The 1999 Venezuelan Flood Presented by Tibi Marin KDHE/KSU DEDICATED TO THE PEOPLE OF VENEZUELA WHO LOST THEIR LIVES IN THE 1999 VENEZUELAN FLOOD MAP OF VENEZUELA Information about Venezuela Officially Republic of Venezuela Estimated Population: 21,005,000 Surface Area: 352,143 sq mi (912,050 sq km) Venezuela has a coastline 1,750 mi (2,816 km) long on the Caribbean Sea in the north. It is bordered on the south by Brazil, on the west and southwest by Colombia, and on the east by Guyana. Dependencies include Margarita Island, Tortuga Island, and many smaller island groups in the Caribbean. The capital and largest city is Caracas. INTRODUCTION Landslides have caused major socioeconomic impacts on people, their homes and possessions, industrial establishments, and lifelines, such as highways, railways, and communications systems. Socioeconomic losses due to slope failures are great and apparently are growing as the built environment expands into unstable hillside areas under the pressures of expanding populations and urban development. Human activities disturb large volumes of earth materials in construction of buildings, transportation routes, canals, and communications systems, and thus have been a major factor in increases in damages due to slope failures, and increasing the extent of natural disasters such as the 1999 Venezuelan Flood. Topography of the Area in Study • Venezuela is extremely steep and rugged. The crest of the Sierra de Avila reaches 2,700 m within about 6-10 km of the coast. The rivers and streams of this mountainous region drain to the north and emerge from steep canyons onto alluvial fans before emptying into the Caribbean Sea. In Vargas little relatively flat area is available for development with the exception of the alluvial fans. Nature of geologic event: • An unusually wet period in 1999 resulted in rainfall accumulation at sea level on the Caribbean coast of 293 mm for the first 2 weeks of December, followed by an additional 911 mm of rainfall from December 14 to 16 (MARN, 2000). • Fifteen days of constant and intense rainfall in Venezuela culminated on 16 December 1999 in extensive flooding and massive landslides in seven northern states of the country. • Rivers overflowed their banks and swept through poor districts in the capital city of Caracas. THE FLOOD • The disaster started when torrential rains triggered landslides that crashed down from Mount Avila, a mountain separating Caracas from the Caribbean coast. • The floods affected the South American country's entire northern coast, stretching from the tourist resort Margarita Island to the western Zulia state bordering Colombia. Nature of geologic event: • The mountain soil had been weakened by the removal of vegetation through deforestation caused by urban development and migration from other nearby countries. (shantytowns ) • The heavy rainfall caused massive flooding and debris flows in the channels of major drainages that severely damaged coastal communities along the Caribbean Sea. • In coastal valleys, mud slides buried most of the towns of Macuto and Caraballeda while the towns of Los Corales, Camuri Chico and Carmen de Uria totally disappeared under avalanches of mud. GEOLOGIC MAP OF VENEZUELA • On December 15 and 16, 1999, landslides (mostly debris flows) and flash floods along the northern coastal zone of the state of Vargas and neighboring states in northern Venezuela killed an estimated 30,000 people (USAID, 2000), caused extensive property damage, and changed hillslope, stream channel and alluvial fan morphology. • These shantytowns and resorts had been developing in the dry riverbeds and on steep unstable hillsides outside the larger city as part of a wide-scale population shift from farming regions to urban areas, especially those migrating from countries such as : Colombia, Ecuador, Peru and others in search for better jobs. DEBRIS FLOW IN THE AFFECTED AREA According to the national government, the partial figures on the disaster in the country are projected as follows: • • • • • • Persons affected: 331,164 Persons left homeless: 250,000 Disappeared persons: 7,200 Deaths: 50,000 Housing units affected: 63,935 Housing units destroyed: 23,234 • Within this region the Venezuelan Geological Survey and the Ministry of Ambient and Natural Resources characterized geologic conditions where landslides initiated on hillsides and examined the texture of debris-flow deposits in the channels of nine drainages. Boulders up to 5 m long were carried along by the flows, impacted structures causing serious damage, and were deposited on the fan. • The volume of debris-flow and flood deposition on the fan was measured to be about 2 million cubic meters. • The total volume of material transported and deposited by landslides throughout the Vargas region ranks this as one of the most severe historical erosional events worldwide. • Large populations live on or near alluvial fans in locations such as Los Angeles, California, Salt Lake City, Utah, Denver, Colorado, and lesser known areas such as and Vargas, Venezuela. • A combination of debris flows that transported massive boulders, and flash floods carrying extremely high sediment loads were the principal agents of destruction • On virtually every alluvial fan along the Vargas coastline, rivers incised new channels into fan surfaces to depths of several meters, and massive amounts of new sediment were disgorged upon fan surfaces in quantities of up to 15 metric tons per square meter. • Sediment size ranged from clay and sand to boulders as large as 10 m in diameter. Sediment and debris including massive boulders were deposited up to several meters thick across large sections of alluvial fans in Camuri Grande and Caraballeda • The states of Zulia, Falcón, Yaracuy, Sucre, Anzoátegui and Nueva Esparta were also affected, but in less degree. • The fact remains, however, that the environmental hazards of disease transmission are heightened, and epidemic outbreaks are possible, which makes it necessary to assign priority to epidemiological and environmental surveillance so that proper sanitary measures may be taken. EPIDEMIOLOGICAL REPORT • The epidemiological and environmental information was analyzed to determine the effects on health and the needs for allocation of resources. • The states hardest hit by the disaster were Vargas and Miranda. The effects on the Federal District (D.F.) was also considered owing to its geographic contiguity to them and to the fact that it shares their population dynamics and similar geololgical makeup The following factors operate in the transmission of diseases in the wake of a disaster: • The diseases already present in the population prior to • • • • • the disaster and their endemic and epidemic levels. The environmental changes caused by the disaster. Population shifts. Damage to public facilities. Shortcomings in surveillance and in disease-control programs. Changes in the resistance of individuals to diseases. Diseases already present in the population • The danger of an epidemic in the wake of a disaster is a function of the preceding endemic and epidemic levels of diseases in the population. • The recurrently most important diseases are the diarrheas, dysentery from different causes, measles, airway infections, meningococcal meningitis, intestinal parasitoses, scabies and other dermatoses, tuberculosis, and malaria. • Predisaster situation of the leading endemoepidemic diseases in Venezuela Malaria: the cumulative reported incidence in the country in 1999 was below that of 1998. • In the six epidemiological weeks prior to the disaster incidence was on the rise. The entire country was affected, and the states at greatest risk for this disease were Zulia, Vargas, Sucre, Portuguesa, Miranda, Falcón, Barinas, and the Federal District. The situation was aggravated by the presence of hemorrhagic dengue. Environmental changes brought about by the disaster • These changes could alter the possibilities for the spread of diseases, the most important of which are the vector-borne (mainly mosquitoes) and the water-borne. • Floods heighten the risk of leptospirosis. Inadequate collection of solid wastes leads to the multiplication of flies as a physical vector for diarrheas and conjunctivitis. • The water supply is reportedly greatly compromised in the states of Vargas and Miranda, and water disinfection is a high priority for the prevention of water-borne outbreaks (diarrheas, including cholera). • In building a scenario for the effects on the health of the population in the short and middle run, it is also necessary to take account of the outbreaks of diseases in the wake of natural disasters —among them leptospirosis, typhoid, food poisoning, minor infections of the airways, diarrheas, cholera, and malaria. MITIGATION • Because most of the coastal zone in Vargas consists of steep mountain fronts that rise abruptly from the Caribbean Sea, the alluvial fans provide practically the only flat areas upon which to build. • Rebuilding and reoccupation of these areas requires careful determination of hazard zones to avoid future loss of life and property. ACTIVITIES TO BE CARRIED OUT FOR MITIGATION OF RISK FACTORS 1. Internal cleaning of buildings Mud removal Rubble removal Removal of unserviceable articles 2. Cleaning of surroundings and common areas. Removal of mud from streets and avenues. Removal of rubble from streets and avenues. 3. Collection and final disposal of wastes. Sanitary landfills. Spillways. Incineration. 4. Health surveillance and education Framing and circulation of directives. 5. Provision to the community of reliable access to drinking water. 6. Repair of the drinking water distribution system. 7. Health surveillance and education. 8. Ensuring that foods supplied to disaster victims are in wholesome condition. 9. Sanitary evaluation of establishments that process foods and dispense them to the community. Conclusions • In Venezuela, the extremely steep, tectonically active Cordillera de la Costa forms the boundary with a tropical sea. • Easterly trade-winds can force moist air masses upslope and precipitate large rainfall volumes, creating conditions for high-magnitude debris flows and flash floods such as the one in 1999. • This example from Venezuela shows the potential for extreme loss of life and property damage where a large population occupies an alluvial fan Without careful planning of human settlements, the impacts of these types of disasters are likely to increase in the future. • By building communities and other infrastructure on alluvial fans, dramatic natural hydrologic processes have been changed into major lethal events such as the ones in: California, Venezuela, Peru, Colombia, Chile, Panama, Kansas. REFERENCES • • MARN, 2000. Informe Preliminar Sobre los Aspectos Ambientales Vinculadas al Desastre Natural Ocurrido en Venezuela Durante el Mes de Diciembre de 1999. Wieczorek, G. F., B. A. Morgan, and R. H. Campbell, 2000. Debris-Flow Hazards in the Blue Ridge of Central Virginia. Environmental & Engineering Geoscience, 6(1): 3- 23. • Garner, H.F., 1959. Stratigraphic-Sedimentary Significance of Contemporary Climate and Relief in Four Regions of the Andes Mountains. Geological Society of America Bulletin 70(10): 1327-1368. • El Nacional. Venezuelan Newspaper El-Nacional.com • El Universal. Venezuelan Newspaper. El-Universal.com. • CNN.COM • www.fema.gov Report of the Flood in Caraballeda, Venezuela. (Debris-Flow Deposits and Contours of Maximum Boulder Size on the Caraballeda Fan, Venezuela) Wieczorek, G.F., Larsen, M.C., Eaton, L.S., Morgan, B.A. and Blair, J. L. U.S. Geological Survey MARN, 1999, Cronica Cartografica de la Catastrofe de Venezuela: Ministerio del Ambiente y de los Recursos Naturales (MARN), Servicio Autonomo de Geografia y Cartografia Nacional, 15 p. MARN, 2000, Comison ambiental para la evaluation y tratamiento intergral de las cuencas torrenciales del Estado Vargas, Informe de advance: Marzo, 2000, 43 p. •Pierson, T.C., and Costa, J.E., 1987, A rheologic classification of subaerial and sediment-water flows, in Costa, J.E., and Wieczorek, G.F., eds., Debris flows/avalanches: Process, recognition and mitigation: Geological Society of America, Reviews in Engineering Geology, v. 7, p. 1-12. •Salcedo, D.A., 2000, Los flujos torrenciales catastróficos de Diciembre de 1999, en el estado Vargas y en Caracas: Características y lecciones apprendidas. Memorias XVI Seminario Venezolano de Geotecnia, Caracas. p. 128-175. •Schuster, R.L., Salcedo, D.A., and Valenzuela, L., in press, Catastrophic landslides of South America, S. Evans and J. DeGraff, eds., Reviews in Engineering Geology, v. 14, Geological Society of America, pp.