for the Thinking Classroom • • Credit Weebly http://conceptbasedinstruction.weebly.com/ © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson We will increase thinking classrooms by writing units that: - Clearly identify big ideas, understandings, knowledge & skills before beginning a unit (Stage 1) - Articulate how to know students have learned (Stage 2) - Include instruction where teachers: (Stage 3) -Target expected outcomes -Engage students in tasks that are meaningful, worthwhile, & challenging -Let students struggle appropriately -Require students transfer their learning to new & novel situations 3 Participate in all sessions 2) Collaboratively write an ELA unit 3) Self-assess your unit quality 4) Implement the unit 1) 4 To enable you to do your job by: Facilitating PD sessions Providing feedback on unit development Coaching implementation of unit Distance &/or in-classroom support 5 Desired Outcomes – For Today Learner Outcomes: Participants will understand that concept-based curriculum is a three-dimensional curriculum design model that frames the factual content of subject areas with disciplinary concepts and generalizations when writing units. Participants will be able to (on their own): Write generalizations/big ideas that are transferable and are conceptual understandings drawn from, and supported by, the critical content of a discipline. Why conceptual teaching? Structure of Knowledge/Process Choosing Conceptual Lens Transfer Goals Create Unit Webs Write Generalizations/Understandings ◦ By next time……You will need to have completed: Transfer Goals Unit Web Generalizations 7 Introduce yourselves at tables and discuss any questions you have so far. Throughout the day, please write any questions on index cards relating to concept-based lesson planning teaching and give them to the facilitator. 8 Identify with whom you will write your ELA unit. Groups should be about 3-4 teachers You will want to work with teachers at your own grade level. Implemented in Spring 2015 9 Exchange email addresses Identify a recorder/contact for your group Consider using Google Docs as your collaboration tool K-2: Send unit or link to Tabitha DeMey 3-6: Send unit or link to Heidi McGuire 10 Have you ever seen young children who hold misconceptions of important events in history? Let’s look at some actual answers to questions on a 5th grade history test! One of the causes of the Revolutionary War was the English put tacks in their tea. Also, the colonists would send their parcels through the post without stamps. Finally, the colonists won the war and no longer had to pay for taxis. Delegates from the original 13 states formed the Contented Congress. Abraham Lincoln became America’s greatest Precedent. Lincoln’s mother died in infancy, and he was born in a log cabin which he built with his own hands. Abraham Lincoln freed the slaves by signing the Enunciation Proclamation. On the night of April 14, 1865, Lincoln went to the theater and got shot in his seat by one of the actors in a moving picture show. The believed assinator was John Wilkes Booth, a supposingly insane actor. This ruined Booth’s career. The sun never set on the British Empire because the British Empire is in the East and the sun sets in the West. Queen Victoria was the longest queen. She sat on a thorn for 63 years. She was a moral woman who practiced virtue. Her death was the final event which ended her reign. Let’s think about… What do thinking classrooms look like? How can we move from a twodimensional… © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson to a more effective threedimensional model for curriculum and instruction to foster thinkin How is knowledge structured? How is process structured? How can we use these structures to focus teaching and learning, improve and significantly the academic performance of all © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson What is concept-based curriculum? How is it different from the traditional topic/skill- based curriculum? How do we scaffold thinking from lower to higher levels? © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson What does concept-based instruction look like? © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson What is the difference between an activity, and a performance of deep understanding? What are the critical components for a quality curriculum? © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Intentional Teaching © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Social Change Forces Impacting Education • • • • Expanding role of technology Changing job demands Increasing global interdependence of people Changing social norms and value structures • Worldwide competition and markets • Rapid growth of knowledge • Environmental concerns © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Our Changing World © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Lynn Erickson Jay McTighe Clarify results & evidence before lesson design Thinking like an assessor is key to effective design The work is only “coverage” or “nice activity” unless focused on questions and big ideas, related to the standards Instruction has become an activity in repeating the teacher 2 4 I want students to understand… I want students to understand THAT… The US Constitution The US Constitution was a solution based on compromise to real and pressing problems and (this is content!) disagreements in government The three branches of US They were a brilliant government balance and limit of 2 powers. 5 Information without Intellect is Meaningless Critical, Creative, Reflective Curious, Playful © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Metacognitiv e Traditional Curriculum... is Topic Based HISTORY: Early European Migration World War I and II Indigenous Peoples of Australia Irish Potato Famine Adolph Hitler The Holocaust The Industrial Revolution… © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Science: The Earth’s crust The solar system, The human body The Periodic Table… Traditional Curriculum... is Topic Based Language Arts: The Cat in the Hat Shakespeare British literature The eight parts of speech … © 2014 H. Lynn Erickson and Lois Lanning What Does Iowa Core Say? Iowa Core ELA book p. 7 Students who are Collage and Career Ready in Reading, Writing, Speaking, Listening, and Language © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson versus © 2012 H. Lynn Erickson Two-dimensional versus Three-dimensional Coverage-centered “inch deep, mile wide” to ideas. Idea-centered -facts and skills provide a foundation understand conceptual, transferable Intellectually shallow - lacks a conceptual focus focus, requires to ignite synergistic thinking lower and thinking—producing and © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Intellectual depth -a “conceptual lens,” or mental processing between the conceptual levels of intellectual depth understanding. 31 Two-dimensional versus Threedimensional Inability to transfer factual knowledge - facts do not transfer; locked in time, place, or situation. Concepts and Generalizations Transfer -allows the brain to make connections and see patterns. Fails to meet the intellectual Develops the intellect to handle a world demands of the 21st century of increasing complexity and accelerating change. © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Are You a Teacher? Are you a teacher? 33 Think of Factual Knowledge which is locked in time, place or situation Understanding Conceptual ransfers through time, across cultures, and across situations © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson which The Structure of Knowledge Topics: • Specific • Locked in time, place or situation. • Do not transfer. Facts: • • • Provide support for Principles and Generalizations. Locked in time, place or situation. Do not transfer. The Structure of Knowledge Concepts: • Mental constructs drawn from the topic • Transfer across time, culture and situations • 1 or 2 words or a small phrase • Timeless, • Universal, • Abstract to different degrees The Structure of Knowledge Principle: • A generalization that rises to the level of a Law or Axiom. • Does not use qualifiers. Generalization: • Two or more concepts stated in a sentence of relationship • Transfers through time across cultures and across situations. • Supported by the facts. The Structure of Knowledge Theory: • A supposition or set of conceptual ideas used to explain a phenomenon or practice. The Structure of Knowledge Knowledge • People migrate to meet a variety of needs. • Migration may lead to new opportunities or greater freedom. • Migration • Opportunity • Needs • Hardship Westward Movement Early © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson American settlers migrated west. Early American settlers looked for new opportunities. The Structure of Knowledge Grade 2 - Example Using the appropriate tools aids measurement accuracy. Standard length units express how much longer one object is than another. •length unit object • equivalence • tools • • accuracy Measurement *Since mathematics is a conceptual language, the “Topics” are actually broader concepts which break down into microconcepts at the next level. 3 2 1 © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson The Structure of Process The student understands that…Readers make inferences about characters using background knowledge and text evidence. •Inference •Background Knowledge •Character •Text Evidence Reading Process © Lois Lanning, 2012 The student understands that…_____________ _________________ _________________ _______. Concept or Topic? Transportation A concept is an organizing Intelligence idea; a mental construct... | Timeless |Universal | Abstract (to different degrees) | Represented by 1 or 2 words | Examples share common attributes © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Examples of Subject Area Concepts Concepts in Science Social Studies Text Order Organism Population System Change Evolution Cycle Interaction Energy/Matte r Equilibrium Habitat Conflict/Cooperation Patterns Scarcity System Change/Continuity Culture Supply/Demand Civilization Migration/Immigratio n Interdependence Prejudice Perspective Conflict Cooperatio n Power Relationshi ps Envy Emotions Oppression Influence Writer’s Craft Reader’s Craft Organizati on Word Choice TextConvention s Fluency Voice Presentatio n Symbolism Allegory Metaphor Protagonist Antagonist Inference Context Clues Meaning Paraphrase Summary Text Structure Directionalit y Self – regulation Imagery Genre Background Knowledge Which are “macro-concepts?” Which are “microconcepts?” © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson and Lois Lanning Concepts • • • • • • • • • • • Interdependence/Dependence/Independence Classification Solution Perception Decisions Systems Change Continuity Order Conflict Cooperation © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Social Studies Concepts Geography Concepts Macro-concepts: • Place • Space • Region • Location • Interaction * Interdependence © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Micro-concepts: • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Physical environment Landforms Geographical Patterns Natural Processes Migration Population density Growth rates Cultural landscapes Urbanization Settlement patterns Geographical locations Rural/urban Natural resources Technology Natural disasters Spatial organization Power Identity Survival Fear Inner/Outer conflict Courage Love Relationships Loss Friendships Caring/Sharing Jealousy Tolerance Idealism Isolationism Greed Sacrifice Compromise Control Justice Humanity/Inhumanity Elements of Genre 53 Comprehension/Understanding (of text) • • • • • • • • • • • • Strategies/Skills • Directionality Phonological Awareness Phonics Self-Regulation • Problem Solving • Metacognition • Self-Correction • Reading Rate Text language/Vocabulary Inference Summary Connections Imagery Text structures/features Background Knowledge • Purpose • • • • • Response (to text) • • • • • • • Aesthetic pleasure Information Entertainment Explanation Research • • Connections Discourse protocols Collaboration Perspective Personal reflection Text evidence Cultural understanding Motication/appeal Critiquing Text • • • • • • Literary criticism Evaluation Judgment Believability Appreciation/recognitio n of author’s craft Relevance • • • • Production (of text) Voice • • Tone • Mood • Dialect Organization • Transitions • Text structure • Leads • • details Fluency • Rhythm • Cadence • Flow Writing/speaking conventions • Grammar • Language (formal/informal) • Mechanics • Literary Devices • Format • Alliteration • Word choice/usage • Hyperbole • Audience awareness • Imagery • Persuasive techniques • Metaphor • Allusion Writing Process • Figurative • Brainstorm language • Draft • Simile • Response • Onomatopoei • Revision a • Publication • Symbolism’ Conceptual lens: ??? The Power of a Conceptual Lens Significant Individuals in Histor The conceptual lens “integrates thinking” © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson The Power of a Conceptual Lens Leadershi p Significant Individuals in History © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Power/Change The Power of a Conceptual Lens Significant Individuals in History © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Looking at a topic through a “conceptual lens” engages the personal intellect and emotions of the student… creates a deeper level of understanding, helps retain the factual information because it must be processed at a deeper level in the brain, and facilitates a greater love of learning. © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson National Media © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Lens: Persuasive Force National Media © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Conceptual lens ______________________ Topic: Stories from Around the World: Folktales © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Sample Conceptual Lenses Conflict Complexity Beliefs/Values Paradox Interdependenc e Interactions Freedom Transformation s Force © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Identity Patterns Relationships Origins Change Revolution Perspective Reform Heroes Power Influence System Balance Structure/functio n Innovation Design Genius Aesthetics Creativity To develop the intellect and increase motivation for learning, curriculum and instruction must create a “synergy” between the lower (factual) and higher (conceptual) levels of thinking. Cartoons by David Ford davidford@cablespeed.com © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson The Conceptual Mind © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson © 2005 H. Lynn Erickson Cartoon by David Ford © 2005 H. Lynn Erickson Cartoon by David Ford It is the Conceptual Mind that …. creates connections to prior experience and finds relevance synergistically works with the factual level of knowledge, and lower level process skills sees patterns across examples which reveal deeper, to develop the intellect transferable understandings recognizes the transferability of knowledge > creates the motivation for learning © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson and Lois Lanning Integration refers to the cognitive process of seeing patterns and connections at the conceptual level of thinking. © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Coordinated, Multidisciplinary Unit A little art Use of Language Processes A little math The Human Body A little science A little literature The “Potpourri Unit” of Facts and Activities © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson INTEGRATED, INTERDISCIPLINARY CURRICULUM… looks at a topically-based theme, problem, or issue through… an integrating, “conceptual lens” such as Interdependence or System. © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Integrated, Interdisciplinary Unit Health Conceptual Lens: System Wellness Nutrition Eating Disorders Weight Management Substance Abuse Diseases Science Circulatory System Respiratory System Digestive System, etc. Function & structure Interdependence Math Literacy The Human Body Calculations: heart rate, body mass, Statistics Measurements: height, weight Ratios Charts; graphs © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson and Lois Lanning Art Research Process Reading Comprehension Presentation Writing Conventions Physical Body Control Education Movement Draw a body: symmetry, line, shape Human forms art realism, abstract, Coordination Muscle System Fitness Endurance The goal of integration... is to facilitate integrated, higher level thinking. The conceptual lens pulls thinking to the integration level. © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson 1. Identify Desired Results What is it that I want the students to understand and know and be able to do? How will I know that they know 2. Determine Acceptable Evidence what I want them to know? 3. Plan Learning Experiences What do I need to do in the classroom to prepare them for the assessment? 7 6 Stage 1- Desired Results Transfer Goals: Generalizations/Understandings: Essential Questions: Students will understand that… Students will know… Students will be able to… Stage 2- Assessment Evidence Performance Tasks: Other Evidence: Stage 3- Learning Plan Learning Activities: 7 7 Writing Transfer Goals A transfer goal- • states what students should be able to do with knowledge and skill, on their own, in general terms, in the long run. • Answers the “Why?” and “What can you do with this?” questions. The transfer goal is at the heart of the unit. © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson The Generalizations derived from the web will indicate the content that will be addressed in the unit instruction. Not everything on the web will be included in the instruction. Grade 2 Conceptual Lens: Culture Interdependence • community • neighborhoods • Cooperation in a community to solve problems Economics History •collaboration to build a community Geography • Interdependence of land and people in our community • communities use resources to meet needs and wants • goods & services Our • Cost/benefit Community • Wants/needs • Inventions -new products • Advertising • Workers - wages (incentives, e.g., pay) Government/Civics Transfer Goals: • Local government Jobs Students will be able to - leaders: mayor, city council independently use their learning to: - roles • Apply concepts and systems of • Laws, rules in our community economics to participate • Citizenship - rights and responsibilities productively in a global • Citizens working together economy. • Apply knowledge of political and social systems to participate actively as an informed citizen Conceptual Lens Concepts in: Understanding Text Concepts in: Critiquing Text Unit Title Concepts in: Responding to Text Concepts in: Producing Text Transfer Goals: Source: © 2009 Dr. Lois Lanning Avon, Connecticut © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Conceptual Lens: Characterization Understanding Text: (R, L) Responding To Text: (S, W) • • • • Meaningful connections to characters Text Evidence Partner read/share Similarities and differences of characters across texts Key ideas and details Comprehensive descriptions Major events & challenges Story elements of narrative text • Characters’ points of view • Character traits, dialogue, actions Critiquing Text: (L, S, W, Character’s voice Unit Title R) Vocabulary Qualities of friendship • Opinions of author’s Character Summary depiction of characters Study: How Grade level phonics & word supported by text evidence analysis • Believability of character do we get to • Inference • Realistic problem/solution • Questions to support • Quality of text illustrations know comprehension • Conclusions Producing Text : (W) characters? • Fluency • Oral/written responses (to literal, Transfer Goals: interpretive and open ended questions) Students will be able to independently use their • Shared writing learning to: • Narrative Writing • Analyze how and why individuals, events, and • Writing Conventions ideas develop and interact over the course of a • Writing process text. • *Temporal words • Assess how point of view or purpose shapes • *Transition words the content and style of a text. • *Eye contact, speaking voice • Write narratives to develop real or imagined • *Opinion pieces (writing journals) experiences or events using effective technique, well-chosen details, well- Core Source: Designing Concept-based Curriculum for English Language Arts, Meeting theand Common 85 structured even sequences. with Intellectual Integrity, K-12, By Lois Lanning.Corwing Press Copyright 2013 • • • • • • • • • GENERALIZATIONS are SUMMARIES OF THOUGHT “WHAT DO I UNDERSTAND as a result of my study that I can TRANSFER?” © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson GENERALIZATION= Essential or Enduring Understanding, Statement of Two or more concepts Inquiry or Central Idea in a relationship... CONCEPTUAL IDEAS THAT TRANSFER DEVELOP “DEEP UNDERSTANDING” ©1997 H. Lynn Erickson Writing Generalizations >No proper or personal nouns >No pronouns in sentence (“our, we, they…”) >Has a present tense verb >Contains at least two concepts >Is a transferable idea that is supported by the factual content >May need a qualifier (“often, can, may”) if not true in all situations— but is still an important idea © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Level 1 Verbs (“No No” Verbs) affects | impacts | influence | is, are, have © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson The Structure of Knowledge The student understands that…_People buy goods and 3. services to meet their wants and needs. Goods & Services Wants & Needs People Our Community © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Producers & Consumers 2. 1. People should care for the environment. Error: Value Statement……..ask Why? Improved: People care for the environment to preserve natural resources. 92 Writers’ rely on the plot to carry the story. Error: Not True – Writers rely more on character development than plot. Improved: Writers’ rely on the characters to carry the plot of a story. 93 Writers tell enough about a topic so others can understand what they are writing about and can answer questions they may have and know why they are writing. Errors: Awkward sentence, unclear, uses pronoun Improved • Effective writers provide relevant information to convey a clear message. • Writers incorporate text structure and content area vocabulary for the purpose of imparting 94 Readers rely on text connections in order to comprehend. Errors: Value Statement – needs qualifier Improved: • Readers integrate and cross check multiple strategies and skills to deepen comprehension of text. • Readers may rely on text connections to © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Informed citizens must read widely. Error: Value Statement Only 1 concept Improved: • Reading about issues from a variety of perspectives develops a more informed citizenry. • Gathering issues from multiple sources © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Established Goals (Standards): National Driver Development Standards G1 Demonstrate a working knowledge or rules, regulations and procedures of operating an automobile G2 Use visual search skills to obtain correct information and make reduced-risk decisions for effective speed and position adjustments Stage 1 –Desired Results Transfer Goals Students will be able to independently use their learning to: Drive courteously and defensively without accidents or needless risk. Anticipate and adapt their knowledge of safe and defensive driving to various traffic, road and weather conditions. Meaning-Making Generalizations/Understandings: Generalizations/Understan Essential Questions Students Students will keep considering… dings: will understand that… Students will understand that… G3 Interact with other users within the Highway Transportation System by Acquisition of Knowledge and Skill adjusting speed, space, and communications to Students will know… Students will be skilled at… avoid conflicts and reduce risk G4 Demonstrate balanced vehicle movement through steering, braking, and accelerating in a precise 97 Checking Our Generalizations >No proper or personal nouns >No pronouns in sentence (“our, we, they…”) >Has a present tense verb >Contains at least two concepts >Is a transferable idea that is supported by the factual content >May need a qualifier (“often, can, may”) if not true in all situations— but is still an important idea © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson Established Goals (Standards): National Driver Development Standards Stage 1 –Desired Results Transfer Goals Students will be able to independently use their learning to: Drive courteously and defensively without accidents or needless risk. Anticipate and adapt their knowledge of safe and defensive driving to various traffic, road and weather conditions. G1 Demonstrate a Meaning-Making working knowledge or Generalizations/Understandings: Essential Questions rules, regulations and Students will understand that… Students will keep considering… procedures of operating A motor vehicle can become a an automobile lethal weapon, and driving one demands constant attention. G2 Use visual search Defensive driving assumes that skills to obtain correct other drivers are not attentive and information and make that they might make sudden or illreduced-risk decisions for advised moves. effective speed and Effective drivers constantly adapt to position adjustments the various traffic, road, and weather conditions. G3 Interact with other users within the Highway Transportation System by Acquisition of Knowledge and Skill adjusting speed, space, and communications to Students will know… Students will be skilled at… avoid conflicts and reduce risk G4 Demonstrate balanced vehicle movement through steering, braking, and accelerating in a precise 99 Grade 2 Conceptual Lens: Interdependence Culture •collaboration to build a community over time • community • neighborhoods • Cooperation in a community to solve problems Economics History Geography • Interdependence of land and people in our community • communities use resources to meet needs and wants Our • goods & services Community • Cost/benefit • Wants & needs • Inventions -new products • Advertising • Workers - wages (incentives, e.g., pay) Government/Civics Transfer Goals: • Local government Jobs Students will be able to - leaders: mayor, city council independently use their learning to: - roles • Apply concepts and systems of • Laws, rules in our community economics to participate • Citizenship - rights and responsibilities productively in a global • Citizens working together economy. • Apply knowledge of political and social systems to participate actively as an informed citizen Interdependence in Our Community Culture 1. A community can consist of a neighborhood or many neighborhoods that share public services such as schools, law enforcement and hospitals. 2. People in a community cooperate to solve problems that affect their daily lives. Grade 2 Conceptual Lens: Characterization Understanding Text: (R, L) Responding To Text: (S, W) • • • • Meaningful connections to characters Text Evidence Partner read/share Similarities and differences of characters across texts Key ideas and details Comprehensive descriptions Major events & challenges Story elements of narrative text • Characters’ points of view • Character traits, dialogue, actions Critiquing Text: (L, S, W, Character’s voice Unit Title R) Vocabulary Qualities of friendship • Opinions of author’s Character Summary depiction of characters Study: How Grade level phonics & word supported by text evidence analysis • Believability of character do we get to • Inference • Realistic problem/solution • Questions to support • Quality of text illustrations know comprehension • Conclusions Producing Text : (W) characters? • Fluency • Oral/written responses (to literal, Transfer Goals: interpretive and open ended questions) Students will be able to independently use their • Shared writing learning to: • Narrative Writing • Analyze how and why individuals, events, and • Writing Conventions ideas develop and interact over the course of a • Writing process text. • *Temporal words • Assess how point of view or purpose shapes • *Transition words the content and style of a text. • *Eye contact, speaking voice • Write narratives to develop real or imagined • *Opinion pieces (writing journals) experiences or events using effective technique, well-chosen details, well- Core Source: Designing Concept-based Curriculum for English Language Arts, Meeting theand Common 102 structured even sequences. with Intellectual Integrity, K-12, By Lois Lanning.Corwing Press Copyright 2013 • • • • • • • • • Character Study: How do we get to know characters? Grade 2 1. Character dialogue and actions reveal character traits. 2. Background experiences help readers identify and relate to story characters. 3. Authors develop a story and its characters based on genre and purpose. 4. Character relationships shape and drive events in a story 5. Readers make inferences about characters using evidence from the text. When we teach to the levels of concepts and generalizations we are teaching for deep understanding and the transfer of knowledge. © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson • Brainstorm your unit web – keeping your conceptual lens in mind when identifying the concepts for each strand. • Write generalizations for your conceptual lens, and for each strand around your unit title-1 or 2 per strand. Send completed web & generalizations to: K-2: Tabitha: tdemey@aea8.k12.ia.us or © 2010 H. Lynn Erickson