American University of Beirut Model United Nations Training Manual 1 Intenational Affairs Table of Contents About the United Nations………………………………………………………………………………...3 Member Countries………………………………………………………………………………..4 Observers and Entities………………………………………………………………………….5 Model United Nations……………………………………………………………………………………...6 Basic Information…………………………………………………………………………………….……...6 Steps of a MUN Conference……………………………………………………………………………...7 Pre-Conference Preparation………………………………………………………………….7 Rules of Procedure………………………………………………………………………………...………..8 General Rules…………………………………………………………………...…………………..8 Rules Governing Debate………………………………………………………………………..8 Rules Governing Points……………………………….………………………………………10 Rules Governing the Path to a Draft Resolution……………………………………10 Rules Governing Voting………………………………………………………………………11 Resolutions……………………………………...……………………………………………………………13 Example of a Resolution……………………………………………………………………...14 2 About the United Nations Principle Organs of the UN: 1. General Assembly-All 193 members, observer states, and NGO’s (such as WHO, ICRC, World Bank, etc). 2. Security Council-15 Members including P5 veto members (USA, UK, France, Russia, China). 3. Economic and Social Council-54 members 4. Trusteeship Council 5. International Court of Justice-15 judges 6. Secretariat 7. Specialized Agencies Six Official Languages: 1. Arabic 2. Chinese 3. English 4. French 5. Russian 6. Spanish Secretary General: Ban Ki-Moon Founding Date: 24 October 1945 3 Member Countries Afghanistan Chad Grenada Lithuania Panama Swaziland Albania Chile Guatemala Luxembourg Papua New Guinea Sweden Algeria China Guinea Macedonia Paraguay Switzerland Andorra Colombia Guinea-Bissau Madagascar Peru Syrian Arab Republic Angola Comoros Guyana Malawi Philippines Tajikistan Antigua and Barbuda Congo Haiti Malaysia Poland United Republic of Tanzania Argentina Democratic Republic of the Congo Honduras Maldives Romania Thailand Armenia Costa Rica Hungary Mali Russian Federation Timor-Leste Australia Côte d'Ivoire Iceland Malta Portugal Togo Austria Croatia India Marshall Islands Qatar Tonga Azerbaijan Cuba Indonesia Mauritania Rwanda Trinidad and Tobago Bahamas Cyprus Iran (Islamic Republic of) Mauritius Saint Kitts and Nevis Tunisia Bahrain Czech Republic Iraq Mexico Saint Lucia Turkey Bangladesh Denmark Ireland Micronesia Saint Vincent and the Grenadines Turkmenistan Barbados Djibouti Israel Republic of Moldova Samoa Tuvalu Belarus Dominica Italy Monaco San Marino Uganda Belgium Dominican Republic Jamaica Mongolia Sao Tome and Principe Ukraine Belize Ecuador Japan Montenegro Saudi Arabia United Arab Emirates Benin Egypt Jordan Morocco Senegal United Kingdom Bhutan El Salvador Kazakhstan Mozambique Serbia United States of America Bolivia Equatorial Guinea Kenya Myanmar Seychelles Uruguay Bosnia and Herzegovina Eritrea Kiribati Namibia Sierra Leone Uzbekistan Estonia Democratic People's Republic of Korea Nauru Singapore Vanuatu Botswana 4 Brazil Ethiopia Republic of Korea Nepal Slovakia Venezuela Brunei Darussalam Fiji Kuwait Netherlands Slovenia Viet Nam Bulgaria Finland Kyrgyzstan New Zealand Solomon Islands Yemen Burkina Faso France Lao People's Democratic Republic Nicaragua Somalia Zambia Burundi Gabon Latvia Niger South Africa Zimbabwe Cambodia Gambia Lebanon Nigeria South Sudan Cameroon Georgia Lesotho Norway Spain Canada Germany Liberia Oman Sri Lanka Cape Verde Central African Republic Ghana Libya Pakistan Sudan Greece Liechtenstein Palau Suriname Observers & Entities Holy See: Non-member Observer State Palestine Liberation Organization-Observer Entity European Union-Observer Regional Organization Model United Nations Model United Nations (MUN) is a practical activity where individuals are given the opportunity to simulate the activities of the United Nations as Ambassadors 5 of their selected countries. The activity is a great way to learn about international affairs and politics whilst developing various skills including: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Public Speaking Lobbying/Persuasion Leadership Problem solving Proper legal language The simulations take part in an organized structure very similar to the way in which the UN conducts its discussions (and which many organizations in the world follow). This organized form of debate follows the principles of Robert’s Rules of Order, and this training manual is designed to teach you the principles that you must apply when you come to debate at a MUN conference either within the university, nationally or internationally. It is worth noting that not all MUN conferences follow the exact set of rules; there are a few minor differences between American-styled and European-styled conferences. Because we attend American-organized conferences we will be following their set of rules. However the differences are almost negligible and the chairperson will be more than happy to explain what the differences are if you are not used to our style of conferences. Basic Information Each individual is referred to as a DELEGATE. Delegates are not allowed to refer to each other by personal names or in the first person. You may not use the terms ‘I’, ‘Me’ or any delegate’s names when in formal debate (when in informal debate you may relax this requirement). Leading each committee is at least one CHAIR. This individual has the ultimate authority-it would be the biggest of violations to cross the chairperson in an unreasonable manner as he/she has the final say on all matters and has the power to force you to leave the room. The Chair must be knowledgeable on the details of proper procedure because it is their job to guide the delegates through debate. The chair is often supported by a DIAS that sits alongside him/her. A Dias may vary in size and role depending on the size of the conference but its major responsibility includes assisting the Chair on time keeping, rules of procedure, and note passing. Steps of a MUN Conference Pre Conference Country Assignment and Research 6 Beginning of Conference Speakers’ List Moderated Caucuses Unmoderated Caucuses Middle of Conference Working Papers End of Conference Draft Resolutions Voting Pre-Conference Preparation Delegates should research the committee itself-what is its focus, powers and influence. Delegates have to know every important detail of their country. Make sure you tick every single one of these boxes: o Where is the country located, and who are your neighbors? o Who are your enemies and allies, and what are their opinions/details concerning topic? o Learn your government details (Leader, System, Capital city). o Relevant details to topic need to be known. If the economy is an important factor in discussion know what resources your country has and its strengths/weaknesses. If security is an issue make sure you know information about your national security. o UN Policy on the topic. o Past UN Resolutions on the topic (available on site) are key for you to have a better picture as to what has historically happened. They are also useful to include in resolutions o Your previous voting records must be known. o Useful facts: do not underestimate the power of facts. Sometimes when travelling abroad you will be asked to write a position paperbut not within AUB. A position paper details your country’s policy and opinion of the question, and want you want to achieve at this meeting. Starting Websites: CIA World Factbook Government website (not always easy) UN Agency website Rules of Procedure General Rules Rule #1:Participation of Non-Members and NGO’s 7 Representatives of Accredited Observers have the same rights as full members except that they will not have the right to sign or vote on any draft resolutions or amendments. They do have the right to vote on procedural matters however. A NGO has the right to address the committee in oral or written form with approval of the Chair, stating its stance on the topic and possible contributions it may make. Rule #2: Quorum Quorum denotes the minimum number of delegates who need to be present in order to open debate. Quorum requires at least one-quarter of the members of the committee (as declared at the beginning of the session) to be present. In order to vote on any substantive motion, the Committee must establish the presence of a simple majority of members. Rules Governing Debate Rule #3: Debate When multiple topics are set for one conference, the committee must start by the setting of the agenda to decide what order the topics will be discussed in committee. A motion is made for a certain sequence and a ‘second’ is needed to get the motion rolling. A speaker’s list is established ‘for’ and ‘against’ the motion. A vote of two-thirds is required to close the debate on the setting of the agenda, unless there are no more speakers. If only one topic is set for discussion then this step may be avoided. Once the agenda is set, a new continuous Speaker’s List is formed for general debate during which the Chair recognizes delegates to speak. It sets the order of debate unless a motion is introduced which takes precedence. If a draft resolution is introduced it remains on the floor until the Committee closes debate on the topic. Rule #4: Unmoderated Caucus An unmoderated caucus gives the delegates freedom to discuss the topic in an informal manner. Rules of Procedure are temporarily suspended while delegates lobby amongst each other. It is frequently used to sort countries into blocs and to cooperate to put together working papers and resolutions. A delegate may motion for the unmoderated caucus at any time that the floor is open. The delegate must specify a time limit (20mins max) and a topic of discussion. The motion will pass by a simple majority. Unmoderated caucuses are ranked in descending order of length. Rule #5: Moderated Caucus A moderated caucus is opposite to the unmoderated caucus; the style of debate remains formal and the Chair calls on delegates to speak for a short period of time. The purpose is to facilitate substantive debate, and the Chair will temporarily depart from the Speaker’s List. 8 A motion for a moderated caucus is made at any time that the floor is open. The delegate must briefly explain its purpose and specify a time limit (20mins Max) as well as a time limit for individual speeches. The motion will pass by a simple majority, and if more than one moderated caucus is proposed they are ranked in descending order of duration and individual speakers time. No motions are in order between speeches during a moderated caucus, and speeches must remain on topic. There is no yielding of time in moderated caucuses. Rule# 6: Closure of Debate When the floor is over, a delegate may move to close debate on the substantive or procedural matter under discussion. They may close debate on a general topic, debate on the agenda, or debate on an amendment. However the Chair may rule such a motion dilatory. Speakers for the motion are not entertained. Closure of debate requires a 2/3 majority of the members present and voting. Rule #7: Suspension/Adjournment of the Meeting If the delegates wish to take a break they may motion to suspend the meeting until another designated time. Whenever the floor is open, a delegate may move to suspension of the meeting or adjournment of the meeting. The Chair may rule such motions out of order. A simple majority is needed to pass. Rule #8: Postponement and Resumption of Debate Whenever the floor is open, a delegate may move for the postponement of debate on a draft resolution/amendment/topic. This is known as ‘tabling’ and requires a 2/3-majority vote to pass with only one speaker for and against the motion permitted to speak. A motion to resume debate on an amendment/draft resolution/topic will require a simple majority to pass. Rule #9: Reconsideration A motion to reconsider may be made when a draft resolution/amendment has been adopted or rejected, and must be made by a member who voted with the majority. A 2/3 majority is required for reconsideration. Rule #10: Appeal An appeal may only be made to procedural matters and only immediately after it has been pronounced. A 2/3 majority is needed to overrule the decision made by the Chair. Rule #11: Yields A delegate may grant the right to speak on substantive matters to either: (i) another delegate (ii) to questions during which the Chair recognizes delegates to ask questions to the speaker (iii) the chair, if the delegate wishes to release control of the floor/time. Rule #12: Right of Reply A delegate whose personal/national integrity has been impugned by another delegate may submit a Right of Reply in writing to the Committee staff. A 9 delegate granted a Right of Reply would not address the Committee except at the request of the Chair. Rules Governing Points Rule #13: Points of Personal Privilege Whenever a delegate experiences personal discomfort that impairs his/her ability to participate in the proceedings, he/she may raise a Point of Personal Privilege to request that this discomfort be corrected. A delegate may only interrupt another delegate using a point of personal privilege if the delegate speaking is inaudible. Rule #14: Points of Order A Point of Order may be raised to indicate an instance of improper parliamentary procedure, and will be immediately decided by the Chair in accordance with the Rules of Procedure. The Chair may rule out of order these points that are dilatory or improper. A Point of Order may not interrupt a speaker during the speech. Rule #15: Points of Parliamentary Inquiry A delegate may raise a Point of Parliamentary Inquiry to ask a Chair a question regarding the rules of procedure. This may never interrupt a speaker. Rules Governing the Path to a Draft Resolution Rule #16: Working Papers Delegates may propose a working paper for Committee consideration. These are written suggestions that need not be written in draft resolution; rather they can be written in any format. The purpose of the working paper is to put forward suggestions that may be later turned into proper legal form. Working papers do not require signatories or votes of approval. Rule #17: Draft Resolution A draft resolution may be introduced when it has received the approval of 25% of the committee through signature. Signing a draft resolution does not indicate support for the document but rather a willingness to see the draft resolution discussed. There are no official sponsors of draft resolutions. A draft resolution requires a simple majority to pass, and only one resolution may be passed per topic. Rule #18: Introducing Draft Resolutions Once the draft resolution has been approved by the Chair, he/she may read the operative clauses if time permits. Alternatively, the Chair may recognize a certain number of delegates to come forward to answer questions about the resolution or to provide an informal presentation. A procedural vote is then taken to determine whether the resolution should be introduced requiring a simple majority. Once a draft resolution is passed it is on the floor until the debate is postponed or another resolution is passed. 10 Rule #19: Amendments Delegates may amend any draft resolution that has been introduced by adding to or deleting parts of it. Only one amendment may be introduced at any time and requires the signature of 12% of the voting members. There can be no friendly amendments except if there is a typographical error. A motion to introduce an amendment requires a simple majority. This does not mean that the amendment has passed however-when it is passed general debate is suspended and a speaker’s list is formed for and against the amendment. Discussion on the amendment may be closed by a Motion to Close Debate (maximum of two speakers for and against) after which the committee will move to vote on the passing of the amendment. Amendments require a simple majority to pass. Rules Governing Voting Rule #20: Procedural Voting Procedural voting covers any voting done to decide the structure of the debate, and does not consist of voting on amendments or draft resolutions. Every member of the committee is required to vote and abstentions are permitted. A simple majority is achieved when those in favor outnumber those against., and a 2/3 majority exists when there are twice as many in favor than those against. Rule #21: Substantive Voting Substantive voting covers only voting over draft resolutions or amendments. At this time the chambers are sealed and nobody is allowed to enter or exit the room. Only the following Points or Motions may be entertained: Division of the Question Reordering Draft Resolutions Motion to Vote by Acclamation Motion for a Roll Call Vote Point of Personal Privilege Point of Parliamentary Inquiry Point of Order Rule #22: Voting by Acclamation The Committee Chair has the right to ask his or her members if there are any objections to a vote by acclamation. If there are no objections then the motion will be automatically adopted without the committee going into voting procedure. Rule #23: Reordering Draft Resolutions A motion to Reorder Draft Resolutions will be made only immediately after entering voting procedure and before voting has started. A simple majority is required to pass and then the Chair will reorder the draft resolution voting. Rule # 24: Division of the Question 11 A delegate may move to vote on individual operative clauses separately through a Motion to Divide the Question. Preambulatory and sub-operative clauses are not altered by a division. The motion requires a simple majority to pass, following which a separate procedural vote will be taken on each divided part to determine whether or not it is to be included in the final draft resolution. Rule #25: Roll Call Voting A delegate has the right to request a roll call vote once debate on a draft resolution is closed, and can only be made for substantive votes. The Chair will call on members in alphabetical order starting with a randomly selected member during which delegates may vote “Yes”, “Yes with Rights”, “No”, “No with Rights”, “Abstain”, or “Pass”. Delegates that asked for rights may explain why they voted the way they did when it is against their policy. A delegate that voted “Pass” must vote during the second round of voting. Precedence of Motions 1 Point of Personal Privilege 2 Point of Order 3 Point of Parliamentary Inquiry 4 Adjournment of the Meeting 5 Suspension of the Meeting 6 Unmoderated Caucusing 7 Moderated Caucusing 8 Introduction of Draft Resolution 9 Introduction of an Amendment 10 Postponement of Debate 11 Resumption of Debate 12 Closure of Debate Precedence of Motions at the start of voting procedure 1 2 3 4 5 6 Point of Personal Privilege Point of Order Point of Parliamentary Inquiry Reordering Draft Resolutions Division of the Question Motion for a Roll Call Vote Resolutions A resolution represents a proposed solution for a national and/or international problem. A resolution must always be written according to the specific policy and position of the delegate's represented country, rather than based on his/her 12 own personal stance on the topic. It is recommended that the resolution be clear and detailed. The resolution should be the original work of the delegate. Delegates may cite/quote sources. However, in case plagiarism is detected, the resolution will not be debated, and the concerned delegate’s teacher advisor will be notified. The resolution consists of two main parts: 1. Perambulatory Clauses, which contain background information and supporting arguments for the operative clauses to follow. 2. Operative Clauses, contain the policy statements of the body making the decision. Each operative clause should contain only one clear, unambiguous statement of the decision being taken by the body. Each operative clause should be numbered separately, arranged in a logical or chronological sequence and each must begin with a verb in the third person singular of the present tense. Operative clauses should take action against the problem presented. Some common perambulatory phrases start with: • Affirming • Deeply disturbed • Guided by • Alarmed by • Deeply regretting • Having adopted • Having considered • Observing • Having considered further • Aware of • Emphasizing • Having devoted attention • Believing • Expecting •Realizing • Bearing in mind • Having examined • Recalling • Confident • Having studied • Recognizing • Contemplating • Fulfilling • Having heard • Convinced • Fully aware • Having received • Declaring • Fully alarmed • Keeping in mind • Deeply concerned • Fully believing • Noting with regret • Deeply conscious • Further deploring • Noting with satisfaction • Deeply convinced • Further recalling • Noting with deep concern • Taking note • Noting further • Seeking Some common operative clause beginnings are: • Accepts • Affirms • Approves • Asks • Authorizes • Calls • Calls upon • Condemns • Confirms •Considers • Declares accordingly • Deplores • Designate • Draws attention • Emphasizes • Encourages • Endorses • Expresses its hope• Further invites • Further proclaims • Further recommends • Further reminds • Further requests • Further resolves • Proposes • Suggests • Supports • Transmits • Urges *Note: When writing a resolution, it is best to write the operative clauses first (so you know what action you would like to see the United Nations take or what attitude it ought to adopt) and then to write the perambulatory clauses. The number of operative clauses must always exceed the number of perambulatory clauses. Main Structure of the Resolution • The introductory word or phrase of each perambulatory clause is italicized. • The introductory word or phrase of each operative clause is underlined. • Each operative clause is numbered. • Sub-clauses are lettered, and sub-sub-clauses are numbered. • Clauses end with a comma. Example of a Resolution Resolution GA/3/1.1 13 General Assembly Third Committee Sponsors: United States, Austria and Italy Signatories: Greece, Tajikistan, Japan, Canada, Mali, the Netherlands and Gabon Topic: “Strengthening UN coordination of humanitarian assistance in complex emergencies” The General Assembly, Reminding all nations of the celebration of the 50th anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which recognizes the inherent dignity, equality and inalienable rights of all global citizens, Reaffirming its Resolution 33/1996 of 25 July 1996, which encourages Governments to work with UN bodies aimed at improving the coordination and effectiveness of humanitarian assistance, Noting with satisfaction the past efforts of various relevant UN bodies and nongovernmental organizations, Stressing the fact that the United Nations faces significant financial obstacles and is in need of reform, particularly in the humanitarian realm, 1. Encourages all relevant agencies of the United Nations to collaborate more closely with countries at the grassroots level to enhance the carrying out of relief efforts; 2. Urges member states to comply with the goals of the UN Department of Humanitarian Affairs to streamline efforts of humanitarian aid; 3. Requests that all nations develop rapid deployment forces to better enhance the coordination of relief efforts of humanitarian assistance in complex emergencies; 4. Calls for the development of a United Nations Trust Fund that encourages voluntary donations from the private transnational sector to aid in funding the implementation of rapid deployment forces; 5. Stresses the continuing need for impartial and objective information on the political, economic and social situations and events of all countries; 6. Calls upon states to respond quickly and generously to consolidated appeals for humanitarian assistance; and 7. Requests the expansion of preventive actions and assurance of post-conflict assistance through reconstruction and development. 14