Report to the City of Millwood Community Consultation “Developing a Vibrant Business Community Project” Executive Summary This report seeks to advise the Millwood City Council of the progress of the “Developing a Vibrant Business Community Project” and seeks Councils formal support of the project through focused capital works projects and services provided by the City and Community Groups. The formal support for the project by the Millwood City Council will facilitate seeking grants, sponsorship, donations, or community based funding for projects and activities which “Develop a Vibrant Business Community”. In early 2015, the City of Millwood commenced a project to assist its business community to develop a vibrant and desirable business community. Several Community Consultation meetings were held to canvass the views and expectations of individual businesses, business groups, community groups and interested community members. Key Focus Areas were identified around which to develop a unique identify for the City, to develop City infrastructure and community events that promote the City and attract people and business to Millwood. Millwood as “A Gathering Place” resulted as a brand identity developed through the Branding Committee. As “A Gathering Place” Millwood reflects and celebrates its past, tie in with its community events into a recognizable theme to benefit the community and business. Millwood will be recognizable place where people want to stop and explore and bond with. Essentially Millwood wants to be recognized as a desirable destination. The City of Millwood has an opportunity to take a leadership role to promote the City of Millwood as a desirable destination. A focused approach through this project will assist the City to develop infrastructure that fits the central themes and promotes the various aspects of the City and support the well-being of the community and businesses. The community is committed to making a difference and to that extent the formation of the Millwood Community Association provides an entity which can seek funding, deliver services and promote Millwood separately to the City. Business groups, historical and community support groups can now include their activities under the auspices of the Millwood Community Association to promote a coordinated and consistently presented view of the City. It is essential that the City of Millwood takes an active leadership role to support the “Building a Vibrant Business Community” project. This will enable the development of cohesive programs and activities which all support the central Millwood brand and enable funding applications to support the various program activities. Background and Details In early 2015, the City of Millwood commenced a project to assist its business community to develop a vibrant and desirable business community. The City engaged Strategem Business Consultants to assist in the community consultation process, to act as a facilitator for the process and as the City’s representative to continue the development of the project. The City recognized the successes of other transformational communities in Spokane including the Parry Street District, Hillyard District, University District and the Garland District. Strategem Business Consultants Page 1 A stakeholder consultation process was developed through which interested businesses and the community could participate. Business leaders, community groups, representatives from Greater Spokane, the Small Business Association, Spokane County Library and interested members of the community were invited to the inaugural Stakeholder meeting. Mayor Freeman shared the City’s desire to develop the business community, the City’s existing capital works programs and to work with a formal community organization. The stakeholder consultation process identified several Focus Area themes which provides a focus for capital works programs, community programs, and harnesses current community activities. Three Community Stakeholder Meetings, several Branding meetings and many meetings to develop themes and action plans were held. COMMUNITY COMMENTS RECORDED AS PART OF “BRAINSTORMING” IDEAS – Inaugural meeting CONCERNS ATTRACTIONS Parking for business – Argonne West Valley School District Limited Growth Access to road system – I90 – major roads Small businesses River Time & Resources limited – low cost. Drug abuse – Nature Safety Family place Vandalism crime Centennial Trail Right of way Parking in the park Turnoffs Events in the park Traffic – Volume + Speed Bus Service Know by School District Historic district Known by landmarks Tree City USA Intimate OPPORTUNITIES Nice Park Traffic Walkable Regional population Lots of amenities Build attractions Strong faith based Other models to look at Felts Field activities Landmarks Good population + pass through traffic THINGS TO FOCUS ON Large regional population not tapped into Advertising – places, activities How to make Millwood attractive Who we are – develop clear identity Getting traffic to stop and turn What infrastructure needed to capture traffic Repurpose buildings into identity – no identify benefits? What is Millwood Gateway sign – Trent / Walgreens Others don’t know who we are / we do. Continue proactive interactions Trees and Inland Empire Paper Don’t know location No signage unique Attractive area but not broadcast Strategem Business Consultants Page 2 Demographic data Demographic data collected indicates that the City of Millwood has a population of 1,856, with 748 households and 148 businesses registered in the City. Population demographics of the City of Millwood suggest that it is predominately residential, with a large proportion (64%) of small households of 1-2 people and a majority white-collar office workers. The average household expenditure levels ($48,000) are comparable to Spokane Value ($49,000) and to the City of Spokane ($47,000). Consumer household spending patterns indicate that 50% of expenditure is on groceries, department /mail /catalog purchases, computers, pharmacy and warehouse superstores. 13% of purchases are at new car dealers. Millwood has a comparatively high proportion of home Owner-Occupancy (74%) and Renter-Occupied (26%). This varies significantly to owner/occupancy in the City of Spokane is (53%), Tacoma (51.5%), Vancouver WA (49.4%), and may be interpreted as people setting roots in Millwood and being a permanent part of the community. Anecdotally people in and out of the region speak fondly of Millwood. Millwood has active community service groups such as the Presbyterian Church, Zion Lutheran Church and the West Valley and Millwood Schools. Business demographics indicate that 148 businesses are registered in the City. The ratio of Businesses to Households essentially gives an indication of the land use devoted to business and indicates that Millwood is much more slanted toward business than the surrounding cities. Millwood has (148/748) = 18.9% businesses, Spokane Valley 13.1%, Spokane 13.2%, and Liberty Lakes 11.4%. Analysis of Millwood Demographics and Opportunities Millwood has a unique opportunity to reinvent itself, to develop a readily understood and concise image which would benefit businesses and household residents. The City has a long and proud history as a regional center, it has many existing natural features and buildings, is a key part as a north-south gateway between Spokane Valley and northern Spokane County, there is a harmonious integration of nature, people, business, industry and activities. Its image is not clear. People that know Millwood recognize its nature, the sense of community and its suburban tree lined streets and historical homes. Census statistics and business registrations indicate that Millwood has a large number of businesses (184) compared to households (18.9%). Additionally, Millwood has a large house proportion of rental housing (26% of all housing units) are business activities in their own right. The most visual businesses are located along Trent and Argonne are retail and concentrated near the Trent/Argonne intersection and in concentrated commercial spaces, the major being the Albertsons and Walgreen complexes. Service businesses fill in along these roads and include attorneys, medical facilities, financial services, motor vehicle repairs, small strip retailers, manufacturing. Community buildings are mainly off the major streets and include the schools, churches, fire station. Strategem Business Consultants Page 3 Millwood businesses are small by nature and are therefore less likely to have resources and skills to understand the current population and economic demographics. They are also less likely to be able to target market to regional residents and passersby and would benefit from business promotion as a group. They are more likely to be located in Millwood because of low property prices and rents and by extension be less likely to appeal to higher income earners. Specific marketing strategies can change this perspective. Not all business can benefit from passing traffic. Businesses located near the shopping precincts have sufficient parking, relative ease of turning and attract passing traffic. Businesses near the historical area have the most to gain from untapped passing traffic, traffic calming and additional parking. Opportunities exist to promote the historical area to generate more interactive uses for people in this area. The Stakeholder Group also recognized that the City’s support should assist the visible main street as well as the invisible off-main street businesses. Millwood currently has very strong community participation through the Better for Business Group, the Historical Group, Friends of Millwood, Presbyterian Church, Spokane County Library, and the West Valley School District. Many community events such as the Farmers Market, Millwood Dayz rely heavily on community support. Opportunities to develop a Vibrant Business Community Millwood’s opportunity is to emulate the example of other transformations such as the South Parry, Hillyard, Garland and University Districts, however recognizing its own unique differences, its historical background, a limited number of small businesses and its strong community support. Given the size of the City of Millwood and its limited resources, the City’s role could be better served by acting variously as a FACILITATOR to stimulate and support the community and business group’s actions and to assist as a PROMOTER in developing Capital Works programs that support Millwood and as a CONSTRUCTOR to build community infrastructure. Actions to date to develop a Vibrant Business Community 1. Identify Focus Areas around which to pursue opportunities Community – building a vibrant community through business participation Recreation – building a vibrant community through existing and new recreational opportunities Education – building a vibrant community through education programs focused on businesses Property – building a vibrant community through zoning and public and private infrastructure Technology – building a vibrant community through new technologies Focus Areas identify opportunities that are consistent with the aim to provide a vibrant business community. Easily achieved opportunities (Low-Hanging Fruit) will be pursue for early funding and implementation. Strategem Business Consultants Page 4 2. Develop Millwood’s unique Identity and Brand A concise Brand Identity would assist the City of Millwood and its business community to promote the region in a cohesive and consistent way. A Brand Identity will assist in the developing cohesive community streetscapes, infrastructure, community activities and business services. A Brand theme was developed by the Branding Committee (volunteer Stakeholder participants), and presented to the Community Group, the key themes of Millwood as “A gathering place”, “Small time USA”, “linking history with a planned future”. The Community Group approved the branding themes and recommended that the Branding Committee continue with the Branding process. Case42 donated its resources to develop a Brochure highlighting Millwood’s current features and using QR code technology. Case42 developed a draft “storyboard” brochure to promote Millwood and to capitalize on Millwood as a “Gathering Place” for community and business. By recognizing and promoting the Focus Areas the City brand recognizes it’s history, affinity with nature, community activities that support the communal gathering and physical enjoyment and to create a destination where people want to stop and participate in businesses in the region. Millwood was a historic gathering place for the Spokane Tribe. The City Park is a natural place of gathering for community, leads naturally into the historical area, tree lined streets for walking, cycling and has the nearby Spokane river as a focus for enjoying water. Physical entry statements at the City boundaries will define Millwood, signage on I-90 can identify Millwood as a Point of Interest, and within the City signage directing to activities and places of interest can be erected as once of items. Developing a common streetscape on the entire Argonne with its epicenter in the historical district provides a common theme for businesses to promote. A coordinated promotion methodology through brochures, icon scanning, use of the a community Website, promotions through clever internet traffic, participation with Greater Spokane are examples of effective and low cost promotion of the City’s and its attractions. 3. Millwood Community Association The Millwood Community Association is a 501 (3) organization and was established to act as a community and business organization, separate from the City of Millwood which can harness the community and work with the City of Millwood to promote activities and events within Millwood and create a vibrant community and benefiting businesses. The inaugural directors are Shirene Young, Dave McClave and Alexander Scott. 4. Millwood Ambassadors: Project Ambassadors were nominated to act as “Champions” for the revitalization project, to be the Leaders of the Focus Area and to promote the “Building a Vibrant Business Community” project and to continue as a link into the future. Strategem Business Consultants Page 5 Focus Group Area Business Association Community Recreation Education Property Technology / Ambassadors Shirene Young, Dave McClave, Alexander Scott Shirene Young, Greg Mott, Marge Anderson Vickie Naccarado and Sam Sheree West, Sue Shields Chuck Watson, Jeff Postelwait Chuck Watson, Jeff Postelwait 5. Low-Hanging Fruit: Focus Group will identify opportunities that are consistent with the aim to provide a vibrant business community. Easily achieved opportunities (Low-Hanging Fruit) will be presented to the Millwood Community Association and the City for early funding and implementation. Examples of City Infrastructure includes entry signage, streetscape designs for the historic district; city park design; walking paths to link the City Park to the historic district and to the West Valley School; traffic calming along Argonne; safe crossing places along Argonne; parking along Argonne, identifying and promoting off-main-street parking at the City Park, near the community center and other designated areas around the City and places of interest; engaging with Spokane County for river access and parking near the Argonne bridge; street furniture to promote walking, cycling and other enjoyment of the City, information plaques to promote the City’s history. Examples of Community participation includes: using the existing resources, web sites and support of the Historical Society and Friends of Millwood to promote the City’s history, to identify places of interest for visitors promoting businesses through communal brochures, mobile apps such as Q-links and community internet site developing activities to promote the City’s brand as a Gathering Place through community events promotion of existing businesses / community functions such as Farmers Market, Millwood Cycling, Rockwood Bakery, The Corner Door, Banner Bank, Walmart, Albertsons promote cycle pathways in the Millwood which cater for people at different skill and ability levels and showing cycle routes that promote the City’s history and future promote the natural attractions in the City such as the tree lined street, the Spokane river frontage, promoting existing river entry points, new access near Argonne Bridge and an opportunity to stroll into the commercial, historic and recreational areas attracting new businesses to the City which can build upon the City’s brand promoting the technological opportunities available as a “smart city” through community wi-fi, high capacity telecommunications developing smart technology for safer communities developing on-going education for business and community through the Spokane County Library outreach programs and bringing SBA and other business support to Millwood Strategem Business Consultants Page 6 developing partnerships with universities / colleges with local businesses whereby students can undertake projects that assist the student studies and the business – for example undertaking marketing surveys, developing streetscapes, developing community programs to focus on health or community well being promoting Millwood as a center of business excellence with monthly business presentations by academics and local businesses focusing on a topic of interest and show casing a business in the Millwood region. This facilitates business knowledge and show promotes local business and promotes Millwood as being progressive. 6. Funding: Numerous opportunities exist through grants, sponsorship, donations, or community based funding. Key to grant funding will be clearly defined goals, mechanisms for accountable project design development and project delivery and the support of the City of Millwood and its community. Conclusion The City of Millwood has an opportunity to take a leadership role to promote the City of Millwood as a desirable destination. A focused approach through this project will assist the City to develop infrastructure that fits the central themes and promotes the various aspects of the City and support the well-being of the community and businesses. The community is committed to making a difference and to that extent the formation of the Millwood Community Association provides an entity which can seek funding, deliver services and promote Millwood separately to the City. Business groups, historical and community support groups can now include their activities under the auspices of the Millwood Community Association to promote a coordinated and consistently presented view of the City. It is essential that the City of Millwood takes an active leadership role to support the “Building a Vibrant Business Community” project. This will enable the development of cohesive programs and activities which all support the central Millwood brand and enable funding applications to support the various program activities. Strategem Business Consultants Page 7 Strategem Business Consultants Page 8 Strategem Business Consultants Page 9 Strategem Business Consultants Page 10