Roosevelt, Taft, and
Wilson
The Presidential effect on
Progressivism
How Taft Became President
William Howard Taft was TR’s most trusted
Lieutenant, hand-picked successor
Interesting fact: Taft was 350lbs
Progressive reformer
More regard for the law, would not abuse the powers
of the presidency like TR.
Taft easily won the election in 1908 over Democrat
William Jennings Bryan
President Taft
4 yrs. later Taft would leave the most
decisively beat president of the 20th century.
Problem: He could not satisfy both republican
conservatives and progressives
Taft and the Progressives
Strike 1: Did not lower the Tariff
Strike 2: Appointed pro-big business,
borderline corrupt Secretary of Interior,
Richard Ballinger
- Pinchot vs. Ballinger Controversy
Summarize the event
Who would these events upset?
How would these events upset them? TR?
Roosevelt vs. Taft
Roosevelt had traveled to Africa and Europe
after his departure from Whitehouse
Angered by Taft’s actions
Felt only he could Re-unite Conservatives and
Progressives
Roosevelt’s
“New Nationalism”
Gave Speech on September 10, 1910 called
“New Nationalism”
Speech included Progressive reforms
Basically, a slap in Taft’s face
1910 Congressional Election
Conservative Republicans suffered huge defeat in
the Congressional Elections. What does this
mean?
People are unhappy with Government
People dislike Taft
Roosevelt vs. Taft
Strike 3: U.S. Steel suit in Oct. 27, 1911
TR organized a monopoly with US steel to
help during an economic recession in 1907.
TAFT charged them with a lawsuit and said
the monopoly was illegal.
Slap in TR’s face.
In 1912, the Republican Party splits at it convention:
Why did they support or oppose Taft?
Progressives:
Opposed Taft because he signed
and defended the Payne-Aldrich
Tariff (A weak bill that raised
tariffs, but not enough to
protect American-big business.)
Opposed Taft because he
seemed to oppose conservation
Opposed Taft because he
supported the more
conservative members of the
republican senate, (Joseph
Cannon)
Conservatives:
Supported Taft because they
opposed progressivism, Teddy
Roosevelt’s Square Deal
programs and low tariffs.
Supported Taft because he
favored big business
LaFollette
Roosevelt liked La Follette who was campaining
for Republican nomination
La Follette suffered nervous breakdown in Feb
1912, Roosevelt announced his candidacy Feb 22.
Roosevelt vs. Taft
TR declares a run for presidency
Battle now for the Republican Nomination:
Roosevelt = Progressive Republicans
Taft = Conservative Republicans
TR won victories in all 13 presidential primaries, but
lost the nomination to Taft
TR formed Progressive Party
Said it was “Fit as a bull moose”, hence BULL MOOSE
party
Woodrow Wilson
as Presidential Nominee
Democratic Presidential Candidate
Governor of NJ and professor of Political Science
at Princeton
Committed to Reform – Platform called “New
Freedom”
Why is this a problem for the REPUBLICANS!?!
Election of 1912
Taft resigned to defeat, hardly campaigned
TR campaigned tons, until would-be assassin shot
him, and sidelined him last few weeks before
election
In Nov, TR and Taft split republican vote, Wilson
held onto most Democrats and won easily.
In the 1912 Election, four parties run for President:
Who did each party run for president?
Progressive Party:
Theodore President
Democratic Party:
Woodrow Wilson
Republican Party:
William Howard Taft
Socialist Party:
Eugene V. Debs
Electoral
Vote
Popular Vote
(%)
435
6,293,454
(41.9)
Theodore Roosevelt
(Progressive/Bull Moose)
88
4,119,538
(27.4)
William H. Taft
(Republican)
8
3,484,980
(23.2)
Eugene V. Debs
(Socialist)
—
900,672
(6.0)
Other Parties
(Prohibition; Socialist Labor)
—
235,025
Woodrow Wilson
(Democratic)
Election of 1912
Woodrow Wilson as a Progressive
Concentrated powers of Exec branch in his own hands, more
than TR or Taft
Firm control over his cabinet
Delegated real authority only to those loyal to him
Progressive Acts
Income Tax – graduated income tax, 1% tax on individuals or
corporations earning over $4,000 a year, up to 6% for those over
$500,000
Federal Reserve Act – reform American banking system, passed
December 1913
Federal Trade Commission Act – created a regulatory agency that
would help business determine in advance whether their actions would
be acceptable to the gov.
Clayton Antitrust Act – anti-monopoly act which Wilson eventually
lost interest in after awhile
Woodrow Wilson as a Progressive
By 1914, Wilson believed New Freedom was complete
Refused to support movement for national woman suffrage
Dismissed any new progressive reform legislation
Congressional elections of 1914 smashed democrats, and
Presidents lackluster attempt at reforms
By 1915 – Wilson began to support a 2nd flurry of reforms
Keating-Owen Act – prohibited shipment across state lines of goods
produced by underage children (court invalidated this act in 1918)
Smith-Lever Act – demonstrated how fed gov. could influence local
behavior, fed grants to states that agreed to support agricultural
extension education.