University of Jordan
Deanship of Academic Research
Academic Research Council
Form 1-D-Journal: Evaluation Form for the Purpose of Academic Promotion
(Journal Paper Evaluation)
No.: ……………….
Date: ……………….
Reviewer name:
Reviewer address:
Based on your reputation and experience in your specialization field it’s my pleasure to send you a
copy of the entitled research
(
That published in the journal entitled with
(
)
)
Which is presented by a member of the academic staff at the University of Jordan for promotion.
And because paragraph (B) (26) from the Instructions of academic staff at the University of Jordan
states that there’s no academic production for promotion means should be accepted unless it’s being
reviewed first. So I’m sending you a copy of the mentioned research hoping that you would give us
your opinion and review in the light of the reviewing elements of journals at the Deanship of Academic
Research at the University of Jordan. And please let us know if the suggested outputs of the researcher
can be accepted for promotion means.
I appreciate your academic position and hope that your review will be based on the form, making sure
to send it back as soon as possible. Your review will be dealt with in secrecy without mentioning your
name or place of work.
Sending you my thanks and appreciation. And as an appreciation for your efforts in enriching the
academic conferences, the University will be giving you a symbolic reward (60) JD or what equals it for
doing this work.
Dean of Deanship of Academic Research
Prof. Abeer Fayez Al-Bawab
Tel: (962-6)5355000 Fax: (962-6) 5355599 Amman 11942 Jordan
‫الجامعة األردنية‬
‫عمادة البحث العلمي‬
‫مجلس البحث العلمي‬
‫ م‬- ‫ د‬-1 ‫نموذج رقم‬
Date: …………….
Title of research
Reviewing the research published in journals
Elements of reviewing
20%
1.
The extent to which the paper conforms to
recent information in terms of adequacy and
modernization
2.
The extent to which the paper adds genuine
information to the linguistic inquiry
3.
The extent to which the author succeeds in
explaining his paper properly
4.
The extent to which the information involved is
needed
5.
The extent to which the paper is free of either
scientific or edited errors
6.
The extent to which subjects of the paper are
harmonic with one another
7.
Does the paper attract many researchers?
8.
The extent to which figures, tables, etc are used
9.
Does the paper deliver the main concern for
which it was written?
40%
60%
80%
100%
Reviewer’s opinion
General Assessment of published research
(% mark should be placed inside square)
Accept the research for purposes of
promotion
%
:‫التقدير العام للبحث‬
)‫(توضع النسبة المئوية في داخل المربع‬
Yes
‫نعم‬
No
‫ال‬
Yes
‫نعم‬
No
‫ال‬
Accept the research for purposes of promotion
if it gets the 75% mark or above
The research is unique
Accept the research for purposes of promotion
if it gets the 90% mark or above
‫الجامعة األردنية‬
‫عمادة البحث العلمي‬
‫مجلس البحث العلمي‬
‫ م‬- ‫ د‬-1 ‫نموذج رقم‬
Date: …………
Do you consider the published research to be distinguished? Justify:
Further suggestions that may improve the level of the published research
Other remarks
‫الجامعة األردنية‬
‫عمادة البحث العلمي‬
‫مجلس البحث العلمي‬
‫ م‬- ‫ د‬-1 ‫نموذج رقم‬
Date: …………
Reviewer Data
Name
(English)
…………………………………
…………
(P.O. Box)
Telephone
…………
No. (Home)
(Fax)
…………
(Affiliation)
‫بيانات المقوم‬
…………
(City)
………….
(Postal
Code)
Telephone No.
(Office)
(E-mail)
…………
(College)
…………
(Reviewer’s Signature)
……….. (Country) ………….
…………
(Mobile)
……………………………………
Date
Remarks:
1. This report should be comprehensive, detailed
and typewritten.
2. Additional relevant comments, suggestions or
criticism would be appreciated.
3. For your convenience, you may fill and submit
this form electronically at the web site:
http://research.ju.edu.jo
‫االسم‬
)‫(عربي‬
…………………………………
(Department)
…………
…………
:‫مالحظات‬
.ً‫ يجب أن يكون هذا التقرير شامالً ومفصالً ومطبوعا‬.1
‫ نرحب بأي تعليقات أو اقتراحات أو انتقادات إضافية لها عالقة‬.2
. ‫بموضوع البحث‬
:‫ يمكنكم تعبئة النموذج وإرساله إلكترونيا ً من خالل الموقع‬.3
http://research .ju.edu.jo
Tel: (962-6)5355000 Fax: (962-6) 5300815 Amman 11942 Jordan
Email: research@ju.edu.jo
http://research.ju.edu.jo