2 Feedback
Arno
James
Christian
Katerina
1
3 The Work Packages
Introduction to afternoon break out groups
2
Table of Contents
Objectives:
1. Introduction to the afternoon breakout groups
2. Overview of Work-Package plans
Product and Waste Characterisation – Patrick and Susanne
Stocks and Flows – Jaco
End User Requirements – David
Information Network - Sarah
3
Product Characterisation WP2
Waste Characterisation WP4
23rd April 2015
Brussels
Patrick Wager
Susanne Rotter
This project has received funding from the
European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and
innovation programme under grant agreement
No 641999.
ProSUM
Prospecting Secondary raw materials in the Urban mine and Mining wastes
WP1 Project management (WF)
WP2
Product
Characterisation
(Empa)
WP3
Stocks and flows
Characterisation
(UNU)
WP4
Waste
Characterisation
(TUB)
Components
Products
Fractions
CRM POM
CRM Stocks
CRM in Waste
WP5
Knowledge Base (BRGM)
WP6
Exploitation (WF)
Information
5 Network
Objectives and tasks
1. Identify existing CRM data sources on
a.
b.
c.
d.
products put on the market
end of life (EoL) products
residues from waste treatment
mining waste
2. Assess and validate data
3. Evaluate and test sampling, sample preparation and
chemical analysis methods for CRM quantification
4. Data protocols
6
Identify existing CRM data sources
Task
Identify and assess existing CRM
data sources
a.
b.
c.
d.
Deliverables
1. Reports on available data (M12)
2. Report on data assessment (M24)
7
products put on the market
end of life (EoL) products
residues from waste treatment
mining waste
Identify existing CRM data sources on
Raw materials considered by ProSUM
Ia
1
H
001
not critical according to EC 2014, but considered relevant
IIa
(K)
2 3Li
Be
4
IVa
B
006
Al
014
Ga
32
In
50
Tl
82
Ho
68
005
Va
C
007
Si
015
Ge
33
Sn
51
Pb
83
Er
69
VIa VIIa
N
008
O
009
P
016
S
017
As
034
Se
035
Sb
52
Bi
84
He
002
F
010
Ne
Cl
018
Br
036
I
054
At
086
not addressed by EC 2014
Na
012
K
020
Rb
038
Cs
056
011
Mg
IIIb
(M)
4
IIIa
consideration in discussion
(L)
3
VIIIa
Critical according to EC 2014
019
IVb
Ca 21Sc
022
Sr
040
Vb
Ti
023
Zr
41
VIb VIIb
V
024
Cr
025
Nb
42
Mo
043
Ta
74
W
75
Pr
60
Nd
61
VIII
Mn
026
Fe
27
Tc
44
Ru
45
Os
77
Ib
Co
028
Ni
29
Rh
46
Pd
47
Ir
78
Pt
79
Gd
65
IIb
Cu
030
Zn
Ag
48
Au
80
Tb
66
013
31
Ar
Kr
(N)
5
37
Y
39
Cd
49
Hg
81
Dy
67
Te
053
Po
085
Xe
(O)
6
55
Ba 57La
Hf
73
Ce
59
72
Re
76
(P)
58
Pm 62Sm 63Eu
64
+ glass, plastics
8
Tm 70Yb
Lu
71
Rn
Identify existing data sources
Data maps
•
•
•
•
Track information flows
Map data “holders” & “producers”
Indicate data availability
Show data granularity
10
Sampling, sample preparation & chemical analysis
Task
Evaluate and test sampling, sample preparation and
chemical analysis methods for CRM quantification
Deliverables
1. Recommendations for sampling and analysis of
products, components and wastes (M30)
11
Sampling, sample preparation & chemical analysis
WP2
3 "particularly interesting" products
and components (POM /EoL)
- sensors
- LED
- photovoltaic applications
WP4
4-6 "particularly interesting"
waste fractions
- printed wiring boards scrap
- thermal battery treatment
fractions
- ...
• Criteria for "particularly interesting" products / components / waste
fractions:
 include different types of matrices (alloys, silica based, …)
 cover the three product groups considered in ProSUM (batteries, EEE,
vehicles) with expected growing market share + mining waste
 little data on CRM composition available
 etc.
12
Your views on …
• major challenges in acquiring data related to CRM and
other relevant raw materials;
• your role in data acquisition
• standardisation and harmonisation needs
13
Stocks and Flows – WP3
23rd April 2015
Brussels
Jaco Huisman
This project has received funding from the
European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and
innovation programme under grant agreement
No 641999.
ProSUM
Prospecting Secondary raw materials in the Urban mine and Mining wastes
WP1 Project management (WF)
WP2
Product
Characterisation
(Empa)
WP3
Stocks and flows
Characterisation
(UNU)
WP4
Waste
Characterisation
(TUB)
Components
Products
Fractions
CRM POM
CRM Stocks
CRM in Waste
WP5
Knowledge Base (BRGM)
WP6
Exploitation (WF)
Information
15 Network
Objectives and Tasks WP3
• Describe, compile and harmonize available data on
the stocks and flows of CRM containing products
• Assess disposal trends and complementary flows
• Stock - flow model development
• Analysis and data handling framework for WP5
• Data quality tests and recommendations for
maintenance and updating
16
Stocks and Flows – WP3
Key challenges
• From products stocks and flows to CRM stocks and
flows
• Trends over time / rapid technology changes
affecting disposal
• Data on product flows for Batteries and ELV
17
Your views on …
• Types and definitions of complementary flows
• Challenges in acquiring comprehensive data
• Your needs related to stock and flows information
• Inventory existing studies and activities
If time allows:
• Harmonisation and standardisation needs
• How to update information
18
Knowledge Base– WP5
23rd April 2015
Brussels
David Gardner
This project has received funding from the
European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and
innovation programme under grant agreement
No 641999.
ProSUM
Prospecting Secondary raw materials in the Urban mine and Mining wastes
WP1 Project management (WF)
WP2
Product
Characterisation
(Empa)
WP3
Stocks and flows
Characterisation
(UNU)
WP4
Waste
Characterisation
(TUB)
Components
Products
Fractions
CRM POM
CRM Stocks
CRM in Waste
WP5
Knowledge Base (BRGM)
WP6
Exploitation (WF)
Information
20 Network
Contents
1 Examples of material and product flows
2 Data needed to map flows
3 Seeking your input
21
Generic product flow
22
Geographic region
MATERIAL FLOW
MATERIAL FLOW
ID:
Code list:
Facilities
ID:
ID, depending on the
CATEGORY:
ATTACHED DATA:
DATA:
DATA:
-Quantity
-Quantity
-Quantity
-Value
-Value
-Value
-Purity
-CRM?
-CRM?
-CRM?
-Price
Code list:
COMMODITY
ATTACHED DATA:
DATA:
DATA:
-Legal
Name
-Quantity
-Quantity type
-Organisation
-Value
-Value
-Location
-CRM?
-Capacity
-CRM?
Code list:
COMPOUND
Code list:
PART
Code list:
Facilities
ATTACHED DATA:
DATA:
ATTACHED TAGS:
Code list:
COMPONENT
Destination: ID
Geograpic
region
Code list:
PRODUCT
23
Source:
ID Geographic
region
DATA:
-Legal
Name
-Quantity
-Quantity type
-Organisation
-Value
-Value
-Location
-CRM?
-Capacity
-CRM?
Your views on ….
• What tangible/ factual outputs would you expect to see?
Map of Europe with layers, material flow data in tables,
other types of infographics
• The basic flow diagram – what are the boundaries?
• Specific questions like the detail by region / country /
Europe, etc.
24
The Information
Network –WP6
Information Network Launch
23rd April 2015
Brussels
Sarah Downes
This project has received funding from the
European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and
innovation programme under grant agreement
No 641999.
ProSUM
Prospecting Secondary raw materials in the Urban mine and Mining wastes
WP1 Project management (WF)
WP2
Product
Characterisation
(Empa)
WP3
Stocks and flows
Characterisation
(UNU)
WP4
Waste
Characterisation
(TUB)
Components
Products
Fractions
CRM POM
CRM Stocks
CRM in Waste
WP5
Knowledge Base (BRGM)
WP6
Exploitation (WF)
Information
26 Network
Improved coordination and support
• Improve the knowledge base
• Enable coordination and collaborative work to
enhance data gathering
• Raise awareness and share best practice
• Facilitate standardisation
• Support policy dialogue
• Support further research
27
Membership
• Researchers
• Recycling industry – pre-processors, recyclers and
smelters
• Producers and their component suppliers
• Producer Responsibility Organisations and Associations
• Public authorities –policy makers, national statistics
offices, national and regional government
• Geological surveys
• Waste industry
• Other EU projects e.g. KIC on Raw Materials
28
Objectives
• Allow partners to identify the knowledge and data
requirements to support on-going and future data
collection and dissemination
• Identify data and information needs by industry and
policy makers including the granularity and format
• Coordinate harmonised data collection in standard
formats
• Engage in communication and dissemination along the
value chain to improve the knowledge base
• Provide recommendations and standards
29
Operation Strategy
• Interface between project and stakeholders
• Share best practice and knowledge
• Showcase advances and opportunities in data
gathering and exchange
• Create opportunities and cooperation on data
pooling
• Agree a Terms of Reference for members
• Develop a Business Plan for life beyond the project
30
Operation Tactics
•
•
•
•
Annual Network Meetings
Special Interest Groups
Identify end user requirements and test EU-UMKDP
Website Platform
• Discussion groups
• MOOCs
• Data Sharing Agreements – protection of data
31
Your views on …
• Provide useful data and intelligence for stakeholders
• Engage a wide range of end users
• Identify opportunities and overcome barriers to gathering
data
• Act as a vehicle to disseminate project findings and results
to raise awareness
• Improve the coordination and cooperation of data owners
and improve the interoperability and harmonisation of data
• Assist in improving the knowledge base on the availability of
secondary raw materials, particularly critical raw materials
32
Afternoon Breakouts
1. Product and Waste Characterisation
•
•
Forum A
Patrick and Susanne
2. Stocks and Flows
•
•
Forum B
Jaco
3. End User Requirements
•
•
Consilium A
David
4. Information Network
•
•
Consilium B
Pascal
33
Lunch at OO!
34