Happy Planners How to make sure your advisers stick around June 2011 Prepared by Coredata About CoreData CoreData is an Australian based market intelligence and research consultancy specialising in financial services. The group provides clients with market intelligence, guidance on strategic positioning, methods for developing new business, advice on operational marketing and other consulting services. We pride ourselves on our ability to: identify market trends at the earliest opportunity formulate insightful quantifiable research bring deep market knowledge to research and strategy development blend experienced financial services, research, marketing and media professionals bring perspective to existing market conditions and evolving trends. Prepared by Coredata 2 Where Does CoreData Operate? Prepared by Coredata Sampling Prepared by Coredata What We’ll Talk About Today • Background and methodology: Licensee Research • Key Insights: 1. Shape of the industry 2. What advisers want 3. And the winner is… • Wrap Up/Q&A Prepared by Coredata 5 About the Licensee Research CoreData’s annual licensee study aims to deliver financial planning dealer groups key insight into the evolving needs and demands of financial advisers and outlines the specific triggers influencing them to join/leave a given licensee. It assesses the ability of dealer groups to attract and retain quality financial advisers in the Australian financial services market. The research provides insight into the shifting demands of financial advisers and their overall satisfaction with their licensee across a broad range of areas. Prepared by Coredata 6 Research Context methodology sample segmentation period Prepared by Coredata Online survey sent to CoreData’s adviser database (1,558 respondents). Total sample: 966 financial advisers & 592 practice principals By licensee versus the industry and by adviser behavioural profile. Year-on-year comparisons provide a view as to the trends in the market and how the industry is shifting. March 2011 7 STAR Index - Internal Quantitative adviser ratings within the following subsets Support Depth and quality of compliance support Extent of practice management support We will also separately assess value of marketing and technical support Trade Mark Brand Adviser opinion towards operating under their dealer brand Adviser perception towards each licensee brand Weighting given to branding importance by advisers Autonomy Range of available investment and administration products Adviser opinion on levels of bureaucracy in the dealer group Perceived independence of dealer group Revenues Existing income structure of licensee (benchmarked against broader industry) Satisfaction levels of planners with remuneration Prepared by Coredata 8 STAR Index - External Quantitative external adviser ratings within the following subsets Support Perceptions of depth and quality of compliance, practice management, marketing and all types of support of dealers Trade Mark Brand External adviser opinion on pros/cons of operating under each licensee How important is branding per se to external advisers Autonomy Industry view as to the range of investment products available Adviser perceptions as to the levels of bureaucracy in the dealer External opinions on the independence of the licensee Revenues Prepared by Coredata Comparison of all income structures of industry advisers Comparison of the attitudes of each licensee’s advisers towards remuneration levels vs the broader industry 9 Key Insights 1. Shape of the industry 2. What advisers want 3. And the winner is… Prepared by Coredata 10 Commission Still Relied Upon By Many Which of the following are a part of the remuneration model you operate under? Prepared by Coredata How do your clients pay you for the financial advice they receive? 11 Things Will Have To Change… Approximately how many clients do you have? • On average advisers oversee 300 clients, a reduction on 2010 (360) but still too many to service in an Opt-in environment. Prepared by Coredata What percentage of these would you personally meet with at least once a year? • On average, advisers meet with just three in five clients in person at least annually (58.3%). 12 The Success Of Diversified Businesses Which of the following advisory services do you offer clients? Have you experienced profit growth in your business in the past 12 months? By Services offered cluster • Those businesses offering the four key pillars plus either SMSFs, direct equities or direct property are more likely to have experienced profit growth both in 2010 and 2011. Prepared by Coredata 13 Profit Growth Up, But Loyalty Down Profit growth & industry sentiment towards their licensee • Profit growth is on a strong upwards trend, yet loyalty at an industry level is declining, suggesting that advisers’ focus has shifted beyond survival mode and they are now focusing on their future. Prepared by Coredata 14 An Industry Divided Fee driven generalists Remuneration Charging method Years as an adviser Number of clients Client contact FUA Average FUA per client Licensee helps you develop your business Licensee focused on your needs Most upfront & ongoing fees from clients & revenue from Investment/Risk products Mostly fees based on a percentage of assets (74.6%) and fees determined by the service provider (51.7%) Slightly more experienced (21.8% have advised for 21 years or more) Slightly likely to have larger client base (33.2% > 300) More likely to be Salary/ Bonus Stretched risk specialist More likely to get revenue from Investment/Risk products Unloved disengaged More likely to be on Salary Mostly fees based on a percentage of assets (67.5%) Predominandtly less experienced (55.6% have advised forlikely 0-10 to years) Much less have larger client base (24.9% > 300 clients) Mostly paid by Commission per Mostly fees based on a transaction (77.8%) percentage of assets (69.6%) Predominandtly less Most experienced (42.4% have experienced (47.7% have advised for 21 years or more) advised forlikely 0-10 to years) Much less have larger Fairly likely to have larger client client base (28.1% > 300 base (45.5% > 300 clients) clients) Least likely to meet clients Meet many clients in person Meet many clients (50.8% meet Meet less clients (49.6% meet (52.5% meet less than 40% of (51.7% meet more than 60% of more than 60% of clients) more than 60% of clients) their clients) clients) Bigger FUA (22.9% have more Biggest FUA (23.0% have more Smaller FUA (61.6% have less Mid-size FUA (59.4% have $10than $60 milion ) than $60 million) than $10 million) 60 million) Mid Size Fish (30.7% have Bigger Fish (34.9% have more Smaller Fish (64.6% have less Bigger Fish (34.9% have more $60<$140k) than $250k) than $60k) than $250k) Most feel helped (88.1%) Focused on needs (82.1%) Extremely loyal to licensee (97.5%) Loyalty to Licensee Feel valued as an adviser within your Licensee Feel completely valued (90.9%) More likely had profit growth Profit growth in last year (80.9%) Overall satisfaction Extremely satisfied (92.5%) Most likely to recommend Likely to recommend (89.0%) Most have recommended Have actually recommended (82.4%) Switching potential within the year Much less likely (3.1%) Switching potential within the next 5 years Much less likely (10.7%) Prepared by Coredata Salaried support seeker Feel very helped (94.3%) Extremely focused on needs (91.2%) Extremely loyal to licensee (98.3%) Much less feel helped (59.6%) Much less focused on needs (54.5%) Feel least helped (24.4%) Feel least focused on needs (7.4%) Loyal to licensee (81.8%) Much less loyal (53.1%) Feel completely valued (93.6%) More likely had profit growth (81.7%) Extremely satisfied (91.2%) Most likely to recommend (88.6%) Many have recommended (73.9%) Much less likely (5.0%) Much less feel valued (59.6%) Less likely had profit growth (70.7%) Much less satisfied (53.5%) Much less likely to recommend (56.6%) Much less have recommended (62.6%) More likely (17.2%) Feel least valued (19.6%) Much less likely had profit growth (60.2%) Very few satisfied (4.5%) Very few likely to recommend (8.5%) Least have recommended (40.6%) Much more likely (36.4%) More likely (16.6%) More likely (16.7%) Much more likely (35.8%) 15 Almost One Third Are Disengaged Satisfied with remuneration Satisfied with adviser support Satisfied with product choice Satisfied with brand strength Satisfied with the extent to which your PDM supports your practice with the proposed fee for service regulatory change Satisfied with the extent to which your PDM supports your practice with other legislative changes Satisfied the licensee helps my business to develop a customer value proposition (CVP) Agribusiness Investment Debt Management Direct Equities Direct Property Investment Estate Planning/Wills Gearing & Margin Lending Insurance and Risk Protection Managed Funds Investing Retirement Planning Superannuation (excluding SMSFs) SMSFs Tax Advice Unlisted Investing (Excl Residential Property) Fee driven generalists Salaried support seeker Stretched risk specialist Unloved disengaged 16.1% 25.5% 32.0% 18.2% 16.0% 23.0% 22.6% 26.6% 18.2% 18.2% 24.2% 12.1% 1.6% 0.0% 8.2% 5.7% 78.6% 77.9% 54.5% 27.7% 67.9% 74.6% 52.8% 17.3% 76.9% 12.2% 42.0% 63.3% 11.3% 53.3% 69.0% 94.7% 98.1% 97.5% 95.9% 76.2% 30.1% 8.8% 84.9% 8.3% 41.1% 52.5% 7.1% 47.5% 75.1% 91.0% 97.1% 98.3% 97.4% 70.3% 22.3% 4.0% 66.7% 1.0% 4.0% 0.0% 0.0% 6.1% 4.0% 96.0% 35.4% 33.3% 68.7% 1.0% 1.0% 0.0% 28.6% 8.0% 45.5% 61.4% 13.9% 47.2% 74.4% 90.1% 98.0% 98.3% 96.3% 75.0% 29.8% 3.7% Industry Fee driven generalists Salaried support seeker Stretched risk specialist Unloved disengaged Prepared by Coredata 26.8% 35.3% 8.3% 29.6% 16 State Representation By Segment In which state are you based? By Segments • Salaried support seekers are most prevalent in NSW, QLD and SA. • The highest proportion of Unloved disengaged advisers are in TAS (34.6%) and NSW (33.5%). Prepared by Coredata 17 Satisfaction & Profit Growth Correlated • Advisers who experienced profit growth are four times as likely to be satisfied with their licensee than those who did not experience profit growth (80.3% compared to 19.7%). Overall satisfaction By Have you experienced profit growth in your business in the past 12 months? • In saying that, 58.6% of those advisers who experienced profit growth in the last 12 months remain dissatisfied with their licensee. Prepared by Coredata 18 Risk A Boon For Advisers Which of the following advisory services do you offer clients? By Have you experienced profit growth in your business in the past 12 months? • Those advisers offering insurance and risk protection are more likely to have experienced profit growth than those who are not (75.8% vs. 61.9%). Likewise, advisers offering agribusiness investment, direct equities, direct property investment and SMSFs are slightly more likely to have reported a growth in profits in the last 12 months. Prepared by Coredata 19 Key Insights 1. Shape of the industry 2. What advisers want 3. And the winner is… Prepared by Coredata 20 Value For Money & Flexibility Valued “Some of the new licensees that are positioning themselves now with the ‘pick and poke’ service menu where you tick what you want on the shopping list and that’s what you pay for… I think that that will gather momentum, particularly in the new environment we’re moving to because everybody’s at a different stage in their career and everyone requires something different. Where the licensees have an offering that allows you, depending on which stage you’re at within your business, to choose the services you want and pay for those, that’s a winning structure” Male, adviser for 30 years, Futuro Financial Services Prepared by Coredata “It’s value for money. So it’s essentially looking at it like a client. ‘Am I getting value for money for what I want?’ And also, can you support MDAs? If there’s a check list of I want this, this and this and it adds up to a fee that’s reasonable – and they’re not going to be ramming stuff down your throat that challenges your independence.” Male, adviser for 22 years, Morgan Stanley Smith Barney “It comes back to things like, to me, the recommended list. What are the available investments on the recommended list? What is the policy for recommending outside the recommended list? What’s their policy on direct equities? Can we buy some direct equities? That to me is important, the flexibility around that.” Male, adviser for 19 years, Financial Wisdom 21 The Most Critical Licensee Services Which of the following licensee support services have you used in the last 12 months? Prepared by Coredata In terms of importance, please allocate percentages to the following licensee attributes. 22 Product Independence A Key Trigger • Product independence/choice is the number one driver for joining a licensee (49.9%), just ahead of compliance support (44.9%), remuneration (43.2%) and technical services (42.7%). Please tick any of the following factors that if good/bad would make you more inclined to join/leave a licensee? • However compliance support & remuneration appear to be ‘hygiene factors’; advisers are more likely to leave a licensee if compliance is poor, than they are to join if it’s strong. Prepared by Coredata 23 Driver Analysis (STAR Index) Prepared by Coredata 24 Top 15 Attributes 2011 2010 Importance Importance Rank Rank Attribute Movement Category Top 3 Leaders ipac EP, Commonwealth, ipac FP 1 3 Quality of technical information provided Technical services 2 9 Relevance of technical presentations and seminars Technical services 3 26 4 14 5 1 6 23 Paraplanners are competent and knowledgeable Paraplanning 7 25 Licensee pays revenue accurately Remuneration 8 New Licensee helps me articulate the value of my advice to my clients - Marketing support and communications 9 New Licensee helps me source the right advisers for my business - Business planning 10 22 Quality of technical publications 11 12 Licensee keeps me informed of what is going on in the industry in a timely manner Marketing support and communications 12 20 Quality of training materials provided Education and training 13 29 The extent to which your PDM adds value to your business 14 19 The investment guidelines provided by the licensee are appropriate for my business 15 18 Revenue statements are easy to read Prepared by Coredata Licensee helps me recruit and retain the right staff for my business Audit process helps me develop my business by identifying problems and providing solutions Research team is able to clearly communicate their requirements Business planning Compliance support Research Technical services Practice Development Managers (PDMs) / Practice Managers / Business Coaches Research Remuneration ipac EP, Commonwealth, ipac FP Commonwealth, NAB, ipac EP ipac EP, Commonwealth, MLC/Garvan Commonwealth, Genesys, ipac EP ipac EP, AXA, Genesys Genesys, Commonwealth, ipac EP Commonwealth, Charter, ipac EP Commonwealth, NAB, ipac EP Commonwealth, ipac EP, Financial Wisdom Commonwealth, Charter, Securitor Commonwealth, Genesys, Charter Genesys, Commonwealth, ipac EP Commonwealth, ipac EP, Genesys Genesys, Commonwealth, PIS 25 Attribute Ratings Marketing support and communications Quality of the marketing materials provided to promote my business Ability to customise marketing materials Licensee keeps me informed of what is going on in the industry in a timely manner Licensee helps me articulate the value of my advice to my clients Overall satisfaction with marketing support and communications Compliance support Advice guidelines are easy to understand Advice tools are easy to use Audit process helps me develop my business by identifying problems and providing solutions Overall satisfaction with compliance support Technical services Relevance of technical presentations and seminars Quality of technical information provided Quality of technical publications Timeliness of information on legislative and technical changes Overall satisfaction with technical services Paraplanning Paraplanning service provided by my licensee represents good value for money Quality of the Statements of Advice provided by the paraplanning service Paraplanners are competent and knowledgeable Overall satisfaction with the paraplanning service Prepared by Coredata Industry 2010 Industry 2011 6.56 6.54 7.20 6.75 6.90 6.76 7.49 7.07 7.09 Industry 2010 Industry 2011 7.00 6.78 7.01 7.06 6.83 6.58 6.95 6.93 Industry 2010 Industry 2011 7.27 7.59 7.41 7.53 7.48 7.34 7.72 7.56 7.72 7.68 Industry 2010 Industry 2011 6.64 6.77 6.99 6.78 7.46 7.28 7.52 7.34 % Contribution to the Overall model 1.68% 1.19% 3.48% 4.48% % Contribution to the Overall model 1.00% 0.56% 5.85% % Contribution to the Overall model 7.87% 8.05% 3.77% 1.21% % Contribution to the Overall model 2.01% 1.36% 5.42% 26 Attribute Ratings Education and training Availability of adviser to adviser information sharing and networking opportunities Relevance of professional development days and national conferences Quality of training materials provided Overall satisfaction with education and training Business planning Licensee helps with my business development Licensee helps me recruit and retain the right staff for my business Licensee helps my business to develop a customer value proposition (CVP) Licensee helps me source the right advisers for my business Licensee helps me segment my client base Licensee helps me determine appropriate pricing of my services Overall satisfaction with business planning Practice Development Managers (PDMs) / Practice Managers / Business Coaches The extent to which your PDM adds value to your business The extent to which your PDM supports your practice with the proposed fee for service regulatory change The extent to which your PDM supports your practice with other legislative changes The responsiveness of your PDM Overall satisfaction with your PDM Research The ease of contacting the research team Research team is able to clearly communicate their requirements The investment guidelines provided by the licensee are appropriate for my business The quality of investment and risk research Overall satisfaction with research Remuneration Licensee pays revenue in a timely manner Licensee pays revenue accurately Revenue statements produced by the licensee are accurate Revenue statements are easy to read Overall satisfaction with revenue payments Acquisitions and succession Licensee has a wide choice of succession options Licensee provides technical guidance when acquiring another practice Licensee makes resources available to help me integrate an acquisition Overall satisfaction with acquisitions and succession Prepared by Coredata Industry 2010 Industry 2011 7.06 7.08 7.08 6.76 6.96 7.07 7.05 Industry 2010 Industry 2011 6.06 5.57 6.08 6.91 6.42 7.37 6.62 7.01 7.06 7.16 Industry 2010 Industry 2011 6.12 6.92 6.66 6.83 7.03 6.74 7.46 7.27 Industry 2010 Industry 2011 6.93 6.80 7.00 7.07 6.94 7.25 7.27 7.14 7.40 7.29 Industry 2010 Industry 2011 8.28 8.04 8.02 7.73 7.99 8.37 8.09 8.09 7.72 7.98 Industry 2010 Industry 2011 6.05 5.76 5.86 5.93 7.27 6.94 7.01 7.08 5.58 % Contribution to the Overall model 0.07% 0.71% 3.43% % Contribution to the Overall model 1.39% 7.81% 2.46% 4.13% 1.95% 2.25% % Contribution to the Overall model 3.42% 1.78% 0.42% 2.65% % Contribution to the Overall model 1.05% 5.67% 3.15% 0.36% % Contribution to the Overall model 0.76% 4.65% 1.13% 2.82% % Contribution to the Overall model 27 Key Insights 1. Shape of the industry 2. What advisers want 3. And the winner is… Prepared by Coredata 28 Internal STAR: Commonwealth FP Overall STAR Internal Ratings Prepared by Coredata 29 External STAR: ipac EP & ipac FP Overall STAR External Ratings Prepared by Coredata 30 Average rating scores (0-10) 4 2 0 Prepared by Coredata 6.0 Financial Wisdom 5.8 6.1 7.2 6.6 Securitor 7.3 RI Advice* 6.1 Professional Investment Services 6.5 MLC/Garvan Financial Planning 6.7 Millennium3 Financial Planning* 5.7 ipac Financial Planning 8.3 ipac Equity Partners Hillross Financial Services* 7.1 Guardian Financial Planning 7.4 Godfrey Pembroke* Genesys Wealth Advisers 6.0 Count Financial 7.4 National Australia Bank Financial Planning Average score: 6.8 Commonwealth Financial Planning 7.4 Charter Financial Planning 8 AXA Financial Planning 6.1 Apogee Financial Planning* 6 6.3 AMP Financial Planning CFP & ipac EP Top Overall Satisfaction... Overall, how satisfied are you with your licensee? 10 7.9 31 Prepared by Coredata 4 2 0 5.4 6.1 7.1 6.6 Securitor 6.3 RI Advice* Professional Investment Services 7.3 National Australia Bank Financial Planning 6.3 MLC/Garvan Financial Planning 6.7 Millennium3 Financial Planning* 5.6 ipac Financial Planning 8.3 ipac Equity Partners Hillross Financial Services* 7.4 Guardian Financial Planning 7.4 Godfrey Pembroke* 7.5 Genesys Wealth Advisers 6.0 Financial Wisdom 6.0 6.1 Count Financial Commonwealth Financial Planning 7.4 Charter Financial Planning 6 6.3 AXA Financial Planning 8 Apogee Financial Planning* AMP Financial Planning Likelihood to recommend (0-10) ... And Have Highest Advocacy Levels How likely are you to recommend your licensee? 10 8.2 Average score: 6.8 32 Prepared by Coredata 3.8 3.8 3.8 2.8 2 0 3.1 4.4 Securitor RI Advice* Professional Investment Services 3.1 5.1 Securitor 4.6 RI Advice* 0 1.7 National Australia Bank Financial Planning 2.8 Professional Investment Services 0.8 2.2 MLC/Garvan Financial Planning 1.5 Millennium3 Financial Planning* 3.4 National Australia Bank Financial Planning 3.3 MLC/Garvan Financial Planning 5.3 ipac Financial Planning 1 ipac Equity Partners 2.5 Millennium3 Financial Planning* 4.8 Hillross Financial Services* Guardian Financial Planning 5 ipac Financial Planning Genesys Wealth Advisers 3.2 ipac Equity Partners 4.8 Financial Wisdom Count Financial 3.7 Hillross Financial Services* 4.7 Godfrey Pembroke* Average score: 2.6 Guardian Financial Planning 4.4 Commonwealth Financial Planning 1.2 1.6 Godfrey Pembroke* Average Score: 4.7 Charter Financial Planning 2.0 Genesys Wealth Advisers 4.6 2.7 Financial Wisdom 3.9 2.9 Count Financial 6 AXA Financial Planning 3 Commonwealth Financial Planning 4 3.1 Charter Financial Planning 8 AXA Financial Planning 2 Apogee Financial Planning* AMP Financial Planning Likelihood to switch (0-10) 4 Apogee Financial Planning* AMP Financial Planning Likelihood to switch (0-10) Switching Intent Increases Over Time How likely are you to switch to a new licensee within the next 12 months? 4.0 3.2 2.0 How likely are you to switch to a new licensee within the next 5 years? 6.3 5.2 3.4 33 Having Own AFSL Trumps All Offers • When asked to rank the ‘top five’ dealer groups to work for, having their own ASFL was deemed the most attractive option. Please rank who you believe are the top 5 dealers to work for, where 1 indicates the top dealer to work for. • There was little differentiation among the licensees with Charter Financial Planning placing second by a small margin (3.4). AXA Financial Planning, ipac Equity Partners, Shadforth and CFP also rated highly, all with a score of 3.3 out of 5. Prepared by Coredata 34 Charter FP ‘Best Licensee’ In Industry Overall, which licensee do you perceive to be the best in the industry? • When asked to name the licensee they perceive to be the best in the industry (excluding their own), again having their own AFSL ranked first, with one quarter of advisers considering this option to exceed the offer of any licensee in the market (24.4%). • Charter FP was the highest ranked licensee with 8.0% of adviser votes, followed by Macquarie Private Wealth (7.2%), AXA FP (6.1%) and AMP FP (4.8%). Prepared by Coredata Own AFSL Charter Financial Planning Macquarie Private Wealth AXA Financial Planning AMP Financial Planning Godfrey Pembroke MLC/Garvan Financial Planning Shadforth Financial Group ipac Financial Planning Count Financial Professional Investment Services Commonwealth Financial Planning Lonsdale Financial Group Securitor Genesys Wealth Advisers ipac Equity Partners Apogee Financial Planning RBS Morgans Westpac Financial Planning AFS Hillross Financial Services Tynan Mackenzie Matrix Planning Solutions Financial Wisdom Millennium3 Financial Planning Wealthsure WHK Financial Planning Bridges Financial Planning Aon Financial Planning and Protection Financial Services Partners National Australia Bank Financial Planning RI Advice ANZ Financial Planning St George Financial Planning Sentry Group Guardian Financial Planning Magnitude Australian Financial Group (AFG) Futuro Financial Services Meritum Financial Group Other 24.4 8.0 7.2 6.1 4.8 3.7 3.1 3.1 2.9 2.5 2.3 2.2 2.2 1.9 1.5 1.4 1.3 1.1 1.1 1.0 1.0 0.9 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.7 0.7 0.6 0.4 0.4 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 9.2 0 10 20 % 35 30 Prepared by Coredata 4 2 0 6.20 5.96 ipac Financial Planning 6 Count Financial 6.88 AMP Financial Planning 7.03 Guardian Financial Planning 7.06 Financial Wisdom 7.06 Professional Investment Services 7.41 National Australia Bank Financial Planning 7.48 Securitor 7.54 AXA Financial Planning 7.91 MLC/Garvan Financial Planning 8 Charter Financial Planning 8.01 Genesys Wealth Advisers 8.24 ipac Equity Partners Commonwealth Financial Planning Average rating scores (0-10) CoreData Licensee Of The Year 2011 10 Licensee of the Year 2011 7.39 6.62 36 In Summary…. Industry at a tipping point.. Crunch time for licensees Advisers want flexibility & value; education & tech services increasingly important CFP trumps competition in 2011; Charter FP & ipac groups poised for growth Prepared by Coredata 37 info@coredata.com.au