MODULE 9 INTERPRETING FINANCIALS AT BOARD LEVEL ADB Private Sector Development Initiative Corporate Governance Training Solomon Islands, 2014-2015 Originally by Dr Judy Taylor Acknowledgement These materials were produced by Dr Judy Taylor from La Trobe University, through the Asian Development Bank’s Pacific Private Sector Development Initiative (PSDI). PSDI is a regional technical assistance facility co-financed by the Asian Development Bank, Australian Aid and the New Zealand Aid Programme. Module 9: Interpreting financials at board level • What are the main financial statements • How to read the financial statements Introduction to key financial statements 1. balance sheet 2. changes in equity 3. income statement 4. comprehensive income 5. cash flow statement. Overview of financial governance The board is responsible for the true and fair financial reporting of their company (entity) While the board delegates some of the oversight tasks to committees, they retain ultimate responsibility and authority Board’s role is not to manage, but to ensure the organisation is being managed (governed) When something goes wrong the board is collectively accountable. Financial statements All companies must complete a Balance Sheet as well as an Income Statement IFRS compliant companies must complete all 5 statements The Cash Flow Statement is required under IFRS and for companies that have to be audited Unfortunately the Cash Flow Statement is not required to be completed by all companies, but directors who do not compare their budgeted cash flow with their actual cash flow are missing vital information on the health of their company Underlying principle Accrual system underlies balance sheet income statement Accrual system “determines profit by recognising revenues as earned when the goods/services are provided, and expenses as incurred when the benefit is consumed”.1 eg. sale or purchase on credit 1. Anthony Simmons and Richard Hardy, Cambridge VCE Accounting Units 1 &2, (2012, Cambridge University Press), p.277 Performance V Position The income statement shows the performance of the company over a period of time, whereas the balance sheet shows the position of the company on a set date Cash Flow The cash flow statement is drawn up on the basis of cash received and paid, classified as operating, investing and financing activities. Together these three accounts provide useful and valuable insight into the financial health and performance of the company How to read a balance sheet Balance sheet consists of three main categories Assets - things the company owns Liabilities - things the company owes Equity - the owners portion and retained earnings of the company A=L+E Owners Equity Alternatively we can see the balance sheet from the owner’s perspective E= A-L Balance Sheet format There are many acceptable formats for the presentation of the balance sheet. The industry type, such as manufacturing, retail or medical, usually determines the format. A variety of balance sheet formats can be found online by googling “format balance sheet”. Balance sheet What is an asset, what is a liability? IASB framework defines them as: Assets: “Resources controlled by the enterprise as a result of past events and from which future economic benefits are expected to flow to the enterprise. Assets are what a company owns. Liabilities: present obligations of an enterprise arising from past events, the settlement of which is expected to result in an outflow of resources embodying economic benefits. Liabilities are what the company owes. Equity: in public companies, also known as shareholders equity or stockholders equity. Assets less liabilities. “Equity is the residual interest in the assets after subtracting liabilities.” 2 2. IASB, Framework for the Preparation and Presentation of Financial Statements, Para 4.4(a), 4.44-57 Classification of Assets and Liabilities Assets are divided between current assets (CA), those that will be used up within a year non-current assets (NCA) that will live beyond a year. Liabilities are also divided into two categories current liabilities (CL), those that need to be paid within a year non-current liabilities (NCL), those that will be paid after a year Equity is the owner’s contribution (stock/shares) into the company as well as the retained earnings (undistributed profits) of the company and any capital reserves. Balance sheet - overview At a glance the balance of each of these categories should be CA>CL You should have more assets that will mature within one year than liabilities. Otherwise you will not be able to meet all short-term liquidity commitments. NCA>NCL The NCA should be greater than NCL, Finally assets should be able to generate a return sufficient to cover the liabilities (interest, lease and rent payments) and pay a reward to the owners of the capital (dividends) How to read an income statement The income statement is a statement of revenue and expenses earned and incurred using accrual accounting. It shows how the company has performed over the period, usually 12 months. INCOME: “Increases in economic benefits in the form of inflows or enhancements of assets, or decreases in liabilities that result in an increase in equity. Income includes both revenues and gains. Revenues represent income from ordinary activities of the enterprise. Gains may result from ordinary activities or other activities.”3 Expenses: “decreases in economic benefits in the form of outflows or depletion of assets or increases in liabilities that result in decreases in equity.”4 Income is recognised if it is probable to occur and when it can be measured reliably 3. IASB, Framework for the Preparation and Presentation of Financial Statements, (2010)Para 4.38 4. IASB, Framework for the Preparation and Presentation of Financial Statements, (2010)Para 4.25 (a-b) How to read an income statement The expenses listed on the income statement can be grouped either by function or by nature. Example - by nature including all depreciation relating to machinery used in production as well as depreciation of office furniture together– they are all depreciation. grouping by function grouping all costs that are incurred in manufacturing such as only depreciation on machinery plus production inputs.5 (Depreciation of office furniture would appear under operating costs.) Both are permitted under IFRS 5. Thomas R. Robinson, International Financial Statement Analysis, (2012, Wiley) p 138 Income statement An income statement is tiered giving at least five subtotals of profit,6 gross profit profit for year before tax profit for year from continuing operations profit for the year total comprehensive income for the year When the income Statement is analysed more tiers are added. See next Module. Gross profit 1. Gross profit This profit is generated by revenue (usually net after an allowance for bad debts has been estimated) from the sale of goods and or services of a firm’s continuing operations (the main purpose) less the cost of manufacturing or purchasing the inputs. The gross profit is independent of the firm’s capital structure. Net revenue less cost of goods sold = gross profit Profit for year before tax 2. Profit for year before tax Gross profit Plus - other income such as interest income or other gains and losses, less - the indirect cost of selling and administrative activities as well as other expenses such as research and development, -but not interest and taxation expenses. Gross profit less operating expenses = EBIT profit for the year before interest and tax EBIT less interest = EBT profit for year before tax Profit for year from continuing operations 3. Profit for year from continuing operations, profit for the year before tax, EBT, less tax expense =profit for the year from continuing operations. 4. Profit for the year =profit for the year from continuing operations less discontinued operations Comprehensive income 5. Total comprehensive income for the year This includes a list of amounts that are included in the calculation of the income statement as well as amounts that are not. Listed but not included - gains such as revaluation of property, share of gain or loss on property revaluation of associate, or re-measurement of defined benefit obligations must be recorded but not included in income. Listed and Included - other gains such as exchange differences on translating foreign operations, net fair values gain available from sale of financial assets and net fair value gain on hedging instruments entered into for cash flow hedges are included Profit for year plus other comprehensive income = total comprehensive income for the year. Financial Reporting Sales Cost of sales Gross profit Operating expenses Depreciation & amortisation EBIT Interest EBT Tax Income continuing operation Less discontinued operation Net Income/Profit for year Revaluation of property Translation gain (loss) Comprehensive income 2013 50000 25000 25000 12000 2014 60000 32000 28000 14000 2000 11000 1000 10000 500 9500 2000 4000 10000 2000 8000 600 7400 1500 7500 1500 2000 9500 6100 1500 (1200) 4900 Tiered income helps directors These levels are helpful for directors who need to understand where their profit is coming from. 1. Core function 2. Core function less operational costs and debt 3. Profit less impact of taxation 4. Profit impacted for activities closed down or sold 5. Income after effect of non core activities How to read the Cash flow statement The cash flow statement has 4 components, Cash flow from operations (CFO) Cash flow from investing (CFI) Cash flow from financing. (CFF) Reconciliation of cash balance with previous year. Cash flow statement shows what cash has been received and paid. It does not show the profitability of the company. How to read the Cash flow statement CFO Records activities that create revenues and expenditures from ‘core’ manufacturing or production or servicing operations Can include interest receipts and interest payments but NOT net interest CFI Cash flow from investing represents the purchase or sale of productive assets for cash, e.g. property plant and equipment, shares in another company (not held for trading). Cash flow from investments in joint ventures and affiliates and cash flow from long term investment in securities are included as investing cash flows. Cash flow consequences of acquisitions and divestments are also included as investing cash flows. Interest on investment activities can be classified as either CFI or CFO How to read the Cash flow statement CFF Cash inflows include additional borrowings and equity capital raisings Cash outflows include debt repayments and equity capital buy backs Dividend payments are included as financing cash outflows, Interest expenses can be either CFF or CFO Presentation of Cash flow 2 Methods direct method or indirect method. Both methods give different information, but should give the same result. only CFO is done on an indirect basis both CFI and CFF are always constructed using the direct method. IFRS prefer direct but allow indirect Direct versus indirect method direct method gives the gross amounts of revenues and expenses received and paid. indirect method begins with the net income and makes adjustments to the net income for amounts that were not received or paid, for noncash amounts and for changes in working capital accounts. The indirect method tells you why there is a difference between net income and Cash flow from operations whereas the direct method gives you information regarding gross sales received and gross expenses paid. What do you expect to see on a cash flow statement? Cash flow from operations should be positive. A young company may not have a positive CFO, but a mature company will not survive if its CFO is not positive. Directors must review the CFO: Is the company generating enough cash from their operations to be able to meet the obligations above AND to grow the company? What you do not see on the cash flow statement Noncash transactions Companies settling a debt by issuing equity capital. This transaction would not be reported within the cash flow statement as no cash flow occurred. However because the transaction may affect future cash flows through increased dividend payments, they should be disclosed in a separate schedule What do you not see in the financial statements? The three financial statements usually aggregate the activity of the business so that the financial statements appear very superficial. Detail can found in the footnotes to the accounts that often run over 40 or 50 pages. The financial statements cannot be understood properly unless the footnotes are all read thoroughly. Statement of Changes in Equity activity. Equity is made up of shareholders’ contribution (share capital), reserves and retained earnings. Complete columns B and D for each year. Calculate the retained earnings for each year in column E. Check: Does total profits less total dividends over the 4 years = retained earnings at the end of year 4?