Umpolung Reactivity of Functional Groups : The Stetter and The Benzoin Reactions Pierre-André Fournier Collins Group 1 What’s an Umpolung? Any process by which the normal nucleophile and electrophile are interchanged. Classical example : the use of dithianes O R' O + H X R R R' Protection Deprotection X S R' S H Base S S R R' S R' S R Additional protection/deprotection steps. Stoichiometric amount of reagents. Highly basic conditions. 2 Benzoin and Stetter Reactions. Can we functionalize the aldehyde in one step? O R O H EWD O Stetter reaction R' O EWD R R'' Precatalyst, base R' Benzoin reaction R'' O Precatalyst, base R R' R'' 1,4 addition X R R'' R' OH 1,2 addition Catalyst : cyanide, phosphite or heterocyclic carbene. Benzoin reaction : Addition of an acyl anion equivalent to a carbonyl. Stetter reaction : Addition of an acyl anion equivalent to an activated olefin. 3 Benzoin and Stetter Reactions : New Synthetic Tools? Total synthesis of (±)-Hirsutic Acid C (Trost, 1979) OH H HO2 C O H (±)-Hirsutic Acid C CN OH N S MeO O O CN I (2.3 eq.) Et3N (50 eq.), 2-propanol, 82°C, 5h H 8 steps O MeO2C O MeO2C H 67% Rough conditions (50 eq. of Et3N) Low yields Very specific Trost, B.M.; Shuey, C.D.; DiNinno, F.Jr.; MeElvain, S.S.. J. Am. Chem. Soc.. 1979, 101,1284-1285. 4 The Cross Benzoin Reaction. O H H MeO CN- H H O O MeO OH O H DBU (70 mol%) 1 (20 mol%) t-BuOH, 40°C, 1h O O MeO Thermodynamic Product O H OH Not Observed O OH OH OH 50% N Br S (1) Not Observed No control of the chemioselectivity. Suzuki, K.; Bode, J.W.; Hachisu, Y. Adv. Synth Catal. 2004, 346,1097-1100. 5 Mechanism of the Benzoin Reaction. DBU (70 mol%) Catalyst 1 (20 mol%) t-BuOH, 40°C, 1h O H O OH OH N Br S (1) 50% X R R' N O Ph Ph OH R' R R'' Elimination O R' R S OH Ph Base N N O R'' S Ph H R'' S Nu attack R' Ph R N R'' O S Proton transf er Ph H R' R N HO R'' Proton transf er S O Ph 1,2 Addition Ph Ph OH R N R' Breslow Intermediate S O Ph R'' 6 Asymmetric Benzoin Condensation. Meerwein's reagent O O OMe Me3OBF4 NH O quant. PhHN PhNHNH2 N t -Bu NEt 3 t -Bu O Ar H Ph HC(OEt)3 HBF4, MeOH, 12h, 80°C N O 77% NH N N O 65% t -Bu KOt -Bu (10 mol%) Catalyst 2 (10 mol%) THF, 16h, 18°C BF4 N (2) t -Bu O Ar Ar OH O Ph Cl O Br O Ph OH OH F 83%, 90 ee% Me OH 16%, 93 ee% MeO OH Cl 81%, 83 ee% O Me F O 82%, 64 ee% OMe O OH 8%, 95 ee% O O OH Br 80%, 53 ee% O O OH 100%, 64 ee% 0°C, 45 min O O OH 41%, 88 ee% -78°C Enders, D.; Kallfass, U. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed.. 2002, 41, 1743-1745. 7 Jeffrey S. Johnson Intermolecular Benzoin Reaction B.Sc. : University of Kansas (1994) Ph.D. : Harvard University (1999) (David A. Evans) PDF : University of California (1999-2001) (Robert Bergman) Assistant Professor : University of North Carolina (2001 – present) 8 Controlling the Reaction : The Use of Acylsilanes. O H SiEt3 H MeO KCN (30 mol%) 18-crown-6 (30 mol%) Et 2O, 25°C O H O OSiEt3 MeO 85% O H H Et3Si MeO KCN (30 mol%) 18-crown-6 (30 mol%) Et 2O, 25°C O H Et3 SiO O MeO 79% Need to prepare the acylsilanes… Aryl Alkyl O Alk LiSiX3 N O O Alk SiX3 60-85% Me 3SiSiMe3 + Ar Cl Pd Cl (5 mol%) Pd O Cl O Ar P(OEt) 3 (10 mol%) Linghu, X.;Johnson, J.S. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2003, 42, 2534-2536. SiX3 10-80% 9 Silyl Cross Benzoin Reaction : Mechanism. O H H Et3Si MeO KCN (30 mol%) 18-crown-6 (30 mol%) Et 2O, 25°C O H Et 3 SiO O MeO 79% O Ph Et3SiO PMP O CN O retrocyanation CN Ph PMP OSiEt3 Ph SiEt3 Cyanation O CN 1,4-silyl migration Et3SiO SiEt3 [1,2]-Brook Rearrangement CN Ph PMP O 1,2 Addition OSiEt3 C O N PMP Linghu, X.;Johnson, J.S. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2003, 42, 2534-2536. 10 Silyl Benzoin Reaction : Scope and Limitations. O R1 O + TES R2 H KCN (30 mol%) 18-crown-6 (30 mol%) Et2O, 25°C, 2h O R2 R1 OTES O R1 O + TES H R2 1. La(CN)3 (10 mol%) THF, 23°C, <5min. 2. aq. HCL, MeOH aa O R2 R1 OR Cl O OTES O OTES Cl 82% 87%* OTES O 85% MeO OTES 51% 75% 88% 85% 84% Cl O O Ph OH 64% 15 min. O OTES OTES MeO O n-Hex TESO O O 79% 81%* 86% 83% O OMe O Ph OH 70% 15 min. OH 48% 15 min. Limitation : R1 and R2 must be aryls to prevent aldol reaction. Linghu, X.;Johnson, J.S. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2003, 42, 2534-2536. Linghu, X.; Bausch, C.C.; Johnson, J.S. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2005, 127, 1833-1840. 11 Other Synthetic Methods to Make a-Hydroxy Ketones. O 1. LDA 2. O 2 3. P(OEt)3 1. LDA, TMSCl 2. m-CPBA 3. TBAF HO O O HO O O O 1. LDA 2. MoOPh O O O HO Mo O N O 1. NaHMDS 2. Davie's Reagent HO O O NMe2 P NMe 2 Me2 N (MoOPh) O Ph O N N SO2 Ph Davie's Reagent S O O O 100$ / g Needs to form the enolate. Lack of stereocontrol. 12 Chiral Metallophosphites for Enantioselective Silyl Benzoin Reaction. O R1 O + TES O H R2 Catalyst 3 (5-20 mol%) n-BuLi (20-40 mol%) THF, 30 min., 0°C to 25°C OTES 84%, 82 ee% O MeO Cl O OTES 75%, 82 ee% O OTES 83%, 88 ee% O OTES 65%, 85 ee% Ph Ph O R2 R1 OTES O Me O O O P O H Me O Ph Ph OMe O OTES Cl 82%, 87 ee% O (3) OTES 87%, 91 ee% O OTES OTES 78%, 73 ee% 88%, 41 ee% Limitation : R1 and R2 must be aryls to prevent aldol reaction. Linghu, X.; Potnick, J.R.; Johnson, J.S. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2004, 126, 3070-3071. 13 Jeffrey W. Bode Intramolecular Benzoin Reaction – Catalytic Homoenolate Generation B.Sc. : Trinity University (San Antonio) (1996) Ph.D. : ETH Zürich (2001) (Erick M. Carreira) PDF : Tokyo Institute of Technology (2001-2003) (Keisuke Suzuki) Assistant Professor : University of California (2003 – present) 14 Aldehyde-Ketone Benzoin Cyclization. O Catalyst 4 (20 mol%) DBU (20 mol%) THF, r.t., 24 h, 44%, 96 ee% O O N O (4) OH Cl N N Ph OH O OH O 7h, 70%, 96 ee% O OH O 0.5h, 69%, 60 ee% 15h, 73%, 39 ee% OMe N O O Et OH 18h, 47%, 90 ee% N O O O i-Pr OH 19h, 74%, 85 ee% O Ph OH 6h, 91%, 98 ee% O OH 19h, 73%, 99 ee% Suzuki, K.; Bode, J.W.; Hachisu, Y. Adv. Synth Catal. 2004, 346,1097-1100. Takikawa, H.; Hachisu, Y.; Bode, J.W.; Suzuki, K. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2006, 45, 3492-3494. 15 Catalytic Homoenolate Generation : Synthesis of g-Butyrolactones. O Catalyst 5 (8 mol%) DBU (7 mol%) 10:1 THF:t-BuOH r.t., 15h Br O H H + O Mes N O Cl Br N Mes (5) 84%, 7:1 dr Mes N N Mes Cl 1-Naph Base Ar O O 1-Naph O N N 4-MeOC 6 H4 Mes Ph p-CO2 Me-C6 H4 Nu attack 76%, 4:1 dr Mes Ph N 4-MeOC6 H4 Ph N Proton Transf er 87%, 5:1 dr 65%, 4:1 dr Mes OH 1-Naph Mes O H 1-Naph N 1-Naph O Mes 79%, 4:1 dr O O O 4-BrC 6 H4 Elimination O O H O Mes 4-BrC 6H 4 Ar O O O N O O O Mes N O 1-Naph MeO2 C Mes N O Breslow Intermidiate O TIPS Addition 1-Naph Ar O O Mes N 1-Naph5:1 dr 67%, Mes OH TIPS 1-Naph Nu addition 83%, 5:1 dr N Mes N Mes N TIPS Homoenolate 41%, 3:1 dr O H Ar Sohn, S.S.; Rosen, E.L.; Bode, J.W. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2004, 126, 14370-14371. 16 Catalytic Homoenolates Generation : Synthesis of g-lactames. O O N H + 1-Naph S Ar 1-Naph Catalyst 5 (8 mol%) DBU (7 mol%) 10:1 THF:t-BuOH r.t., 15h O H Me Me O N O ArO2 S ArO 2S N MeO Ph 69%, 3:1 dr ArO2 S N p-Tol O CF3 70%, 3:2 dr N Mes (5) Cl ArO2 S N p-Tol 70%, 3.5:1 dr ArO2 S N p-Tol O Ph Me Ph 73%, 1.7:1 dr F3 C ArO 2S N Ph Ph O O N O Ph ArO 2S O N p-Tol 70%, 4:1 dr Mes N 96%, >10:1 dr Ar : p-MeOC6 H4 ArO2 S O N O O S Ar 61%,8:1 dr O 62%, 5:1 dr ArO2 S N p-Tol O TIPS O 65%, 3.5:1 dr Ph 51%, 10:1 dr Average yields, but low diastereoselectivities. He, M.; Bode, J.W. Org. Lett. 2005, 7, 3131-3134. 17 Intermolecular Stetter Reaction in Total Synthesis. Tius’ synthesis of the macrocyclic core of Roseophilin. OMe Cl N O NH Roseophilin MeO O 1. O • Li N O O 6-Heptenal, Et 3N, 6 BzO 2. AcOH 3. BzCl, Et3N BzO O OH O H2 Pd/C, THF 92% Grubbs' I BzO 90% 49% (2 steps) O O BzO O Bn N Cl S (6) (NH4)2CO3, propionic acid 140°C, 10h 52% Harrington, P.E.; Tius, M.A. Org. Lett. 1999, 1, 649-651. 60% HN O 18 Intermolecular Stetter Reaction. EWD O Precatalyst, Base + R' R'' R O EWD R' R'' R H Lack of selectivity. Scheidt’s Methodology : Modification of the substrate. EWD R' R'' R EWD R'' ONa R O O EWD R' R'' R SiEt 3 O + R' Precatalyst, Base, Alcool O + Precatalyst, Base, Alcool O EWD R' R'' R 19 Karl A. Scheidt Intermolecular Stetter Reaction – Acylsilanes Chemistry B.S. : University of Notre-Dame (1994) Ph.D. : Indiana University / University of Michigan (1999) (William R. Roush) PDF : Harvard University (1999-2002) (David A. Evans) Assistant Professor : Northwestern University (2002 – present) 20 Biomimetic Conjugate Addition of Acyl Anion. Nature‘s approach to acyl anions. O O Pyruvate OH Dehydrogenase -CO2 RS SR O O S R acetylCoA Biomimetic approach to acyl anions. O R' O ONa + R' O N R N Catalyst 6 (20 mol%) pH 7.2 buffer MeOH, 70°C O O N R N OH Bn N Cl S (6) Myers, M.C.; Bharadwaj, A.R.; Milgram, B.C.; Scheidt, K.A. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2005, 127, 14675-14680. 21 Pyruvate as a Source of Acyl Anion Equivalent : Mecanism. O R' O ONa + R' Catalyst 6 (20 mol%) N Conditions R O O N R N O OH N Bn N Cl S (6) O O R' O Bn N O HO C O S R' N Bn Addition S HO O IM O OH Elimination CO2 R R' Loss of CO2 O IM OH R OH S R' Bn Addition N Bn O HO OH S R' N Breslow Intermidiate IM R O O R N + N NaOEt, EtOH E: Z > 95:5 O N R N 22 Pyruvate as a Source of Acyl Anion Equivalent. Organic conditions: O O OH + Me N Ph O N R' Catalyst 6 (20 mol%) THF, DBU, 70°C 85% O O N R OH N Bn N Cl S (6) Aqueous conditions: ONa + Ph Me N Me O Me O O IM Me MeO Me O O IM O OMe O 87% Me O IM O IM Cl Me O IM 87% O N Me O IM 87% O N Me O O R pH form 5 to 12 91-94% N O R' Catalyst 6 (20 mol%) buffer, MeOH, 70°C O O O S 87% O Me IM Me O O IM CF3 76% 80% 90% 35% Organic Conditions 23 Pyruvate as a Source of Acyl Anion Equivalent. O O ONa + R N Ph O R' Catalyst 6 (20 mol%) pH 7.2 buffer MeOH, 70°C O N H 2P N O O N Ph O Ph OH IM O Ph 92% O O IM Ph 90% O O IM Cl S (6) O Ph 72% Bn N IM 95% N O O Ph O S O IM Ph 96% O N O IM Ph 76% F3 C O IM 91% O O Ph IM No Reaction Imidazole easily transformed to an amide or an ester . R O MeOTf O N Ph N R O O MeOH, DABCO N Ph N R Ph O O OMe 78% (2 steps) 24 Addition of Acylsilanes. O O R + TMS R1 R2 R catalyst 1 (30 mol%) DBU, i-PrOH, THF, 70°C O O R1 OH R2 N Br S (1) O R TMS Et OTMS N Addition [1,2] Brook S S R HO O Et N OH 2 R O i-PrOH Elimination R1 Desilylation R O R2 OH R1 HO S R Et TMSOi-Pr OH Addition S R N Et O N OH Breslow Intermidiate R2 R1 Lots of solvents, bases and catalysts screened. Mattson, A.E.; Bharadwaj, A.R.; Zuhl, A.M.; Scheidt, K.A. J. org. Chem. 2006, 71, 5715-5724. 25 Addition of Acylsilanes. Ph TMS + Ph Ph catalyst 1 (30 mol%) DBU, i -PrOH, THF, 70°C O O Ph O O Ph OH Ph 77% Ph O Ph O Ph O O Ph Ph O 1-Naph Cl Ph O O O Ph 80% Br S (1) Ph O O Ph OMe 82% N Ph MeO OMe 72% 75% 77% Effective preparation of 1,4-diketone. O HN O O O AcO OH Salviadione 3-acetoxy-19-hydroxyspongia13(16),14-dien-2-one 26 Synthesis of Pyrroles and Furanes by Sila-Stetter/Paal-Knorr Sequence. Furans: O O R + TMS R1 R2 1. catalyst 1 (20 mol%) DBU, i -PrOH, THF, 70°C 2. AcOH O R R2 OH R1 O Ph Ph O Et Ph Ph Ph 81% Et O Ph 3,4-ClPh 82% O Et Ph O Me 4-BrPh 84% Br S (1) O Me Ph Ph p-Tol Ph 81% N 74% 83% Pyrroles: Ph O O R TMS + R1 R2 1. catalyst 1 (20 mol%) DBU, i -PrOH, THF, 70°C 2. PhNH2 TsOH, 4A sieves N Ph Ph OH Ph N Br S (1) 66% Ph Ph H N Ph Ph Cy N Ph 62% Ph Ph 4-ClPh N 4-OMePh 69% Ph Ph N Ph 69% Ph n-Pr Ph Ph Me N Ph N Ph Ph Ph 82% Ph 4-NH2 Ph 54% 70% Good yields for a one-pot synthesis of this type of molecule. Bharadwaj, A.R.; Scheidt, K.A. Org. Lett. 2004, 6, 2465-2468. 27 Tomislav Rovis. Intramolecular Asymmetric Stetter Reaction – NHC Design B.Sc. : University of Toronto (1990) Ph.D. : University of Toronto (1993-1998) (Mark Lautens) PDF : Harvard University (1998-2000) (David A. Evans) Assistant Professor : Colorado State University (2000 – present)28 Asymmetric Intramolecular Stetter Reaction : First Screening. Catalyst Screening . O O R 1 N R O 2 N X N Ph O CO2 Et (20 mol%) KHMDS (20 mol%) CO2 Et xylenes, 25°C, 24h O R1/R2 X Yield (%) ee (%) H/Bn BF4 85 90 H/t-Bu BF4 0 - H/i-Pr Cl 27 79 H/Ph Cl 48 80 Indanyl BF4 58 95 Effect of the Electronic Properties of the Catalyst. O N N N BF4 O X O (20 mol%) O CO2 Et KHMDS (20 mol%) xylenes, 25°C, 24h O CO2 Et X Yield (%) ee (%) H 58 95 Cl 60 91 OMe 94 94 Possible EWG : Ketones, Esters, Nitriles. Kerr, M.S.; de Alaniz, J.R.; Rovis, T. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2002, 124, 10298-10299. 29 Asymmetric Intramolecular Stetter Reaction : a-Substituted Cycloketones. O O CO2 Et O Catalyst 7 (20 mol%) O O CO2 Et KHMDS (20 mol%) xylenes, 25°C, 24h O CO2 Et N CO2 Et N N BF4 OMe O (7) 94%, 94ee% O CO2 Et O CO2 Me Me O O O Me 80%, 97ee% O CO2 Me N Me 64%, 82ee% S OMe 90%, 84ee% O 95%, 87ee% CO2 Me O 63%, 96ee% CO2 Et O CO2 Et N N Bn CO 2Me 72%, 84ee% 35%, 94ee% (8) N BF4 N Ph 90%, 92ee% With catalyst 8 Epimerization observed only in rare cases. O H Catalyst 8 (20 mol%) O O O CO2 Me KHMDS (20 mol%) xylenes, 25°C, 24h CO2 Me O 90%,<5ee% O Catalyst 8 (20 mol%) CO2 Me KHMDS (20 mol%) xylenes, 25°C, 24h CO2 Me 81%,95ee% 30 Formation of Quaternary Stereocenters via Stetter Reaction. O O O Catalyst 9 (20 mol%) Me CO2 Me O Et3N (2 eq.) PhMe, 25°C, 24h O Me CO2 Me (9) F Ph O 92%, 89ee% O Et CO2 Me S 95%, 99ee% O O Me O Me 4-NO 2Ph 85%, 96ee% Et CO2 Me 95%, 92ee% Me O 81%, 95ee% F O O Br Me CO2 Me F F BF 4 96%, 97ee% O O N F N N O O Me 55%, 99ee% O n-Bu O CO 2Me CO2 Me Ph 71%, 98ee% N Bn 86%, 90ee% With catalyst 8 (8) N BF4 N Ph Highly selective methods for the formation of quaternary centers. O O Me O Ph O Catalyst 9 (20 mol%) Me KHMDS (20 mol%) O CO2 Me PhMe, 25°C, 24h From E olef in : 85%, 96ee% From Z olef in : 50%, 56ee% Kerr, M.S.; Rovis, T. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2004, 126, 8876-8877. 31 Formation of Contiguous Stereocenters via Stetter Reaction. N O Bn Me O CO2Et N BF 4 N Ar O (20 mol%) H CO2Et Me Base (20 mol%) PhMe, 25°C, 24h O Ar Base Yield (%) ee (%) dr (%) Ph KHMDS 85 90 3:1 to 12:1 Ph --- 88 90 15:1 p-CF3Ph --- 94 95 30:1 HMDS and the carbene can epimerize the stereocentres. No epimerization observed with a less basic carbene (p-CF3Ph) 32 Formation of Contiguous Stereocenters via Stetter Reaction. O O Me O CO2 Et O H Catalyst 8 (20 mol%) PhMe, 25°C, 24h CO2Et O H CO2 Et O O O H O O O H Bn CO2 Et (8) O O 95%, 83ee%, 13:1 dr O H O 80%, 95ee%, 18:1 dr O H Me H O H H O O N N 4-CF Ph 3 N O 80%, 84ee%, 20:1 dr H 95%, 94ee%, 10:1 dr Me Bn O 53%, 94ee%, 12:1 dr CO2 Et 81%, 95ee%, 30:1 dr n-Bu O H 94%, 99ee%, 50:1 dr O Ph N O H O H O 85%, 55ee%, 10:1 dr 80%, 88ee%, 15:1 dr 33 Source of The Diastereoselectivity. Reactions with E and Z olefins shows that bond rotation is slower than protonation. 34 Synthesis of Hydrobenzofuranones via Desymmetrization. Ar Yield (%) ee (%) O dr (%) O 4-MeOPh 90 88 >95:5 Ph 75 80 >95:5 C6F5 92 31 MeO O Me H Et O 90%, 92ee% H 4-BrPh H O O 78%, 85ee% Me O 87%, 94ee% MeO O 87%, 88ee% O 86%, >99ee% O H O Me O O Ph O Me O H O i-Pr O MeO O H O Me KHMDS (20 mol%) PhMe, 25°C, <5 min O 86%, 94ee% O O O H (20 mol%) O H O O BF4 >95:5 O N N Ar N OMe O O 71%, 99ee% t-Bu t-Bu H t -Bu O O 62%, >99ee% 2h Liu, Q.; Rovis, T. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2006, 128, 2552-2553. 35 Stetter and Benzoin Reaction. Intermolecular Benzoin Reaction: Acylsilanes are required. Alkyls are problematic. Reaction works well with aryls. Intramolecular Benzoin Reaction: No substrate modifications required. Works with alkyl and aryl. Promising asymmetric version. Intermolecular Stetter Reaction: Acylsilanes or pyruvates are required. Limited to aryls. Effective synthesis of pyrroles and furanes. T. Rovis Intermolecular Stetter Reaction: No substrate modifications required. Works with alkyl and aryl. Synthesis of multiple stereocenters in one step. J.S. Johnson J.W. Bode K.A. Scheidt 36 --. Bode – Opening of epoxides. 37 --. Bode - Opening of cyclopropanes. 38 Applications of Ru-Based Chiral Metathesis Catalysts. Jeff Bode – Cross Stetter, intramolecular benzoin, intramolecular benzoin on ketones Johnson – Sylil benzoin (racemic and chiral) Enders - ? Karl Scheidt – Biomimetic Stetter, « esterification » of aldehydes, Sila-Stetter (+ PaalKnorr one-pot) Tom Rovis – Asymmetric Stetter Tius, Trost, 39 Sylil Benzoin Reaction : Scope and Limitations. O R1 O + R2 H TES KCN (30 mol%) 18-crown-6 (30 mol%) Et 2O, 25°C, 2h O R2 R1 OTES Cl O OTES OTES OTES Cl 82% O OTES 75% 85% OTES 85% O O TESO O MeO 79% 86% O OMe O O MeO OTES 51% Limitation : R1 and R2 must be aryls. 40