Five Generic Competitive Strategies

advertisement

STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT

FIVE GENERIC COMPETITIVE STRATEGIES

By

Charles D. Little, Ph.D

FIVE GENERIC COMPETITIVE STRATEGIES

Competitive strategy relates to all the different strategies a company may do to:

Gain a competitive advantage

Retain existing market share

Capture new market share

Identify and access new market opportunities

Satisfy wants and needs

Provide superior value in a product or service

Position and differentiate the product

Optimize manipulation of the marketing mix

Achieve its goals in the competitive market place

FIVE GENERIC COMPETITIVE STRATEGIES

Competitive strategy then integrates with…

All other functional level activities

Operational processes to deliver value to the customer

Organizational structure

Technical talent and human capital

Organizational politics

Organizational policy

Budget policy

Management and leadership

et al…

…in order to optimize success in the market place.

FIVE GENERIC COMPETITIVE STRATEGIES

Question:

To what extent do you believe that the competitive strategy sets

the tone for the organizational mission and vision of the organization?

Answer:

Likely to a significant extent, because assessment of market opportunities can give rise to the potential for organizational success and the specific

organizational efforts necessary to satisfy customer wants and needs.

FIVE GENERIC COMPETITIVE STRATEGIES

Broad factors that distinguish one competitive strategy from another:

 Whether a company’s target market is broad or narrow, or

 Whether the company is pursuing a competitive advantage linked to low costs or product differentiation.

FIVE GENERIC COMPETITIVE STRATEGIES

1. Low-cost provider strategy…

Targeting:

Price sensitive markets…price conscious buyers

Segments with limited incomes

Price sensitive customers in greater numbers thereby increasing profits (although thin profit margins)

Extreme price competitive markets

Products are essentially the same

Where brand differences are inconsequential to the consumer

When substitutes are readily available

Good strategy for new entrants

FIVE GENERIC COMPETITIVE STRATEGIES

1. Low-cost provider strategy…

Strategic inputs:

Optimize economies of scale

Purchase in volume, JIT, keep raw materials costs low

Utilize bargaining power

Low cost inputs

Reduce materials handling and shipping costs

Advanced production technology and process designs

Offer incentives

Minimize operational and administrative staff and cost

Merge support systems (ordering, procurement, billing, etc.)

Pursue supply chain efficiency, i.e. limit ‘middle men’

Efficient utilization of resources (plant, materials, human capital)

Vertical integration

Operate at full capacity (full advantage of fixed costs)

Efficient communications systems and information technology

Outsource where practicable

Sell direct to customer (where practicable)

Continuous improvement

Continuous learning

FIVE GENERIC COMPETITIVE STRATEGIES

1. Low-cost provider strategy…

*Keeping costs low, yet offering basic features that low cost buyers consider essential.

Examples:

 Wal-Mart

 Sam’s

 99 Cent Stores

 The Attic

 Dollar Tree

 Dollar General

 Family Dollar

FIVE GENERIC COMPETITIVE STRATEGIES

2.

Broad differentiation strategy…

Targeting:

Diverse needs and preferences among target markets

A broad range of buyers

Value conscious consumers

Products and services stand apart in consumers’ minds

Customers looking for a unique value proposition

Premium price products

Buyers loyal to the brand (value the unique differentiation)

FIVE GENERIC COMPETITIVE STRATEGIES

2. Broad differentiation strategy…

Strategic inputs:

Customer service

Unique tangible and intangible attributes

Special order availability

Continuous product improvement and innovation (design and features)

Uninterrupted product availability

Value enhancement through efficient marketing channels

Constant value signaling (through price, quality, performance, taste, packaging, advertising, standout attributes, reputation, status, et al)

Coordination with suppliers

Marketing intensity

Make it more difficult for a competitor to copy it

Employee skill and knowledge of the product

Continuous improvement in organization

Defensive strategy

FIVE GENERIC COMPETITIVE STRATEGIES

2.

Broad differentiation strategy…

Examples:

 Rolex

 Microsoft

 FedEx

 BMW

 Michelin

 Gucci

 Land’s End

 Nike

 Snack Wells

 Briggs and Stratton

 Harley-Davidson

 Avis

 Versaci

 Starbucks

 Victoria Secret

 HEB Plumbing

FIVE GENERIC COMPETITIVE STRATEGIES

3/4. Market focused strategy…cost and niche*

Targeting:

Price conscious customers (similar to low cost provider strategy)

Well defined segments

Appealing to cultures and geographical preferences

Brand loyal customers

Appeal to broad market segments (low cost)

Wants and needs of narrow and unique market segment (niche)

*Good way to discourage entry of industry leaders

*Another differentiation and positioning strategy

FIVE GENERIC COMPETITIVE STRATEGIES

3/4. Market focused strategy…cost and niche

Strategic inputs (essentially the same as low cost provider strategy):

Optimize economies of scale

Purchase in volume, JIT, keep raw materials costs low

Utilize bargaining power

Low cost inputs

Reduce materials handling and shipping costs

Advanced production technology and process designs

Offer incentives

Minimize operational and administrative staff and cost

Merge support systems (ordering, procurement, billing, etc.)

Pursue supply chain efficiency, i.e. limit ‘middle men’

Efficient utilization of resources (plant, materials, human capital)

Vertical integration

Operate at full capacity (full advantage of fixed costs)

Efficient communications systems and information technology

Outsource where practicable

Sell direct to customer (where practicable)

Continuous improvement

Continuous learning

FIVE GENERIC COMPETITIVE STRATEGIES

3/4. Market focused strategy…cost and niche

Examples:

 Community Coffee (niche)

 Grand Ole Opry (niche)

 Krispy Kreme Doughnuts (niche, cost – now broad)

 Red Box (niche, cost)

 Best Buy (niche, cost – now broad)

 Trader Joe’s (niche)

 Tabasco (niche, cost)

 Oberweis Dairies (niche)

 Haltom’s Jewelers (niche)

 Dairy Queen (niche, cost)

 Bluebonnet Bakery (niche)

 Exparanza’s Bakery (niche)

 Micro-breweries and local bars (niche)

 Family Dollar, Dollar General, Fred’s (niche, cost – now broad)

 Coors (niche, cost, now broad)

 Duck Head (niche, cost - now broad)

 Local restaurants (niche)

 Men’s Warehouse (niche)

 Market Basket (niche)

 Central market (niche)

FIVE GENERIC COMPETITIVE STRATEGIES

5. Best cost provider strategy…*

Targeting:

Low cost, differentiation markets (a hybrid)

Broad markets and market niches (middle ground)

Value conscious buyers

Those who shy away from cheap, low-end products and expensive high-end products

Willing to pay a fair price for functionality and performance

More for the money

*Balances low-cost against emphasis on differentiation and positioning

FIVE GENERIC COMPETITIVE STRATEGIES

5. Best cost provider strategy…

Strategic inputs:

Positioning near the middle of the market

Combines other basic strategies

Medium quality at below average price, or

Somewhat higher quality at an average or slightly higher price

Adjust strategy for economic conditions, i.e. more value conscious

Match strategy to internal resources and capabilities

FIVE GENERIC COMPETITIVE STRATEGIES

5. Best cost provider strategy…

Examples:

 Lexus (by Toyota)

 Target

 Savane

 Marriott Courtyard

 Spalding

 UPS

 Little Debbie

 Bimbo Bakeries

 Black Eyed Pea

 Ruby Tuesday

 Budweiser

 Goodyear

FIVE GENERIC COMPETITIVE STRATEGIES

Summary

The differences between the classic five generic competitive strategies is somewhat subtle to the untrained eye. Admittedly, there is some degree of overlap. However, they are significant in strategic planning as they relate to the ability of the organization to gain a competitive advantage.

They offer product and brand distinction in terms of price, value, quality, and performance, which not only positions the product uniquely, but the brand, itself.

Thus, the competitive strategy may indeed set the tone for the mission of the organization, because the entire organization must function jointly to provide the level of quality and performance in the market place, that is consistent with the organization’s overall business level strategy.

Download