ATHENA M38 Final review
27-29 March, 2007
Funchal, Portugal
Project B2
Amparo Roca de Togores, AIDIMA
© ATHENA Consortium 2006
1
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Project Goals





Continuously high level of dissemination about main ATHENA
results
Feeding and updating the website contents
Encouraging and controlling ATHENA partners to organize
workshops and present ATHENA achieved results in main
related conferences
Support EIC
Success for I-ESA conference to establish it as a series of
conferences after ATHENA and INTEROP projects conclusion
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
2
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Major Achievements
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
Newsletter
IST 06
eChallenges
Publications
Papers
Website statistics
I-ESA 07
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
3
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Newsletter
•ATHENA eNewsletter No.7
•No.8 after the Conference
• Conference conclusions
• ATHENA results
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
4
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
IST ‘06
• Additional efforts for the IST website award
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
5
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
IST ‘06
• Networking session “Enterprise Networks: How to overcome the
obstacles to their effective diffusion”
– Co-organized by TIEKE (Finland), ENEA (Italy) and the ATHENA
project.
• Booth showing results and demonstrators on:
–
–
–
–
–
–
Modelling and enacting cross-organisational business processes;
Platform-Independent Model for service-oriented architectures;
Creation and exchange of enterprise models;
Model-driven development of agents;
Semantics tool suite;
ATHENA training curriculum
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
6
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
eChallenges ‘06
●
●
6 ATHENA papers at the conference
Best Paper Award to “Using Onion Routing to secure
Peer Supported Business Collaboration”, by Fabian
Stäber, Udo Bartlang and Jörg Müller from Siemens
AG, Germany.
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
7
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Publications
Publication
Partners
Criteria
“Framework for enhanced interoperability through UNINOVA
ontological harmonization of enterprise models
“,RICARDO JARDIM-GONCALVES, JOÃO P.M.A.
SILVA, ANTÓNIO A.C. MONTEIRO, ADOLFO
STEIGER-GARÇÃO,chapter of book entitled
"Ontologies in the Context of Information Systems",
Springer , November 2006.
Springer is a major recognised editor
for recognized scientific books.
Edited by Prof. Rajiv Kishore,
Department of Management
Science & Systems. School of
Management. State University of
New York at Buffalo
Ricardo Jardim-Goncalves, Antonio Grilo, Adolfo SteigerGarcao, Mass Customization Information Systems in
Business, published by Idea Group, Inc., publisher of
the Idea Group Publishing, Information Science
Publishing, IRM Press, CyberTech Publishing and
Idea Group Reference imprints , March 2007
Book edited by Prof. Dr. Thorsten
Blecker, Hamburg University of
Technology (TUHH), Germany &
Prof. Dr. Gerhard Friedrich,
University of Klagenfurt, Austria.
UNINOVA
“Evolution of Business Interoperability in the Automotive
IWI-HSG
Industry”, Christine Legner, Kirstin Wende. Book by
Cunningham, P., Cunningham, M. (Eds.): “Exploiting
the Knowledge Economy - Issues, Applications, Case
Studies”, October 2006
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
8
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Publications
Publication
Partners
Criteria
“Challenging the Interoperability in the
Construction Industry with MDA and SoA”,
Ricardo Goncalves, Antonio Grilo, Adolfo
Steiger Garcao, Computers in Industry.
UNINOVA
SCI Impact factor: 0,69
“Enabling interoperability of STEP
Application Protocols at meta-data and
knowledge level”, Ricardo JardimGonçalves, Nicolas Figay and Adolfo
Steiger-Garção, International Journal of
Technology Management (IJTM), Volume
36, Number 4 / 2006, pp. 402-421.
EADS,
UNINOVA
SCI Impact factor: 0,284
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
9
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Papers
●
3rd IEEE Int. Conference on Intelligent Systems (IEEE IS’06),
at Westminster University, London, United Kingdom, 4-6
September 2006.
●
●
●
“Ontological harmonization of enterprise product models: an
experimented scenario”, Ricardo Jardim-Gonçalves, João P M A
Silva, Adolfo Steiger-Garcao, António A C Monteiro.
“A framework for STEP-based harmonization of conceptual
models”, Delgado M, Agostinho, C, Malo, P, Gonçalves, R.,
“Product Data integration in the demand of interoperability in eBusiness”, Agostinho, C. ; Costa, R. ; Malo, P.; JardimGonçalves, R.
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
10
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Papers
●
ASME 2006. Sep 2006
●
●
ECPPM’06, Valencia, Spain. September 2006.
●
●
●
“Conformance Testing for XML-based STEP Conceptual Models”, Ricardo
Jardim-Goncalves, Sérgio Onofre, Carlos Agostinho, Adolfo SteigerGarcao,
“Interoperable Framework to support Collaborative Business Processes
in eProcurement at AEC-FM”, Ruben Costa, Pedro Malo, Ricardo
Goncalves, Adolfo Steiger Garcao,
“Assessing Construction Interoperability Using a MDA and SOA
Architecture From an e-Business Perspective”, Antonio Grilo, Ricardo
Gonçalves, Adolfo Steiger Garcao.
CE2006, Antibes-France, September 18-22 2006.
●
●
“A framework for STEP-based harmonization of conceptual models”,
Carlos Agostinho, Marco Delgado, Steiger Garcao, Ricardo Gonçalves,
“Collaborative Product Development: EADS Pilot based on ATHENA
results", Nicolas Figay, CE2006, Antibes-France, September 18-22 2006.
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
11
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Papers
●
MATES 2006, Erfurt, Germany, 19-20 September 2006.
●
●
●
●
●
“Meta-models, Models, and Model Transformations:Towards Interoperable Agents”,
Christian Hahn, Cristiaan Madrigal-Mora, Klaus Fischer, Brian Elvesæter, Arne-Jørgen
Berre, and Ingo Zinnikus,
“A Model Driven Approach to Agent-Based Service-Oriented Architectures”, Ingo
Zinnikus, Gorka Benguria, Brian Elvesæter, Klaus Fischer, Julien Vayssiere.
“Agent-supported Cross-Organizational Business Process Management and
Implementation “,T. Kahl, D. Vanderhaeghen, J. Ziemann, I. Zinnikus, P. Loos, K.
Fischer.
“Multiagent System Technologies”, K. Fischer, E. André, I.J Timm, N. Zhong,
MATES 2006, Erfurt, Germany, 19-20 September 2006.
ICEBE 2006, Shanghai, China, 24-26 October 2006.
●
Paper: “Configuring Processes and Business Components—An Integrated Approach to
Enterprise Systems Collaboration”, Christian Janiesch, Alexander Dreiling, Ulrike
Greiner, Sonia Lippe,
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
12
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Papers
●
eChallenges e-2006 Conference & Exhibition, Barcelona, Spain, 25 - 27
October 2006.
●
●
●
●
●
●
“Using Onion Routing to Secure Peer-to-Peer Supported Business Collaboration”,
Fabian Stäber, Udo Bartlang, Jörg. P. Müller. (Best Paper Award).
“A Validation Architecture for Advanced Interoperability Provisioning", N. Ivezic, E.
Barkmeyer,B. Kulvatunyou, A. Jones, P. Snack, Z. Marjanovic, H. Cho,
“Enterprise Model Driven Creation of Business Protocols”, T. Kahl, J. Ziemann, U.
Greiner, S. Lippe.
“Evolution of Business Interoperability in the Automotive Industry”, Kristin Wende,
Christine Legner.
“Taking the most of MDA and SOA to challenge SMEs in the advent of a Single
European Information Space”, Marco Delgado, Carlos Agostinho, Ricardo
Gonçalves,
“Semantic Reconciliation of Business Documents in a SOA Framework”, Michele
Missikoff, Alessandra Bagnato, Eva Coscia, Lorenzo Pondrelli, Francesco Taglino.
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
13
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Papers
●
EDOC 2006, Hong Kong, 16-20 October 2006.
●
●
SWAP 2006, Pisa, Italy, 18-20 December 2006
●
●
“MDSS: A framework for the integration of ontology mapping tools”,
Gabriele Marcelli, Tania Di Mascio, Fulvio D’Antonio,.
PRO-VE’06, Helsinki, Finland, 25-27 September 2006.
●
●
“Integrated Configuration of Enterprise Systems for Interoperability",
Christian Janiesch, Alexander Dreiling, Ulrike Greiner, and Sonia Lippe,
“Towards a recommendation system for model mapping/transformations
tasks”, Fulvio D'Antonio, Michele Missikoff, Paolo Bottoni, Axel Hahn, Kevin
Hausmann.
ENEI’06, Vienna, Austria, 4 September 2006.
●
“Semaphore – A Model-Based Semantic Mapping Framework”, Andreas
Limyr.
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
14
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Papers
●
INSITE Conference 2006, Johannesburg, South Africa, 24-26 September 2006
●
●
ASIM 2006, University of Kassel, 26-27 September 2006.
●
●
“Framework
for Establishing Enterprise Modeling in the Context of Collaborative
Enterprises", Thomas Knothe, Dieter, Boell, Kristof Schneider, Timo Kahl,
ICCBSS 2007, Banff, Alberta, Canada, February 26 – March 2, 2007.
●
●
●
“Simulation von Geschäftsprozessen”,
HICSS 2007, Waikoloa, Big Island, Hawaii, USA, 3-6 January, 2007.
●
●
“Model Generated Workplace”, Dieter Boll,.
“Data Model Transformation for Supporting the Interoperability”, Gorka Benguria,
Xabier Larrucea,
“MDSOA for achieving interoperability”, Xabier Larrucea, Gorka Benguria.
8. Internationale Tagung Wirtschaftsinformatik, Karlsruhe, Germany, 28
February – 2 March, 2007.
●
“Cross-organizational processes in Public Administrations: Conceptual modeling
and implementation with Web Service Protocols”, J. Ziemann, T. Kahl, T. Matheis,
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
15
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Website statistics
Month
Unique Visitors
Number of Visits
Visits Average
Pages
Referrer
s
Aug
7.253
7.848
1,1
77.048
6.194
Sep
7.727
9.220
1,18
93.689
5.628
Oct
8.245
9.296
1,11
132.747
6.057
Nov
7.100
8.279
1,17
149.294
4.303
Dec
6.257
7.202
1
107.853
4.605
Jan
9.308
10.563
1,13
125.371
7.970
Feb
8.955
9.947
1.1
83.835
6.983
--
--
--
--
--
--
Total
54.845
62.355
769.837
26.006
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
16
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
I-ESA ‘07
16154 visits
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
17
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Committees
●
I-ESA 07 committees already stablished
●
●
●
●
IPC Chairs – Jörg Müller (ATHENA)/Kai Mertins (INTEROP)
Steering Committee
●
María José Núñez, Petra Frenzel, Ricardo Gonçalves
Michel Léonard, Martin Zelm, Guy Doumeingts
●
Man-Sze Li and Adolfo Steiger
●
Dimitri Konstantas (INTEROP)
●
●
●
●
Advisory Board
Workshop Chair
Tutorials Chairs
●
Raúl Poler (INTEROP)
Frank Lillehagen (ATHENA)
●
Bruno Vallespir
●
Stefan Schuster
●
●
●
Ricardo Gonçalves. (ATHENA). General Chair
Martin Zelm. (INTEROP). General Co-Chair
Doctoral Symposium Chair
Exhibition and Brockerage Event Chair
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
18
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Sponsors
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
IFIP
IFAC
ISO TC 184
ISO TC 184 SC4
INTERNATIONAL STEP CENTRES
ASME
IMS
INA
MANUFUTURE
International Relay Centres NETWORK
IRC –CENEMES
REDIT
1st European Summit on Interoperability in eGovernement
OPET
ORACLE
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
19
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Expressions of Interest
●
●
●
●
Workshops: 14
Tutorials: 5
Meetings: 2
Papers: 73
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
20
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Brochure
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
21
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Tutorials
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
Fundamentals in Interoperability. Ricardo Gonçalves, UNINOVA
Modelling Regarding Interoperability for Enterprise Networks. FrankWalter Jaekel, Fraunhofer IPK.
Enterprise Interoperability – Basic concepts, definitions and
approaches. David Chen, Université Bordeaux 1
Cross organizational Business Processes – Issues, Concepts,
Technologies and Tools. Ulrike Greiner, SAP Research
Architectures and Platforms. Klaus Fisher, DFKI
Migration of Legacy Assets to SOA Environments. Grace Lewis,
Software Engineering Institute. Carnegie Mellon.
From Model Transformations to Model Driven Interoperability. JeanPierre Bourey, École Centrale de Lille and Reyes Grangel, Universitat
Jaume I .
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
22
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Tutorials
●
●
●
●
●
●
Introduction to Business Interoperability. Baptiste Lebreton, Insead.
Enterprise modelling as a way to achieve interoperability. Mikel
Vergara, European Software Institute.
Semantic Technologies for Interoperability: Achievements and
Challenges. Michele Missikoff and Francesco Taglino, CNR.
Active Knowledge Modelling of Enterprises. Frank Lillehagen, AKM
UN/CEFACT e-Business framework: Closing the semantic gap of
Service Oriented Architectures. Christoph Schroth, SAP AG
An adaptive framework for mitigating software development risk: In
the financial Services Sector. Edwin Gray, Glasgow Caledonian
University.
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
23
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Workshops
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
FSOA 2007: Foundation of Service-Oriented Architecture
Enterprise Knowledge Management
Architectures for Enterprise INteroperability (AREIN)
Enabling Rapid and Reliable Cross-Enterprise Interoperable
Systems: Impacting the Industry in the Global Environment - CEIS'07
2nd International Workshop on Interoperability Solutions to Trust,
Security, Policies and QoS for Enhanced Enterprise Systems
Exercise on organisational interoperability approaches for
collaborative networks – OiCoN
Challenging the Interoperability towards the Single European
Information Space (SEIS)
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
24
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Workshops
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
Building Information Model and Interoperability I&D and Practice
Developments (BIMI)
Overcoming the pain of culture, knowledge and cost of
interoperability in SMEs
Enabling Model-Driven Architecture: Model Transformation,
Derivation and Extension
GENESIS - Interoperable services for business and
governments
Enterprise Assistive Technology: ICT &Disability
Interoperability in the iGovernment. Challenging the i2010
objectives
Interoperability in Manufacturing – requirements, new
technologies and business opportunities
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
25
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Keynote Speakers
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
Cristina Martínez. (European Commission)
Howard Mason. (ISO TC 184 SC4)
Engelbert Westkämper (Fraunhofer-IPA)
Reinhard Büscher (European Commission)
Guy Doumeingts (Adelior France)
Dan Nagy (IMS)
Uwe Vieille (UNISYS - OSA)
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
26
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
International School in Interoperability
Industrial practices and emerging solutions
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
EM1 Enterprise Modeling
CI2 - The ATHENA Interoperability Framework
CI3 - Practices of Interoperability in SMEs
EM2 Active Knowledge Modeling of Enterprises (adapted
for research)
EM3 Center Business Networking
AP5 Principles of Model-driven Interoperability – MDI
AP6 Model-driven Interoperable Web services, agents and
P2P solutions
AP2 Planning and specification of Interoperable S-O
Solutions
BI1 Introduction to Business Interoperability
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
27
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
International School in Interoperability
Concepts and Theory
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
O01 Synchronisation of Different Distributed Enterprise
Models
O02 Model Driven Interoperability
O03 Model Morphisms
O04 Semantic Enrichment of Enterprise Models for
Interoperability
O05 Business / IT alignment
O06 Methods, Requirements and Method Engineering for
Interoperability
O07 Non-functional aspects of interoperability
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
28
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Brokerage event
• In collaboration with the IRC network
• 10 half an hour meetings
• 9 participants
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
29
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Best Paper Awards
• IFIP sponsorship (500 € per award)
– Best Paper Award
– Young Researcher Best Paper Award
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
30
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Best Paper Awards
• IFIP sponsorship (500 € per award)
– Best Paper Award
– Young Researcher Best Paper Award
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
31
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Best Paper Awards
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
32
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Final figures
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
Registrations: 423
Submitted papers: 140
Full papers approved: 60
Short papers approved: 40
Keynote speakers: 8
Workshops: 14
Tutorials: 13
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
33
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
Parallel events
●
●
ISO TC 184 SC4 meeting
Europe INNOVA First Thematic Workshop
'Standards and Innovation' and Partnering Event
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
34
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
B2: Performance indicators (I)
●
●
Interest Group (IG): 968 External members
Marketing material:
●
●
●
●
●
Brochure;
Poster;
Flyers
Newsletter issues: 7 (+1)
Liaisons
●
●
NoE: INTEROP
Standardisation bodies and organizations:
●
●
●
●
1 former liaison now member of ATHENA: AIAG;
Actually 3 formal liaisons: NIST, KorBIT, OAG;
Communications through mailing lists: 63
Exhibitions: 2
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
35
ATHENA M38 Final Review Meeting, March 2007, Funchal
B2: Performance indicators (II)
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
Workshops:15
Conferences attended: 18
Website news: 20
Direct mailings: 25
Papers presented: 28 + I-ESA
Publication in International Scientific Journals and chapter of
books: 5
ATHENA conferences: I-ESA 07
Collaboration with INTEROP:
ECOOP; Joint IST 6th Framework Project Workshop; IFAC 2004; IST
2004; e-Challenges 2004; INTEROP-ESA ’05; collaborative Ws WP5
Interop-A1 Athena; e-Challenges ’05; I-ESA ’06; Industrial SMEs
workshop at I-ESA ’06; joint training activities at I-ESA ’06;
preparation I-ESA 07
© ATHENA Consortium 2007
36