Chapter: 1 Basic Ideas SECTION 1.1 EXERCISES 21. Answers will vary. Understanding the Concepts 22. Answers will vary. Stratified Exercises 1-6 are the Check Your Understanding exercises located within the section. Their answers are found on page 12. 23. Answers will vary. Cluster 7. population 26. Cluster 8. sample 27. Sample of convenience 9. simple random sample 28. Systematic 24. Answers will vary. Systematic 25. Stratified 10. sample of convenience 29. Voluntary response 11. cluster 30. Cluster 12. stratified 31. Sample of convenience 13. False. A sample of convenience is acceptable when it is difficult or impossible to draw a sample in a truly random way. 32. Simple random sample 33. Stratified 34. Cluster 14. False. In a cluster sample, a simple random sample of clusters is selected, and every individual in each selected cluster is part of the sample. 35. Simple random sample 36. Stratified 15. True. Working with the Concepts 16. True. 37. Sample of convenience. In order to choose a simple random sample, every individual in the population has to have the same chance of being selected. Since presumably every person in the world suffers from headaches, this means that the pharmaceutical company would have to randomly select persons from every state and every country, which is not feasible. Practicing the Skills 17. Statistic 18. Parameter 19. Parameter 20. Statistic 1 © 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part. Chapter: 1 Basic Ideas 38. Simple random sample. It would not be difficult to randomly select 100 students from all of the student body at a university. Each student has a student ID number and 100 students could be randomly selected from them via a lottery type generator. 39. Obtain a list of all registered voters in the town, and randomly select out 500 of them. be an example of voluntary response sampling. If we have the school’s admission’s office draw a simple random sample of 50 males at the school, as well as a simple random sample of 50 females at the school, and we interview all subjects within these two strata, this would be stratified sampling. If we choose three different one-half hour time intervals, and interview all students at the library as to their opinion on the issue, this would be an example of cluster sampling. Finally, if we interview every 8th student that walks into the library over a certain amount of time, this would be an example of systematic sampling. 40. Randomly choose items off of the assembly line. For instance, take an item. Then maybe let 10 go by, then take another item. Let 10 more go by, then select another item. Let 10 more go by, select another item. Continue selecting items in this fashion. 44. In cluster sampling, the population is divided into clusters, then a simple random sample of these clusters is selected, and every unit within the selected clusters is sampled. This is a two-stage sampling plan. In systematic sampling, we first select a random starting point in the population, and then sample every kth item beginning at that starting point. This is also a two-stage sampling plan, where we employ a simple random sample of size 1 from the list of potential starting points, and then census the sampling units at multiples of k units from the initial unit. 41. Draw a stratified sample. That is, separate the employees by gender, then randomly choose equal number of men and women from their respective strata. 42. Using a computer, the IRS can randomly select 1000 W2 tax forms from the population of all tax forms. Extending the Concepts 43. To get a simple random sample, we could have the school’s admission’s office randomly choose 75 names from the entire student enrollment, then we would interview these subjects. To get a sample of convenience, we could go to the school’s student center and randomly ask students about their opinions. We could put an advertisement in the school’s newspaper, or hand out flyers on campus, asking students to go to a particular Facebook page and express their opinions on the issue. This would SECTION 1-2 EXERCISES Understanding the Concepts Exercises 1-4 are the Check Your Understanding exercises located within the section. Their answers are found on page 18. 2 © 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part. Chapter: 1 Basic Ideas 5. variables 28. ordinal 6. qualitative 29. nominal 7. Quantitative 30. nominal 8. nominal; ordinal 31. nominal 9. discrete 32. ordinal 10. Continuous 33. continuous 11. False. Quantitative variables do. 34. continuous 12. True 35. discrete 13. True 36. discrete 14. True 37. continuous Practicing the Skills 38. discrete 15. qualitative Working with the Concepts 16. quantitative 39. ordinal 17. quantitative 40. discrete 18. qualitative 41. ordinal 19. quantitative 42. quantitative 20. quantitative 43. nominal 21. qualitative 44. ordinal 22. qualitative 45 (A) Game Title and Publisher (B) % of Gaming Audience and Average Minutes Played per Week (C) Publisher (D) Game Title 23. qualitative 24. quantitative 25. ordinal 46 (A) Movie Title, Creative Type, and MPAA Rating (B) Year, Ticket Sales, and Tickets Sold (C) Movie Title and Creative Type 26. nominal 27. ordinal 3 © 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part. Chapter: 1 Basic Ideas (D) MPAA Rating 14. False. Observational studies are generally less reliable than randomized experiments. Extending the Concepts 47 (A) (B) (C) (D) (E) (F) (G) 15. True ordinal yes no quantitative yes; yes nominal no; no 16. True Practicing the Skills 17 (A) It is a randomized experiment. (B) Yes. In a randomized experiment, if there are large differences in outcomes among the treatment groups, we may conclude that the differences are due to the treatments. SECTION 1-3 EXERCISES 18 (A) It is an observational study. Understanding the Concepts (B) No. In an observational study, when there are differences in the outcomes among the treatment groups, it is often difficult to determine whether the differences are due to the treatments or to confounding. Exercises 1-4 are the Check Your Understanding exercises located within the section. Their answers are found on page 26. 5. randomized 6. double-blind 7. observational 8. confounder 9. prospective 19 (A) It is a randomized experiment. (B) Yes. In a randomized experiment, if there are large differences in outcomes among the treatment groups, we may conclude that the differences are due to the treatments. 10. cohort 20 (A) The four types of fertilizer. 11. True (B) It is a randomized experiment. 12. False. A confounder makes it harder to draw conclusions from a study. (C) Yes. In a randomized experiment, if there are large differences in outcomes among the treatment groups, we may conclude that the differences are due to the treatments. 13. False. In an observational study, subjects choose their own treatments. 4 © 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part. Chapter: 1 Basic Ideas (D) cross-sectional Working with the Concepts (E) it is unlikely 21. An observational study will be necessary, this is because the subjects themselves decide where they live. Extending the Concepts 29 (A) yes 22. It is possible to design a randomized experiment, since the scientists may assign the subjects at random to the two treatments. 23. It could be due to confounding. (B) It was important for the doctors in the study not to know which children were getting the vaccine because a doctor’s diagnosis may be influenced by the knowledge of which particular treatment a patient received. 24. It could be due to confounding. (C) It could be due to confounding of one’s socio-economic status. 25 (A) False 30 (A) no (B) True (B) no 26. Age is a likely confounder. Older children tend to be taller and also tend to know more words. (C) It could still be due to confounding of one’s socio-economic status. Again, the children who did not participate in the study were more likely to come from lower-income families, who tended to have lower rates of polio. 27 (A) heart rate (B) maternal smoking (C) cohort SECTION 1-4 EXERCISES (D) prospective Understanding the Concepts (E) Yes. Smoking mothers may be in worse shape than nonsmoking mothers, and the conditioning (or lack thereof) may be a confounder. Exercises 1 and 2 are the Check Your Understanding exercises located within the section. Their answers are found on page 29. 28 (A) respiratory problems 3. voluntary response surveys (B) formaldehyde level 4. nonresponders (C) cohort 5. population 5 © 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part. Chapter: 1 Basic Ideas gone completely cellular, and such a sampling method misses this entire large group of people. 6. False. The way that a question in a survey is worded has a huge effect on the responses. 7. True 20. Yes, many people pick the first of something when they are not sure. 8. False. The fact that a sample is large, does not make it any better or more reliable. Extending the Concepts 21 (A) In essence, the poll surveyed the rich, and a majority of the rich are Republicans. That is why, the digest had the Republican candidate incorrectly winning in a landslide. Practicing the Skills 9. nonresponse 10. sampling bias (B) Only about one-fifth of the surveys were returned. This creates nonresponse bias. 11. self-interest 12. nonresponse (C) A big sample size does not offset bias. 13. voluntary response 14. social acceptability Chapter Quiz 15. nonresponse 16. social acceptability Working with the Concepts 17 (A) No. (B) No. The first survey has self-interest bias, and the second one has social acceptability as well as leading question bias. 18. Yes, because many people do not pick up the phones when they do not recognize the number on their caller ID. This creates nonresponse bias. 19. Yes, because many people have 1. Answers will vary. 2. qualitative 3. True 4. 5. Continuous False. It should represent the population as much as possible. 6. stratified sample 7. acceptable 8. sample of convenience 9. True 10. observational study 6 © 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part. Chapter: 1 Basic Ideas (B) It is unlikely, because in a randomized experiment, if there are large differences in outcomes among the treatment groups, we may conclude that the differences are due to the treatments. 11. randomized experiment 12. differences in the treatments 13. Seniors are older and maybe better prepared and more experienced. 11 (A) observational study 14. True (B) Yes, because in an observational study, when there are differences in the outcomes among the treatment groups, it is often difficult to determine whether the differences are due to the treatments or to confounding. 15. Not reliable at all. Review Exercises 1. quantitative 2. nominal 12 (A) randomized experiment 3. continuous (B) It is unlikely, because in a randomized experiment, if there are large differences in outcomes among the treatment groups, we may conclude that the differences are due to the treatments. 4 (A) True (B) True (C) False. It is discrete. 5. stratified sample 13. It is a voluntary response sample. 6. voluntary response sample 14. It has nonresponse bias. 7. cluster sample 15. It has nonresponse bias. 8. simple random sample 9. (A) observational study (B) Yes, people in countries with the fluoridation of water are probably wealthier than people in countries without it, and therefore probably have better overall dental care. Write About It 1. A stratified sample is one in which the population is divided into groups and a random sample is drawn from each group. In a cluster sample, a simple random sample of clusters is selected, and every individual in each selected cluster is part of the sample. 10 (A) randomized experiment 7 © 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part. Chapter: 1 Basic Ideas 2. The most basic, and in many cases the best, sampling method is the method of simple random sampling. In simple random sampling, the sample represents the population very closely. This is very desirable. However, in a sample of convenience, the sample may differ systematically in some way from the population. selected for the sample. Any method of selecting the subjects (like randomly generating a list of names from a computer random number generator) that is analogous to lottery selection, works fine. 4. An example of an ordinal random variable is X = the letter grade on exam #1 for each student in the statistics class 3. A circumstance under which a sample of convenience might be used is when an engineer wishes to study the crushing strength of a hugh shipment of concrete blocks that are very heavy. In such an instance, sampling blocks in the center or on the bottom might not be possible. An example of a nominal random variable is X = the political part affiliations of all the students in the class An example of a discrete random variable is X = the number of people who went to the mall today A cluster sample would be used to estimate the unemployment rate in a county. In this instance, a simple random sample of households in the county would be selected, and every member of each household would be interviewed. An example of a continuous random variable is X = the weights (in pounds) of all the students in the class 5. Qualitative variables are not numeric. They are variables that classify subjects into categories. A stratified sample would be used if we wanted to poll the opinions on a certain issue by gender. The population would be divided into the two genders, and a random sample would be selected out of each sex. 6. The major difference between a randomized experiment and an observational study has to do with the nature of assigning the subjects to respective treatment groups. If the assignment is made by the investigator it is randomized. If however, the assignment is not made by the investigator, it is observational. As such, if there are large differences in outcomes among the treatment groups in a randomized study, we may conclude that the differences are attributed to the treatments. This is not necessarily true for an observational study because of the effects of confounding. A systematic sample is employed when police pull over every 10th car or so at a sobriety check point. Whenever possible, we prefer to use a simple random sample selected from a population of interest. The governing principle here is that each subject has the same likelihood of being 8 © 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part. Chapter: 1 Basic Ideas 7. In a double-blind study, neither the investigators nor the subjects know who has been assigned to which treatment. The major advantage to this is that no biases of the doctors or subjects can interfere with the results. There really is no disadvantage, other than it is not always possible to do such a study. However, whenever possible, double-blind studies should be performed. 8. If a major pharmaceutical company pays a statistician a lot of money to perform statistical analyses as to the utility of a certain drug, the statistician has a paid vested interest in the outcome, as does the company. It might be tempting to “fudge” the results to obtain a positive outcome. 9 (A) This question has very leading question bias. It is hinting that people are doing something wrong and really should change. A better question would be, “If you had more money, do you think you would spend it or save it?” 2. 41 4. 43 5. 2 6. 4.7% 7. Yes, there is a significant difference between the two. 8. Because every person who returned the questionnaire via school return did so on a day that corresponded to a high exposure PM level. 9. Because every person who returned the questionnaire via mail return did so on a day that corresponded to a low exposure PM level. 11. The people who had symptoms all returned their questionnaires via school return, with the exception of two who mailed it in. Everyone else who mailed in their responses did not have any symptoms. This is indeed evidence that people who have symptoms are eager to participate, while those who are unaffected are less interested. Therefore, the mode of response is related to the outcomes. Case Study: Air Pollution and Respiratory Symptoms 450 9.1% 10. The people who did not return their questionnaires via school return, had to be mailed another questionnaire. This time delay caused the researchers to get these questionnaires later, well into April when it was warmer. Since less wood burning stoves are being used than they were in March, this definitely affects the PM level and wheezing percentages. (B) This question has social acceptability bias. A much better question would be, “What is your opinion on funding for charitable organizations?” Chose from the following: they have enough, they need more, or they have too much 1. 3. 9 © 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part. Chapter: 1 Basic Ideas 12. By telephoning the subjects over a few days or weeks, the confounding would have been drastically reduced because then they would not have had the striking change in weather affecting the outcomes. Notice how the actual study went from March 5 until April 22. 10 © 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.