Incentive Pay Systems Pay for Performance Plans Individual incentive plans Group incentive plans Profit-Sharing Gain-sharing 28% 32% 13% ESOPs Variable Pay Pay for Knowledge/Skill-Based All-salaried work force Lump sum awards, bonuses 5% 11% Individual Incentive Plans Pay plans designed to relate pay directly to performance or productivity, often used in conjunction with a basic wage and salary system. Piece rate plans Plans based on time saved Plans based on commission Individual bonuses Suggestion Systems Incentives for Managers Annual bonuses Long-term performance plans Performance share plan (unit plan) Stock options Qualified stock options Nonqualified stock options Incentive stock option (ISO) Stock-for-stock swap Stock appreciation rights Phantom Stock Restricted stock Premium price options Group Incentives Organization-wide incentifes Profit Sharing and Gain-Sharing Plans Scanlon-type plans Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs) DuPont’s “Profit Sharing” Eligibility: Group Vice President to Hourly Performance measurement: Time horizon: Unit profit target Annual--phase in Payout method: Lump sum cash Formula: Base pay is 94% of other units’ base. Less than 80% target: NO PAYOUT 80%-100% target: 3% 100%-150% target: 3% to 18% Three Gain-Sharing Formulas Ratio Numerator Ratio Denominator (input factor) (outcome factor) Scanlon Plan Payroll Costs Net Sales Rucker Plan Labor Costs Value Added Improshare Actual Hours Worked Total Standard Value Hours Exhibit 5-7 Scanlon, Rucker, and Improshare Plans: A Comparison of Key Features FEATURE SCANLON RUCKER IMPROSHARE Required Productivity improvement Labor costs plus raw materials costs plus services costs (e.g., utilities) Required Productivity improvement Completing work at or sooner than production standard Not required Screening and production committees Screening and production committees Not applicable Monthly Monthly Weekly Program goal Productivity improvement Basis for savings Labor costs Employee involvement Type of employee involvement Bonus payout frequency Exhibit 5-4 A Sample Behavioral Encouragement Plan That Rewards Employee Attendance At the end of each three-month period, employees with exemplary attendance records will receive monetary incentive awards according to the following schedule. Note that the number of days absent does not refer to such company-approved absences as vacation, personal illness, jury duty, bereavement leave, military duty, scheduled holidays, and educational leave. NUMBER OF DAYS ABSENT 0 days (perfect attendance) 1 day 2 days 3 days 4 days MONETARY INCENTIVE AWARD $250 $200 $100 $ 50 $ 25 Typical Performance Measures for Individual, Group, and Company-wide Incentive Plans Individual Incentive Plans Quantity of work output Quality of work output Monthly sales Work safety record Work attendance Group Incentive Plans Customer satisfaction Labor cost savings (base pay, overtime pay, benefits) Materials cost savings Reduction in accidents Services cost savings (e.g., utilities) Company-wide Incentive Plans Company profits Cost containment Market share Sales revenue