THE COLD WAR 1945-1990 CAUSES OF THE COLD WAR “Causes” Debated • Consistent US, British, & French hostility towards Soviets since 1917 revolution • Stalin’s aggressive policies & seizure of Poland made West fear Soviet expansionism • Suspicions throughout WWII • Truman ended aid to Stalin’s troops immediately in 1945 • Stalin thought Soviet Union needed a “buffer” zone in Europe – Truman viewed it as communist takeover – US officials portrayed Stalin as a tyrant END OF WWII • During and before WWII, there was a mistrust between the western Allies and the Soviet Union – Stalin’s crimes were known – Feared communism • End of the war = 2 superpowers emerged – United States – democracy; capitalist – Soviet Union – communist • Quickly began spreading influence in respective spheres Different Goals United States • Encourage democracy • Prevent spread of Communist governments • Gain access to markets & raw materials to fuel industry • Rebuild European governments for stability & trade • Reunite Germany to stabilize it & increase security of Europe Soviet Union • Encourage communism & global workers’ revolution • Rebuild war-ravaged economy using Eastern Europe’s industrial equipment & raw materials • Control Eastern Europe to protect borders & balance US influence • Keep Germany divided to prevent its waging war again The Iron Curtain • US allied with other democratic/capitalist nations & spread its influence to others emerging from WWII – Major Allies = Great Britain & France – Additionally = Spain, W. Germany, Italy, Turkey, Norway, Greece • Soviet Union occupied much of Eastern Europe – Red Army had liberated area from Nazi control – Nations became satellite states of the USSR – Installed communist governments – Poland, E. Germany, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, Romania, Bulgaria • Churchill nicknamed the division in Europe “the Iron Curtain” Division of Germany • Agreements at Yalta & Potsdam Peace Conferences split Germany into 4 occupied zones – – • Disagreement on how to treat Germany – – • US – reprogram German attitude through censorship & confronting Nazi past USSR – crush Nazism (extreme capitalism) with communism & redistribute land Western Allies merged individual zones into West Germany in 1948 – – – • Each controlled by Allied victor – Great Britain, France, US, and Soviet Union Berlin (capital) also split – East & West Escalated Cold War tensions US also began economic buildup of W. Germany through Marshall Plan aid Notions of permanently weakened Germany ended by ‘48 Stalin retaliated by blockading Berlin – – Berlin surrounded by USSR occupied zone – cut off railways to bring in supplies Allies responded with the Berlin Airlift 19481949 • • Dropped food, supplies, & even coal to Berliners Stalin ended blockade May 1949 COLD WAR CHARACTERISTICS Cold War Leaders Soviet Union • • • • • • • • Led by leader of the Communist Party Joseph Stalin [1920s-1953] Georgy Malenkov [1953-1955] Nikita Krushchev [19551964] Leonid Brezhnev [1964-1982] Yuri Andropov [1982-1984] Constantin Cherenko [19841985] Mikhail Gorbachev [19851991] United States • • • • • • • • • Led by democratically elected President Dwight D. Eisenhower [1953]1961] John F. Kennedy [1961-1963] Lyndon B. Johnson [19631969] Richard Nixon [1969-1974] Gerald Ford [1974-1977] Jimmy Carter [1977-1981] Ronald Reagan [1981-1989] George H.W. Bush [19891993] • US Foreign Policy Concepts Truman Doctrine, 1947 – – US provides political, military, & economic aid to democratic nations under threat from external or internal authoritarian forces Justified intervention in countries at risk of falling to communism • • – • Reoriented foreign policy away from isolation to one of intervention in far away conflicts Marshall Plan [European Recovery Program] 1948 – – – – – – • Example = aided Greek government against communists in its civil war in 1940s Example = aided Turkey, which had lost British aid US initiative to aid Europe & Asia in postwar recovery named for Sect. of State George C. Marshall Rebuild European economies to be stable for trade Gave $13 Billion [$120B today] – most to Great Britain, France, and West Germany Fanned by fear of communist expansion & rapid deterioration of European economies in the winter of 1946-47 Generated resurgence of European industrialization & increased investment Very suspicious to Moscow Containment, 1947-1989 – – – – Foreign policy developed by George F. Kennan Basic strategy for the Cold War – keep communism & Russian domination from spreading Counter “Soviet pressure against free institutions of the Western world” through “counter-force at a series of constantly shifting geographical and political points” Very controversial – required US to intervene wherever Soviets had eyes Opposing Alliances • North Atlantic Treaty Organization, 1949 [NATO] – Military alliance of Western European & North American states – Against USSR & its Eastern European allies – Attack on any one member armed force by all member nations • Warsaw Pact, 1955 – Treaty binding the Soviet Union and countries of Eastern Europe – Formed in response to NATO Nuclear Arms Race & MAD • • World saw US use nuclear bombs at end of WWII Prompted race to build up nuclear capabilities among developed nations – – • Harsh words heightened tension & threat of using atomic weapons – – – • Eisenhower: US would reduce USSR to “a smoking, radiating ruin at the end of two hours” Khrushchev: “We will bury you.” Brinkmanship – tactic of appearing to be on the verge of war to persuade the opposition to retreat Tensions almost erupted in war in 1962: Cuban Missile Crisis – – – • USSR wanted parity with US Other Western Allies also developed nuclear weapons Soviet Union deployed missiles to Cuba in response to US attempts to overthrow Cuban government Soviets supported Castro Chose diplomacy over war in the end Nuclear weapons never used though due to theory of mutually assured destruction – – – Use of bomb on one side would cause use by the other Nuclear holocaust End of mankind? • • Nuclear Arms Limits Nuclear Test Ban Treaty, 1963 – US, USSR, & Great Britain – USSR had been building an Anti-Ballistic Missile defense around Moscow, enabling them to launch a missile & then shoot down incoming ones… Believed limiting development of offensive & defensive systems would stabilize USSR-US relations Continued by Nixon Johnson called for strategic arms limitation talks [SALT] in 1967 – – • • • 1968 – US & USSR proposed world treaty against further proliferation, leading to the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty signed by 137 countries Negotiated weapons limits 1972 Helsinki Accords – • Affirmed boundaries & called for economic, social, & governmental contacts and cooperation in humanitarian fields between two alliances SALT II – built upon SALT in 1972-1979 – – – – – SALT I didn’t prevent each side from enlarging their forces SALT II focused on limiting & ultimately reducing Multiple Independently Targeted Re-Entry Vehicles [MIRVs] Ford & Brezhnev agreed on basic framework in Nov. 1974 Still didn’t have # cap on strategic bombers or total # warheads Carter & Brezhnev signed SALT II Treaty in Vienna 1979 • • • • Limited nuclear forces to 2,250 delivery vehicles Variety of other restrictions, including MIRVs Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty pursued by Reagan after SALT II’s expiration 1985 – Argued that research in the Strategic Defense Initiative adhered to 1972 treaty… – – – Vietnam shocked people Growing fear of nuclear holocaust Increased talks & visitation of leaders Détente – permanetn relaxation in international affairs in the Cold War Space Race • Coincided with nuclear arms race • Battling science & technology for greatness • Contest to launch space satellites – Soviet Union launched Sputnik into orbit in 1957 – US launched own satellite 3 months later • US placed first men on the moon – Neil Armstrong & Buzz Aldrin – in 1969 • • Proxy Wars US & USSR didn’t directly battle each other, rather they supported opposing sides in other conflicts Cuba, 1950s--– – – – • Nicaragua, 1970s – – – – – • USSR supported Castro regime US assisted former dictator Batista CIA even trained anti-Castro Cuban exiles in 1960, invading (and failing miserably) in April 1961 at Bay of Pigs Augmented by Cuban Missile Crisis Dictator Somoza funded by the US, but both US and USSR aided the rebel Sandinistas and their leader Daniel Ortega Sandinistas toppled leader in 1979, then gave assistance to other Marxist Rebels in El Salvador US supported anti-Communist forces – Contras – to help El Salvador fight rebels Civil War lasted more than a decade & weakened Nicaraguan economy Ortega did hold free elections in 1990, when he was beaten, but later reelected in 2006 Iran, 1950s – – – Oil-rich lands attracted both superpowers US supported the Shah in westernization & suppressing conservative Muslim leaders, including Ayatollah Rubolla Khomeini Khomeini returned from exile & established an Islamic state, requiring strict adherence to Islam • • • Hatred of US at heart of foreign policy Encouraged Muslims everywhere to overthrow secular governments War erupted with Iraq in 1980 – US secretly aided both sides; USSR aided Iraq 1M died before UN negotiated ceasefire in 1988 THE COLD WAR THAWS Khrushchev Thaw • Came to power in 1953 after Stalin’s death • Embarked on de-Stalinization, denouncing his jailing & killing of loyal Soviets • Called for peaceful competition with capitalist states • Did not change life in satellite countries – Resentment turned to active protest • Hungary 1956 – Imre Nagy formed new government & demanded end of Soviet troops’ occupation Soviet tanks & infantry entered Budapest • Thousands of freedom fighters armed, but overwhelmed • Nagy executed • Pro-Soviet government installed by Moscow • Lost prestige after Cuban Missile Crisis • Party leaders removed him in 1963 Détente • Nixon moved toward détente – lessening tensions of the 1970s • First president to visit communist country [China] in 1972 • Began Strategic Arms Limitation Talks [SALT] in 1972 • Visited Moscow in 1972 • Brezhnev visited Washington DC in 1973 • Helsinki Accords signed 1975 – US, USSR, & major Western powers accepted European frontiers established after WWII – Recognized West & East Germany – Agreed to provide for human rights, incl. freedom of speech Brezhnev Repression • • • Succeeded Nikita Khrushchev as First Secretary of the Soviet Communist Party Oct. 15, 1964 Adopted repressive domestic policies – – – – Laws limited freedom of speech & worship Government censorship Clamped down on protestors Secret police arrested many, expelled from USSR, or executed – Use of Warsaw Pact forces to intervene in any Eastern Bloc nation which was seen to compromise communist rule & Soviet domination Foreign Policy = “Brezhnev Doctrine,” 1968 • • • – – • • Moderating policies… Leaving Soviet sphere of influence… “Each Communist Party is responsible not only to its own people, but also to all socialist countries, to the entire Communist movement.” Evident prominently in the Prague Spring, 1968 Czechoslovakia Note – term used by the Western media, not necessarily Brezhnev or the USSR itself Equipped Arab states with weapons in the Six Day War [Middle East, 1960s] By the time of his death in Nov. 1982, a thaw was detected in Cold War tensions – – Had met with Richard Nixon USSR didn’t have economic base to cope with cost of the Cold War [unlike US] Gorbachev – Final Impetus • • Entered office in 1985 – – 54 years old = younger than predecessors New outlook on challenges facing USSR – Had been engaged in unsuccessful war in Afghanistan people pressuring for an exit – – – Uprisings & calls for looser controls on satellite nations in Eastern Europe Economy struggling Citizens chafing under poor standard of living & lack of freedom – Glasnost – “political openness” USSR losing ground & hold on territory • • Installed major reforms to avoid total collapse • • • – – • Gorbachev exited war in 1989 Sought to ease strict controls imposed on citizens Greater freedom to the media & religious groups Included democratization by 1988 Perestroika - “restructuring” of economic problems; moving away from state planning Determined to end nuclear rivalry with US, pursuing negotiations with Reagan 1985-1988 Swept communist governments in E. Europe from power & ended Cold War within 5 years – – Decided to abandon Soviet control of E. European nations 1988 – declared all nations should be free to choose their own course without outside interference Ending the Cold War • • • Gorbachev hoped reforms would modernize & revitalize Soviet Union Unleashed social forces that dissolved the USSR 1989 – Communist regimes fell in Poland, Hungary, E. Germany, Czechoslovakia, Bulgaria, & Romania – Berlin Wall fell • • 1990 – Discussions for reunification of Germany Meanwhile, Gorbachev adopted more conservative policies in Soviet Union, remaining committed to socialism – Angry Communists attempted to remove Gorbachev from power 1991 by staging a coup • Failed due to efforts of Boris Yeltsin, president of Russian Republic – most powerful political figure – But, by end of the year Yeltsin & other reformers completely undid the old order – Soviet Union dissolved into 15 individual republics – Gorbachev resigned from presidency (of a non-existent nation at that point) on Dec. 25, 1991 EFFECTS OF THE COLD WAR End of the Bloc • 15 new independent states emerged – Armenia, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Estonia, Georgia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Latvia, Lithuania, Moldova, Russia, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, Ukraine, & Uzbekistan • Allied under the Commonwealth of Independent States [CIS] in 1991 – Also called the Russian Commonwealth – Loose association of states • Belarus, Russian Federation, Ukraine originally • Then Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Moldova, Turkmenistan, Tajikistan, & Uzbekistan • Today = 9 member states [Armenia, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Moldova, Russia, Tajikistan, & Uzbekistan] + Ukraine [participating state] & Turkmenistan [associate state] – Few supranational powers; more symbolic • Coordinates trade, finance, lawmaking, and security • Cooperation on cross-border crime prevention End of the Bipolar World • During Cold War, world was bipolar with the US and USSR as superpowers • After the war, the international system was unipolar – United States sole world superpower – By 1989, had military alliances with 50 countries & 1.5M troops in 117 countries • New terminology – Before: • First World – US & Western Allies • Second World – USSR & Allies • Third World – nonaligned nations; developing states in Africa, Asia, & South America – Now: • Developed – US, Canada, Western Europe, Russia, Japan, & other industrialized states • Developing – non-industrial or industrializing nations of Asia, Africa, South America, and eastern Europe Russia Under Yeltsin • • Most powerful figure in the Commonwealth of Independent States = President of Russia Problems – ailing economy, political opposition, & unpopular war in Chechnya – Military spending cut dramatically, leaving many unemployed – Suffered recession worse than the Great Depression – Standard of living worsened overall in Russia • Goal to reform economy with shock therapy – shift to free-market economies – – – – Lowered trade barriers Removed price controls Ended subsidies to state-owned industries Initially, prices & inflation soared at 800% [normal is 2%] • • Thousands out of work Fueled political crisis – – • Yeltsin ordered troops to bombard building of legislators who opposed him Opponents accused Yeltsin of acting like a dictator Resigned in 1999 – Vladimir Putin took over War in Chechnya • Largely Muslim area in Southwestern Russia • Declared its independence in 1991 – Yeltsin denied its right to secede • Ordered 40,000 troops to the area in 1994 • Reduced capital of Grozny to rubble – Sparked anger throughout Russia • Yeltsin sought to end war because an election was coming [needed popularity] – Signed ceasefire – Was reelected • War broke again between Russia & Chechnya, lasting through the decade Russia Under Putin • Took office 1999 • Forcefully dealt with rebellion in Chechnya, but violence continues in the region – War drew terrorism into Moscow 2002 – seized a theater & killed 150 people – Popular support for war faded – Putin moved to suppress critics – Chechen elections helped restore order in 2005 – Rebels largely quieted by 2010, but rebellion simmers • Economic, social, & political problems to address – Growth in homelessness, domestic violence, unemployment, decreased life expectancy – Moved to greater participation in world trade, modernizing banking, insurance, and tax codes – Attacks on free press – unpopular worldwide Crimea & Ukraine • Russia began sending military equipment & troops into Ukraine following Feb. 2014 Ukrainian Revolution – Soldiers began taking control of strategic positions in Crimea – Russia then annexed Crimea • Demonstrations by pro-Russian groups in Donbass area escalated into armed conflict between separatist forces & Ukrainian government – Intensive troop movement continued & fought in eastern Ukraine according to human rights groups [Russia denies claims] • Annexation met harsh resistance from international community – Largely ethnic Russian population with historic ties to Russia – Was part of Ukraine, but was annexed during turbulent time in Ukrainian government – Economic sanctions from US and UN • • • Annexation illegal? Use of military force elsewhere in Europe? Western world largely denounced war as part of foreign policy likely to only see economic sanctions – US pledged $1B to Ukraine on Mar. 4, 2014 – NATO deployed ships & air force monitoring in the Baltics & Poland Other Cold War Legacies • Loss of life in proxy wars, incl. Korea & Vietnam – • Economic & social tensions – – – • • • Plus interstate, ethnic, and revolutionary wars in postSoviet nations Newly founded states inherited expenses, commitments, & resources they weren’t prepared for National security burdens Environmental contamination legacies Increased # liberal democracies, esp. Eastern Europe New technology for nuclear power & energy + radiation for medical treatments Military development & spending has continued, esp. with nuclear-armed ballistic missiles & defense systems – – – No formal treaty ending war Still have disincentives to developing new nuclear facilities US & Russia inherited responsibilities & costs of maintaining nuclear arsenals • • • • • • US – 7,315 warheads Russia – 8,000 warheads France – 300 China - 250 Great Britain – 225 Pakistan, Israel, India, & North Korea too (<150 each) ANALYSIS ESSAY Explain how & why differences in What were they? What were they in the postwar period? ideologies and policies between the United What does this mean? States and the USSR resulted in a cold war, the formation of new alliances, and Who was allied together in the West? The East? How is this diff. from before? periodic military clashes. When did this happen? Cuban Missile Crisis & Bay of Pigs…