A large print version of these minutes is available, please contact 01793 604185 to request MINUTES OF A MEETING OF THE COUNCIL OF GOVERNORS HELD IN PUBLIC ON THURSDAY 29 NOVEMBER 2012 AT 4.30PM IN LECTURE HALL 1, GREAT WESTERN HOSPITAL, SWINDON Present Governors: Bruce Laurie (BL) Clive Bassett (CB) Harry Dale (HD) Geraint Day (GD) Jon Elliman (JE) Godfrey Fowler (GF) Bill Fishlock (BF) Marcus Galea (MG) Mike Halliwell (MH) Peter Hanson (PH) Janet Jarmin (JJ) Brian Mattock (BM) Jemima Milton (JM) Srini Madhaven (SM) David Stevens (DS) Kevin Parry (KP) Rosemarie Phillips (RP) Phil Prentice (PP) Margaret White (MW) Chairman of the Trust Nominated Governor (Prospect Hospice) Public Governor (Swindon Constituency and Lead Governor) Public Governor (Swindon Constituency) Nominated Governor (The Academy) Public Governor (Wiltshire Constituency) Nominated Governor (Swindon PCT) Staff Governor Public Governor (Northern Wiltshire) Staff Governor Public Governor (Central Wiltshire) Nominated Governor (Swindon Council) Nominated Governor (Wiltshire Council) Public Governor (West Berks and Oxon) Nominated Governor (Wiltshire PCT) Public Governor (Swindon Constituency) Public Governor (Swindon Constituency) Public Governor (Swindon Constituency) Public Governor (Wiltshire Constituency) Also in attendance: Robert Burns (RB) Rowland Cobbald (RC) Roger Hill (RH) Angela Gillibrand (AG) Claire Litchfield (CL) Julie Marshman (JM) Kevin McNamara (KM) Carole Nicholl (CN) Roger Thomas (RT) Dr Kate Tredgett (KT) Nerissa Vaughan (NV) Hilary Walker (HW) Non Executive Director Non Executive Director Non Executive Director Non Executive Director and Deputy Chair of the Trust Governance Officer Matron (part of meeting) Head of Communications and Stakeholder Engagement (part of meeting) Company Secretary and Head of Corporate Governance Interim Director of Estates and Facilities (part of meeting) Consultant, Palliative Care (part of meeting) Chief Executive Interim Chief Nurse Members of the public – 2 PUBLIC PART OF MEETING Page 1 of 14 PUBLIC Council of Governors meeting – 29 November2012 at 5.00pm No. Minute 94/12 Chairman’s Welcome and apologies for absence The Chairman welcomed everyone to the meeting, and in particular noted the attendance of new governors, Mike Halliwell and Rosemarie Phillips. Apologies were noted from: Vicki Barnett; Lisa Campisano; and Ros Thomson. 95/12 Results of 2012 Governor Elections/Reappointments/Nominations The Chairman reported that following approval of the constitution by Monitor making changes to eligibility criteria, Bill Fishlock and David Stevens had been re-appointed as governors. CN introduced Paper 1, which outlined the results of the elections held in 2012. It was reported that the election result was as follows: Lisa Campisano (Staff constituency) Mike Halliwell (Northern Wiltshire) VACANT (Northern Wiltshire) Janet Jarmin (Central Wiltshire) Roger Johnson (Gloucestershire and BANES) Rosemarie Phillips (Swindon) Phil Prentice (Swindon) Margaret White (Central Wiltshire) A paper showing the composition of the Council of Governors was circulated at the meeting. It was reported that Roger Johnson, who had been elected to the seat in Gloucestershire and BANES had sadly died before taking up office, and therefore a vacancy remained. 96/12 Lead and Deputy Lead Governor Elections CN reported that, in accordance with the requirements of the Constitution, two public governors had nominated themselves for the positions of Lead and Deputy Lead Governor. CN advised that as there had been one nomination per position a secret ballot was not required and the nominated individuals stood appointed in accordance with the provisions of the Constitution. A paper setting out the candidates and their supporting statements was circulated at the meeting. RESOLVED (a) That Harry Dale (seconded by Phil Prentice) be appointed Lead Governor until the Annual Meeting of the Council of Governors in November 2013 (b) That Ros Thomson (seconded by Harry Dale) be appointed Deputy Lead Governor until the Annual Meeting of the Council of Governors in November 2013. Page 2 of 14 PUBLIC Council of Governors meeting – 29 November2012 at 5.00pm Action by Whom No. Minute Action by Whom 97/12 Declaration of Interests None. 98/12 Public Minutes of Council of Governors held 8 October 2012 The minutes of the part of the Council of Governor’s meeting held in public on 8 October 2012 were adopted and signed as a correct record. RESOLVED That the minutes of the meeting held in public on 8 October 2012 be adopted and signed as a correct record. 99/12 Action Tracker The governors noted the position with outstanding actions. RESOLVED that the Action Tracker be received 100/12 Questions from Public None. 101/12 Questions from Governors This item was considered with Listening to our patients, (minute 106/12 refers). A number of questions had been submitted in advance of the meeting by RP. CL had circulated a list of the questions and answers to those questions. BL advised that any outstanding responses to the questions raised would be circulated outside of the meeting. The Chairman advised that he did not intend to read the questions and answers individually, and this was supported by the Council of Governors. 1. “The Autumn edition of Horizon is splendid – it is written in columns which a visually impaired person (VIP) can put under a reading machine to read. These magazines are distributed in e.g. the neurology department – would it be possible to have 2 or 3 large print copies in the ophthalmology outpatients? Have you explored putting it on Talking Newspapers so it becomes more accessible?” “We did have a few large print copies previously. These were professionally done but at a high cost – around £25 per copy. We can look at a cheaper alternative. With regards to talking newspapers, we have not considered this, but will look into it to understand costs and practicalities and will keep you informed – action, Communications Team.” 2. “I understand that £45,000 has been put aside to upgrade the hospital signage. When will this be done? I assume it will be in accordance with the April 2011 report written Page 3 of 14 PUBLIC Council of Governors meeting – 29 November2012 at 5.00pm C No. Minute Action by Whom by Chris Fielding from the RNIB”. “Yes, a meeting was held on 23 November to discuss signage and agree priorities. The RNIB report was used as the basis of the meeting the early agreement was to increase Braille signage near toilets etc. For signage to the eye clinic to be black writing on a yellow background.” 3. “As you will be aware, many hospitals have an eye care liaison officer (ECLO). For those not familiar with the post of an eye care liaison officer, it is a post that forms a bridge between the hospital and finding resources in the community to support the patient who may well be in shock after having a difficult diagnosis. Is the FT working with the CCG on obtaining funding for this important post?” “Currently we have a one off amount of money to train a person (volunteer or member of staff) from the trust to be an ECLO. We have yet to identify someone who can perform this role. This training will be duplicated by a volunteer from Wiltshire Blind, giving 2 trained persons available for some time during a week. There is no funding from the PCT or social services to add this as a new, full time and recurrent post. We are currently grading the job to discover how much the role would cost for a permanent post, but have no money to fund this from the trust with commissioners funding.” 4. “One resource that you will be aware is available is the register of registered blind people held by the Council. Do you have a data sharing agreement in place so this register can be used across the health economy?” “We provide the data to the council for this register in the form of blind registrations by our doctors. We keep copies of the registrations on file, but have no further information from the council. We do not use their register and have no sharing agreement”. RESOLVED That the questions raised and answers given be noted. 102/12 Report of the Chairman Death of Roger Johnson The Chairman welcomed the new governors to the meeting and announced the sad news that Roger Johnson, who had been elected as the Governor for Gloucestershire and BANES had passed away on 20 November. BL advised that Roger had been a very active member of Friends of Fairford Hospital and that he had been looking forward to working with Roger on the Council of Governors. BL expressed his condolences to Roger’s family and friends. Outgoing Governors BL expressed his sincere thanks for the contribution of Godfrey Fowler, Marcus Galea and Geraint Day, who would no longer be part of the Council of Governors. BL wished each of them well for the future on behalf of the Council. Page 4 of 14 PUBLIC Council of Governors meeting – 29 November2012 at 5.00pm No. Minute BL advised that the revisions to the Constitution had been approved by Monitor and that the changes were now in effect, the result being that both Bill Fishlock and David Stevens had been reinstated as governors. Tape recording of meetings BL advised that a query had been received as to whether it would be permissible for a governor to tape record meetings as an aide memoire. BL stated that the Constitution was silent on this point and that it had been custom and practice not to record meetings, but to produce contemporaneous minutes. BL stated that the Company Secretary advised against the tape recording as it was not usual practice at public meetings and that people might have feel inclined to speak freely and openly if they were aware that they were being recorded. RESOLVED (a) That the report of the Chairman be received; and (b) That it be agreed that the tape recording of meetings be not permitted. 103/12 Report of the Chief Executive The Chief Executive provided Governors with a brief update as follows: Monitor NV advised that some of the Board members had met with Monitor regarding some concerns Monitor had regarding this Trust’s ability to deliver its Annual Plan and to discuss the transfer of assets from former Wiltshire Community Health Services (WCHS) sites to this Trust. NV reported that this had been a positive meeting. Health Service Journal Awards NV reported that the Trust had received two nominations for awards by the Health Service Journal, in two separate categories. NV advised that she was very proud of this achievement, which recognised the work of the Trust. NV stated that nominations had been received for both the work around the “Think Drink” campaign, and the Ambulatory Care Unit. NV reported that staff had attended the awards, and although had not won, it was a fantastic achievement to be nominated. Nursing Strategy NV advised that work was ongoing with regards to the Nursing Strategy, and that Governors would receive a presentation later in the meeting from the newly appointed Chief Nurse, Hilary Walker. RESOLVED That the report of the Chief Executive be received. 104/12 Liverpool Care Pathway The Council of Governors received a presentation on the Liverpool Care Pathway, by Dr Kate Tredgett and Julie Marshman, Senior Nurse. BL advised that he had requested the inclusion of Page 5 of 14 PUBLIC Council of Governors meeting – 29 November2012 at 5.00pm Action by Whom No. Minute this presentation, following recent reports in the press around the pathway and he wished governors to have a better understanding. The presentation about the Liverpool Care Pathway (LCP) covered the following: Communication Medication Symptoms Comfort Reduced need for food and drink Supporting care in the last hours of life Decision making Documentation Assessment Care after death Family support A number of key points were drawn from the presentation notably: Diagnosis of dying was made before implementation of the LCP. The LCP had developed over time and was based on research based evidence of best practice. There was a need to make the dying experience the best it could be for the patient and family. Regular review of any patient on the LCP was a key component. The patient needed to understand and agree to what happened on the LCP. Communication was a key element of the LCP. Consideration was given as to whether treatment should continue and often the focus was on keeping a patient comfortable. Where appropriate patients were fed and provided with drinks. However, artificial nutrition was different. It was explained that increased fluids could often result in greater secretions, rattle and discomfort to the patient. The median time on the LCP was 27 hours with the median age of patients being 83 years old. 40% of deaths were supported by the LCP. All deaths were reviewed to determine whether they were expected or not. Often patients were frightened but there were proactive teams on wards who were able to offer advice and reassurance. KT advised that the Liverpool Care Pathway (LCP) provided benefits for both the patients and the staff providing their care. KT advised that the pathway improved the confidence of nurses, helped to manage the patient’s symptoms and improved multi-disciplinary team working, by ensuring that all members of the team delivering care were aware of the plan. KT advised that using the LCP provided improved documentation of the care delivered and enabled anticipatory prescribing of medications for the 5 key symptoms that could develop for patients. KT confirmed that in order for patients to be placed on the LCP, a senior clinician had to provide a diagnosis of dying for the patient and that a full explanation of the plan of care had to be given to the patient. KT advised that by using the LCP the Trust had accessed educational support, mandatory e.learning modules, biannual study days, preceptorship training and link nurse training. Page 6 of 14 PUBLIC Council of Governors meeting – 29 November2012 at 5.00pm Action by Whom No. Minute KT reported that most patients who were placed on the pathway were on it for 24-48 hours. In addition, she reported that the pathway was fluid, and so if any changes were detected which would change the diagnosis of dying then the position would be reviewed. KT circulated at copy of the LCP document, so that the governors could understand its content. KT confirmed that the LCP was used as it was nationally recognised and members of the public had an understanding of what it meant. The Chairman thanked Dr Tredgett and Julie Marshman for their presentation. RESOLVED That the presentation be received 105/12 Listening to our patients (eyes and ears) (this item was considered with the Questions from Governors (minute 102/12 refers) It was noted that RP had submitted some issues that she wished to be considered under this item. The questions raised are detailed below, along with the Trust’s response. 1. “Concern has been expressed to me about the lack of a timely response by staff to letters sent in by patients. Are there standards for people to respond to patient letters, in particular the governors and PALS?” “Responses to patient letters to PALS are monitored. We can provide you with the Patient Experience Working Group Dashboard so that you can see current performance”. 2. “Some patients are unable to read the usual font size for letters being sent out from the hospital. When will letters sent to patients be in a font that they can read for themselves (including Braille)?” “Appointment letters are being reviewed as described in the response to question 4. Ophthalmology letters have been reviewed with clinical staff and two patient’s feedback. The conclusion was that all Ophthalmology Letters would be sent in font size 16 and this is being implemented. In addition all letters will have a clear directive at the bottom explaining how patients requiring larger font/brail can contact the Eye department to arrange this communication. Please find attached some meeting notes and prescriptive changes sent to IT for implementation.” 3. “I have been contacted by a few people who have had a poor experience of care at the hospital. When they have tried to say something, the staff member has been abrupt and dismissive. It would be useful to know what training is given to staff at all levels including those on temporary contracts or locums on how to deal with such feedback. I also think that we as Governors should have the opportunity to see the positive feedback that I know many patients give to the staff. How do you check that the training in relation to patient feedback has worked? What feedback do you give the Swindon residents about the complaints you have received as a Foundation Trust?” Page 7 of 14 PUBLIC Council of Governors meeting – 29 November2012 at 5.00pm Action by Whom No. Minute “We share complaints information with Governors through the patient experience working group, and through the annual report but this is perhaps an area we can do more on. We are currently running customer service training and will review complaints in those areas to look at impact. Our “Goldfish bowl” training has also just started which is to be aimed at senior clinical staff. It is still in its early days but progress will be monitored.” 4. “I am aware that patients get their appointments cancelled. Several people have said to me that when they are notified of the cancellation they would really like another date for the appointment in the same letter.” “The Outpatient ‘Eyes to the Future Project’ is systematically reviewing the outpatient departments and is starting with Ophthalmology, Respiratory and ENT. This work streams from this review are informed by Patient and Staff workshops and questionnaires. David Moss, Outpatient Manager has communicated this to all booking staff to ensure whenever possible an appointment is reallocated at the same time as the cancellation is actioned. Whilst this is best practice, this is not always possible if future clinics have not been timetabled.” 5. “Patients who need regular appointments (e.g. for those needing Lucentis) would appreciate having their next appointment before they leave the hospital. It would be very helpful if the receptionist could make these appointments for people.” “We are trying to add more capacity into the department to enable more appointments to be available so that the reception staff can book appointments at the time. For most of this year we have had vacancies for doctors that we have had difficulties filling. Good quality eye doctors are currently in short supply, and we remain optimistic that we will recruit to the vacant positions soon.” 6. “Along with other people, I have difficulty in reading some communications from the hospital. You always put at the end ‘if you can’t read this ...’. Could this be at the beginning? It would also be good if acronyms were at the beginning as well.” We can ensure that this is included in agendas and paperwork sent out to members through the membership office. Investigations will be made as to whether it is possible for other areas to follow. 7. “Some people with Advance Directives are concerned that the staff may not always be aware that one exists. It would be helpful if reference to these was made on the front of the notes, rather than on the inside front cover. Would it be possible to know where reference is made to the Advance Directive on patient’s computerised notes?” “We have a policy of not recording anything other than the patient demographics on the front cover of the case notes for confidentiality reasons. Instead, a red ‘warning’ label should be attached to the front cover indicating that an alert or allergy is recorded on the inside. There is a customised box printed on the inside front cover of the notes to record any such alerts or allergies. An Advance Directive would be recorded in this way – as an alert. On Medway, the hospital’s computerised records system; a Medical Alert is added to indicate the presence of an Advance Directive. The existence of an Alert will be displayed when anyone accesses that particular record.” Page 8 of 14 PUBLIC Council of Governors meeting – 29 November2012 at 5.00pm Action by Whom No. Minute Action by Whom RESOLVED That the issues raised and the responses given be noted. 106/12 Nursing Strategy The Governors received a presentation from the Chief Nurse, Hilary Walker regarding the new Nursing Strategy. HW shared the vision and aims of the strategy with the governors. explaining that it was built around 6 “C”s: Care; compassion; commitment; courage; competence and communication. HW commented that the national narrative was woven into this strategy, with these 6 “c”s having been identified by the new Chief Nursing Officer, Jane Cummings. HW explained that it was intended that the strategy should be a working document, which would be easily accessible by members of staff. MG commented that it was important that record keeping was part of the strategy, as it was an important part of the nursing role. HW commented that record keeping was a work stream in the strategy. DS commented that he would have expected to see “empowerment” within the strategy. He commented that it was important that nurses felt that they could take ownership, particularly when dealing with complaints. HW commented that a bespoke leadership development programme would be developed and would commence in January. GD questioned whether there had been any dialogue with the local education board. HW commented that there had not, however she recognised that this was important. HW confirmed that the Local Involvement Networks had been invited to comment on the strategy. JM commented that it would have been helpful if the strategy had been received in advance of the meeting, so that the governors could have considered it fully. This comment was noted. RESOLVED 107/12 CL to add That the Nursing Strategy be received and that Hilary Walker be invited to return to the to the Council of Governors in six months time in order to report on progress. action tracker Bus Services Update Governors received a report from Roger Thomas, Interim Director of Estates regarding bus services to Great Western Hospital. It was reported that the Section 106 agreement monies from developers that had been used to subsidise bus services to the Great Western Hospital would cease at the end of the year. He commented that the subsidy to run bus services to GWH for 10 years had amounted to £7 Page 9 of 14 PUBLIC Council of Governors meeting – 29 November2012 at 5.00pm No. Minute Action by Whom million. RT advised that from January 2013, only commercially viable buses would run to the GWH, as neither the Trust nor Swindon Borough Council would be able to put funds towards subsidy. RT advised that there was likely to be an impact on car parking, as there was insufficient space on the site to accommodate those now likely to travel by car, in the absence of bus services. RT advised that a meeting had been held between the Trust and Swindon Borough Council to discuss the position. RT advised that there was some space available to develop for car parking on site which was being explored. RT Governors questioned whether the bus companies had been involved in discussions around the future provision of services. It was suggested that a meeting be arranged with Thamesdown Transport, the estates team and Swindon Borough Council. To assist the matter it was further suggested that consideration should be given to representatives from Thamesdown to the next council of governors meeting, although this was not supported, noting that the matter would first need to be discussed by all parties. BM, the appointed governor for Swindon Borough Council commented that he was happy to assist in the facilitation of such a meeting. BM suggested that the gap in services needed to be understood and that sponsorship might be a possibility to explore. He suggested that section 106 monies might be available from a neighbouring development site which should be looked into. BL undertook to talk to BM outside of the meeting on how to progress this, including a meeting with all bus service providers. HD expressed concern that this matter had only just been reported to the governors. BL responded that this had been the first Council of Governors meeting since he had become aware of the issue. HD suggested that concerns should be drawn to the attention of local MPs but no specific action was agreed on this comment. KP questioned how many additional car parking spaces the Trust could accommodate. RT commented that a plan would have to be worked out, but that the gravel car park could be stretched and that more disabled spaces could be available to the front of the hospital. RESOLVED that the update be received 109/12 Membership Strategy The governors received a paper from the Governance Officer outlining the revised membership strategy. CN introduced the paper, noting that there was a change of focus towards maintaining and providing meaningful opportunities for engagement and contact between governors and members, rather than solely increasing numbers. It was noted that a range of initiatives would be introduced, such as public lectures and community events. It was noted that an action plan would be developed and would be monitored by the Membership Working Group. GD commented that he thought the strategy was excellent, particularly the development of Page 10 of 14 PUBLIC Council of Governors meeting – 29 November2012 at 5.00pm No. Minute Action by Whom Clinical Lectures and that the election turnout had been good when compared to other recent elections. RESOLVED That the Membership Strategy be approved 110/12 Calendar of Meetings The Council of Governors noted the Calendar of meetings for the forthcoming year. JJ commented that she had not been consulted and the dates of some of the meetings were unsuitable for her. RESOLVED that the calendar of meetings be approved. 111/12 Membership of Working Groups Governors received a paper setting out the membership of working groups for the year 2012/13 and the terms of reference for each. It was agreed that governors should indicate to the lead governor, Harry Dale, which groups they wished to be involved in. RESOLVED That the Terms of Reference of the working groups be approved together with the membership subject to any amendments notified to the Lead Governors and Company Secretary during the course of the year. 113/12 Review of the Constitution The Governors received and considered a report from the Company Secretary which sought views on proposed changes to the Constitution. These changes were to divide the staff constituency into classes to better reflect the composition of the Trust’s staff base and to add other partnership organisations for the purpose of nominating governors, noting the expected abolition of Primary Care Trusts (PCTs) in 2013. The Company Secretary draw attention to the report which reminded the Council of Governors of the previous suggestion for the staff constituency split agreed in 2010. However, since that time, the staff base of the Trust had changed and therefore in consultation with the Director of Workforce and Education, the proposed classes were as follows, details of which were circulated at the meeting: Hospital nursing and therapy staff Community nursing and therapy staff Doctors and dentists Page 11 of 14 PUBLIC Council of Governors meeting – 29 November2012 at 5.00pm No. Minute Action by Whom Administrators, maintenance, auxiliary and volunteers It was noted that the number of staff governors would increase from three to four. The proposed staff classes were supported. With regard to the pending abolition of PCTs there was an opportunity to consider other partnership organisations which might nominate governors. Clinical Commissioning Groups had been mentioned but not formally discussed and therefore the Council of Governors was asked to express a view on this. Governors supported NHS Swindon Clinical Commission Group and NHS Wiltshire Clinical Commissioning Group as partnership organisations for the purpose of nominating governors as these would be organisations which the Trust would work in close partnership with. It was recorded that more than half of the Governors were present and the proposed changes were endorsed unanimously. RESOLVED that the Board be advised that the proposed changes to the Constitution are supported by the Council of Governors as follows: - 114/12 Change Division of the Staff Constituency into classes as follows with an increase from 3 governors to 4: Hospital nursing and therapy staff Community nursing and therapy staff Doctors and dentists Administrators, maintenance, auxiliary and volunteers 1 governor each with a minimum membership of 100. Reason To ensure the staff constituency reflects the composition of the staff base. The addition of two other partnership governors, namely from NHS Swindon Clinical Commission Group and NHS Wiltshire Clinical Commissioning Group To ensure the appointed governors are from relevant partnership organisations. Dates of next meeting It was noted that the date of the next meeting was 18 February 2013 at 4.30pm in Lecture Hall 2, The Academy. 115/12 Resolution of the Council of Governors to exclude the public and the press RESOLVED Page 12 of 14 PUBLIC Council of Governors meeting – 29 November2012 at 5.00pm No. Minute That members of the public and the press be excluded from the remainder of the meeting, having regard to the confidential nature of the business to be conducted. Page 13 of 14 PUBLIC Council of Governors meeting – 29 November2012 at 5.00pm Action by Whom PUBLIC SUMMARY OF ITEMS CONSIDERED IN PRIVATE PART OF THE JOINT TRUST BOARD AND COUNCIL OF GOVERNORS MEETING HELD ON 29 NOVEMBER 2012 16.30 Public Summary No. PS/116 Minute Private Minutes The minutes of the private part of the Council of Governors meeting held in private on 8 October 2012 were adopted and signed as a correct record. PS/117 Minutes of Working Groups The minutes of the following Joint Committees were received: Joint Nominations Committee - 5 November Joint Nominations Committee - 28 November 2012, the recommendations contained therein were approved (Minute PS/118 refers) PS/118 Appointment of Non Executive Directors Further to the receipt of the minutes of the Joint Nominations Committee, which met on 28 November 2012 and the recommendation contained therein the Council of Governors RESOLVED that Professor Dame Janet Husband DBE and Philippa Green be appointed as Non Executive Directors of the Trust for a period of three years commencing on 1 January 2013. PS/119 Private Urgent Business None. Chairman_____________________ Date _____________________________ Page 14 of 14 PUBLIC Council of Governors meeting – 29 November2012 at 5.00pm