Basic Hydrology Water Quality: Sediment production and transport Sediment in streams The significance of sediment in streams has two aspects – the water quality aspect is related to suspended sediment • unwanted suspended sediment can cause domestic water quality problems, and can cause physical damage to fish – supply and movement of coarse sediment in streams is a channel morphology issue • excessive coarse sediment in streams can adversely affect fish habitat and fill in water control structures Sediment movement in streams Sediment movement in stream channels can be categorized by grain size or by the process that transports it – suspended sediment consists of fine particles of silt and clay that are carried by the water column • suspended sediment movement is independent of flow rate – wash load is a term that refers to sediment that is carried by the water column, that has grain size distribution smaller than the channel bed – saltating bed load • consists of fine to medium sand • movement is dependent on the velocity of flow: at low flow it may not move, but at high flow it may bounce high up into the water column – behaviour may be similar to suspended sediment for fine sand at high flow – bed load consists of coarse sand, gravel and larger sized particles that are transported by rolling along the channel bed. • bed load transport is also dependent on flow rate • there is a threshold flow velocity needed to get it moving Grain size classes size class gravel v. coarse sand coarse sand medium sand fine sand v. fine sand coarse silt silt clay diameter range (mm) microns 2.00 + 1.0 - 2.0 0.5 - 1.0 250 - 500 0.25 - 0.5 125 - 250 0.125 - 0.25 63 - 125 0.0625 - 0.125 31 - 63 0.031 - 0.0625 3.9 - 31 0.0039 - 0.031 < 0.0039 Sediment production vs. transport Sediment production refers to the addition of new sediment to the channel system – landslides – surface erosion – channel bank erosion Sediment transport refers to the movement of sediment that is already in the channel system Types of sediment transport systems Supply limited – most rivers are supply limited in terms of sediment production – the stream has the ability to move all the sediment that is supplied to it, hence sediment transport is limited by the supply – sediment transport tends to exhibit pulse behaviour, sediment movement occurs mostly on the hydrograph rising limb – hysteresis occurs where sediment concentration for a given flow is greater for rising than falling streamflow Suspended sediment pulse, Russell Creek 300 30 200 20 100 10 0 0 11 /1 9 9/ 1 11 /2 9 0/ 1 11 /2 9 1/ 1 11 /2 9 2/ 1 11 /2 9 3/ 1 11 /2 9 4/ 1 Suspended Sediment (mg/l) Discharge (m3/s) 40 SS concentration vs. discharge Suspended Sediment (mg/l) 300 19 - 20 November 1991 Russell Creek Supply limited 200 100 0 0 10 20 Discharge (m3/s) 30 40 Spray River near Banff, 1973 Supply limited 400 300 10 200 5 100 0 4/30/73 0 5/31/73 7/1/73 8/1/73 9/1/73 Suspended Sediment (mg/l) Streamflow (m3/s) 15 Sediment transport types Transport limited – transport limited sediment transport is far less common than supply limited – occurs when the sediment supply to the stream is in excess of the ability of the stream to transport it • occurs in braided and anastamosed rivers where sediment supply is high – as a result, more sediment moves on the falling limb than the rising limb of the hydrograph – hysteresis occurs where sediment concentration for a given flow is greater for falling than rising streamflow – large rivers can exhibit both types of transport behaviour Dual behaviour of large rivers Large rivers tend to be transport limited during freshet periods – sediment concentrations tend to be high during spring freshet because • flow is low - sediment is “concentrated” • sediment production occurs as a result of supply of sediment accumulated over winter that enters the system all at once As flows increase, they become supply limited – sediment transport capability increases Fraser River at Mission, 1983 400 8000 300 6000 200 4000 100 2000 0 3/31/83 0 4/30/83 5/30/83 6/29/83 7/29/83 Suspended Sediment (mg/l) Streamflow (m3/s) 10000 Transport vs. supply limited Fraser River 1983 transport limited April Suspended Sediment (mg/l) 400 supply limited May - June 300 200 100 0 0 2000 4000 6000 Streamflow (m3/s) 8000 10000 Columbia River 1976 somewhere south of Golden 800 transport limited event 600 2000 400 1000 200 0 3/31/76 0 4/30/76 5/30/76 6/29/76 7/29/76 8/28/76 Suspended Sediment (mg/l) Streamflow (m3/s) 3000 May 1976 Columbia River Suspended Sediment (mg/l) 400 300 200 100 0 200 400 600 Streamflow (m3/s) 800 Measurement of suspended sed. Direct method: sample analysis – a sample of stream water is collected using a manual DH48 depth integrated sampler or an automatic sampler such as ISCO 3700 – the sample is filtered through a 2 mm filter to determine sediment concentration in mg/l Indirect method: turbidity is measured and interpreted as SS conc. by field and lab calibration Sediment production processes rain splash erosion – sheet wash erosion - surface runoff freeze-thaw erosion – expansion and contraction of erodible rock surfaces – frost expansion – needle ice development animal movement ravelling of loose sediment surfaces undercutting and slumping of loose surfaces mass wasting Factors controlling sediment production Cause of runoff – rainfall produces more sediment than an equivalent volume of snowmelt • rain erosion on exposed sediment sources vs. water yield from snowpack that blankets the exposed sed. • rainfall produces larger peaks than streamflow, hence greater sediment transport and channel scour Size of storm – larger storms generally produce more sediment • larger yield, and greater peak concentration Controlling factors Watershed morphology – lithology: softer more erodible bedrock (e.g., basalt - Catherine Cr.) produces more sediment than harder more resistant bedrock (e.g., granite - Russell Creek) – type and connectivity of sediment sources • debris flow deposits are big producers • hillside sediment sources – landslide scars, road cuts – slope stability Controlling factors Land use, e.g. logging and related activities – related to other factors such as slope stability and surface erosion from road surfaces and cut and fill slopes • increase in mass wasting processes following logging • yarding disturbance – potential increase in streamflow after logging • increase in sediment transport capability • increase in stream channel and bank erosion Sediment Production at Russell Cr. Total Sediment Yield (kg/storm) 1000000 100000 10000 1000 100 10 Peak Suspended Sediment Conc. (mg/l) 0 20 40 60 Maximum 12-hour Rain Intensity 1000 100 10 1 0 0 5 10 15 20 25 Maximum 3-hour Rain Intensity (mm) How does logging affect sediment production? Studies show that increased sediment after logging is related to logging roads – surface erosion from road surfaces – road related landslides Open slope failures increase after logging If soil disturbance is minimized, clear-cuts are not sediment sources – burning – ground skidding