a scientific theory is a set of related assumptions that allows scientists to use logical deductive reasoning to formulate testable hypotheses .
a set of related assumptions
a set of related assumptions
a set of related assumptions
logical deductive reasoning
testable
cognitive dissonance theory
cognitive dissonance: uncomfortable feeling or stress caused by holding two contradictory ideas simultaneously.
"dissonant" vs. "consonant"
the theory of cognitive dissonance proposes that people have a fundamental cognitive drive to reduce this dissonance by modifying an existing belief, or rejecting one of the contradictory ideas.
1)the introduction of a new cognition that is dissonant with a currently held cognition creates a state of "dissonance"
2) the magnitude of the “dissonance” relates to the relative importance of the involved cognitions
3) dissonance can be reduced either by eliminating dissonant cognitions, or by adding new consonant cognitions.
4) the maximum possible dissonance is equal to the resistance to change of the less "resistant cognition"; therefore, once dissonance reaches a certain level, one of the dissonant cognition will be changed or eliminated, and dissonance will be reduced.
Q: Are they relevant? Are they directly testable?
human beings, when persuaded to lie without being given sufficient justification, will carry out the task by convincing themselves of the falsehood, rather than telling a bald lie
Q: Does it flow from the previous assumptions?
Is it testable?
Festinger’s experiment
students were made to perform tedious and meaningless tasks
participants rated these tasks very negatively.
after a long period of doing this, students were told the experiment was over and they could leave.
however, the experimenter then asked the subject for a small favor.
the participant was asked to fill in as a research assistant and try to persuade another subject that the dull, boring tasks the subject had just completed were actually interesting and engaging.
some participants were paid $20 for the favor, another group was paid $1, and a control group was not requested to perform the favor.
when asked to rate the peg-turning tasks later, those in the $1 group rated them more positively than those in the $20 group and control group.
Q: Is this explainable by the cognitive dissonance theory? How is the result related to the theory?
other ways of forming the hypotheses
people who feel dissonance will seek information that will reduce dissonance and avoid information that will increase dissonance
people who are involuntarily exposed to information that increases dissonance are likely to discount that information, either by ignoring it, misinterpreting it, or denying it.
alternate theories exist because the very nature of a theory allows the theorist to make speculations from a particular point of view.
observations are colored by the individual observer’s frame of reference, so there may be many diverse theories.
generates research : generates a number of hypotheses that can be investigated through research.
descriptive research hypothesis testing
organizes data into a meaningful structure, provides an explanation for the results, and help ask further questions.
Integrate knowledge into an intelligible framework shape as many bits of information as possible into arrangement
falsifiable : can be confirmed or disconfirmed
be precise enough negative research results: refute the theory; suggest discard or modify it
guides action : provide the practitioner with a guide to action
internally consistent
components logically compatible consistent use of language
parsimonious : be as simple as possible
determinism vs. free choice
pessimism vs. optimism
causality vs. teleology
conscious vs. unconscious determinants of behavior
biological vs. social influences on personality
uniqueness vs. similarities
personality inventories
reliability : does it yield consistent result?
validity : does it measure what it intends to measure?
• Construct validity : the extent to which an instrument measures some hypothetical construct such as intelligence, extraversion, etc.
Convergent validity
Divergent validity
Discriminant validity
• Predictive validity : the extent that a test predicts future.