LAW OF LAND WARFARE FM 27-10 Terminal Learning Objective Action: Identify what actions are legal and what actions are illegal as they relate to the treatment of captured personnel. Condition: Classroom Environment Standards: IAW OSA FY03 CTG Safety Requirements NONE Risk Assessment Level LOW Environment Considerations NONE CLASS OVERVIEW The principles, spirit, and intent of the Geneva Conventions The law of war prohibiting unnecessary destruction The law of war requiring humane treatment of prisoner of war(pow's), other captured and detained personnel, and civilians CLASS OVERVIEW (CONT.) The obligation not to commit war crimes The Obligation to report all violations of the Law of War The significant provisions of the Geneva Convention relative to the treatment of Prisoners Of War (PW) THE LAW OF LAND WARFARE Will not inflict unnecessary destruction or suffering in accomplishing our military mission Will treat prisoners of war, other captured or detained personnel humanely Will not obey an order whose execution is a crime in violation of the Law of Land Warfare THE LAW OF LAND WARFARE Are personally responsible for unlawful acts committed by ourselves Are entitled to humane treatment if we are captured or detained by the enemy PROHIBITIONS ON TARGETS The regulations prohibit the destruction or seizure of enemy property unless imperatively demanded by the necessities of war Under the provisions of the Geneva conventions a military target or a place occupied by a combatant force, can be attacked; however, the attack or shelling by any means whatsoever of undefended towns, buildings, villages are prohibited PROHIBITIONS ON TARGETS We should also remember that in attacks and shelling all necessary measures must be taken to spare, as far as possible , buildings dedicated to religion, art, science or charitable purposes The same applies to historical monuments ILLEGAL TRICKS AND METHODS IDENTIFYING BUILDINGS AS HOSPITALS BUT IN REALITY THEY WERE BEING USED AS DIRECT MILITARY PURPOSES PRETENDING TO SURRENDER IN ORDER TO FACILITATE AN ATTACK PROHIBITIONS ON WEAPONS THE EMPLOYMENT OF ARMS , MATERIAL, OR PROJECTILES DESIGNED TO CAUSE UNNECESSARY SUFFERING IS PROHIBITED WOULD THE WEAPON NEEDLESSLY CAUSE OR AGGRAVATE SUFFERING? DOES THE WEAPON VIOLATE ANY SPECIFIC OR IMPLIED PROHIBITION CONTAINED IN ANY TREATY HUMANE TREATMENT OF NONCOMBATANTS BASIC RULE: TREAT ALL PRISONERS OF WAR, CIVILIANS, OR OTHER DETAINED PERSONNEL HUMANELY. YOU CAN FULFILL YOUR MILITARY MISSION SUCH AS SEARCH, SEIZE, SEGREGATE, SPEED, AND SAFEGUARD BASIC RULE : TREAT ALL POW'S AND DETAINEES WITH HUMANE TREATMENT LIKE YOU WOULD EXPECT IF IT WAS YOURSELF RIGHTS TO WHICH PRISONERS ARE ENTITLED FOOD AND HOUSING MEDICAL CARE RELIGIOUS FREEDOM PERSONAL PROPERTY OTHER PRIVILEGES INTERROGATION OBSERVANCE OF CAMP REGULATIONS WORK Humane Treatment ( FM 27-10, para. 88 - 96, 266) Everyone is Entitled No Degrading or Humiliating Treatment Protected From Violence & Intimidation Shielded From Insults & Public Curiosity Given Respect for Their Persons & Honors No Reprisals Allowed Equal Treatment (FM 27-10, para 92) Required Regardless of Race, Religious Beliefs, Nationality, Political Opinions, or Other Distinctions Based on Similar Criteria. May Be Segregated in Order to Maintain Order in the Camp, to Impose Punishment, for Medical Reasons or Protection. Women must have separate facilities and be treated as favorably as men. HUMANE TREATMENT OF POW'S A COMMANDER WILL NOT PUT HIS PRISONERS TO DEATH BECAUSE THEIR PRESENCE RETARDS HIS MOVEMENT OR DIMINISHES HIS POWER OF RESISTANCE BY NECESSITATING A LARGE GUARD. IT IS LIKEWISE UNLAWFUL FOR A COMMANDER TO KILL HIS PRISONERS ON GROUNDS OF SELF PRESERVATION, EVEN IN THE CASE OF COMMANDO OR AIRBORNE OPERATIONS HUMANE TREATMENT OF CIVILIANS ALL PERSONS WILL BE TREATED WITH CONSIDERATION AND WITHOUT ANY ADVERSE DISTINCTION BASED ON RACE, RELIGION, OR POLITICAL OPINION MEMBERS OF THE CIVILIAN POPULATION CANNOT BE BRUTALIZED OR EXECUTED SOLDIERS RESPONSIBILITIES U.S. SOLDIERS ARE SWORN TO THE GENEVA- HAGUE CONVENTION TREATIES AND ARE TO CARRY OUT THESE RULES DURING THEIR TENURE IN COMBAT U.S. SOLDIERS WILL BE HELD RESPONSIBLE FOR THEIR ACTIONS AND ARE PUNISHABLE BY THE U.C.M.J. FOR ANY VIOLATIONS WAR CRIMES Using poisoned or otherwise forbidden arms or ammunition, such as dum dum bullets Pretending to surrender as a trick Mutilation of dead bodies Firing on churches, hospitals etc. which are of no military importance Abuse of or firing on the flag of truce Misuse of the red cross emblem Use of civilian clothing to disguise themselves Commanders’ Duties & Responsibilities CDRs Can Be Criminally Liable for War Crimes If They: Ordered the War Crime, Knew About the War Crime BUT Nothing to Stop it, or The CDR Should Have Known of the Crime and Did NOT Act to Stop it. Commanders Also Have a Duty to Investigate War Crimes Promptly Did Soldier’s Duties and Responsibilities Watch for Evidence of Prior Abuse Document & Report any Suspicions of Prior Abuse You MUST Report Violations & Suspected Violations of Laws of War as Serious Incidents. Responsible for Own Acts or Omissions which Violate Law of War Must NOT Obey Unlawful Orders If Soldier Receives Unlawful Order, Soldier Should Try to Prevent the Order From Being Carried Out Dealing With Illegal Orders Clarify Unclear Orders If the Order is Illegal, The Soldier MUST State So Use Moral Arguments Threaten to Report the Act Ask the Senior Soldier to Stop the Act Refuse to Obey the Order If the Order is NOT Withdrawn, or the Act IS Committed, Report Incident or Order Reasons for Reporting War Crimes Enemy War Crimes Can Be the Basis for Legitimate Reprisals. Publishing Enemy War Crimes Can Be Used to Influence Public Opinion, Including Soldier’s, Against the Enemy. Reporting Allied War Crimes Helps us follow Geneva Convention Rules on Transferring Captives ANY QUESTIONS ?