Chapter 10 Radical Reactions Created by Professor William Tam & Dr. Phillis Chang Ch. 10 - 1 About The Authors These Powerpoint Lecture Slides were created and prepared by Professor William Tam and his wife Dr. Phillis Chang. Professor William Tam received his B.Sc. at the University of Hong Kong in 1990 and his Ph.D. at the University of Toronto (Canada) in 1995. He was an NSERC postdoctoral fellow at the Imperial College (UK) and at Harvard University (USA). He joined the Department of Chemistry at the University of Guelph (Ontario, Canada) in 1998 and is currently a Full Professor and Associate Chair in the department. Professor Tam has received several awards in research and teaching, and according to Essential Science Indicators, he is currently ranked as the Top 1% most cited Chemists worldwide. He has published four books and over 80 scientific papers in top international journals such as J. Am. Chem. Soc., Angew. Chem., Org. Lett., and J. Org. Chem. Dr. Phillis Chang received her B.Sc. at New York University (USA) in 1994, her M.Sc. and Ph.D. in 1997 and 2001 at the University of Guelph (Canada). She lives in Guelph with her husband, William, and their son, Matthew. Ch. 10 - 2 1. Introduction: How Radicals Form and How They React Heterolysis A B heterolytic bond cleavage A + B ions Homolysis A B homolytic bond cleavage A + B radicals Ch. 10 - 3 1A. Production of Radicals Homolysis of covalent bonds ● Need heat or light (hn) R O Cl O Cl R heat hn (alkoxyl radical) 2R O (chlorine radical) 2 Cl Ch. 10 - 4 1B. Reactions of Radicals Almost all small radicals are short-lived, highly reactive species Cl + H CH3 H + CH3 Cl R R + C C C C Ch. 10 - 5 2. Homolytic Bond Dissociation Energies (DH°) H + H H H Ho = 436 kJ/mol Cl + Cl Cl Ho = 243 kJ/mol Cl H H H + H Ho = 436 kJ/mol Cl Cl Cl + Cl Ho = 243 kJ/mol Bond formation is an exothermic process. Reactions in which only bond breaking occurs are always endothermic. Ch. 10 - 6 The energies required to break covalent bonds homolytically are called homolytic bond dissociation energies, and they are usually abbreviated by the symbol DH ° Ch. 10 - 7 Single-Bond Homolytic Dissociation Energies (DH°) at 25°C Bond Broken kJ/mol H–H 436 F–F 159 Cl–Cl 243 Br–Br 193 I–I 151 Ch. 10 - 8 Single-Bond Homolytic Dissociation Energies (DH°) at 25°C Bond Broken kJ/mol H–F 570 H–Cl 432 H–Br 366 H–I 298 Ch. 10 - 9 Single-Bond Homolytic Dissociation Energies (DH°) at 25°C Bond Broken kJ/mol Bond Broken kJ/mol H3C–H 440 H3C–F 461 H3C–Cl 352 H3C–Br 293 H3C–OH 387 H3C–I 240 H3C–OCH3 348 Ch. 10 - 10 Single-Bond Homolytic Dissociation Energies (DH°) at 25°C Bond Broken Cl Cl Cl kJ/mol Bond Broken Br 354 355 349 Br Br kJ/mol 294 298 292 Ch. 10 - 11 Single-Bond Homolytic Dissociation Energies (DH°) at 25°C Bond Broken H H Ph kJ/mol Bond Broken H 423 413 H 400 H 375 Ph HC C kJ/mol 369 H 465 H 474 H 547 Ch. 10 - 12 2A. Use Homolytic Bond Dissociation Energies to Calculate Heats of Reaction o o (DH = 432 kJ/mol) ☓ 2 (DH = 436 kJ/mol) o (DH = 243 kJ/mol) H H + Cl +679 kJ is required to cleave 1 mol of H2 bonds and 1 mol of Cl2 bonds Cl 2H Cl -864 kJ is evolved in formation of bonds in 2 mol of HCl Ch. 10 - 13 o H = 2 (432 kJ/mol) + (436 kJ/mol + 243 kJ/mol) = 864 kJ/mol + 679 kJ/mol = 185 kJ/mol Overall, the reaction of 1 mol of H2 and 1 mol of Cl2 to form 2 mol of HCl is exothermic Ch. 10 - 14 2B. Use Homolytic Bond Dissociation Energies to Determine the Relative Stabilities of Radicals Ho = +423 kJ/mol H + H Propyl radical (a 1o radical) Ho = +413 kJ/mol + H H Isopropyl radical (a 2o radical) Ch. 10 - 15 + tert-Butyl radical H (a 3o radical) H Ho = +400 kJ/mol H + Isobutyl radical (a 1o radical) H Ho = +422 kJ/mol Ch. 10 - 16 Relative Stability ● Carbon radicals are considered to be electron deficient (similar to carbocations), thus electron donating groups stabilize radicals o C o 3 >2 >1 CH3 CH3 o H CH3 > CH3 C H CH3 > CH3 C H H>H C H (positive inductive effect of alkyl groups stabilize radical) Ch. 10 - 17 3. The Reactions of Alkanes with Halogens Alkanes have no functional group and are inert to many reagents and do not undergo many reactions Halogenation of alkanes is one of the most typical free radical reactions Ch. 10 - 18 Alkanes react with molecular halogens to produce alkyl halides by a substitution reaction called radical halogenation R H + X2 heat or light (hn) R X + H X Ch. 10 - 19 3A. Multiple Halogen Substitution H H C H H + Cl2 heat or light H H C Cl Cl + H H C H +H Cl H Cl + Cl C Cl Cl + Cl C Cl Cl Cl Ch. 10 - 20 3B. Lack of Chlorine Selectivity Chlorination of most higher alkanes gives a mixture of isomeric monochloro products as well as more highly halogenated compounds ● Chlorine is relatively unselective; it does not discriminate greatly among the different types of hydrogen atoms (primary, secondary, and tertiary) in an alkane Ch. 10 - 21 Cl2 Cl + light Isobutane Isobutyl chloride (48%) Cl tert-Butyl chloride (29%) Polichlorinated + + HCl products (23%) ● Because alkane chlorinations usually yield a complex mixture of products, they are not useful as synthetic methods when the goal is preparation of a specific alkyl chloride Ch. 10 - 22 ● An exception is the halogenation of an alkane (or cycloalkane) whose hydrogen atoms are all equivalent. [Equivalent hydrogen atoms are defined as those which on replacement by some other group (e.g., chlorine) yield the same compound.] Ch. 10 - 23 + Cl2 Neopentane (excess) heat or light Cl + H Cl Neopentyl chloride ● Bromine is generally less reactive toward alkanes than chlorine, and bromine is more selective in the site of attack when it does react Ch. 10 - 24 4. Chlorination of Methane: Mechanism of Reaction Most radical reactions include 3 stages (steps) (1) chain initiation (2) chain propagation (3) chain termination Ch. 10 - 25 Mechanism of Free Radical Chlorination of CH4 (1) Chain initiation Cl Cl hn (homolytic cleavage) 2 Cl ● Radicals are created in this step Ch. 10 - 26 (2) Chain propagation H (i) Cl + H C H H Cl + CH3 H (ii) CH3 + Cl Cl CH3Cl + Cl ● Repeating (i) and (ii) in a chain reaction provides the product CH3Cl ● In chain propagation, one radical generates another and the process goes on Ch. 10 - 27 (2) Chain propagation ● Other than CH3Cl, other chlorination products can be formed in the chain propagation step Cl (ia) Cl + H C H H Cl + CH2Cl H (iia) CH2Cl + Cl Cl CH2Cl2 + Cl Ch. 10 - 28 (2) Chain propagation Cl (ib) Cl + H C Cl H Cl + CHCl2 H (iib) CHCl2 + Cl Cl CHCl 3 + Cl Cl (ic) Cl + H C Cl H Cl + CCl3 Cl (iic) CCl3 + Cl Cl CCl4 + Cl Ch. 10 - 29 (3) Chain termination Cl + CH3 + Cl + CH3 Cl CH3 H3C CH2Cl CH2Cl2 CHCl2 + CCl3 CH3 Cl2HC CH3 CCl3 Ch. 10 - 30 (3) Chain termination ● Free radical reactions cannot be completed without chain termination ● All radicals are quenched in this step ● Radical reactions usually provide mixture of many different products ● Synthesis of CH3Cl or CCl4 is possible using different amounts of reactants (CH4 and Cl2) Ch. 10 - 31 e.g.: CH4 (large excess) + Cl2 hn CH3Cl (mainly) CH4 + Cl2 (large excess) hn CCl4 (mainly) Ch. 10 - 32 5. Chlorination of Methane: Energy Changes Chain initiation Step 1 Cl Cl (DHo = 243) 2 Cl Ho = +243 kJ/mol Ch. 10 - 33 Chain propagation Step 2 H3C CH3 + H H + Cl (DHo = 440) Cl (DHo = 432) Ho = +8 kJ/mol Step 3 CH3 + Cl Cl (DHo = 243) H3C Cl + Cl (DHo = 352) Ho = 109 kJ/mol Ch. 10 - 34 Chain termination CH3 + Cl H3C Ho = 352 kJ/mol Cl (DHo = 352) CH3 + CH3 H3C o CH3 Ho = 378 kJ/mol (DH = 378) Cl + Cl Cl Cl Ho = 243 kJ/mol o (DH = 243) Ch. 10 - 35 The addition of the chain-propagation steps yields the overall equation for the chlorination of methane H3C CH3 + H H + Cl Cl Ho = +8 kJ/mol CH3 + Cl Cl H3C Cl + Cl o H = 109 kJ/mol H3C H + Cl Cl H3C Cl + H Cl Ho = 101 kJ/mol Ch. 10 - 36 5A. The Overall Free-Energy Change o o G = H – T S o For many reactions the entropy change o is so small that the term T S in the above expression is almost zero, and o o G is approximately equal to H Ch. 10 - 37 CH4 + Cl2 CH3Cl + HCl 2 mol of the products are formed from the same number of moles of the reactants ● Thus the number of translational degrees of freedom available to products and reactants is the same CH3Cl is a tetrahedral molecule like CH4, and HCl is a diatomic molecule like Cl2 ● This means that vibrational and rotational degrees of freedom available to products and reactants should also be approximately the same Ch. 10 - 38 CH4 + Cl2 CH3Cl + HCl o S = +2.8 J K-1 mol-1 At room temperature (298 K) the TS term is 0.8 kJ mol-1 o o H = 101 kJ mol-1 o G = 102 kJ mol-1 Ch. 10 - 39 5B. Activation Energies A low energy of activation means a reaction will take place rapidly; a high energy of activation means that a reaction will take place slowly Chain initiation Step 1 Cl2 2 Cl • Eact = +243 kJ/mol Chain propagation Step 2 Cl • + CH4 HCl + CH3 • Step 3 Eact = +16 kJ/mol Cl • + Cl2 CH3Cl + Cl • Eact = ~8 kJ/mol Ch. 10 - 40 Estimates of energies of activation (1) Any reaction in which bonds are broken will have an energy of activation greater than zero. This will be true even if a stronger bond is formed and the reaction is exothermic. The reason: Bond formation and bond breaking do not occur simultaneously in the transition state. Bond formation lags behind, and its energy is not all available for bond breaking Ch. 10 - 41 Estimates of energies of activation (2) Activation energies of endothermic reactions that involve both bond formation and bond rupture will be o greater than the heat of reaction, H H + Cl CH3 + H Cl o o (DH = 440) H = +8 kJ/mol (DHo = 432) Eact = +16 kJ/mol H3C H + Br CH3 + H Br o o (DH = 440) H = +74 kJ/mol (DHo = 366) Eact = +78 kJ/mol H3C Ch. 10 - 42 Ch. 10 - 43 Estimates of energies of activation (3) The energy of activation of a gasphase reaction where bonds are broken homolytically but no bonds are formed o is equal to H Cl Cl (DHo = 243) 2 Cl o H = +243 kJ/mol Eact = +243 kJ/mol Ch. 10 - 44 Estimates of energies of activation (4) The energy of activation for a gasphase reaction in which small radicals combine to form molecules is usually zero 2 CH3 H3C CH3 (DHo = 378) o H = 378 kJ/mol Eact = 0 Ch. 10 - 45 5C. Reaction of Methane with Other Halogens FLUORINATION o H (kJ/mol) (kJ/mol) +159 +159 F • + CH4 HF + • CH3 130 +5.0 CH3 + F2 CH3F + F • 302 small Eact Chain initiation F2 2 F • Chain propagation • o Overall H = 432 Ch. 10 - 46 CHLORINATION o H (kJ/mol) (kJ/mol) +243 +243 +8 +16 109 small Eact Chain initiation Cl2 2 Cl • Chain propagation Cl • + CH4 HCl + • CH3 • CH3 + Cl2 CH3Cl + Cl • o Overall H = 101 Ch. 10 - 47 BROMINATION o H (kJ/mol) (kJ/mol) +193 +193 +74 +78 100 small Eact Chain initiation Br2 2 Br • Chain propagation Br • + CH4 HBr + • CH3 • CH3 + Br2 CH3Br + Br • o Overall H = 26 Ch. 10 - 48 IODINATION o H (kJ/mol) (kJ/mol) +151 +151 I • + CH4 HI + • CH3 +142 +140 CH3 + I2 CH3I + I • 89 small Eact Chain initiation I2 2 I • Chain propagation • o Overall H = +53 Ch. 10 - 49 6. Halogenation of Higher Alkanes Mechanism for radical halogenation of ethane Chain initiation Step 1 Cl2 light or heat 2 Cl Chain propagation Step 2 CH3CH2 H + Cl CH3CH2 + H Cl Step 3 CH3CH2 + Cl Cl CH3CH2 Cl + Cl Ch. 10 - 50 Chain termination CH3CH2 + Cl CH3CH2 + CH3CH2 Cl + Cl CH3CH2 Cl CH3CH2 CH2CH3 Cl Cl Ch. 10 - 51 Cl Cl2 Cl + light 25oC Cl2 Cl + light Cl 25oC Cl2 Cl + 300oC Cl + + Cl Cl Ch. 10 - 52 6A. Selectivity of Bromine Bromination is slower than chlorination because the 1st propagation step is more endothermic (overall still exothermic). As a result, bromination is more selective than chlorination H + Br2 hn Br (99%) + H Br (< 1%) Ch. 10 - 53 Br Mechanism hn Br H 2 Br Br + H Br (major; 3o radical more stable) H H Br H + H Br (minor; 1o radical less stable) Ch. 10 - 54 Mechanism Br (major) Br H H Br Br (minor) Ch. 10 - 55 Br2 Br + hn 127oC (trace) Cl2 Cl + hn 25oC Br (> 99%) (63%) Cl (37%) Ch. 10 - 56 7. The Geometry of Alkyl Radicals p-orbital R C R R sp2 hybridized Planar, similar to carbocation Ch. 10 - 57 8. Reactions That Generate Tetrahedral Chirality Centers Cl Cl2 Pentane (achiral) Cl achiral 1-Chloropentane (achiral) + * ( )-2-Chloropentane (a racemic form) + Cl 3-Chloropentane (achiral) Ch. 10 - 58 The Stereochemistry of chlorination at C2 of pentane C2 CH3CH2CH2CH2CH3 Cl + Cl CH3 Cl + Cl CH3 Cl2 H (a) CH2CH2CH3 (S)-2-Chloropentane (50%) Cl2 C H H3C H (b) H3CH2CH2C Cl CH2CH2CH3 trigonal planar radical (achiral) enantiomers (R)-2-Chloropentane (50%) Ch. 10 - 59 8A. Generation of a Second Chirality Center in a Radical Halogenation Cl Cl Cl2 3 2 diastereomers H hn H (S)-2Chloropentane (chiral) 2 3 H 2 3 Cl Cl (2S,3S)Dichloropentane (chiral) (2S,3R)Dichloropentane (chiral) from bottom Cl2 face Cl + Cl trigonal planar from top Cl2 face Ch. 10 - 60 Note that other products are formed, of course, by chlorination at other carbon atoms Ch. 10 - 61 9. Radical Addition to Alkenes: The Anti-Markovnikov Addition of Hydrogen Bromide Anti-Markovnikov addition of HBr to alkenes – peroxide effect ● Addition of HBr to alkenes usually follows Markovnikov’s rule HBr Br H not H Br Ch. 10 - 62 ● In the presence of peroxides (RO– OR), anti-Markovnikov addition is observed HBr H Br not Br H RO OR heat Ch. 10 - 63 Mechanism ● Via a radical mechanism RO OR RO + heat (homolytic cleavage) (chain initiation) H Br 2 RO ROH + Br Ch. 10 - 64 Br + Br o (3 radical, more stable) Br not Br + o (1 radical, less stable) H + H Br Br + Br Br Ch. 10 - 65 Synthetic application Br HBr (via more stable 2o carbocation) HBr RO-OR heat Br (via more stable 2o radical) Ch. 10 - 66 Hydrogen bromide is the only hydrogen halide that gives anti-Markovnikov addition when peroxides are present Hydrogen fluoride, hydrogen chloride, and hydrogen iodide do not give antiMarkovnikov addition even when peroxides are present Ch. 10 - 67 10. Radical Polymerization of Alkenes: Chain-Growth Polymers n CH2 CH2 (monomer) peroxide heat CH2CH2 n (polymer) Ch. 10 - 68 Via radical mechanism (i) RO OR (ii) RO + (iii) RO (iv) RO H2C 2 RO CH2 CH2CH2 CH2CH2 + H2C RO CH2CH2CH2CH2 CH2CH2CH2CH2 RO RO CH2 + CH2CH2 H2C 2 CH2 CH2CH2 Ch. 10 - 69 (v) RO CH2CH2 RO (vi) RO CH2CH2 + 2 CH2CH2 + CH2CH2 n OR CH2CH2OR CH2CH2 n RO CH2CH2 RO CH2CH2 n CH2CH2 OR Ch. x 10 - 70 Other common polymers n CH2 CHCH 3 Polypropylene n CH2 CHCl ROOR CH3 n ROOR PVC (plumbing polymer) n CF2 CF2 CH2CH ROOR Polytetrafluroethene (Teflon) CH2CH Cl CF2CF2 n n Ch. 10 - 71 Other common polymers CH3 n CH2 C COOMe ROOR CH3 CH2C COOMe Polymethyl methacrylate (windshield, contact lenses) n CH2 CHPh ROOR Polysterene (styrofoam, coffee cup, etc.) n CH2CH Ph n Ch. 10 - 72 END OF CHAPTER 10 Ch. 10 - 73