File - Sierra Paige Shenk

advertisement
Shenk 1
Sierra Shenk
Aughenbaugh
English 12
07 February 2014
Statutory Rape Reputation Leading Towards Only Males
Can the law justly send teenagers to jail for having consensual, non-forcible sex? The
answer is yes in some states and no in many others. Why the inconsistencies when it comes to
statutory rape? “Because every state has a statutory rape law in some form, this case presents a
challenge to a long and continuing tradition of criminal laws that confine men for what could be
consensual sex with minors who are close to the age of majority” (Colb). Statutory rape
continues to be a controversial debate in America, largely because no one can agree on the age of
consent of a person. One person may be ready for sex before another; that knowledge creates a
serious issue when making laws that affect all people. Statutory rape laws are discriminatory
toward males because it criminalizes consensual sex between teenagers, the age of consent is
inconsistent across the nation, and it allows for a culture of dishonesty.
The premise behind the laws of statutory rape is that certain ages of young people are
incapable of giving consent for sexual behavior. Due to many actions of sexual behavior that
involve young people at the ages under eighteen with someone eighteen or older has been
causing many debates on the outcome on these situations. These situations have led to arguments
across the nation and, in some cases, the lives of males that are involved. Males that have been in
issues with statutory rape are often criticized, when there is a possibility that no one has heard
the entire truth or the whole story. People assume that when a male is involved it is entirely his
fault, however, without both sides of the story, no judgment can be made. Statutory rape laws are
Shenk 2
mainly to keep young people safe, which should be stating consensual sex among teens should
not be criminalized.
Because of raging parents and furious teens, males are getting convicted for statutory
rape and are left with nothing. While fighting through the battle, even if they are guilty, the
process begins; the criticism, the hatred and even disbelief will occur. In the end if found guilty,
the male will be considered a sex offender, and afterwards from being named as a sex offender
they are then listed in sites such as “Megan’s Law.” This allows the public to see each and every
sex offender in the area surrounding them. One will stay a sex offender until the law gives the
consent to be released from the title. If an “adult,” eighteen or older, is having sexual contact
with minors less than eighteen years of age, then one can become listed as a sex offender for
having sexual contact with one under the age of consent:
The truth is that these laws cannot make such distinctions but lawmakers seem to have
attempted to account for variations in relationships. The laws are certainly more nuanced
than I had expected, though above anything else, these laws are complicated. Each state
has its own law and decides a number of factors for itself, including age of consent,
minimum age of ‘victim,’ age differential, and minimum age of ‘perpetrator’ in order to
prosecute. (Kempner)
If there is an age differential then the victim is above the 18 years of age and the age of the
younger partner is at the age under 18, then without a parents consent this would be considered
to be illegal which can have many consequences to come. Understanding that the law is in fact
the law show that if one is eighteen or older having “consensual” sex with a minor can lead to
court hearings and even jail. The minimum age of defendant in order to prosecute is the age
below which an individual cannot be prosecuted for engaging in sexual activities with minors
Shenk 3
(Sylvester). If the female is at minimum age of giving consent then there is no possible way to
engage charges against the male; while the age of consent varies currently, each state requires a
minimum age of consent of at least sixteen years of age (Smith). Recently, studies show that
sending juveniles to homes and then eventually jail causes more problems to the juvenile then it
does correcting their mistakes. “Rape is no excess, no aberration, no accident, no mistake--it
embodies sexuality as the culture defines it. As long as these definitions remain intact--that is, as
long as men are defined as sexual aggressors and women are defined as passive receptors lacking
integrity--men who are exemplars of the norm will rape women.” (Dictionary)
While many others research this problem, people have come up with a more reasonable solution
to the situation such as; rehabilitation programs.
Close-in-age dating relationships have been the topic of discussion due to the argument;
“should there be a law for these situations?” Given that many teenagers who are close in age are
probably having sexual behavior violates statutory rape laws. This shows that close-in-age dating
relationships are more acceptable in society and is not frowned upon. Due to statutory rape laws
with a parent’s consent, close-in-age dating relationships are not accused to be inappropriate in
the situation of statutory rape. Underage girls who experience sex with older males are going to
or have already experienced a negative outcome such as, problems in the future also, many
struggles throughout time with their past experiences. With that being said, without the consent
of neither mother nor father, the law can be enforced throughout the matter of endangerment of a
child (Kempner).
As a teen approaches his or her way into the sexual behavior stage, many are ready
before others; there is no exact age for all kids.. The nation’s way of dealing with an amazingly
serious problem has been to enforce laws stating certain ages shall not and should not be
Shenk 4
involved in sexual relationships with each other. Not only have statistics shown that many
pregnancies and STD-related occurrences have been known to be traced back to statutory rape
and minors having sex without taking cautioning measures but, many of these situations have
been leading back to non-consensual sex or parent approval. In 2000, nine million cases of
STD’s were reported among people in the age range of fifteen to twenty four (Buckley).
Although many pregnancies have occurred due to statutory rape, many of these women
getting pregnant are usually minors. Minors who give consent to sex with an older male can lead
to a pregnancy if unsafely handled:
One pregnant girl was sentenced to 30 days for a misdemeanor and she was quite shocked
by the severity of the sentence. The prosecutor pointed out that the community had every
right to be shocked at the prospect of a child being born out of wedlock, which increases
by a very high percentage the probability that that child will end up in prison, on welfare,
illiterate and on drugs. (Buckley)
Abortions are also a serious issue due to these types of relationships. As studies have shown
many abortions have been due to statutory rape and as well as rape (Sylvester). To society,
anything with the word ”rape” involved is considered a crime; because of this, men should
demand to see women’s ID before engaging in sexual activity to avoid any misunderstandings.
“It is little wonder that rape is one of the least-reported crimes. Perhaps it is the only crime in
which the victim becomes the accused and, in reality, it is she who must prove her good
reputation, her mental soundness, and her impeccable propriety.”
Many states feel the need to enforce laws against teen sex; taking these actions into
consideration and completing a successful demand of males asking for her approval is not only
discriminating towards teens all over the nation but showing teens that human nature is “wrong”
Shenk 5
by having consensual sex. This can further criminalize sex in America rather than teaching
responsibility. This could also lead to secrecy and immoral behaviors in teens. Teen sex is and
always will be considered “wrong” to most adults but to teen’s sex should not be considered a
crime, especially when there is no harm being done. Statutory rape laws are often overkill and
prosecute wrongly.
Yes, all adults have their own opinions on teenage sex, but they never stop to think about
the teens opinions. Teens have a state of mind as well; yes, they may make bad decisions from
time to time but that’s how every single person has learned, from their mistakes. Statutory rape is
huge but sometime people need to step back and think whose fault is it and whose cause the real
problem. Not all males should be the center of attention when it comes to accusing someone for
statutory rape; most cases involve a female who’s usually the minor in the process, which takes a
terrible outlook on the older male. Yes the male may be older but it doesn’t always mean he was
in the wrong completely. Females have just as much power as males do when it come to
speaking their mind and saying yes to giving consent. Consent is not only for one person in the
situation but for everyone. Statutory rape laws are main criminalizing males due to the belief of
the male race being the problem in all situations involving rape. In reality many statutory rape
situations need to not be looked over an assumed. Criminalizing males has been the reasons for
many statutory rape cases. “There is something wrong with a law that forces a judge to brand a
young man as a rapist ... for the rest of his life simply for having sex with someone before her
16th birthday” (Kempner).
Shenk 6
Works Cited
Buckley, William F. “Society Should Enforce Laws against Teen Sex.” Teenage Sexuality.
Ed. Tamara L. Roleff. San Diego: Greenhaven Press, 2001. Opposing Viewpoints. Rpt. from
“Enforce the Law in Idaho.” Washington Times 12 July 1996. Opposing Viewpoints in
Context. Web. 23 Jan. 2014.
Kempner, Martha. “Age of Consent Laws Are Confusing.” Age of Consent. Ed. Christine
Watkins. Detroit: Greenhaven Press, 2013. At Issue. Rpt. from “Legislating Teen Sex:
What’s (Terribly) Wrong with Our Age of Consent Laws.” 2012. Opposing Viewpoints in
Context. Web. 23 Jan. 2014.
Kempner, Martha. “Consensual Sex Among Teens Should Not Be Criminalized.” Teen
Dating. Ed. Louise I. Gerdes. Detroit: Greenhaven Press, 2013. Opposing Viewpoints. Rpt.
from “Legislating Teen Sex: What’s (Terribly) Wrong with Our Age of Consent Laws.”
http://rhrealitycheck.org. 2012. Opposing Viewpoints in Context. Web. 23 Jan. 2014.
Smith, Brittany Logino, and Glen A. Kercher. “Provisions for Juvenile Offenders Are Important
in Age of Consent Laws.” Age of Consent. Ed. Christine Watkins. Detroit: Greenhaven Press,
2013. At Issue. Rpt. from “Adolescent Sexual Behavior and the Law.” 2011. Opposing
Viewpoints in Context. Web. 23 Jan. 2014.
Sylvester, Kathleen, and Jonathan O’Connell. “Statutory Rape Laws Should Be Enforced.”
Teenage Sexuality. Ed. Tamara L. Roleff. Detroit: Greenhaven Press, 2006. Opposing
Viewpoints. Rpt. from “Protect Young Girls.” Baltimore Sun 17 June 2003:13A. Opposing
Viewpoints in Context. Web. 23 Jan. 2014.
Download