Why genes are regulated? • Minimize energy consumption--why express a gene you do not need? (economy) • Control growth--many cells in a mature organism do not grow, and expression of genes involved in promoting cell division is tightly regulated. (physiological balance) • Development--inappropriate expression of genes that regulate differentiation may adversely affect development (pathology) • Response to environment (dynamic) How is gene regulation controlled? Transcription- at initiation and at termination. Less happened at elongation. RNA processing- only happened in Eukaryotes via modification, splicing, transport, or stability. not available in Prokaryotes (overcome by transcription is intimately tied up with translation) Translation- its regulation is analogous to those of transcription, happened at initiation and at termination Gene regulation in transcription A principle example by Jacob and Monod (1961) cis-acting element: not convertible, function as a DNA sequence in situ, phyiscal linked trans-acting element: diffusible trans-acting element Gene activity is regulated by the specific interactions of the trans-acting products (usually proteins/RNAs) with the cis-acting sequences (usually sites in DNA). diffuse structural gene regulator gene (cis-acting element: usually upstream of target genes including promoter and terminator.) The outcome of regulation may be positive or negative. Components in regulatory circuits Regulators and mechanisms: Protein regulators:1. allostery - two different sites, one for nucleic acid target, the other for a small molecule 2. multimer (usually has a symmetrical organization) -cooperative binding effect RNA regulators: usually a small RNA molecule 1. changes in 2° structure 2. complementary base pairing Consequence of targeting: a. Formation of the double helical structure may itself be sufficient. b. Duplex formation may be important because it sequesters a region of the target RNA The relationship of regulators in gene regulatory circuits: Coordinate: an operator controls the expression of many genes Network: one regulator is required for the production of another (cascade) Antagonize: a series of regulators each of which antagonizes another Autogenous: a protein regulates expression of the gene that codes for itself A diffusible trans-acting factor bound to cis-acting targeting site(s) is: Negative control Half of prokaryotic genes Positive control default state of genes is active Half of prokaryotic genes default state of genes is inactive Most of eukaryotic genes activators control level Repressors and activators are required very short cis-acting sequences (<10bp) to function. Such as the hexamers of -35 and -10 for the RNA polymerase. Bacterial Lactose Operon Lac I P/O Lac z Lac y Lac a By Monod,1940 • Three genes are coordinately regulated. • Controlled by the metabolic state of the cell -- carbon source. – Negative control • lac I gene – Positive control • CAP-cAMP • • • • • Jacob & Monod Induction of the β- galactosidase gene in response to lactose. Lactose - Inducer of activity Synthesis of new protein. In the absence of lactose, the gene is not expressed. The Lac operon Element purpose Operator (LacO) binding site for repressor Promote r (LacP) binding site for RNA polymerase gene encoding lac repressor protein Repress or (LacI) Binds to DNA at operator and blocks binding of RNA polymerase at promoter Pi promoter for LacI CAP binding site for cAMP/CAP complex The lac operon- A negative control (Jacob and Monod model of transcriptional regulation of the lac operon by lac repressor ) Polycistron– bacterial structural genes are often organized into clusters, coordinately controlled by means of interactions at a single promoter. Monocistron– only one gene is controlled by an individual promoter. Operon = Operator + Structural gene(s) (lacZYA) T trans-acting factor tetramer (38kD/each) 10 tetramers in a wild type cell (independent transcription unit: monocistron) T tetramer of ~500kD Cleave the β-galactoside into component sugars. Lactose → glucose + galactose 30kD membrane bound protein Transfer an acetyl group form acetyl-CoA to β-galactosides Transports β-galactoside into the cell Cluster is transcribed into a single polycistronic mRNA from a promoter where initiation of transcription is regulated. The Lac operon Element purpose Operator (LacO) binding site for repressor Promote r (LacP) binding site for RNA polymerase gene encoding lac repressor protein Repress or (LacI) Binds to DNA at operator and blocks binding of RNA polymerase at promoter Pi promoter for LacI CAP binding site for cAMP/CAP complex Metabolic action of LacZ gene product, β-galactosidase LacI repressor form a tetramer bound onto the operator How the lac genes are controlled? Repressor and RNA polymerase bind at sites that overlap around the transcription startpoint of the lac operon. Hence, the transcription of genes are turned off by the Lac repressor binding to Olac. RNA polymerase (Plac) Repressor (~60bp) (Olac) (~26bp) A mutation that inactivates the regulator causes the structural genes to remain in the expressed condition. Repressor and inducer Action • In absence of lactose, repressor binds DNA and blocks expression of Lac ZYA genes LacI gene product bound Lac z Lac y • In presence of lactose, repressor releases from DNA and lac zya genes express LacI released Lac z Lac y Lac a + lactose Lac a Repressor no longer binds - genes can be active. Induction of lac operon Jacob and Monod model of transcriptional regulation of the lac operon by lac repressor The expression of lac operon: an induction Induction of mRNA and protein (also happened in yeast) unstable mRNA with ~3min half-life Protein is more stable Within 2-3 mins, ~5000 enzyme molecules are present and can reach up to 5%-10% of the total soluble protein of the bacterium. ~5 molecules (to ensure a minimal amount to start the induction) IPTG: a gratuitous inducer • Artificial inducer of the beta galactosidase gene. • Not metabolized. vs. Lactose The induction does not depend on the activity of inducer. The system must possess some component, distinct from the target enzyme, that recognizes the appropriate substrate; and its ability to recognize related potential substrates is different from that of the enzyme. Conversion of repressors into an inactive leads to gene expression: an allosteric control LacI repressor possesses dual properties: 1. binds to DNA preventing transcription (Allosteric effect) 2. interacts with small-molecule inducer changing its own conformation 2 Inducer binding changing shape 1 DNA binding preventing Tx polycistron coordinate regulation 1. Sequential expression 2. Relative same amount Mutagenesis is an approach to analyze the operator Un-inducible mutants constitutive mutants vs. cis-acting mutations: map on promoter and operator trans-acting product mutations: lacI locus Oc type: operator loses binding with lacI lacI- type: loss of function of lacI Absence the DNA binding activity Allosteric Recessive mutation: complementary by wild type cis-dominance: 1.mutation(s) at any site that is physically contiguous with the sequences it controls 2. cannot be assigned to a complementation group. Consistent with the operator as a typical cis-acting site, whose function depends upon recognition of its DNA sequence by some trans-acting factor. Plac mutant--Promoter loses binding with RNA pol Absence the inducer binding site lacIs mutant (locked in to the active form that recognizes the operator and prvents transcription.) lacI-d mutant provides the multimeric property of the LacI protein lacI-d mutant: damages in DNA binding site (as a dominant negative mutant to LacI its own function) negative complementation Tetramer is formed in LacI repressor. Heterotetramer may be formed as interallelic complemenatation. Combination between lacI-d and lacI+ leads to occur negative complementation, suggesting lacI-d is called dominant negative. WT lacI- complementary WT Oc Noncomplementary WT lacIs WT lacI-d Molecular Mechanism of repress working on its operator : palindorme Symmetry in the protein. The operator makes the same pattern of contacts with a repressor monomer. Functional important bases (essential specific contacts) point mutation Contact (modification) Cover by repressor (DNase fingerprint) Structure of LacI repressor Several domains: N-terminal DNA-binding domain (a.a. 1-59) a hinge 2X core domains Fit into the major groove of DNA, make special contacts Conformation change (from core domains) leads to signal the DNA binding capacity. Headpiece (aa 1-59) independent from core 6X : Cleft between core domains Headpiece changes its orientation Loses contact with DNA : contains 2X leucine heptad repeats inducer bound A half-site of the dyad symmetry sequence can bind an intact repressor monomer. The affinity for DNA is many orders of magnitude higher by intact repressor, that is dimer/tetramer. Higher order of LacI repressor form dimer Inducer-binding cleft Hydrophobic core : form dimer C-terminal helices : form tetramer dimer form lacIs inducer binding dimer form lacItetramer form lacI-d :DNA binding Why tetramer? Tetramer can bind two operators simultaneously. O1: in the initial region of the lac operon, strongest affinity for repressor O2: 410bp downstream of startpoint, weaker affinity for repressor O3: 83bp upstream of startpoint, weaker affinity for repressor O2 X O3 X CAP (catabolite associated protein) 2-4X 2-4X 100X Repressor tetramer O1 CAP In fact, the repressor binding onto operator(s) enhances RNA polymerase binding at the promoter. However the bound RNA polymerase is prevented from initiating transcription (stored at closed complex). enable transcription to begin immediately upon induction, instead of waiting for an RNA polymerase to be captured. Repressor is always bound to DNA Proteins that have a high affinity for a specific DNA sequence also have a low affinity for other DNA sequences. Every base pair in the bacterial genome is the start of a low-affinity binding-site for repressor. The large number of low-affinity sites ensures that all repressor protein is bound to DNA. Repressor binds to the operator by moving from a low-affinity site rather than by equilibrating from solution. The operator competes with low-affinity sites to bind repressor In the absence of inducer, the operator has an affinity for repressor that is 10 7× that of a low affinity site. The level of 10 repressor tetramers per cell ensures that the operator is bound by repressor 96% of the time. Induction reduces the affinity for the operator to 10 4× that of low-affinity sites, so that only 3% of operators are bound. Induction causes repressor to move from the operator to a low-affinity site by direct displacement. These parameters could be changed by a reduction in the effective concentration of DNA in vivo. A kinetic view of repressors on an operator What affects the repressor binding to the operator: genome size, specificity of the repressor, the amount of the repressor existed/required 1. Repressors have a high affinity for a specific DNA sequence and also have a low affinity for other DNA sequences. 2. Hence, the large number of low-affinity sites ensures that all repressors are bound to DNA. 3. Excessive repressor proteins ensure that the operator is occupied by a repressor at ~96% All of repressors are bound to DNA Re-distribution randomly on the genome Inducer binding leads to lose specificity of bound to operator comparing to other DNA sequences Specificity to the high affinity site Repressor binds to the operator by moving from a low-affinity site rather than by equilibrating from soluation. How inducer binding to free repressor? Free repressor binding to DNA results from the reduction of its affinity. How the repressor tetramer set off from the DNA? 1. Upset equilibrium 2. Directly displacement (affinity change/flow) (involves conformational change, (unbalance) but not bond breaking) Dynamic balance >15 mins Hence, prefer fast See next slide Not reversible Repression can occur at multiple loci A repressor will act on all loci that have a copy of its target operator sequence A diffusible trans-acting factor bound to cis-acting targeting site(s) is: Negative control Half of prokaryotic genes Positive control default state of genes is active Half of prokaryotic genes default state of genes is inactive Most of eukaryotic genes activators control level Repressors and activators are required very short cis-acting sequences (<10bp) to function. Such as the hexamers of -35 and -10 for the RNA polymerase. Catabolite Repressionpositive control • Additional control mechanism prevents Lac operon expression when Glucose is present. • Lactose + Glucose to E. coli-- Lac operon will remain off. • Cells have a glucose sensor. How do bacteria control the carbon sources? Phoenolpyruvate:glycose phosphotransferase = PTS Glucose repression controls use of carbon sources: Phenomenon: 1. 2. 3. E. coli uses glucose in preference to other carbon sources Glucose prevents uptake of alternative carbon sources Exclude expression of the operons coding for the enzymes that metabolize other carbon sources (such as lac, gal, ara) Mechanism: 1. Inducer exclusion 2. Inhibition of positive regulator, CRP activity (see next) IIAglc-P (crr gene) IIAglc IIAglc Regulation of CRP activity a positive regulator which may overcome a deficiency in the promoter, e.g. a poor consensus sequence at -35 or -10 CRP activator controls the activity of a large set of operons in E. coli. A dimer of CRP is activated by a single molecules of cyclin AMP IIA-P IIAglc Adenylate cyclase cAMP Catabolite activator protein (CAP; also known as cAMP receptor protein, CRP) Glucose in reducing cyclic AMP levels is to deprive the relevant operons of a control factor necessary for their expression -P Catabolite activator protein (CAP) = cAMP receptor protein, CRP) 22.5KDa protein to form a homodimer. an N-terminal domain required for CAP dimerisation and the binding of cAMP, a C-terminal domain that contains a helix-turn-helix motif required for the binding of DNA. Gene activator: AR1 (activating region 1) region within the C-terminal domain, which interacts with the C-terminal domain of the RNAP alpha subunit (aCTD); AR2 (activating region 2) region within the N-terminal domain, which interacts with the N-terminal domain of RNAP alpha subunit (aNTD); AR3 (activating region 3) region within the N-terminal domain, which interacts with the RNAP sigma70 (s70) subunit. CAP is one of over 300 transcription factors used by Escherichia coli alone. Such as metabolism of sugars and amino acids, transport processes, protein folding, toxin production and pilus synthesis. TGTGA conserved pentamer is essential and an inverted repeat version given the strongest interaction with CRP How CRP activator works to positively control transcription? 1. Increase the rate of initial binding to form a closed comolex 2. CAP + cAMP allow formation of an open promoter comoplex How? CRP: form a dimer (22.5kD/each), each of them has a DNA binding region and a transcription-activating region. Binding ~22bp in a responsive promoter TGTGA conserved pentamer is essential and an inverted repeat version given the strongest interaction with CRP (increase affinity to DAN a lot) CRP binding sites lie in different locations relative to the startpoint in the various operons that it regulates Strong binding Weak binding CRP in regulation of lac operon Only the activating region of the subunit nearer the startpoint is required, presumably because it touches RNA polymerase. >>>> Orientation-independent Dimer promotes the binding affinity of CAP onto DNA The CRP protein can bind at different sites relative to RNA poymerase How CAP work? 3 classes of CAP-dependent promoters promoter closed complex formation e.g. lac promoter Class I CAP-dependent promoter activation: CAP dimer interacting with the aCTD of RNAP, which is also comprised of b and s subunits promoter complex to an open complex e.g. galP1 promoter promoter closed complex formation Class II CAP-dependent promoter activation: CAP dimer interacting with the aCTD and aNTD of RNAP 1. involve class I and class II mechanisms of action in an additive manner e.g. malK promoter 2. two CAP dimers could function differently Class III CAP-dependent promoter activation: two CAP dimers interacting with the aCTD of RNAP Journal of Molecular Biology 293, S. Busby and R. Ebright, Transcription Activation by Catabolite Activator Protein (CAP), 199-213 (1999), CRP bends DNA ~90° Diverse control circuits by regulators default state → expressed (need a repressor to switch off) interfering Lac operon default state X expressed (need an activator to switch on) essential CRP, σ presence of inducer via 1. Allosteric changes 2. Activation of proteins (e.g. by Oxidation) 3. (de)phosphorylation Outcome is expressed Trp operon via co-repressor Outcome is not expressed A fail-safe, selective advantage due to increased efficiency (basal level expression) The stringent response produces (p)ppGpp (alarmones) Poor growth conditions cause bacteria to produce the small molecule regulators ppGpp and pppGpp to shut down a wide range of activities associated with inhibition of Tx. Stringent response L11/S50 via conformation change Uncharged tRNA /Ribosome 10~20X tRNA+rRNA ↓ 3X mRNA ↓ ~5~10% total RNAs ↓ Protein degradation ↑ (Relaxed) e.g. EF-Tu EF-G ~20sec Reversed reapidly (Idling reaction) The stringent factor RelA is a (p)ppGpp synthetase that is associated with ~5% of ribosomes. RelA is activated when the A site is occupied by an uncharged tRNA. One (p)ppGpp is produced every time an uncharged tRNA enters the A site. P A (p)ppGpp inhibits transcription of rRNA 1. 2. Initiation of Tx is specifically inhibited at the promoters of operons coding for rRNA The elongation phase of Tx of many or most templates is reduced by ppGpp The level of protein synthesis increases in proportion with the growth rate. Ribosome ≡ protein synthesis ≡ cell growth NTP level as 1. an indicator 2. drives the initiation by stabilizing the open complex Components in regulatory circuits Regulators and mechanisms: Protein regulators:1. allostery - two different sites, one for nucleic acid target, the other for a small molecule 2. multimer (usually has a symmetrical organization) -cooperative binding effect RNA regulators: usually a small RNA molecule 1. changes in 2° structure 2. complementary base pairing Consequence of targeting: a. Formation of the double helical structure may itself be sufficient. b. Duplex formation may be important because it sequesters a region of the target RNA The relationship of regulators in gene regulated: Coordinate (operon): an operator controls the expression of many genes Network (cascade): one regulator is required for the production of another Circuits: Antagonize: a series of regulators each of which antagonizes another Autogenous: a protein regulates expression of the gene that codes for itself Attenuation: a negative control alternative secondary structures control attenuation (analogous to allosteric changes of conformation) External event (signal) controls the formation of the hairpin needed for intrinsic termination. = attenuator An intrinsic protein or it may respond to a small molecule (~ repressor or co-repressor) to stabilize or destabilize the hairpin Nucleic acid shifts to different conformation Attenuation RNAi trp operon in Bacillus subtilis A terminator protein , TRAP, is activated by tryptophan to prevent transcription of trp genes. In the absence of tryptophan, the activity of TRAP is inhibited by uncharged tRNAtrp anti-TRAP. TRAP: 11 subunits, bound with tRNAtrp and then wounded by RNA. Response to trp level TRAP Uncharged tRNA anti-TRAP The trp operon in E. coli Ribosome (translation) is the intrinsic protein (stimulated by trp) to stabilize/destabilize the termination hairpin (attenuator) on mRNA. Anti-termination: (signal dependent) A leader sequence preceding the trp genes contains an attenuator (terminator hairpin) whose 2° structure can be changed dependent on the translation of the leader peptide. Resided wthin attenuator Attenuator stop transcription No translation signal→ ribosome movement conformation change of attenuator →disrupt the loop1 and 2 base pairing No termination, transcription continues Architecture of trp operon in E. coli: Two folds regulation Tryptophan dependent translation (movement) Promoter/Operator region 140bp Translated into protein Discover: chorismic acid → tryptophan 1 TrpR: repressor X70 Mutations increase expression 10X in presence of Trp. Regulation of trp genes expression by 2 folds (encoded by another gene) independent 2 attenuation Both respond to the Trp level inside of a cell X10 intrinsic terminator The position of the ribosome on mRNA controls attenuation (I) What signal ? : Tryptophan dependent translation (movement) ribosome stalling Loop 1 and 2 base pairing impaired Loop2 and 3 forms pairing Leader peptide translation Loop 1 and 2 base pairing impaired Loop 2 and 3 base pairing impaired (ribosome continues move) Loop 3 and 4 forms base pairing The position of the ribosome on mRNA controls attenuation (II) The position of the ribosome on mRNA controls attenuation (III) Base pairing between loops loop 1 2 3 4 Signal molecule tRNAtrp directly controls the attenuation Translation a leader peptide, termination happens at hairpin cannot translate, ribosome stalled, then disrupts terminator A feature of protein synthetic apparatus. Translation can be regulated Even though transcription is coordinated (i.e. operons), the differences can be created in translation 1. A repressor protein can regulate translation by preventing a ribosome from binding to an initiation codon. 1. 2. Accessibility of initiation codons in a polycistronic mRNA can be controlled by changes in the structure of the mRNA that occur as the result of translation. 2. 1 cistron 2 cistron 1 and 2 are not mutually exclusive Proteins that bind to sequences within the initiation regions of mRNAs may function as translational repressors r-protein synthesis is controlled by (-) autogenous regulation Translation of an r-protein operon can be controlled by a product of the operon that binds to a site on the polycistronic mRNA Clusters/operons of gene expression apparatus: Ribosomal proteins, protein-synthesis factors, RNA Pol and factors… R-proteins binding affinity: rRNA >mRNA str spc S10 α L11 rif Features: Equimolar amount Intermingling Ribosomal proteins, synthesis factors, RNA pol (represent by single gene) Small number of operons Autogenous Autonomously regulated: negative regulation Phage T4 p32 is controlled by an autogenous circuit p32 binds to its own mRNA to prevent initiation of translation A quantitative regulation Contributes to recombination, repair, replication When the function of the proteins prevented, more of it is made. Each regulatory interaction is unique such as RegA proteins Autogenous regulation is often used to control synthesis of macromolecular assemblies The precursor to microtubules, free tubulin protein, inhibits translation of tubulin mRNA. Pool of free tubulins is sensed Free tubulin binds on mRNA or nacent peptide Tubulin mRNA on polysomes is degraded while free tubulin bound Extrinsic :repressor regulators Intrinsic: autogenous controls RNA regulators A regulator RNA is a small RNA with a single-stranded region that can pair with a single-stranded region in a target RNA Antisense RNA: in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes A reversing orientation of a gene with regard to its promoter make an antisense RNA. Provide an importance of the time of gene expression Formation is happened in either nucleus or cytoplasm In an artificial way to inhibit a mRNA activity by a synthetic antisense RNA, the antisense RNA is needed to a considerable excessive amount. RNA interfering happens in dsRNAs In vivo Complementary base pairing to control RNA activity by another RNA (usually, targeted RNAs are mRNAs) Trans-acting factor A double stranded region Base pairing complementary Usually, regulator RNAs are small (short) RNA molecules (single-stranded) General mechanisms: changes in 2° structure of the target (No allosteric affecting by small mols) Forming a duplex region → block initiation of translation (1) cause termination of transcription (3) create a target for an endonuclease (2) 2. 1. 3. Bacterial oxyS RNA is a regulator RNA (sRNA) One of 17 different sRNAs, which affects many targets by repression or activation. Respond to oxidation by expressing antioxidant defense genes. short Repress ribosome binding Prevent translation encodes a protein that is believed to be part of the export apparatus for flagellum assembly initiation site Not a protein but a short RNA A trans-acting regulator at post-transcription levels; >10 target genes The oxyR mutant is resulted from the overxpression of the oxyS sRNA regulator Global sRNA regulator in bacteria RNA binding protein; needed for Qβphage replication Similar to Sm protein in eukaryotes (binds to snRNA) Improve the ss exposure Hfq protein RprA OxyS FlhA encodes a protein that is believed to be part of the export apparatus for flagellum assembly DsrA rpoS Sigma factor for general stress response In eukaryotes Discovery of MicroRNAs Regulate gene expression by base pairing with complementary sequences in target mRNAs 858-62 862-64 Dartmouth Medical School, Department of Genetics, Hanover, NH Whitehead Institute for Biomedical Research, and Department of Biology, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 9 Cambridge Center, Cambridge, MA Lin4 miRNA regulates the expression of stage-specific developmental events Induces late event of larva development Imprecise base pairing by miRNA (21 bases) Post-transcriptional transcriptional Several target sites are existed close to the 3’ end of target mRNA (Usually in non-translational region) Different approaches to study microRNA MicroRNAs are distributed among eukaryotes a Nematode pre-miRNA Let 7. b Arabidopsis pre-miRNA-172. c Polycistronic pri-miRNA in rice. d Polycistronic pri-miRNA in nematodes Structure of pri-miRNAs alternate poly-A-site Drosha cleavage sites Dicer cleavage sites RNA interference Recovery in tobacco plants infected with tobacco ringspot virus. The original legend1 to the figure reads ‘Turkish tobacco plant 23 days after inoculation with ringspot. Note the gradual decline in the development of ringspot symptoms on the upper leaves until finally the top leaves appear perfectly normal’. We now know that the virus causing the initial symptoms had activated viral RNA silencing that inhibited spread of the infection into the upper leaves, and caused them to be specifically immune to tobacco ringspot virus secondary infection. RNA interference (RNAi) and gene silencing triggers degradation of mRNAs complementary to either strand of a short dsRNA, called siRNA (short interfering RNA), and causes silencing of host genes : 3’end 2 bases protrusion creates via Dicer enzyme (ATP dependent) Mechanism of RNAi dicer RISC (RNA-induced silencing complex) The general pathway of RNAi in vitro Small RNA biogenesis in animals Pasha (DGCR8) ~21-25nt ~70nt A mRNA transcript by RNA Pol II Small RNAs act upstream of several effectors histone methyltransferases The potential of RNAi in studies of gene function and genomics Post-transcription gene silencing (PTGS): dsRNA inhibits expression of a gene exists in plants and fungi. Viral infection: virus-induced gene silence (VIGS) is a natural defense mechanism in plants. (during virus replicating which forms dsRNA intermediates; required RNA-dependent RNA polymerase) amplification siRNA or signal can be systemically transported to other non-infected cells Virus as a vector for gene silencing Virus as a vector to harbor exogenous gene fragments. Inoculation of the recombinant virus into cells, the corresponding endogenous genes are silenced The mechanism of RNAi RNAi has been observed in plants, fungi, mammals, worms, and flies and offers significant therapeutic potent (a) RNAi as a natural process. (b) RNAi using synthetic siRNAs.