The Changing Nature of Marketing: Implications for Research, Teaching and Practice Yoram (Jerry) Wind The Lauder Professor Professor of Marketing Director, SEI Center for Advanced Studies in Management Academic Director, Wharton Fellows Program The Wharton School Elsevier Science Distinguished Scholar Award Lecture Society for Marketing Advances New Orleans, November 6, 2003 1 AGENDA I. The Changing Business Environment 2 AGENDA I. The Changing Business Environment II. The Changing Nature of Marketing 3 AGENDA I. The Changing Business Environment II. The Changing Nature of Marketing III. Implications for Research IV. Implications for Teaching/ Learning V. Implications for Practice 4 AGENDA I. The Changing Business Environment II. The Changing Nature of Marketing III. Implications for Research IV. Implications for Teaching/ Learning V. Implications for Practice VI. Personal Implications and Next Steps 5 I. The Changing Business Environment • Globalization; The 86% Opportunities… 6 I. The Changing Business Environment • • Globalization; The 86% Opportunities The Turbulent Economy 7 I. The Changing Business Environment • • • Globalization; The 86% Opportunities; Outsourcing The Turbulent Economy Terrorist Threats; Wars; Anti US Feelings 8 I. The Changing Business Environment • • • • Globalization; The 86% Opportunities; Outsourcing The Turbulent Economy Terrorist Threats; Wars; Anti US Feelings The Internet.. 9 I. The Changing Business Environment • • • • • Globalization; The 86% Opportunities; Outsourcing The Turbulent Economy Terrorist Threats; Wars; Anti US Feelings The Internet.. Science and Technology 10 I. The Changing Business Environment • • • • • • Globalization; The 86% Opportunities; Outsourcing The Turbulent Economy Terrorist Threats; Wars; Anti US Feelings The Internet.. Science and Technology Demographics; Migration… 11 I. The Changing Business Environment • • • • • • • Globalization; The 86% Opportunities; Outsourcing The Turbulent Economy Terrorist Threats; Wars; Anti US Feelings The Internet.. Science and Technology Demographics; Migration… Consumers Life Styles, Expectations & Behavior… 12 I. The Changing Business Environment • • • • • • • • Globalization; The 86% Opportunities; Outsourcing The Turbulent Economy Terrorist Threats; Wars; Anti US Feelings The Internet.. Science and Technology Demographics; Migration… Consumers Life Styles, Expectations & Behavior… The Pressure of Wall St. Expectations.. 13 I. The Changing Business Environment • • • • • • • • • Globalization; The 86% Opportunities; Outsourcing The Turbulent Economy Terrorist Threats; Wars; Anti US Feelings The Internet.. Science and Technology Demographics Consumers Life Styles, Expectations & Behavior… The Pressure of Wall St. Expectations.. Business Models and Practices 14 I. The Changing Business Environment • • • • • • • • • • • Globalization; The 86% Opportunities; Outsourcing The Turbulent Economy Terrorist Threats; Wars; Anti US Feelings The Internet.. Science and Technology Demographics Consumers Life Styles, Expectations & Behavior The Pressure of Wall St. Expectations.. Business Models and Practices Increased Commoditization; Innovations 15 I. The Changing Business Environment • • • • • • • • • • • Globalization; The 86% Opportunities; Outsourcing The Turbulent Economy Terrorist Threats; Wars; Anti US Feelings The Internet.. Science and Technology Demographics Consumers Life Styles, Expectations & Behavior The Pressure of Wall St. Expectations.. Business Models and Practices Innovations Uncertainty, change, complexity… 16 Need to Reexamine our Mental Models Mental Models • • • • • • • • The 4 Minute Mile The Gorilla and the Ball The Ticketing Agent and the Counter Inner City vs. Emerging Domestic Markets Source: Wind & Crook with Gunther; Making Sense: What You See is What You Think and What You 17 Think is What You See; Wharton School Press 2004 Challenge your Mental Models It’s all about Mental Models – but which one? • What if People really are an asset & not an expense? Source: Wind, Crook and Gunther, Making Sense: What You See is What you Think, Wharton School Press, 2004 18 Challenge your Mental Models It’s all about Mental Models – but which one? • What if People really are an asset & not an expense? • What if inventory really is a liability & not an asset? Source: Wind, Crook and Gunther, Making Sense: What You See is What you Think, Wharton School Press, 2004 19 Challenge your Mental Models It’s all about Mental Models – but which one? • What if People really are an asset & not an expense? • What if inventory really is a liability & not an asset? • What if technology is expensed & not capitalized? Source: Wind, Crook and Gunther, Making Sense: What You See is What you Think, Wharton School Press, 2004 20 Challenge your Mental Models It’s all about Mental Models – but which one? • What if People really are an asset & not an expense? • What if inventory really is a liability & not an asset? • What if technology is expensed & not capitalized? • What if financial reporting is in real time & not quarterly & yearly? Source: Wind, Crook and Gunther, Making Sense: What You See is What you Think, Wharton School Press, 2004 21 Neuroscience – New Developments • We make sense of things, to a large degree, by what is already in our heads – “what we think is what we see, what we see is what we think” Source: Wind, Crook and Gunther, Making Sense: What You See is What you Think, Wharton School Press, 2004 22 Neuroscience – New Developments • We make sense of things, to a large degree, by what is already in our heads – “what we think is what we see, what we see is what we think” • Most of the optical input is discarded & replaced by our internal “mental models” (Walter Freeman University of California, Berkeley) Source: Wind, Crook and Gunther, Making Sense: What You See is What you Think, Wharton School Press, 2004 23 Neuroscience – New Developments • We make sense of things, to a large degree, by what is already in our heads – “what we think is what we see, what we see is what we think” • Most of the optical input is discarded & replaced by our internal “mental models” (Walter Freeman University of California, Berkeley) • Mental models are “reality” and are developed over time through experience, education & training. Source: Wind, Crook and Gunther, Making Sense: What You See is What you Think, Wharton School Press, 2004 24 The Process of Making Sense 1. Understand the power and limits of mental models 4. Transform your world by acting quickly and effectively upon the new models 2. Keep your models relevant 3. Overcome inhibitors to change by reshaping infrastructure and the thinking of others Source: Wind & Crook with Gunther; Making Sense: What You See is What You Think and What You 25 Think is What You See; Wharton School Press 2004 II. Illlustrative Changes in the Nature of Marketing 1. Market Driven Vision, Value Proposition and Objectives 26 The Key Premise of Market Driven Vision Customers Needs & Wants Products & Service Offerings Required Infrastructure, Processes… 27 The Key Premise of Market Driven Vision Customers Needs & Wants Products & Service Offerings AND Required Infrastructure, Processes… • Expanding the Role of the Customer from Passive Audience to “CoProducer” 28 The Key Premise of Market Driven Vision Customers Needs & Wants Products & Service Offerings AND Required Infrastructure, Processes… • Expanding the Role of the Customer from Passive Audience to “CoProducer” • Expanding the Focus of Marketing Strategy to Creating, Delivering and Sustaining Value 29 The Key Premise of Market Driven Vision Customers Needs & Wants Products & Service Offerings AND Required Infrastructure, Processes… • Expanding the Role of the Customer from Passive Audience to “CoProducer” • Expanding the Focus of Marketing Strategy to Creating, Delivering and Sustaining Value • Expanding the Focus from Customers to all Stakeholders 30 Marketing Driven Vision, Value Proposition and Objectives Total Financial/ Business Solution Price per Pill/ Discount Pills Total Integrated Wellness Solution 31 Marketing Driven Vision, Value Proposition and Objectives Total Financial/ Business Solution Price per Pill/ Discount Pills Total Integrated Wellness Solution Establish corporate objectives focused on share of wallet (and maximizing life time value of customers) vs. Market Share. Or Coca Cola’s share of all beverages vs. share of colas or Crest from toothpaste to “Happy Smiles for life”. 32 Marketing Driven Vision, Value Proposition and Objectives Total Financial/ Business Solution Price per Pill/ Discount Pills Total Integrated Wellness Solution Consider corporate objectives focused on share of wallet (and maximizing life time value of customers) vs. Market Share. Or Coca Cola’s share of all beverages vs. share of colas or Crest from toothpaste to “Happy Smiles for Life”. Establish measures of desired customer outcomes such as: Attraction, Retention, Share of Wallet, Up Price Tolerance, Down Price Impact… 33 Marketing Driven Vision, Value Proposition and Objectives Total Financial/ Business Solution Price per Pill/ Discount Pills Total Integrated Wellness Solution Establish corporate objectives focused on share of wallet (and maximizing life time value of customers) vs. Market Share. Or Coca Cola’s share of all beverages vs. share of colas or Crest from toothpaste to “Happy Smiles for Life”. Establish measures of desired customer outcomes such as: Attraction, Retention, Share of Wallet, Up Price Tolerance, Down Price Impact… Focus on ROMI and Market Driven Dashboards 34 II. Illlustrative Changes in the Nature of Marketing 1. 2. Market Driven Vision, Value Proposition and Objectives Marketing Innovations… 35 Illustrative Marketing Innovations… • • • • • • • Segments of one… Emotional based positioning “Guerilla Marketing” / “Buzz Marketing” - Red Bull New Business Models – RyanAir Dynamic Pricing – Priceline.com The rise of the auctions – e-Bay Marketing built into the product experience – Seth Godin “Purple Cow” and “99 Cows” • Innovative distribution – Costco, Amazon, Home Depot… • Creating WOM - BuzzAgent • • 36 Illustrative DASHBOARD of a High Tech Company Shareholder Value Financial Performance Brand Equity Corporate Reputation Marketing Relationship Employee Satisfaction Brand Perception Customer Experience Brand Promise 37 II. Illlustrative Changes in the Nature of Marketing 1. 2. 3. Market Driven Vision, Value Proposition and Objectives Marketing Innovations… Technology, Marketing and the Power of Convergence. 38 The Power of Convergence Mastering the 5 C’s of Convergence Marketing Source: Wind, Mahajan & Gunther, Convergence Marketing, Financial Times Prentice Hall, 2001 39 The Power of Convergence Mastering the 5 C’s of Convergence Marketing Converging on Customerization and Personalization: Make it mine Source: Wind, Mahajan & Gunther, Convergence Marketing, Financial Times Prentice Hall, 2001 40 The Power of Convergence Mastering the 5 C’s of Convergence Marketing Converging on Customerization and Personalization: Make it mine Converging on Communities: Let me be a part of it Source: Wind, Mahajan & Gunther, Convergence Marketing, Financial Times Prentice Hall, 2001 41 The Power of Convergence Mastering the 5 C’s of Convergence Marketing Converging on Customerization and Personalization: Make it mine Converging on Communities: Let me be a part of it Converging on Channels: I want to call, click and visit Source: Wind, Mahajan & Gunther, Convergence Marketing, Financial Times Prentice Hall, 2001 42 The Power of Convergence Mastering the 5 C’s of Convergence Marketing Converging on Customerization and Personalization: Make it mine Converging on Communities: Let me be a part of it Converging on Competitive Value: Give me more for my money Converging on Channels: I want to call, click and visit Source: Wind, Mahajan & Gunther, Convergence Marketing, Financial Times Prentice Hall, 2001 43 The Power of Convergence Mastering the 5 C’s of Convergence Marketing Converging on Customerization and Personalization: Make it mine Converging on Choice: Give me tools to make better decisions Converging on Competitive Value: Give me more for my money Converging on Communities: Let me be a part of it Converging on Channels: I want to call, click and visit Source: Wind, Mahajan & Gunther, Convergence Marketing, Financial Times Prentice Hall, 2001 44 II. Illlustrative Changes in the Nature of Marketing 1. 2. 3. 4. Market Driven Vision, Value Proposition and Objectives Marketing Innovations… Technology, Marketing and the Power of Convergence Marketing Science – Data Mining, Experiments… 45 Marketing Science – Data Mining, Experiments… • Advances in Marketing Research and Modeling • The proliferation of DATA Mining • DSS & Corporate Dashboards • Dynamic Resource Allocation • Experiments, Adaptive Experimentation, and the creation of a “sense and respond” organization 46 II. Illlustrative Changes in the Nature of Marketing 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Market Driven Vision, Value Proposition and Objectives Marketing Innovations… Technology, Marketing and the Power of Convergence Marketing Science – Data Mining, Experiments… The Focus on Customer Experience 47 The Focus on Customer Experience Products 48 The Focus on Customer Experience Products Product and Service 49 The Focus on Customer Experience Products Product and Service Product and Service Solution 50 The Focus on Customer Experience Products Product and Service Product and Service Solution Total interactive experience… 51 II. Illlustrative Changes in the Nature of Marketing 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Market Driven Vision, Value Proposition and Objectives Marketing Innovations… Technology, Marketing and the Power of Convergence Marketing Science – Data Mining, Experiments… The Focus on Customer Experience Marketing and the Impact of X-Functional Integration 52 Marketing and the Impact of X-Functional Integration There are no Marketing problems, only business problems involving Marketing, Operations, Finance, Human Resources,… 53 Marketing and the Impact of X-Functional Integration There are no Marketing problems, only business problems involving Marketing, Operations, Finance, Human Resources,… Illustrative forces: • ERP, CRM, Integrated Supply Chain… 54 Marketing and the Impact of X-Functional Integration There are no Marketing problems, only business problems involving Marketing, Operations, Finance, Human Resources,… Illustrative forces: • ERP, CRM, Integrated Supply Chain… • New Product, Market and Business Development… 55 Marketing and the Impact of X-Functional Integration There are no Marketing problems, only business problems involving Marketing, Operations, Finance, Human Resources,… Illustrative forces: • ERP, CRM, Integrated Supply Chain… • New Product, Market and Business Development… • The importance of service quality and response time throughout the life of the “product”.. 56 Marketing and the Impact of X-Functional Integration There are no Marketing problems, only business problems involving Marketing, Operations, Finance, Human Resources,… Illustrative forces: • ERP, CRM, Integrated Supply Chain… • New Product, Market and Business Development… • The importance of service quality and response time throughout the life of the “product”.. • Turning customer service into a profitable sales engine… The Wharton X-Functional Integration Initiatives… 57 The Wharton X-Functional Integration Initiatives • CEO Panel… • Natural Points of Linkages • Creating New Interdisciplinary Offerings – Marketing & STAT – Marketing & Operations – Marketing & Accounting – • Projects • Curriculum Navigator • • 58 II. Illlustrative Changes in the Nature of Marketing 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Market Driven Vision, Value Proposition and Objectives Marketing Innovations… Technology, Marketing and the Power of Convergence Marketing Science – Data Mining, Experiments… The Focus on Customer Experience Marketing and the Impact of X-Functional Integration From Passive Consumers and Stakeholders to Advocates… 59 From Passive Consumers and Stakeholders to Advocates… • From Passive to Active Audiences…From CRM to CMR 60 From Passive Consumers and Stakeholders to Advocates… • From Passive to Active Audiences…From CRM to CMR • In search of “partners” (in development…) 61 From Passive Consumers and Stakeholders to Advocates… • From Passive to Active Audiences…From CRM to CMR • In search of “partners” (in development…) • From customers satisfaction to customer reference-ability and advocacy 62 From Passive Consumers and Stakeholders to Advocates… • From Passive to Active Audiences…From CRM to CMR • In search of “partners” (in development…) • From customers satisfaction to customer reference-ability and advocacy • From narrow focus on customers to stakeholders • • 63 II. Illlustrative Changes in the Nature of Marketing 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Market Driven Vision, Value Proposition and Objectives Marketing Innovations… Technology, Marketing and the Power of Convergence Marketing Science – Data Mining, Experiments… The Focus on Customer Experience Marketing and the Impact of X-Functional Integration From Passive Consumers and Stakeholders to Advocates… Marketing as the Engine of Growth 64 Marketing as the Engine of Growth Increasingly the Role of Marketing is Viewed as: • Driving the creation of value through the development of relationship with customers and with those whose decisions influence and shape the environment in which we work (BP Amaco). 65 Marketing as the Engine of Growth Increasingly the Role of Marketing is Viewed as: • Driving the creation of value through the development of relationship with customers and with those whose decisions influence and shape the environment in which we work (BP Amaco). • Growing profitability, building brand equity, creating customer centric culture (PNC) 66 Marketing as the Engine of Growth Increasingly the Role of Marketing is Viewed as: • Driving the creation of value through the development of relationship with customers and with those whose decisions influence and shape the environment in which we work (BP Amaco). • Growing profitability, building brand equity, creating customer centric culture (PNC) • Driving Growth (ARAMARK) 67 Marketing as the Engine of Growth Increasingly the Role of Marketing is Viewed as: • Driving the creation of value through the development of relationship with customers and with those whose decisions influence and shape the environment in which we work (BP Amaco). • Growing profitability, building brand equity, creating customer centric culture (PNC) • Driving Growth (ARAMARK) • Creating and building leadership brands consumers love (P&G) 68 Marketing as the Engine of Growth Increasingly the Role of Marketing is Viewed as: • Driving the creation of value through the development of relationship with customers and with those whose decisions influence and shape the environment in which we work (BP Amaco). • Growing profitability, building brand equity, creating customer centric culture (PNC) • Driving Growth (ARAMARK) • Creating and building leadership brands consumers love (P&G) • Leading the continued transformation of the company (Samsung) 69 III. Implications 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Market Driven Vision, Value Proposition and Objectives Marketing Innovations… Technology, Marketing and the Power of Convergence Marketing Science – Data Mining, Experiments… The Focus on Customer Experience Marketing and the Impact of X-Functional Integration From Passive Consumers and Stakeholders to Advocates… Marketing as the Engine of Growth • For Research • For Teaching/Learning • For Practice Research Implications and Next Steps… 70 III. Implications for Research 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Market Driven Vision, Value Proposition and Objectives Marketing Innovations… Technology, Marketing and the Power of Convergence Marketing Science – Data Mining, Experiments… The Focus on Customer Experience Marketing and the Impact of X-Functional Integration From Passive Consumers and Stakeholders to Advocates… Marketing as the Engine of Growth 1. 2. 3. Objective Scope Application Bridging the Silos of: • Secondary and Primary Research • Qualitative and Quantitative • Research and Modeling • Customers and Intermediaries • Individuals and the Unit of Analysis • Brand/Marketing and Top Management • Marketing decisions and Business decisions • Static measures & data and Dynamic Reality • Research Implications and Next Steps… 71 IV. Implications for Teaching/ Learning 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Market Driven Vision, Value Proposition and Objectives Marketing Innovations… Technology, Marketing and the Power of Convergence Marketing Science – Data Mining, Experiments… The Focus on Customer Experience Marketing and the Impact of XFunctional Integration From Passive Consumers and Stakeholders to Advocates… Marketing as the Engine of Growth Toward a New Learning Paradigm Time and Place 72 The New Management Education Paradigm Facilitated by the Advances in Information Technology Mode of Learning Interactive Learning Involving Real World Task Mostly Passive Standardized Educational Content Customized Discrete Time and Place Time and Place Any Time and Place 73 V. Implications for Management Practice 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Market Driven Vision, Value Proposition and Objectives Marketing Innovations… Technology, Marketing and the Power of Convergence Marketing Science – Data Mining, Experiments… The Focus on Customer Experience Marketing and the Impact of XFunctional Integration From Passive Consumers and Stakeholders to Advocates… Marketing as the Engine of Growth • Are you focused on blockbuster brands? • Do you have an integrated total marketing strategy? • Do you have an integrated stakeholder strategy? • Is your marketing investments necessary for long term growth? • In hard times, do you cut your marketing budget? • • The Power of Integration… 74 Toward an Integrated Marketing Strategy: Leveraging the Power of Synergy An Illustrative Pharmaceutical Example Toward Integrated Brand Promise • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Product Design Packaging ADV DM Web Collateral Sales force Trade Show PR Sponsorship POS Cause Related Marketing WOM… Toward Integrated Customer Experience • • • • Bridging the Brand Silos Bridging Products, Service & Information Toward Integrated Stakeholder Solutions • • • • • • • • • Physicians Patients Payers Hospitals Pharmacists Influencials/O.L. Media 75 V. Implications for Management Practice • • • • • • • • Market Driven Vision, Value Proposition and Objectives Marketing Innovations… Technology, Marketing and the Power of Convergence Marketing Science – Data Mining, Experiments… The Focus on Customer Experience Marketing and the Impact of X-Functional Integration From Passive Consumers and Stakeholders to Advocates… Marketing as the Engine of Growth Scenarios [Market Driven] Vision [Market Driven] Business Paradigm and Value Proposition [Market Driven] Objectives [Marketing Driven] Strategy [Market Driven] Organizational Architecture Implementation 76 Organizational Architecture Organizational Culture and Value Structure Processes •Vision • Business model and value proposition • Objectives • Strategies The Organizational Stakeholders: Customers Employees Shareholders Partners Suppliers Communities Government Other Location and Facilities Performance measures and incentives Technology Resources People and Competencies • The Emergence of the CMO • The decline of the marketing function and the emergence of a Marketing Driven Organization • The Emergence of Marketing Networks • The Emergence of Outsourcing • • 77 VI. Personal Implications and Next Steps • • • • • • 78 And Framing the Next Steps in the Context of MSI’s Priorities • • • • Return on Marketing Branding Growth, Innovation, and New Products Understanding Customers 79 Next Steps: My Recommendations 1. Challenge your Mental Models 80 Next Steps: My Recommendations 1. Challenge your Mental Models 2. Search for Balance of the old & the new…the quantitative and the qualitative 81 Next Steps: My Recommendations 1. Challenge your Mental Models 2. Search for Balance of the old & the new…the quantitative and the qualitative 3. Focus on Metrics 82 Next Steps: My Recommendations 1. Challenge your Mental Models 2. Search for Balance of the old & the new…the quantitative and the qualitative 3. Focus on Metrics 4. Focus on Integration and on Bridging the Silos 83 Next Steps: My Recommendations 1. Challenge your Mental Models 2. Search for Balance of the old & the new…the quantitative and the qualitative 3. Focus on Metrics 4. Focus on Integration and on Bridging the Silos 5. Experiment, Experiment, Experiment 84 Next Steps: My Recommendations 1. Challenge your Mental Models 2. Search for Balance of the old & the new…the quantitative and the qualitative 3. Focus on Metrics 4. Focus on Integration and on Bridging the Silos 5. Experiment, Experiment, Experiment 6. Develop the Needed New Capabilities 85 Next Steps: My Recommendations 1. Challenge your Mental Models 2. Search for Balance of the old & the new…the quantitative and the qualitative 3. Focus on Metrics 4. Focus on Integration and on Bridging the Silos 5. Experiment, Experiment, Experiment 6. Develop the Needed New Capabilities 7. Have Passion, Energize and Have Fun 86 87 88 89 90