The Business Skills Handbook The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development The Business Skills Handbook Leadership Skills Week 18 The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Reading Recommended text: The Business Skills Handbook Horn, R. London: CIPD 1st edition, 2009 ISBN: 1843982188 Chapter 18: Leadership, Coaching and Mentoring Skills (page 451) The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Lecture Outline understanding and using management the characteristics of management work practical management skills understanding the nature of leadership trait leadership skills behavioural leadership skills The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Learning Objectives understand and use the distinction between management and leadership understand the aspects of managing develop different ways of leading The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management The two terms leadership and management are often used as if they are the same thing – they are not. You will need to have the distinction clear if you are to lead groups and teams effectively. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management [2] Let’s look at management first. Management is the control and direction of people and resources to achieve the agreed vision and objectives of the organisation. This is a very important function of business, but it is different from leadership. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management [3] In your business career your first steps are very likely to be as a manager. So what do managers do? What should managers do? The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management [4] Henry Mintzberg has had a major and enduring impact on the nature of management since his book, The Nature of Managerial Work, was published in 1973. There have been numerous add-ins to the basic ideas over the years. There has also been extensive research and investigation looking at the nature of the manager’s work. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management [5] One of the basic building blocks of Mintzberg’s beliefs, and a major driver for this book, is that management is the applying of human skills to organisational systems. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management [6] His much published and reiterated paper, ‘The Manager’s Job: Folklore and Fact’ (1975), exposes the constant pressure managers feel, the push to do too much work, respond too quickly and deal with interruptions. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management [7] Mintzberg expresses the manager’s job in six characteristics and ten roles. The characteristics of management work are: Management tasks are a mixture of regular, programmed jobs and unprogrammed tasks. Management tasks require both generalist and specialist skills. Managers seek information from all sources but show a preference for that which is orally transmitted. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management [8] Managerial work is made up of tasks and activities that are characterised by brevity, variety and fragmentation. Management work is more an art than a science and is reliant on intuitive processes and a ‘feel’ for what is right. Management work is becoming more complex. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management [9] The ten roles that make up the content of the manager's job are: Interpersonal figurehead – performing symbolic duties as a representative of the organisation leader – establishing the atmosphere and motivating subordinates networker – developing and maintaining webs of contacts, both inside and outside the organisation The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management [10] Information monitor – collecting all types of information that are relevant and useful to the organisation disseminator – transmitting information from outside the organisation to those inside spokesman – transmitting information from inside the organisation to outsiders The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management [11] Decision-making entrepreneur – initiating change and adapting to the environment disturbance-handler – dealing with unexpected events resource-allocator – deciding on the use of the organisation’s resources negotiator – negotiating with individuals and dealing with other organisations The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management [12] You can probably see from Mintzberg’s early work that management is a function that organises and executes the organisation’s effort. Traditionally we teach management rather like it is a science. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management [13] Management skills are acquired by training, education and practice. Management skills are applied by understanding vision, people, team dynamics, creativity and empathy. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management [14] Practical management involves using scarce resources and making the most of those resources. In modern business there are always scarce resources. There is never enough: time, finance, people, expertise, raw material or knowledge. How you argue for and use the resources that are made available to you will be the measure of your success. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management in Practice If you are new to management, you may wonder what you will do all day. The following is a list of managerial activities that I have put together from my own experience and the experience of managers I have known. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management in Practice [2] Organising – designing processes, procedures and practices for others to follow Analysing – investigating things and discovering the various aspects of those things and how they currently fit and work together The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management in Practice [3] Evaluating – assessing whether people, processes, resources and other things are operating effectively Planning – setting out the steps that individuals and teams need to take to get something done. This includes short-term planning of activities covering days, weeks, months, and long-term planning covering months and years. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management in Practice [4] Financial aspects – arguing for resources, budgeting for those resources and accounting for what has been spent and what has been produced; also, costing goods and service Motivating – talking to teams and individuals to inspire and motivate them The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management in Practice [5] Monitoring – checking the progress of products and services to ensure targets are met; also, checking on the actions and outcomes of people Negotiating – discussions and actions that resolve conflict, agree ways forward, sort out problems, and so on The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management in Practice [6] Providing – all teams and employees need things to do their work. As a manager you will spend a lot of time negotiating what is needed and arranging for the necessary things to be provided at the right time. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management in Practice [7] Paperwork – recording and requesting actions required by the organisation in paper or electronic form. As one anonymous airline manager remarked, ‘I never knew how much paper it took to get a plane in the air.’ The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Management in Practice [8] This is a very general idea of the types of activity you can expect to do when you become a manager. As with all assertions, challenge and probe my version of what management involves. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Leadership Leadership is about creating a vision and direction for people. This is in contrast to management, which is concerned with organising and directing individuals and teams to achieve agreed organisational objectives related to an organisational vision. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Leadership [2] The two roles of leader and manager are nearly always intertwined. One cannot exist without the other. So while you will be expected to manage the day-to-day aspects of getting things done, you will also need to create some vision, focus and direction for your staff. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Leadership [3] This can be on a small scale, where small teams need to understand, to see, what has to be done. It can also be on a grand scale, where you are leading a whole organisation or group of organisations. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Leadership [4] Leadership styles can vary greatly and there is no ‘right’ or ‘wrong’ way to lead. You will develop your own leadership style in time, but to begin with I will consider some of the well-known approaches. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Trait Leadership Trait leadership approaches are grounded on the idea that leaders contain a set of traits and behaviours that could be studied and emulated by others. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Trait Leadership [2] You may have already noticed that at university and work there are some people that seem to have natural leadership qualities. People just seem to accept them as leaders and want to be led by them. So we seem to know leadership when we see it. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Trait Leadership [3] However, if I ask you to set down what it is that makes a good leader, you might struggle to come up with a clear list of things. What makes a good leader ? The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Trait Leadership [4] When it comes to studying leadership traits we could adopt the approach of looking at great leaders and then seeing how the majority of leaders measure up. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Trait Leadership [5] Alternatively, we could look at everyday leaders and see what traits they have that make them effective. The problem with great leaders is that they are often individual and the traits they display are rather rare in practical leading. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Trait Leadership [6] So let’s try to come up with a list of traits that could make you an effective leader. What are traits of good leaders? The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Trait Leadership [7] I think you will have found a massive amount of traits that indicate a good leader. I also expect that there was very little agreement between different authorities. If you focus on the more researched and evidenced sources, you may have found a similar list of traits to what follows. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Trait Leadership [8] Traits of leaders – a synthesis energy, vitality and enthusiasm honest and trustworthy able to see the big picture – vision good at doing things – task competence within specialist areas understands and accepts team and individual needs, wants and desires The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Trait Leadership [9] skilful person-handler, negotiator and conflict-handler effective decision-maker inspires and motivates courage and stickability values diversity The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Trait Leadership [10] achievement driven intelligence accepts responsibility and remains calm under pressure self-confident and self-aware. but also balanced, humble and modest assertive and can lead from the front The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Trait Leadership [11] supportive and can lead from the rear adaptable, flexible and can handle change consistency a good listener The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Behavioural Leadership Behavioural leadership moves on from the traits of leaders to the behaviour of leaders. The focus of this approach is how leaders behave towards those they lead. The different patterns of behaviour are grouped together into styles of leadership. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Behavioural Leadership [2] The most popular of these styles is the managerial grid (Blake and Mouton 1978). The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Behavioural Leadership [3] The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Behavioural Leadership [4] The managerial grid is based on only two dimensions. These are: Concern for people – this represents the degree to which the leader considers the needs and wants of the team. Low implies that the leader gives no concern for the people in the team and high implies that the leader considers and acts on the needs the team. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Behavioural Leadership [5] Concern for production – is the degree that the leader is concerned with achieving concrete outcomes. Low implies little concern for the productive output and high means the leader is fully focused on achieving agreed outcomes. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Behavioural Leadership [6] If you plot any one person on these two dimensions, you come up with one of Blake and Mouton’s five leadership styles. Working from the bottom left corner of the figure we have: The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Behavioural Leadership [7] Impoverished Leadership – Low Production/Low People The leader has little concern for either production or people. The work environment is neither personally pleasant and satisfying nor high achieving. This style of leadership is likely to create a demotivated workforce that achieves very little. If this characterises your work group, you make need to look at and change your leadership style. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Behavioural Leadership [8] Produce or Perish – High Production/Low People This style is also known as leadership compliance style – ‘do what you are told’. This style of leader believes that people are just like any other resource and are there to produce output. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Behavioural Leadership [9] This style of leader is autocratic with strict rules about working. There will be very little social interaction between team members during work hours. Their management style will punish inappropriate work behaviours as the way to motivate staff. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Behavioural Leadership [10] Middle of the Road Management – Medium Production/Medium People This style of leader balances the needs of the people carrying out the work with the need to achieve and produce. The compromise of balancing the two foci means that leaders using this style will not produce high-performance teams. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Behavioural Leadership [11] The compromises create this middle ground position where teams are satisfied and production is average. When you first search for your own leadership style, it is this position that is often taken until you develop more experience. This middle ground position is not a bad style to adopt for new leaders because they can build on the people and task focus to improve the performance of the team. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Behavioural Leadership [12] Country Club Management – Low Production/High People The leader using this style puts the greatest emphasis on the well-being, needs and feelings of the team. The basic managerial assumption is that if the team is happy, the productive output will be high. This is often wrong! The team is happy and interacts well but it is at the expense of production. So the team likes working under this style of management but does not work as hard as they could. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Behavioural Leadership [13] Team Leadership – High Production/High People This is the most desired leadership style as it produces happy teams that produce high outputs. Employees’ views and needs are canvassed and acted upon but in the context of producing high outputs. Team members are likely to be fully involved in the management process. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Behavioural Leadership [14] The leader maximises both the people focus and the productive output by skilled interventions. While you may desire to use this leadership style, it is not easy to achieve. The main difficulty is to balance the team needs and involvement with maximum output. Teams operating under this style of leadership are likely to trust the leader and the leader will trust the team. The team will be happy, motivated and focused on production. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Behavioural Leadership [15] The managerial grid is a practical and useful way to focus on your own leadership style. A weakness is that it only focuses on two dimensions of a very complex process. It does however allow you to diagnose your own style and work towards something more desirable. It is not too difficult to create other two-dimensional tables that focus on your own precise leadership context. The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Activity Case Study Preparation Zulu computers 120 minutes’ prep 5 minutes’ feedback Feedback to the group – answers to the four tasks The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development Next Week • the skills required to manage a traditional career • the skills required in modern careers: protean and portfolio • understand career theory • strategies for making the transition into a career The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development The Business Skills Handbook The End The Business Skills Handbook Roy Horn - Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development