Bond Valuation Professor Thomas Chemmanur Bond Valuation A bond represents borrowing by firms from investors. F Face Value of the bond (sometimes known as "par value"); this is the amount the company will pay back at the maturity of the bond. Ct Coupon or interest payment at date t. Usually coupon amounts are the same at each date, in which case we will simply use C for coupon. A coupon is often expressed as a percentage c of the face value. This percentage is called "coupon rate". Then, C = c•F, where c is expressed in decimals. Notice that the coupon rate is specified as part of the bond (it is not something that changes according to economic conditions). 2 Bond Valuation n The number of periods to maturity. r The rate of return per period at which the bond cash flows are to be discounted, determined by financial market conditions. For the present, we will assume that cashflows at all dates are to be discounted at the same rate. r changes as the general level of interest rates in the economy changes. The price that you are willing to pay for the bond is simply the present value of all the cash flows that the bond entitles you to; Thus, C3 Cn F C1 C2 P ..... 2 3 (1 r ) (1 r ) (1 r ) (1 r ) n 3 Bond Valuation Usually coupon payments are made semi-annually; this means that the length of a period is a half-year, and r should be in terms of return per half-year; n should also be in halfyears. If the price of the bond is less than the face value, we say that the bond is selling at a "discount"; if they are the same, the bond is selling at par; if the price is higher than the face value, it is selling at a "premium". 4 Example If Teletron Electronics has a bond outstanding that pays a $75 coupon semi-annually, what is its price? The annual interest rate = 10%; 15 years to maturity. r = 10/2 = 5% n = 15*2 = 30 PERIODS P = 75 (PVIFA 5%, 30) + 1000(PVIF 5%, 30) = 75 (15.3725) + 1000(0.2314) = $1384.34 There are several rules about bond pricing that can be kept in mind. 5 Some Rules of Bond Valuation • • • • • (i) WHEN c = r , THE BOND SELLS AT PAR (ii) WHEN c > r, THE BOND SELLS AT A PREMIUM (FOR n > 0); WHEN c < r, THE BOND SELLS AT A DISCOUNT (FOR n > 0); (iii) WHEN r , PRICE FALLS; AND WHEN r , PRICE INCREASES. (iv) THE LONGER THE MATURITY, THE MORE SENSITIVE THE BOND PRICE TO INTEREST RATE CHANGES. (v) AS n 0 (THE BOND APPROACHES MATURITY), P F (FACE VALUE); AT n = 0, P = F. 6 Summary of Bond Valuation Rules Bond Price, p r<c r=c F r>c 0 Time to Maturity, n 7 Yield to Maturity The yield to maturity of a bond is the rate of return we would earn if we bought the bond at a price P and held it till it matures. That is, it is that rate of return r that solves the bond pricing equation for a known P. Clearly YTM will be different for different values of P. (Usually, yield to maturity is computed and quoted in the financial press assuming semi-annual compounding). The assumption here is that you are able to re-invest all coupons you receive also at the rate of return r. 8 What determines the yield of bonds? 1. Real Interest Rate 2. Inflation Rate 3. Time to Maturity Real Interest Rate ( rc ) Is defined as the interest rate that would prevail in a world without inflation. It depends on: (a) Investor Preferences (current vs. future consumption) (b) Production Opportunities Inflation Rate (p) Inflation exists in most economies, measured by: 9 What determines the yield of bonds? PRICE OF A BASKET OF GOODS NEXT YEAR (1 + p) = PRICE OF SAME BASKET THIS YEAR p = (Ratio of PRICES) – 1 E.g. Consumer Price Index Relationship between real and nominal (money) interest rates. (Fisher’s Theory) (1 + r) = (1 + rc) (1 + p) 10 Term Structure of Interest Rates Often, the discounting rate to be applied to a one year loan is different from that for a two year loan, etc. The relationship between the length of a loan (or, to talk in terms of a bond, the time to maturity) and the rate of return you can earn on a loan (the yield to maturity in the case of a bond) is called the term-structure of interest rates or the yield curve. To make this relationship clear, we will think in terms of 'spot rates.' A spot rate is the rate of return on a loan or a bond which has only one cash flow to the investor: the investor makes a loan of an amount P and gets back the amount F at the maturity of the loan. Remember that this is exactly the same as investing in a bond with a zero coupon rate, which has a current price P and face value F. 11 Term Structure of Interest Rates Thus the one-year spot rate is the yield to maturity on zero coupon bonds (sometimes referred to as 'pure discount' bonds) of one year maturity. Let us denote the one year spot rate by r1. Then, the price of a one-year maturity zero-coupon bond with face value F is given by: F P01 (1 r1 ) Similarly, the two-year spot rate r2 is the rate of return on a twoyear loan, or equivalently, the yield to maturity on a two year zero-coupon bond. Then, the price of a two-year zero coupon bond is, F P02 (1 r ) 2 12 Term Structure of Interest Rates We can write down similar relationships between the prices of a three year pure discount bond, a four year zero coupon bond etc., and the corresponding spot rates r3, r4, r5 etc. Now, if r1 < r2 < r3 ...etc., the term structure is uniformly upward sloping, which is very often the case. On the other hand, if r1 > r2 > r3... the term structure is uniformly downward sloping. The term structure is 'flat' if r1 = r2 = r3 ...etc. The termstructure can also take other shapes as well. With all the spot rates, we can price any riskless bond with cash flows of any magnitude and at arbitrary points in time. This is because we can show that all cash flows of similar riskiness occurring at 13 the same point in time should be Term Structure of Interest Rates Thus, consider a bond with coupons C1, C2, C3, ...Cn occurring at time periods t=1, 2, 3, ...n. In addition, let the face value of the bond be F. The price of the bond is then given by, Cn F C1 C2 P .... 2 (1 r1 ) (1 r2 ) (1 rn ) n YTM TYPICAL YIELD CURVES 0 Time to Maturity, n 14 Example Compute the spot rates given the following zero coupon bond prices : P01 = $900; P02 = $820; P03 = $725 (Assume $1000 face values). P01 = 900 = 1000 1000 r= -1 (1 + r1 ) 900 1000 1000 P02 = 820 = r2 = -1 2 (1 + r2 ) 820 1000 1000 3 P03 = 725 = r3 = -1 3 (1 + r3 ) 725 15 Decomposing a Zero Coupon Bond Decomposing a zero coupon bond into a portfolio of zero coupon bonds: 1. If the yield curve is upward sloping, the yield on a coupon bond will be lower than on a zero coupon bond (why?) 2. If the yield curve is downward sloping, the yield on a coupon bond will be higher than on a zero-coupon bond. 3. The key is to realize that the yield on coupon bonds are weighted averages of the corresponding spot rates. 16 The Law of One Price What happens if the bond price is different from the price computed by the above formula? We can show that in that case, 'the law of one price' is violated, and there are opportunities for making arbitrage profits which can be taken advantage of by investors, and the price of the bond will be driven back to the above price. law of one price: securities (or portfolios of securities) which have the same riskiness, and which entitle the holder to the same stream of cash flows should have the same current price. Remember that whenever there are arbitrage opportunities, the security markets cannot be in equilibrium: thus the equilibrium price of the above bond should be given by the above formula. 17 Problem Is there an arbitrage opportunity? BOND A B C CASH FLOW AT DATE: 1 2 80 1080 1100 120 1120 PRICE 982 880 1010 Let us try to replicate bond C with bonds A and B: nA (80) + nB (1100) = 120 (1) nA (1080) + nB (0) = 1120 (2) 18 Problem From (2) Substituting in (1), 1120 nA = = 1.037 1080 120 - 1.037(80) nB = = 0.03367 1100 So, by the law of one price, PC = nA (PA) + nB (PB) = 1.037 (982) + 0.03367 (880) = 1047.96 1010 Therefore, an arbitrage opportunity exists. Buy bond C and sell and equivalent portfolio of bonds A and B. 19 Valuing Perpetual Bonds If a bond pays a coupon C each period for ever (no face value), its market value (at a discounting rate r) is, P = C/r, since the coupon stream forms a perpetual annuity. Also called a consol bond Example: C = $50/yr r = 12% = 0.12 P = 50/0.12 = $416.67 20 Valuing Preferred Stock “Preferred stock” usually promise a fixed payment forever (however, unlike corporate bonds, the company can miss payments without going bankrupt). Thus, they can be treated as a perpetuity: P = C/r. Here C denotes the "preferred dividend". 21