INTRODUCTION TO FORENSIC SCIENCE GUIDED NOTES Name:_____________________ Forensic Science Forensic science is the ______________________________________________________________. Another word for forensic science is __________________________. The main job of a forensic scientist is to study the ____________________________________________. FORENSIC SCIENTIST GUIDED NOTES What happens after a crime is committed? Crime-scene investigators (police) arrive to find, collect, protect, and transport evidence. Most often, the CSI will call in various experts to analyze different types of evidence. Forensic Pathologists A physician with special training in pathology (disease) ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ Other responsibilities: Reviews medical history Reviews witness statements Performs autopsy Collects evidence (toxicology, microscopic examination of organs, DNA analysis, etc.) Writes a report, include an official cause of death Provides testimony in criminal court In complicated cases, a forensic pathologist may also be asked to examine and photograph the crime scene himself. Medical Examiners vs Coroners The person _______________________________________ to perform autopsies and determine cause of death may be either a medical examiner or a coroner. Medical examiners ___________________________________forensic pathologists Coroners __________________________________________ forensic pathologists, or they may be doctors with a different specialty (e.g. obstetrics), or they may not even have any medical training at all. Most counties have adopted the newer medical examiner system, but some rural areas still employ coroners. 1 Specialized forensic scientists - match the name with the job description Forensic pathologist Determines a person’s competency to stand trial, sign documents, or make medical decisions; determines motivation of suicide victims, and provides psychological profiles of suspects. Forensic anthropologist Gathers evidence from the body and/or living victims. Reviews medical records, witness statements, police reports, conducts autopsies, and determines cause of death. Forensic odontologist Examines plant fragments, pollen, or soil to place a suspect at a crime scene or to determine whether a body has been moved. Forensic entomology Determines the types of fluids present and matches samples of fluids to victims or suspects. Forensic psychiatrist Examines and identifies firearms, bullets, and shell casing, and searches for gun shot residue. Forensic serologist Examines finger, palm, and foot prints, and matches them to prints taken from suspects, other crime scenes, or databases. Forensic botanist Examines marks found on the crime scene and matches them to tools found with suspects. Crime scene investigator Uses insect larvae found in corpses to determine time of death and whether the body has been moved from one location to another Latent print examiner Determines the authenticity and authorship of various documents Firearms examiner Analyze and compare hair, fibers, glass, soils, and paints to determine their type and origin, and to place suspects at the crime scene Toolmark examiner Identifies unknown bodies by comparing teeth with dental records or matches a suspect’s teeth with bite marks on the victim or other evidence. Document examiner Collects, protects, and transports evidence from the crime scene to the crime lab. May also sketch and photograph the crime scene. Trace evidence examiner Examines skeletal remains to determine age, sex, and race of the deceased. May also identify types of injury / disease and establish time of death. Education and Salary of other specialties The ___________________________________________ (who study ____________________ evidence) typically all __________________________________________ (MD or Ph.D.). Salary: 50K – 100 K The ______________________ (who study _____________________________) usually require a ______________________________________________, though sometimes former police officers without formal degrees train for these specialties. Salary: 40K – 80K 2 Expert witnesses and the law In any case involving a death, the _______________________________ will testify Experts in other specialties may also be called to testify It is the ________________ who decides ___________________________ to be considered an expert and ______________________ they are allowed to present Legal precedent for expert witness testimony Frye vs. United States (1923) “Frye Standard”: expert testimony must be based on “______________________________ scientific principle” that is “________________________________” and has obtained “__________________________” in the scientific community Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceutical, Inc. (1993) “Rule 702” or “Daubert standard” Explicitly states that it is up to ______________________________ whether to allow testimony Offered judges the following guidelines for admissible techniques and theories subject to testing and __________________________ ___________________________ known __________________________ Attained widespread _______________________ How do these two standards differ? Other rules for expert witness testimony Expert witnesses are ______________________ before the jury What does this mean? Experts testify as to their ______________________, ___________________, and ____________________________ before presenting evidence. Because they must explain complicated information, expert witnesses have much greater freedom in how they testify (i.e. they can _______________________, rather than just _____________________ __________________________________) 3 TYPES OF EVIDENCE GUIDED NOTES Evidence is something that _______________________________________________________ Types of Evidence – Direct vs. Indirect __________________________ - Evidence that establishes a fact ______________________________ ___________________________ Example: ______________________________________ ___________________________________ / circumstantial evidence - Evidence that only provides a ___________________________________ about a fact Example: _________________________________________ Direct or Indirect? Soil matching a crime location found on a suspect’s clothing Possession of an illegal substance Video of a person committing a crime Fingerprint at crime scene Fingerprints on the murder weapon DNA match to skin under victim’s fingernails ** Some people argue that ____________________________ are direct evidence** When could you argue that fingerprints on the murder weapon are direct evidence? When could you argue that fingerprints on the murder weapon are indirect evidence? What about skin under the victim’s fingernails? When is it direct? When is it indirect? Types of Evidence – Testimonial vs Documentary vs Physical Testimonial evidence -- _________________________________ Documentary evidence - _________________________ relevant to a crime Example: audio / video / written documents Physical evidence -- any object or material relevant to a crime 4 Which type of evidence? DVD stolen from a store Surveillance video of a robbery Crime scene photographs Which is kind of evidence is best? _______________________________________________________________________ Problems with eye-witness accounts Most cases of wrongful imprisonment are due to mistaken eyewitness identification! Eye witnesses may be wrong for many reasons: Age / eyesight / hearing / alcohol or drugs Stress / fear can focus and alter perceptions Encounters may be brief or take place under poor conditions New information may alter memories Physical Evidence Although ________________________, physical evidence is more reliable than eyewitness accounts. With enough physical evidence, a strong case can be made. Locard’s Exchange Principle: “______________________________________________” Every time someone goes some where, they leave behind physical evidence, and pick up evidence from their environment. trace What can physical evidence show? It can ______________________________ at a the crime scene or with the victim It can help _______________________________ (for example, blood splatter can indicate the relative position of two people) Can ___________________________________ / indicate that crime took place (e.g. finding gasoline at a fire indicates arson) 5 The value of physical evidence The more unique or _______________________________ a piece of evidence is, the better its _______________________________________ – the stronger proof it provides. Example: Finding that a suspect has the same brand of duct tape that was used in a crime is ok evidence. BUT, if the torn end of the duct tape used in a crime exactly matches the torn end of the suspect’s role, that is much better evidence. Describing Evidence Determine whether each type of evidence listed below is direct or indirect, physical or testimonial. For physical evidence, also describe additional details that might individualize the evidence and/or increase its probative value. Survelliance camera videotape of a crime Written contract Blood stained clothing Eyewitness account Hair found at the crime scene 6