RVTS Conference 2014 “Creating a School Culture of Prevention” Frank J. Zenere, Ed.S. School Psychologist, Crisis Management Specialist Miami-Dade County Public Schools Miami, Florida U.S.A. June 3, 2014 Kristiansand, Norway Greetings from Miami Miami-Dade County Public Schools Fourth largest school district in the U.S.A. (350,000 students) 73% of students eligible for free and reduced price lunch 91% of all Miami-Dade students are minority children 50% of all families are foreign born More than 12% of households are headed by a family member with less than a 9th grade education 75% of families speak a language other than English at home Miami-Dade entered the 21st century with graduation rates barely 55% A CHANGING WORLD … CHANGING NEEDS 5 M-DCPS meets these changing needs. Student Safety & Health Priority Areas School Safety 7 DID YOU KNOW? 8 Tragic incidents and large scale acts of violence in schools anywhere in the United States are EXTREMELY RARE. Homicides on school grounds during the school day are VERY RARE 9 U.S. Department of Justice, 2012 What does research say about the most serious incidences of school violence? 10 Safe School Initiative Findings 11 Incidents of targeted violence at school rarely were sudden, impulsive acts. Prior to most incidents, other people knew about the attacker’s idea and/or plan to attack. There is no accurate or useful “profile” of students who engaged in targeted school violence. Most attackers engaged in some behavior prior to the incident that caused others concern or indicated a need for help. United States Secret Service and the United States Department of Education, 2002 Safe School Initiative Findings • • • • • Most attackers had difficulty coping with losses or personal failures. Many had considered or attempted suicide. Many attackers felt bullied, persecuted or injured by others prior to the attack. Most attackers had access to and had used weapons prior to the attack. In many cases, other students were involved in some capacity. United States Secret Service and the United States Department of Education, 2002 12 13 Bullying Statistics, 2010, U.S.A. Approximately, 70-80% of school age students have been involved in bullying during their school years, as a bully, victim or bystander (Graham, 2011). Children identified as bullies often experience significant mental health problems such as depression (Swearer, Song, Cary. Eagler & Mickelson, 2001). Victims of chronic bullying suffer severe and profound consequences including; depression, anxiety and are at incresed risk of dropping out of school. Cyberbulling victims are twice as likely to attempt suicide as others who are bullied (Hinduja & Patchin, 2010). 90% of bullying takes place between 4th and 8th grades (makebeatsnotbeatdowns.org ). DID YOU KNOW? There were 6,477 homeless students identified in MiamiDade County Public Schools in 2012-2013. • Florida reported 117,612 AIDS cases to CDC, cumulatively, from the beginning of the epidemic through December 2008. • Florida ranked 3rd highest among the 50 states in cumulative reported AIDS cases. • Miami ranks as the top city in the nation with the most reported cases. 16 DID YOU KNOW? Drug use by 12th grade students in the U.S.A. over the last year. •Alcohol: 70.6% •Marijuana: 34.3% •Stimulants: 10% •Other Opiates: 9.5% •Tranquilizers: 7.3% •Sedatives: 6.5% •Hallucinogens: 6.2% •Cocaine: 5.3% •Inhalants: 4.2% •Steroids:2.5% •Heroin: 0.9% 17 United States Department of Justice, 2012 • Currently there are approximately 27 million people enslaved throughout the world with 2.5 million located in the USA. • Florida, with one of the highest incidences of human trafficking in the country, has been identified as a hub for human trafficking. • Trafficking can involve schoolage children—particularly those not living with their parents—who are most vulnerable. 18 Mental Health in the U.S.A. At least 1 in 5 children and adolescents has a mental health disorder 1 in 10 has a serious disorder 90% of people who develop a mental disorder show warning signs during their teen years Youth Suicide Data, U.S.A., 2010 Suicide was the third leading cause of death for 15-24 year olds. For youth aged 15-19, the suicide rate was 13.62 per 100,000; for children 10-14, the rate was 1.29 per 100,000. Male youth die by suicide four times more frequently than female youth. The majority of youth who died by suicide used firearms (44.5% of deaths). Suffocation was the second most common method (39.7% of deaths). American Association of Suicidology Youth Suicide Data in Norway Age 15-24, Male and Female 80 70 Number of Suicides 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 2010 2011 Year 2012 Youth Suicide Data in Norway Age 15-24, Male 70 60 Number of Suicides 50 40 30 20 10 0 2010 2011 Year 2012 Youth Suicide Data in Norway Age 15-24, Female 25 Number of Suicides 20 15 10 5 0 2010 2011 Year 2012 Youth Suicide Data in Norway Age 15-24, Male and Female 90 80 70 Number of Suicides 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 2007 2008 2009 Year 2010 2011 2012 Why Schools Should Address Suicide Maintaining a safe school environment is part of a school’s overall mission. Other prevention activities (e.g., violence, bullying, substance abuse, etc.) can also reduce suicide risk (Epstein & Spirito, 2009). Programs that improve school climate and promote connectedness help reduce suicide risk (Blum, McNeely & Rinehart, 2002). Activities designed to prevent suicide and promote student mental health reinforce the benefits of other student wellness programs. Preventing Suicide: A Toolkit for High Schools, 2012 Why Schools Should Address Suicide 26.1% of high school students, grade 9-12, felt sad or hopeless for two or more weeks 16 % of high school students, grade 9-12, seriously considered suicide in the previous 12 months 8% of students, grade 9-12, reported making at least one suicide attempt in the previous 12 months 30%-40% of teens who die by suicide have made a prior attempt USA, Youth Risk Behavior Survey, 2011, CDC, 2012 Why Schools Should Address Suicide Approximately 90% of youth suicide victims suffer from some form of mental illness, the majority of which have a mood disorder. Mental illness can impact student performance in the following ways: Difficulty concentrating Academic difficulties Disruptive behavior Problems with peers Increased irritability and aggression Poor judgment Excessive sleeping Why Schools Should Address Suicide A student suicide can significantly impact other students and the entire school community. Taking appropriate and timely actions following a suicide is critical in helping students cope with the loss and preventing additional tragedies. Preventing Suicide: A Toolkit for High Schools, 2012 Why Schools Should Address Suicide Schools have been sued for negligence for the following reasons: Failure to notify parents if their child appears to be suicidal Failure to get assistance for a student at risk of suicide Failure to adequately supervise a student at risk Preventing Suicide: A Toolkit for High Schools, 2012 Components of Comprehensive School Suicide Prevention Plans Policy and procedures Universal, targeted and indicated prevention Gatekeeper training Screening Risk assessment protocol Resource identification Case management Postvention plan Miller, D., SUNY Suicide Prevention Components Tier 3: Intensive, Individual Interventions 1-5% individual students Tier 2: Targeted, classroom, group Interventions 5-10% students Tier 1: Universal, Prevention and Interventions 80-90%% individual students Suicide Prevention: Universal Program Perspectives Focus upon reduction of risk factors – intrapersonal and interpersonal. Enhance protective factors - intrapersonal and interpersonal (family, school, community) Risk Factors and Protective Factors 33 Suicide prevention efforts seek to reduce risk factors and increase protective factors. Risk Factors are characteristics that make it more likely that a person will think about suicide or engage in suicidal behaviors - could create the impetus for a suicidal act. Protective Factors are not just the opposite or lack of risk factors. They are conditions that promote strength and resilience and ensure that vulnerable individuals are supported and connected with others during difficult times, thereby making suicidal behaviors less likely. Risk Factors Previous suicide attempt/ gesture Feelings of hopelessness or isolation Psychopathology (depressive disorders/mood disorders) Parental psychopathology Substance abuse disorder Family history of suicidal behavior Life stressors such as interpersonal losses (relationship, social, work) and legal or disciplinary problems Access to firearms Physical abuse/Sexual Abuse Conduct disorders or disruptive behaviors Sexual orientation (homosexual, bisexual, and trans-gendered youth) Juvenile delinquency School and/or work problems Contagion or imitation exposure to media accounts of suicidal behavior in friends/acquaintances) Living alone and/or runaways Chronic physical illness Aggressive-impulsive behaviors Protective Factors Family cohesion (family with mutual involvement, shared interests, and emotional support Academic achievement Good coping skills Perceived connectedness to school Good relationships with peers Lack of access to means for suicidal behavior Help-seeking behavior/advice seeking Impulse control Problem solving/conflict resolution abilities Social integration/opportunities to participate Sense of worth/confidence Stable environment Access to and care for mental/physical/substance disorders Responsibilities for others/pets Religiosity (a controversial topic currently) Universal Prevention Components Universal Prevention Components Skill building lessons for students Suicide awareness education, including knowledge of warning signs (Middle and Senior High Schools) Promote help-seeking Screening of all students Gatekeeper training for caregivers Suicide Prevention Curricula Purpose Provide information about suicide prevention Promote positive attitudes Increase students’ ability to recognize if they or their peers are at risk of suicide Encourage students to seek help for themselves and their peers. Preventing Suicide: A Toolkit for High Schools, 2012 Suicide Prevention Curricula Content Basic information about depression and suicide Warning signs that indicate a student may be in imminent danger of suicide Underlying factors that place a student at higher risk of suicide Appropriate responses when someone is depressed or suicidal Help-seeking skills and resources Preventing Suicide: A Toolkit for High Schools, 2012 WHAT WE DO KNOW… Presenting information to students can increase knowledge, positively affect referral practices and change their negative attitudes toward suicidal youth Talking about suicide with youth, including warning signs, does NOT result in negative, unintended side effects Reliable and valid screening and assessment measures and methods are available Miller, D., SUNY WHAT WE DO KNOW The following have lead to reductions in self- reported suicidal behavior Providing information to students regarding suicide awareness and intervention Teaching students problem solving and coping skills Reinforcing protective factors, while addressing risk factors Miller, D., SUNY MIAMI-DADE COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS SUICIDE PREVENTION COMPONENTS Universal Level Comprehensive Student Services Program PK-12: Meets the academic, personal/social, career/community awareness and health needs of all students. This program provides students with nonacademic skills that promote and support student achievement and individual growth. COMPREHENSIVE STUDENT SERVICES PROGRAM Philosophical Basis Program Content Program Modes of Delivery Resources Philosophical Basis Our Vision- The Division of Student Services provides the necessary resources and services for students to be successful in school, work, and in life. School Counseling Professionals 45 School Social Workers Individual Counseling Group Counseling Family Counseling Crisis Prevention Crisis Intervention Community Resources College Assistance Career/Goal Exploration Evaluation Consultation Academic Advisement School Psychologists TRUST Specialists School Counselors Program Content Student Development Framework (standards and benchmarks) Four (4) Areas of skill development Academic Personal/Social Career/Community Awareness Health and Wellness Program Modes of Delivery The program modes of delivery organize the work of student services personnel into direct and indirect activities and services. They include the direct services to students, parents, teachers, and administrators through curriculum, planning, responsive services, and indirect services of system support. Resources The Comprehensive Student Services Program PKAdult is supported by resources in the form of personnel, funding, policies and procedures, and the community. Goals Eliminate or reduce barriers to student achievement Maximize student personal, emotional and social growth Promote and enhance a healthy and safe learning environment Provide support to teachers, administrators and staff Miami-Dade County Public Schools Suicide Prevention Components Universal Level Curricula to Promote Healthy Relationships/Youth Empowerment: provides developmental and transitional strategies to promote physical and psychological health, and the social-emotional wellbeing of all students (e.g., teen dating violence, sexting). “To Reach Ultimate Success Together” TRUST PROGRAM What Is TRUST? This is a comprehensive student assistance program designed to provide prevention, intervention, referral, and follow-up services to students and their families who may be experiencing problems in the area of substance abuse and other self-defeating behaviors. The TRUST Focus Minimizes student risk factors. Promotes protective factors. Creates a research-based approach to substance abuse. Who Are Our TRUST Specialists? Master’s or doctoral level professionals with degrees in counseling, psychology, social work, or related field. Certification in guidance and counseling, school social work, school psychology. TRUST Specialist’s Role Implement substance education curriculum Implement staff in-service trainings Assist administrators and other Student Services staff in working with drug involved youths Provide individual, group and family counseling Provide community resources TRUST Curriculum Focus Substance Abuse Education Substance Abuse and Risk –Taking Behaviors Identify The Media’s Influence on Social Culture Science/Social Studies Curriculum Infusion Managing Your Emotions Skills for Developing Healthy Relationships and Responsible Behavior Components of Solving Conflicts Developing Good Decision-Making/Assertive Refusal Skills Methods To Change Unwanted Behavior Developing Peer Leaders Typical or Troubled Typical or Troubled: program developed by the American Psychiatric Foundation aimed at training school personnel to recognize signs of potential student mental health concerns and seek assistance from appropriate staff. The program will be adapted for parents and students. A program of the American Psychiatric Foundation Brought to you via the Office of Exceptional Student Education and the Division of Student Services Typical or Troubled: School Mental Health Education NOTICE TALK ACT Everyone Can Make a Difference Every Adult School Staff Parents Main Components of Presentation State of the problem Treatment Steps to take Warning signs Normal teen development Types of mental health problems Referral process Talking to parents Managing the Classroom Typical? or Troubled? 62 • Typical or Troubled? TM Typical Teens • Complex period of rapid change, transition • Challenges: fitting in, defining identity, competing demands (school, home) • Sometimes - other home issues (divorce, violence or substance abuse) Bottom line: May display alterations of mood, distressing thoughts, anxiety, and impulsive behavior. • Experiencing more than normal developmental challenges • Without treatment, more likely to have serious problems: • Academic • Relationships • Employment • Typical or Troubled? TM Signs of Trouble Teen Mental Health Disorders Mood disorders Anxiety disorders Psychotic disorders Behavioral/disruptive disorders • Typical or Troubled? TM Gatekeeper Training Universal level Staff Webinar: recorded suicide prevention webinar for school personnel. Webinar builds knowledge in the areas of suicide awareness, risk and protective factors, warning signs, myths and help-seeking. Early Warning Signs Withdrawal from friends and family Preoccupation with death Marked personality change and serious mood changes Difficulty concentrating Difficulties in school (decline in quality of work) Change in eating and sleeping habits Loss of interest in pleasurable activities Frequent complaints about physical symptoms, often related to emotions, such as stomachaches, headaches, fatigue, etc. Persistent boredom Loss of interest in things one cares about Late Warning Signs Actually talking about suicide or a plan Exhibiting impulsivity such as violent actions, rebellious behavior, or running away Refusing help, feeling “beyond help” Complaining of being a bad person or feeling “rotten inside” Making statements about hopelessness, helplessness, or worthlessness. Not tolerating praise or rewards Giving verbal hints with statements such as: “I won’t be a problem for you much longer,” “Nothing matters,” “It’s no use,” and “I won’t see you again” Becoming suddenly cheerful after a period of depression-this may mean that the student has already made the decision to escape all problems by ending his/her life Giving away favorite possessions Making a last will and testament Saying other things like: “I’m going to kill myself,” “I wish I were dead,” “or “I shouldn’t have been born.” Myths About Suicide Talking to someone about suicide may give him or her the idea. Anyone who tries to kill him or herself is irrational or insane. People who talk about suicide don’t usually do it, they just want attention. If someone is determined to take his or her own life there is nothing you can do about it. The Samaritans, 2014 BeSafe Anonymous Reporting System: students are made aware of multiple methods of contacting school police to report knowledge of individuals planning to selfharm or harm others; reinforced by campus posters. WHAT WE DO KNOW… Screening tools have been used effectively at schoolwide, class-wide and individual levels Screening assessment measures can accurately and effectively identify at-risk and high-risk youth The use of screening procedures does NOT lead to an increased level of self-reported distress or suicidal behavior Miller, D., SUNY Targeted Prevention Components Suicide Prevention Components Targeted level Student Assistance Profile: At the end of each grading period, counselors receive a printout on each student that reviews major areas of functioning including academic performance, attendance and behavioral concerns. Students demonstrating difficulty in several areas meet with a school counselor. Suicide Prevention Components Targeted level Student Support Team: multidisciplinary team that discusses at-risk students and determines best course of intervention. Group Counseling Services: school-based small group interventions exploring grief issues, GLBTQ student support, dropout prevention, anger management and other areas of concern. Suicide Prevention Components Targeted level Health Connect in Our Schools: program that addresses health needs of children through health promotion, education and care. These school-based teams are located in at-risk communities and consist of one nurse, two health aides, and a clinical social worker. Postvention: peer survivors of student suicide are provided services focused upon addressing grief responses, prevention of contagion effects, and maintaining a safe, secure and positive school climate. Skill-Building Programs for Students at Risk of Suicide Purpose Build coping, problem-solving and cognitive skills Address related problems such as depression and other mental health issues and substance abuse Content Problem- solving and coping skills exercises Activities to improve resilience and interpersonal relationships Focus on the prevention or reduction of self-destructive behavior Indicated Prevention Components YOUTH SUICIDAL BEHAVIOR: ASSESSMENT AND INTERVENTION Conduct mental health status examination Conduct suicide risk behavior assessment Involve law enforcement, if necessary Contact parent/guardian Provide supervision Provide recommendations for community-based mental health resources Provide follow-up support Document the process Crisis Hotline Reporting The crisis hotline is used to report select student risk behaviors that have come to the attention of a school staff member, whether the behavior occurred on campus or in the community. The school mental health professional that is working with the student is responsible for reporting the risk behavior, after the crisis situation has been stabilized. How and What to Report? Contact the Crisis Hotline at 305-995-CARE (2273) Identify if you are calling to complete a report or if you require immediate consultation Report knowledge of the following behaviors: Suicidal ideation, threat or gesture Suicide attempt Homicidal ideation, threat or gesture Self-injurious behavior Consultation Consultation may include discussion of District response procedures, risk assessment guidelines and intervention strategies. Crisis Team members may also assist schools in identifying and locating appropriate resources for individuals and families. It is sometimes just helpful to have a colleague listen and reflect upon your concerns. Treatment and Case Management Barriers to Treatment of At-Risk Youth Neither teens nor the adults who are close to them recognize symptoms as a treatable illness Fear of what treatment might involve Belief that nothing can help Perception that seeking help is a weakness or a failure-stigma Feeling too embarrassed to seek help American Foundation for Suicide Prevention, 2011 Facts About Treatment Some depressed teens show improvement in 4-6 weeks with structured psychotherapy alone Most others experience significant reduction of depressive symptoms with antidepressant medication Supplementary interventions (exercise, yoga, breathing exercises, changes in diet) improve mood, relieve anxiety and reduce stress that contributes to depression American Foundation for Suicide Prevention, 2011 Facts About Antidepressant Medications Medications work by restoring brain chemistry back to normal A small percentage of youth show agitation and abnormal behavior that may include increased suicidal thoughts and behavior Since 2004, FDA warning recommends close monitoring of youth taking antidepressants for worsening of symptoms, suicidal thoughts or behavior, or other changes American Foundation for Suicide Prevention, 2011 School Actions Following Treatment/Hospitalization Schedule a Student Support Team meeting upon return to school Ask parent/guardian to sign the Mutual Consent for Release of Information form Discuss who, if any, staff member(s) they would like to inform about the suicidal behavior event Adjust classroom schedule and work load to accommodate the student’s needs Designate school support person(s) Be aware of any medications student is taking along with potential side effects Provide assistance in preparing responses to potential questions from peers Check on the student regularly following his/her return to school SUICIDAL BEHAVIOR AMONG AT-RISK STUDENT POPULATIONS Suicide and Bullying, is there a Connection? Nearly 25% of 10th grade students who reported being bullied also reported having made a suicide attempt in the past 12 months( Youth Suicide Prevention Program, 2010-2011). Half of 12th grade students who reported being bullied also reported feeling sad and hopeless almost everyday for two consecutive weeks ( Youth Suicide Prevention Program, 2010-2011). In one study, researchers found a clear relationship between cyberbullying and suicide; 78% of suicide victims had been subjected to bullying at school and online (American Academy of Pediatrics, 2012). Suicide and Bullying, is there a connection? A study conducted by Klomek, et al.,2011 found that exposure to bullying had relatively few outcomes for the majority of youth. The only group that showed suicidal ideation and behavior following high school was youth who suffered from depression at the time they were bullied. Another longitudinal study links exposure to prolonged bullying to the development of serious mental disorders (depression and anxiety) in later life. 25 % of this group reported suicidal ideation or behavior as an adult (Copeland et al., 2013). Suicide and Bullying: Limits to Research Findings Although involvement in bullying is related to a greater likelihood of suicidal thoughts and behavior, one cannot conclude that bullying causes suicidal thoughts and behaviors Most studies have looked at the correlation between bullying and suicide at one point in time; more longitudinal studies are needed Other factors, such as mental health problems and family history of suicide, play a much larger role in predicting suicidal thoughts and behaviors than bullying (stopbullying.gov, Suicide Prevention Resource Center, 2011) Suicidal Behavior among LGBTQ Students LGB high school students and students unsure of their sexual orientation were 3.4 times more likely to have attempted suicide in the last year than their straight peers (Garafalo et al., 1999). 30.1 percent of transgender individuals reported they have attempted suicide (Kenagy, 2005). Numerous studies cite that LGB youth have higher rates of suicide ideation than their straight peers (Massachusetts Dept. Of Education, 2006). Suicidal Behavior Among LGBTQ Students Being LGBT is not in isolation a risk factor for suicidal behavior; however, stressors that they face, including discrimination and harassment- are directly associated with suicidal behavior American Association of Suicidology Suicidal Behavior Among LGBTQ Youth: Implications for Prevention Provide professional development for school staff about issues faced by LGBTQ youth, including the elevated risk for suicidal behavior, victimization, and family rejection Develop policies and procedures for responding to youth suicidal behavior and self-injury Create and enforce non-discrimination polices that extend equal rights to all sexual orientations and gender identities Develop school-based support groups for LGBTQ youth and their families Suicide Prevention Resource Center, 2008 YOUTH SUICIDE PREVENTION: CULTURAL IMPLICATIONS It is estimated that by the year 2030, minority children will outnumber white children in the United States. Therefore, the availability of quality mental health services for minorities is critical to the future of our nation (CDC, 2005). Youth Suicide Prevention: Cultural implications Be aware of cultural protective factors Understand the role of acculturation Determine the impact of religion and spirituality Understand the interpretations of distress across cultures Be aware of attitudes toward help-seeking, especially mental health services Understand the role of family in treatment Dispel cultural myths Be aware of the battle between collectivism vs. independence Goldston et al., 2008 Suicide Prevention in M-DCPS: Historical Perspective 1980-1988 : Student Suicide Rate 5.5/100,000 1989: Program Implementation 1989-2006: Student Suicide Rate 1.4/100,000 1990-2005: Suicide Rates for Youth 5-19 years M-DCPS Suicide Rate 1.3/100,000 Florida Suicide Rate 3.0/100,000 USA Suicide Rate 3.5/100,000 Student Risk Behavior: Five Year Review Risk Behavior 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13 4 2 4 1 7 35 38 39 31 67 39 36 28 17 26 279 237 202 90 207 288 357 346 271 310 Self- Injury Homicidal Threats 133 182 149 65 242 4 86 118 84 103 Homicidal Ideations 106 82 42 11 27 Homicidal Gestures 0 0 0 5 2 Misc. Risk Behaviors 96 49 33 118 255 Missing Persons Total 364 342 400 285 220 1,348 1,411 1,301 978 1,488 Suicides Suicide Attempts Suicidal Gestures Suicidal Threats Suicidal Ideations Student Suicide Data, Rate per 100,000 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13 1.2 0.6 1.2 0.3 2.0 2.5 2 1.5 1 Suicide Rate 0.5 0 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13 Student Suicide Attempt Data, Rate per 100,000 2008-09 10.1 2009-10 11.0 2010-11 11.2 2011-12 8.9 2012-13 19.1 25 20 15 Suicide Attempts 10 5 0 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13 “We really need to put more resources in prevention. No matter how well we plan, you can’t plan for everything. The big lesson is that there are limits to our response.” - James Steinberg QUESTIONS