Retrieved from: http://www.mysterescanadiens.ca/blooden.html Historical Fiction ‘Making and Remaking the Past’ Dr. Wendy Donawa Reading Canada Dr. Leah C. Fowler SECTION IV Where Does ‘History’ End? This section explores fiction set amid the two world wars and the intervening Depression, and the meanings they suggest to the growing sense of national consciousness. It examines literature depicting the experience of ethnic groups originally marginalized, then increasingly understood to be valuable components of Canada’s cultural mosaic. Retrieved from: http://britishmilitariaforums.yuku.com/topic/10030 IV.A. Entering the century, entering the country Retrieved from: http://www.broadbandtvnews.com/2011/05/24/digital-tv-boom-timeahead-for-eastern-europe/ IV.A.1. Eastern Europe: Oppression and migration European immigration to Canada in the early years of the century was fueled not only by industrial economics but also by violent change in Eastern Europe, particularly in Russia. Your Mouth is Lovely (Nancy Richler, 2002) At 23, Miriam, the Jewish protagonist, is serving a life sentence in Siberia, writing her memoir from the infant daughter who will never know her, whom she has headed over to her sister to take to Canada and raise her as her own. This text highlights the lives of people driven to desperation and conveys a woman caught up in circumstances beyond her control. Retrieved from: http://openlibrary.org/works/OL5957137W/Your_Mouth_Is_Lovely Russländer (Sandra Birdsell, 2001) This text begins in 1910, in a wealthy Mennonite farming community in Russia, whose devout inhabitants seem scarcely aware of the poverty, oppression, and resentment of their Russian workers. The narrator, Katya, now an old woman in Winnipeg, but eight years old as the story begins, recalls an idyllic childhood world that will later implode with the 1917 massacre of her family. Retrieved from: http://www.sandrabirdsell.com/bookshelf/the-russlander/ Retrieved from: http://www.canadashistory.ca/Magazine/OnlineExclusive/Articles/History-Spotlight--British-Home-Children.aspx IV.A.2. Home children Not all the vulnerable children who arrived in Canada were fleeing revolution and violence. Between 1869 and the Great Depression, in a largely forgotten social experiment, British ‘Home Children’ – orphaned and abandoned children – were removed from streets, workhouses, and impoverished parents, and dispatched to servitude in different parts of the Commonwealth. Orphan at My Door (Jean Little, 2001) Set in 1897 in Guelph, Ontario, the young diarist, Victoria, records her family’s acquisition of a sad, silent ‘home girl’. She eventually befriends the little servant, and vows to help her rescue the younger brother from the abusive placement in which he has been placed. Retrieved from: http://openlibrary.org/works/OL470697W/Orphan_at_my_door Retrieved from: http://www.canadianbadlands.org/cbl/tours / IV.A.3. Internal migration: Boomtowns and Cities Canada’s expanding and changing population was not only the result of migration from abroad; there was also constant internal migration as workers moved to farms, cities, and single-industry boomtowns. Keely: The Girl from Turtle Mountain (Deborah Ellis, 2004) Keely arrives in this frontier town in 1901 with her widowed father, one of hundreds of workers pouring in for employment in the coal mine. Keeley befriends a variety of colourful characters including E. Cora Hind, the first woman to succeed as a journalist in Western Canada. Retrieved from: http://www.openbooktoronto.com/books/our_canadian_girl_keeley_01_girl_turtle_mount ain_deborah_ellis Terror at Turtle Mountain (Penny Draper, 2006) This riveting, action-filled survival story for the younger reader recreates the terror-filed night in 1903 when 100 million tons of limestone crashed down Turtle Mountain, burying the town of Frank. The 13-year-old protagonist is instrumental in the town’s rescue efforts, and the book includes useful resources, websites, and archival photographs. Retrieved from: http://openlibrary.org/books/OL8549719M/Terror_at_Turtle_Mountain Deafening (Frances Itani, 2003) Five-year-old Grania, the youngest daughter of small-town Ontario hoteliers, has lost her hearing to scarlet fever. Her parents are too burdened by guilt and too mired in false hopes to work with her obvious intelligence. But she is blessed with a fiercely determined grandmother whose innovative instruction is described in a way that opens the world of the Deaf to the reader. http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/312881.Deafening The Bone-Collector’s Son (Paul Yee, 2003) In Vancouver’s Chinatown, 14- year-old Bing Wing resentfully assists his father in the lowly job of collecting bones from old Chinese graves to be sent back to China. A double ghost story, with one ghost haunting the bone collector and another haunting the house where Bing works. Retrieved from: http://www.ryerson.ca/library/events/asian_heritage/yee.html Retrieved from: http://schools.4j.lane.edu/churchill/library/classes/WWIQuest/WWIWebquest.html IV.B. World War I: War literature and the YA reader Renee Englot poses some thoughtful questions to interrogate war narratives: Is the reader positioned to see war as complex? Does it open up different understandings and the growth of awareness? How is the enemy represented by the author, and treated by the fictional characters? Is there an implied acknowledgement of common humanity? Are the consequences of war examined, and do they contribute to civic literacy? “Gonna study war much more: War in historical fiction for children.” Canadian Children’s Literature 33 (1): 17 pp.180-197 More contemporary novelists have widened their scope to consider the destructive force of the war on the individual psyche, the dissolving distinctions of gender and class, the definition of ‘manly’ behaviour, and its implications. And in the Morning (John Wilson, 2003) Told in diary entries, newspaper clippings, and letters, this text conveys war’s psychological impact on soldiers. At 15, Jim cannot wait to fight in the war. But when his father is killed in action, and his mother succumbs to depression, under-aged Jim enlists. Retrieved from: http://www.bookcentre.ca/library/catalogue/and_morning Megiddo’s Shadow (Arthur Slade, 2006) Based on Slade’s grandfather’s experiences, sixteen-year-old Edward lies about his age, enlisting to avenge his brother’s death, and leaving his depressed widower father in Saskatchewan. After training, impatient for action, he is sent to the Palestine front against the Turkish, where heat, dust, malaria, and brutality alter the wide-eyed innocent. Retrieved from: http://www.arts.on.ca/Page1806.aspx The Wars ( Timothy Findley, 1977) This text reconstructs the puzzling career of sensitive 19year-old Robert Ross, a Canadian who enlists in the Great War and is sent overseas to the trenches. Here, he is traumatized by the bloody carnage of violent and meaningless death, and of cruelty to animals as well as to humans. Retrieved from: http://englishimmersionfrancaise.wordpress.com/2011/07/12/mayreading/ Retrieved from: http://www.lismore.nsw.gov.au/cp_themes/default/page.asp?p=DOC-DFT-07-22-23 IV.C. Between the wars The aftermath of WWI was so profound that many see the second World War as the child of the first. The 30 million casualties, the social disruption and psychological trauma, the dispossession and relocation of ethnic populations, the reinvention of national boundaries, and the disappearance of an ordered way of life left a social and political void. The values once unexamined and accepted uncritically – ideas about class and gender, about the rights of ordinary people, about assumptions of British ‘superiority’, and of patriotism itself, were no longer taken as self-evident. Retrieved from: http://libcom.org/history/1930-present-labour-unrest-successivegeographical-restructuring-world-automobile-indust IV.C.1. Labour unrest Red Goodwin (John Wilson, 2006) Will, a 16-year-old English boy whose father was killed in the war, is sent out to live with his uncle, a mine manager in Cumberland on Vancouver Island. In the town’s highly stratified society, young Will soon finds himself torn between obedience to his uncle, loyalty to his father’s memory, and attraction to Goodwin’s vision of a more just society. Retrieved from: http://ronsdalepress.com/books/red-goodwin / Retrieved from: http://www.couriermail.com.au/news/features/new-chums-skilled-us-upfor-new-era/story-e6freoro-1225804539876 IV.C.2. Post-war immigration The displacement and dislocation of European populations meant a continued flow of immigrants into what would eventually be known as the Canadian mosaic. It is not surprising that Canadian literature set in this era includes themes of exile, dislocation, and alienation, or that it demonstrates patterns of loss and change across multi-generational narratives. Disappearing Moon Café (Sky Lee, 1990) This text follows four generations of Wongs across a century in which the Chinese were restricted mainly to menial and service occupations. Retrieved from: http://www.asiancanadianwiki.org/wiki/Sky_Lee The Concubine’s Children (Denise Chong, 1995) Her maternal grandmother, sold as a concubine to Chan Sam, is sent out to Gold Mountain to bear him sons, while her earnings are sent back to China to support the ‘at-home’ wife. Retrieved from: http://www.wlu.ca/page.php?grp_id=2529&p=11318 Retrieved from: http://www.frumforum.com/stiglitz-rewrites-the-great-depression IV.C.3. The Great Depression Regardless of race or ethnic history, North Americans felt the impact of the 1929 American Stock Market Crash. A decade of unprecedented drought, hailstorms, locusts, and poor farming practices depleted the soil, ruined most farmers, and exacerbated Canada’s plunge into the Depression. Who Has Seen the Wind? (W.O. Mitchell, 1947) The young boy’s journey from innocence to experience and his realization of death and loss take place during the Depression in small-town Saskatchewan. As the relatively secure son of the town’s pharmacist, Brian is free of the worst deprivations of that decade, but he observes the effects of poverty in his friend Ben, the town’s ‘wild child’, and in the suicide of the town’s lonely Chinese restauranteur when malnourished children are taken from him. Retrieved from: http://hungrylikethewoolf.wordpress.com/2010/09/28/who-has-seen-the-wind-byw-o-mitchell/ The Landing (John Ibbitson, 2008) This text takes the reader to Depression-era Muskoka, where fifteen-year-old Ben and his widowed mother live with Ben’s bitter, critical uncle. Musically talented, Ben knows his life will be limited without the professional teaching that is utterly beyond his reach – or so he believes. Retrieved from: http://www.renaudbray.com/books_product.aspx?id=984391&def=Landing(The)%2CIBBITSON%2C+JOHN% 2C9781554532346&page=184 Hobo Jungle (Dorothy Joan Harris, 2003) Ellen’s dad has lost his job, and the family crowds into her grandfather’s Vancouver home, where they stretch every penny to make do, and Ellen chafes at the endless mending and crowding and poverty. OUR CANADIAN GIRL SERIES Retrieved from: http://www.amazon.ca/Ellen-Hobo-Jungle-CanadianGirl/dp/0141002700/ref=sr_1_fkmr0_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1329861136&sr=8-1-fkmr0 Not a Nickel to Spare: The Great Depression Diary of Sally Cohen (Perry Nodelman, 2007) Coping with the Depression is challenging enough, but when Sally ventures outside of Toronto’s Jewish district, she must cope with anti-Semitism as well. DEAR CANADA SERIES Retrieved from: http://www.amazon.ca/Not-Nickel-Spare-GreatDepression/dp/0439961300 Retrieved from: http://www.rememberingthechildren.ca/history/history-acc.htm IV.C.4. Residential Schools Between the wars, the prospects for Aboriginal youth were bleak. The Indian Residential System (IRS) had firmly established an educational policy whose aim was the forced assimilation of Aboriginal students into the lower fringes of mainstream white society Legislation acts were intended by their makers to be benevolent and protective: they laid out stages by which Indians could, in effect, become ‘honorary whites’ in the process losing their Indian rights and identity. Legislators had not anticipated the emotional and cultural devastation experienced by children so forcibly removed from their known world of family, community, and language. As Long as the Rivers Flow (Larry Loyie, 2005) Set in 1944, this text is an elegiac account of his last summer before he must leave for residential school. Retrieved from: http://firstnationswriter.blogspot.com / Nicola Campbell’s texts convey in simple, poetic language the attachment to a life attuned to nature, family, and tradition and their immanent uprooting to be taken away to residential school. Shi-shi-etko, 2005 Retrieved from: http://www.okanagan.bc.ca/Page12327.aspx Shin-chi’s Canoe, 2007 Retrieved from: http://www.jacketflap.com/megablog/index.asp?tagid=10393&tag=The+Tiger's+Bookshelf Maata’s Journal (Paul Sullivan, 2003) Set in 1924 and stranded on an Eastern Arctic mapping expedition and awaiting rescue, 17-year-old Maata reflects back on her life and recounts the difficulties of adapting to change and the challenge of trying to live in two worlds. Retrieved from: http://openlibrary.org/works/OL482523W/Maata's_journal Retrieved from: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II IV.D. The World War II decade Writers of the World War II decade moved away from the Romantic patriotism seen at the onset of WWI; they expressed the costs of war, physical and psychological, and examined war’s dehumanizing impact. Retrieved from: http://ehsjournal.org/http:/ehsjournal.org/scott-nadler/environmentalmanagement-geographic-mismatch-coping-with-dislocation-in-the-global-economy/2010/ IV.D.1. Conflicts and dislocations The English Patient (Michael Ondatje, 1992) This dense and complex narrative interweaves two plots: In one, the ‘English patient’ is seen to actually be a Hungarian explorer in 1930s North Africa, having an intense affair with a colleague’s wife. The other plot is set in the ruins of 1944 central Italy, in an isolated Tuscan villa, once a military hospital. Retrieved from: http://www.amazon.ca/English-Patient-Michael-Ondaatje/dp/039428013X The Lost Garden (Helen Humphreys, 2004) This text is set in the English countryside during the WWII Blitz. Gwen, a horticulturist, has fled the bombed-out devastation of London for a ruined estate, where she takes charge of a group of Land Army girls cultivating foodcrops for the war effort. Retrieved from: http://www.amazon.ca/Lost-Garden-Helen-Humphreys/dp/0006393594 Retrieved from: http://www.180360720.no/index.php/archive/confusing-social-mediawith-media/ IV.D.2. The Torn Social Fabric In early September 1939, nearly 3, 000, 000 people were transported from endangered cities to the safety of the countryside. Most were children, labeled like luggage, and separated from their parents. The trauma of fear, separation, and isolation experienced by so many are still clear in survivors’ accounts 60 years later. Retrieved from: http://www.qlhs.org.uk/oracle/2008-warchildhood/index.htm IV.D.2.a. Evacuees and disrupted communities The Guests of War Trilogy (Kit Pearson) depicts in detail the fallout, over five years, from the ruptured lives of two evacuated children. The Sky is Falling (1989) Looking at the Moon (1991) The Lights Go on Again (1993) Retrieved from: http://openlibrary.org/works/OL2802858W/Guests_of_War_Trilogy Boy O’Boy (Brian Doyle, 2005) Set in Ottawa’s Lowertown at the war’s end, this is a powerful, painful novel for young adults. Young Billy O’Boy and his friend Martin reflect on grim news from the war, on their families’ equally grim dilemmas, and on their hero, Captain Marvel. Retrieved from: http://www.tower.com/boy-oboy-brian-doyle-paperback/wapi/100366473 The Cure for Death by Lightning (Gail Anderson-Dargatz, 1996) Isolated and vulnerable on her family’s remote farm, 15-yearold Beth, the narrator, is haunted by dark fears of known and unknown malice: a mysterious, unseen predator, as well as more sinister abuse at the hands of her father, who is unhinged by a First World War head injury. Retrieved from: //www.goodreads.com/book/show/824173.The_Cure_For_Death_By_Lightning Jade Peony (Wayson Choy, 1997) Three children tell of their family during the WWII years, each from his or her point of view; however, they are clearly rooted in the longing for bonds between generations that connect them to events shaping Chinese immigrant life earlier in the century. Retrieved from: http://openlibrary.org/works/OL2402995W/The_jade_peony Retrieved from: http://esjay07.wordpress.com/photo-gallery/japanese-internment-2/ IV.D.2.b. The Japanese-Canadian internment and dispersal Obasan (Joy Kogawa, 1981) This text chronicles the erosion of civil rights experienced by Canadians of Japanese descent during WWII. Marginalized voices critique the ‘normal’ official voice of authority: Historical thinking and literary insight expose the official version of Japanese-Canadian history as a lie. Retrieved from: http://www.whonnock.ca/whonnock/Events-Pictures.htm Retrieved from: http://www.newtbdrugs.org/blog/2010/07/the-sanatorium-files-part-3the-sanatorium-movement/ IV.D.2.c. Public health, tuberculosis, and the sanatoria The World War II era was marked by public health measures that transformed the future for those suffering from tuberculosis, which was, until mid-century, Canada’s biggest killer. Queen of Hearts (Martha Brooks, 2010) Set in the early war years, fun- loving 15-year-old Marie-Claire enjoys her close-knit farm family and flirtations at the local army base. In a flash, that life is gone as she and her younger brother and sister are diagnosed with tuberculosis and thrust into the isolation of the sanatorium life, quarantined even from one another. Retrieved from: http://mabelsfablesraves.blogspot.com/2010_10_01_archive.html Consumption (Kevin Patterson, 2006) Although Victoria’s story begins in 1962, her treatment is complex, and when she does return to her Inuit community six years later, she is alienated and almost unable to speak Inuktitut. Retrieved from: http://www.mcdermidagency.com/authInfo.cfm?auth=87&userID=6 Retrieved from: http://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.com/articles/jews IV.D.2.d. Jewish-Canadian Holocaust narratives The contributions of Jewish-Canadian writers include richly-imagined accounts of Jewish immigration and settlement, the complex negotiations of ethnicity and gender within their own community, the tensions of new citizenship and Old Country, and the ever-present antiSemitism and ‘otherness’ to both the Catholic norm of Quebec, and the powerful Anglo-Celtic norm of Protestant Canada. Margit, Book One: Home Free (Kathy Kacer, 2003) 11-year-old Margit has escaped German-occupied Czechoslovakia, and is part of the small group of Jewish refugees allowed into Canada, despite the government’s policy of exclusion. Retrieved from: http://lookingglassreview.com/html/the_our_canadian_girl_series.html Clara’s War (Kathy Kacer, 2001) This text centres on 13-year-old Clara’s imprisonment in the Terezin concentration camp, and her effort to find meaning in the children’s opera she participates in, in an environment without hope. Retrieved from: http://www.amazon.ca/Claras-War-Kathy-Kacer/dp/1896764428 The Thought of High Windows (Lynne Kositsky, 2004) Sixteen-year-old Esther is on the run from Germany to France, with a group of 60 teenaged refugees. Esther’s loneliness and misery come equally from her very real danger, and from her exclusion, even amid danger, by the attractive and popular young refugees. Retrieved from: http://openlibrary.org/books/OL8570429M/The_Thought_of_High_Windows Turned Away (Carol Matas, 2005) This text dramatizes the Canadian government’s shameful refusal to accept a number of children who were cleared to leave their countries. Retrieved from: http://www.umanitoba.ca/outreach/cm/vol12/no3/turnedaway.html In My Enemy’s House (Carol Matas, 1999) This text follows Marisa, a blond, blue-eyed Polish Jew who escapes the ghetto, finds papers to disguise herself as a Polish Christian, and travels to Weimar, where she finds work as a servant with a wealthy farming family who treat her well.Yet she must live a lie in order to survive. Retrieved from: http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/369295.In_My_Enemy_s_House Greater than Angels (Carol Matas, 1998) This text fictionalizes a true story of a village in France that committed itself to sheltering deported Jewish children. Le Chambon is a small farming community in southern France, who, with their pacifist pastor, helped hide as many Jews as arrived there. Retrieved from: http://www.amazon.com/Greater-Than-AngelsCarol-Matas/dp/068983084X The Whirlwind (Carol Matas, 2007) Set in 1941 Seattle, 14-year- old Ben and his family have fled from the horrors of Nazi Germany. Ben begins to hope for safety, enjoying the friendship of John, a Japanese-American boy. Retrieved from: http://openlibrary.org/books/OL9319080M/The_Whirlwind I was the Child of Holocaust Survivors (Bernice Eisenstein, 2006) Eisenstein’s parents met in Auschwitz, married shortly after the Liberation, and immigrated to Canada. The trauma of their experiences and the ever-present horror of memory permeated their lives. Retrieved from: http://openlibrary.org/books/OL8876332M/I_Was_a_Child_of_Holocaust_Survivors Retrieved from: http://fbh.ycdsb.ca/departments/fbh_library/students/chapter_4.html IV.E. Reading post-war Canada History does not happen in neat sections and, much as we love charts and timelines, history cannot be filed in pigeonholes. Events seem to happen with shocking suddenness – human catastrophes are generally the result of multiple pressures, fissures, and historical tentacles of cause and effect. Retrieved from: http://users.erols.com/mwhite28/coldwar1.htm IV.E.1. Post-war, Cold War The end of WWII did not mean the end of ideological struggle. While populations struggled to mend their lives after the end of overt hostilities, the Cold War framed the unarmed confrontations between the United States and the Soviet Union and their allies. Each superpower was motivated by fear of world domination by the other and by its implications for nuclear war. Pure Springs (Brian Doyle, 2007) Martin, from Boy O’Boy, 2003, is now 15, an orphan, and the Korean war has begun. Fatherless and with male role models all heroically off at war, Martin who is still haunted by the choirmaster’s sexual abuse, is working for a crooked delivery man who initiates Martin into the world of crime. Retrieved from: http://openlibrary.org/books/OL8212310M/Pure_Spring The Way the Crow Flies (Ann-Marie MacDonald, 2003) Nowhere is this dichotomy Retrieved from: http://classic.eyeonbooks.com/ibp.php?ISBN=0060578955 between Cold War demoralization and middleclass complacence more searingly depicted than this text. The connection of private and personal choices to the international zeitgeist, a tale of innocence betrayed, is told through the consciousness of sunny, imaginative, eight-yearold Madeleine McCarthy. Gemini Summer (Iain Lawrence, 2007) Young Danny River and his teenaged brother Beau are devoted, despite brotherly squabbles. Danny wants nothing more than a dog; Beau, enraptured by the space race, watches breathlessly as the Gemini space missions are covered on television, and heroworships the astronaut Gus Grissom. Retrieved from: http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/192757631 Rex Zero and the End of the World (Tim Wynne-Jones, 2006) Eleven-year-old Rex’s family has just moved from Vancouver; Rex and his sister check for Communists, caught up with the paranoia and excitement of possible air raids, bomb shelters, gas masks, and the prospects of nuclear war. Retrieved from: http://openlibrary.org/works/OL47001W/Rex_Zero_and_the_end_of_the_world Retrieved from: http://grist.org/politics/2009-12-07-the-physics-of-copenhagenwhy-politics-as-usual-may-mean-the-end/ IV.E.2. Mid-century and the human rights pendulum Perhaps both historical understanding and literary ‘dose of imagination’ teach concern for how human rights can evolve out of personal devastation and difficulty, and teach, as well, a profound desire to nurture and protect vulnerable and disadvantaged populations. Juvie: Inside Canada’s Youth Jails (Gordon Cruse, 2007) This text points how the Juvenile Delinquents Act, the Young Offenders Act, and the Youth Criminal Justice Act are flawed and beneficial, but none offer solutions that will satisfy equally the general public, lawenforcement officers, the courts, or the offenders themselves (in Lidster, 2007, p. D11). Retrieved from: http://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/juvie-gordon-cruse/1015783178 Tin Angel (Shannon Cowan, 2007) Ronnie faces, first, her father’s death, then the loss of the family’s idyllic mountain lodge, then the move to town, and her mother’s depression and drinking problem. Details of Ronnie’s story, at first blurred and meaningless, gradually build up to damning evidence that leads to her arrest. Retrieved from: http://openlibrary.org/works/OL6234796W/Tin_Angel Retrieved from: http://educ.queensu.ca/news/aboriginalvoices.html IV.E.3. Aboriginal voices: ‘An unacknowledged shadow’ The mid-century saw little improvement in the lives of Aboriginal youth, who were still subject to removal from their families, and whose education was still enforced assimilation. Kiss of the Fur Queen (Tomson Highway, 1998) Tomson and his brother Rene were taken from their family and placed in the Le Pas residential school where they were both sexually abused by the priests. But both boys were gifted and had their creative talents nurtured. Retrieved from: http://www.amazon.co.uk/American-Indian-Literature-CriticalStudies/dp/0806139331/ref=sr_1_2?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1329866003&sr=1-2 Green Grass, Running Water (Thomas King, 1993) King uses wit and ridicule, an intertextual grab-bag of popular culture and Judeo-Christian myth, to skewer myths and stereotypes, to expose the absurdity of cultural and patriarchal oppression that has kept them outside the dominant culture. Retrieved from: http://www.amazon.ca/Green-Grass-Running-WaterThomas/dp/0006485138