Rabbi Joshua Heller, Rosh Hashanah 5775 p 1 A Sermon I’ve Resisted Giving for 10 years. Delivered by Rabbi Joshua Heller Congregation B’nai Torah First Day Rosh Hashanah, 5775 A story is told of a rabbi who, after a few weeks in his new congregation, decides to give a sermon about some behavior and decorum issues in the synagogue. He begins by talking about inappropriate clothing that some of the bar/bat mitzvah guests have been wearing, and a couple in the front is whispering and nodding in appreciation. He rails about the disruptions caused by cell phones, and the couple continues to offer their encouragement “he’s really preaching it now!” He really gets up head of steam as he launches into the people who talk during services, and the couple in front turn their faces to a scowl. Loud enough for the whole congregation to hear, they offer their critique: “now he’s stopped preaching and started meddling.” Some congregants have strong opinions about what rabbis should talk about from the bimah. I’ve found that many are really only concerned about two parts of the sermon- the beginning and the end, and how far apart they are. This year there have been numerous articles on the pressure on rabbis to talk about, or not talk about, Israel this year. To say, or not say this; to say or not say that. There are rabbis who have been pushed out of congregations, congregants who have quit. Those who are B’nai Torah veterans know that I usually end up having something to say about Israel most High Holidays, and I’ll say a more than a few words about Israel today, but I’d like to suggest that as this year has unfolded, Israel is actually something of a red herring. The real story is at the same time far more grand, and far more petty1. It is about the whole world and the individual, about the universal and the particular, themes that are in sharp relief on Rosh Hashanah. It’s about Jews, and the anti-Semites who hate them, but also how we feel about ourselves as well. The story could be a heartbreaker, but it’s actually cause for hope and even pride. But let’s start with Israel. Over the years, many have tried to give a concise summary of the state of the Jewish state. 14 years ago, Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak was interviewed on American television by Sam Donaldson. He was asked to sum up the prospects for peace, in one word. He responded: “Good.” Donaldson asked “Can you expand on that? How about in two words?” “Not Good.” Those are both pretty accurate descriptions. 1 This year’s sermon bingo. Rabbi Joshua Heller, Rosh Hashanah 5775 p 2 We have a lot to be proud of. Israel, as a modern country, has staked out a unique position in a tough neighborhood. Despite war and conflict, and despite, or perhaps because, of a lack of oil, somehow it has developed a vigorous entrepreneurial economy- just shy of 9 million residents, a world center for high tech and high culture. Tel Aviv is like a Middle Eastern Los Angeles, (with almost as many Israelis), and Ramat Gan its Century City. Looking at it as an American, you can appreciate that, even with its imperfections, it is more democratic than any other country in the region, an ally to the US. It’s facing challenges of how to integrate a very diverse population- Jews from ultra-orthodox to ultra-secular, Christians and Muslims, Arabs and Russians. There are continued negotiations to determine how to preserve religious rights for all at holy sites like the Kotel, to wrestle with economic inequality, and challenges to the environment. People of faith are drawn to Israel, because it is a land with an incredible history and legacy. With all due respect to Nordstrom’s, it is the holy land. When you read the bible, the backdrop to every story that matters is found in its majestic mountains, its fertile valleys. It was also the crossroads of the ancient world- the king’s highway was used by invading armies from Egypt to Assyria. Persians, Turks, Christians, Moslems, each had more than one turn. We were exiled and returned, and exiled again, but we never forgot our homeland. We held fast to a covenant and held it in our prayers every day for two thousand years. Its very stones tell the story of our people, its waters flow with sacred inspiration. Next summer, we are taking a group to Israel, to draw that inspiration. But if you ask the world at large, Israel seems to be associated with conflict and condemnation. This was a tough summer for Israel. For the past few years, the Fatah group, which controls much of the West Bank, has been more or less willing to express a desire for peace, at least in English, but in practice has offered cooperation to keep the peace and protect lives on both sides. There has been simmering conflict with Hamas, sometimes hot and sometimes cold, with Hamas firing rockets on Israeli towns and farms, causing great distress to those living in border communities, but really not affecting the quality of life in Israel as a whole. This summer, Hamas-affiliated terrorists kidnapped and killed three Israeli teenagers. The conflict quickly escalated, and before long, Hamas had lobbed thousands of rockets at Israel. Israeli civilian casualties were mercifully low, because of the Iron Dome missile defense system. Along the way, the world discovered that Hamas had diverted millions and millions of dollars of construction and humanitarian supplies, that could have been used to build roads, schools and hospitals, to construct long tunnels into Israel. Hamas was planning a colossal attack using those tunnels (some have suggested that it would have been on this holiday) to murder and kidnap dozens of Israeli civilians, women and children. Rabbi Joshua Heller, Rosh Hashanah 5775 p 3 Israel sent soldiers into Gaza to take out those tunnels, and rockets, and 66 lost their lives. Hamas had a strategy unique in the annals of war. Usually, you use your missiles and bunkers to defend your population. Hamas used its population to defend its missiles and bunkers, hiding rockets in schools and near homes and apartments. Israel took a step unheard of in warfare. They would send warnings to civilians to leave an area with military targets, and Hamas would ask (or force) those civilians to crowd in, so that Israelis would have choose between leaving the launchers and bunkers intact, or risking civilian casualties. The goal was to maximize civilian casualties, to make it impossible for Israel to respond to Hamas attacks without harming women and children. This summer, we had a chance to study some of the ethical dilemmas that Israel faced, and how our tradition guides responses to those tough scenarios. If you do a statistical breakdown of the gender and age of the 2000 or so killed in Gaza, it seems to confirm Israel’s assessment that despite Hamas’ best efforts to put women and children in harm’s way, about 50% of those killed were Hamas fighters. And so the fight went on, until after 6 weeks and 11 broken ceasefires, Israel and Hamas came up with one that held. Some pundits have suggested that it was primarily because Hamas was out of rockets. It’s not surprising that Israel was subject to unbridled condemnation from the world’s most violent and oppressive regimes in the UN, who would tell you that Israel is not only the villain and the aggressor against the Palestinians, but the root of all evil in the larger world. Also, perhaps no surprise either that the media bought the Hamas strategy. There was an amusing set of articles from the New York Times explaining why their reporters and photographers on the ground had never seen a Hamas militant. There’s no mystery. Many international news organizations use local stringers who have a clear bias. Foreign reporters who might otherwise be honest know that they will be expelled or killed if they report on what Hamas was actually doing. Meanwhile, media chiefs needed to be perceived as “evenhanded,” and tried to create an illusion of parity between a terrorist army that was trying to maximize civilian casualties, and a democratic state that was trying to minimize them. Most importantly, though, if it bleeds, it leads. News about Israel gets eyeballs and sells ads. Around the world, including here in the US, a movement called BDS (boycott, divestment and sanctions), seeks to make Israel a pariah in the business world, to put Israel out in the cold in the world of culture, sports, and academia. You can’t Rabbi Joshua Heller, Rosh Hashanah 5775 p 4 walk 20 feet on a college campus without running into a “rebel without a clue” who wants protest Israel. Whereas support for Israel used to be one of a number of shared assumptions that crossed party lines in the US, movements seeking to criticize or marginalize Israel have become increasingly vocal and influential. Even more distressing, criticism of Israel, would seem to have become a focus and an outlet for hatred of Jews in general. Hate crimes have been on the rise across Europe this summer. In Germany, with no hint of irony, pro-Palestinian protesters shouted “Gas the Jews” and a synagogue was firebombed. Four people were gunned down at the Jewish museum in Brussels. In France, mobs shattered Jewish store windows, and many neighborhoods are simply unsafe for Jews to enter. Morale is free falling, and about 1% of the Jews in France (currently the third largest Jewish community in the world after Israel and the US) will be leaving for Israel this year. In England a store guard denied entrance to Jewish students, and after mobs trashed store aisles with Israeli foods, some stores stopped stocking kosher products altogether. We feel safe on this side of the pond. But maybe we should sleep with one eye open. In Miami, in August, a rabbi was shot on his way to synagogue. The story just kind of sank beneath the surface. Law enforcement on the case was quoted as saying: “Again I’m not really sure what it was, but it definitely was not a hate crime.2” I have heard of a number of synagogues that have been vandalized, but have been asked not to publicize the incidents due to a fear of copycat crimes. One Jewish school in New York drew controversy when an administrator suggested that its students take off kippot when leaving the building. To be fair, even 25 years ago, most of my friends who went there were doing that anyway. Here’s the puzzle behind this whole scenario. I know why I care about Israel: because of its past as the birthplace of my faith, because of its present as home to my brothers, and because of its future as a source of inspiration. I know why Hamas cares about Israel- they see the entire land of Israel as land that belongs to Palestinians, no matter how it was bought or what it was traded for, and because their vision of Islam doesn’t allow for a non-Moslem political presence in the Middle East. But the question I must ask is: why does everyone else care? Of all of the 40 different wars and conflicts going on around the world, why is Israel singled out on streets and campus squares? Hundreds of thousands of Syrians are killed in civil war, with barely a peep from the larger world. ISIS kills thousands of innocent http://miami.cbslocal.com/2014/09/19/police-believe-they-know-some-of-the-peopleinvolved-in-rabbi-murder/ 2 Rabbi Joshua Heller, Rosh Hashanah 5775 p 5 people, Moslem and Christian, but until they behead an American on YouTube, it doesn’t matter. Hundreds of girls are kidnapped in Nigeria to be used as slaves in the most degrading way, and the world mobilizes … a twitter hashtag? More to the point: other countries in the world are subject to criticism as to how they act. Israel’s sin is its mere existence. Israel is attacked not just for shooting back at the people who are shooting at its civilians, but even for having the Iron Dome defensive system. The U.N’s top human rights official criticized Israel and the U.S. for not sharing that system with the people shooting at it! I think the answer is ultimately not about Israel, but about the Jews. This summer, the Episcopal Chaplain at Yale, Reverend Bruce Shipman, wrote a letter addressing the rise in anti-Semitic attacks around the world. He was wrong, but in an incredibly instructive way. He felt that we Jews were ourselves to blame for the attacks against us. By virtue of our association with Israel, we were responsible for its behavior, and for whatever invective or violence its enemies might hurl against us. “The best antidote to anti-Semitism would be for Israel's patrons abroad to press the government of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu for finalstatus resolution to the Palestinian question.” There are so many things wrong with Rev. Shipman’s letter and that I just don’t have time to address them all. However, there is one overarching error that deserves note. In blaming antiSemitism on Israel’s place in the world, Rev Shipman has repeated an oft-made mistake. He has confused the cause and the symptom. Of course, you can’t actually blame anti-Semitism on Israel. In high culture, this month the Metropolitan Opera in New York is staging an opera called “The Death of Klinghoffer.” This controversial piece offers a sympathetic view of Palestinian terrorists who hijacked a cruise ship, shot an old Jewish man in a wheelchair and threw him overboard. One can only imagine what they could do to top that: “9/11, the Musical?” But even if you take back Vanessa Redgrave, and go pre-1948, you have T.S. Eliot, and Richard Wagner who were professed anti-Semites. Anti-Semites have been speaking with a southern accent for many years. In Mississippi, a rabbi was told that he was not welcome in a local restaurant, and in Kentucky, there is a candidate for senate running on the slogan “with Jews we lose.” But then how do you explain Leo Frank, who was lynched just a few miles from here, 99 years ago? One can understand the Reverend’s consternation and confusion. If there is not some external, geopolitical source for hatred of Jews, what cause could there be? Is there no internal logic, is it just a sort of full moon fever that grips people for no reason? Well, yes, to an extent. Hatred of minorities is no news. Almost every Rabbi Joshua Heller, Rosh Hashanah 5775 p 6 culture in the world has, at some point, feared or oppressed minorities and outsiders. We have a legacy in our own country of racial tension and violence. But hating Jews is somehow different. There’s a reason why hating anyone else is racism, while hating Jews has its own word. To really understand why, we have to dive deeply into the theology of what it means to be Jewish in a larger world, a theology that is especially visible on Rosh Hashanah, and this High Holiday season. We wrestle with the balance between the particular- that which is distinctively Jewish, and the universal- that which is shared by all nations. The “Jewish New Year” is actually in Nissan, the month of the Exodus, and Passover. That’s why Rosh Hashanah is described in the Torah as the “first day of the 7th month, not the first month. The Exodus is the birth of the Jewish people, while Rosh Hashanah is intended to be the new year for the whole world, Jew and non-Jew alike. In the Zichronot section of the Musaf service today, in a passage adapted from the Jerusalem Talmud, we declare “V’al hamedinot bo yeamer”- God decrees on this day regarding all countries, which for the sword, and which for peace, which for hunger and which for abundance, and creatures are recalled on it to remember them for life or death. The High Holiday liturgy, again and again, explores the idea that Jews have a particular relationship with God, distinctive to our own faith, but there is also a universal opportunity that is open to all. For example, there is the Aleinu, which originated in the High Holiday liturgy, but was so popular that it was added to every daily service. Aleinu begins by talking about the uniqueness of the Jewish faith, the distinctiveness of Jewish worship, but ends with the sentiment that all peoples will come to recognize the One God, each worshipping in their own way. Most significantly, though, we as a Jewish people are the bridge between the universal and the particular. Parashat Ha’azinu, the passage from Deuteronomy which we read this coming Shabbat, explains, “behanchel elyon goim, behafrido b’nai adam”- when God set the divisions of man, He fixed the boundaries of the peoples, in relation to Israel’s numbers. Somehow, we were meant to play a role, far beyond our numbers, in the spiritual development of the world. For thousands of years, we have been guided by those verses, whether we realized it or not. We have served light unto the nations, as having a role in world history, in the development of world spirituality and ethics, far beyond our own numbers. That’s not always an enviable role. The German Philosopher, Friedrich Nietzsche explained it well, in his Genealogy of Morals. To paraphrase, he explained that it was the Jews who turned the world on its head by claiming that the powerful and aristocratic are wicked, and it is the Rabbi Joshua Heller, Rosh Hashanah 5775 p 7 lowly, poor and oppressed who are the chosen of God, and he hated us for that. Oddly enough, Nietzsche wasn’t specifically an anti-Semite. If you read his writings, it becomes clear that he really hated everyone, but his writings became an important influence on Nazi thought. Nevertheless, I think Nietzsche captured an important idea, Jews, influenced by our prophetic tradition, have often been at the forefront of calling for justice, defending the poor and oppressed, of demanding that even the losers have their rights I’m reminded of the story of the woman who asks her husband what time it is. He responds “Let me get my shofar and I will tell you.” “How can you tell time with a shofar?” she asks. He opens the window and begins blowing. Voices ring out through the neighborhood. “Stop that, it’s 3 in the morning!” Nobody likes the person who makes them realize what time it is. There’s a discomfort with us when we ourselves are weak, and an even greater discomfort when we ourselves have some strength and power. Judaism has had an outsize impact on world thought and philosophy. Think about the way the shofar makes a sound, starting with the small end but emerging at the wide end. Often the Jews are the small end of the shofar, from which ultimately a large noise emerges. The teachings of Christianity and Islam both emerged from our faith. Their story is our story. In some way, those faith traditions in some ways mark the fulfillment of Aleinu, bringing monotheism to the larger, non-Jewish world. However, that has sometimes caused great unease. It has taken some Christian denominations many generations to understand that they do not have to reject or dismissu our continued covenant with God in order to assert the legitimacy of their own. Islam is still struggling to understand the debt it pays to Jewish narrative and law. The Moslem tradition takes the very story we read today, about the binding of Isaac, and claims that it is not a Jewish story at all, but rather is the story of Ishmael. When I became a congregational rabbi, I made a commitment to myself that I would not give a sermon whose main focus was anti-Semitism, and I’ve done a pretty good job keeping that promise. To be sure, I’ve spoken about terrorism, the holocaust, Iran’s desire to wipe Israel off the map, but I’ve never given a sermon with anti-Semitism as its primary agenda. Those of you who sit through my sermons week in and week out, and know how much gets past my internal filter, will particularly appreciate that. There’s a reason I made that commitment, and a reason that I’ve broken it today. The reason I made that commitment is that I believe our Judaism should be about love, not fear. I believe that we should be Jewish because of everything that is Rabbi Joshua Heller, Rosh Hashanah 5775 p 8 great about Judaism, not because someone else doesn’t like us, or we have something to prove. Anti-Semitism doesn’t move us to be better Jews, it moves us to be bitter Jews. I made that commitment because anti-Semitism is not an encouragement or an inducement to embrace our tradition. Would you really be enthusiastic about a culture, a religion, an ethnicity if you were told repeatedly how despised it had been throughout the ages? If I wanted to undertake a time-honored belief system that would lead me to be the victim of scorn and negativity, I’d become a cubs fan. I made that commitment because I don’t believe in crying wolf. There are those who see anti-Semites under every rock, who use it as an excuse to justify practices and beliefs that I don’t think are constructive. However, I am speaking about anti-Semitism today, because those people are not always wrong- just because you are paranoid doesn’t mean they aren’t out to get you. I am speaking about anti-Semitism today because, more so that any other time in my lifetime, I think there are dangers that are not insurmountable, but can only be overcome if they are named and addressed, and exposed to the light of day. And yet, even in the midst of some scary times, there are some glimmers of hope. First of all, the geopolitical situation has changed in the Middle East. It used to be all the Moslems against Israel, but suddenly, the field of allegiances is much more complicated. Shiite vs. Sunni, radical vs. moderate, new players like Qatar and Turkey. In the Middle East, sometimes the enemy of my enemy is … also my enemy, but sometimes the enemy of my enemy’s friend is my friend too. You have Egypt and Saudi Arabia realizing that they fear ISIS and Iran more than they fear Israel. Amidst the terrorists and the extremists, you see the rise of moderate Moslem voices, voices from the Arab world telling Hamas that it is time to, stop being all or nothing, and come to the table, make a deal. I think there is also hope at the ground level, when one looks at the individual, rather than the global. It’s one thing to hate Jews, or Israelis, or whoever, as a group. It’s another thing to sit with another human being, and recognize that her or she is not just a face in the crowd. I recently had the chance to witness two incredible conversations. In Washington, DC, I got to see a conversation between Mosab Hassan Yousef, the son of a leader of Hamas, and Gonen Ben Yitzchak. Youssef rejected the violence that Hamas was carrying out against Israelis and its own people, and ended up working with Ben Yitzchak, a Shin Bet operative, to Rabbi Joshua Heller, Rosh Hashanah 5775 p 9 thwart terrorist activities. Their experiences are the subject of a movie called “the Green Prince.” The whole point of the high holidays is that people are indeed capable of change. The other dialogue that gave me hope happened here in Atlanta. Rabbi Hanan Schlesinger, is a “settler” in Alon Shvut, one of the Jewish blocs in the West Bank. He is an Orthodox Jew, living in an area inhabited by Jews until 1948, when they were massacred. His counterpart, is Ali Abu Awwad a former PLO security operative, who owns a plot of land within that block. Their conversation began with each saying to the other “you don’t know how it feels,” but they realized what they had in common- a devotion to the land, a love of their families and a fear of violence that might harm those families, that they have more in common with each other than with the folks in Tel Aviv. They are working together to create a new kind of dialogue, that may someday bear fruit. We are all individuals. If enough choose to change, then you have changed the world. You may think I’m running down a dream. I’m not polyanna-ish. There are many different conflicts in the Middle East, and real peace will require cooperation among many partners. I have no illusions about peace with the Palestinians. It will take a change in theology, in rhetoric, and education. The waiting is the hardest part. And indeed, before that happens, I fear that we will witness terrible violence, and increasingly bold attempts at delegitimization of Israel- attempts to isolate it diplomatically and theologically, but even logistically, by threatening the airport. It’s a long, long road, I’m not convinced that it will happen in my lifetime, but I believe but there will come a day when the Palestinian people will come to the same realizations, that you don’t have to live like a refugee, that their resources are better spent building than attacking. Perhaps there will be a realization that neither side is simply going away, and that this is not a war that either side can truly win. Will they raise the courage to say “I don’t wanna fight?” Will they choose leaders who can make peace, a peace that is built on some tough compromises, but a peace that is built to last? I believe that there is also cause for cautious optimism here in the US. Please raise your hand if you parked in a church parking lot today (many hands go up). You can compare notes later. The Baptists, the Presbyterians, the Mormons, they disagree about fundamental issues of theology and interpretation of scripture. However, they all agree that they want to help you get to services on time! It’s not just about neighborly cooperation. Rabbi Joshua Heller, Rosh Hashanah 5775 p 10 We are blessed to be able to participate in real, meaningful dialogue and conversation. So for example, we have developed a very special relationship with Mount Vernon Presbyterian Church, that consists of both talk and action. Last week, we had our first session of a public conversation called “a Rabbi and a Minister walk into a bar.” Over 50 people showed up to hear pastor Joe B of MVP schmooze with me. We work together to staff a homeless shelter. When the PCUSA- the national organizing body of many US Presbyterian Churches, voted to divest from companies doing business with Israel, our local church expressed their disagreement. You may not be aware that one of our members is the Associate Director for Christians United for Israel, an umbrella organization that represents hundreds of thousands of Christian Zionists. Some Jews are wary, concerned that perhaps they support us for all the wrong reasons, or that it is a pretense for conversion, but I must disagree. Having spoken to leaders in the organization, I know that there is a great sincerity and love. There is an appreciation that we are two faith traditions that share common roots, stories and values. So maybe it’s all right for now. Here in this country, intermarriage between Jews and non-Jews has reached numbers that have never been seen. People fret and wring their hands. One of the things that it means is we are embraced, that American non-Jews are ok marrying Jews. A young woman feels that she can love Jesus and her boyfriend too. The boundaries between the specific and the universal are blurred. This brings me back to the premise of this whole discussion, the universal and the particular. One of the byproducts of this summer’s conflict is that Israelis were more united than they had been in decades. Prime Minister Netanyahu had far higher approval ratings than he was in fact entitled to- even the peaceniks were rooting for him. They wanted him to say “I won’t back down.” They recognized that this is truly an existential fight for Israel as a Jewish state. And yet, just as Israeli society is united, American Jewry finds these conversations all the more troubling and divisive. American Jews have an increasingly complex relationship with Israel. At one point, it was all about Falafel, bar mitzvah on massada, and American Girls and boys going on Birthright. Now we can hardly read each other’s Facebook feeds. Why is that? I believe it is because we wrestle with the balance between the universal and the particular. Our universalist values tell us that in any fight, we should be rooting for the underdog. It’s ethically easy to be powerless, and to be the victim. We don’t know what to do when we actually have a bit of power. Rabbi Joshua Heller, Rosh Hashanah 5775 p 11 We also are caught up in the question of whether Israel is allowed to be a country like any other. On this Rosh Hashanah, every nation of the world is Judged. Israel is judged, too. God is the ultimate judge, but we serve as human judges. I would suggest that we need not judge Israel more leniently than any other nation, but also must not judge her more strictly. If you are a fighter for justice, that’s great, but don’t single out Israel for special criticism in the family of nations. If you love Israel unconditionally, you must still remember that the ends don’t justify the means. I believe that, even with its flaws, Israel will fare well in honest, true judgment before God, and is morally entitled to hold its head high among the family of nations. There are those with whom we have conflict because we each call out competing claims to the same land, and ultimately, those claims will have to be settled people to people, person to person. Maybe those seeds have been planted, even if they take a long time to sprout. Most importantly, on this Rosh Hashanah, I want to offer, if you will, a shout out to the haters. I believe that our Jewish people has a special place in the world. The people who love us know it. The people who hate us know even better. They hate us because we represent an ideal. Yes, we are a nation like any other- if you prick us, do we not bleed? But we are also the shofar that disturbs complacency. We can draw inspiration from the fact, the reminder that even those who hate us know that we are here to make a difference. Let this year be not about responding to a negative, but about being more positive. For over 3000 of the 5774 years, they have tried to silence our voices. May this be another year where our joyous sounds are still heard. This year’s Sermon Bingo key: Petty, Heartbreak, Century City, King’s Highway, Breakdown, Out in in the Cold, “Rebel without a clue” (Into the great wide Open). Free falling Vanessa Redgrave (Quit Jamming Me) Southern accent, Full Moon Fever. Even the Losers, Yer so Bad, All or Nothing, Running Down a Dream, Long, Long Road, Live Like a Refugee, I don’t wanna fight, Built to Last, The Waiting is the Hardest Part, I Won’t Back Down, For all the Wrong Reasons, “Loves Jesus and her boyfriend, too” (Free Fallin’), American Girl