Chapter 2 Indigenous Sacred Ways Understanding indigenous sacred ways Cultural diversity The circle of right relationships Spiritual specialists Group observances Contemporary issues Professor D'Ascoli Key terms cosmogony Dreaming (Dream Time) indigenous lifeway medicine person orisa shaman vision quest Professor D'Ascoli “All animals have power, because the Great Spirit dwells in all of them, even a tiny ant, a butterfly, a tree, a flower, a rock. The modern, white man’s way keeps that power from us, dilutes it. To come to nature, feel its power, let it help you, one needs time and patience for that....You have so little time for contemplation....It lessens a person’s life, all that grind, that hurrying and scurrying about. Lame Deer, Lakota nation Professor D'Ascoli “The wicasa wakan [holy man] wants to be by himself. He wants to be away from the crowd, from everyday matters. He likes to meditate, leaning against a tree or rock, feeling the earth move beneath him, feeling the weight of that big flaming sky upon him....Closing his eyes, he sees many things clearly. What you see with your eyes shut is what counts....” Lame Deer, Lakota nation Professor D'Ascoli Approximate distribution of indigenous groups in this chapter. Professor D'Ascoli Understanding Indigenous Sacred Ways Have traditionally been little understood by outsiders Many traditions have been practiced in secret— hidden from outsiders—hindering scholarly study May be seen as a lifeway - an approach to all aspects of life Common ground between these religions and those on the outside is emerging Emerging ideas on indigenous religion First, some traditional elders are beginning to share their core values regarding reverence for the earth with others because of their concerns about current ecological developments Second, members of global religions (and others) are coming to a new appreciation for the profundity and value embedded in indigenous sacred ways, particularly with respect to the environment Third, some members of global faiths are being attracted to the spirituality and practices of indigenous religions However, some indigenous leaders fear that their spiritual traditions are being trivialized and/or exploited Cultural Diversity Although focus is on common characteristics of indigenous religions, these religions are quite distinct As a whole, indigenous forms of spirituality exhibit traditions that developed within a spectrum of cultural, religious, and material diversity Some indigenous cultures have been highly developed whereas others still embody a basic strategy of survival (e.g., Australian Aborigines). Uluru (Ayers Rock) is sacred to Australian aborigines. Professor D'Ascoli Cultural Diversity Groups whose material culture is simple nonetheless may have highly complex cosmogonies or models of the origins of the universe and their purpose in it Such groups may live in somewhat sheltered ancestral enclosures or large contemporary urban areas They also vary in the degree of adaptation to and absorption of the dominant religions in their regions (e.g. indigenous African religious traditions fused with Christianity in the context of slavery, such as Vodou and Santeria). The Circle of Right Relationships For many indigenous peoples, everything in the cosmos is intimately interrelated Sometime represented as a circle, which has no beginning, no end Cosmos is thought to contain divinities, spirits, and ancestors All aspects of the tangible world are imbued with spirit Common theme in indigenous lifeways is developing an appropriate relationship with spiritual energy Efe children in Democratic Republic of Congo play “circle game.” Professor D'Ascoli Navajo sand-painting shows Father Sky with constellations and the Milky Way forming his body and Mother Earth with the four sacred plants, squash, beans, tobacco, and corn forming hers. Professor D'Ascoli Spiritual Specialists In hunting and gathering tribes religion is private; individuals have direct access to the unseen However, the world of the spirit is thought to be dangerous Interacting with spirit world best left to those specially trained for it Storytellers Common role because traditions are oral rather than written What is held in memory cannot be physically destroyed but if all the storytellers die the knowledge is lost In Africa poets are considered “technicians of the sacred” Other roles: drummers, tricksters, sacred clowns, secret societies, priests/priestesses Mystical Intermediaries Shaman is a generic term used by scholars for those who offer themselves as mystical intermediaries Shamanic methods are extremely ancient The shaman is often a healer or a helper to society May be hereditary or recognized as a special gift Group Observances Humans can help maintain the natural harmony of the world by practicing ritual observances These rituals are community-centered Some follow the major points of passage in the human life cycle Birth Naming Puberty Marriage Death Prayer cloths on a sacred tree at a Sun Dance in Mexico. Professor D'Ascoli Individual Observance Balances the communal dimension of ritual observance Important for individuals to experience a personal connection with the realm of the spirits Undergoing a vision quest (usually at puberty) is a common means of access to the other world The gods and the spirits of the dead appear in costumed initiates in West Africa. Professor D'Ascoli Contemporary Issues Central concern: the near obliteration of these responses to the sacred world Many indigenous people have been displaced by development Indigenous world view that reveres all creation, recognizes the circle of life, and honors the human relationship with mother earth may be necessary to stop the present ecological destruction of the planet Anthropology of Primitive Religions Animism Tylor first studied religion anthropologically and developed a taxonomy of religions. Animism was seen as the most primitive and is defined as a belief in souls that derives from the first attempt to explain dreams and like phenomena. Mana and Taboo Mana is defined as belief in an immanent supernatural domain or life-force, potentially subject to human manipulation. The Polynesian and Melanesian concepts of mana are contrasted. Melanesian mana is defined as a sacred impersonal force that is much like the Western concept of luck. Polynesian mana and the related concept of taboo are related to the more hierarchical nature of Polynesian society. Magic and Religion Magic refers to supernatural techniques intended to accomplish specific aims. Magic may be imitative (as with voodoo dolls) or contagious (accomplished through contact). Anxiety, Control, Solace Magic is an instrument of control, but religion serves to provide stability when no control or understanding is possible. Malinowski saw tribal religions as being focused on life crises. Rituals Rituals are formal, performed in sacred contexts. Rituals convey information about the culture of the participants and, hence, the participants themselves. Rituals are inherently social, and participation in them necessarily implies social commitment. Rites of Passage Rites of passage are religious rituals which mark and facilitate a person's movement from one (social) state of being to another (e.g., Plains Indians’ vision quests). Rites of passage have three phases: Separation – the participant(s) withdraws from the group and begins moving from one place to another. Liminality – the period between states, during which the participant(s) has left one place but has not yet entered the next. Incorporation – the participant(s) reenters society with a new status having completed the rite. Liminality is part of every rite of passage and involves the temporary suspension and even reversal of everyday social distinctions. Communitas refers to collective liminality, characterized by enhanced feelings of social solidarity and minimized distinctions. Totemism Rituals play an important role in creating and maintaining group solidarity. In totemic societies, each descent group has an animal, plant, or geographical feature from which they claim descent. Totems are the apical ancestor of clans. The members of a clan did not kill or eat their totem, except once a year when the members of the clan gathered for ceremonies dedicated to the totem. Totemism is a religion in which elements of nature act as sacred templates for society by means of symbolic association. Totemism uses nature as a model for society. Each descent group has a totem, which occupies a specific niche in nature. Social differences mirror the natural order of the environment. The unity of the human social order is enhanced by symbolic association with and imitation of the natural order. Religion and Cultural Ecology: Sacred Cattle in India Ahimsa is the Hindu doctrine of nonviolence that forbids the killing of animals. Western economic development experts often use this principle as an example of how religion can stand in the way of development. Hindus seem to irrationally ignore a valuable food source (beef). Hindus also raise scraggly and thin cows, unlike the bigger cattle of Europe and the U.S. These views are ethnocentric and wrong as cattle play an important adaptive role in an Indian ecosystem that has evolved over thousands of years Hindus use cattle for transportation, traction, and manure. Bigger cattle eat more, making them more expensive to keep. Social Control The power of religion affects action. Religion can be used to mobilize large segments of society through systems of real and perceived rewards and punishments. Witch hunts play an important role in limiting social deviancy in addition to functioning as leveling mechanisms to reduce differences in wealth and status between members of society. Many religions have a formal code of ethics that prohibit certain behavior while promoting other kinds of behavior. Religions also maintain social control by stressing the fleeting nature of life. Kinds of Religion Religious forms vary from culture to culture, but there are correlations between political organization and religious type. Religious Practitioners and Types Wallace defined religion as consisting of all a society’s cult institutions (rituals and associated beliefs) and developed four categories from this. In Shamanic religions, shamans are part-time religious intermediaries who may act as curers--these religions are most characteristic of foragers. Communal religions have shamans, community rituals, multiple nature gods, and are more characteristic of food producers than foragers. Olympian religions first appeared with states, have full-time religious specialists whose organization may mimic the states, and have potent anthropomorphic gods who may exist as a pantheon. Monotheistic religions have all the attributes of Olympian religions, except that the pantheon of gods is subsumed under a single eternal, omniscient, omnipotent, and omnipresent being. Christian Values Max Weber linked the spread of capitalism to the values central to the Protestant faith: independent, entrepreneurial, hard working, future-oriented, and free thinking. The emphasis Catholics placed on immediate happiness and security, and the notion that salvation was attainable only when a priest mediated on one’s behalf, did not fit well with capitalism. World Religions In the U.S. Protestants outnumber Catholics, but in Canada the reverse is true. Religious affiliation in North America varies with ethnic background, age, and geography. Revitalization Movements Religious movements that act as mediums for social change are called revitalization movements. The colonial-era Iroquois reformation led by Handsome Lake is an example of a revitalization movement. Syncretisms A syncretism is a cultural mix, including religious blends, that emerge when two or more cultural traditions come into contact. Examples include voodoo, santeria, and candomlé. The cargo cults of Melanesia and Papua New Guinea are syncretisms of Christian doctrine with aboriginal beliefs. Syncretisms often emerge when traditional, non-Western societies have regular contact with industrialized societies. Syncretisms attempt to explain European domination and wealth and to achieve similar success magically by mimicking European behavior and symbols. A New Age Since the 1960s, there has been a decline in formal organized religions. New Age religions have appropriated ideas, themes, symbols, and ways of life from the religious practices of Native Americans, Australian Aborigines, and east Asian religions. Recognizing Religion It is difficult to distinguish between sacred and secular rituals as behavior can simultaneously have sacred and secular aspects. Americans try to maintain a strict division between the sacred and the profane, but many other societies like the Betsileo do not. A Pilgrimage to Walt Disney World Walt Disney World functions much like a sacred shrine that is a major pilgrimage destination It has an inner, sacred center surrounded by an outer more secular domain. Parking lot designations are distinguished with totemlike images of the Disney cast of characters. The monorail provides travelers with a brief liminal period as they cross between the outer, secular world into the inner, sacred center of the Magic Kingdom. Within the Magic Kingdom Spending time in the Magic Kingdom reaffirms, maintains, and solidifies the world of Disney as all of the pilgrims share a common status as visitors while experiencing the same adventures. Most of the structures and attractions at the Magic Kingdom are designed to reaffirm and recall a traditional set of American values. Myths, Legends, Folk Tales myths, legends and folktales Storytelling is common to every culture. Most people enjoy listening to stories. Storytellers have catered to the need for a 'good story' since the beginning of civilization. Most people have their own favorite story from childhood and, often, these tales are both fascinating and frightening. These stories include legends, myths and folktales. What are legends? A legend is a semi-true story, which has been passed on from person-to-person and has important meaning or symbolism for the culture in which it originates. A legend usually includes an element of truth, or is based on historic facts, but with 'mythical qualities'. Legends usually involve heroic characters or fantastic places and often encompass the spiritual beliefs of the culture in which they originate. What are myths? A myth is a story based on tradition or legend, which has a deep symbolic meaning. A myth 'conveys a truth' to those who tell it and hear it, rather than necessarily recording a true event. Although some myths can be accounts of actual events, they have become transformed by symbolic meaning or shifted in time or place. Myths are often used to explain universal and local beginnings and involve supernatural beings. The great power of the meaning of these stories, to the culture in which they developed, is a major reason why they survive as long as they do - sometimes for thousands of years. What are folktales? A folktale is a popular story that was passed on in spoken form, from one generation to the next. Usually the author is unknown and there are often many versions of the tale. Folktales comprise fables, fairy tales, old legends and even 'urban legends'. Again, some tales may have been based on a partial truth that has been lost or hidden over time. It is difficult to categorize folktales precisely because they fit into many categories. Folk tales are often referred to as Tall Tales. What is the difference between legends, myths and folktales? Myths, legends and folktales are hard to classify and often overlap. Imagine a line (or continuum) as illustrated below, with an historical account based on facts at one end and myths or cultural folktales at the other; as you progress towards the mythical/folktale end of the line, what an event symbolizes to people, or what they feel about it, becomes of greater historical significance than the facts, which become less important. By the time you reach the far end of the spectrum, the story has taken on a life of its own and the facts of the original event, if there ever was one, have become almost irrelevant. It is the message that is important. Why were the stories told? As well as making fascinating reading, these stories also tell us a great deal about how people in the past saw, and understood, the world around them. There are many reasons why stories are told and passed down the generations. Here are just a few of them: To strengthen a community and provide a common understanding. Stories often reflect the beliefs of the people who tell them. The popularity of any story depends on whether those listening approve of the values underlying it. By telling and listening to stories, people confirmed their ideas about the world around them. Things that people found scary, infuriating, or desirable all found their way into the stories and they were passed on, because people wanted to be assured that other people around them were thinking along the same lines. Continued As a way of providing moral guidance and showing people how they should conduct themselves, including the consequences of not doing so. Myths and legends, like any good stories, often include a moral. Within the myth, the hurt or embarrassment experienced by people is often due to their own stupidity, greed, dishonesty or negligence. To explain how the world works, for example why the seasons change, and to explain strange happenings or phenomena such as eclipses - the reasons for which were unknown in early times. For entertainment purposes. Stories were told to amuse and enthrall an audience in the days before TV and other forms of mass entertainment. Continued To pass on history and knowledge, such as the outcome of battles and tales of courage, in ages when many people could not read or write. Many myths have an element of truth that has been built upon and embellished over the years. For fame, money or recognition - as in all areas of life, not all stories were told for good reasons. For example, stories of bravery in battle could enhance the status of an individual or a group or, in later centuries, a good ghost story could be sold for money. The truth was not always the most important consideration. Regardless of why they were told, many of the stories still remain popular today and, although we no longer swap stories around the fireside, the tradition of storytelling still continues in the form of urban legends. Many older stories also live on in current day carnivals or festivals, which have their roots in a very different past. Features of Myths and Legends A re-telling The orientation is typically timeless e.g. ‘Long, long ago’ ‘ Before animals walked the earth’ A single animal is representative of all animals of that kind Natural forces like wind and fire are represented by gods or god-like form The resolution of myths and legends explain why things are the way we are A classic opening and\or closing (e.g. Once upon a time…., And they all lived happily after) A representative of good and evil in characters Stereotypes e.g. Animals e.g. wolves are bad; rescuers are male The representative of certain values, wealth= happiness, beauty = happiness The involvement of supernatural forces, e.g. fairy godmothers, creatures that can talk Tales are based around themes like trickery and foolishness summarizing the outcome of the myth or legend ‘But still to this day…’ ‘So every time you see…’ These comments sum up how things came to be . What makes a hero? A hero is someone who is distinguished for his or her courage or ability. They are admired for brave deeds and noble qualities. They may have performed heroic acts. They may also be someone who is a model or an ideal. Folktales / Tall Tales A tall tale is a story that provides enjoyment to a wide variety of audiences. Tall tales stretch the imagination through colorful figurative language and exaggerations. Tall tales are also known as lying tales; they are humorous exaggerations. Tall tales may come from other countries but we are most familiar with American ones. Attributes of tall tales Tall tales are often about the frontier days in the United States. They are an exaggeration of the hardships of frontier life. Tall tales may be about animals, weather, everyday events, and ordinary people; but the more famous tales are about heroes. Tall tales often feature over-sized people and exaggerated deeds. Chapter 3 Hinduism Philosophical and metaphysical origins Major philosophical systems Religious foundations and theistic paths The Hindu way of life Hinduism in the modern world Professor D'Ascoli Key terms ashram atman avatar bhakti Brahman brahmin caste chakra darsan deva dharma guru Kali Yuga karma moksha prana puja reincarnation rishi Shaivite Professor D'Ascoli Shakta samsara sannyasin Sanskrit secularism sutra Tantra Vaisnavite yoga “In the beginning there was Existence alone--One only, without a second. He, the One, thought to himself: Let me be many, let me grow forth. Thus out of himself he projected the universe, and having projected out of himself the universe, he entered every being. All that is has its self in him alone. Of all things he is the subtle essence. He is the truth. He is the self. And that....THAT ART THOU.” Chandogya Upanishad Professor D'Ascoli “There is no truth superior to Me. Everything rests upon Me, as pearls are strung on a thread.... I am the taste of water, the light of the sun and the moon, the syllable om in Vedic mantras; I am the sound in ether and ability in man.... All states of being--goodness, passion, or ignorance--are manifested by My energy. I am, in one sense, everything--but I am independent. I am not under the modes of this material nature.” Bhagavad Gita Professor D'Ascoli Timeline c. 8000-6000 BCE c. 2500-1500 c. 2000-900 c. 1500 c. 1000-500 BCE c. 400 BCE-200 CE c. 400 BCE-400 CE 200 BCE 100-300 CE c. 600-1800 711 c. 788-820 1556-1707 1836-1886 1857-1947 Traditionally, Vedas heard by rishis Indus Valley civilization Supposed Aryan invasions of N. India Early Vedas composed Upanishads systematized by Vyasa Ramayana (present form) Mahabharata (present form) Traditionally, Patanjali edits Yoga Sutras Code of Manu compiled Bhakti movement flourishes Muslim invasions begin Shankara reorganizes Vedanta Mogul Empire Life of Ramakrishna British rule of India Professor D'Ascoli Professor D'Ascoli Introduction Some scholars claim there is no central tradition that can be identified as Hinduism, however, it can be dated back over 5000 years. The term Hinduism did not become common until the 19th century A range of practices that vary according to region, caste, gender, and education The philosophic Brahmanic tradition often referred to as Hinduism is but one aspect of a larger tradition Professor D'Ascoli HINDUISM A label that includes a wide range of: Religious practices Customs Beliefs Sacred places Deities Hinduism is tolerant of this variety and does not condemn certain religious practices or beliefs as evil Background Hindu derives from Sanskrit word for Indus River Hindu worship focuses on a pantheon of gods who personify the forces of nature (not an historical person or prophet) At the center of the Hindu religion is the idea of Brahman – the indivisible essence of all spiritual reality, the divine source of all being Brahman: Essence of Reality He is not ultimate reality because he can be visualized. Brahma’s life span = each day is 1000 times the whole of human history. The world will end with the appearance of Vishnu is about 4000 years from now. Basic Beliefs Brahman’s 3 functions are divided into 3 gods: (1) Brahma – the creator – not the same as Brahman; (2) Vishnu – the preserver; and (3) Shiva – the destroyer. Brahman is the supreme reality Brahman has two aspects, transcendent (impersonal and unknowable) and immanent (personal and knowable) In the impersonal aspect, Brahman lies outside the realm of human description and can only be sensed as a presence within oneself and the rest of the universe God is “immanent,” the universe is the manifestation rather than the creation of God In the personal aspect, Brahman can be known in various forms—the many Hindu deities and the rest of creation Philosophical and Metaphysical Origins Brahmanic tradition traces back to the Vedic age, thousands of years ago The Vedas Foundation of upper-caste Brahmanic Hinduism Revered collection of ancient sacred hymns The Rig Veda is the first & oldest of 4 collections (earliest copy we have dates from 1200BCE – making it the earliest Indo-European document in history) Professor D'Ascoli Major Philosophical Systems Share Roots in the vedas Direct personal experience of truth thru meditation Ethics as necessary to orderly social life (related to karma) Suffering is due to ignorance of the eternal self Professor D'Ascoli Kharma and the soul The idea of kharma is also central to Hindi thought Kharma means action, however the concept of kharma involves moral cause and effect (you get what you put out) People’s accumulation of these moral actions will determine the form in which he or she will reincarnate Because of this people’s current condition (poor, deformed, etc) is believed to have been caused by your previous misuse of your earlier existence Ancient Hindu society reflects these religious beliefs in their caste system. All have an atman or soul which can never be destroyed. Five Major Doctrines Truth is one, Sages call it by different names Rig Veda, 1.164.46 All Mankind is One Family Hitopadesha, Subhashita Ratna Bhandagare Law of Karma - As you sow, so shall you reap Mahabharata, Shantiparva 299.42; BG 18.60 That mode of living which is founded upon total harmlessness towards all creatures or [in case of genuine necessity] upon a minimum of such harm, is the highest morality Mahabharata, Shantiparva 262.5-6 Whenever there is a decline of virtue, God incarnates Himself on earth to uphold righteousness Bhagavad Gita 4.7, 4.8 Major Philosophical Systems (continued) Samkhya: Two states of reality Purusha, the Self Prakriti, the cause of the material universe Advaita Vedanta Monistic Based on the Upanishads Yoga: raja, jnana, karma, bhakti Union with the true Self Professor D'Ascoli Religious Foundations and Theistic Paths Three major groupings of deities worshipped by Hindus Shaktas: worship a Mother Goddess Shaivites: worship the god Shiva Vaishnavites: worship the god Vishnu THE TWO MOST POPULAR GODS SHIVA VISHNU Avatars of Vishnu Krishna Rama Goddesses Lakshmi Saraswati Kali Wife of Shiva Black in color & wearing a necklace of skulls. She is a bloodthirsty goddess. A violent destroyer of her enemies affectionate and caring for her devotees. . The Ganges River Falling from its source of Vishnu’s feet onto Shiva’s head and out from his hair, the water of the Ganges is sacred enough to purify all sins. Banaras - Hindu’s Holy City Pilgrims come from all over to bathe in the Ganges. Countless Hindus come to Banaras to die. It has 1500 temples, most of them devoted to Shiva. It is a gathering place for the religiously learned and their disciples. Yogi meditating in the Himalaya Mountains near the home of Shiva at the source of the Ganges River. Professor D'Ascoli The Epics and Puranas Ilustrate trend toward personal love for a deity Two major epics Ramayana Mahabharata (includes the Bhagavad-Gita The Puranas Poetic Sanskrit texts that narrate the myths of ancient times Professor D'Ascoli Caste System Indian society is divided into 4 distinct classes or castes: (1) Brahmins – priests, leaders, seers and religious authorities; (2) Kshatriyas – originally the kings and warriors of the ancient past, now they are the administrators, politicians and civil authorities; (3) Vaishyas – businessmen, merchants, traders, doctors, lawyers, teachers, etc.; and (4) Shudras – they are the laborers, the servant class. However, even beneath the Shudras are the Outcastes – called the ‘untouchables’ – these are members of Indian society who fall outside of any of the castes and are therefore avoided by members of the other classes completely The Hindu Way of Life Ritual: central to Hinduism Castes, duties, and life goals 4 occupational groups: Brahmins, Kshatriayas, Vaishyas, Shudras Untouchables lay outside the sysem 4 major goals for a good life: dharma, artha, kama, moksha Professor D'Ascoli The Hindu Way of Life (continued) Life stages: student, householder, meditation/study, renunciation The guru: spiritual leader Women’s duties: dharma, marital wealth, sensual pleasure Fasts, prayers, and auspicious designs: determined by a complex lunar or solar calendar Professor D'Ascoli The Hindu Way of Life (continued) Reverence of trees and rivers Pilgrimages Festivals Professor D'Ascoli The 2001 Kumbha Mela was the largest ever gathering of people. Professor D'Ascoli Hinduism in the Modern World Hinduism has been influenced by contact with Buddhism, Jainism, and later Islam, and Christianity Modern movements: currently being challenged by social reform movements Global Hinduism: Has spread through immigration and conversion Professor D'Ascoli Hinduism in the Modern World (continued) Hindu identity Some link Hinduism with nationalism India’s constitution enshrines secularism According to the Indian Supreme Court, to be Hindu means [next slide] Professor D'Ascoli Hindu Identity (continued) Acceptance and reverence for the Vedas as the foundation of Hindu philosophy; A spirit of tolerance, and willingness to understand and appreciate others’ points of view, recognizing that truth has many sides; Acceptance of the belief that vast cosmic periods of creation, maintenance, and dissolution continuously recur; Acceptance of belief in reincarnation; Recognition that paths to salvation and truth are many; Recognition that there may be numerous gods and goddesses to worship, without necessarily believing in worship through idols; Unlike other religions, absence of belief in a specific set of philosophic concepts. Professor D'Ascoli