Page | 1 Pasadena City College Department of Religious Studies RELIGIOUS STUDIES 2 Philip Ricards, Ph.D. Comparative Religions: Far East Professor of Religious Studies (Religions of South and East Asia) Spring 2014 Office C 431; x7859 pcricards@pasadena.edu Text: 1.) M.P. Fisher, Living Religions: Eastern Traditions Prentice Hall, 2002 2.) Encyclopedia of Eastern Philosophy and Religions. (Shambhala Pubs.) STUDENT LEARNING OUTCOMES The purpose of the course is to introduce students to the thought-forms, literature, history, and current practices of the major living religions of South and East Asia. Introductory attention will be given to archaic religions and the nature of religion in general reality. Upon successful completion of the course: 1. Students will demonstrate an understanding of the nature of religion in general. 2. Students will be able to identify the thought-forms, literature, and history of the major living religions of South and East Asia: Hinduism, Buddhism, and Chinese religion, with some attention to Jainism and Shinto. 3. Students will demonstrate an understanding of how religion is currently practiced in South and East Asia as well as each religious tradition’s distinctive contribution to human understanding of and response to sacred reality. Page | 2 COURSE FORMAT Instruction in the class will involve lecture, video, and slide presentations. These are intended to supplement and complement material presented in the course text. COURSE REQUIREMENTS Students are expected to attend class faithfully, read all assignments in a timely fashion, and successfully complete all quizzes, examinations, and other written assignments. Mastery of the assigned material in the class text is a necessary precondition to success in the class, along with good note-taking of class lectures. Recording devices are not allowed in class. TESTS: There will be periodic tests over course material. Tests will be varied in format, from multiple choice to short answer to essay. One low or missing test grade will be dropped. NO MAKE UP TESTS will be given. Final Examination: There will be an in-class final exam. Tests will constitute 100% of the course grade, with adjustments for (lack of) attendance and Extra Credit, if any. CLASS PARTICIPATION: Students are encouraged to participate in discussion of course materials by way of question and comment. Participation also involves regular attendance, paying attention to the questions and comments of others in the class. Students who consistently participate by way of appropriate question and comment and/or have perfect attendance (i.e. NO absences) will have an advantage in the case of ‘borderline’ grades. ATTENDANCE: Any unauthorized absence during the first two weeks of class will result in the student being dropped from the course.1% for each hour of unexcused absence will be deducted from the final grade point average for the class. According to PCC policy and the State of California Education Code, MORE THAN SIX HOURS (Four [4] classes) of absence for any reason is grounds for being dropped from the class and PROHIBIT ANY GRADE FOR THE COURSE HIGHER THAN “C”. Page | 3 Extra Credit: One extra credit report worth up to 4% is possible. See attached Protocol for Extra Credit. Extra Credit points will be added to the final grade point average. SCHEDULE OF ASSIGNMENTS** ** Schedule is tentative and subject to change at Instructor's discretion. TOPICS Part One: The Nature and Study of Religion Part Two: Origins of Religion in India: Vedic Religion and Jainism Part Three: Buddhism READING Living Religions: Ch 1 Ch. 2 & Ch. 3 Ch. 4 Part Four: Chinese Religions Ch. 6 Part Five: Japanese Religions Ch. 7 Each Part will take 3 to 15 or more class hours. Pasadena City College insists on ACADEMIC HONESTY. Students are required to do their own work only and are directed to familiarize themselves with the details of this issue by comprehending the content of the Pasadena Community College District "Policy on Academic Honesty". Please see the appropriate pages in the PCC Handbook. Page | 4 Religious Studies 2 Religions of South and East Asia Dr. Ricards Protocols for Extra Credit Various ways of earning extra credit are possible by, for example, visiting religious sites (temples, ashrams, meditation centers, etc) ,and/or attending at cultural event of religious significance. One extra credit report for up to 4% points is possible. The percentage earned will be added to the final grade point average. VISIT TO TEMPLES, MUSEUMS, ASHRAMS, ETC. Visits must occur during the course of the semester. Previous visits will not count. Moreover, your visit should be to a religious tradition outside your own, although that could, for example, be going to a Buddhist temple in the Theravada tradition if you happen to be a Chinese Mahayana Buddhist. Please include any information by way of brochures and the like along with your written response to your visit. Describe the nature of the place and as much as you can about what goes on there. Be sure to include your own reactions to your visit whatever they might be. At least 2 pages, typed, single-spaced, etc. ATTENDANCE AT CULTURAL EVENT OF RELIGIOUS IMPORTANCE Same as above. At least 2 pages, typed, single-spaced, etc. OTHER POSSIBILITIES: See your instructor to discuss what you have in mind. Projects due last day of class before Final RELIGIONS OF SOUTH AND EAST ASIA Page | 5 A Religious Vocabulary* * All Vocabulary items on this very limited list from Sanscrit or Pali for Indian Buddhism and Hinduism are the writer's own transliterations from authoritative Indological sources, made in the phonetic interest of individuals with no acquaintance with these languages. Otherwise, the writer follows contemporary protocols for phonetic transliteration from Tibetan, Chinese in its various dialects, Japanese, and other Asian languages (e.g., Thai, Burmese, Lao, Indonesian). Some underlined words indicate transliterations of terms, names of divinities, or 'heroic' characters that are sometimes uncommon in English. HINDUISM I. PRE-ARYAN INDIA: Indus Valley Civilization:the Dravidians, Mohenjo Daro, Harappa, Indus “Script II. TEXTS: SHRUTI ("HEARD") and smriti ("remembered") SHRUTI (“Scripture”) The Four Vedas: Rg, Sama, Yajur, & (Atharva) The Samhitas, the Brahmanas, the Aranyakas, the Upanishads. SMRITI (“Tradition”) The Great Epics: The Ramayana: Rama, Sita, Hanuman, Ravanna The Mahabharata: The Kauravas: Dhritarashtra The Five Pandavas brothers: Yudishthira, Arjuna Bhima, Sahadeva, Nakula Draupadi: wife of the 5 Pandavas (Bhagavad-Gita and Krishna) Other texts: The Puranas, Sectarian Agamas, and various Tantras The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali Dharma Shastras, e.g.The Code of Manu Vedanta Sutras of Badarayana Works of Various Teachers, etc III. THE ARYANS & Vedic Religion: The Brahminical Tradition –to @ 500 B.C.E. The Seven Rishi The Devas Agni, Indra, Varuna, Rudra (Shiva), Soma VAC: Sacred Sound--the expression of Being (sat) The Fire Sacrifice: Tapas (“heat” – austerities) OM (aum) BRAHMAN: Sat chit ananda—the infinite awareness of blissful being, neti-neti – “not this, not that!” Page | 6 ATMAN: the core of one’s being ATMAN = BRAHMAN: tat tvam asi-“That, thou art!” Avidya – ignorance of Brahman KARMA/SAMASARA : Moral causality and the round of birth/death/rebirth IV. CLASSICAL HINDUISM ( 500 B.C.E. – 500 C.E. ) THE FOUR VARNA (‘COLORS’) CLASSES (‘caste’ = jati = subdivisions of Varna Brahmin – priests Kshatriya (Rajanya) – rulers/nobility/warriors Vaishya - merchants Shudra – servants (Outcaste Groupings -- Dalits) THE THREE (FOUR) VEDIC (HINDU) VALUES: Dharma - duty, righteousness Kama - pleasure Artha – worldly success ( MOKSHA – release, freedom liberation) THE FOUR "STAGES OF LIFE" 1. Student. 2. Householder. 3. Withdrawal. 4. Sannyasin (Jivan Mukti THREE TRADITIONAL MARGAS (YOGAS) Karma Marga //Yoga Bhakti Marga / Yoga Jyana (Jnana) Marga / Yoga (Raja Yoga of Patanjali) V. MEDIEVAL HINDUISM ( 500 C.E – 1500 C.E.) THE INDIAN THEIGONY The TRIMURTI: THE Purusha – ”supreme person” (The personal God) Brahma, Vishnu (Narayana), Shiva Consorts of the Gods: Saraswati, Lakshmi, Shri Devi Mounts (Vehicles) of the Gods THE TANTRIC REVOLUTION: 6001200 (and beyond) The Universe is sacred body of the Goddess and her fertile sexual fluids are ritually employed to produce siddhis -- “Powerful ones”. Immortality and alchemy. Page | 7 THE SIX ORTHODOX DARSHANAS (VIEWPOINTS) 1 & 2: Samkya/Yoga (Distinctionism / Raja Yoga) Prakriti – ‘matter’composed of the Three Gunas (qualities): rajas-- passion/energy; sattvas-- lucidity/mind; tamas-- darkness/inertia 3 & 4: Nyaya / Vaisheshika (Logic / "Atomism") 5. Purva Vedanta: Mimamsa (Exegesis): The Prior Vedanta (Meaning of the Veda) 6. Uttara (Final) Vedanta: A. Advaita Vedanta -- Shankaracharya B. “Qualified” Non-Dualism – Ramanujacharya C. Other schools VI. MODERN HINDUISM 1500 —> PRESENT THE FOUR MAJOR CONTEMPORARY SAMPRADAYA (pathways) 1. Shaivism and 2. Shaktism Shiva / Shakti SHRI DEVI (The Goddess) : Kali, Durga, Parvati, Chamunda, Bhoo Devi,. Sons of Shiva : Ganesha ; Kartikkeya/Skanda/Subramaniyan Tantric Hinduism Kundalini Yoga 3. Vaishnavism: VISHNU / Lakshmi KRISHNA (of Vrindavan) Radha and the Gopis –“milkmaids Avatars of Vishnu: Rama, Krishna, Narasingha, Buddha, etc. The Alvars -- Poets of Bhakti (Devotional religion) 4. Smarta (liberal, based on Smriti) Hinduism 5. Guru Marga VII. RECENT EVENTS, MOVEMENTS: THE RAJ: British India; ARYA SAMAJ (Devananda Saraswati) BRAHMO SAMAJ ( Rob Mohan Roy) HINDUTVA Page | 8 JAINISM I. Texts: The Jaina Sutras Sectarian Literature II. Important Figures and Concepts Mahavira – “Great Hero” = Vardhamanaa Nattaputra Tirthankara – The “Ford-Finder” across the river of samsara Asceticism – starve out impurities Kevala – complete liberation from samsara as utterly pure jiva Isatpragbhara – transcendental state of the liberated jiva Karma (Jaina View) - a subtle to gross matter clinging to everything, all actions have karmic effects. Samsara – the round of birth/death/rebirth Hylozoism – everything is alive, “ensouled”. Jiva – “soul/living being” Ajiva – non-soul/non-living = Karmic matter Ahimsa – “Non-injury”, respect for all life Three Major Sects: Digambaras – Sky-clad Shvetambaras – White Clad Sthanakvadins – Worship in austere quarters to avoid appearance of idolatry Page | 9 BUDDHISM I. Texts: A. The Pali Canon (Tripitaka : “Three Baskets”) Sutta Pitaka Vinaya Pitaka Abhidhamma Pitaka B. Mahayana Sutra Literature Lotus Sutra (Saddharma Pundarika Sutra) Perfection of Wisdom Sutras (Prajnaparamita Sutra) Diamond Sutra Heart Sutra Avatamsaka (Garland) Sutra Various Tantras (yogic handbooks, manuals) II. Persons, Places, Concepts, Movements, Events A. Historical Background The Buddhadharma: The Middle Way: The Teaching of the Buddha Siddartha Gautama (Gotama), The Buddha, “The Awakened One” Shakyamuni – The Sage of the Shakyas The Bodhisatva (1)’Buddha-to-be’ Kapilavastu(Lumbini): Birth // Kushinara: Death King Shudhodana – Father of The Buddha Queen Maya – Mother of The Buddha Yashodara – Wife of the Buddha Rahula – Son of the Buddha B. THE FOUR SIGHTS: 1)sickness, 2)old age, 3)death,4) a sannyasin. The “Great Renunciation”: 6 years study with Yogic Teachers and practice of extreme asceticism Bodhgaya – Place of Bodhi under the “Bo Tree”. P a g e | 10 C. BODHI / ENLIGHTENMENT The Four Dhyana (trance states) The Six "Superknowledges" The Three "Cognitions" D. The Triratna (Triple Gem): Buddha, Dharma, Sangha P a g e | 11 THE FOUR NOBLE TRUTHS (CATTARI ARIYASACCANI – Pali) Truth 1 presents the content of the first Three Sights. Truths 2 - 4 derive from the experience of Bodhi. [Pali spelling is usually given first, with Sanscrit (Skt.) spelling as noted.] 1. The Truth of Suffering: ***Samsara is Dukkha (Duhkha, Skt.) -- life is unsatisfactory Dukkha (Duhkha, Skt.) = unsatisfactoriness: suffering, physical and mental, dsease, rebirth, decay, death, conjunction with the hated, separation from the dear. We want what we cannot have; we attach the selves we think we are to things that have no substantial existence. We do not understand the nature of things -- ignorance/avidya 2. The Truth of the Cause of Suffering: Dukkha is caused by Tanha (Trishna, Skt.; lit., ‘thirst’) Tanha / Trishna: Ignorant craving, inordinate desire, is the desire to pull apart from the rest of life, to seek fulfillment in the isolated illusory ego. The will to private fulfillment. All the inclinations which tend to continue or increase separateness of the self including all forms of selfishness at the expense of other sentient beings. What's wrong with desire? Tanha is the source of dukkha because there is no-thing out there which can be possessed and no one to do the possessing. All is "boundless openness". Anicca ( anitya, Skt.)-- Impermanence. away. What begins, ends. Everything changes, moves, slips The world is not composed of things, of objective essences which could possibly be possessed. But this also means that there is an end to duhkha, as well: "Because there is an unborn, an unmade, an uncompounded, there is liberation from the born, the made, and the compounded." Anatta (anatman, Skt.) -- no 'atman', no 'soul'. We are not who/what we think we are. We are not soul-substances with "own-being". Illustrations: Questions of King Milinda: The Lamp, the Chariot; “the sound of my voice’; memory : Oliver Sachs' "Lost Mariner"; Regarding Henry. The empirical, conventional self/ego is illusory. Buddhist analysis of the empirical self discloses it as an energetic, momentarily configured process composed of the interaction of five skandhas (strands, grasping bundles, ‘vectored energies’) of: -- body, our material component -- feelings/affective states, emotions -- perceptions, physical and mental -- karmic dispositions, habits of action P a g e | 12 -- states of consciousness Paticca-Samuppada (Pratitya-samutpada--Skt.) -- co-dependent arising, universal relativity, nothing has its own private 'own-being'. Everything depends on everything else. There is no independent, self-existing anything anywhere. All is “Boundless Openness”. Also, pratitya samutpada refers to the 12-fold chain of causation: ignorancedispositions consciousnessname and form the six sense fields contact feeling craving appropriation becomingbirth aging and dying. . . and on to ignorance again. 3. The Truth of the Cessation of Suffering: Removing Tanha removes Dukkha. Pull out the poisoned arrow, the wound heals. 4. The Truth of the Way to the Cessation of Suffering: The way to remove Tanha is the Eightfold Path THE EIGHTFOLD PATH (ATHANGIKA MARGA) “Right “ here has the connotation of "perfect". Right, "perfect" comprehension of the Eightfold Path comes only with Bodhi, enlightenment, FREEDOM.) 1 & 2 are Prajna – wisdom 1. Right Views -- a, for now provisional, acceptance of the Buddhadharma as true. 2. Right Intention -- one intends to follow the path to its fruition in nirvana acting with lovingkindness and compassion towards all sentient creatures. 3, 4, & 5 are Shila- morality 3. Right Speech 4. Right Action 5. Right Occupation Buddhist ethics are partly "Consequentialist", specifically, right and wrong are judged in terms of whether the speech, action, occupation lead toward or away from Bodhi both for oneself and others, but the intention of the agent is also a factor in gauging its rightness. Key here is the fundamental notion of Ahimsa – Harmlessness; but ignorant, even though well-intentioned actions have only common-sense [but sometimes unfortunate, even deadly, but not karmic,] consequences. [E.g., the Monkeys in the garden.] Three Poisons are to be avoided: greed (lust), hatred, ignorance. THE FIVE PRECEPTS: All Buddhists are enjoined to take the Five Precepts: 1. Not to kill, 2. Not to lie, 3. Not to take anything that is not given (or bought, for laity), P a g e | 13 4. To abstain from sexual impropriety, 5. To avoid intoxicants. THE TEN PRECEPTS: Monastics take five further vows. 6. Eating only at prescribed times 7. Refraining from music, dancing, singing, and stage plays (movies these days). Exceptions are possible, depending on whether attendance at such events conduces or not to Bodhi. 8. No fancy perfumes 9. No "high" bed 10. No handling money. This prohibition is now considerably modified, due to the cash economies of current societies, as opposed to the largely barter economies of India in the 5th cent. bce. 6, 7, & 8 are Samadhi - spiritual practices. Mindfulness meditation (vipassana) is specifically enjoined here. 6. Right Effort: There are four types of Right Effort: -- To prevent evil, unwholesome (mental) states from arising -- To abandon them if they should arise -- To generate wholesome states not yet existing -- To maintain wholesome states without lapse, causing them to develop and reach full growth and perfection 7. Right Mindfulness: This is mindfulness meditation, or vipassana, anchored in awareness of breathing, and progressing through awareness of mind states and their associations with vedana, bodily sensations and their karmic origins. 8. Right Concentration: Further cultivation of specific trance states -- the Buddha enumerates eight – beginning with awareness of the breath and progressing through ever more subtle and important levels of the mind. (See Conze, Buddhist Meditation, for further information.) P a g e | 14 III. BUDDHISM IN DEVELOPMENT A. Early Buddhism: The Mahasangikas and Sthaviras B. THERAVADA (SOUTHERN) BUDDHISM : The Way of the Elders (aka HINAYANA) Emphasis on Vipassana meditation, with little ritualizing Goal: The Arhat C. MAHAYANA (NORTHERN) BUDDHISM Prajna (‘wisdom’ – “skill in means” – insight into reality) Karuna (compassion) Goal: The Bodhisattva Ideal Central “Insight”: Samsara = Nirvana The Trikaya: Dharmakaya, Samboghakaya, Nirmanakaya Yogachara School (“Mind Only” – Buddhist Idealism) Madhyamika School (Radical negation in the service of Bodhi) Nagarjuna – Premier Buddhalogian of the Madhyamika Celestial Bodhisattvas and Dhyani (meditation) Buddhas: Avalokiteshvara = Kwan Yin = Tara = Amida Buddha (Amitabha) Vairochana = Adi Buddha = Vajrasattva = Samantabhadra Maitreya Buddha Manjushri D. TIBETAN BUDDHISM [Vajrayana (Tantric) Buddhism] Bon Shamanism – indigeneous animism of Tibet Padmasambhava – Tantric master from India to Tibet Red Hats (Nyingmapa)— “Old School” Yellow Hats (Gelugpa) – Reformed School of Tsongkapa The Dalai Lama -- incarnation of Avalokiteshvara The Panchen Lama – incarnation of Amitabha Deity Yogas – identification with celestial Bodhisatvas Tantric sex yoga – overcome passion through passion Wrathful Protector Deities (fierce protectors of Dharma) P a g e | 15 Paldan Lhamo, Mahakala, others RELIGIONS OF CHINESE ORIGIN: “FAMILY RELIGION”, CONFUCIANISM AND TAOISM I. TEXTS: The Five Classics: I Ching, etc. The Analects of Confucius The Book of Mencius The Dao Deh Ching (Tao Teh Ching) II. The Great Church: “Three Rivers flowing into One” Confucianism, Daoism, and Buddhism as one religion, built upon the duties of Filiality (Hsiao) and a sense of the Sacred pervading all of life. III. FAMILY RELIGION--"Ancestor Worship" The centrality of Hsiao and Li Funerary Rites and Duties to the Ancestors IV. DAOISM (Taoism) Philosophical Daoism “Anarchistic Naturalism” Laozi (Lao-tse) Zhuangzi (Chuang-tse) DAO: Yin/Yang Wu-wei ('non-acting' ): active letting-be) Religious and “Church” Daoism Shangdi/Tian – God on high/”Heaven” The Jade Emperor – Popular name for the High God Tudigung (local ‘earth god’) V. CONFUCIANISM: Juchiao—The Scholar’s Way: “Law and Order” ; The Five Relations Confucius (Kung fu-tsu: Master Kung) Mencius (Meng Fu-tsu) Tian Ming Destiny Hsiao (Filiality) Li (ritualized propriety in behavior) Shu (reciprocity) Chung (loyalty) Ren (human-heartedness) Chih (learning) P a g e | 16 Chung-Yung ("the middle way") JAPANESE RELIGION I. SHINTO (Shen Dao -- from the Chinese) -- The Sacred Way Texts: The Kojiki and Nihongi Persons, Places, Concepts, Movements, Events Kami No Michi – “The Way of the Kami” Kami – awe-inspiring powers of the natural and human worlds Amaterasu – Sun Kami Shentai – sacred repositories of Kami Power Shrine Shinto State Shinto Bushido – The Warrior’s Code The Tokugawa Shogunate (16th-19th cents.) The Meiji Restoration (mid-19th cent.) Japanese Imperialism "Emperor Worship" II. Japanese Buddhism A. Shin Buddhism (Pure Land Buddhism): Salvation by "other power" Amida Buddha – Buddha of infinite life, & compassion Nembutsu – ritual invocation of Amida Buddha “Namo Amida Butsu – I rely on Amida Buddha” Shinran – ‘apostle’ of Pure Land Nichiren - “ “ “ “ and devotion to the Lotus Sutra B. Zen Buddhism: Salvation by "own power" Soto School / Zazen - ‘sitting meditation’ Rinzai School / Koan – Zen Riddle C. Shingon Buddhism: Japanese Tantric Buddhism Ritual devotion to Vairochana Buddha" D. “New Religions” Tenrikyo – Sacred Heavenly Parent P a g e | 17 Dr. Ricards RS2Handout 1 I.THE STUDY OF RELIGION A. Introduction 1. What is Religion? 2. Working definition: A human seeking of and responding to what is experienced as “holy/sacred” B. Similarities among Religions 1. Substantive (Essential): a. There is a Holy Reality. b. Human Fulfillment comes by being in harmony or subordination to that Reality c. Belief in the reality of a fundamental moral order 2. Functional: Emotional, Social, Intellectual 3. Formal: Conceptual, Performative, Social, C. Types 1. 2. 3. 4. of Religion Cosmic Acosmic Historical Mixed Types D. Approaches to the Study of Religion: 1. ETIC 2. EMIC II.THE HISTORY OF RELIGIONS A. Issues concerning the origins of religion 1. Anthropological theories: Tylor & Animism; Codrington & Marret: Mana 2. Sociological Theories: Durckheim & Totemism B. Critiques of A. C. Issues in the evolutionary explanation of religion 1. J. G. Frazier: ages of "magic, religion, science" 2. Other theories: Goddess theory; “entheogenic” plants D. Critiques of C. E. Robert Bellah’s Neo-Evolutionary Classification 1. Primal 2. Archaic 3. Classical 4. Modern