BURNS Dr. M. Vidanapathirana MBBS, DLM, MD, MA, MFFLM (UK) Senior Lecturer, department of Forensic Medicine, FOMS, University of Sri Jayewardenepura Time required to cause a burn 44c x few hours 50c x few minutes 65c x few seconds 750c x 2 ½ hours to cause complete incineration (become ash and pieces of calcined bones)- eg cremations at crematoriums. Out come of a burn depends on Type of burn Surface area Depth of burn Distribution Patients age, diseases, injuries Skin thickness x temperature x duration of contact Skin circulation (If old- due to less circulation out come of the burns is poor. In young – vice versa. Presence of inhalation injuries- fumes can kill with minimal surface burns Classification of burns 1. Thermal burns 2 Chemical burns 3. Electrical burns 4. Mechanical/ Friction burns – will be discussed under the lecture on abrasions) 1. THERMAL BURNS 1) Definition- i. Injuries caused by the local effects of heat. (Cold burns /hypothermic burns? – therefore we need a broad definition) ii. Injuries caused by coagulation necrosis of tissues. Different Types of thermal burns- SCALD BURNS FLAME BURNS FLASH BURNS CONTACT BURNS RADIANT BURNS CHEMICAL BURNS MICROWAVE BURNS A. Scald burns Scald burns are a common form of child abuse. Scald buns – usually blisters present. Red/ pale and moist/sodden burns. As the fluid moves down the body, the burns become progressively less severe. Boiling water can cause 3rd degree burns when 158 F X 1 second of contact. But no charring, carbonization or hair singing. 3 types of scald burnsi. Immersion burns (accidental or deliberate), ii. Splash or spill burns (usually accidental. Some times deliberate,) iii. Steam burns (by super heated steam) (usually accidental) a. Immersion scald burns Immersion or spill /splash scald burnsusually by hot water. Can be accidental or homicidal. Accidental spill burns- usually children involve. Usually the burns are on face, neck, upper chest and arms. Clothing protects the skin from spill scald burns. c. Super heated steam/ hot air burns - i. Skin- severe scald-like burns. ii. With inhalation- of steam (moist hot gases)- burns of the larynx, trachea, and alveolar occurs. Alveolar burns progress to adult respiratory distress syndrome. Some times can cause laryngeal oedema, leading to an asphyxial death. Super heated steam burns or hot air burns 2. Flame burns 3. Radiant heat burns If low radiant heat• i. Usually 1st degree (erythema) or 2nd degree (blistering) • ii. If prolonged exposure, the skin become light brown leathery (= well done turkey) • iii. if further exposure- can cause hair singing and even charring of body. If high radiant heat• 2nd degree burns even in 10 milliseconds Radiant burns Flash burns- type of radiant burns Depth of burns 1) 1st degree Depth- Epithelium Appearance- Erythema without blistering (Histo- dilated congested vessels in dermis) Epidermis is intact but there is some injury to the cells. Later these cells can be peeled off as in sunburns. Causes- Prolonged exposure to low intensity heat or light (sun light) or short duration exposure to high intensity heat or light Pain(+) Capillary return-(+) Scarring- absent (Heals without scarring) Eschar(-) Muscle burns-(-) 2nd degree / partial thickness burns Depth-dermal Sub divided into Superficial or deep burns. 2a.- Superficial partial thickness - Blustering stage. oedema at the dermo – epidermal junction. Destruction of corneum, stiatum granulosum but the basal epidermal layer not totally destroyed. Heals without scarring in 1/52. 2b- Deep partial thickness-Beyond the blister stage, but few blisters might be found. complete disruption of dermis and destruction of most of the basal layer. The dermal appendages (around hair, sebaceous and sweat glands are spared. They can regenerate the epidermis. Therefore heals with or without scarring in 2/52). Appearance 2a. blisters more. 2b. beyond blister stage. Few blisters may be found. Moist, red lesions.. Pain-(+) Capillary return-(+) Dermis appears red. Blotches on pressure. Scarring- Heals with or without scarring Eschar-(-) Muscle burns-(-) 3rd degree / full thickness burns Depth- Sub dermal/ sub cutaneous. Coagulation necrosis of the epidermis and dermis with destruction of all the dermal appendages. Appearance Usually dry, white, leathery lesions. Sometimes brown or black lesions due to charring and eschar formation. No blisters CausesPain- No Capillary return- No Scarring- Heals with scarring Eschar-Can form an eschar, which is dry, hard and black. Later, it sloughs off and underlying granulation tissue appears. Muscle burns- No 4th degree burns/ deep burns Depth- Extending to subcutaneous tissue and beyond. Appearance- charring CausesPain-(-) Capillary return-(-) Scarring- Heals with scarring Eschar-Can form an eschar, which is dry, hard and black. Later, it sloughs off and underlying granulation tissue appears. Muscle burns-(+) Superficial muscles can get charred. Deep muscles can be partially cooked. (PM burning). If severe, pugilistic attitude (boxers posture) Candle effect- Subcutaneous tissue acts as wax. Clothes can act as a wick. So, can burn the body as a candle - 4th degree or deep burns - Pugilistic attitude Surface area of burns It is measured according to the Walles’s rule of 9s. (Now use Lund and Browder chart, especially for children.) • • • • • Head- 9% Upper limbs –9% each. Trunk (front & back) – 18% each. Lower limbs – 18% each. Perineum – 1%. (surface area of the palm is 1%. It can be used to assess the incompletely burnt areas) (9% x 3 + 18% x 4 + 1% = 100) Rule of nine Whether he was alive at the time of burn? (Ante mortem or postmortem burns) It is difficult to differentiate AM or PM burns by gross examination. Even microscopic examination may not be helpful if victim has not survived long enough to develop an inflammatory reaction. Blisters do not indicate AM or PM burns, as they can be produced during PM period as well. Even the red rim around blisters can be seen in PM blisters. Red margin can be due to heat contraction of dermal capillaries forcing blood to the periphery of the burn. Injuries found on a burnt body other than burns? 1. Ante mortem injuries (i) Homicidal injuries, (ii) AM Masonry falling 2. Postmortem injuries (i) Homicidal dismemberment of the body (ii) PM masonry falling (iii) PM burns (spurious wounds/heat artifacts) eg. 1. Heat rupture, 2. Heat fracture, 3. Heat haematoma ii. Heat ruptures Heat fractures – outer table Pathophysiology of burns 1) Capillary dilatation and increased permeability 2)Blister formation (Therefore can develop hypovolaemic shock) 3)Absorption of oedema fluid (occur after about 2 days) 4) Sick cell syndrome (reduction of intra cellular potassium and increase of intra cellular sodium) 5) Blood cells and muscles destruction (releasing potassium, calcium, phosphate etc) 6) Acute renal failure (ischaemic acute renal tubular necrosis and toxic acute renal tubular necrosis) Cause of death in burns Immediate deaths a. Burns, b. Smoke inhalation, 1. (i) Hot gases – cause laryngeal oedema resulting asphyxia (ii) Toxic gases – eg CO, CN, NO, Phosgene – cause poisoning. (iii) Irrespirable gases – eg CO2 – cause hypoxia. c. Masonry falling causing vital organ damage or traumatic asphyxia. Delayed deaths deaths within 2 - 3 days 2. i. shock (including toxic shock), ii. Fluid loss (hypovolaemic shock) iii. Acute respiratory failure due to gas inhalation, deaths after 2 - 3 days i. sepsis (following infected burns, bed sores, gas gangrene) ii. Chronic respiratory failure, iii. Renal failure – (ischaemic or toxic ARTN) Causes of death in a body found in a burnt down house 1. Can die due to burns Extensive burns Gases Masonry fallings Lightning burns High tension electrocution burns 2. Can die due to other causes a) Homicidal (killed by other means and surreptitiously disposed by PM burning) b) Natural death – could have been aggravated by the effects of burn. Aims of investigation of a burnt body 1. Identification 2. If died of burns, Must be alive at the time of fire, i. Swallowing of soot, ii. Inhalation of soot and gases How did he die, i. Burns, ii. Smoke inhalation, 3. If died of burns, why couldn’t he escapei. Suicide, ii. Homicidal burns, iii. Drunken or drugged, iv. Disabled by acute or chronic illness, 4. If didn’t die of burns, how did he die, a. PM burning after killing by another method. Eg. manual or ligature strangulation, stab, cuts, firearm injuries, head injuries etc. b. Post crash fire in RTAs. Smoke inhalation deaths Some bodies become severely burnt. But some show searing injury of skin (become light brown colour with stiff leathery consistency) with or with out blisters. Some times no burns at all. If no or minimal burns, the cause of death is usually “smoke inhalation”. 1. The commonest way is CO poisoning. If died of CO poisoning, diagnosis is easy. Hypostasis, muscles and internal organs and blood are cherry-red colour. But it is not enough, DDs – Cyanide poisoning, refrigeration. Therefore blood CO level should be assessed. Some times, lethal CO level may not have cherry red colour, hence blood level is very important. The average CO level of deaths due to automobile exhaust gas is more than 70%. But in fire deaths, it is usually above 20%. Some times, can die even at lower levels if other causes such as coronary atheroma also contribute. 2. Oxygen deprivation 3. Cyanide poisoning (but very rare in fire deaths. The other problem is the interpretation of the blood level as it can enter blood by PM burning or can produce even in the test tube due to decomposition. The other problem is the false positives caused by sulfides in blood) 4. Free radicals (inactivate surfactants thus prevent oxygen diffusion through alveoli) , 5. Non-specified toxic substances. Inhalation injuries By hot gases inhalation- whether it is dry or moist, can cause a rapidly fatal obstructive oedema of the larynx. But it is uncommon. Laryngeal spasms can cause by extremely hot air inhalation. This concept is how ever just conjecture. Burning of the air passages. a. Hot dry air inhalation- though it causes external skin burns, it has little or no effect on the lower trachea or lungs. Dry air loose most of its heat before reaching the lungs. Mild injury to upper trachea can occur. b. Hot moist air inhalation (eg. steam inhalation)- burns of the airways occur. Steam contains 4000 times more heat than dry air. Inhalation injuries of the lungs are chemical injuries caused by the by products of incomplete combustion. They produce i. pulmonary oedema due to injury to endothelial –epithelial interface, ii. collapse of alveolar due to decreased production of surfactant, iii. Broncho-cilliary injury. Causes of fire 1. Smoking – a common cause. Sleeping with lighted cigarettes. 2. Children- due to lack of supervision. So the parents can be charged for negligence. Social services are also indirectly responsible. 7) Medico legal investigation of a burnt body 1. Authority – ISD or Magistrate order. 2. History – History of the incident (from eye witnesses) – WWWWW History after the incident (from eye witnesses) – dying declaration, treatments given History before the incident (from relatives) - PMH / PSH / social history (alcohol, other abuses) / previous attempts of suicides, enemies, threats etc. 3. Visit to the scene 1. Examine the surroundings Place of killing or death - site of maximum burns Site of the body found Relationship between them. Manner of death (NASH)- locked from inside etc. Cause of death – preliminary idea Trace evidence collection – weapons, inflammable substances, matches, soil beneath the body for inflammable substances. etc. Volitional activity – blood stains distribution, foot and palm prints, disturbance at the scene Then Examine the body Attitude of the body – sexual posture, clothes raise etc Injuries – compare with the surroundings Cause of death – preliminary idea Time since death – cooling by rectal temperature, rigor mortis, hypostasis, putrefaction Changing of position – eg raised hand indicates changing of position after death. Now cover the head and four extremities with cellophane bags and put the body into a body bag and transport to the mortuary. 4. Identification of the deceased If no thermal injuries to body, the death is usually said to be caused by smoke inhalation. In such bodies identification is not a problem. Visual identification, photographs and fingerprints can be used. But if facial structures are mutilated and no fingerprints can be obtained, other methods of identification has to be used. 1. Dental identification. Therefore a PM dental chart is prepared and PM dental X-rays are taken. Better if remove the jaws and can take good X-rays. Better if split at the middle and take good lateral X-rays. Since these bodies are badly mutilated, should cause no problem with the next of kin. Dental X-rays does not require fillings but can be made on bony structure of the jaws and the orientation, structure and appearence of the teeth alone is enough for identification. Even one tooth is enough for specific identification. Just as reliable as fingerprinting. 2. Comparison of AM X-rays (skull, chest, abdomen, limb or any area is suitable) can be compared with PM X-rays.eg. bone structures, soft tissue calcifications, gallstones, kidney stones, clips, plates, screws etc. positive identification can be done even with single unique finding. 3. DNA- if cannot identify by fingerprints, dental records, or X-rays, then DNA can be used. (samples can be taken from deep thigh muscles, bone marrow or teeth) 4. If non of the above methods are available, can do only a tentative identification by using, i. circumstantial evidence, ii. personal possession (documents, ornaments, cloths) iii. tattoos, scars, absence of organs, deformities, defects, diseases etc. 5. If no tentative identification is possible, can do facial reconstruction and publish in media. 5. Preliminary investigations Photographs with scale X –rays – specially if firearm injury or bomb blast are suspected Trace evidence collection– if inflammable substance are used, swabs from Clothes and body. If sexual violence is suspected sperms swabs etc. 6. Clothing examination Examine and remove the clothes. Air dry them and sent to government analyst for inflammable substances analysis. 7. External examination 1) Identification – as mentioned above 2) Time since death assessment – may be difficult. Rigor mortis - (difficult to interpret because with heating RM appear early and disappear early. If completely charred body can be in heat stiffening [pugilistic attitude] ) Hypostasis - can be masked by skin burns. Sometimes hypostasis can be pink due to CO poisoning. Putrefaction – can be altered with secondary infections. 3) Examination of Burns (i) Type – scald / dry / flash, (ii) Depth – 1st , 2nd , 3rd or 4th degree, (iii) SA – rule of 9, (iv) Whether he was alive at the time of burn or not, (v) Clothing and hair burns 4. Other injuries (i) Ante mortem injuries – homicidal (FAI, stab, blast etc), masonry falling (ii) Postmortem injuries – dismemberment, Masonry falling, Postmortem burns (heat haematom heat rupture, heat fracture) 5) Cause of death features If immediate death - i. Burns, ii. Gases – (CO, CN, Phosgene poisoning, Asphyxial signs due to laryngeal oedema, Hypoxic signs due to carbon dioxide poisoning.), iii. Masonary fallings- traumatic asphyxia or vital organ damage If delayed death – renal failure, Septicaemia, and Toxaemia features. 1. 2. Lab investigations a) Blood for alcohol and toxicology b) Blood for gasses (CO, CN, Nitric Oxide and Phosgene) c) Histology for natural causes, septicaemia features (micro abscesses) etc. Conclusions (i) Identification of victim (x ray, dental etc) (ii) Identification of weapon – if used (iii) Injuries interpretation – burn injuries / other injuries as discussed above. (iv) Incident reconstruction – period of survival, volitional activity (v) Cause of death (vi) Category of hurt – especially in live patients (vii) Time since death – difficulties in assessment, as discussed above. (viii) Tests for sexual assaults – swabs for sperms (heat can destroy seminal stains) (ix)NASH (Natural / accidental/suicidal/homicidal/ postmortem burning) (x) Trace evidence collection- according to Locard’s principle. Suicidal burns Rare. Douse themselves with a flammable liquid eg.Kerosene oil, and then set themselves on fire. At the scene- flammable substance container, matches or cigarette lighter are usually found. Examine them for fingerprints and compare them with the victim. On examinaton- 2 or 3rd degree burns most on the front side. Death- some times not immediate, but die of a complication. About 50% die at the scene. Investigations i. clothing to analyse volatile or petroleum substances. So they shoud be placed in a glass container with a screw top cap. But not in plastic bags, a volatile substances can escape through plastic. ii. soil beneath the body to analyse for volatile substances. Iii. Blood for CO- usually elevated even they are flash fires. Some times can get a low (slightly elevated) or negative CO level, if burnt at outdoors or in a larger room. But if suicide in a small enclosure such a car, usually get an elevated CO. Relegious fanatics. Widows jump into creamating site. Accidental burns Commonest is accidental burns. Kerosene burns. Kitchen burns. Industrial burns. (cracker factory burns) Incapacitated with alcohol or drugs and sleep with lighted cigarettes. Lightning burns. Homicidal burns 1. Incendiary bombs (petrol bombs) 2. Napam bombs 3. Incapacitated with alcohol, drugs or head injury and then set fire. Investigations has to be carried out by fire experts also. Eg. government analyst. Reasons- i. for profit- insurance claims, ii. to take revenge, iii. pyromania, iv. to conceal a crime such as burglary. Postmortem disposal by burning Reasons i. to conceal a homicide. Therefore the first thing the pathologist has to establish is that the individual is dead prior to fire. How to suspect – 1. 4th degree burns , some times completely cremated. It is difficult to completely cremate a body out side a crematorium due to high water content. Unless the body was burnt on a grill like structure, so that as it burns, the melting fat will feed the fire and contribute to the consumption of the body. spontaneous human combusion is not accepted now. so if highly cremated body, suspect postmortem burn rather than an accidental fire. 2. Ante mortem injuries (firearm injuries, stabs, blast) 3. Inflammable substances Chemical burns Tissue damage depends on, i. agent, ii. its concentration, iii. quantity, iv. duration of contact, v. extent of penetration of the body. chemicals continue to act on tissues until they are, i. neutralized by another agent or ii. inactivated by body tissues reactions ActionCoagulate proteins by, i. reduction, ii. oxidation, iii. salt formation, iv. corrosion, v. protoplasmic poisoning, vi. metabolic competition or inhibition, vii. desiccation or viii. ischaemic complication of vesicants. Caused by, i. acids, ii. alkali, iii. vesicants (blister producing substances) iv. prolonged contact of some compounds- eg gasoline (partial thickness burns) or cement. Acids Strong acids- pH usually <2. They precipitate proteins. They cause coagulation necrosis resulting hard eschar or scab. Burns are clearly demarcated, dry and hard. Oedema is mild. Usually 2nd degree/ deep partial thickness burns. But if prolonged contact, there can be 3rd degree burns eg. concentrated H2SO4 , HCl or HNO3 . The scab usually dark, leather – like, dry. HCl causes much deeper burns than others. Sulfuric acid- black or brown, Nitic acid – yellow scab, HCl- white or gray, Phenol – light gray or light brown, Some acids cause not only skin burns but also systemic poisoning. Eg. phenol, yellow phosphorous, ammonium sulfide. Eg. i. Phenol associated with acute renal tubular necrosis, ii. phosphorus- liver and kidney necrosis. Alkaline burns - need pH >11.5 to cause injury to tissues. Alkali’s cause severe damage than acids as they dissolve proteins and saponify fats. They cause liquefaction necrosis resulting deeper invasion of tissues. Microwave burns Mechanism – generate heat through molecular agitation. Greater the water content, greater the heat produced. Eg. skin and muscles has more water than fat in subcutaneous tissue. Therefore sandwich type burns. ie. Burns on skin and muscles but sparing the in-between fat in subcutaneous tissue. Radiant heat of ovens cook from out side to in. but microwaves directly heat the internal tissue. Direct microwave injuries are rare. Eg accidental burns in children or deliberate burns in children in battered baby syndrome. FlashFlash fires fires are the fires involving flammable hydrocarbon liquids. It starts with s flash and then follows with flame fire. Flash occurs at flash point. Flash point is the temperature at which sufficient fuel has evaporated to sustain a brief flash of fire. Flame fire occurs at flame or fire point. Which is a slightly higher temperature than the flash point. The initial flash will increase this required temperature of the vapor for the flame to occur. Then it continues to burn until it consumes the whole fuel. But flame will not burn the fuel but the vapor that evaporate will be burnt until it consume the whole fuel. If flash fire occurs in a room, In 45 seconds- oxygen falls and carbon dioxide increases markedly. So in next 15 seconds CO produced. But if no new air enters to the room, the fire will go out through lack of oxygen. Flash over Occur in fires in confined spaces eg. A room. After the onset of the fire, even it is small, it causes radiant heat, hot gases and smoke. Gases and smoke moves up and form a layer immediately below the ceiling. Heat up the ceiling and upper parts of the walls. With time the thickness of this hot gases increases and extend gradually down towards the floor. Then the radiant heat from the fire and the heat of the gases heat up the lower parts of the walls and objects on the floor. So the combustible materials in the room begin to give off flammable gases (this is called pyrolysis). At some point the combustible objects reach their ignition temperature. At this point the flame sweeps over the room involving almost whole room at once. This is called flash over. Usually it takes about 5-20 mts to start the flash over. Usually the temperature at flash over is 500-600C. Internal examination Compare with external injuries Exclude natural causes of death Find the real cause of death. Organs examination No specific features will appear due to burns But some effects due to cause of death can manifest. Eg If immediate death – some times internal organs also burnt.. asphyxia / gas poisoning/ hypoxic features can appear. If delayed death – septicaemia features can appear. a) Infected burns b) Abscesses in most organs (if micro abscesses may not be seen to naked eye) c) Liver - fatty, large, yellow and friable d) Spleen – large, friable, diffluent e) Adrenal glands – haemorrhages Acute renal failure features can appear a) Kidneys swollen (cut section bulged out) b) Cortex pale medulla congested. Lab investigations a) Blood for alcohol and toxicology b) Blood for gasses (CO, CN, Nitric Oxide and Phosgene) c) Histology for natural causes, septicaemia features (micro abscesses) etc. Conclusions (i) Identification of victim (x ray, dental etc) (ii) Identification of weapon – if used (iii) Injuries interpretation – burn injuries / other injuries as discussed above. (iv) Incident reconstruction – period of survival, volitional activity (v) Cause of death (vi) Category of hurt – especially in live patients (vii) Time since death – difficulties in assessment, as discussed above. (viii) Tests for sexual assaults – swabs for sperms (heat can destroy seminal stains) (ix)NASH (Natural / accidental/suicidal/homicidal/ postmortem burning) (x) Trace evidence collection- according to Locard’s principle. Thank you