AUDIT PROGRAM By - Jayant R. Shetye 1 A DETAILED AUDIT PROGRAM By - Jayant R. Shetye An audit program consists of an appropriate audit procedure to achieve audit objectives. Audit programmes are prepared while planning the audit. At the planning stage, auditors will need to prepare audit tests to test the account areas. As part of the planning stage, auditors need to prepare audit tests to test the account areas. To assist the auditors there are audit assertions for the purpose of Audit. Transactions are to be tested in audit with reference to the audit assertions. Assertions will be different for different account areas. 2 AUDIT ASSERTIONS Assertion Questions Occurrence Is the transaction recorded expenditure in correct year account? Regularity Is the transaction legal and regular? Disclosure Is the transaction correctly coded and disclosed? By - Jayant R. Shetye Completeness Has the transaction been recorded in the accounting records? Measurement Is the transaction recorded at the correct value? as of 3 STAGES IN AN AUDIT Stages Particulars Audit Initiation II Vouching of Transaction III Statutory Compliances IV In-depth Scrutiny of Ledgers V Preparation of Financial Statements and Final Reporting Stages of audit are explained in the following slides. By - Jayant R. Shetye I 4 STAGE I: AUDIT INITIATION 1. Studying the incorporation documentation i.e. Partnership deed, Memorandum and Articles of Association By - Jayant R. Shetye Understanding the Entity and its environment. The industry in which the entity operates and the internal controls implemented; for example for a manufacturing Concern the following should be considered. a) List the products manufactured. b) Narrate the Manufacturing process. c) Brief on Delivery mechanism and invoicing method, PO tracking d) Note on Inventory Maintenance and related records of goods sold, manufactured. 5 STAGE I: AUDIT INITIATION 2. 4. By - Jayant R. Shetye 3. Determine the nature, timing & extent of other audit procedures Ensure that Auditor’s Appointment Letters are obtained and acceptance replied. Confirmation of opening balances: Check the current year's opening balances with the closing balances of audited Financial Statements of the previous year. 6 STAGE II: VOUCHING AND VERIFICATION OF TRANSACTION Purchases/Sales 1. Check the date, amount, authorization, number, etc. of the invoice with the accounting entry passed in Accounting Software. 2. Whether Purchase Order was made for the purchase. 3. Verify the related Sales/Purchase order. 4. Whether Purchase Order was duly authorized by Administrative Head. 5. Whether Material/ Equipment ordered for has been received. 6. In case of part receipt of materials; whether amount is paid only for the received materials or for all materials ordered. 7. Whether Rate charged & Qty received matches with the original order. 8. Confirm the accuracy of arithmetical calculations of the invoice (Quantity*Amount). 9. Ascertain whether the quantity mentioned is correct alongwith the supporting such as Delivery challan. 10. See that materials rejected if any have been properly accounted for . By - Jayant R. Shetye 7 STAGE II: VOUCHING AND VERIFICATION OF TRANSACTION 1. 2. 4. 5. 1. 2. Confirmation of Balances Confirmation of balances with the banks / Lending institutions should be obtained on a monthly basis for the purpose of preparation of bank reconciliation statements. Confirmation of balances with the Creditors / Debtors should be obtained on a six monthly basis. The balances in the Creditors/Debtors Ledger account should also be reconciled with the balances as per the party’s books on a six monthly basis. By - Jayant R. Shetye 3. Checking of Bank reconciliation Confirm the bank balances along with the bank statements. Note the cheques which are outstanding for long, and also ascertain the reasons for the same i.e. Stale Cheques. List the cheques which have been issued but not recorded. Also list the cheques which have remained uncleared for more than 30 days. Obtain the copy of quarter end reconciliation statement in our audit file. 8 STAGE II: VOUCHING AND VERIFICATION OF TRANSACTION 1. 2. 3. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. Check authorization of Journal Vouchers by a responsible person. Check the Journal vouchers with supporting Bills / Invoices /documents. Check that supporting documents are duly approved by an appropriate authority. Check the correctness of the accounting head - debit / credit. Check that all the relevant columns of the journal vouchers have been properly filled in. In case of contractors bills check that bills submitted by the contractors are supported by the Work Orders issued in advance to the contractors. No bill should be passed unless supported by a/ WO and the value of the Bill should be in agreement with the WO prepared. Check that the Work Orders are prepared in advance before the start of the work. Check that the bills of the contractors are duly approved and certified for payment by the person responsible for getting the work done i.e the user. All the bills must have “Approval” for payment in writing by the user on the face of the bill. Check that all the supporting bills / invoices to a journal voucher are approved / certified for payment by the User Department. The user Department should specifically put a remark on the bill for approval/ payment. In case of contract jobs relating to labour supply the bills are to be supported by attendance sheets duly certified by the Time Office. In case of transporters bills - check the bills with the agreed rates and receipted copies of consignment notes. Check the measurement books in case of bills for civil work and ensure that the Measurement books are signed and checked by the Engineer in charge of the Work. In case of running and final bills for civil work check that the civil engineer has checked and verified the measurements and entries of all running and final bills are made in the Measurement Books. By - Jayant R. Shetye 4. JOURNAL VOUCHERS 9 STAGE II: VOUCHING AND VERIFICATION OF TRANSACTION Advance to Employees Check the Trial balance in respect of Advance to employees to ascertain the amount outstanding in the name of each employee. Find out the date since when the advance is outstanding to be settled and make a list if employees advances that have not been settled for a long period. 2. Ensure that no further advance is given to an employee unless the previous outstanding advance is cleared by him. 3. Advance to an employee may be towards - Travel / Official work\ loan or a salary advance. Ensure that the recovery is made from the salary of the employee when the advance taken by the employee is not settled by him within a reasonable period. 4. Further check that the recovery of installments in respect of loan / salary advance is made correctly on monthly basis from the salary of the employees. 5. Check and make a list of employees who have left the company and their full and final settlements have not been made but debit balances are still appearing in their names in the Advance to employees account. By - Jayant R. Shetye 1. 10 STAGE II: VOUCHING AND VERIFICATION OF TRANSACTION 1. 2. 4. 5. 6. 7. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. By - Jayant R. Shetye 3. Check the Cash/Bank transactions Check authorization of Cash Vouchers / Bank Vouchers by a responsible person. Check supporting Bills / Invoices Check the correctness of the accounting head – expense / income Check for cash receipts signature /acknowledgement of cash recd. Check that all the relevant columns of the Cash/ bank vouchers have been properly filled in. Check that all the supporting to the Vouchers are crossed as cancelled after the payment. Check that payments are made only against original supporting. Payroll The amount of salary drawn by a staff is in accordance with companies policy; Appointment of the staff is as per the rules and regulations and post sanctioned; The pay drawn by a newly appointed staff is as per the appointment letter; Necessary deductions have been made in accordance with the relevant rules and orders Salaries paid have been properly recorded in the salary register The payment of salary must be duly acknowledged by the payee staff only; and Salary increments are as per the rules and orders. 11 STAGE III: STATUTORY COMPLIANCES Profession Tax 1. 2. 2. Prepare the Month-wise Table Verify. Whether PT has been deducted correctly for all employees as per salary working Sales Tax/VAT/Service Tax 1. 1. By - Jayant R. Shetye 3. TDS Verify whether the tax has been deducted at the correct rates and against the correct bill. Prepare the Delay in TDS deposit and TDS not deducted table. Whether certificate is properly prepared and delivered to client Verify the Calculation of VAT/Service Tax Payable and prepare computation of VAT/Service Tax Liability and Payment Statement. Check Original Payment Challan. Verify whether Tax has been paid on/before due date. Incase of delay, whether the same has been paid along-with interest. 12 STAGE IV: IN-DEPTH SCRUTINY OF LEDGERS. 1. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. Prepare the bill-wise outstanding entries, along-with the remarks of receipts during the subsequent audit period. Obtain the Auditee's response, for debtors outstanding of more than 90 days. Verify if there have been any mutual settlement, identify the bad debts, if any. Check whether discount allowed is properly recorded. Incase of sales return, verify the proper reversal of VAT, if necessary and its inventory accounting Check that the balance shown by the Debtors Ledger Trial balance agrees with the balance shown by the Debtors control account in the General Ledger Trial balance. Check the Age-wise analysis of Sundry Debtors and comment upon it. Check the Debtors Accounts that are stuck up for long and are doubtful of recovery. Check the debtors accounts where legal cases have been filed / are to be filed and ascertain the progress in the legal cases. By - Jayant R. Shetye 2. Debtors Scrutiny 13 STAGE IV: IN-DEPTH SCRUTINY OF LEDGERS. 1. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. During Creditors scrutiny, verify if there are any long outstanding bills. Obtain the Auditee's response, for Creditors outstanding of more than 90 days. Verify if there have been any mutual settlement. Check whether discount received is correctly recorded. Check the accounting entry for purchase return. Check the period for which the amount is outstanding. Ascertain the reasons for the outstanding amount. Check whether the amount has actually paid after the date of balance sheet date . By - Jayant R. Shetye 2. Creditors Scrutiny Check the Age-wise analysis of Sundry Debtors and comment upon it. 14 STAGE IV: IN-DEPTH SCRUTINY OF LEDGERS. 1. 2. 4. 5. 6. 7. By - Jayant R. Shetye 3. Scrutiny of Fixed Assets and Depreciation Check the Bills for any new purchases which were made during the year. Check whether the rates for depreciation are proper and also whether it has been correctly calculated. Schedule II is applicable to companies incorporated under Companies Act. Whether the asset has been capitalized properly. Fixed assets are properly recorded at cost/valuation. Ensure appropriate authority for acquisition. Whether the Fixed Assets purchased are tagged giving an appropriate reference number. Whether the asset has been entered in the fixed asset register 15 STAGE IV: IN-DEPTH SCRUTINY OF LEDGERS. 1. 2. 4. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Secured loans/Term loans/Cash Credit. Obtain the Statement of Accounts from the financier Bank/ Institution Obtain interest certificate as to compare with the balance in the Books. If the loans are obtained from Directors/ Shareholders, obtain certificate that the same is not given out of borrowed funds. Balance, Additions , Repayment, interest credited , Tax Deducted and any other Adjustments , so as to agree with the total opening and total closing balance and maximum outstanding during the year. By - Jayant R. Shetye 3. Fixed Deposits Reconcile the amount with FD certificate. Ask for 16-A & check whether TDS have been correctly deducted by bank. Reconcile the TDS deducted with 26AS statement. Collect Form 16-A for your record. 16 STAGE IV: IN-DEPTH SCRUTINY OF LEDGERS. 1. 2. 1. 2. 1. 2. 3. Scrutiny of Other Assets Investigate about how the closing balances have been obtained. Check the Bills for any new purchases which were made during the year. Investments Details of Investments at the Year end Check the income accrued on the Investments Disclosure requirements under Schedule III. By - Jayant R. Shetye 3. Director's Account Scrutiny Check the transactions that have taken place through the directors personal account. Verify the calculation of directors remuneration including the amount of the TDS Deducted. See that the personal expenses have been debited to drawings accounts 17 STAGE IV: IN-DEPTH SCRUTINY OF LEDGERS. 1. 2. 4. 5. 6. 7. By - Jayant R. Shetye 3. Inventory Check the Method of Valuation of the Closing Stock. Reconcile the physical / book items of inventory showing opening balances, purchases , issued for consumption/sales , short & excess and closing Stock with the Excise Records.. trace the deviations if any from the method of valuation of Stock, purchases, sale according to section 145A of the Income Tax Act. According to the provisions of the said section all duties, cess, taxes and levies are to be Included at the first instance in the said items including provisions for excise duty on closing stock of finished goods. Check the Compliance of the Accounting Standard -2 " Valuation of Inventories.“ It may be noted that the said Accounting Standard ignores the CENVAT adjustments and only exclusive method is permissible. Sheet of physical verification conducted by the management to be obtained. 18 STAGE IV: IN-DEPTH SCRUTINY OF LEDGERS. 1. 3. 4. 1. 2. 3. Provision for Taxation Ensure the taxation provided according to the taxation Laws applicable at the date of balance Sheet Ensure that provision for tax is made in accordance with the AS-22. " Deferred Tax" Ensure that Provisions u/s 115JB MAT is also considered. By - Jayant R. Shetye 2. Loans and Advances Given Prepare the Chart of Loans and advances given showing the opening balance, additions, repayment , interest charged , TDS deducted and other adjustments made during the year.. Check the Compliances as per Para 8(B) above. Obtain the details of Due from directors with maximum outstanding during the year Ensure proper disclosure is made w. r. t. security aspects. 19 STAGE IV: IN-DEPTH SCRUTINY OF LEDGERS. 1. 2. Obtain the documentary evidence, Agreements, and calculation of commission and their recognition in the Accounts. By - Jayant R. Shetye 3. Other Incomes Interest Income correlate the same with TDS receivable for the year. Insurance Claims received. Commission Income 20 STAGE V: PREPARATION OF FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND FINAL REPORTING By - Jayant R. Shetye CARO 2015 Applicability. Tax Audit Applicability Prepare Financial Statements based on the final data obtained from the client. Prepare Ratio Analysis along-with the possible reasons from management for material deviations. Preparing the Draft Computation of Income. Advance tax table and Tax issues, if any. 21 FOLLOWING SHOULD ALWAYS BE A PART OF YOUR AUDIT FILE Copy of the audited PLBS of the previous year 2. Letter of Appointment. 3. Summary of Audit Visits 4. Printout of all the tables made during the audit visit in the form specified 5. Copies of the quarterly bank statements 6. Any working papers prepared on behalf of the client 7. Copies of acknowledgements of TDS returns 8. Copies of acknowledgements of VAT returns 9. Printouts of ledger accounts taken during the course of audit 10. Any other document obtained during the course of Audit. By - Jayant R. Shetye 1. 22 Audit Sampling Audit Sampling Requires auditors judgment. By - Jayant R. Shetye Statistical Sampling Simple Random Sampling This method uses sampling without replacement; that is, once an item has been selected for testing it is removed from the population and is not subject to re-selection. An auditor can implement simple random sampling in one of two ways: computer programs or random number tables. Systematic (Interval) Sampling This method provides for the selection of sample items in such a way that there is a uniform interval between each sample item. Under this method of sampling, every "Nth" item is selected with a random start. Example every 4th item Stratified (Cluster) Sampling This method provides for the selection of sample items by breaking the population down into strata, or clusters. Each strata is then treated separately. For this plan to be effective, dispersion within clusters should be greater than dispersion among clusters. An example of cluster sampling is the inclusion in the sample of all remittances or cash disbursements for a particular month. 23 By - Jayant R. Shetye 24