Databases & Data Mining Operational Data Tools Techniques marketers use to learn more about their own operations, competitors, and customers Includes: • databases • cookies • web analytics data warehouses server log files Database Collection of data structured for quick retrieval of pieces for analysis & application History – 1960s-how much your firm spent on advertising this year – 1980s-advertising dollars by state & year – 1990s-drill down to city/month/zip code – 2000s-predictive, based on past, what are we likely to spend in future? How will this affect sales? Database Benefits of use • • • • Identify best/worst customers Better target promotions to customers Help customers find what they need Establish two-way communication with customers • Integrate data across business divisions • Track competitors Database Marketing Data collected • • • • • Markets Segments Competitors Suppliers Partners Data Consumer data collected • • • • Demographics, geodemographics Transaction histories Lifestyle Behaviors – clickstream, time spent on site • Technical specifications – browser type Databases Marketers: suited for CRM activities • • • • • customer contact identify customers for special offers cross or up-selling tailoring advertising messages predicting purchase rates Database Planning & Design Usually done by IT department • Plan to decide what they want & where to get it from • Organized by files, records, & fields In-house database: build from company data Compiled database: buy from others who collect data Double Click Online advertising firm • Started in 1996 Purchased data warehouse firm Abacus in 1999 • Owns database with over 3.5 billion transaction from 90+ million US households – Largest proprietary buyer behavior database in US Double Click’s Abacus Abacus Database Products • B2C Alliance: consumer focused catalog & specialty retail marketers – Data from over 90 million households • B2B Alliance: direct response marketers – Data from over 75 million business contacts that are actively purchasing Double Click’s Abacus Abacus Database Products • Retail Solutions: specialty retailers who want to increase store traffic within a defined trade area – Highly targeted mailings for increased store sales • Data Management Solutions: customized solution for targeting “right” customers with “best” offer – Multichannel databases, cross channel measurement, data processing, and strategic/analytic services to assess your customers’ behaviors Data Warehousing Store houses for massive amounts of data Data Mining Software systematically sifts through databases looking for significant patterns & correlations Used to create predictive relationships • profile credit card purchases • probability a customer will purchase $500 of goods from a catalog • more than filtering, make predictions Jiffy Lube Began data warehouse project (1998) • Head of marketing, IT, Enterprise data manager Took 7 months to plan • Longer to load 35 million vehicle records • When Parent, Pennzoil, bought Quaker State added another 15 million records Used to profile most profitable customers • Target them with direct mail offers of services that match their interests Privacy Sensitive Tools Cookies: small data files automatically placed on a user’s browser by a web site’s server • used to track & gather information Bugs: electronic GIF images placed by 3rd party media & research companies • collects cookie information on more than one site Privacy Sensitive Tools Server Logs: plain text files that track web data • interpreted by reporting programs – user’s name, place requested, whether file was received or not, size of file, browser used, date/time of request, presence of firewall or not – traffic counters Web Analytics: collecting, organizing & analyzing data for marketing applications Marketing Research Overview of Marketing Research Primary vs Secondary Research Qualitative vs Quantitative Methods Research process • state problem/question, develop plan, collect & organize data, analyze data, report results Traditional research moving online New methods developing for e-commerce Methods Moving Online Qualitative • Focus Groups Online • Interviews Brainstorming Chat Analysis Quantitative • Surveys • Reviews • Simulations Panels Conjoint analysis Online Focus Groups Earliest use documented in 1994 Outgrowth of chat room technology Originally limited to Internet topics Serious trade publication coverage began about 1998 Now used for wide variety of topics Researchers divided on applicability Process Determine target population Arrange technical resources & logistics Recruit sample Re-screen sample • Identity & Internet, computing ability & resources Conduct focus group(s) Prepare transcripts Generate analysis and reports Demonstration Advantages Speed • Avg. turnaround time 5 business days – Transcripts available immediately – Analysis and reports generated sooner Cost savings • Travel • Focus group facility rental/catering • Transcription Access difficult-to-reach populations • Specific user groups Advantages Quality of Response • Less opportunity for only a few participants to dominate (potentially) • Inclusive: most respondents answer every question • Anonymity increases participants' candor and interaction with moderator • Private treatment of "sensitive" topics Disadvantages Online populations not representative No auditory and visual cues • Tone of voice, Facial expressions, Body language, Gestures, Group interactions Reliance on "emoticons” • , “JK” & “LOL” Participant Resources • Level of Internet experience, Typing/Writing skills, Quality of computer and software Other Issues Other Issues • Site security • False identities • Attention to topic vs. external stimuli • Maximum of 6 respondents suggested • Labor Intensive Still Experimental... Measuring Effectiveness of Interactive Media Began with Web Advertising Measurement Most Measures tell cost effectiveness • not tell if achieved desired effect Can refine media & creative choice in real time Hit & Stickiness were first widely accepted standards • Found to be weak, but still used widely today • Potential Industry Standard? Hits The number of files served from a page When a visitor requests a page & it is served, hits are the number of ads in the page • 3 banner ads, 1 graphic, 1 sponsorship--5 hits • Fails to identify contact between ad & visitor • Does not track what happens after page opens Clicks Click Through: when a visitor clicks on a banner ad, activates link, & goes to site – does not capture purchase information Click Rate: Percentage of times ad is clicked divided by number of times served – ad on Yahoo comes in front of a visitor 500 times, it is clicked 10 times, =2% click rate Conversion Rate: rate of those who click & buy (=buyers/viewers) Impressions Opportunity to see an ad/number of times available for viewing CPM--cost per thousand--pricing mechanism for ads • vary for value of host site • 2001 average CPM was $33/1,000 impressions Pages: Number of pages downloaded from a site (but visitor may not view each page) Visitors The total number of people who visit a web site in a period of time • If someone visits multiple times, each time is counted (duplication) Unique visitor: unduplicated number of people visiting in period of time • identified by cookies or IP Eyeballs: number of site visitors that see an ad Stickiness Stickiness: total impressions/month divided by unique visitors/month • captures attractiveness Other relevant terms: • Rate -- cost of placing ad – 2000, CPM for health & fitness $42.50 average – 2000, CPM for general news $37.47 average Branding Advertising & Traffic Building Branding As Internet grows, branding becomes even more important • short run, strong brands: Amazon, EBay Brand includes • name, symbol, design or other elements • provides meaning & identifies ownership • differentiates the product from competition Building a Brand Branding Efforts • • • • • • Awareness Brand promise Character/Personality Create Relationship Shape behavior Provide Reinforcement How to Build Brand Awareness Online Must use on & off-line promotions • Advertising, sales promotions, direct marketing, personal selling, & publicity – 70% of consumers went to a site because of TV, newspaper, & WOM Can use viral marketing to create a buzz • Chat rooms, Screen beans, Tell a friend campaign Pillsbury Begun as flour milling company in 1869 • Marketed in more than 70 countries Pillsbury bake-off competition – Over 50 years old • Utilizes viral marketing with its own website – $1 Million prize – 50% of its 10,000 entries are received online – Recipes on site emailed to friends Burger King The subservient chicken • “Have it Your Way” motto • Get the chicken to do what you want – 300+ actions Created by Crispin, Porter & Bogusky ad agency (2004) Targeted toward 20-30 year olds Burger King Viral Marketing Technique • Promotions that spread word-of-mouth Launched on April 7, 2004 • Only 20 people told about it – Friends of those at agency • 20+ million hits • Six minutes average stickiness • Since promoted site in TV ads Advertising & Traffic Novelty no longer guarantees traffic • Estimated to be over 2 billion websites (2005) Building traffic expensive & difficult Essential beginning points • Search engines • Email marketing Search Engines Search Engine Usage Search Engine Advertising Domain Names Search Engine Usage 90% of Internet users access a search engine Most consumers type in product name on search engine (28%) • 23% link directly to domain name • 9% type in brand name Importance of meta-tags Search Engine Advertising Google • Started in 1998 • 150 million searches per day • Scans over 2 billion web sites Adwords program (2002) • Bid for listing at top of search – Average is .19 cents per click • Pay based on clicks on link Search Engine Advertising Search generates too many results • Few users go beyond first few pages in search List with ALL search engines • Use meta-tags to improve placement Smaller firms most likely to benefit from search engine optimization • 38% of small business owners report that they use some form of online advertising Domain Names Until 1984, Internet addresses had a 10-digit numeric number Domain names introduced as letters instead of numbers Hierarchical order of domains • Top level: .edu, .com, .net, .org, .gov, .mil – And two digit country code • More names added in 2000: .info, .biz, .name, .museum Brand hierarchy issue Domain Names Not to exceed 67 characters Name should be trademarked Can register name online • 80 different companies • Verisign was the first – 16 million names registered in 2001 Own contract for 1-10 years Domain Names Brand needs a great name Domain name should: • reinforce branding – short, descriptive, associated with firm/product, easy to remember • build traffic • anticipate consumer behavior & mistakes • avoid clutter Email Marketing Valuable tool • Better reach of market segment • Lower cost Email lists cost about .10 - .50 per name • Includes rental, email distribution, tracking, & final reporting Direct mail marketing: 1-2% response rate • Permission email gets 30-40% response Easymail Interactive Oldest independent email list broker (1999) 1500+ unique email lists • • • • Sorted by category 276+ million opt-in consumer email addresses 35+ million B2B 105 million international Other Traffic Builders Sales Promotions Personal Selling Public Relations & Publicity Advertising Sales Promotions Temporary inducements to stimulate demand, build traffic, increase sales, influence channel members • found on 93% of commercial web sites – contests, sweepstakes, coupons – games, free samples, club memberships Marketers spent over $10 billion on these efforts in 2004 Personal Selling Sales person interacts with customer • Email or instant messaging/chat Can be effective online • Uncomplicated purchases • Or to support the offline sale IBM combines online information with offline sales negotiations for its high-end enterprise computer systems Public Relations & Publicity Sponsored programs to build image & goodwill of firm • community based events, plant tours, etc. • live chats with executives • schedule online events to launch product or web site Volvo (2000) conducted the first digital automobile launch Public Relations & Publicity Providing information to the media to generate positive consumer word of mouth • email press releases to other media • most corporate web sites have pressrooms with archived press releases Online Advertising First banner ad displayed by IBM on Hotwire.com in 1994 $263 billion total advertising dollars in marketplace $9.6 billion spent on online advertising (2004) • 25% of total US advertising spending – structural changes & growth ($0 in 1994) Online Advertising Largest spenders are in consumer brands • retail, music, & automotive Most direct response • solicit immediate response with a click Focus on branding, awareness, positioning, and product features/benefits Banner Ads 35% of total Internet advertising (2001) • Interactive bulletin boards Response rate average .75 - .3% (2002) • First banner in 1994 garnered 30% click through More effective for national firms Banner Ads Higher click through bold colors top of page placement animation call to action limited exposure larger size Getting larger over time • Large frames can increase awareness by 40% Flash increases click rate by 19% Other Forms of Advertising House Ads: pop-ups on own web site (AOL) • Approximately 28% of advertising space on top rated web sites (2000) Sponsorships: small button near sponsor’s product/web site content • Approximately 25% of all online advertising revenue (2001) Other Forms of Advertising Interstitials--rich media ads on web sites • Like small TV ads • 5-30 seconds Minimovies--cinema type ads filmed for Internet showing • 5-6 minutes • viral marketing BMW minimovies Created by ad agency Fallon Worldwide • 85% of BMW buyers research car online before buying • BMW drivers spent more time with the brand online than through television ads • Cost $15 million to produce • Launched in April 2001 – By July, 2001 over 6 million downloads – Average 16 minutes stickiness on site Other Forms of Advertising Yellow Pages Advertising--1.5% click through rate online • localized by zip code Classified ads--newspapers or portals (Yahoo) • can search local or national Webcast ads--streaming audio/video broadcasts • stream ads in web content • 34% of all Internet users listen to web radio Pricing Standard Pricing Based on demand, set to maximize profits However, many factors influence price – internal objectives, cost, economy, competitors, government, seasons, etc. – cross-channel pricing (same in industry) – multitier pricing (level of service) Prices often fall in range--ceiling, floor, acceptable level Online Pricing Issues Price sensitive consumers lead to increased price competition Information symmetry Price transparency – Intelligence agents (MySimon) Shipping/handling fees also relevant to price for consumers Factors Affecting Online Pricing Unique value asset • unique features & benefits, higher price Substitute awareness effect • awareness of alternatives impacts price • easier to search for substitutes online Total expenditure effect • spend a lot on purchase, shop for best price Factors Affecting Online Pricing Shared cost effect • different people choosing product versus paying leads to higher prices Price-quality effect • before buying use cues & signals to judge quality – trust, confidence, & role of established brands Inventory effect • swing in price is greater for perishables Different Pricing Models Fixed prices--one preset price – Saturn Negotiated prices--haggle over price – Honda Auctions--forward auction--bid up price, highest wins – Ebay Demand collection/name your own price – Priceline.com Different Pricing Models Falling price game--prices fall daily, buyer can bid at price points – JCPenney (2001); Discontinued (2002) Barter--non-monetary exchange – Spun.com’s videogame trade Bundling--combine products into larger packages for single fee – Sprint --telecommunications and more Dynamic Pricing Offered price that reflects demand, inventory level, & buyer characteristics at that time • more easily implemented online • perceived fairness issue Similar to real-time pricing • rental markets, yield management, auctions Rental markets Real-time pricing works well with real-time users Product rental is an immediate need – digital goods – software rental – charge for each use Yield Management Matching of price & available capacity • create restrictions, give lower price to discriminate by sensitivity – airlines Yield management most effective: – fixed, perishable capacity services – high level of fixed costs – identifiable customer base with segments – demand uncertainty & technology to deal with it Yield management Can smooth uncertainties in demand • combined with web application could be applied to various industries – tax preparation – hair styling Trust, Security, & Privacy And Ethical Considerations Some Areas of Concern Online Consumer Research Privacy of data • ChoicePoint fired by Pennsylvania DOT • Posted private drivers’ license records on the web • 2005 Government security report: SEC not adequately protecting privacy of sensitive financial data Some Areas of Concern Information use • Census data used in 1942 to round up Japanese Americans for war camps • 2000 Census first online data collection – 65% response despite law requiring participation Information accuracy • 2002 ChoicePoint sued for selling unregulated data to US Government – FBI, IRS, Drug Enforcement, Immigration Some Areas of Concern Cyberterrorism • Coined in 1980s • Any major based computer attack on government or economy • Hackers – Civil disobedience – Attention to cause – Spread fear Cyberterrorism Since 9/11: unlawful attacks and threats of attach against computers, networks, and the information stored therein when done to intimidate or coerce a government or its people in furtherance of political or social objectives • Example: Denial of Service Attacks (2000) – Ebay, Yahoo, CNN caused over $1 billion in losses Cyberterrorism 49% of IT professionals say a major cyber attack on the US government is imminent 72% say that the government will have a hard time defending against it • • • • 74% believe financial institutions will be hit 67% communication system 67% transportation infrastructure 64% utilities Cyberterrorism Speculated attacks • Bomb or electromagnetic weapon destroys Internet infrastructure • Viruses, denial of service attacks • Stolen classified information • Remote hijacking of control systems – Financial markets, media broadcasts, infrastructure (dams, power grids) Cyberterrorism In first half of 2002, Internet attacks toward 400 companies in 30 countries grew 64% Private companies were twice as likely to be attacked • Compared to private, non-profit, & government entities combined Trust 68% of consumer found profiling acceptable • 9% found it acceptable to make profits from selling personal information to third parties Consumers do not mind organizations using data for better service • Concern is sharing of data Trust Privacy Policies make clear to consumers type of information collected & how it us used • 92% of web sites collect personal information • 86% do not disclose what they will do with that information – legal implications – lack of consumer trust – bankruptcy issues Security Needs for information control • server security • encryption software Staff responsibility: keeping information current & stay abreast of policies on information access Fraud Intentional exploitation of person, group or enterprise • FBI collected 49,000+ complaints in 2001 – $17.8 million dollar loss • Most fraud reported on auction sites (42.8%) – non-deliverable purchase/payments (20.3%) • 76% C2C fraud, 24% B2C fraud – common states: California, Florida, New York, & Texas Liability Duty, responsibility or obligation to consumers • responsible for not selling defective products Web sites often create disclaimers as a disavowal of liability • few guidelines on disclaimers • do not necessarily limit liability Build credibility & trust How to build consumer confidence • E-Trust, independent ratings • Ebay’s ratings of seller credibility – verification of identities – insurance against fraud – escrow accounts – ban on bidding on own products – ban on buyers who do not complete sale Legal Issues Related to the Internet Local law firm specializing in e-commerce: Kennedy Covington Lobdell & Hickman, L.L.P. Bank of America Corporate Center, 100 North Tryon Street, 42nd Floor, Charlotte, North Carolina 28202-4006 Legal Issues Pace of online competition creates problems Laws often develop after a practice has been established – law is well behind the practice • Example legal issues: – unsolicited communication – personal jurisdiction – intellectual property Unsolicited Commercial Email California Business & Professions Code (1998) • Illegal to send UCE with out true domain name source – Internet Service Providers can regulate spammers • UCE must include the phrase ADV for normal advertising & ADV:ADLT for adult material Federal & many state governments are considering similar SPAM laws Personal jurisdiction A lawsuit may be brought against individual in state where: • • • • person resides business is transacted harm occurs contract was created A lack of geography complicates jurisdiction • jurisdiction can be created without physical presence Personal jurisdiction case U.S. v. Jay Cohen (2000) • Outcome: first conviction for illegally accepting bets & wagers from Americans over the Internet & telephones – Federal Wire Wager Act (1964), 5 years in prison & a $250,000 fine • Kyl Bill (1998/2001) updates Wire Wager Act – Illegal to offer online gambling, 4 years in prison & $20,000 fine – Failed in the House Jurisdiction Tests Interactive/Passive Relations Test Interaction with target market in given location • 800# (two-way, active) • one-way information on website (passive) Upload/Download Status Test Country where server’s site is located has jurisdiction • nation has priority • not all cases have followed this rule Changes in Jurisdictional Reach 2001 US Patriot Act greatly expands US government monitoring of email, Internet, & cell phone communications Unprecedented access to communications Gives US government dominance over Internet backbone Intellectual Property Copyright: the exclusive legal right to reproduce, publish, & sell the matter and form of a literary, musical, or artistic work – easy to draw on other peoples’ work online – P2P exchange controversy Trademark: a brand of a firm is given legal protection because it is capable of exclusive appropriation – the firm has exclusive rights to the brand name and/or brand mark Using copyrighted material Not illegal to use material that is: • already in the public domain – time limit; US government material; idea or formula Fair Use provision says that: – can use material for noncommercial purposes – can use material that is primarily informational – less material used, more covered by fair use – less negative economic impact, more likely fair use Domain names Steps: register domain name, pay for ownership, & research whether it violates existing copyright laws • for example, .com, .edu, .org, .net have been sold by Verisign Once you own the domain name, may be able to sell it to other parties Domain names Responsibility of individual (not Verisign) to verify that there is no claim on a name Existing businesses & organizations retain their domain name rights even if they have not taken action to secure the name Each country has its own copyright laws leading to further complications Meta-tags Key words in HTML code on web sites used by search engine • can see them under “view page source” Cannot substitute inappropriate trademark phrases in meta-tags Intellectual Property Cases Net-related Copyright Interpretations • Religious Technology Center v. Netcom Online Communication Services et al. (1995) – Outcome: the World Wide Web “multiplies the effect of market substitution” • U.S. v. LaMacchia (1994) – Outcome: No profit, no infringement Intellectual Property Law No Electronic Theft (NET) Act of 1997 • First Web-oriented copyright legislation; intended to close the “LaMacchia loophole” – Federal crime to distribute or possess illegal electronic copies of copyrighted materials valued over $2,500 (even when profit is not involved) – Maximum penalty: five (5) years in prison and a $250,000 fine Intellectual Property Cases Net-related Trademark Interpretations • Avon v. Carnetta Wong (1996) – Outcome: initial (court-based) understanding of the relationship between trademarks and domain names • Oppendahl & Larson v. Advance Concepts (1997) – Outcome: Infringement occurs even if a company’s name is hidden from view Intellectual Property Law Anticybersquatting Consumer Protection Act of 1999 • First Web-specific trademark legislation; seeks to prevent “bad faith” registration of domain names World Intellectual Property Organization • Arbitration of allocation.com case (2001) – Outcome: party may keep domain name even though its held by someone else (generic term) Property Protection “Foxing” • netiquette term referring to FOX Broadcasting’s self-policing activities Rapid speed is a concern – Gnutella software – Movies Can intellectual property be protected? • Are laws enforceable on the Internet?