DO or DI: Differentiating Instruction So All Students Can Succeed Danny Brassell, Ph.D. www.lazyreaders.com dannybrassell.com Who are you? Give your Lottery smile… and introduce yourself to the folks around you. Play with me! GET A PARTNER • Decide who is PARTNER A and who is PARTNER B. • PARTNER A stand up and for 20 seconds tell your partner everything you do well. • PARTNER B, look up to your partner and repeat after me: • “You’re amazing!” • “I want to be just like you someday.” GET A PARTNER • PARTNER A may sit down. • PARTNER B stand up and for 20 seconds tell your partner everything you do well. • PARTNER A, look up to your partner and repeat after me: • “What a stud!” • “I’m not worthy.” Give yourselves a hand! GIVE YOURSELVES A HAND! No matter what you do, you are always a teacher and a role model Who am I? Danny teacher of many ages, cultures, shapes & sizes Stand and Deliver Two janitors and an airport security guard “Choose a job you love and you will never have to work a day in your life.” - Confucious By the end of this presentation… QuickTime™ and a TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor are needed to see this picture. QuickTime™ and a TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor are needed to see this picture. RUX cited? Get pumped! Sing with me! The Differentiation Diddy (to the tune of “Do Wah Diddy Diddy”) There I was just about to teach my class Singin’, “Do what I say. I’m the teacher. Yes, indeed.” Then my students looked at me en mass Askin’, “Do what you say? Are you kiddin’? We can’t read.” They looked stressed (looked stressed) They looked bored (looked bored) They looked stressed. They looked bored… They were not a happy hoard. The Differentiation Diddy (to the tune of “Do Wah Diddy Diddy”) I had kids of all sizes. They were different, every one. Singin’, “do you want to teach a standard or me?” They asked, “Why is school always work, and no fun?” Sing this: “That is not the way that school has to be!” I said, “Yes!” (said “yes”) You’re all right (all right) I said, “Yes!” You’re all right... Now our future’s lookin’ bright. The Differentiation Diddy (to the tune of “Do Wah Diddy Diddy”) Our class is now happy, and we learn a lot more. ‘Cuz we each are different, and we learn differently. When others critique us, we just shut-our-door. And we play. And we sing. And we think critically. YEAH! Give yourselves a hand! GIVE YOURSELVES A HAND! Let’s have Learning Goals By the end of this presentation, we will have: • Determined what differentiated instruction means and why it is important; • Discussed ways to meet standards without sacrificing student readiness, interests and learning styles; • Examined 50 tricks teachers may keep in mind when differentiating instruction; and • Reviewed songs, games and activities designed to stimulate student interest in school. E-mail inquiries via my website: www.dannybrassell.com Thank you, Carol Tomlinson! Thank you, Howard Gardner! Thank you, Gordon Dryden & Jeannette Vos! What Is Differentiated Instruction? Differentiated instruction is a teaching philosophy based on the premise that teachers should adapt instruction to student differences. Rather than marching students through the curriculum lockstep, teachers should modify their instruction to meet students’ varying readiness levels, learning preferences, and interests. Therefore, the teacher proactively plans a variety of ways to ‘get at’ and express learning. - Carol Ann Tomlinson huh? Whenever a teacher reaches out to an individual or small group to vary his or her teaching in order to create the best learning experience possible, that teacher is differentiating instruction. - CAROL ANN TOMLINSON Oh… Raise your hand if you have a variety of different students in your class. Raise your hand if you utilize a number of different teaching strategies with your students. Raise your hand if you have a hand. [Repeat after me] I think therefore I am. - Descartes [Repeat after me] I think I will succeed; therefore, I can. - us, just now Look at the person to your left and the person to your right and the person behind you and the person in front of you. [Repeat after me] We are all different. We can all learn something from each other. - us, just now Wave your arms wildly if you choose to learn from others! Compliment the people around you, and say you are happy to be here. DO or DI? Chances are, you’re already doing it. - me (just now) Why Is Differentiating Instruction Important? To learn a particular concept, some children need days; some, ten minutes, but the typical lockstep school schedule ignores this fundamental fact. - Marilyn Hughes Eight Principles of a Differentiated Classroom Principle #1 The teacher is clear about what matters in the content area. Principle #2 The teacher understands, appreciates and builds upon student differences. Principle #3 Assessment and instruction are inseparable. You’re wrong! vs. Why did you say that? Play with me! Right-Brain Word Puzzles Directions • Each group of words shares a common trait. • Only one answer shares that same trait. • Figure out the common trait and select the correct answer. Right-Brain Word Puzzle #1 • sexes a. dined • level b. mom • redder c. start Right-Brain Word Puzzle #2 • golden a. trace • tallow b. crawl • clamp c. oven Right-Brain Word Puzzle #3 • tea a. wee • eye b. you • sea c. ate Principle #4 All students participate in respectful work. Principle #5 Students and teachers collaborate in learning. Principle #6 The teacher adjusts content, process, and product in response to student readiness, interests, and learning styles. Principle #7 Goals of a differentiated classroom are maximum growth and continued success. Principle #8 Flexibility is the hallmark of a differentiated classroom. AIR TRAFFIC Number of decisions per hour Environment Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #1 Create a supportive environment of respect (teacher-students, students-tostudents). Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #2 Develop a sense of community. Conondrums Visual Puzzle Convert Diagram A to Diagram B. Do it by moving only three circles. Visual Puzzle ANSWER: Math Puzzle Which number continues this sequence? 1 3 6 10 12 3 5 3 3 ? Math Puzzle ANSWER: 1 3 6 10 12 3 5 3 3 6 The lower numbers indicate the number of letters in the preceding upper number. Thinking Puzzle • • • • I am sitting at a table. Ten flies are on the table. With one swat - I kill three flies. How many flies are left on the table? Thinking Puzzle ANSWER: • 3 • I killed three flies - so they would remain on the table. The rest would have flown away immediately. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #3 Facilitate an environment where students feel safe to take risks. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #4 Promote the development of a broad range of skills and interests, incorporating all senses. e.g. Great classroom libraries appeal to the… Senses Touch Sight Smell Taste Sound Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #5 Set-up physical classroom for student-centered instruction. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #6 Provide purposeful materials and resources. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #7 Have high expectations for ALL. If you refuse to accept anything but the best in life, you very often get it. - Somerset Maugham Readiness When a teacher tries to teach something to the entire class at the same time, chances are, one-third of the kids already know it; one-third will get it; and the remaining third won’t. So two-thirds of the children are wasting their time. - Lilian Katz Teachers often cope with the academic diversity in their classrooms by teaching to the middle. Count with me! How to Count to Ten in Japanese ENGLISH JAPANESE SOUND ACTION one two ichi ni Itchy knee. Scratch your knee. three four five six san shi go rocko Sun, she go rocko. Point to sky. seven eight shishi hatchi Chi-chi Hat-chi Double sneeze Put on hat. nine kyu Coo Coo like dove. ten ju Jew Jewish hat. Fingers thru hair Walk. Rock ‘n’ roll. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #8 Allow students to “show what they know” in a variety of ways. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #9 Provide students with plenty of time to explore, understand and transfer learning to longterm memory. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #10 Permit students time to revisit ideas and concepts in order to connect or extend them. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #11 Ensure lessons are developmentally appropriate. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #12 Tier activities to provide appropriate level of challenge. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #13 Compact curriculum to provide enrichment and challenge. Interest If a student has a spark (or better still, a fire), a curiosity about a topic, learning is more likely for that student. - Carol Ann Tomlinson (2001) If there is anything we wish to change in the child, we should first examine it and see whether it is not something that could better be changed in ourselves. - Carl Jung Leveraging Student Interest An informal survey of elementary aged students found they are most interested in ... a. conjugating verbs. b. balancing a complex chemical equation. c. the Pythagorean theorem. d. dinosaurs and volcanoes. Presentation matters Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #14 Incorporate creativity. figure out the expression. Let’s try to Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #15 Provide students real choices in what they learn, how they learn and how they demonstrate learning (flexible and varied). Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #16 Offer real-world challenges that are directly connected to the students’ lives. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #17 Offer novel, unique and engaging activities to capture and sustain students’ attention. Up Close & Personal The Picture Quiz www.coolquiz.com Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #18 Use multi-media/technology. computer friend Technological INTERLUDE www.mindjet.com Cool semantic maps! www.inspiration.com www.eduplace.com www.internet4classrooms.com/di Learning Profile The biggest mistake of past centuries in teaching has been to treat all children as if they were variants of the same individual and thus to feel justified in teaching them all the same subjects in the same way. - Howard Gardner Howard Gardner Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #19 Focus on students’ learning styles. It’s not how smart you are. It’s how you are smart. Sternberg’s Three Intelligences Creative Analytical Practical • We all have some of each of these intelligences, but are usually stronger in one or two areas than in others. • We should strive to use all three…but also recognize where students’ strengths lie and teach through those intelligences as often as possible, particularly when introducing new ideas. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #20 Emphasize brain-compatible instruction. Draw with me! Artist Inside 1. Get out a piece of paper. 2. Draw a pig. 3. You have 38 seconds. Who Are You? • Top of paper: positive, optimistic • Middle of paper: realist • Bottom of paper: pessimistic & tend to behave negatively Who Are You? • • • Facing left: believe in tradition, are friendly & remember dates (e.g. birthdays) Facing right: innovative and active, but don’t have strong sense of family & don’t remember dates Facing front: you are direct, enjoy playing devil’s advocate & neither fear nor avoid discussion Who Are You? • Many details: analytical, cautious & distrustful • Few details: emotional and naïve, care little for details & enjoy taking risks Who Are You? • Less than 4 legs: insecure or living through a period of change • 4 legs: secure, stubborn & stick to ideals Who Are You? • The size of your pig’s ears indicates what kind of listener you are. • The length of your pig’s tail indicates your job satisfaction. Courtesy: drawapig.desktopcreatures.com Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #21 Recognize and honor cultural diversity. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #22 Emphasize student strengths and develop ways to compensate for weaknesses so they do not inhibit what student can do. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #23 Permit positive movement. Dance with me! Teachin’ Has Got You! (to the beat of “Waddlyacha”) Teachin’ has got you. Teachin’ has got you. What do you do? What do you do? (repeat) It’s the craziest job. There’s quite a lot to it. I don’t know how I’m gonna get though it. I like the job. It’s the job I like best. I love teaching my students at school! (faster) Content Instruction begins where the students are, not at the front of the curriculum guide. - CAROL ANN TOMLINSON to Differentiate Content • • • • • • • • • • • • Reading Partners / Reading Buddies * Choral Reading/Antiphonal Reading Flip Books Split Journals (Double Entry – Triple Entry) Books on Tape Highlights on Tape Digests/ “Cliff Notes” Notetaking Organizers Varied Texts Varied Supplementary Materials Highlighted Texts Think-Pair-Share/Preview-Midview-Postview Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #24 Present the curriculum through interdisciplinary “big ideas” versus disconnected small facts. Remember jigsaw puzzles: they’re much easier when you can see the whole picture first. - GORDON DRYDEN, The Learning Revolution Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #25 Plan before, during and after instruction. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #26 Negotiate contracts to provide appropriate learning activities for students. Motivation and productivity skyrocket when students reach their goals. - BETTIE B. YOUNGS, The 6 Vital Ingredients of Self-Esteem: How to Develop Them in Students Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #27 Challenge students (i + 1). Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #28 Create centers. Sing with me! The Newspaper Song (to the tune of “The Facts of Life”) You take the good. You take the bad. You take them both, and there you have: a newspaper. A newspaper. There are sections for business reports, entertainment, news and sports. A newspaper. A newspaper. It has everything! You can buy the car of your dreams! It has classifieds and movie times, stories showing local crimes. You…you…You can share it with your friends, and learn the facts of life! FACT/opinion Can You Find….? • A used Ford for less than $500.00 • A place to hear Irish music • The oldest person on the obituary page • A story about a mouse • A recipe for bouillabaisse • The price of Iams dog food • Two places to have your teeth whitened • What movie is playing at 7:30 at the cinema 12 • A story about the governor • A used fiddle for sale • The score of the football game • Why Jerry Frenz is angry? • The interest rate on a new Dodge pickup truck • The address of the local library • The time of the AARP meeting • The publisher’s name • Etc. Wacky Headlines • • • • • • • Kids make nutritious snacks Police help dog bite victim Miners refuse to work after death Hospital sued by 7 foot doctors Lung cancer in women mushrooms Eye drops off shelf Safety experts say school bus passengers should be belted • Panda mating fails; veterinarian takes over Cut to the Chase Look at the following photos and come up with a headline as quickly as possible. Remember, briefer headlines sell more newspapers! Shameless Self-Promotion News Flash! Newspaper Activities to Meet Language-Arts Standards & Differentiate Instruction by Danny Brassell Makes a great gift for that special someone. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #29 Co-develop standards with students. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #30 Clearly state expectations (be specific about requirements). Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #31 Empower learners! Encourage students to help set and enforce norms. Process Learning is most effective when it’s fun. - PETER KLINE, The Everyday Genius I never worked a day in my life. It was all fun. - Thomas Edison To learn it, do it! - ROBERT C. SCHANK, Engines for Learning TO DIFFERENTIATE PROCESS • Fun & Games • RAFTs • Cubing, Think Dots • Choices (Intelligences) • Centers • Tiered lessons • Contracts Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #32 Utilize active, hands-on learning. 80 percent of learning difficulties are related to stress. Remove the stress, and you remove the difficulties. - GORDON STOKES, The Learning Revolution Children learn best when they are helped to discover the underlying principles for themselves. - PETER KLINE, The Everyday Genius Stand with me! Energizing Breaths • The key to energizing breaths is to take large belly breaths, and exhale the air rapidly through your nostrils. • By exhaling rapidly, students are removing stale air from their bodies, thus encouraging them to feel more relaxed and focused. got confidence? • Clasp your hands together. • Which thumb is on top? got confidence? • Left thumb on top: you rely on logic & reason. You are the most confident when your decisions are based on real-world information. • Right thumb on top: you trust your intuition. You are most confident when your gut says you’re doing the right thing. Facts, schmacks! got confidence? Do you think you have a thin thumb or a thick thumb? got confidence? • Thin thumb: are most confident hanging with a few close friends. They like parties where everyone could fit on the same elevator. • Thick thumb: are just as confident in large groups as one-on-one. They like parties where everyone can fit in the same stadium. got confidence? Is your thumb short or long? got confidence? • Short thumb: work very confidently and quickly. Always the first ones to turn in a math test. • Long thumb: slow and careful. Yet they never lose a thumb war. Go figure! got confidence? • Sit down. • Relax your hands and plop them on your lap, palm side down. • Where does your left thumb land? got confidence? • Way out to side: super-confident and like to be in charge. Some people call you bossy. You should have them fired. • Not far from your palm: medium-confident. You care what people think about you, but not enough to actually change or do anything. • Touching or curled under your palm: you might feel pretty unconfident now, like you want to hide from the world. But remember, you’re thumb-one wonderful! Thank you, Karen Phillips! Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #33 Allow students to work collaboratively and independently (flexible grouping). Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #34 Make use of higher level thinking and questioning strategies. If the questions are simple so is the thinking. kids & adults think differently Sister Roseanna & Heavenly Hector Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #35 Offer students plenty of time for reflection and goal setting. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #36 Vary strategies. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #37 Consider integrated curriculum, problem-based learning and service learning. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #38 Balance teacher-chosen and teacher-directed activities with student-chosen and studentdirected activities. The art of teaching is developing into the art of teaching children to teach themselves. - HELENA H. WALLENBERG and MICHAEL S. BOGOLEA The Welfare Rennaissance: The New Swedish Model Children’s work IS their play. Children learn from everything they do. - CAROLYN HOOPER, New Zealand Playcenter Movement Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #39 Help students understand group’s shared needs for success, to belong, to trust, the future, etc. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #40 Monitor student progress constantly. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #41 Aim high; scaffold weaknesses. Read with me! If I Had My Child to Raise Over Again by Diane Loomans, Full Esteem Ahead If I had my child to raise all over again, I’d finger paint more, and point the finger less. I’d do less correcting, and more connecting. I’d take my eyes off my watch, and watch with my eyes. I would care to know less, and know to care more. If I Had My Child to Raise Over Again by Diane Loomans, Full Esteem Ahead I’d take more hikes, and fly more kites. I’d stop playing serious, and seriously play. I’d run through more fields, and gaze at more stars. I’d do more hugging, and less tugging. I would be firm less often, and affirm much more. I’d build self-esteem first, and the house later. I’d teach less about the love of power, And more about the power of love. I keep six honest serving men, they taught me all I knew: Their names are What and Why and When and How and Where and Who. - RUDYARD KIPLING, The Elephant Child Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #42 Teach for meaning; not rote. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #43 Be flexible (with time, space, materials and groupings). Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #44 Teach strategies explicitly so student has “easy way out” of tough spots. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #45 Collaborate with parents, resource specialists, etc. It takes a village! parents friend Product If there were only one truth, you couldn’t paint a hundred canvases on the same theme. - Pablo Picasso All children are born geniuses, and we spend the first six years of their lives degeniusing them. - BUCKMINSTER FULLER to Differentiate Product • Choices based on readiness, interest, and learning profile • Clear expectations • Timelines • Agreements • Product Guides • Rubrics • Evaluation Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #46 Provide opportunities for projects, creativity, problems and challenges. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #47 Focus on student growth. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #48 Initiate student-maintained portfolios and assessments with varied and original products. THINKING ABOUT ON-GOING ASSESSMENT 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. STUDENT DATA SOURCES Journal entry Short answer test Open response test Home learning Notebook Oral response Portfolio entry Exhibition Culminating product Question writing Problem solving TEACHER DATA MECHANISMS 1. Anecdotal records 2. Observation by checklist 3. Skills checklist 4. Class discussion 5. Small group interaction 6. Teacher – student conference 7. Assessment stations 8. Exit cards 9. Problem posing 10. Performance tasks and rubrics Differentiated Report Cards On report cards, I need to find a way to show individual growth and relative standing to students and parents A = Excellent Growth B = Very Good Growth C = Some Growth D = Little Growth F = No Observable Growth 1=The student is Above Grade Level 2=The student is Working At Grade Level 3=The student is Working Below Grade Level Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #49 Support students in creating products for real events/audience through public displays and performances. Dare to Differentiate: 50 Terrific Teacher Tricks Trick #50 Emphasize quality of thought and expression vs. accuracy. Look with me! Whisper to your neighbor what you think the picture looks like. Do you see a woman? Or do you see a saxophone player? Or do you see something else? A bird, perhaps? A ray gun, possibly? Maybe you see a puffing dragon? Or a funky spaceship? What’s the correct answer? It depends on your imagination. Incidentally, it’s obviously a futuristic telephone. Raise your hand if you enjoyed this presentation. Raise your hand if you learned a thing or two. Raise your hand if you have a hand. Turn to the folks around you and thank them for assisting your learning. Review In this presentation, we: • Determined what differentiated instruction means and why it is important; • Discussed ways to meet standards without sacrificing student readiness, interests and learning styles; • Examined 50 tricks teachers may keep in mind when differentiating instruction; and • Reviewed songs, games and activities designed to stimulate student interest in school. The real art of discovery consists not in finding new lands, but in seeing with new eyes. - Marcel Proust Shameless Self-Promotion Find cool short book (adult, young adult & children’s) recommendations at: www.lazyreaders.com dannybrassell.com Buy one of my books… The perfect gifts for that special someone. Thank you for bringing me here to speak. I always appreciate referrals. My employment makes my wife happy, which simplifies my life immensely. Happy wife = happy life Remember, you make a difference every day. Thank you for joining me today. Enjoy the journey ahead of you. dannybrassell.com