3,000 Interest Expense 3,000 To reverse amortization of discount on bonds payable recorded by S Company during current year (and not needed by consolidated entity since the constructive loss was recorded in its entirety in 2012). 6. Interest Revenue * 27,000 Interest Expense 27,000 To eliminate intercompany interest. * ($45,000 x 60%) or ($13,500 + $13,500) Slide 9-31 LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Consolidated Statements Workpaper Entries Worksheet entries for December 31, 2013. 7. Bonds Payable ($500,000 x 60%) 300,000 Investment in S Company Bonds 300,000 To eliminate intercompany bond investment and bonds payable. 8. Dividend Income Dividends Declared—S Company 9. Beginning Retained Earnings—S Company Common Stock—S Company Investment in S Company Stock Noncontrolling Interest in Equity Slide 9-32 48,000 48,000 805,000 1,000,000 1,444,000 361,000 LO 2 Allocating the constructive gain or loss. Consolidated Statements Workpaper—2013 Income Statement Sales Dividend income Interest income Total revenue Cost of goods sold Interest expense Other expenses Total cost and expense Net income Noncontrolling interest Net income Retained Earnings Statement Retained earnings, 1/1 P Company S Company Net income Dividends declared Retained earnings, 12/31 Balance Sheet Investment in S Co. bonds Investment in S. Co. stock Other assets Total assets 9% bonds payable Discount on bonds payable Other liabilities Capital stock Retained earnings NCI in net assets 1/1 NCI in net assets 12/31 Slide 9-33 Total liab. & equity P Company 3,546,000 48,000 24,500 3,618,500 2,040,000 S Company 2,020,000 1,124,500 3,164,500 454,000 630,000 1,880,000 140,000 454,000 140,000 2,020,000 1,200,000 50,000 805,000 140,000 (60,000) 885,000 2,220,000 3,000,000 2,100,000 2,690,000 2,690,000 500,000 (15,000) 320,000 1,000,000 885,000 7,320,000 2,690,000 NCI 2,500 (4) 3,000 (5) 27,000 (6) 75,000 10,000 (2) 9,600 (3) 805,000 (9) 75,000 899,600 2,500 (4) 307,500 1,200,000 5,812,500 7,320,000 Eliminations Credit 48,000 (8) 27,000 (6) 1,796,000 454,000 (150,000) 2,100,000 Debit Cost Method 32,500 244,000 (1) 10,000 (2) 300,000 (7) 1,444,000 (9) 300,000 (7) 3,000 (5) 12,000 (3) 1,000,000 (9) 899,600 2,400 (3) 324,500 361,000 (9) 2,451,500 28,600 28,600 1,754,500 5,014,500 551,500 (28,600) 522,900 28,600 (12,000) 16,600 2,020,400 522,900 (150,000) 2,393,300 244,000 (1) 32,500 48,000 (1) 324,500 2,451,500 Consolidated Balances 5,566,000 5,566,000 3,240,000 20,000 - 16,600 358,600 375,200 8,502,500 8,502,500 200,000 (6,000) 2,540,000 3,000,000 2,393,300 375,200 8,502,500 Interim Purchase of Intercompany Bonds Had the bonds been held during 2012, P Company would have amortized a portion of the premium and S Company would have amortized a part of the discount. Assuming that P Company amortized $500 and S Company amortized $600 during 2012, the original workpaper entries (2) and (3) for constructive losses) are modified as follows: Slide 9-34 2. Loss on Constructive Retirement Bonds Interest Revenue Investment in S Company Bonds 10,000 3. Loss on Constructive Retirement of Bonds Interest Expense Discount on Bonds Payable 12,000 500 9,500 600 11,400 Notes Receivable Discounted A company may issue a note to an affiliated company that may then discount the note with an outside party. OR A company holding a note receivable from an outside party may discount the note with an affiliated company. From a consolidation point of view, a receivable held by one of the affiliated companies should be reported in the consolidated balance sheet only if the note is due from an outside party. Slide 9-35 LO 3 Discounting a note issued to an affiliated company with an outside company. Stock Dividends Issued by a Subsidiary Company Parent company records receipt of shares in a memorandum entry only. Subsidiary records the declaration of a stock dividend as a transfer from retained earnings to one or more paid-in capital account. Amount transferred is dependent on a large or small stock dividend. Slide 9-36 LO 4 Stock dividends issued by a subsidiary. Stock Dividends Issued by a Subsidiary Company Illustration: Assume that P Company purchased 4,000 shares of S Company’s $100 par value common stock on January 2, 2009, for $560,000. At the time of purchase, S Company reported common stock and retained earnings balances of $500,000 and $200,000, respectively. If consolidated statements were prepared on January 2, 2009, the investment eliminating entry would be: Slide 9-37 Capital Stock—S Company 500,000 1/1 Retained Earnings—S Company 200,000 Investment in S Company 560,000 Noncontrolling Interest in Equity 140,000 LO 4 Stock dividends issued by a subsidiary. Stock Dividends Issued by a Subsidiary Company Illustration: Now assume that S Company reports net income of $50,000 and declares a 30% stock dividend (1,500 shares) on December 31, 2009. S Company would record the dividend as follows (par value): Stock Dividend Declared (or R/E) Capital Stock (1,500 shares $100) 150,000 150,000 The only entry made by P Company in 2009 is a memorandum entry to record the receipt of 1,200 shares from S Company. Slide 9-38 LO 4 Stock dividends issued by a subsidiary. Consolidated Statements Workpaper—2009 Cost Method Consolidated Statement Workpaper December 31, 2009 Income Statement Net/consolidated income Noncontrolling interest Net income Retained Earnings Statement Retained earnings, 1/1 P Company S Company Net income Dividends declared Retained earnings, 12/31 Balance Sheet Investment in S Company Fixed assets Total assets P Company S Company 240,000 50,000 240,000 50,000 Debit Eliminations Credit - - NCI 10,000 10,000 290,000 (10,000) 280,000 10,000 (30,000) (20,000) 460,000 280,000 740,000 460,000 240,000 700,000 200,000 50,000 (150,000) 100,000 200,000 (2) 200,000 120,000 (1) 120,000 Consolidated Balances 560,000 (2) 560,000 1,240,000 1,800,000 800,000 800,000 2,040,000 2,040,000 Total liabilities Capital stock P Company S Company 200,000 50,000 250,000 Retained earnings NCI in net assets 1/1 NCI in net assets 12/31 Total liab. & equity 700,000 100,000 120,000 (1) 500,000 (2) 200,000 1,800,000 800,000 820,000 Slide 9-39 900,000 650,000 30,000 120,000 140,000 (2) 820,000 (20,000) 140,000 150,000 900,000 740,000 150,000 2,040,000 LO 4 Stock dividends issued by a subsidiary. Stock Dividends Issued by a Subsidiary Company Worksheet Entries – Year Stock Dividends Are Declared 1. Capital Stock—S Company 120,000 Stock Dividends Declared—S Company 120,000 To reverse effects of stock dividend ($150,000 x 80%). 2. 1/1 Retained Earnings—S Company Capital Stock—S Company 200,000 500,000 Investment in S Company 560,000 Noncontrolling Interest in Equity 140,000 To eliminate investment account and recognize noncontrolling interest. Slide 9-40 LO 4 Stock dividends issued by a subsidiary. Stock Dividends Issued by a Subsidiary Company Stock Dividends Issued from Postacquisition Earnings If the stock dividend had been more than retained earnings ($200,000), some of the postacquisition earnings of the subsidiary would have been capitalized. Committee on Accounting Procedure: Occasionally, subsidiary companies capitalize retained earnings arising since acquisition, by means of a stock dividend or otherwise. This does not require a transfer to capital surplus on consolidation. Slide 9-41 LO 6 Subsidiary stock dividends issued from postacquisition earnings. Stock Dividends Issued by a Subsidiary Company Dividends from Preacquisition Earnings Effects of a liquidating dividend on the consolidated statements workpaper entries: Assume that P Company acquired an 80% interest in S Company on January 2, 2009, for $560,000. At the time of purchase, S Company had capital stock and retained earnings in the amounts of $500,000 and $200,000, respectively. During the first year that the investment was held, S Company reported net income of $200,000. On December 31, 2009, the subsidiary declared and paid a cash dividend of $250,000. Slide 9-42 LO 6 Subsidiary stock dividends issued from preacquisition earnings. Stock Dividends Issued by a Subsidiary Company Dividends from Preacquisition Earnings Liquidating dividends are accounted for as a return of part of the original investment. P Company’s Books Cash 200,000 Dividend Income ($200,000 x 80%) 160,000 Investment in S Company ($50,000 x 80%) 40,000 To record receipt of a cash dividend from S Company Slide 9-43 LO 6 Subsidiary stock dividends issued from preacquisition earnings. Stock Dividends Issued by a Subsidiary Company Dividends from Preacquisition Earnings The December 31, 2009, eliminating entries are as follows: 1. Dividend Income 160,000 Dividends Declared—S Company 160,000 To eliminate intercompany dividends. 2. Investment in S Company Dividends Declared—S Company 40,000 40,000 To reverse the liquidating dividend. Slide 9-44 LO 6 Subsidiary stock dividends issued from preacquisition earnings. Stock Dividends Issued by a Subsidiary Company Dividends from Preacquisition Earnings The December 31, 2009, eliminating entries are as follows: 3. Beginning Retained Earnings—S Co. Capital Stock—S Company 200,000 500,000 Investment in S Company 560,000 Noncontrolling Interest in Equity 140,000 To eliminate investment account and create noncontrolling interest. Slide 9-45 LO 6 Subsidiary stock dividends issued from preacquisition earnings. Subsidiary with Preferred and Common Stock Outstanding Determining Equity Interest of Each Class of Stockholders Subsidiary company preferred shares not held by the parent company are considered part of the noncontrolling interest. In consolidation, each class of stockholders has an interest in the net assets of the firm, so it is necessary to allocate: Subsidiary’s Stockholders’ Equity between preferred and common stock interests. Retained Earnings and Net Income amounts to each class of stockholders, based on dividend preference. Slide 9-46 LO 7 Allocating the purchase price between common and preferred stockholders. Consolidating with Preferred Stock Outstanding Illustration: Assume the following information concerning the capital accounts of S Company as of January 2, 2009: 8%, $100 par value preferred stock, cumulative, nonparticipating, dividends in arrears for 2008, call price is $103,5,000 shares outstanding $ 500,000 Common stock, $10 par value Other contributed capital—excess on issue of common stock over par 305,000 Retained earnings 200,000 Total stockholders’ equity Slide 9-47 1,000,000 $2,005,000 LO 7 Allocating the purchase price between common and preferred stockholders. Consolidating with Preferred Stock Outstanding On January 2, 2009, P Company acquired 80% of the outstanding common stock for $1,160,000 and 30% of the outstanding preferred stock for $180,000. During the year, S Company reported net income of $200,000 and declared no cash dividends. The entry to record the purchase is: P Company’s Books Investment in S Co. preferred stock Investment in S Co. Common Stock Cash Slide 9-48 180,000 1,160,000 1,340,000 LO 7 Allocating the purchase price between common and preferred stockholders. Consolidating with Preferred Stock Outstanding Computation and Allocation of Difference Between Implied and Book Value Acquired—Preferred Stock Date of Acquisition - 1/1/ 2009 Parent 30% NCI 70% Total 100% Purchase price and implied value $ 180,000 $ 420,000 $ 600,000 Less: Book value of equity acquired: $100 par preferred stock - 8% (150,000) (350,000) (500,000) Retained earnings ** (16,500) (38,500) (55,000) Difference between implied and BV 13,500 31,500 45,000 Reduce Paid-in-Capital—Parent (13,500) Reduce Noncontrolling Interest in Equity * (31,500) Total allocated (45,000) Balance 0 0 0 * Noncontrolling interest after adjustment $420,000 - $31,500 = $388,500 ** ($103 call + $8 dividends in arrears - $100 par) x 5,000 shares = $11 x 5,000 Slide 9-49 = $55,000 LO 7 Allocating the purchase price between common and preferred stockholders. Consolidating with Preferred Stock Outstanding Consolidated Statements Workpaper Entries—2009 Cost Method or Partial Equity Method 1a. Beginning Retained Earnings—S Co. Preferred Stock—S Co. 55,000 500,000 Difference Between Implied and BV 45,000 Investment in S Co. Preferred Stock 180,000 Noncontrolling Interest in Equity 420,000 To eliminate the preferred stock investment account and recognize the noncontrolling interest in equity. Slide 9-50 LO 7 Allocating the purchase price between common and preferred stockholders. Consolidating with Preferred Stock Outstanding Consolidated Statements Workpaper Entries—2009 Cost Method or Partial Equity Method 1b. Other Contributed Capital—P Company 13,500 Noncontrolling Interest in Equity 31,500 Difference Between Implied and Book Value 45,000 To allocate the difference between implied and book values of preferred stock to equity. Slide 9-51 LO 7 Allocating the purchase price between common and preferred stockholders. Consolidating with Preferred Stock Outstanding Computation and Allocation of Difference Between Implied and Book Value Acquired—Common Stock Parent 80% Date of Acquisition - 1/1/ 2009 Purchase price and implied value Less: Book value of equity acquired: $10 par common stock Contributed capital -common stock Retained earnings* Difference between implied and BV $ 1,160,000 (800,000) (244,000) (116,000) 0 NCI 20% $ 290,000 (200,000) (61,000) (29,000) 0 Total 100% $ 1,450,000 (1,000,000) (305,000) (145,000) 0 * $200,000 - $55,000 = $145,000 Slide 9-52 LO 7 Allocating the purchase price between common and preferred stockholders. Consolidating with Preferred Stock Outstanding Consolidated Statements Workpaper Entries—2009 Cost Method or Partial Equity Method 2. Beginning Retained Earnings—S Co. Common Stock—S Co. 1,000,000 Other Contributed Capital—S Co. Investment in S Co. Common Stock NCI in Equity 145,000 305,000 1,160,000 290,000 To eliminate the common stock investment account and recognize NCI. Slide 9-53 LO 7 Allocating the purchase price between common and preferred stockholders. Consolidating with Preferred Stock Outstanding Noncontrolling interest in the consolidated income for 2009 is computed as follows: Contribution to Consolidated Income Reported net income of S Company Income allocated to preferred stock Income allocated to common stock NCI in consolidated income Slide 9-54 $ 200,000 $ 40,000 160,000 NCI % 70% 20% NCI $ 28,000 32,000 $ 60,000 LO 7 Allocating the purchase price between common and preferred stockholders. Consolidating with Preferred Stock Outstanding Consolidated Statement Workpaper December 31, 2009 P Income Statement Company Net/consolidated income 800,000 Noncontrolling interest in Dividend income Preferred stock Common stock Net income 800,000 Retained Earnings Statement Retained earnings, 1/1 P Company 1,450,000 S Company Preferred stock Common stock Net income 800,000 Dividends declared (500,000) Retained earnings, 12/31 1,750,000 Balance Sheet Investment in S Company Preferred stock 180,000 Common stock 1,160,000 Difference Implied and BV Other assets 5,410,000 SlideTotal assets 6,750,000 9-55 S Company 200,000 200,000 Eliminations Debit Credit - 55,000 145,000 200,000 55,000 145,000 400,000 200,000 28,000 32,000 60,000 - (1a) (2) 60,000 - 180,000 1,160,000 (1a) 45,000 45,000 2,805,000 2,805,000 NCI 60,000 (1a) (2) (1b) Cost Method Page 1 Consolidated Balances 1,000,000 (60,000) 940,000 1,450,000 940,000 (500,000) 1,890,000 8,215,000 8,215,000 Consolidating with Preferred Stock Outstanding Retained earnings, 1/1 P Company S Company Preferred stock Common stock Net income Dividends declared Retained earnings, 12/31 Balance Sheet Investment in S Company Preferred stock Common stock Difference Implied and BV Other assets Total assets Total liabilities Preferred stock S Co. Common stock Other contributed capital P Company S Company Retained earnings NCI in net assets 1/1 NCI in net assets 12/31 SlideTotal liab. & equity 9-56 1,450,000 800,000 (500,000) 1,750,000 55,000 145,000 200,000 55,000 145,000 400,000 200,000 180,000 1,160,000 5,410,000 6,750,000 1,600,000 3,000,000 6,750,000 - 180,000 1,160,000 45,000 (1a) 45,000 2,805,000 2,805,000 600,000 500,000 1,000,000 400,000 1,750,000 60,000 305,000 400,000 2,805,000 500,000 1,000,000 (1a) 13,500 305,000 200,000 31,500 (1b) 60,000 (1a) (2) (1b) (2) (2) 60,000 (1b) 420,000(1a) 678,500 290,000 (2) 738,500 2,095,000 2,095,000 Cost Method Page 2 1,450,000 940,000 (500,000) 1,890,000 8,215,000 8,215,000 2,200,000 3,000,000 386,500 1,890,000 738,500 8,215,000 Copyright Copyright © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction or translation of this work beyond that permitted in Section 117 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act without the express written permission of the copyright owner is unlawful. Request for further information should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons, Inc. The purchaser may make back-up copies for his/her own use only and not for distribution or resale. The Publisher assumes no responsibility for errors, omissions, or damages, caused by the use of these programs or from the use of the information contained herein. Slide 9-57