SINGLE-CULTURE
SINGLETOP-DOWN
ORGANIZATION
COMMAND & CONTROL
EQUITIES
OLD
Sustainable
Reality-Based
Non-Zero
Outcomes
LEADERS
DECIDE
SECRET
SOURCES & METHODS
TIME
IMPACT
SHORT
OBSCURE
DETAIL
OBVIOUS
DETAIL
Localized
Resilience
TIME
IMPACT
LONG
OPEN
SOURCES & METHODS
PEOPLE
DECIDE
NEW
BOTTOM-UP
MULTI-CULTURAL & INFORMATION-SHARING
TRANS-NATIONAL
EQUITIES
Consciousness
Movements
Products
Domains
Practices
Infrastructure
Enablers
Aspects
Open Hardware
Open Farm
Technology
Open Small
Business
Techology
Open Patents
Creative
Commons
Copyright
Open Networks
Open
Source
Software
Open
Spectrum
Engineering
R
URBANE
RURAL
S
Open
I
Society
L
Open
Open
I
Government
Deliberation
E
Open
N
Open
Source
Data
C
Intelligence
Access
BIO- E
Open
Money
}
REGIONAL,
NATIONALGLOBAL
Angel
Animal
Aristocracy
Art
Astronomy
Beauty
Being
Cause
Change
Change
Citizen
Constitution
Courage
Custom &
Convention
Definition
Democracy
Desire
Dialectic
Duty
Education
Element
Emotion
Eternity
Evolution
Experience
Family
Fate
Form
God
Good & Evil
Government
Habit
Happiness
History
Honor
Hypothesis
Idea
Immortality
Induction
Infinity
Judgment
Justice
Knowledge
Labor
Language
Law
Liberty
Life & Death
Logic
Love
Man
Mathematics
Matter
Mechanics
Medicine
Memory &
Imagination
Metaphysics
Mind
Monarchy
Nature
Necessity &
Contingency
Oligarchy
One & Many
Opinion
Opposition
Philosophy
Physics
Pleasure & Pain
Poetry
Principle
Progress
Prophecy
Prudence
Punishment
Quality
Quantity
Reasoning
Relation
Religion
Revolution
Rhetoric
Same & Other
Science
Sense
Sigh & Symbol
Sin
Slavery
Soul
Space
State
Temperance
Theology
Time
Truth
Tyranny
Universal &
Particular
Virtue &
Vice
War &
Peace
Wealth
Will
Wisdom
World
Cause
One & Many
Change
BEING
B
Chance
Same & Other
Opposition
Labor, Slavery, War & Peace
Life & Death
Desire, Emotion, Sense
Beauty, World
Happiness, Punishment
Animal
N
NATURE
Opinion, Pleasure and Pain
MAN
Insight, Love
M
Judgment, Perspective, Wisdom
Sincerity, Will
Custom & Convention, Language
Harmony, Prudence, Virtue & VIce
Principle
S
Astronomy, Mechanics, Medicine, Physics, Mathematics
Hypothesis, Induction, Logic, Reasoning
SCIENCE
Habit, Time
Fate
G
Eternity
Immortality
Dialectic
Angel, Good & Evil, Sin, Soul
GOD
01
02
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
Poverty
Infectious Disease
Environmental Degradation
Inter-State Conflict
Civil War
Genocide
Other Atrocties
Proliferation
Terrorism
Transnational Crime
Headquarters/Field
Management
Status
Seniority
Military
Experience
Life
Experience
Pay
Scale
Group
Family
Status
Religion
Country
Knowledge
Mental Physical
Ability Ability
Sexual
Orientation
Gender
Identity
Language
Age
Union
Education Affiliation
Race
Ethni
Gender city
Work
Experience
Job
Title
Work
Style
Income
Personal
Habits
Communication
Style
Department/Unit/Group
Work
Location
SCIENCE IS
A SET OF
BELIEFS
SCIENCE
IS A
PROCESS
RELIGION IS
A SET OF
BELIEFS
RELIGION
IS A
PROCESS
Potentially
Conflicting
Reinforcing
Conflicting
Potentially
Co-Existing
Integral
Consciousness
Religion &
Spirtuality
Philosophy
Science
Digital
Information
English
Language
Oral & Unpublished
Analog
Information
Information
Secret
Technical
Collection
33 Vital
Languages
150 Key
Languages
3,000 Other
Distinct Languages
Diplomatic &
Commercial
Collection
Clandestine
Human Collection
50%
All-Source
Processing
Non-Existent
Most Satisfying
OSINT
HUMINT
STATE
SIGINT
IMINT
MASINT
50%
0%
Less Costly
10 High-Level
Threats to Humanity
(UN Report 2004)
10
WASTE & Transnational
Crime
CORRUPTION
50%-70%
Lost Value
06 Family
07 Health
01
Poverty
Publicize Cost
of Corruption
12 Core Policies
MUST Be Developed
In Relation to One Another
Publicize
“True Cost” of
Goods & Services
China, Islam, Ethnic, Etc.
Narrowly Focused!
I
IV
Lessons of History
Spies & Secrecy
II
III
Global Coverage
National Intelligence
Cost-Sharing with Others
Shared Early Warning
Harness & Nurture Distributed
Intelligence of Whole Nation
Healthy
Lifestyle
True Cost
To Society
Preventable
True Cost
To Heal
Public Information &
Government Oversight
Healthy
Environment
Not
Preventable
Government
Oversight
Public
Information
Surgical &
Pharmaceutical
Remediation
Natural and
Alternative
Remediation
Future Far
Strategic
Future Near
History &
Current
Interests
Now
StrategicOperational
Operational
Partial Sharing
+ Inter-Tribal National
+ Regional Multinational
Strategic, Operational,
Tactical, Technical
Multinational & Inter-Tribal
Information Sharing & Sense-Making
Herring Triangle
Strategic Forecasting
10% Need, 40% Cost
Primary Research &
Experts on Demand
20% Need, 30% Cost
Help Desk (Shared)
Private Answers NOW
30% Need, 20% Cost
Recurring Monitoring
All Topics Big & Small
40% Need, 10% Cost
Jan Herring, NIO/S&T 1970’s
Competitive Intelligence Guru
Government, Law Enforcement, Military Perspectives
Academic/NGO Perspectives
Commercial/Media Perspectives
Civil Society (Labor, Religion, Other) Perspective
Citizen Monitoring Officers (CMO)
-- Poverty
-- Infectious Disease
-- Environmental Degradation
-- Inter-State Conflict
-- Civil War
-- Genocide
-- Other Atrocities
Zip Code
-- Proliferation
-- Terrorism
-- Crime
County/District
-- Agriculture
-- Diplomacy
State/Province
-- Economy
-- Education
-- Energy
Bio-Region
-- Family
-- Health
-- Immigration
Country/Tribal Nation
-- Justice
-- Security
-- Society
Whole Earth
-- Water
-- Citizen Monitoring Coordinator (CMC)
Descriptive Policy
One-Pagers for
Each Agency and
Each Line Item
Moderated
Discussion
for Each
Issue
Across All
Agencies
Comparison of
Partisan Policy by
Line Item Sorted by
State, County, &
Congressional District
Candidate Budgets*
Delta
Democratic Budget
Republican Budget
Partisan Policy
One-Pagers with
Budget Numbers
Libertarian Budget
Tea Party Budget
Independent Budget
***
Spreadsheets of
Actual US Budgets
Past, Present,
Future
OurBudget
MyBudget
[Zip/Party]
Green Budget
Reform Budget
Sandbox Budget**
* Only official campaigns may enter ** For new/unaffiliated voters *** One link
Zip Code
County/District
State/Province
Bio-Region
Country/Tribal Nation
Whole Earth
Single Line Represents
Infinite Number of
Diversity Planes (28+)
Conservation
& Resistance
Growth
to the
Limits
Today….
Birth & Re-Birth
With Innovation
Constructive
Destruction,
Chaos &
Innovation
01 Citizen as Sensor
02 Soldier as Sensor (Overt/Open Signals)
03 Operational Test & Evaluation
04 Inspector-General (Organization, Government, International)
05 Security Observation/Remote Webcams
06 Document Exploitation/Imagery
07 Overt Subject Matter Experts (SME)
08 Defense Attaches, Foreign Area Officers, MTT, MAG, TDY
09 Human Terrain Teams (HTT)
10 Interrogator-Translator Teams (ITT)
11 Soldier as Sensor (Covert “Hides”)
Technology-Centric,
Engineering-oriented
predict
monitor
communicate
analyze
explore
report
store
integrate
transform
clean
collect
Human-centric,
design-oriented
Secure
Base
Social
Competencies
Education
Six Domains
of Resilience
Positive
Values
Friendships
Talent &
Interests
Governance
Networks
Metabolic or
Market Flows
Production, supply, and
consumptions chains.
Institutional structures
and organizations
Urban
Resilience
Demographics human
capital and inequity
Ecosystems services in
urban landscapes
Social
Dynamics
Built
Environment
DOMAINS OF SOCIETY
• Political-Legal-Military
• Socio-Economic
• Ideo-Cultural
• Techno-Demographic
• Natural-Geographic
ATTRIBUTES OF MAN
• Perception
• Identity
• Competence
• Investment
• Risk
• Extroversion
• Transcendence
• Synergy
• Complexity
IV Organizational Intelligence
Organizational
Memory System
Meta-Data
Copyright, Patents,
Trade-Secrets
E-Commerce
E-Sharing
Related
Ecologies
Information & SenseMaking Services
Open
Standards
Open
Standards
Information
Mapping
Living Memory
Internal Technical
Project/Group
Management
Internal
Reporting
Data
Conversion &
Mining
Open
Standards
Vendor
Reporting
III External Information
Expert Hires
-Just Time
M4IS2
Centre
Digital Search Automated
& Retrieval
Analysis
I Knowledge Management
Monitoring
- Customers
- Other
- Government
- Technology
- Environment
Local
Knowledge
Multi-Lingual Multi-Media
Global Human
Personal Brand
Travel &
Training
Cell #
RapidSMS
Churning
(Rotationals)
Personal Cell,
Email, Skype
Personal Directory
(Email, Web, Phone)
II Collaborative Work
Open Earth
Budget
Open Earth
Game
Autonomous
Open Internet
Open Earth
Intelligence
Open Earth
Policy
Dialogs
Cluster of
Food Need
Over Time
Time-Phased
Harmonized Giving
All those with something to give
All those with a need, however miniscule
Cluster of
Medical Needs
Peer to peer
giving
Cluster of
Clothing Need
Powered by Zero Waste Mind-Sets, Enabled by Ubiquitous Information Access
Benefit #1: On Demand Precision Giving Benefit #2: Elimination of Overhead
Benefit #3: Harnesses Giving of Billion Individuals Who Do Not Give Now
Figure
14: Global Range
Gifts Table Illustrated
Peacekeeping
Intelligence
21:ofInfluence
How OTHERS Spend
Billions of Dollars
Number of
US Voters
Contributing
Peace from Above
Intelligence-Driven Precision Peace Targets, Space, Cyber, Air